But still, it was a real word like it is fascinating how grammar Nazis cry about doomsday over something that technically was a real thing, just because of their perceived ignorance and superiority.
Didn't know this person so I searched him up with the quote and Google had a direct deadend then ask chatgpt and it said that Voltaire believed the opposite while also not being able to find the origins and attribution of that quote to this guy
On language evolving and being shaped by society:
“Custom is the reason for all things, and it is simply because something has been done or said in a certain way that it should continue to be done or said in that way.” — Philosophical Dictionary
This supports the idea that language is shaped by use, not rigid definitions imposed by elites.
On how the elite manipulate language and knowledge:
“The rich, who are often ignorant, have an interest in keeping the people in ignorance.” — Questions sur l’Encyclopédie
This suggests that language and knowledge are controlled by the powerful to maintain superiority.
On how the poor are unfairly judged:
“The comfort of the rich depends upon an abundant supply of the poor.” — Poverty
While not directly about language, this highlights class oppression, which extends to linguistic discrimination.
On absurdities in authority, including linguistic ones:
“Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities.” — Questions sur les Miracles
This could be used to argue against blindly following linguistic elitism as a form of control.
Voltaire was deeply skeptical of arbitrary authority, including language policing.
Ah, but you mistake the purpose of defining terms! I do not ask for rigid, elite-imposed meanings, I ask for clarity in discourse, so that neither the powerful nor the cunning can manipulate words to their advantage. Voltaire himself exposed the way vague and deceptive language is used to keep people in ignorance. If language is a weapon, defining terms is not oppression; it is self-defense.
So like that was my first thought as well, but the word turns up in the Oxford English Dictionary, but it’s not a common word. I wonder if the op has a predilection for obscure words or just forgot the word “exclude”
44
u/TheDeerWoman Mar 04 '25
“discluded”. We are doomed.