r/github • u/janukss • Jun 14 '20
GitHub to replace "master" with alternative term to avoid slavery references
https://www.zdnet.com/article/github-to-replace-master-with-alternative-term-to-avoid-slavery-references/
196
Upvotes
r/github • u/janukss • Jun 14 '20
1
u/brennanfee Jun 18 '20
Bad intent must be DEMONSTRATED not assumed. That which can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.
There was no "unconscious harm" here. The terms are entirely not personified. They don't refer to humans irrespective of the skin colors involved.
It can if it can be demonstrated that they had bad intent. Shaming a person can have a positive effect. Or at least it can become a teachable moment. But the linchpin is being able to be sure of their intent. If their intent was without harm then there is nothing to teach. That's the difference between teaching a preaching (in this context at least). If you lecture someone for something they didn't mean they simply ignore you. If it is clear they had ill intent (and we exposed that)... they can (although not always) can learn from that moment.
But as I have said over and over again here... there was no ill intent, no usage of the variation of the words that refers to people.
No. Again, you are incorrect. GitHub (and Microsoft, their new owners) are not "the people" where the usage came from. It came from the creators of Bitkeeper.
That's because... those reading the ill intent are, "well actually", wrong.
Please... in what way am I wrong? I can't speak for others that you are referring to. But, I was there when Bitkeeper was being used and when Git was written. I watched it all happen. I also am aware of the two words being used in CS engineering for quite some time... ALL of those usages in no way referring to people. And in no cases causing any harm.
Sure. I can understand that. Offense, as I have said is subjective and a personal thing. I have also been told by black friends that they couldn't care less about words but are extremely concerned about a society that tolerates a cop putting his knee on the neck of a citizen for 8 minutes and 46 seconds.