r/github • • Jun 14 '20

GitHub to replace "master" with alternative term to avoid slavery references

https://www.zdnet.com/article/github-to-replace-master-with-alternative-term-to-avoid-slavery-references/
196 Upvotes

296 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/brennanfee Jun 18 '20

You’re way, way too hung up on intent. Bad intent is the “simple” case.

Bad intent must be DEMONSTRATED not assumed. That which can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence.

The unconscious harms are much more challenging to root out.

There was no "unconscious harm" here. The terms are entirely not personified. They don't refer to humans irrespective of the skin colors involved.

Pointing out someone’s bad intent doesn’t encourage them to change it.

It can if it can be demonstrated that they had bad intent. Shaming a person can have a positive effect. Or at least it can become a teachable moment. But the linchpin is being able to be sure of their intent. If their intent was without harm then there is nothing to teach. That's the difference between teaching a preaching (in this context at least). If you lecture someone for something they didn't mean they simply ignore you. If it is clear they had ill intent (and we exposed that)... they can (although not always) can learn from that moment.

But as I have said over and over again here... there was no ill intent, no usage of the variation of the words that refers to people.

This case is extra bizarre because the people responsible have by and large all come out eager to make a change.

No. Again, you are incorrect. GitHub (and Microsoft, their new owners) are not "the people" where the usage came from. It came from the creators of Bitkeeper.

This thread is just, in my opinion, full of whiny privileged wannabe-know-it-alls having a big “well actually” fest,

That's because... those reading the ill intent are, "well actually", wrong.

and being totally wrong in basically every way.

Please... in what way am I wrong? I can't speak for others that you are referring to. But, I was there when Bitkeeper was being used and when Git was written. I watched it all happen. I also am aware of the two words being used in CS engineering for quite some time... ALL of those usages in no way referring to people. And in no cases causing any harm.

I’ve been told by black friends that every single time they see the word “slave” it’s uncomfortable or unnerving.

Sure. I can understand that. Offense, as I have said is subjective and a personal thing. I have also been told by black friends that they couldn't care less about words but are extremely concerned about a society that tolerates a cop putting his knee on the neck of a citizen for 8 minutes and 46 seconds.

1

u/BigLebowskiBot Jun 18 '20

You're not wrong, Walter, you're just an asshole.

1

u/brennanfee Jun 18 '20

And assuming ill intent onto a person unjustly is a problem. You don't know me, I am not an asshole... I just have perspective on what matters here.

1

u/brandonlive Jun 18 '20

Perspective on what matters seems to be one thing you clearly do not have.

1

u/brennanfee Jun 18 '20

Perspective on what matters seems to be one thing you clearly do not have.

If you seriously are trying to argue that a man being murdered by the police is equally or less important than a word... you are the one with the wrong perspective.

1

u/brandonlive Jun 18 '20

Talk about a straw man...

You’re the one fighting to keep a word for no good reason.

Showing solidarity with people who’ve suffered is a worthwhile endeavor. Bitching because you might have to learn to use a different word is not “perspective”.

1

u/brennanfee Jun 18 '20

You’re the one fighting to keep a word for no good reason.

I don't care whether they keep the word or not. I care that we focus on things that will actually make a difference rather than trying to score "woke" points.

1

u/Disillusionedhamster Jun 19 '20

I can't feel my sides oh my God hahah

You're arguing with a bot whose sole purpose is to quote big lebowski quotes . Talk about perspective .

1

u/brandonlive Jun 18 '20

Master/slave has been banned terminology at most major tech companies (including Microsoft) for at least 15 years. There are tools run on the source code to identify and file bugs when these policies are violated. I know the same kind of thing happens elsewhere.

Words matter, regardless of intent.

I never considered “master” in the context of Git harmful, and when I first saw discussion of this I inquired why it was problematic since it didn’t seem to have a good reason to be. I was directed to the evidence that it was based on a master/slave pairing in Bitkeeper, and referred to examples of people saying they’d prefer to see it changed. Including the guy who picked that name for Git:

https://twitter.com/xpasky/status/1271477451756056577?s=20

All of that was good enough for me. Maybe examine why it isn’t good enough for you?

1

u/brennanfee Jun 18 '20

Master/slave has been banned terminology at most major tech companies (including Microsoft) for at least 15 years.

Not when I was there. Do you have any proof of this company "policy"?

I never considered “master” in the context of Git harmful,

Because it wasn't. That is my point. The usage is innocuous and non-personified. The only relationship to slavery is the fact that other usages of the word "master" have a relationship to slavery. It's a pointless thing to be concerned about when instead we all should be focused on forcing our police to have accountability for murdering citizens - especially black citizens with such impunity.

I was directed to the evidence that it was based on a master/slave pairing in Bitkeeper,

Yes. But Larry wasn't even referring to the usages of slavery there. The context matters and the usage matters. It never was intended to refer to the institution of slavery.

Maybe examine why it isn’t good enough for you?

People should use whatever terms they want. But I want people to use VALID reasons and SOUND arguments for WHY something is the way it is rather than assuming ill intent.

1

u/brandonlive Jun 18 '20

Policheck has been around since at least 2005, probably earlier.

https://www.theregister.com/2019/09/03/chromium_microsoft_offensive/

I don’t see how you’re still so completely missing the point. The usage isn’t “innocuous” if it hurts someone.

1

u/brennanfee Jun 18 '20

The usage isn’t “innocuous” if it hurts someone.

No. It doesn't.

Having a society that tolerates police murdering black citizens with impunity does produce REAL harm. Having a society that persecutes gays for wanting to marry, or transgender citizens for wanting to use a restroom they are comfortable in... produces harm. Words. Words are harmless. The ideas are what kill. The ill intent is what harms.

1

u/brandonlive Jun 18 '20

More gaslighting. Get lost.

1

u/brennanfee Jun 18 '20

Look... go ahead and focus on issues that won't change anything and just make most other people's eyes roll. I just wish you could instead be an ally for real change rather than just keeping track of your social media points.

1

u/brandonlive Jun 18 '20

You are the only one focusing on this issue and continually trying to score “points” in this thread. That leads me to believe you’re probably not doing anything meaningful to actually help people.

But yeah, keep trolling, that’ll help a lot.

1

u/brennanfee Jun 18 '20

You are the only one focusing on this issue and continually trying to score “points” in this thread.

If I were the only one focusing on this issue, GitHub would not be making a change.

That leads me to believe you’re probably not doing anything meaningful to actually help people.

Come join me: https://wolf-pac.com/

But yeah, keep trolling, that’ll help a lot.

Ad hominem again. Calling someone a troll is just dismissing them rather than focusing on making a cogent argument.