110
u/Legand_dary May 11 '12
108
May 11 '12
And then, some of them say when thrown to their death, "I don't understand!" It just breaks my heart.
86
May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
When ever I see Wheatly's turret-boxes I always get the feeling that they where in extreme pain due to the fact that they where constructed so badly EDIT* thanks to xMalnutrition
52
u/thehemanchronicles May 11 '12
29
u/BraKes22 May 11 '12
Not sure to upvote because of validity of the statement, or downvote because of the unnecessary image of beaten puppies now burned into my brain.
20
u/deityofchaos May 11 '12
Huh, I always just assumed that was the way it was meant to be. Between the way they move and the abomination-like appearance of them, I thought it was just assumed their existence was in agonizing pain. Then again, can robots feel pain?
17
May 11 '12
Well when you're [throwing down cores in the incinerator in Portal 1 GlaDos clearly shows pain.] (/spoiler) Also in Portal 2 when [Wheatly replaces GlaDos they both show pain and they are both robots.] (/spoiler) I have reason to believe all robots show pain in Portal.
→ More replies (13)30
3
May 11 '12
They made me seriously uneasy. Huge spiders? Np. Scorpions the size of a house? Bring it on. But those things.... I was glad when that was over.
16
54
25
9
48
u/ObviousPie May 11 '12
"Please don't kill me Mister, I only do this to pay for my son's insulin injections, I'm not a bad person, please!" - Last words of a prostitute in Grand Theft Auto.
37
u/AufurNitro PC May 11 '12
ಠ_ಠ
the whores of GTA have more of a soul then anyone else in the games
→ More replies (1)34
127
May 11 '12
One day, I got the idea in my head that turrets didn't want to shoot at me, but that their mechanics forced them to. Thus, "I don't hate you," "I don't blame you," etc. It was the saddest day of my life.
82
u/ByDarwinsBeard May 11 '12
That gives the "are you still there?" different context, too.
→ More replies (1)13
16
2
→ More replies (1)2
u/alucard_3501 May 11 '12
Espacially at the end of Portal 2. [ When you ride up the elevator and come to the first four who target you, then start the opera....when I finally played the multi-player I made it a point to avoid killing as many turrets as I could.] (/spoiler)
213
u/Ryusko May 11 '12
Way more time is spent humanizing those turrets than humanizing random npcs in GTA. Makes sense.
83
u/fattywinnarz May 11 '12
Exactly. It's the same as how people cried during Wall-E but not during movies with real actors that are supposed to be sad.
28
May 11 '12
I laughed at the robot deaths in the Transformers movies... but then I cried when I realized I was watching those movies
4
u/Othy May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
As much as I want to, I can't hate Transformers 3. I'm not saying it's a good movie, but I enjoyed the last 40 or so minutes way to much to say I didn't like it.
EDIT: I can't use words...
30
u/rabidllama May 11 '12
If anything the makers of GTA actually took steps to dehumanize the random npcs. Pretty much everyone you meet is a loathsome, obnoxious caricature who's difficult to sympathize with. So you don't.
Plus, the way they fly through the air when you hit them with a car is pretty funny.
30
May 11 '12
Pretty much everyone you meet is a loathsome, obnoxious caricature who's difficult to sympathize with. So you don't.
Yeah, they did do a pretty good job making them seem like realistic New Yorkers.
4
35
u/Rantingbeerjello May 11 '12
39
May 11 '12
i actually considered letting him go too, but i think after all the faceless goons and innocent bystanders i killed without a shred of guilt, it was only fair to them to pop one in the guy who really deserved it.
26
u/Hegs94 May 11 '12
Here's the thing. I played GTA with two personalities. One was the insane killer that drove around Liberty City killing everyone in sight. The other was a reluctant Eastern European trying to make a living in America, but at the same time struggling with the sins of his past. One I used for when I was in free play, the other for when I was seriously doing the campaign. It really made the dynamic with Roman and a lot of the other characters more interesting, and it made the above mentioned part a serious moral dilemma that I struggled with for a while too.
→ More replies (2)8
May 11 '12
i always tried to play how you just explained, with purpose but in the end it just become a huge clash of die hard and death race (original) and i was a monster.
17
May 11 '12
I shot Roman. "HEY COUSIN! LET'S GO BOW- BANG"
3
May 11 '12
I don't have GTA installed at the moment, so, is that possible? If so, does he stop calling afterwards?
→ More replies (1)22
May 11 '12
Nope, he just calls you asking you to bring him back from the hospital ಠ_ಠ .
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)8
14
2
4
u/DarqWolff May 11 '12
What do you mean? Every character in GTA IV has a back story.
I'm not kidding. Behind the scenes, Rockstar developed back stories, personality types, names, etc., for every single character in the game, including random pedestrian NPCs. I think they put more time into that than VALVe did into characterizing the turrets.
2
1
u/chuiu May 11 '12
Exactly! The turrets have way more character and personality than most other video game characters.
1
u/messer May 11 '12
Next time you boot up GTA4, don't jump into a car and start running people over, walk around and listen to them talk. There are more lines of dialogue for the NPCs than probably the whole script of Portal 1 and 2.
74
u/1up7up May 11 '12
yeah i don't really kill them, i lay them gently on their sides :)
50
u/exposito May 11 '12
And then they shut down. Like a computer. They aren't dead, they're just "sleeping".
23
u/DarqWolff May 11 '12
Fuck you for implying that this isn't true with your sarcasm. You know FULL WELL that I'm not killing those things.
4
2
73
23
u/anthemlog May 11 '12
The turrets have higher-pitched, childlike voices. The even say things like "no hard feelings" and ask you to come into their line of fire without malice. On top of them being programmed to kill you, you almost can't hold them responsible for killing you.
With the humans, you can never be sure.
17
May 11 '12
Whenever I can, I make sure to set them down gently. I just face them toward a wall or something. I try to put them all in the same area so they don't get lonely.
45
u/Conman34 May 11 '12
This is reddit. You are NEVER the only one!
28
u/alahos May 11 '12
I wonder who else beats off to nails scraping a blackboard?
38
u/AustinYQM May 11 '12 edited Jul 24 '24
work spectacular frame paint quickest shrill innocent fall birds squalid
13
4
0
199
u/BlueNotesBlues May 11 '12
Well obviously it's because the turrets are white....
→ More replies (8)
9
u/demiel16 May 11 '12
It's so true. I feel so guilty killing them. I want to give them a hug even though they will blow me full of bullet holes.
→ More replies (2)3
17
7
u/HalpTheFan May 11 '12
There is also an empathy created between the characters. You interact with the turrets, as it is how they're programmed, both literally and figuratively. However, in GTA, they are terrible people, living in a terrible society and act that way.
But then again, I do agree with LukaCola too :)
7
u/ImAWhaleBiologist May 11 '12
The turrets have more personality. GTA NPCs just say "Fuck off" every now and again when you poke them.
6
2
13
u/LadyPirateLord May 11 '12
i felt super bad for them too! and they even [sing you such a pretty song at the end!] (/spoiler)
2
May 11 '12
That was actually an out cry for help to not leave them there, Chell didn't give a shit though.
6
6
u/h4ck3rpunk May 11 '12
Their just so innocent sounding, it isn't their fault that they're made like that :(
3
11
9
u/Brentakill May 11 '12
Yes and no. As guilty as I feel, something about getting turret kills in Portal just feels more rewarding than killing pretty much any other enemy in any other game.
2
15
8
4
u/hardcorenecro May 11 '12
This is why I never knocked over a turret unless I absolutely had to, I would run past them and allow myself to get shot, just so long as i didnt have to hurt them. Hell I'd grab the cameras off the walls and use them as cover
3
u/brodyth May 11 '12
Id pick them up and, if there were multiple, arrange them in a circle, still fully functioning. That was until I realized they shot each other when you walked by because they were forced to aim there...
9
u/hardcorenecro May 11 '12
I just placed them side by side facing a part of the room that looked mildly interesting so they couldn't have a chance to hurt me and so they wouldn't get bored.
4
4
4
u/MattioHimself16 May 11 '12
I really don't feel bad for either. I enjoy running over GTA people, and only enjoy knocking turrets over when they all nearly kill me.
4
u/thaspaam May 11 '12
That's because they can't do anything about their impending doom, really. The people in GTA can at least run.
3
u/BoreasBlack May 11 '12
Technically, you're just knocking them over...
2
u/keiyakins May 11 '12
Or fizzling them, throwing them into four-kilometer pits, fizzling them, incinerating them...
2
1
May 11 '12
I don't even like doing that, I try to make them face a wall if possible and will quickly pick up ones that fall over before they shut down so I can put them in a corner :O
3
May 11 '12
So what you're saying is that you feel more at home with computerized animatronic devices than urban street-folk?
4
3
3
3
3
u/Flurryyea May 11 '12
The turrets are represented audibly as innocents caught in the middle of Chell's tests.
The people in GTA literally aggravate by getting in the way when you are trying to dodge the cops.
1
u/JoeScotterpuss May 11 '12
Yeah I felt bad when I realized the first thing they saw other than their tubes/chambers was me pushing them into a pool. Or them getting stuck between two portals. "WhOooOOaAh"
2
3
May 11 '12
I feel really bad when I kill tickers in Gears of War. Some militant aliens find some innocent little bug, attach a bomb to its back, and send it to its imminent death. Then, when it finds you, it causes about as much damaged as a dog humping your leg, but you explode it to death anyway. The sounds they make are so sad.
RIP Ticker warriors.
3
2
2
u/foursticks May 11 '12
As someone who is not an avid gamer, but enjoys gaming, I applaud you for including what games these are from in the image.
2
May 11 '12
C'mon, the turrets are so pathetic! If you kill one, they say something like, "No hard feelings." And then you have Franken Cubes, and they can sing! Thugs can't organize an opera like turrets can!
2
2
u/Xerazal May 11 '12
I tried not to kill any, but accidentally did... Manly tears were shed that day..
2
May 11 '12
Heck, I even grew more attached and protective of the drones in HL2 then any pedestrian or driver in GTA4.
2
u/H4rry May 11 '12
Why does the bottom pic look so good?
1
May 11 '12
I actually came here hoping for an explanation. I played GTA4 on the 360, and thought that maybe the PC version was a million times better and I didn't know it.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/herpderpcake May 11 '12
"I don't blame you"
VS
"Everyone wants to touch me... why?" I suppose that makes sense.
2
May 11 '12
It doesn't really help what you're saying by the fact that they're all black....or...appear to be anyway...
2
2
u/js2195 May 11 '12
Well they both tend to make holes in you if you got on their wrong side (pun intended), so I actually have no problem knocking both down.
2
u/ethereal4k May 11 '12
The characters in GTA fall within the Uncanny Valley range where as the turrets do not.
2
May 11 '12
The portal turrets are so adorable... it saddens me having to knock them over/into pits all the time. :(
2
u/Evil_Bonsai May 11 '12
Can't say I've tried it, or if even possible, but is there an achievement for not killing any of them? If I could, I'd just pic them up and move them so that they look in the opposite direction of where I needed to go so as not to harm them if I could avoid it.
2
u/bigredmnky May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
Good guy gamer references two different games, PUTS THE FUCKING TITLE FOR BOTH. I WANT YOU TO KNOW I RESPECT YOU, WILD MAGNEMITE
2
u/Vynil_Scratch May 11 '12
In Portal 2, right at the beginning of the campaign for the co-op they say that the robots have simulated pain. At least i know they said it somewhere in the game...
Besides, the turrets actually like you and don't tell you to fuck off.
2
May 11 '12
The pedestrians in GTA are all awful.
Have you ever followed a ped on their cell phone in GTA 4? It's actually hilarious sometimes. "Uh-huh. Call me when your water breaks." "It ain't mine bitch, I pulled out."
2
u/Sir_Llama May 11 '12
I like to pick them up and lay them facing a corner where possible. Otherwise I murder them and go cry
2
u/akuma_619 May 11 '12
Has anyone noticed that in video games they usually don't have children characters and if they do you can't kill them.
2
2
May 11 '12
I make it my mission in any game to kill everything that has a high pitched voice.
Others find the voices cute. I find them to be really annoying.
As much as I didn't like the Claptrap revolution DLC for Borderlands, it let me kill Claptraps. Fuck those things.
2
May 11 '12
Actually I felt pretty guilty when killing people on GTA IV when it first came out. After a while the guilt was non-existent.
This can't be a good thing. I'm one step closer to slaughtering everyone I come across.
2
u/Lefthandsucks May 11 '12
I upvoted because you included the name of the game (even if they are easy to see) so you know what you are talking about.
9
u/revenantae May 11 '12
Are. You. Still. There?
13
2
u/DownVotingCats May 11 '12
As it turns out, it's a video game and I feel nothing but entertainment.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Murumasa May 11 '12
Of course I don't feel bad. Those cabs don't even speak, and they arn't even self automated, having those silly blood bags inside them.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Ichiro_Ino May 11 '12
That game below looked a bit real to me at first look, and I was like 'you want to kill real people?'
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Vegedus May 11 '12
And "killing" turrets in Portal means knocking them over, while killing in GTA usually involves a tank or a baseball bat.
1
u/JoeScotterpuss May 11 '12
Hell I connected more to the octopus in the latest DLC trailer than most other characters I've played with.
1
1
u/pewpewk May 11 '12
My guess is that this is actually more related to the concept referred to as the uncanny valley, which I find as a fascinating little topic related to human psychology.
1
May 11 '12
Which version of GTA is this?
I am not a gamer but I remember having fun with GTA2 and 3 back in the day. The main appeal for me was driving around the city in any car you want. The vehicles in this picture look pretty good, I would love to give this a try.
2
u/Dambem May 11 '12
GTA4, its set in the same place as gta 3, and also includes a multiplayer.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/novadaemon May 11 '12
Well to be fair, portal turrets kind of look like a Magnemite. That would explain your issue with killing your own kind.
1
u/Voidsore May 11 '12
When I hear "Are you still there?" I suddendly need to go hug them...from behind
1
1
1
1
1
u/FargoTrader May 11 '12
Oddly the first thing to come to my mind after viewing this image:
GTA needs better diversity for its pedestrians. Three of the peds in that screenshot are wearing the same jacket, two with the same cap, and several of them share the same hair..
/offtopic
1
u/idiot_proof May 11 '12
Thank you for putting the names of the games in the post. Even though I know these games, there's so many posts like yours that don't include the title and loads of people don't know what the hell they're on about.
Anyways, good post, OP.
1
u/UnknownGnome1 May 11 '12
Portal 2. Where even the wall panels have more character than most game's npcs.
1
u/tetsuooooooooooo May 11 '12
I never kill the turrets in portal, I pick them up and put them somewhere where it can't harm me.
1
u/o0260o May 11 '12
Agree when it comes to GTA but when I was playing Mafia 2 and accidentally hit a pedestrian I reloaded the last save.
1
1
May 11 '12
Portal really knows how to elicit an emotional response, doesn't it?
Companion cube was the one that upset me the most out of anything I've ever killed in a video game, ever. Normally killing things in games is satisfying, but killing Companion Cube made me sit there for a good 5 minutes trying not to cry.
Maybe I shouldn't have played it for the first time on acid. Hahaha
1
May 11 '12
With the turrets I think it is the idea of rich and sophisticated minds being enslaved into a deadly but very simple function.
In other words, the machines ability to function depends upon perceptual processes rather than simple movement detection algorithms. Conciousness and personality are a necessary but largely useless by-product.
Although I think I did detect the occasional malicious 'I see you...'
1
1
May 11 '12
The turrets actually have personality to them. It's hard to kill something when it can tap into your emotions.
1
u/geekgroupie42 May 11 '12
i don't think you're supposed to tell us what game the pics are from, figuring it out is half the fun
1
1
1
u/CosmicBard May 11 '12
The Portal turrets don't even die, either, they just sort of fall over and shut down. It's truly sad. Like they realized they were on their backs and just gave up.
1
1
1
u/mack2028 May 11 '12
One is specifically designed to make you feel bad about killing it and one is specifically designed to make you feel ok about killing it. It does not seem that strange that you take the ques given you only that you recognize them without understanding them.
1
u/AshFallenAngel May 11 '12
You're talking about Portal.
Every single person in this thread is going to say you're not alone in this.
But not me. The turrets and weighted companion cube are stupid.
1
u/watermark0n May 12 '12
You can't be the only piece of human garbage around? Surprise, human garbage abounds in r/gaming, it's a community of shitty fucking garbage people.
1
u/RelaxedChap May 11 '12
Easy explanation: you're a sociopath.
1
u/JoeScotterpuss May 11 '12
Playing vidyagaems=instant sociopath status. You could always maneuver around them. Although some were unavoidable.
1
u/Legolambnon May 11 '12 edited May 11 '12
What's ironic is that the companion cube, an inanimate box, has more character than all those ZOMGMasterChiefEzioMactavishShepards you normally find in games.
TF2 pyro is another example. Speaks complete gibberish, but is still the most likeable character out of all of them.
Obviously... no need to mention Chell and Freeman and Dog
235
u/Sir_Goose May 11 '12
"I'm different!"