r/gameofthrones • House Stark • May 16 '12

Wolves in the Lion's Den

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

397 comments sorted by

255

u/IDriveAVan Hodor Hodor Hodor May 16 '12

And Brienne and Melissandre are ladies at Stag parties.

57

u/krackbaby House Bolton May 16 '12

Brienne

Don't you mean Loras?

Brienne is far too manly for that party

50

u/friednoodles Lyanna Mormont May 16 '12

I like Brienne and she's lady enough for me.

26

u/TheFluxIsThis May 16 '12

She's strong enough for a man, but made for a...man.

7

u/crylicylon May 17 '12

Yes, sir, m'lady.

9

u/Netarum May 17 '12

Brienne is like a big, simple, sturdy cellphone. Most people will find it ugly but there is a buyer for it. Also, good for self-defense.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/ZeekySantos Sansa Stark May 17 '12

TV Spoilerat least.

→ More replies (1)

199

u/NewDrekSilver House Martell May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

Everyday I find out how much more brilliant this show is than I previously thought.

→ More replies (12)

36

u/SilkyTheCat House Tyrell May 16 '12

Lions are strongest with their pride, just like wolves are with their packs. Everybody is pretty alone right now ):

31

u/123rune20 Maesters of the Citadel May 16 '12

This show made me like all the Lannisters a bit more. Cersei is regretting (or seems to be) what she did, Tywin was always awesome, and Jaime is still kind of an ass but cool. I like all of them...except Joffrey of course.

30

u/Arketan House Tyrell May 16 '12

I don't think she's regretful, but she's still a sympathetic character.

14

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

She is more sympathetic in the show probably bc [all books] (/b "we don't get her pov until book 4")

3

u/nununicky May 17 '12

i was thinking about that the other day. is this when she starts to Book Spoiler the next time i decide to reread everything, i'm definitely going to pay more attention and see if there were any signs before affc.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/the_blackfish Brynden Tully May 16 '12

She openly speaks her feelings and motives...you can't help but sympathize with her in the position she's in.

8

u/thatguyinconverse May 17 '12

I was literally just telling this to my girlfriend. Like, I showed her the picture and told how the she's Cercei is a much more sympathetic character than the book one.

Jaime tough, he's even more of an ass. At this point in the books, I was starting to soften up towards him, but in the show he goes on to do that thing he did with Alton, just brutal. That speech about vows he gives later doesn't have the same effect a after that.

12

u/A_Prattling_Gimp House Seaworth May 17 '12

I don't understand why he killed him. Alton is a Lannister. They could easily have pretended to fight and Jaime could have pretended to have killed him. He would have happily gone along with it. When Alton was convulsing I was thinking, "all they had to do was make a noise to get the attention of the guard and have Alton pretend to convulse on the floor".

Really unneccesarily brutal if you ask me.

4

u/JustYourLuck House Lannister May 17 '12

Maybe I give Jamie way too much credit, but I figure they'd kill Alton if he helped Jamie escape, and Jamie thought Alton was too big a liability to take with him. Dying by Jamie's hand quickly was better than dying slowly. Still pretty brutal...

3

u/b00ger House Targaryen May 17 '12

Jaime's plan I the show only makes sense if he wasn't thinking it likely he'd survive. I think he said "fuck it, I'm going out with a bang"

4

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

He had been chained up for a good while and is accustom to a life full of violence and one where he's above others. From his point of view there was no better plan.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/AL_CaPWN422 House Targaryen May 17 '12

I still feel like I have to blame Cersei for Joffrey being a dick. I think GRRM made them seem good here on purpose. I hated all the Lannisters and still sympathized with Theon for his douchebaggery because he wanted to be accepted by his father, but this episode makes me do the opposite. It kind of fits with the "everyone can be killed" theme. Everybody can be good or be a cunt.

3

u/123rune20 Maesters of the Citadel May 17 '12

I was angry at Theon until I saw his face at the end of the most recent episode.

13

u/cakezilla Ours Is The Fury May 16 '12

Not to mention Tyrion being the fucking best character.

9

u/Enlightenment777 May 17 '12 edited May 17 '12

1 - Tyrion Lannister

2 - Arya Stark

3 - Jaqen H'ghar

4 - Sandor Clegane

27

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

0 - Hodor

7

u/cakezilla Ours Is The Fury May 17 '12

Hodor.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Or8is Maesters of the Citadel May 17 '12

No love for Tywin Lannister? Charles Dance really brings his a-game. I feel that TV-Tywin is much more interesting that book-Tywin (same goes for Jaqen, to some extent), whereas the Tyrion, Arya and Sandor are already quite awesome in the books.

6

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

Bronn > Sandor

→ More replies (1)

31

u/vulcan257 Braavosi Water Dancers May 16 '12

Might as well add the Caitlyn in Jaime's cage as well.

6

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

So true. After the most recent episode TV Spoiler

3

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

Except she was there by choice.

15

u/DireBaboon Brave Companions May 16 '12

Bravo, great catch

13

u/lolbacon May 17 '12

Braavos, great catch

GOTTFY

26

u/BeefCaptain Brotherhood Without Banners May 16 '12

Well said.

18

u/TroyMantis May 16 '12

Dire-wolves indeed.

9

u/misclanous House Baratheon of King's Landing May 16 '12

This is one of those places where they took ideas from the novel, changed some plot devices around, and made a fantastic narrative piece. Having the two and the contrast between them is fantastic and I really don't care that one of them isn't in the novel.

8

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Ohhhhh...

7

u/red321red321 May 16 '12

i love the dialogue between arya and tywin it's great you can tell that he likes her but it's interesting how she seems to be interested in him too all the while wanting to cut his throat.

19

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Wolves in the throne room

1

u/satanscrotum May 16 '12

Oh no. Don't tell me you've got the Rainbow Illness?

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

No problem man, I've got the Astral Blood

→ More replies (4)

4

u/flashbeagle House Mormont May 16 '12

This is brilliant.

4

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Good on you for picking out this parallel.

39

u/Odusei I Am So Sorry May 16 '12

Alright, I'm not quite done reading the books (halfway through the last one), but where the hell are all the lions? As far as I can tell, Westeros doesn't have any savannas, so they probably don't have any. You also don't see any in the free cities. So where is everyone in these books getting this idea that there's a thing called a lion?

136

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

There aren't any lions in England, either, but it's on their royal crest.

22

u/Odusei I Am So Sorry May 16 '12

But there are wolves in Winterfell, fish in Riverrun, squids near the iron islands, flowers in Highgarden, and definitely a few flayed men at the Dreadfort.

You'd think if the Lannisters picked an animal that lived nowhere near them, they'd at least have a compelling reason (like England does).

40

u/Jfolcik Children of the Forest May 16 '12 edited May 17 '12

There weren't Direwolves near Winterfell for thousands of years before this series began, and the Greyjoy's sigil isn't a squid but a craven kraken, which we've yet to see any evidence that they've ever been around. A sigil doesn't have to be something that can be seen from the house's walls.

22

u/ramonycajones House Stark May 16 '12

kraken*? Sam is a craven

29

u/RedFlocks Red Priests of R'hllor May 16 '12

You be nice to Sam. He's the ASoS.

4

u/Jfolcik Children of the Forest May 16 '12

Whoa! That was weird haha thanks.

6

u/FluffyLion May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

The Stark bloodline has been around for thousands of years as well, when Direwolves were around. Bran the Builder, a Stark ancestor, built the Wall after all.

The kraken can be explained just as it is in real life, a legend born from something that does exist, a squid, perhaps a giant squid, something that we in the real world dismissed as the stuff of legend until only just recently.

Lions, however, are pretty unique. Most mythical animals are simply created using aspects of animals that are already known about (A pegasus a horse with wings, minotaur is a bipedal ox, a cyclops is a giant person with one eye, so on) It's unlikely that someone would simply "invent" a Lion with the animals one can find in Westeros. So far nothing has been mentioned as having existed that looks like a Lion in the 7 kingdoms. Perhaps it exists somewhere in the east, where the Andals, the ancestors of the Lannisters and other Southern families, originated. NVM, it's been pointed out that they did exist in Westeros and simply died out in the wild. I don't remember reading that, but I'll believe them.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/dextiny White Walkers May 17 '12

There is a cameo of a kraken in SOS it's not a spoiler it's just one of the reports/news Varys read to someone. Something like "there as been reports of a kraken destroyed one of the fisherman ships"

2

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

If I recall correctly, the original Lannister symbol was, like, a clown or something. One of the ancestors rebranded the family line for better feudal marketing. He decided to go with the Lion as the family logo. Probably a good decision, all things considered. Kind of like the Baelish family, which is a giant, I think originally from Braavos. But Petyr, brilliant courtier that his is, adopted the mockingbird as his symbol, to seem less threatening to the powers that be. Also a smart marketing decision, no?

→ More replies (7)

13

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

Why do you always type in monospace?

8

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Manderly: Merman. Brax: Unicorn.

If these are in Westeros, we certainly haven't heard of them.

6

u/allycakes May 16 '12

There are some unicorns still past the wall according to the wildlings, but none in Westeros anymore.

3

u/pilinisi May 16 '12

And on Skagos

→ More replies (1)

11

u/bradders42 Stannis Baratheon May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

I think the Lannisters generally have a thing for image, so they picked the "king of beasts"

Edit: Spelling. Thanks fergetcom

16

u/fergetcom May 16 '12

A small g can cast a large shadow.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/watchman_wen May 16 '12

Greyjoy crest is a kraken, not a squid.

2

u/SlumberCat House Seaworth May 17 '12

they should change their sigil to a golden turd.

2

u/selflessGene Dothraki May 17 '12

The Lannisters are descended from another people (Andals, I believe) that came to Westeros and eventually took over the place.

Maybe there were lots of lions in their homeland. Or maybe they are familiar with boating technology to take them to other lands where lions DO exist.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

kraken*

1

u/egonil Hodor Hodor Hodor May 17 '12

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Wish there were unicorns in the UK...

2

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

The Cave Lion existed in Europe (including England) as recently as the last ice age. Some indications point to the lion existing in south east Europe as recntly as 2000 yrs ago. It is possible the symbol of the lion made its way through oral tradition/history to make its way onto the crest.

1

u/UrbisPreturbis May 17 '12

There are lions in medieval Serbian epic poetry. It's quite possible they survived in the Balkans until the 13th century - we really have very few records of the period prior to that.

1

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

More likely that Europeans knew about lions because the Romans imported so many from Africa for their games and fed the Christians to them.

2

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

Lions in European history are much older than the Roman empire. The Nemean Lion is one of the monsters Hercules kills in greek mythology, placing it prior to Rome's influential time period. (during which the gladiatorial games were at their peak)

Plus they were feeding people to lions well before christianity existed. The idea that it was a chrisitian punishment was just perpetuated by the church to assume the persecuted role (the same role they try to push today, war on christmas, railing against separation of church and state etc.)

54

u/[deleted] May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

There used to be lions in the Westerlands (where the Lannisters live) but they're all dead in the wild.

Quote from ADWD

20

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

3

u/AetherIsWaiting Faceless Men May 16 '12

1

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

Well, we know there are jungles, but there might be plains as well.

15

u/titsmcgahee House Baratheon May 16 '12

I believe that there used to be wild lions in western Westeros near present day Lannisport and IIRC there are currently lions kept at Casterly Rock.

11

u/LuckyCanuck13 House Blackfyre May 16 '12

There were lions in Westeros. House Clegane was created after the the original Clegane saved Tytos Lannister (Tywin's father) from a lion. Cersei also petted one at a circus or something.

6

u/tekn04 May 16 '12

In the books it is explained that there used to be lions in Westeros, but that they all died out at some point – I can't remember the specifics of why.

1

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Neckwrecker Children of the Forest May 17 '12

Feline AIDS

9

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Sothoryos or Essos is my guess. Dragons and most people in Westeros originated around Essos.

The only true native people of Westeros are the Children of the Forest (think: ancient tribes in Britain). Then the First Men (Romans) invaded, and then the Andals (Anglo-Saxons).

2

u/TurtleFlip House Seaworth May 17 '12

That's a really good analogy (along with Valyria being clearly influenced by Atlantis). I've been trying to keep the ancient history straight in my head for a while, and this really helps me, since I love ancient/medieval history.

I guess that would make the Wildlings the Scots, then. Never fully conquered by the Romans, had to build a wall to keep them out. Sounds pretty familiar. Hell, Westeros even sort of looks like an inflated/distorted Isle of Britain.

1

u/sixfourch May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

Isn't Valyria supposed to have the Roman vibe?

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

Valyria is basically the lost city of Atlantis (really advanced island nation/peninsula that is lost to a cataclysm). Valyria is also really far from Westeros, and the Valyrians (in the form of the Targaryens who survived the Doom) don't reach Westeros until well after the other invasions.

But as I mentioned in another comment, GRRM mixes and matches a lot of influences from history, various cultures, and myths. There is no one historical counterpart or timeline that matches up perfectly with GRRM's world. If you think you see a historical comparison it might very well be the case that GRRM was inspired by it. Old Valyria definitely has a Roman feel to it, even if it doesn't match the tribes/Romans/Saxons/Normans procession.

2

u/sixfourch May 16 '12

Roman Italy was a really advanced peninsula that was lost to a cataclysm (the fall of Western Rome). Some parts of it didn't fall (Volantis, IIRC) and maintain the governmental structure. The empire had a huge reach (all the way to Dragon's Rock or whatever the name of the island that Stannis was on was) and military technology such that after the central city fell, the outskirts were able to outmatch anyone they chose to.

I never read Valyria as anything other than Rome, though obviously it's not a one-to-one mapping between ASoIaF and reality.

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

While I definitely agree with the Rome/Valyria vibe observation, I don't agree with this:

Roman Italy was a really advanced peninsula that was lost to a cataclysm (the fall of Western Rome).

The fall of Western Rome was a drawn out process, and cannot accurately be called a cataclysm. The reason I liken Valyria to Atlantis is that a huge disaster (meteor/volcano/whatever) wiped out a highly advanced civilization in a fast and brutal blow. That's different from an Empire imploding from within.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/TurtleFlip House Seaworth May 17 '12

That's a stretch. The Western Roman Empire definitely fell more because of decadence/corruption taking it's toll, overstretched borders, and weak leaders. Combined with the pressures of ever more aggressive barbarian invasions, that was it's doom, not any natural disaster. The only thing I can think of that would even be close is Pompeii, and that only destroyed one city, not even the whole or a majority of the Italian peninsula.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Lambchops_Legion Iron Bank of Braavos May 17 '12

I get a Greek city-state vibe from the 9 free cities on the west end of Essos.

Also, I get an Ottoman vibe from Qarth (Constantinople: the city that connected the west to the east, etc)

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Odusei I Am So Sorry May 16 '12

Which ones are the Targaryens?

8

u/[deleted] May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

Since the Normans supplanted the Anglo-Saxons, my guess is the Normans. Though I don't think it's a clean comparison like that. GRRM borrows things from different cultures and empires. I see aspects of the Moors interwoven throughout the Andals and around Essos. The Moors even called their territory Al Andalus.

I also see aspects of Egyptian dynasties in the Targaryens. A ton of ASOIAF is inspired by history and historical figures. I also like the pop culture references (like Howland Reed and his moving castle).

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

The moors are probably more clearly analogous to the Dornish, don't you think...

4

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Sure. Recall that I said there wasn't a clean comparison that perfectly lines up with everything. GRRM borrows from lots of different cultures and injects aspects of them in different places. I can even see some parallels to Egyptian dynasties with the Targaryens.

But I agree; the Moors and Dornish are the most similar of all the Seven Kingdoms to their Real World Historical Counterparts.

2

u/watchman_wen May 16 '12

a mix of Atlantis and the Normans maybe?

5

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Yes. Old Valyria totally has a Lost City of Atlantis thing going.

3

u/sixfourch May 16 '12

It also seems very Roman, at least going by what we learn in ADwD.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/sighlander House Tyrell May 16 '12

Normans?

1

u/don2563 House Targaryen May 16 '12

France?

1

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

Why is your text like that?

2

u/magic_ref May 16 '12

There might have been, a long time ago. Westeros could have been affected by climatic cycles or something like that. After all, there used to be camels in North America. :)

2

u/b00ger House Targaryen May 16 '12

Untagged book "spoilers": It's mentioned in the later books (ADWD, I think. Maybe you're not there yet.) that there used to be lots of actual, real live lions in the Westerlands, and that they now are nearly extinct. There's also a story about the origins of House Clegane, and how a servant saved a Lannister from a lion with his hounds and was rewarded with a title. Hence, the 3 hounds of House Clegane.

2

u/lufraf House Frey May 17 '12

In DwD (no spoiler) someone casually mentions lions having lived in the westerlands but are now extinct. There are still white lions in the Dothraki sea

3

u/myhandleonreddit May 16 '12

Why the hell do you format your comments like that? Think you deserve to stand out more than other users?

1

u/Odusei I Am So Sorry May 17 '12

It helps me find where I've commented in threads. I have no idea what I do and don't deserve, I guess that's why there's a voting system.

2

u/myhandleonreddit May 17 '12

An old trick is to add yourself to your friends list. Then a big red [F] appears next to your username. Let's be honest, what you're doing right now is ridiculous.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/soigneusement Hear Me Roar! May 18 '12

I read your replies like a robot!

How do you change your font like that?

1

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

Whoa, I know, right? How did they even know that there is/was such an animal as a lion? The only thing that could explain this is that there were lions once, who went extinct. Another very important question comes to my mind - are there white bears beyond the wall and do they penguins?

1

u/snipawolf House Dondarrion May 17 '12

Aren't there lions?

The Hound tells about how his family made their crest. There was a story about three dogs chasing down a lioness that the Lannisters were hunting.

1

u/Heuristics May 16 '12

Same place we get the idea of dragons?

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

[deleted]

4

u/Light-of-Aiur May 17 '12

Does anyone use the pegasus as a sigil?

17

u/blambot Night's Watch May 16 '12

Am i the only one who thinks Ned Stark and Tywin would have been good friends under different circumstances....

78

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

They have completely different beliefs, motivations, and methods. Tywin is all about promoting the position of the Lannisters and he will do anything to accomplish that. Ned was all about being a good man, good father, and good lord.

0

u/Kestralotp May 16 '12

Promoting the position of his family* would be a better way to word it.

15

u/RedFlocks Red Priests of R'hllor May 16 '12

His family, the Lannisters.

12

u/Kestralotp May 16 '12

The thing I don't like particularly about the wording, all though correct, it makes Tywin appear as if he is fighting solely for the namesake of "Lannister," and doesn't do the character justice for his real motive. Tywin doesn't do what he does because he's from House Lannister, he does what he does because it is family.

So what you said was correct, but I think it shows Tywin as a deeper character by using "family."

4

u/RedFlocks Red Priests of R'hllor May 16 '12

He talks a lot about making the Lannisters a house to be feared and the legacy of the Lannisters. I think he actually does what he does for the Lannisters not just for family. I think you have it backwards.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

28

u/pnokey May 16 '12

I doubt it. Ned was way to honorable.

25

u/cynognathus House Cassel May 16 '12

“You wear your honor like a suit of armor...You think it keeps you safe, but all it does is weigh you down and make it hard for you to move.”

9

u/hooplah May 16 '12

Yeah, even the dichotomy between Robert and Ned was incredibly contrasted. Robert poked fun at Ned's honorableness.

8

u/Holybasil House Dondarrion May 16 '12

I think Tywin has an equal amount of honor, it's just their moral compasses that doesn't align.

3

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

So is Tywin in a traditional sense. He didn't start the war that he's fighting

6

u/freako_66 May 17 '12

seriously the lanister plan wasnt even all that bad. ned goes to the wall and forsakes all politics with the oath, sansa marries joffrey and unites the two houses, and everyone lives happily ever after. it could have worked if joffrey wasnt just the worst person ever.

3

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

I want to see a conversation with Ned and Tywin, don't care how it goes, just curious

→ More replies (9)

8

u/CEONeil Daenerys Targaryen May 16 '12

Anyone else love how the Hound calls Sansa "little bird"?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/csn1 May 17 '12

I don't remember this scene in "Going Postal". What happened to Lord Vetinari's hair?

2

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

31

u/CEONeil Daenerys Targaryen May 16 '12

Sansa is barely a wolf... Absolutely useless to the family at this point.

143

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

I'd say Sansa is technically more useful than Arya, seeing as Arya is, for all intents and purposes, MIA.

...

I tend to get defensive of Sansa, I guess. xD Her wolf is dead! She has to find her inner Stark without it.

54

u/sporkseverywhere May 16 '12

Arya is MIA, but Sansa is a liability. Essentially, her captivity is the only thing keeping the Starks from playing the "give us our freedom or off with Jamie's head" gambit. Given that, I'd argue that Arya is currently more useful, but only in the way that zero usefulness is technically better than negative usefulness.

Although the Starks still think Arya is captive anyway (and in reality, she is, she's just concealing it), so the difference might be too small to matter.

6

u/Lambchops_Legion Iron Bank of Braavos May 17 '12

her captivity is the only thing keeping the Starks from playing the "give us our freedom or off with Jamie's head" gambit.

That's not true.

Technically, Catelyn and Robb don't know that Arya is MIA. They think she's still being held captive by the Lannisters in King's Landing.

19

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

We could definitely make a case for either girl. I adore them both, just that Arya doesn't need defending all the time like my poor dear Sansa.

7

u/spig House Martell May 16 '12

I hated reading her chapters in the books so far, but in the show they are really pulling her off well.

6

u/TheFluxIsThis May 16 '12

I finished ACOK recently, and I thought that I could see Sansa's confidence in herself building as the story went on. In fact, I saw ACOK as really the account of the times that the Stark children all started to grow up at the same time (except Rickon, but he's only 4, so it's not exactly something you expect of him.)

10

u/anthereddit May 17 '12

I finished ACOK recently
I saw ACOK

I may be immature, but I giggled.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

I see Sansa as essential to the stability of the Kings landing. She has been excellent in changing her personality in order to keep herself alive and remains the stable mind of the monarchy. She will probably be used by Cersei and Tyrion to keep Jeoffrey in check. The question is where Sandor Clegane's alligiance lies. He has shown hints of being the white knight protector of Sansa, and It seems only inevitable that Jeoffrey will strike out at her in a more lethal manner. Her having a period sets us up for Jeoffrey sadism, and we will see how the family reacts to further outburst by the new mad king.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

24

u/skookybird I Am So Sorry May 16 '12

Furthermore, given the chance to kill two high-ranking Lannister men in Harrenhal (including Tywin Lannister himself), which would do wonders for her family’s war effort, Arya instead chooses targets that have personally hurt her (or people she likes) or personally threaten her. ACOK

12

u/emmster House Mormont May 16 '12

Her third name is pretty fucking good, though.

1

u/KoaliaBear Hodor Hodor Hodor May 16 '12

well, remember that she is a pretty young girl. it took her some time to see the bigger picture, but the fact that she figures that out before all her names are gone is pretty impressive to me. i constantly wonder if the eight year old me would have been have as clever.

→ More replies (18)

1

u/oer6000 House Greyjoy May 17 '12

4

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

3

u/oer6000 House Greyjoy May 17 '12 edited May 17 '12

[Post ADWD speculation] (/g "At that point she might as well be in Asshai for all the good she does. Besides she'll leave the kindly man soon enough.")

-11

u/CEONeil Daenerys Targaryen May 16 '12

It just bugs me how she defended Joffrey even after Cersi basically called him crazy.

47

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

Do you really not see what Sansa is doing? She's parroting back whatever bullshit she has to say to stay alive. No matter what any Lannister says to her, she is going to sing Joffrey's praises like an obedient little bird. She thinks he's a monster.

→ More replies (4)

59

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

She knows better than to falter from her false loyalty for any reason. She saw Joffrey take her father's head for fuck's sake!

→ More replies (2)

28

u/wabbajacky House Stark May 16 '12

Because Sansa is wary. She has no idea if Cersei is testing her or not so she has to say the right things at all times, just in case.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (3)

64

u/CiboGenome House Targaryen May 16 '12

Sansa is a fish, not a wolf. She's always been more Tully than Stark.

5

u/befenpo Direwolves May 17 '12

Upvote for quote good ser

8

u/glass_canon May 16 '12

She is sworn to her beloved Joffery, and she may survive us all.

4

u/Unstopkable May 16 '12

But she is the one Stark in the most politically pivotal position against the Lannisters.

13

u/DanC520 May 16 '12

This is so true. Additionally, Sansa lying about the wolf attacking Joffery lead to countless deaths. She has no "inner-wolf", she is just a scared pup.

4

u/rosieblades Hot Pie! May 17 '12

Sansa lying about the wolf attacking Joffery lead to countless deaths

What? How? (Non-reader here)

4

u/krackbaby House Bolton May 17 '12

This was in the show, when Arya and the butcher's boy are playing. Joffrey shows up, acts like a cunt, and Nymeria (Arya's dire wolf) bites that cunt. Sansa loves her sweet prince, so she pretends like the little children caused the ruckus, not cunt Joffrey. Then Cersei has Sansa's wolf put to death (because Nymeria ran away) for the lolz

5

u/rosieblades Hot Pie! May 17 '12

But where are the countless deaths? This incident didn't start the war.

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

The butcher boy died as well and it also caused tension between house stark and the king. Ned and the king were arguing and the king didn't take it easy on Ned.

This resistance pushed Ned further away from the king.

3

u/Doomsayer189 House Dondarrion May 17 '12

Wait, what? How did that remotely affect anything? Unless you mean ASOS

-4

u/CEONeil Daenerys Targaryen May 16 '12

Oh how masterfully you crafted that reply.

2

u/LeberechtReinhold House Manderly May 16 '12

She has more value to the Lannister. Poor lady.

4

u/watchman_wen May 16 '12

Sansa is gathering valuable intelligence in the very seat of power for the Lannisters.

3

u/CEONeil Daenerys Targaryen May 16 '12

like what....

13

u/Neckwrecker Children of the Forest May 17 '12

"Joffrey likes soda pop..."

-2

u/mandingophil May 16 '12

Sansa is probably the only stark who is not proactive in paving her own future. She is completely at the mercy of those controlling her. Her passivity makes me hate the character with a burning passion, but sympathize with her because she was raised to be complacent. I don't like feeling so many conflicting emotions, so I am going to label it as hate for Sansa.

56

u/Arketan House Tyrell May 16 '12

At this point if you don't feel extremely sorry for Sansa, you're an idiot. She's a kid who was raised to be a perfect lady and is currently being held captive and being beaten and almost raped, but she doesn't let anyone see how panicked and scared she is, she's fucking brave.

12

u/Fatal85 May 16 '12

I agree. As much as I'd like to think she could try and run away. I know she lacks the ability to survive on the run long enough to escape to safety.

17

u/mahouyousei House Martell May 17 '12

What I love about her is that she knows this too. She knows that being the Lannister's pet right now is exactly how she can stay alive and she's playing that role beautifully.

Sansa's not stupid. Naive but definitely not stupid. A bit culture shocked too.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Duckylicious May 16 '12

Completely agree - I wasn't a fan of her after the first season, but seriously, what "crimes" had she committed? She was a young teenage girl fantasizing about marrying the Prince (which, in this universe and in her situation, isn't completely absurd), and being a bit of a jerk to her sister. In no way, shape, or form has she deserved anything that happened to her since [TV Spoiler] (/s you left out the charming bit about what happened to her dad). I feel so, so sorry for her.

Sorry if the spoiler's unnecessary, I'm new to this subreddit and after reading the guideline, thought better safe than sorry on that one.

3

u/mandingophil May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12

Don't be so harsh, her character in the books was far less brave than her on screen portrayal. Therefore, as an avid book reader, my opinion of her is skewed slightly toward disliking her. However, the biggest problem with Sansa is she is very passionate about things she wants, without taking a minute to stop and think about all potential outcomes. It is almost as if she is always lacking some crucial knowledge which would guide her to make a better decision; which makes her more of a sheep than a wolf. She has the same braveness Caitlyn has, without her wisdom. She is a fish (Tully), and will always be a fish. [book spoilers minor] (/b "There is still plenty of time for you to dislike her as well, depending on how the show develops her character")

4

u/theyawner House Martell May 17 '12 edited May 17 '12

without taking a minute to stop and think about all potential outcomes.

Sounds like some of the wolves I know.

Edit: Format

2

u/Doomsayer189 House Dondarrion May 17 '12

As in, all of them. Every single Stark is guilty of that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

5

u/zkelvin May 17 '12

You realize she attempted to assassinate Joffrey, right?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/IWillEatForFood May 16 '12

Love Arya, character wise. Plus Maisie Williams is the perfect girl, I don't think they could have casted that part any better. Can't wait for her to turn into the ultimate bad-ass!!

1

u/michaelsong55 House Targaryen May 16 '12

niiice i really like this

1

u/phillipjfried May 16 '12

More like keep your friends close. Keep your enemies closer.

1

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

I wish that dinner knife could drop from the top to the bottom pic

1

u/jethreezy House Blackfyre May 17 '12

Sansa is more like a docile dog.

1

u/eaturliver House Stark May 18 '12

I love your title so much.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '12

AWESOME. I just got that feeling where things you hadn't noticed suddenly click.

1

u/[deleted] May 17 '12

damn cersei is hot.

-8

u/mindctrlpankak May 16 '12

jesus George R. R. Martin is a genius.

8

u/drockers Braavosi Water Dancers May 16 '12

this was never in the books so no don't give him credit.

0

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

[deleted]

4

u/ClownsAteMyBaby May 16 '12

"Co-executive producer" is probably mostly an honorary title. The only episodes he likely has major input into are the ones he's writing.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

[deleted]

1

u/mindctrlpankak May 17 '12

He's consulting and doing writing for the show is he not?

1

u/zersch House Greyjoy May 17 '12

He's not as hands on as you might think. Outside of the episodes he directs himself, that is. Which was... Baelor last season and the upcoming battle this season I think.

0

u/strokerlinx No One May 16 '12

When did Tywin hold Arya?

13

u/drockers Braavosi Water Dancers May 16 '12

It didn't happen in the books. Arya became roose boltons cup bearer when he takes over harrenhal, she also uses her owed debt differently in the show.

1

u/ApexofPigritude House Baelish May 16 '12

I'm actually liking the show version of who she names much better. aSoS, but her reasons for killing who she does in the show are much more thought out than in the books. Season 2

6

u/derpington1244 House Clegane May 16 '12

Happened like episode 2 or 3 in Season 2. Arya and Tywin's scenes completely steal the show, in my opinion. And the Littlefinger scene...good god.

3

u/strokerlinx No One May 16 '12

I'm talking about the books. Maybe its been too long, but I don't remember the two of them in scenes together.

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

They've skipped the part where Arya was in the kitchens, and had her as Tywin's cupbearer right from the start. Hopefuly she'll still be Roose Bolton's cupbearer when (if?) he shows up in the show.

9

u/drockers Braavosi Water Dancers May 16 '12

Arya was never Lord Tywin's cup-bearer just roose's

2

u/strokerlinx No One May 16 '12

Good. I'm not crazy.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

We saw Roose Bolton already, in the second season, with Robb.

4

u/CVI07 We Do Not Sow May 16 '12

In the books, Arya is in Harrenhall with just Gregor in charge. She spends some time as a kitchen girl under that big gross dude, and does a couple other unnoticeable jobs, as Weasel.

In the show she arrives at Harrenhall at the same time as Tywin, who immediately recognizes her as a girl and has her sent to his chambers as a cupbearer. It's actually been a really interesting change, we're getting a lot more character development for Tywin and some great alternate stuff for Arya.

3

u/Shorkan May 16 '12

It didn't happen in the books.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/CEONeil Daenerys Targaryen May 16 '12

I think Littlefinger knew it was her... I'm waiting to see if anything comes from that.

2

u/derpington1244 House Clegane May 17 '12

Oh of course he knew it was her. That's the best part! He hasn't told Tywin yet, if ever, and is just gathering information. He's such a sly little shit, god damn I love this show.

→ More replies (1)