r/gameofthrones • u/althius1 • May 08 '12
I think everyone on Reddit has felt this way at least once...
http://imgur.com/zoh3z81
u/AlexisDeTocqueville We Do Not Sow May 08 '12
His point was actually very important though. He was pointing out that she's never held the Iron Throne. As a businessman, her inexperience only adds to the risk he would incur by giving her ships.
I know he's weird and we're supposed to root for Daenerys, but the spice merchant was totally right to not give her ships.
61
May 08 '12
Are we supposed to root for Dany?
41
u/althius1 May 08 '12
That is a very good point that many have brought up before. If Dany returns to claim the Iron Throne it would mean the death of every character you've ever known or loved. Is she a good guy, or a bad guy?
6
u/poekoelan Faceless Men May 08 '12
YOU EXAGGERATE, SER! I love Ser Barristan and am amused by Ser Jorah, they wouldn't necessarily die. Dany seems like the type to take good counsel, she might spare Tyrion. Anyway the storyline is so huge, she couldn't possibly kill all the chararcters.
4
u/althius1 May 08 '12
While I do not think Dany would personally kill every other main on the show, the war that would rage would devour all of Westeros. I can imagine a few resourceful characters surviving... but many, many would/might be slaughtered in the process.
And of course don't forget this [George RR Martin Spoilers] (/b "Author George R.R. Martin was asked if he had a resolution or ending to the seemingly endless conflict. He replied that the end would be a cloud of dust or snow being driven by the wind across a vast graveyard full of tombstones.")
1
u/poekoelan Faceless Men May 08 '12
Wow, really?? You got a source for that? That seems like a pretty major spoiler from the man himself.
2
1
36
u/SlapHappyDude May 08 '12
I feel like its pretty clear she would be another Mad Queen.
9
u/Aikarus May 08 '12
I can name you three differences between mad and Rightful and the three of them rest on her shoulders.
14
u/oer6000 House Greyjoy May 08 '12
→ More replies (5)3
6
u/poekoelan Faceless Men May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Strongly disagree! All books spoiler but far from a psychotic murderer.
1
2
u/CountDerpington House Targaryen May 08 '12
As Jorah said, she has a gentle heart. I don't think that if she were to take the throne she would kill off everyone because of their family name and their house's involvement with the fall of Aerys. Daenerys was brainwashed by Viserys, and I believe none of her followers have ever really explained to her how mad her father actually was.
I believe she would pardon a lot of people. Especially now that the people who she grew up to hate (Eddard and Robert, mainly) are dead. An exception might be the Lannisters, I don't think she would pardon them. Especially not Jaime, but who knows.
4
u/thesorrow312 May 08 '12
There are no fucking good or bad guys. Why do people feel the need to subscribe to such biblical black and white morality? This book series is all about destroying such primitive plot and character structures.
Yet people on this subreddit go on and on thinking that anyone who is not a Stark, or blindly allied to them, is somehow a bad guy.
This is fucking feudalism kids, there are no god and bad guys, they are all hereditary monarchs and totalitarian dictators. They are inherently not good guys.
"The worst slave-owners were those who were kind to their slaves, and so prevented the horror of the system being realized by those who suffered from it, and understood by those who contemplated it" - Oscar Wilde - The soul of man under Socialism
3
u/FunnyBunny01 Bronn of the Blackwater May 08 '12
I would say Joffery is a bad guy
3
u/thesorrow312 May 08 '12
He may be the sole exception, but he is merely a plot device IMO. He makes no real political decisions, he is a puppet that gets in the way, a child.
My thesis is that all the families are inherently equal. There is no family that should rule, there is no "good guy" or "just" dictator. They all have "equal" justification to rule, that justification is the social and political system of their times, but there is no justification for totalitarianism. As Varis said, its all a game, power is a shadow on a wall.
The same arguments are made today against states and capitalism by the left. This is why I love interpreting the politics of ASOIAF. To put oneself in the mindset of a radical anti authoritarian in the feudal times.
2
u/Condorcet_Winner House Baratheon of Dragonstone May 08 '12
Sure there is justification for totalitarianism. It allows for quicker decision making and more decisive action than can be made in democracies or other bureaucratic societies. Of course unlimited power has its pitfalls, but when you are in such dangerous and turbulent times, having such a powerful leader can offer benefits that other forms of government could not. There is no political deadlock.
If the leader is smart and has the benefit of his people in mind, then a dictatorship can be very effective.
→ More replies (3)3
u/TheRadBaron May 09 '12
Why do people feel the need to subscribe to such biblical black and white morality?
Probably because GRRM likes filling the series with villains so unambiguously evil that it makes Disney cartoons look complex. He often does a decent job keeping away from unambiguously good characters and muddies up some of the evil ones, but just look at Gregor or Joffrey or Aerys or Viserys (keeping to the small pool of non-spoiler examples).
2
u/thesorrow312 May 09 '12
Aerys and Viserys are not evil. They were way more complex than that.
Aerys had psychological problems. Viserys had the same " This is my birthright, I deserve this" delusion that Dany now has. If he had grown up in royalty, rather than in the position he got thrown into, he would have been in a normal social situation.
Joffrey is the only non redeemable character in the entire series.
Gregor is just a tool, like so many people used to be, and are now. He's the perfect, ideal, military pawn.
3
u/primusperegrinus You Know Nothing May 08 '12
I doubt that she would be more cruel that Joffrey, so there's that, at least.
4
8
u/AlexisDeTocqueville We Do Not Sow May 08 '12
Fair enough, I think most fans are at least rooting for her to return to Westeros so something big can happen.
2
0
May 08 '12
[deleted]
3
u/Duder_DBro Sellswords May 08 '12
No offense but couldn't you have put a spoiler on that?
1
u/DallasTruther May 08 '12
Why? It didn't spoil anything for me. I mean, what shocking event did he include? Nada. Really, nothing.
4
u/Duder_DBro Sellswords May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
He ruled out the possibility of an event. I can't get spoilers to work so, yeah, spoilers ahead.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)1
u/roshi94 May 08 '12
Me and my friend got seriously bored with that book, but don't worry, it gets better towards the end, George R. R. Martin style.
Edit: And the next book is awesome!!!
4
u/ShadyG May 08 '12
We're supposed to root for her at Qarth. Perhaps against her in the wider context.
2
u/FAFASGR Hot Pie! May 09 '12
No we are just rooting for her to get back to Westeros so we can get on with the story and not read endlessly about slaves and cooked puppies for no good reason other than that GRRM likes to ramble.
2
u/JanitorWolfman House Greyjoy May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Read all 5 books and I absolutely hate Dany because she is such a indecisive whiny brat. Not to mention those Dragons are murderous fucking beasts that will kill thousands of people for what Dany will think is "the greater good".
2
3
u/SlapHappyDude May 08 '12
Yeah, 3:1 isn't a very big payout for the risk, and that assumes he can trust her to pay up if she wins.
1
u/therealamberrose May 08 '12
3:1 is an okay payout and he probably trusts she'd pay. But she has to win to be able pay. I dislike the spice merchant, but he has a point!
→ More replies (1)2
May 10 '12
I thought it was clear that at this point, Dany relies too much on her bloodlines and is a bit naive. Her time in Qarth is exposing her weakness, which will hopefully lead to her overcoming that weakness.
I'm rooting for her because I'm not overly fond of the Starks, and I want to see more dragons! but I'm sure a lot of people find her annoying.
20
u/althius1 May 08 '12
I gave serious thought to spelling it Grammer....
10
8
May 08 '12
"Grammer" would have been a spelling mistake, not a grammar mistake.
8
2
1
u/CowFu Braavosi Water Dancers May 08 '12
Spelling is part of grammar. Just as a square is still considered a rectangle.
3
u/1_point_21_gigawatts May 08 '12
A single period would have sufficed, your ellipsis is unnecessary.
Also, a proper ellipsis is commonly three periods long (...).
10
u/bettse May 08 '12
a proper ellipsis is commonly three periods long
a proper ellipsis is a precomposed triple-dot glyph, but its commonly approximated using three periods.
2
u/ShadyG May 08 '12
I just realized how lazy I am. I write three periods (or two dashes for an em dash) and let the software create the appropriate glyph as needed.
233
u/ehsteve23 A Lion Still Has Claws May 08 '12
29
u/nakedladies May 08 '12
When this line was on, I chuckled to myself and said out loud "what a cunt".
My flatmate said "No, he's right, it's fewer, not less".
I said "It doesn't really matter though does it?" "It can matter..." "I don't think so" "Less is just wrong, fewer makes more sense".
We could get along better, I suppose.
33
u/ehsteve23 A Lion Still Has Claws May 08 '12
Fewer is correct. Basically if you're counting something, it's fewer (except for money or time), if it's an amount of something, it's less.
4 fewer fingernails
Less wine in the cup17
u/nakedladies May 08 '12
You're right! The rule of thumb I was always taught was "Less traffic, fewer cars".
My point is that grammar/syntax/semantics don't really mean anything to most people, and pointing out a mistake like that makes that person look like argumentative.
8
25
4
May 08 '12
"look like argumentative"
5
u/nakedladies May 08 '12
A syntactical error in a post defending people who make syntactical errors! I'll leave it in. If anyone asks, it was intentional.
→ More replies (1)11
u/bettse May 08 '12
Fewer is correct.
I submit to you http://www.cracked.com/blog/7-commonly-corrected-grammar-errors-that-arent-mistakes/ and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fewer_vs._less#Historical_usage
I contend that there is no 'correct' for this situation, there is only 'preference'
1
1
u/pezzaperry May 09 '12
pretty much the same as much and many, many is when you can count the object, much is like water or w,e.
1
u/InABritishAccent May 08 '12
I side with you. Whether it's right or not, you don't correct someone as they talk about the hand you lopped off.
3
2
0
May 08 '12
[deleted]
10
3
0
May 08 '12
[deleted]
25
6
2
13
May 08 '12
I think I'll keep this one around, useful in these parts.
28
u/fuckingobvious May 08 '12
You used a comma instead of a semi-colon as deliberate irony, right?
5
12
u/PraetorianXVIII House Dayne May 08 '12
"Useful in these parts" isn't an independent clause, so a semicolon would not be appropriate.
6
u/althius1 May 08 '12
I still refer to this all the time; it is the most useful thing I've ever read on the subject. http://theoatmeal.com/comics/semicolon
0
May 08 '12
[deleted]
2
u/PraetorianXVIII House Dayne May 08 '12
Well technically omitting "it's" is what makes it a dependent clause, right?
0
1
2
127
May 08 '12
I actually love how everyone in qarth has said at one point either dragons/tits or gtfo
51
u/thisismyivorytower Brotherhood Without Banners May 08 '12
So Qarth is the Internet of the GoT World?
29
u/Tommah666 Here We Stand May 08 '12
Qarth is the 4chan of Essos. Everyone is desperate to see new content, tits being exposed are common, racism and paedophilia are normal practice as well.
17
2
u/thisismyivorytower Brotherhood Without Banners May 08 '12
I was actually going to call it 4Chan but wasn't sure if there was more to it than what has been seen so far. But you have clarified my point, and I shall agree with you.
2
32
u/PragmaticNewYorker Here We Stand May 08 '12
I will edit what is wrong. Edit! With FIRE AND BLOOD!
8
29
8
5
May 08 '12
i can't stand the fat guy playing the spice king. way too much overacting and flamboyancy. it's ridiculous.
4
4
4
u/bfudge May 08 '12
I'm enjoying this grammar easter egg each week--Stannis on the usage of "less" vs. "fewer", Tyrion telling Cersei that "plots" and "schemes" are the same thing, now this.
3
3
8
May 08 '12
This is why I never liked those "Bush-isms" either. Politics aside, a mistake in grammar or a slip of the tongue doesn't make you an idiot. It happens to everyone.
8
u/geodebug House Manwoody May 08 '12
I agree, people misunderestimated him.
Small slips happen to everyone, but Bush was famous for some seriously funny mistakes (To be fair and balanced, so does our current VP, Biden).
It wasn't so much the small mistakes but the grander ones that made him seem to have a lack of focus on what was coming out of his mouth:
"Too many good docs are getting out of the business. Too many OB-GYNs aren't able to practice their love with women all across this country."
It's not really a lack of intelligence as it is a lack of skill in 'winging it'.
→ More replies (1)2
u/allocater May 08 '12
It happens to everyone
including idiots.
3
May 08 '12
But a slip of the tongue doesn't make someone an idiot. I make mistakes all the time and I'm a god damned genius.
3
u/TemporalSpleen House Baelish May 08 '12
Very true. However, if I made a mistake I would like someone to point it out. It can be done in a polite way, without being rude.
1
0
u/dbe May 08 '12
a slip of the tongue doesn't make you an idiot
Yeah but doing it every 5 minutes isn't helping.
2
2
u/ivebeenhereallsummer May 08 '12
There are several bots wandering Reddit correcting people's grammar. It's as if the d-bags that wrote the bot scripts were thinking, "You know, I LOOOOVE being a cunt but I just don't have enough time in the day to irritate all the people I want."
2
2
2
May 08 '12
EYEBROWS!! CAN'T UNSEE
1
u/gessyca House Targaryen May 08 '12
Natural platinum blonde with blonde eyebrows here. Those things have got to go.
2
u/twincam May 08 '12
Saw this scene/episode last night, and my first thought was reddit...
God I'm sad.
6
May 08 '12
They were arguing semantics, not grammar. Not sure if HBO writers are bad, or just trolling.
17
6
1
u/CowFu Braavosi Water Dancers May 08 '12
Grammar: The whole system and structure of a language or of languages in general, usually taken as consisting of syntax and morphology (including inflections) and sometimes also phonology and semantics
2
1
1
May 08 '12
"I didn't come here to argue what the correct use of grammar is."* You can't argue grammar; that's abominable sentence construction.
1
1
u/DaemonSaDiavlo May 08 '12
On the History Sub Reddits, I feel very much like this. Except, replace grammar with "Sources".
I don't keep a well stocked academic library at my beck and call, with easily reached bookmarks for every bit of knowledge I have accrued. I get it sometimes, the desire to filter the bullshit from the truth, but man, fuck people just replying to ask for a source, especially in a passive aggressive manner.
1
1
1
u/SweatpantsDV House Dayne May 08 '12
The post about not arguing grammar has nothing but grammar arguments in the comments section.
1
u/SayaV May 08 '12
Nope. Part of a successful argument includes less distractions, bad grammar being one of them. remember Nukular?
1
1
u/meorah May 08 '12
and probably for the same reasons: making stupid assumptions, asserting improbable scenarios, and showing only anecdotal credibility. Also whining about getting called out on it.
1
1
u/Monster7000 Hodor Hodor Hodor May 08 '12
Is it just me or is she seem a bit more crazy and unhinged this season? Is it purposeful that she's starting to remind me of Viserys?
1
u/Disposable_Corpus May 08 '12
sigh
No, they weren't discussing grammar, nor semantics. The word she sought to best convey her meaning would be 'word choice' or 'wording'.
1
1
1
u/wuzzup House Targaryen May 08 '12
Right, we did not come for the grammar, we came to beg for free shit from strangers.
1
u/Snargs May 08 '12
Hey man, if you have nothing to contribute to a conversation, might as well spell check.
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
May 08 '12
technically, I see more complaints about spelling and not grammar. being that grammar is not spelling, we might want to reexamine what we are talking about here.
4
0
343
u/SteampunkVillain House Reed May 08 '12
Yet what she meant to say was, "I didn't come here to argue about semantics."