32
u/Makes_It_Gay May 31 '12
Not the asshole I was hoping for.
8
u/jwitham2002 May 31 '12
you're welcome
11
6
1
-15
89
May 31 '12
Fat people can be assholes too.
59
0
129
u/string97bean May 31 '12
As soon as you talk about something nice that you did for someone, it is no longer a good deed.
112
May 31 '12
I don't think it is no longer a good deed, but I think it is trashy and tacky as hell.
21
u/jabacon May 31 '12
the deed is corrupted by the selfish intention thus revealed
19
May 31 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
3
u/Hounmlayn May 31 '12
I would think that if they seek recognition for every good deed, then it's not a good deed, it's attention seeking. But if you just tell people about a couple of good deeds you done, because they made you feel especially good, and you don't give a damn what the person you're telling it to thinks, then is it still a good deed if you just want to get the pent up thought out?
6
u/anachronic May 31 '12
I don't buy this "logic" at all.
If I pull someone out of a burning building, but then steal $20 from them, the life saving is somehow "invalid"?!? Would you rather I left them in the building to burn to death rather than save them?
→ More replies (1)2
May 31 '12
If someone buys me food I dont give a shit about his intentions, atleast I'm not going hungry, its a good deed from my perspective.
→ More replies (1)1
u/Deverone May 31 '12
All deeds have selfish intentions.
3
u/Velodra May 31 '12
That's not true unless you stretch the meaning of selfish far beyond the way it is normally used..
→ More replies (4)31
u/Buscat May 31 '12 edited Jun 03 '12
right, it's only good if you keep it to yourself to feel smugly superior about the good things you do and don't even talk about.
*edit: missed a word, oops.
1
10
May 31 '12
I don't know about that, but using a good deed as an excuse to talk trash about a co-worker is pretty scummy.
I don't see how people are missing the point. People say that woman is an asshole. She buys a guy lunch, nice thing to do, totally not an asshole but to be honestly not really a big freaking deal, not big enough to go tell everyone. Then goes onto facebook, posts about it and ontop of that uses it as an excuse to insult a co-worker.
Woman is the hole of an ass. I would know.
8
u/anachronic May 31 '12
It's still a good deed, but it's a tacky statement.
4
u/DoubleRaptor May 31 '12
Seriously. Buying the guy lunch is a good deed. Even if he then bitched about it for 2 weeks solid, it was still a good deed.
14
May 31 '12
What? That's ridiculous. You're saying that if I volunteer at a homeless shelter, and then it comes up in conversation later, all of a sudden it's worthless?
4
u/anachronic May 31 '12
When it comes up, it makes everyone else that doesn't volunteer feel like a selfish prick, so they have to somehow find a way to paint YOU as a selfish prick, too... so that they don't feel as bad.
It's childish and petty.
I don't think the homeless guy with a belly full of food gives 2 fucks who you tell about your day as long as you feed him.
8
u/noyurawk May 31 '12
There's a difference between "coming up in a conversation" and "telling others for recognition". If you do something for the recognition, it isn't selfless anymore.
6
u/trythemain May 31 '12
People volunteering at a homeless shelter almost certainly are getting self-satisfaction out of it, and so whether it is truly selfless or debatable. Doing a deed for own satisfaction or doing it for recognition is really the same in that you are gaining from it either way, and arbitrarily condemning one form of reward but not another is unnecessary.
4
u/Deverone May 31 '12
No one voluntarily does something unless they feel they are getting something out of it.
→ More replies (6)3
u/trythemain May 31 '12
Yeah, true altruism is incredibly uncommon and many psychologists aren't sold on the idea that it exists at all.
1
u/Fabbyfubz May 31 '12
Why does a good deed have to also be selfless to make it good? If a person donates, volunteers etc. and isn't very humble about it, it doesn't cancel out the good they did.
1
May 31 '12
Who says a good deed has to be selfless? I agree that it makes it a little less selfless, but I don't know how relevant that is.
1
u/noyurawk May 31 '12
It's still a good deed but if you try to pass as a compassionate person genuinely concerned with the well being of others (philanthropist, saint, guru, great guy with a big heart, etc), it just comes off as fake, much like companies doing it for the PR capital.
→ More replies (1)5
u/Trollfailbot May 31 '12
That's asinine.
It's called a 'good deed' because it's a deed that was good. I don't understand where talking about it comes into play.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Pravusmentis May 31 '12
That's not true, it's still a good deed, but if you never tell anyone then no one can claim you did it so you could tell people about it.
14
u/The_Limericist May 31 '12
When you give of yourself you're adored,
As long as it's of your accord.
Don't seek out some praise,
Or grumble for days.
A good deed is its own reward.
5
u/HasFuckedYourMom May 31 '12
Posting your good deeds on Facebook kind of negates the fact that you just did a good deed.
2
Jun 01 '12
Don't think she was looking for praise. Seemed to me she was more just venting. But the second person was more just judging.
8
3
8
u/brningpyre May 31 '12
I think people need to realize that doing a good deed doesn't make you not an douche bag. Not being an douche bag makes you not an douche bag.
2
May 31 '12
an douche bag?
3
u/brningpyre May 31 '12
Whoops. I had changed it from asshole, and forgot to take out the 'n'. Thanks for catching that, though.
2
2
4
u/hiitsdennis May 31 '12
So you're an asshole if you hate a fat person even if its not because they're fat??
14
u/DuchySleeps May 31 '12
You're an asshole when you do something seemingly altruistic, but later use your actions to try and garner attention while simultaneously criticizing the person you 'helped.'
→ More replies (1)-4
May 31 '12
You are not allowed to hate anyone who is a minority, overweight, stupid, female (attractive or unattractive), less successful than you, etc...
You can basically only hate upper-middle to upper class white males (especially if they are republicans)!
3
May 31 '12
Forget about the dislike part for a sec. So the guy could stand to lose some weight. OMG, you don't LOSE weight by skipping meals. The guy would just go home tonight STARVING and end up eating twice as much on a stomach that is geared up to make fat because it thinks he's going through some sort of trauma.
If this guy REALLY cared about the guy and wanted him to lose weight he should have brought him healthy snacks that he could nibble on all day. Tanking your blood sugar is like fixing a fever by sticking your head in the freezer.
→ More replies (12)
2
May 31 '12
It reminds me of how Christians (the religious that call their higher power "God" and celebrate Easter and Christmas) defend themselves when I ask "Why don't you donate to charities or volunteer at all?"
Ah, the good ole' mindset of the stupids. They don't have any sense of self awareness.
1
1
u/Pravusmentis May 31 '12
See guys, that's why OP'sOP failed this weeks challenge of doing something nice for someone and not telling anyone. He should try harder next time.
1
u/Arknell May 31 '12
You can't be unselfish and then tell someone about it for vanity's sake, that's the law of the universe. It's enough that you and the other person knows. Or if it's not a person but an animal or you did something without witnesses (even better), then it's enough that you and the Horsehead Nebula knows. Discipline!
1
u/Foogey May 31 '12
...And then posts it on facebook to receive praise.
Do people even do nice gestures anymore without feeling like they have to announce it to anyone/everyone?
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
May 31 '12
I'm an overweight guy and this Facebook post doesn't bother me.. I didn't take it as an insult, really.
1
Jun 01 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
I just called somebody an asshole on facebook because they were venting about doing something they had to do but didn't want to. Why doesn't anyone like to hang out with me?!
Also: Nobody in this thread seems to understand what venting is. You guys need to get out more, and that's bad coming from me...
1
u/chicagogam Jun 01 '12
oh i thought there as going to be something about the recipient doing something terribly ungrateful, but i guess not... yah the good deed doer doesn't seem terribly nice. i wonder why he offered lunch..people are complex..
1
1
1
u/Dwnvtngthdmms Jun 01 '12
13 minutes eh? Do us all a favor and wait until you have more to post next time.
1
1
u/c3wifjah Jun 01 '12
It's posts like this that make me wonder why I subscribe to /r/funny. What is funny about this?
1
-4
May 31 '12
It should be socially acceptable to hate fat people.
I'm not even kidding. Seriously. If you're fat, go fuck yourself.
4
u/anachronic May 31 '12
Why do you even care if someone else is fat?
Grow up.
Focus on addressing your own flaws (like your superficial personality) rather than obsessing about some stranger's weight.
→ More replies (7)
1
May 31 '12
I know that shew wasn't being an asshole because of weight but if she wanted to be called a nice person she shouldn't say "oh I just bought a lunch for someone I don't care for.." because saying that after buying someone lunch must make the person receiving said lunch feel like shit.
-1
0
-2
0
0
May 31 '12
She said she disliked the guy, but didn't give the reason why she disliked him. She also mentioned in kind of a backdoor way that he's fat. That's a big difference between "disliked someone BECAUSE they're fat". Asshole.
0
u/bstone99 May 31 '12
I don't have a problem with this. Your thoughts don't make you an asshole. Your actions do. She did something nice, just cuz she doesn't care for him or she thinks she's fat, doesn't make her an asshole
-14
u/twoclose May 31 '12
i don't like fat people either. why am i supposed to feel bad for something 100% preventable?
6
May 31 '12
What do you care if someone is fat? Besides the fact that being fat is not always 100% preventable (for a variety of reasons, including people who are injured and no longer have the ability to fully exercise), in the end, why do you really care? Do you hate someone with crooked teeth? Bad hair? What reason do you have for just not liking fat people?
→ More replies (3)3
May 31 '12
I personally know several people who have lost vast amounts of weight by simply changing their diet. No changes in exercise, no additional exercise, maybe no exercise at all.
2
u/lurrker Jun 01 '12
I was overweight. The only thing I had to lose was excuses, and got to my target weight in 3 months. No workouts, just paleo/keto diet. Found a food allergy in the process (wheat). Have stayed 80% paleo, and right at my target weight. Never hungry, and dont even crave the stuff I used to. It's awesome, except I needed all new clothes.
People at work have noticed the change, and 5 have actually attempted the same. 3 with good results, one far beyond (marathons and crossfit), and one gave up (the only male). One was diabetic, and had to make sure it was ok with the doctor. Doctor said it's probably the best thing they could do at this point.
→ More replies (1)9
May 31 '12
You can not like them all you want, but being vocal about your hatred of a person on their physical appearance alone is a dickish act.
→ More replies (9)0
May 31 '12 edited Jun 01 '12
Actually, if nobody talks about problems then it takes a lot longer for the problem to get resolved. In this instance, twoclose is I am sure mentioning that it is important to have open discussion about the health of people who might be obese when such a condition is indeed very preventable.
IMHO, I equate fatness with laziness. Every single time. I don't go out of my way to hate on them or anything, but I have trouble relating to people who don't consider their health as important as I consider mine.
EDIT: Am I getting downvoted for my stance on open discussion, or for my opinion?
4
May 31 '12
But there's talking about it and there's being an asshole about it. The years of relentless bullying I got didn't make me lose weight, it just made me sad and I got comfort from food like I always had. Then when I said "enough is enough" and lost weight because I wanted to, I had a lot of success.
→ More replies (1)5
May 31 '12
This is usually what smug people say to justify their pretentious behavior.
It's not your job or responsibility to "resolve" anything, and ultimately, you just like the feeling of superiority.
→ More replies (3)
-3
0
-1
-1
May 31 '12
He's an asshole for buying someone a meal? Sure he didn't want to do it but he still did. It's not like he did anything wrong.
Fucking eejits.
-3
u/CaptainAmerican May 31 '12
I don't ever feel bad for fat people. I work really hard to avoid terrible foods and a sedentary lifestyle. They take up too much space and stink. Hahah. That's an asshole thing to say. But, don't act like you thin people aren't on the same page.
-2
-2
-2
-2
u/jerusalemcampground May 31 '12
Not liking someone because they're fat is a perfectly legitimate reason for not liking someone.
0
0
u/2_eyed_cyclops May 31 '12
And you also felt a need to display to everyone that you did something that would not classify you as an asshole
0
u/studsterkel May 31 '12
Sorry assholes, you cannot go back in time and undo something nice someone did and pretend it was mean, because you changed your mind.
It was a nice thing to do then, and it was a nice thing to do now.
-4
u/UseThe4s May 31 '12
That guy sounds like a prick. But then again, I don't like fat people either. Guess I'm an asshole.
2
u/Beetlebum95 May 31 '12
Judging peoples worth on their physical appearance, why would that make you an asshole?
→ More replies (2)
352
u/Drunken_Economist May 31 '12
So it's okay to dislike people, but not okay to dislike fat people?