r/funny • u/[deleted] • May 19 '12
I don't think I'm qualified to have an opinion on this.
166
u/metarugia May 19 '12
I read that as "2nd Grader gets in trouble for MILK Tribute" ...
13
May 20 '12
I thought it was a Harvey Milk tribute, and that maybe he was trying to suggest being gay is like being black or something like that. Yeah IDK..
17
7
4
u/TheCake_IsA_Lie May 19 '12
As did I. I then noticed his hands were white, yet I could not see his face O_o
2
2
u/w3sticles May 19 '12
That is exactly what I read. I came to the comments to see if American Milk has a black guy on the label or something.
Now I just feel silly.
2
→ More replies (1)2
1.0k
u/awesimo May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12
That's some pretty intense irony right there.
EDIT: It's ironic because the boy did this as a tribute to a man who fought for equal rights, but got in trouble because white people aren't allowed to dress up as black people.
48
u/mayonnnnaise May 19 '12
Too bad they didn't allow the kid to give his report on the news. I'm pretty sure what he had to say was more important than anything I just heard in that video.
37
u/gigashadowwolf May 19 '12
I found out about this by almost getting suspended from school for trying something similar. We only had three black kids in theater and we were doing a play with 5 black characters. None of the black kids even knew why me and the girl in dark make up got in trouble.
→ More replies (1)222
u/Shumuu May 19 '12
Is this true ? You can't dress up/ paint your face black ?
Not from America myself :p
289
u/Deepmist May 19 '12
You can legally, as far as I know. It's just socially unacceptable for some reason.
Edit: Here's the history that makes it taboo: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackface
216
May 19 '12
It's just socially unacceptable for some reason.
It's because people have used it in an offensive/disrespectful way. It didn't seem like that was the kid's intention though.
→ More replies (18)241
May 19 '12
He's in second grade. I REALLY doubt he knew about something that was at its highest popularity during the 1920's.
→ More replies (83)→ More replies (30)35
u/Shumuu May 19 '12
Interesting! Thanks
But I still cant the reasoning behind it , to put a little Kid on TV because of this ...
→ More replies (11)17
17
u/Thatquietchick May 20 '12
As long as you're not being offensive, I'm cool with it.
-Official Black Person-
→ More replies (1)40
u/duckinferno May 19 '12
Yeah this is all sorts of wtf. How racism has survived for so long into the second millenia in that country is beyond me. The kid coloured his skin in tribute of a guy who preached that one shouldn't judge someone on the colour of their skin... seems like a reverant act to me, but then, I'm not a racist.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (26)18
u/Chilapox May 19 '12
Because people did it in a racist and oppressive way in the past so now if anyone does it, it must be because they are racist.
→ More replies (6)86
u/Diffusion9 May 19 '12
The worst is that everybody keep saying Blackface. It's not fucking Blackface. It does not mean "this kid painted his face black" it means "My face is painted black. my lips are comically red. I AM MAKING FUN OF BLACK PEOPLE."
→ More replies (23)18
5
May 20 '12
A not-friend of mine insisted that my friend was racist for dressing up as her favorite rapper, Lil Wayne, because she was white. Yes, please stop paying tribute to your heroes of other races.
→ More replies (2)3
May 20 '12
"I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: 'We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal.' I have a dream that one day on the red hills of Georgia the sons of former slaves and the sons of former slaveowners will be able to sit down together at a table of brotherhood. I have a dream that one day even the state of Mississippi, a desert state, sweltering with the heat of injustice and oppression, will be transformed into an oasis of freedom and justice. I have a dream that my four children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character. I have a dream today".
5
→ More replies (46)4
u/flanders4ever May 19 '12
Also, that he focused on the equality of all races. A white boy dressing up as a black boy should be a-okay since they're both equal. But, they are two separate races, so the whole 'separate but equal' thing that this forces us to confront is, well, just weird.
Also, you don't have to be black to rep Dr. King.
On the other hand, the kid could just be a douchebag. Little kids are either amoral monsters or little saints. Its about the content of character.
→ More replies (2)
30
May 19 '12
i knew a guy that did this every year for halloween so he could be jimi hendrix. it wasnt even black paint he looked like an indian with a fro. he never got in trouble at school.
→ More replies (1)8
u/Nomagon May 19 '12
Did he show up at school like that or was it afterschool when he did it? I got in trouble for dressing up as Waldo at school during halloween/dress up week because hats are distracting.
16
u/Thundershrimp May 19 '12
"Waldo should be difficult to find. You and your hat must depart in shame."- Nomagon's school
→ More replies (4)3
51
May 19 '12
"2nd grader gets pigmentation alteration to play MLK for school project." Tropic Thunder anyone?
72
u/th1nker May 19 '12
Call me a sceptic, but how do we know he isn't black and painted his hands white?
→ More replies (4)
89
May 19 '12
Why do stupid white people get mad at other white people, because they don't actually know what racism is
→ More replies (11)61
May 19 '12
Ask /r/politics that.
99% of Reddit doesn't know what racism is and freely labels anything potentially offensive as racism.
→ More replies (11)43
17
May 19 '12
Ok, this is just dumb. The kid dressed as his hero who fought for equal rights for both races. Just because he had to put on some body paint to give a realistic tone to it makes it racist or something? Just what the hell?
→ More replies (1)
5
May 19 '12
That was the funniest interview I have ever seen.
17
u/CoffinRehersal May 19 '12
I wouldn't know. The OP just posted a shitty screencap and didn't link the video at all.
47
7
79
May 19 '12
Kids don't see color unless their parents point it out to them.
27
u/lolblumpkin May 20 '12
Exactly, and the lady who was saying that "other students were offended" I can 100% guarantee that is complete bullshit. As a teacher at an elementary school, I can say that something like this would be the furthest thing from students' minds. They would most likely just be laughing because that kid looked so differently. She is obviously just saying that other students were offended to cover up for the uneasiness that the faculty/staff felt.
7
→ More replies (8)2
u/mimus May 20 '12
I once had the awkward task of explaining to a kid I was babysitting what "black people" means.
58
u/BlueLinchpin May 19 '12
Painting your face black =/= blackface. Why don't people get this?
20
May 19 '12
Because if they got it, they couldn't feast on the delicious outrage produced by not getting it.
2
→ More replies (1)5
12
12
May 20 '12
Haha one of the runningbacks I blocked for back in high school was a "White guy" for halloween. it was pretty funny. He had a light blue polo with a yellow stripe outlined by two smaller red stripes, pleated khaki pants, and he straightened his hair and dyed it blond, then put on peach colored skin paint. The school was afraid to confront him about it. I thought it was funny. "Hello everybody, I would like to use my credit card within my means, I'm buying a big TV on impulse. McDonalds is bad for me, I only eat it once a day."
12
u/piranhadawn May 20 '12
That's ironic. Kids dress up as Native Americans every Thanksgiving. They don't make the news.
→ More replies (1)2
10
May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
I had a black room mate that painted his face white for Halloween. He was Sweeney Todd. Nobody really cared. The white paint didn't quite work with his skin color though. We just kinda laughed at the hilarity that that caused and everyone enjoyed their Halloween. I don't think any one should really care if someone paints their face. This is sadly tragic though because this kid was actually honoring MLK and these sensitive crusaders tainted his actions with allegations of racism and offensiveness.
I don't understand why people blow trivial stories up like this. Even if that child's actions were meant to be racist, why does it get TV news coverage? "Racist 2nd grader dresses up as MLK". Soon we'll be getting stories like: "Tommy called Susie a big fat meanie-head." "3rd grader pukes up chocolate milk through his nose".
→ More replies (3)
584
u/Drunken_Economist May 19 '12
Anyone else not get it? All I see is the content of his character.
→ More replies (17)208
u/jettrscga May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12
→ More replies (10)13
17
u/Therealsebastiandior May 20 '12
I'm black and this is completely ridiculous, things like this could actually reduce racial sensitivity. Who ever reported this or took offense is an idiot.
→ More replies (1)7
u/masuabie May 20 '12
They are just making sure they kid knows what racism is so it's legacy can live on.
8
u/Uploaded_by_iLurk May 20 '12
You have to love the innocence of youth. This kid and all others have the potential to grow up never knowing what racism is until some dumbass adults overreact to something and slaps a racist label on it.
8
u/GrayStudios May 20 '12
I've said it before and I'll say it again. "Black face" should not, unless done in an intentionally offensive context, be taboo in American society any longer. It shows a clear inequality of race, and only serves to further separate us. This is a very good example of what I think should be completely okay to do. He wanted to portray Dr. King, so he painted his face. It's not like he left a big white circle around his lips like a minstrel show.
2
May 20 '12
This, and the fact the kid is like eight or nine years old and it would be unacceptable to peg him or his parents as being racist for this clearly innocent paint job.
105
u/Senor_Wilson May 19 '12
DOUBLE STANDARDS EVERYWHERE! I'm pretty sure there was a whole movie dedicated to black dudes dressing up as white chicks... Hmm what was it called? WHITE CHICKS.
58
u/ShadowStalker22 May 19 '12
You forget this
46
u/patesta May 19 '12
This was only acceptable since it was meta. Robert Downey Jr.'s role as an actor dressing up as a black guy created controversy within the film! The film called itself out on its own political incorrectness.
10
u/nixonrichard May 20 '12
And even then it wasn't acceptable. I seem to recall black organizations being pissed off for some silly contrived reason. I think the reason was that they didn't hire a black actor to play the white guy playing the white guy disguised as a black guy.
→ More replies (2)12
25
u/RikF May 19 '12
Not really a double standard (though, in this case I feel that there was much more value, as others have pointed out, in making this a good teachable moment for the students) when there is a historical precedent for dressing white actors in blackface to mock and/or replace black actors (also yellowface as recently as the appalling I Now Pronounce You Chuck and Larry), with no history in this country of the reverse happening. So you're putting 'a whole movie' up against decades of socially acceptable racism.
15
20
u/bigdanrog May 19 '12
And on what planet was "White Chicks" not racist? At what point in the movie did they stop implying that white women are idiots?
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (22)8
u/Maxfunky May 19 '12
Of course this is a double standard--because we all remember the oppressive history behind the practice of having black people paint their faces and pretend to be white. It seems like only yesterday the minstrel shows were full of people capering about in whiteface--feigning the mental retardation associated with white people in the era. Those were ugly times. Lest we never forget them, as the Wayans brothers clearly did.
7
u/imbored53 May 19 '12
It just occurred to me how much MLK looks like the word Milk.
→ More replies (1)
7
7
u/willscy May 20 '12
The fact that this kid had to go through this whole ordeal is BS. I think it's time for people to grow up a little here.
54
u/I_TYPE_IN_ALL_CAPS May 19 '12
I WILL NEVER BE ABLE TO DRESS UP AS MY HERO, MR. T, BECAUSE PEOPLE DON'T UNDERSTAND THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN MINSTREL SHOWS AND COSTUMES.
→ More replies (2)4
12
6
u/SilentAffairs93 May 20 '12
The school knew it was MLK Day, and he was doing it for a project (which isn't racist). Everyone knew the reason for it. It's not a big deal. But of course, like ignorant people always do, they blow it out of proportion. End of Story.
11
u/aksolut May 19 '12
I don't live in the USA (I'm in Argentina) and I don't understand why this is wrong. Can you guys explain it to me? We are actually encouraged to paint ourselves with cork for the school plays in which we represent the slaves that used to live here in the time of our independence revolution! I understand that racism is an actual issue, but I don't think this this can be interpeted as done with a bad intention...
14
u/cookprov May 19 '12
In the USA, "black face" or painting with cork is a symbol of racism that occurred in minstrel shows.
Here is a link explaining the history
→ More replies (1)2
u/Jrex13 May 20 '12
I don't think this this can be interpeted as done with a bad intention
The intention doesn't matter. If someone can interpret your act as racist, then you're a racist. 'MERICA!!!
→ More replies (1)2
u/CyberToyger May 20 '12
Because here in America, we've been taught to toss out our backbones and wear our emotions on our sleeves. As a result, an ungodly large amount of the populous is either Liberal as fuck or Statist/Neoconservative as fuck. You wind up with asshurt politically correct people throwing down the racist card every time a white person does ANYTHING outside of their 'normal behavior or appearance', and on the other side, white people who really ARE racist largely because of the way non-whites act and treat them. Then you have whites and non-whites in the middle of the spectrum who just want to get along and not be a part of all this bullshit.
5
9
u/usernamerayn May 19 '12
does being black qualify me to have an opinion on this?
5
May 19 '12
Yes but being non-black qualifies everyone else as having no opinion that is justifiable.
23
u/KurayamiShikaku May 19 '12
I wonder how many people realize that the reactions of those who were "offended" is one of the major reasons behind why racism still continues to exist.
I'm pretty much in the Morgan Freeman camp on this one - "stop talking about it." I don't mean to look the other way when blatant racism is actually present, but let's be real here - there was nothing racist about this at all.
There may have been similarities between what this child did and racially-charged happenings in the past, but this kid wasn't proclaiming or representing any race as inferior to any other race.
→ More replies (1)5
u/angrywhitedude May 20 '12
I'm pretty much in the Morgan Freeman camp on this one - "stop talking about it."
I'm not sure he meant that to be taken literally. I got the vibe that he was more saying that drawing attention to race all the time was counterproductive. It seemed like that particular statement was more of a frustrated exaggeration than a well-thought out solution to racism.
→ More replies (4)
4
u/BigAndDelicious May 20 '12
The only thing that's racist is the thought that this is racist. People are different shades and colours and that's life. If you have a problem with what this boy did, you're seeing more differences than just the colour of skin... which is so wrong.
7
7
May 19 '12
I think it adds to the historical accuracy. You wouldn't wear sweat pants and a t-shirt to be George Washington. And plus it wasn't mockery.
10
10
u/apullin May 19 '12
Why? Because being black is so horrible that it's ghastly for someone to pretend to be black? That's fucked up.
3
5
5
May 20 '12
The kid is in 2nd grade for gods sake. What a wonderful way to introduce him to the world of racism, by making him feel bad for dressing up as a person of another race.
4
May 19 '12
Why would you get in trouble for that..? He got into character... Where was the uproar when Robert Downey Junior played a white man painted black in Tropic Thunder?
4
2
2
2
u/lowdownlowry May 19 '12
that's ridiculous that the kid got into trouble for that. people making a big deal about race in situations like that just perpetuates and encourages racially-divisive thinking... if the kid had dressed up as the buddha instead, no one would have complained if he was adorned in eastern garb, they would've just figured he was trying to accurately depict the subject of his class project for educational effect. what this kid was doing is no different, and it's absolutely unacceptable that he was punished or "got into trouble" for it.
2
u/LordEnigma May 19 '12
When I was younger, I dressed up as Urkel for Halloween, painting my face and skin black. Everyone thought it was hilarious.
2
2
2
2
u/relevantusername- May 20 '12
That's fucking retarded. It's a kid dressing up for a school project; what kind of idiot puts this nonentity on the news?
2
2
u/smokingnoir May 20 '12
Plus, he wants to remember a person who envisioned a world where we look at character and not race. If I was the kids parents, I would just say to him, no, you did nothing wrong, people just have a big stick up their ass now.
2
u/reedrothchiId May 20 '12
This reminds me of when I wore blackface for my 5th grade halloween costume
2
u/cingalls May 20 '12
Poor kid. No one should have made a big deal. Someone should have just discreetly explained it to the child.
Shame on the news outlet for exploiting this.
2
2
2
2
2
4
u/ReharshedAgain May 20 '12
I am going to go on a limb here and post this. About ten years ago, my best friend told me something I would have never expected out of his lips. He is a successfully 3rd gen African American with family still in Africa. What he said still resounds in my mind today. It isn't that I truly believe it, it is more that my friend believes it and feels this way. He explained that one of the best things to ever happen to this group was slavery. Before you start with the down votes, please read the rest. Yes, slavery in itself is a horrible thing, don't get me wrong. But what Americans did at this time is actually crafted an elite population of hand picked Africans. Look at it this way; slavers would only pick the strongest, cleanest, healthiest, and tallest men. This handpicked created a super-breed of men in the US. Now I personally find this hard to swallow given the atrocities that occurred during the slave trade years, but it was interesting hearing this from a friend who almost made it sound like he was jealous of not coming from the Americas. Food for thought.
→ More replies (1)2
4
u/AdonisChrist May 20 '12
Are we still pretending that blackface is racist?
Sure, if you put on some blackface and act like a stereotypical nigger, yeah. But if you're dressing up as MLK? That's pretty respectful to the black community, no?
Or are we just not allowed to impersonate black people? Because somehow impersonation is racist.
3
May 20 '12
I think its horribly demeaning and prejudice of this kid to dress up in this fashion. For Gods sake, what gives him the right to wear a moustache? Someone should explain to this kid that you can't go around doing that or else you run the risk of offending myself and my fellow moustache wearing men (and old french women)
3
u/SteveDave123 May 20 '12
Ahh, the American system of Political Correctedness strikes again!
To quote the boy "they said it was mean, but i like black people."
This is what happens when you have insane people running the country.
*edit: Although slightly humorous, its more sad than funny. We have devolved SO MUCH in the last decade, that the state we find ourselves in at this point is critical.
4
2
2
2
u/Maxfunky May 19 '12
More media nonsense. The kid didn't "get into trouble", he was just asked to remove the paint--and though it doesn't say so, no doubt the reasons why were explained to him. Seems like a very sensible way to handle the situation. They didn't punish him, because obviously his intentions weren't bad.
The parents, however, who should have had enough sense not to let their kid go to school in blackface in the first place, took the principal's very reasonable and measured actions as a referendum on their parenting skills and decided to act like babies in protest. The press was all too happy to oblige their desire to make a flaming fuckaree out of nothing.
→ More replies (2)
2
1
1
1
May 19 '12
After watching the interview: http://dontwannahearit.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/funny-celebrity-pictures-my-care-cup-is-empty-300x226.jpg
1
u/cynikalAhole99 May 19 '12
I think C Thomas Howell ruined this type of thing..and I guess Robert Downy Jr made it alright again..?
1
1
May 19 '12
I cant read MLK without thinking "Milk", first.
Also, it looks like they figured out how to get Mac into a shrink ray. Silly blackface.
1
1
1
1
u/deadfield918 May 20 '12
I think that it is hilarious that this kid did this. Especially how over the top he did the black face make up and then forgot to do his hands lol
1
u/bgrugby60 May 20 '12
I remember back in the late 90s when the WWF/WWE did this skit where the members of DX parodied The Nation (a predominately black group). I don't remember any backlash from it, in fact it is still considered one of the funniest moments ever.
1
1
May 20 '12
My black friend in school did a report on some white guy so he put a bunch of flour on his face for the presentation, was pretty hilarious. No one complained.
1
1
u/StinkySteve123 May 20 '12
It's all about intention. If you dress in blackface in a disrespectful way, then you're an asshole. If you dress in blackface for a dramatic purpose, like film or television or advertising, then you're toeing the line, but nothing's wrong with that. If you dress in blackface to honor someone, then it's acceptable.
1
u/cl0s33n0ugh May 20 '12
Relevant anecdote from when I was in high school:
During Black History Month my freshman year, there happened to be an African dress-up day. As a skinny white kid, I thought it'd make for a good time to participate. So, I turned a zebra-print drape set of mother's into a dashiki, and fashioned a spear out of tin foil. I won first prize, a $25 dollar gift certificate to The Black-Eyed Pea, and only one person - an assistant principal I more than occasionally crossed paths with - took issue with it. The sooner American society can laugh about these kind of stories, the better off humanity will be.
1
1
u/zerohourrct May 20 '12
I dressed up as hitler. Almost got in big trouble for accidentally leaving coat with swastica armband in the hallway. He's got a pretty interesting life history, up until he starts to go crazy with his racism in the nazi party.
1
u/The_mrs May 20 '12
It's such crap. In 4th grade I dressed in blackface as Langston Hughes to read one of his poems for a project. This was in the late 70's. No one blinked an eye, including the black lady who helped raise us while our mom worked or the reading class teacher who was also a nice black lady!! The assignment was to dress up as the author, how can you dress up as Langston Hughes and leave out such a huge part of his identity? Ugh.
1
1
u/galaxy5000 May 20 '12
How does a white guy go to a Halloween party as OJ Simpson without blackface?
→ More replies (1)2
u/DeepRoot May 20 '12
With a knife driving a Brono? Or how 'bout, maybe, wearing his football jerser? Black face is never acceptable.
1
1
1
1
u/nicholaaaas May 20 '12
he really does look like a young al sharpton. you know back when he was calling NYC "Himyetown"
1
1
May 20 '12
I saw this on TV yesterday while waiting to get my tires changed. I thought he was acting like a hispanic until they said MLK.
1
u/nissanator May 20 '12
Like a little kid knows what black face really means. Give him a break for actually putting a little thought into his project. I had to give a report on salvador dali in high school and I dressed like him and painted on a moustache. I am a female. Got an A+ and extra credit.
1
1
u/Gladestalker May 20 '12
My parents dressed me up as a Blackface Shawn Kemp when I was 7 years old for Halloween and nobody in the neighborhood gave a shit.
1
1
1
May 20 '12
He's a little kid! He doesn't mean it to mock or degrade anyone! We all take ourselves way too seriously. Geez!
1
1
1
u/schlitzkreig May 20 '12
Everyone is qualified to have an opinion on this, myself included.
And I'll just be keeping it to myself. Not because if fear anyone else's reaction, but I don't have the energy to argue with anyone about it, and I think anyone with any opinion about this will wind up in an argument.
1
1
u/Surferdude1212 May 20 '12
All I can think about is it always sunny in philidelphia and Mac's black face
1
May 20 '12
I wonder who actually got offended over this. Black people who felt it was an attack on them, or nosy, media clones with nothing to do but act all superior and righteous and pick on a kid cause its an easy way to make themselves feel good.
1
1
1
u/DarthNihilus1 May 20 '12
MLK Jr. was black. The kid went in got a black face to pay tribute. Fucking prudes.
1
May 20 '12
Official Black Man Here: If Dave Chappelle can powder his face to be a white guy, a white kid can dress up as a proud black man. Its really only when they put on black face, reenact stereotypes, and do their own little minstrel show is when i get pissed off.
1
1
u/I_Am_Always_Correct May 20 '12
If there was no derogatory or caricature like features, and it was a meaningful tribute... nothing he's doing should be considered offensive to the public.
180
u/[deleted] May 19 '12
The interview with the kid is hilarious.