r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/[deleted] • Jun 07 '12
President Of Estonia Slams Paul Krugman: 'Smug, Overbearing & Patronizing'
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/[deleted] • Jun 07 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/Aneirin • Jun 28 '12
A frequent talking point used by Krugman's supporters is that he predicted that the stimulus was "too small" and would have only a weak positive effect on unemployment. However, as Bob Murphy points out here, they often selectively quote him to distort the appearance of what he actually predicted.
Murphy quotes him on arithmetic:
Let’s be generous and assume that the overall multiplier on tax cuts is 1. Then the per-year effect of the plan on GDP is 150 x 1 + 240 x 1.5 = $510 billion. Since it takes $300 billion to reduce the unemployment rate by 1 percentage point, this is shaving 1.7 points off what unemployment would otherwise have been. Finally, compare this with the economic outlook. “Full employment” clearly means an unemployment rate near 5 — the CBO says 5.2 for the NAIRU, which seems high to me. Unemployment is currently about 7 percent, and heading much higher; Obama himself says that absent stimulus it could go into double digits. Suppose that we’re looking at an economy that, absent stimulus, would have an average unemployment rate of 9 percent over the next two years; this plan would cut that to 7.3 percent, which would be a help but could easily be spun by critics as a failure. And that gets us to politics. This really does look like a plan that falls well short of what advocates of strong stimulus were hoping for — and it seems as if that was done in order to win Republican votes. Yet even if the plan gets the hoped-for 80 votes in the Senate, which seems doubtful, responsibility for the plan’s perceived failure, if it’s spun that way, will be placed on Democrats. I see the following scenario: a weak stimulus plan, perhaps even weaker than what we’re talking about now, is crafted to win those extra GOP votes. The plan limits the rise in unemployment, but things are still pretty bad, with the rate peaking at something like 9 percent and coming down only slowly. And then Mitch McConnell says “See, government spending doesn’t work.”
Note the part about how "this plan would cut that to 7.3 percent". This is the actual stimulus plan which was passed, and he said that unemployment would fall to 7.3 percent. This did not happen. But when people quote him, they tend to only quote the part about the "weak stimulus plan" (no doubt, the fault of those damn Republicans!) and his statement that unemployment will barely be limited by the plan. They don't tend to quote him on the part where he was off by a substantial amount (saying that unemployment would be 7.3%). Murphy notes that this is not very different from what other Obama administration economists claimed:
It’s true, Krugman didn’t say, “I bet my life that unemployment won’t break 9.2% with stimulus spending,” but the point is that he has done the same category of error as the official Obama Administration economists. What’s really funny is that I am pretty sure Krugman has quoted from this very blog post before, to show his readers, “Hey, I told you guys this would happen.” But I’m also pretty sure he just quoted the Mitch McConnell stuff, and not the part where Krugman talks (conditionally) of a 7.3% average unemployment rate in 2009-2010, or of an unemployment rate that peaks at 9%.
So, in short, the argument that "Krugman predicted that the stimulus wouldn't be enough" is incredibly disingenuous. He predicted a drop in unemployment which was substantially off, and then claimed credit for his vague hedging on a "weak stimulus plan".
From now on, whenever someone in /r/Keynesian /r/Economics brings up the issue of Paul Krugman saying that "the stimulus wasn't enough" and being "right", bring this up. The numbers are damning; he overestimated the stimulus, and that's that. We need to get rid of this tired narrative which has no basis in reality.
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/OhioHoneyBadger • Oct 20 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/vityok • Jul 20 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/OhioHoneyBadger • Sep 15 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/[deleted] • Feb 14 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/[deleted] • Feb 08 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/phenry08 • Sep 30 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/vityok • Jul 11 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/vityok • Jun 25 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/vityok • Apr 02 '13
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/OhioHoneyBadger • Nov 21 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/Aneirin • Jun 27 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/Aneirin • Jun 19 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/freshbrewedcoffee • May 02 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/[deleted] • Feb 06 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/vityok • Nov 22 '13
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/vityok • Mar 07 '13
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/Aneirin • Feb 03 '13
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/coal600 • Dec 29 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/vityok • Sep 07 '12
r/EnoughKrugmanSpam • u/freshbrewedcoffee • Jun 07 '12