I finished my first ever session of Dungeon World a few days ago, and as I reflected on how the session went, I realized one of the most genius aspects of Dungeon World's design when compared to other games like Pathfinder and D&D (which I have ran for years).
First I'll say that I wasn't terribly happy with how the session went as a whole. It wasn't bad or anything, it just wasn't as amazing as I expected (which, as we shall see, is 100% on me). The reason for this was that I felt like the players "got out" of dangerous encounters too easily, and when the dangerous encounters did actually happen, they weren't as "meaningful" as they were in D&D.
For example. The party started their session in a prison, and had to escape down a mountain to nearby village. The first real encounter came when the party was surrounded by a group of guards (what I thought was going to be my first combat!). The party thief, however, was more interested in escaping quickly, so he said "I want to just kick the guard in the groin and run past him". Sure enough, he succeeded, and I let the party escape in that direction.
The party then ran down the hill, but there was a rockslide on the mountain, which all but one of the party avoided. The fighter was plowed over by some rocks, which did 2 damage, but then the party removed him from the rubble and continued on.
The session ended there (there was quite a bit of roleplaying/rules explaining at the start), and I couldn't help but feel underwhelmed by how everything had gone.
As I spent some time reflecting on the session and what went wrong, I realized where I had gone astray. What I realized was that the reason things didn't work out was because I wasn't really GMing Dungeon World, I was DMing Dungeons and Dragons with some Dungeon World elements thrown it. What I mean was that I had basically segmented my session into a bunch of planned, discrete "encounters" like you do in D&D: first the party will have a fight with some guards, then we will have downtime for a bit, then there will be a rock slide that might damage them, etc, etc. . It wasn't even so much that I had things planned out in advance and had expectations going in, but rather that I didn't run those situations as dynamic action sequences like Dungeon World demands. Instead, I played them out like "encounters" in the Dungeons and Dragons sense: there is a danger, and once that danger is resolved, the party moves onto the next dnger.
On reflection, I realized that I missed so many "golden opportunities" to make moves because in my mind, the "encounter" was over. For the rock slide for instance, I treated it as a skill check or a trap in D&D: okay, roll to see if you take damage from the rock slide? Succeed? You are good. Fail? Take 4 damage. Well, that's that, onto the next thing!
As I reflected though I realized, why the hell did I just settle for "roll damage" as the end of that potentially amazing encounter? The fighter literally got pinned under a pile of massive rocks, why didn't I take this golden opportunity (as dungeon world expressly states to do) to reveal the unwelcome truth that their fighter is trapped, and that a group of guards now surround them, and they have to either dig out their friend or fight off the guards? Why didn't I take that golden opportunity to put the fighter in a spot: you can free yourself and continue onwards, but your equipment is trapped somewhere under the rocks and you'll need to spend some time and risk your discovery fishing it out if you want it back.
My problem was that I was treating the session as a series of discrete encounters rather than as a series of chained moves designed to heighten the tension and excitement of the situation. I didn't make moves, I made a series of planned encounters with the punishment for each failure being "take some damage", which is exactly what D&D has trained me to do over 15 years. I understood Dungeon World in an abstract sense, but I completely failed to take advantage of what makes it so great: making moves. I realize now that moves are the essential structure of the game and the story telling. They aren't just something you use in combat or in the middle of an encounter: MOVES ARE THE ENCOUNTERS. They are the entire session.
Hopefully my next session goes a little better.