r/DebateAnAtheist • • Sep 24 '19

META We lost someone.

1.5k Upvotes

Last year a number of users were invited to become moderators and one of them was u/DoctorMoonSmash. He was an active and thoughtful member of our community and I personally counted him as a friend. Six months ago he went silent around the time he was planning to move and we haven’t heard from him since. It was recently confirmed that he died. Out of respect for his family we’re not releasing any details of who he really was or how he died, we just wanted to pass along that a respected member of our community is no longer with us.

Doc was a funny man who had a lot of wisdom to share. He was compassionate, always looking for ways to help people and was pursuing a career as a medical technician, serving as a paramedic (he would regale you at length how he was properly classified) and his desire to see improvement in medical services. He was also a talented writer who published a book of short stories in the science fiction genre.

I feel that we have lost a valuable member of this community, and while it’s natural for people to come and go Doc’s passing is of a more permanent nature. I’d like to invite people who knew him to offer some words for the rest of us to remember him by.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Jun 06 '21

META Can we stop down voting Theist responses to our comments?

1.4k Upvotes

First let me get ad Hominems out of the way. If a Theist is intentionally being offensive, down vote them to the Phantom Zone.

Plenty of times I see a Theist getting down voted for responding to a question we asked them or a comment we left on their debate post. Even though their response might have been; terrible, nonsensical, fallacious, etc. The theist posted because they thought it was a good response or argument. Instead of down voting we should just tell them why their response was awful.

The point is is that we want them to respond to as much as they can, but if we down vote them everytime they respond, it just punishes and teaches them to not continue the debate any further, which is the opposite of what we want.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Oct 15 '13

What's so bad about Young-Earthers?

1.2k Upvotes

Apparently there is much, much more evidence for an older earth and evolution that i wasn't aware of. I want to thank /u/exchristianKIWI among others who showed me some of this evidence so that i can understand what the scientists have discovered. I guess i was more misled about the topic than i was willing to admit at the beginning, so thank you to anyone who took my questions seriously instead of calling me a troll. I wasn't expecting people to and i was shocked at how hostile some of the replies were. But the few sincere replies might have helped me realize how wrong my family and friends were about this topic and that all i have to do is look. Thank you and God bless.

EDIT: I'm sorry i haven't replied to anything, i will try and do at least some, but i've been mostly off of reddit for a while. Doing other things. Umm, and also thanks to whoever gave me reddit gold (although I'm not sure what exactly that is).


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Apr 26 '21 Bravo

Discussion Topic I believe that religion (mostly Christianity) is made out of fear and to control people.

849 Upvotes

So i was raised Catholic for 16 years (I'm 17 now turning 18 in a few months). Went to very, very religious schools. I never really questioned the religion (well, I've been having doubts when i was 15) until i met my classmate's brother who's an atheist. I asked her (my classmate) why her brother doesn't believe in God, and she said that her brother doesn't believe because he said the Bible doesn't make sense (it also doesn't help that he's gay). And my doubts and skepticism made me think logically. Here's my take on the belief's logic.

*God is all good and all powerful - i believe that this is impossible, considering the way the world has been for thousands of years. If he actually exists, then he's either all good BUT not all powerful, or he's all powerful BUT not good. He cannot be both.

*God gave us free will, but he also has everything planned - you know how bonkers that sounds? Free will and "everything planned" doesn't go hand in hand. If everything is already planned, then we logically don't have free will. And if we really have free will, then obviously, everything isn't planned.

*When we ask for proof of God's existence, they answer with "look around you, the proof is everywhere" - hun, do you know how nuts you sound? That's not proof. That's excuses. They also hit us with "read the bible", like girl, I've been forced reading the bible since i was like 7, and i just found the stories interesting. I didn't see it as a real proof of a God's existence.

*Nothing can exist without a creator - ok, let's say that's true, let's say your thinking is logical, then by going by your own logic, WHO created your God? And the answer i always receive is "no one, because he already existed". Aren't you contradicting your own argument? Like you're going against what you're saying.

*How can they wholeheartedly blindly believe a story written thousands of years ago by people who doesn't have the same knowledge as we do know? People before even thought being gay was a sickness, which we have proved now that it isn't, and people used to put arsenic everywhere, little did they know it could literally kill them. Imagine all the things they believed back then (those who wrote the books), we never know, turns out "Jesus" was just a magician that loves to scam gullible people.

*The bible is true, because places in the bible can be found in real life - well duh? I think they're forgetting that the bible was created by HUMANS, who live in REAL PLACES. If i was a writer, i would obviously write about a real place and connect it to my fictional character to make it believable. With their logic, i can confidently say harry potter is real, you know why? Because owls and Scotland exists. You know how crazy that sounds?

My point is, their teaching doesn't have logic AT ALL. i have no problem believing that we PROBABLY do have a God, but how tf am i going to follow a religion/belief that contradicts itself and just keeps making excuses after excuses to justify their teaching's logic. Christians say science is all just guesses (they obviously don't know what scientific theory means), but isn't their religion just the same? It's all just he said she said. People trusting what other people thousands of years ago said, without any proof at all.

And i get why religion was made, i really do. I can't blame them, it really is comforting to know that i can have a place to go when i die, if i just become a good person and follow God. It really is comforting. But this comfort was brought by fear. Fear of not knowing what's out there, fear of not knowing where we go when we die. Fear of knowing of life is in our hands, and if we end up in a bad situation, we only have ourselves to blame. It IS comforting to know that we have someone to blame (the devil) if we did something bad or something bad happened. So with this fear, people created a religion to comfort people. I can go on more but I'm kinda tired of typing. Comment your thoughts.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Mar 04 '20

Suspected Hit and Run If God knows everything, he knows whether or not I'm going to go to heaven or hell before I was even born. Therefore, he creates people (like myself) that are predestined to go to hell. Why would God do this?

695 Upvotes

Let's say I remained an atheist for the rest of my life. I'm going to go to hell. God knew that I would grow up in an environment where I decided that God is not real and I decided to not believe any of the choices given to me. As God knows everything, he knew that I was going to go to hell before I was even born,

Why would God create me only to suffer for eternity?


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Nov 07 '20 Take My Silver

Philosophy Atheism Resource List

587 Upvotes

u/montesinos7 and I thought it would be a helpful idea to put together a resource guide for good discussions and arguments about atheism and theism. A lot of discussion happens here about theistic arguments, so we thought it would be beneficial to include some of the best cases against theistic arguments and for atheism/naturalism out there. We’re also happy to update the guide if people have specific requests for resources/papers on certain topics, and to answer questions about these resources. This guide focuses mainly on the atheist side of the debate, but eventually we’d like to make a guide with links to pro-theist arguments as well. We hope this will be helpful in critical analysis of theist arguments and in expanding your knowledge of atheism and naturalism.

Edit: u/Instaconfused27 made a large extension that we've now added into the post. Massive thanks to them for the suggestions.

Beginner

  • Thoughtology, with Alex Malpass is a reliable introductory resource on a broad range of topics. Malpass, who has a PhD in philosophy, invites other philosophers to the show for discussions on anything from metaphysics, philosophy of religion, to the philosophy of conspiracy theories.

  • Real Atheology and Crusade Against Ignorance are two more solid youtube channels that often bring on some of the top figures in philosophy of religion to discuss arguments surrounding theism & atheism.

  • Felipe Leon is a philosopher of religion with a solid list of “Six Dozen (or so) Arguments for Atheism” on his blog. He also has a section entitled ‘Assessing Theism’ in which he evaluates (or links to others’ evaluations) of many of the major arguments for God’s existence. If you are interested in some new angles to analyse theism from, this is a good resource.

  • This article by Paul Draper briefly outlines some less mainstream arguments for atheism and agnosticism. Even better when accompanied by this interview of his.

  • This playlist from Capturing Christianity has some very good content. I heavily recommend everything with Josh Rasmussen, Alex Malpass, Joe Schmid, and Graham Oppy. They are very useful to learn some of the steelmanned arguments on both sides and the philosophical background supporting them. If you are new to philosophy, watching some of the Graham Oppy/Josh Rasmussen videos while looking up unfamiliar terms is helpful to become familiar with philosophical terminology.

  • This encyclopedia of philosophy is a good resource for the terminology referenced above, and for understanding a lot of philosophical concepts.

  • Atheism and Agnosticism by Graham Oppy is a good short book which gives a sketch of how to best understand the terms, the method one may use in evaluating which stance towards theism we ought to adopt, and then some basic arguments for both atheism and agnosticism using that method. Graham Oppy is a great philosopher of religion and is one of the more recognised and well regarded atheists within philosophy.

  • My (u/montesinos7) guide to the problem of evil, which should serve as a good directory to some of the essential papers/books on the topic.

  • The Best Argument against God by Graham Oppy is a pretty straightforward and easy to read argument for atheism. It explains a lot of relevant terms and concepts needed for philosophy of religion.

  • Philosophical Disquisitions is a philosophy blog by Dr. John Danaher. One of the main purposes of the blog is to break down technical academic articles so they are more clear and accessible to non-specialists. Dr. Danaher has published in the area of the philosophy of religion and has written dozens of posts on this subject. For example, he has a whole post series index on William Lane Craig's arguments for God's existence, including his famous Kalam Cosmological argument, the Moral argument, and other arguments. He also breaks down the work of many of the best atheist philosophers in the philosophy of religion such as his posts on Graham Oppy on Moral arguments, Stephen Maitzen on Morality and Atheism, Erik Wielenberg on Morality and Meaning, Arif Ahmed on the Resurrection, Wes Morriston on Theistic Morality, and many many more. He's also done a whole series on David Hume's critiques of religion and miracles, as well an entire series on skeptical theism, and other important topics in the philosophy of religion. For those who want to get started with understanding the literature on this topic. Dr. Danaher's blog is the go-to spot.

  • The Non-Existence of God by Nicholas Everitt is one of the best introductions to the philosophy of religion from an atheistic perspective. Everitt's book is comprehensive and introductory: it covers every major argument for the existence of god (including arguments that were developed in the late 20th century such as Alvin Plantinga's Reformed Epistemology and Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism), but it does so in a fairly perspicuous and welcoming manner. Here is a brief introduction and summary of some of the chapters in Everitt's work.

  • Atheism Considered: A Survey of the Rational Rejection of Religious Belief by C.M. Lorkowski is a systematic presentation of challenges to the existence of a higher power. Rather than engaging in a polemic against a religious worldview, Lorkowski charitably refutes the classical arguments for the existence of God, pointing out flaws in their underlying reasoning and highlighting difficulties inherent to revealed sources. In place of a theistic worldview, he argues for adopting a naturalistic one, highlighting naturalism’s capacity to explain world phenomena and contribute to the sciences. Lorkowski demonstrates that replacing theism with naturalism, contra popular assumptions sacrifices nothing in terms of ethics or meaning. A charitable and philosophical introduction to a more rigorous Atheism.

  • Arguing for Atheism: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Religion by Robin Le Poidevin is an excellent introduction to the philosophy of religion from an atheist perspective. It is a useful introduction not only to philosophy of religion but to metaphysics as well. Each chapter serves the dual purpose of analyzing a specific argument, while at the same time introducing a metaphysical concept. Readers may pick up the book in order to strengthen their arguments against the cosmological argument, the argument from necessity, and the argument from design, and come away with a surprising understanding of broader philosophical issues like causation, necessity and contingency, and probability. While Parts I and II on theistic arguments and the problem of evil are excellent, Part III on fictionalism can be safely skipped.

  • Atheism: A Very Short Introduction by Julian Baggini is a brief, extremely accessible introduction for those who want to begin their journey into the philosophy of religion. The book does an important of introducing the reader to important philosophical concepts in the Atheism vs. Theism debate such as how to evaluate arguments, Naturalism, etc. This is an excellent springboard to more thorough works in the philosophy of religion.

  • Morality Without God? by Walter Sinnott-Armstrong is a brief, accessible, and clear introduction to the issues related to God and Morality. One of the most popular arguments for Theism today is the moral argument. Sinnott-Armstrong argues that God is not only not essential to morality, but that our moral behavior should be utterly independent of religion. He attacks several core ideas: that atheists are inherently immoral people; that any society will sink into chaos if it becomes too secular; that without religion, we have no reason to be moral; that absolute moral standards require the existence of God; and that without religion, we simply couldn't know what is wrong and what is right.

Intermediate

  • Majesty of Reason is a youtube channel run by undergraduate Joe Schmid, which has excellent content on philosophy and critical thinking generally, complete with many interviews with important theist and atheist thinkers. His video on why he is agnostic is a particularly good introductory video.

  • An excellent repository of nontheist arguments and essays. Not everything on there is good so be selective, but there are some truly fantastic collections of essays by eminent figures on there.

  • Another great repository of nontheist papers, with a focus on those that seek to disprove the existence of God

  • John Schellenberg has written extensively on the divine hiddenness argument, his most recent work on it is meant for a popular audience and so could be an easy read. He also has a number of books attempting to justify religious skepticism.

  • Paul Draper has written extensively on the problem evil, and his version is considered to be one of the best out there. His responses to criticisms, such as skeptical theism, have been especially excellent.

  • Theism and Explanation by Gregory Dawes is an excellent book in defense of methodological naturalism. Dawes builds up the best case possible for what a successful theistic explanation for phenomenon might look like and then argues that it fails in comparison to the natural explanation.

  • This encyclopedia of philosophy has excellent introductions to many philosophical topics, including those related to arguments for and against theism (Here are some examples).

  • Wes Morriston is a philosopher of religion who has written extensively on the kalam cosmological argument, and his objections are considered to be some of the best out there. He co-wrote a recent paper on the role of infinity in the Kalam argument with Alex Malpass.

  • On the Nature and Existence of God by Richard Gale is a landmark work in the Analytic Philosophy of Religion. It is considered of the most important books from an atheistic point of view in the philosophy of religion after J.L. Mackie's Miracle of Theism. In this work, Gales offers several innovative atheological arguments, before turning his attention to contemporary theistic arguments. Gale deals with the titans of Christian Analytic Philosophy such as Alvin Plantinga, William Alston, Richard Swinburne, and many more. A classic and required reading for anyone interested in these issues.

  • Naturalism and Religion: A Contemporary Philosophical Investigation by Graham Oppy is a tour-de-force that seeks to make a philosophical case for naturalism over all such religious explanatory framework. This book provides an explanation to understand what naturalism is, and whether it can provide a coherent, plausible, and satisfactory answer to the “big questions” typically thought to lie within the magisterium of religion. The book's most general aim is to demonstrate that the very best naturalistic “big pictures” (something akin to a worldview) can be defended against attacks from the very best religious ones. Oppy takes on heavyweights such as Aquinas and Thomism, Alvin Plantinga, and other theistic challenges to Naturalism. Perhaps the best defense of Naturalism in print by one of the world's leading Naturalists.

  • The God Beyond Belief by Nick Trakakis is one of the best works on the problem of evil today. The book has 13 chapters running into 342 pages and is a captivating work that is well organised as each chapter deals with a specific argument and follows naturally from the preceding chapter. The book is a full defence of William Rowe's thesis that the presence of evil renders the existence of an all-powerful, all-good god highly improbable. Trakakis deals with various defenses from Theists such as Skeptical Theism, Free-Will, Soul-Building, etc, and find them all flawed. Trakakis then considered related issues and arguments in the rest of the book, including the problem of God's "divine hiddenness" which he sees as a further indictment against any defence of God's existence. In brief, in the face of evil, God has no reason to hide himself. He must appear and explain or make his ways and reasons known. That leads Trakakis to issues of what a theistic argument must provide in order to succeed in its defence, and he concludes and shows the failure of theists to present any such argument.

  • UseOfReason is the blog of Dr. Alex Malpass, a formidable defender of Atheism who has debated many theists online, including William Lane Craig. While his blog can be a bit technical due to its emphasis on logic, Malpass has excellent discussions on topics related to Contingency arguments, Aquinas' Third Way, Fine-Tuning Arguments, the definition of Atheism, Transcendental arguments, and many many more.

  • Atheism: A Philosophical Justification by Michael Martin is a dated, but still classic work in the skeptical canon of atheistic philosophy of religion. Martin assembles a formidable case against Theism, not only going through many of the classic and contemporary arguments for Theism but offering a strong positive case for Atheism as well.

  • Is God the Best Explanation of Things?: A Dialogue by Felipe Leon and Josh Rasmussen is an up to date, high-level exchange on God in a uniquely productive style. Both the authors are considered among the very best defenders for their respective positions. In their dialogue, they examine classical and cutting-edge arguments for and against a theistic explanation of general features of reality. This book represents the cutting-edge of analytic philosophy of religion and provides an insight into the innovative developments in the Atheism vs. Theism debate.

  • The Improbability of God edited by Michael Martin and Ricki Monnier is an anthology of some of the best contemporary work in the analytic philosophy of religion by some of the best atheist philosophers around such as William Rowe, Theodore Drange, Quentin Smith, J. L. Schellenberg, and Michael Martin. While some of the papers can get extremely technical, the volume as a whole is pretty clear and accessible and contains some of the most powerful arguments in favor of Atheism.

Difficult/Technical

  • Arguing About Gods by Graham Oppy is a seminal book in the naturalist canon at this point. The thesis of the book is that there are no successful arguments for God’s existence, and, similar to Sobel and Mackie, Oppy expertly dissects the major problems in all the major classes of argument (cosmological, teleological, ontological, etc.). An essential read, but one that should be undertaken after having a strong understanding of the arguments at hand.

  • The Miracle of Theism is J.L. Mackie’s famous book in which he deconstructs a wide variety of theistic arguments. The book is well regarded, but it is about 40 years old so there have been a lot of developments in philosophy of religion since, so take some of it with a grain of salt.

  • If you’re up for a bit of a challenge and are well versed in symbolic logic, Jordan Sobel is another very well regarded author and wrote what is still considered one of the best books in all of philosophy of religion. Be aware that this is by far the most difficult book to read on this list.

  • Graham Oppy’s articles are always an excellent resource, they will vary in difficulty to read but many are somewhat technical. Here is one example: a taxonomy of the different forms of cosmological arguments and reasons to reject that any are successful.

  • The Blackwell Companion to Natural Theology is a collection of some of the major arguments for God outlined by important theistic philosophers. Definitely could be a good resource for finding steel manned theist arguments.

  • Divine Intervention: Metaphysical and Epistemological Puzzles by Evan Fales mounts an impressively thorough yet concise argument that there are serious problems with the idea of divine action in the world, and thus with the idea of miracles. The book is a tour-de-force because of the evidence it provides for naturalism and against theism, and also because of the insights it provides into perplexing questions about God's power, explanation, causation, laws of nature, and miracles. It even supports a tentative case for conservation-based or causal closure-based arguments against dualism.

  • Why is there something rather than nothing? by Bede Rundle is a highly technical, dense, but impressively argued work that looks to answer one of the most popular challenges to Atheism and Naturalism today. Rundle argues that if anything at all exists, the physical exists. The priority of the physical is supported by eliminating rival contenders such as Theism and the book concludes with an investigation of this issue and of the possibility that the universe could have existed for an infinite time. Despite the title, Rundle covers topics such as fine-tuning, causality, space, time, essence, existence, necessity, infinity, explanation, mind, and laws of Nature.

  • Robust Ethics: The Metaphysics and Epistemology of Godless Normative Realism by Erik Wielenberg draws on recent work in analytic philosophy and empirical moral psychology to defend non-theistic robust normative realism and develop an empirically-grounded account of human moral knowledge. Non-theistic robust normative realism has it that there are objective, non-natural, sui generis ethical features of the universe that do not depend on God for their existence. A highly technical work, but an excellent counter to the claims of many moral arguments. An accessible summary of the book can be found here.

  • Quentin Smith was considered one of the leading atheist philosophers of religion in the late 20th century. He was one of the leading critics of the Kalam Cosmological argument and did a lot of innovative work in developing the case for Atheism and Naturalism. His landmark paper on the Metaphilosophy of Naturalism is required reading for all Naturalists and Atheists about the challenges and goals of building an expansive Naturalism and Atheism in philosophy and beyond. Smith was an innovative genius and thus a lot of his work is extremely technical and dense, but the parts that can be understood are pretty powerful.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Jan 01 '22

META Why are we allowing mods to do an AMA when they just lock the thread when the questions are uncomfortable to answer?

578 Upvotes

As many of you know, there was an AMA on this sub this morning. This AMA was posted by a new mod, who is of Catholic faith.

To preface: I love the idea of having mods of different faith/non-faith backgrounds. It fits the spirit of the sub — or, at least, it used to.

During this very very brief AMA, the new mod was asked several questions about the many glaring, offensive, criminal, and tragic issues involving the Catholic Church today, and indeed over the many centuries it’s held power.

Some of these questions must have been hard for the mod to read: they were tough, but absolutely fair, questions. I asked a few myself.

After barely two hours, the same mod locked the comments on the thread while numerous conversations were still happening in the thread.

So, my question is to the users here, as well as the mod team: what is the point in having an AMA when the very person who set it up in the first place also closes it down when the conversation takes a turn they don’t like.

Maybe this is a bad take and I’m missing something, but to me, it seems like this sub is okay with closing down conversation when someone doesn’t like what’s happening.

This is a terrible and childish look for this sub, and I do hope to hear from some folks who are likewise worried about the state of the sub.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Aug 18 '21

Philosophy How do you find meaning in your life as an atheist?

571 Upvotes

I am someone who is diagnosed with depression, and even though I believe in God and believe I'll have eternal peace after I die in heaven, I still struggled with finding purpose in waking up everyday. Only reason I didn't end it all was because I was afraid to go to hell...

As an atheist, how do you hope? How do you endure the hardships that come your way knowing you won't be rewarded for your patience? How do you bear seeing injustice in the world without believing a God will eventually punish the wrongdoers? How do you stop yourself from giving up when it's all too much? How do you face the reality of death?

I can't imagine. If I was an atheist I would be long gone.

Edit 1 : I am a Muslim if anyone is wondering.

Edit 2 : I'm surprised how many people answered my question. I'm a bit overwhelmed. English is my third language so I need to read some complex replies very slowly to understand them. I'm sorry if someone took the time to write a long comment and I don't reply to them. I appreciate you all.

Edit 3 : thanks for the gold!


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Nov 16 '19

META Thank you. You guys literally saved my life.

524 Upvotes

You fuckers helped me in ways that I don't think you'll ever be able to understand.

My first post here was a shit show. A terrible, no good, very bad shit show.

But it opened my eyes, while at the same time causing a crisis of conscience over my beliefs. It was hard and it took a while to come to terms with my convictions.

Several individuals were integral in this, but I wanted to specifically call out u/tunage by name. Their wise words of "... Just lessons learned. Scrutinize everything, rigorously" signified a turning point for me.

So simple, right? But tunage's words became almost like an internal "mantra" (for lack of a better term) as I continued to face the underlying fears of accepting my convictions.

u/tunage and the rest of you great fuckers saved my life. This isn't an exaggeration. It's not hyperbole.

I have bipolar, borderline and OCD. A cocktail of delectable mental illnesses that made accepting my convictions so hard.

I wrote my first post on here during an OCD episode. I have scrupulosity, which is religious based obsessions. I've had it since I can remember. I was having the worst episode I ever had at that point and I was resigned to just fucking ending it all. I already had my plan and I'd written all my letters.

I was SLAMMED on my first post here, but that tough correction - it saved my life and gave me something to contemplate. I contemplated what it was I was really scared of and why I was so clingy to an illusion that I knew I didn't trust in my very being.

You guys saved my life.

I told my parents I was atheist this past August. I was shitting my pants the entire time, but I felt so... brave? For being wholly authentic in my beliefs. It was scary, but freeing.

I feel more myself than I ever have.

Thank you.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Apr 16 '21

OP=Atheist Why not Pray for the Restoration of an Amputee's Limbs?

522 Upvotes

I work in a hospital. I see human suffering every day, especially since this pandemic has started.

In my work I have seen tons and tons of people praying over a cancer patient, asking god to heal them.

At the same time, just a few doors down, there will be a human being who lost their leg in some kind of accident - but no one ever prays that their leg (or whatever limb) will grow back.

Why is this?

Is it because of poor faith? Do they not believe that god can regenerate the lost limb (in which case how is this god omnipotent)?

Or is it just a silent acknowledgement that god doesn't care enough to give the limb back?

Reposted topic under corrected flair


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Jun 07 '19

META I think that we may be a little to dogmatic

455 Upvotes

Speaking as an atheist, it always annoys me when I see a theist post a perfectly respectable question. And then I see some atheist start insulting them for no reason. Guys stop don’t be jerks respect the other side they have their reasons for believing what they do and if you disrespect them and insult them or treat them as if they are stupid you only hurt the argument.

Edit if I seemed condescending that wasn’t my intention at all. Also I didn’t phrase this right, what I mean is, that disrespecting the other side only closes them to hearing us out because why should they listen to us if we don’t even care about their argument.

Edit 2 dogma really wasn’t the best word

Edit 3: grammar and punctuation.

Edit 4: MORE GRAMMAR AND PUNCTUATION


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Oct 30 '20

META I need your best arguments for Atheism.

443 Upvotes

I have been tasked with playing Devil’s Advocate tomorrow at school. We are debating Atheism vs. Christianity. I’m arguing pro-Atheism. I need your best arguments to use tomorrow. I want some stuff that are really hard to debate. I am fairly positive we won’t be really researching anything while debating, so logic arguments would be great. Statistic arguments would also be great, but I think using logic is much better in this scenario. If you have any great ones that are absolutely killer, let me know them.

Thanks in advance. I’m pretty excited. I know a few arguments, but not enough to debate my class. It’s a Christian School, and half the people in the class are Jocks, so they don’t know much about atheism or debating if I’m being honest. It’ll be fun.

Edit: So I was very excited, I learned a lot, but sadly the teacher cancelled it. Very disappointing.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Jun 28 '21

Personal Experience People Who Claim To Have Heard/Seen A Deity Have An Illness That Should Be Recognized By Medical Staff

388 Upvotes

People who claim to have heard a deity speak to them, or who have claimed to see one, have hallucinations. The definition of hallucination is "a sensory experience that appears real, but is created by the mind". - paraphrased from Healthline. This is often a symptom of several illnesses, so we can conclude that the person who claims to see/hear a deity has an illness, because nobody else can perceive what the other hears/sees. I think that claiming to see/hear a deity has no basis in reality, whatsoever, can potentially cause the person to dangerous things and is very strange.

Now, I perfectly accept that it is not in their control, and it is perfectly OK to have an illness, whether that be of mind or body, but why isn't people claiming to see/hear deities viewed as an illness by doctors? Serious question. Any attempts to change my view, especially from anybody working in the medical field will be greatly appreciated.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Jan 09 '23

Discussion Topic Most Christians misunderstand how other Christians eventually become atheists.

385 Upvotes

I don’t mean this post to be a detailed defense of atheism. There are plenty of those on this sub. I more mean it as a general information bulletin for the Christian participants of this sub who come here to have discussions in good faith about our respective positions.

I was raised in non-denominational evangelical churches, and I considered myself a Christian until I was about 25; and I was serious about it. I researched different theological perspectives, sought out home churches that fit my understanding of the Bible, went on short term missions trips, etc. Which is all just to say I’ve genuinely experienced both perspectives.

So when I was a Christian, here is what I thought turned Christians into atheists, and what I know a lot of Christians think:

Someone raised in church gets a little older and they start noticing things they don’t like.

Maybe it starts in youth group, and they notice that the most vocal, popular kids in the youth group are partying and hooking up to varying degrees on the low, and just lying about it to everyone. Maybe it happens as an adult, and they hear credible rumors that an associate pastor is having an affair with one of the congregation members, or is addicted to porn, or whatever. Maybe it’s financial, and they don’t like the the pastoral staff lives in big suburban mcmansions paid for with tithes from their working class congregation. Maybe there’s an abuse or financial scandal involving a respected member of their local community, or someone they know from a tv mega church.

Some people think (I thought) those types of people get tired of the hypocrisy of the Christians they see around them, or become misled, and that one day, they sort of just snap and decide, “if this is Christianity, then I don’t want to be a Christian,” and they choose to become an atheist. They often assume we’re angry or resentful.

This is an appealing thing to believe because it has an easy answer. “Well it’s sad these bad/fake Christians left that impression, but those lost people need to realize these bad Christians don’t represent all Christians (which is true) and certainly don’t represent Christ. Hopefully those atheists will find their way back.”

But that’s not what happens. People like that don’t tend to become atheists, or at least don’t self-identify that way. They just stop going to church.

The truth is, the vast majority of atheists don’t ‘choose’ to be atheists. They ‘realize’ they are atheists.

We have enough sense to understand that there are bad Christians just like there are bad Buddhists and bad atheists. That’s not why we leave.

Most of us fight leaving. We read apologetic literature, we talk to our pastors, and we generally bend over backwards to find a way for it to keep making sense in the face of what we’ve otherwise learned about science, and history, and archeology, and sociology, and anthropology, and psychology, and other religions, etc. Usually this is a years long process.

But we eventually realize that we can’t reconcile anything that anyone would call a Christian faith with the other stuff we’ve learned… beyond maybe just vaguely appreciating that there are SOME good lessons in the Bible, in the same way that there are some good messages in any other religious canon.

We don’t choose to believe that way. We realize that that’s already how we feel. At least I had a “wow… I guess I’m an atheist” moment. And there’s no resentment or anger in it. It just is what it is. And it doesn’t scare us anymore, because hell isn’t real to us anymore. We understand it as a product of the imagination of the many authors of one of the many texts of one of the many ancient near eastern religions that took mellinia to evolve into what Christians think hell is today.

And that’s why most of us are never coming back. We didn’t reason our way into Christianity, because we were raised in it. But we did, usually very slowly and reluctantly reason our way out.

I’d be interested to hear other people’s’ thoughts, but I think that’s a fundamental misunderstanding a lot of Christians have about formerly Christian atheists.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Aug 27 '19

OP=Atheist Science is a methodology: clearing up a common misconception held by theists who post here

362 Upvotes

This needs to be clarified.

Science is not a worldview. It’s not a code of ethics. It’s not a framing device.

Science is a methodology. Specifically, it’s this methodology:

  1. Make an observation.

  2. Create a testable if-then hypothesis to explain the observation.

  3. Create an experiment that can accurately test the hypothesis with as little room for error as reasonably possible.

  4. Carry out the experiment with as little error as possible.

  5. If the hypothesis is not supported, make more observations and a new hypothesis to test.

  6. Test the new hypothesis.

  7. Repeat until the hypothesis is supported.

  8. If supported, share the data with others.

  9. Others and yourself conduct more tests based on the hypothesis and repeat the tests already done.

Notice how nowhere in this process is it required to hold a certain code of ethics. It doesn’t require any sort of worldview other than that observations are possible and that reality exists, which is accepted by pretty much everyone already, including theists.

So, is your god able to be understood by science? If observations can or have been made of, pertaining to, or related even tangentially to said god, then science can study said god.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Oct 22 '22

Discussion Topic Christians do not have arguments, just elaborate evasions of criticism.

345 Upvotes

Having been a Christian for many years, and familiar with apologetics, I used to be pretty sympathetic towards the arguments of Christian apologists. But after a few years of deconstruction, I am dubious to the idea that they even have any arguments at all. Most of their “arguments” are just long speeches that try to prevent their theological beliefs from being held to the same standards of evidence as other things.

When their definition of god is shown to be illogical, we are told that god is “above human logic.” When the rules and actions of their god are shown to be immoral, we are told that he is “above human morality and the source of all morality.” When the lack of evidence for god is mentioned, we are told that god is “invisible and mysterious.”

All of these sound like arguments at first blush. But the pattern is always the same, and reveals what they really are: an attempt to make the rules of logic, morality, and evidence, apply to everyone but them.

Do you agree? Do you think that any theistic arguments are truly-so-called, and not just sneaky evasion tactics or distractions?


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Sep 05 '21

Personal Experience Why are you an atheist?

334 Upvotes

If this is the wrong forum for this question, I apologize. I hope it will lead to good discussion.

I want to pose the question: why are you an atheist?

It is my observation that atheism is a reaction to theology. It seems to me that all atheists have become so because of some wound given by a religious order, or a person espousing some religion.

What is your experience?

Edit Oh my goodness! So many responses! I am overwhelmed. I wish I could have a conversation with each and every one of you, but alas, i have only so much time.

If you do not get a response from me, i am sorry, by the way my phone has blown up, im not sure i have seen even half of the responses.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Sep 27 '22

Personal Experience The story of how this sub turned me into an Atheist

327 Upvotes

Note: This post is a long and detailed account of the reasoning for and developments of my beliefs. If you are not up to reading it maybe skip to the last paragraph.

I grew up in a high-demand sect of Christianity called Mormonism. The first time I think I really believed in God was when I was 6 or 7. My grandfather, an extremely devout man, sat our family down and shared his story. When he was a Nutritional Science Ph.D. student at Purdue University he questioned if there was a God. He concluded that if there was a God that God was evil otherwise there would not be so much suffering in the world. During this questioning, he came across Mormon missionaries and met with them a few times but didn't think much of it. Later while sitting in his chemistry lab thinking about the mysteries of the Universe he had a powerful spiritual experience where he heard the word of God tell him that all the answers to his questions were taught to him by the missionaries. He expressed the feeling like a truck had hit him and he burst into tears. From that day on he has dedicated every single energy of his being to the Mormon Church. Hearing this experience from my grandfather whom I greatly admired touched my heart and I felt like this was evidence that what he said was true. I learned about the story of creation and what we call the plan of salvation. The idea of God loving me, there being a life before and after this one, and a judgment resonated with me and I didn't question its truthfulness.

Growing up my life was very involved with my church. I went to church every single Sunday, and on Weekends I participated in youth activities. Our family would pray before every meal and before bed. I was encouraged to read the Bible and the Book of Mormon every single day, and for about half my childhood our family read these scriptures together each night. Once a week we had a Family Home Evening where we did activities together and shared thoughts about what we had learned from the scriptures. Twice a year there was a 10-hour conference from the leaders of the church that I watched from as young as I can remember. There were pictures of Jesus and Temples throughout our house and religious conversations were very common.

My stepfather was a character who is a super controlling narcist who spent at least 5-10 hours every single week lecturing the whole family on religion (mostly the Old Testament) as well as his conspiracy theories focused on the End Times and return of Jesus. He had spent a ton of time researching religion and apologetics and always had an answer to all my young naïve questions. At 11 I remember asking him where the Dinosaurs play in the creation of the earth. He told me we don't know but there are some theories. Possibly the dinosaur bones came from other planets when our earth was created, possibly dinosaurs were alive before the flood but nobody wrote about them, or possibly we misunderstand when the bible says the earth was made in 7 days and to god that was millions or billions of years. I didn't learn about carbon dating until high school chemistry class, but from a very young age, I was taught that science and religion don't contradict. We just don't have all the answers and in time (as in after we die) it will all make sense and we will have all the answers. When I was 13 my stepfather and I read a few books by Brian Green on Quantum Physics. The Uncertainty Principle and idea of infinite Multiverses helped to justify our belief in miracles. I defined a miracle such as turning water into wine or raising someone from the dead as an event that uses scientific and technological mechanisms that we do not yet understand. Growing up I was exposed to every anti-Mormon or anti-religion argument imaginable and spent a lot of time reading and listening to apologetics to help me grapple with and understand these ideas.

My whole life I had heard stories about mission trips. The adventures and experiences people shared were super fun and inspiring. I wanted to serve a mission from as young as I can remember and never once questioned that idea. a Mormon Mission has extremely strict rules such as you can't ever leave your companion's sight, you can't read anything other than the scripters and church material, you can't leave your designated area, and can't hug someone of the opposite gender or have romantic relationships. You have to knock doors, visit members, study the scriptures, or street contact constantly. For the first 6 months of my mission I didn't really follow the rules well and I was deeply miserable. I spent a lot of time hanging out with other missionaries or members or just sitting at my apartment reading books. One time I got in trouble for going to a church Christmas party for a congregation I was not assigned to and almost got sent home by the mission president. At that moment I decided to commit myself to what I believed I should be doing as a missionary. I followed every single rule exactly and spent every second of my time focused on sharing the gospel of Jesus Christ. This next year was the hardest but also most fulfilling and joyful period of my whole life. When I saw someone change the way they live their lives (in accordance with God's will), overcome addictions, connect with a community and make friends, feel of God's unconditional love, etc. I felt so much purpose. Saving people from “Hell” was never a motivating factor. What motivated me was seeing people live a life that I considered better than they were living before.

There was one thought that nagged at my mind throughout my whole life. What are the odds that I would be born into the one true Church when only 0.2% of the world's population believed what I believed? For a long time, I just thought I must be very lucky or maybe God put me in the family I was born into for a reason. Eventually, this thought got me very curious about world religions and about beliefs. On my mission, I read the BYU world religion manual and it was fascinating. I started to believe strongly that there were universal truths that all religions held and that there are truths that some religions understood even better than my own. I have never believed in the idea of reincarnation, but this concept resonated with me in a similar way that the ideas of pre-earth life and the afterlife did. I found a lot of peace in the practice of meditation and wished that the Mormon church spent more time teaching it.

I didn't start to question my beliefs until I read Jonathan Haidt's books while in college. He explained the evolutionary reasons why people believe in religion and covered all the studies that show how religious people are on average happier. It really is him as a liberal atheist trying to understand conservatives and religious people. For a year after I read these books I constantly thought about the concepts and often wished I could unread them. The ideas he explores were fundamental truths that went against everything I had ever known and this was distressing.

I still didn't lose my faith even though I had a lot of internal dissonance and unanswered questions. What I knew was that the happiest I had ever been was when I completely dedicated myself to god and shared the gospel. My grandfather is the kindest, most charitable, tolerant, and humble person I have ever met and he has dedicated his entire life to Mormonism. Everything good in my life seemed to have come from people around me living the gospel of Jesus Christ. Everything bad seemed to come from people either distorting the teaching of the church to control my life in the case of my step-father, or not following the teaching of the church as far as addiction goes in the case of my father. Those closest to me that I saw leave the church fell into a life of alcohol and lies and ultimately misery. My "evidence" for believing was from the experience of living the principles. I didn't necessarily believe the church's claims were completely true, but I believed strongly that living the principles as if they were true led to a better outcome than living as if they were not true.

What got me to the point of not even considering myself Mormon anymore had 2 parts. The first was reading Carl Sagan's book The Demon-Haunted World. This is now my favorite book I have ever read. Sagan uses logic and science to explain why it is irrational to believe in many of the fairy tales people believe in. He spends a significant amount of the book using his method of discovering truth to go through all of the available evidence for aliens. This really resonated with me because much of the same reasoning I had been told justifying the reality of spirits and miracles were used by my stepfather to defend a belief in aliens.

The second part was actually a "spiritual" experience. My first ever psychedelic experience was with Psilocybin mushrooms. During this, I meditated and experienced astral projection and I saw a powerful presence that the only word in the English language has to describe is God. I had so much energy, everything felt vibrant, and time felt like a fragment of my imagination. On this drug, I learned without a doubt that our minds are far more complex and malleable than I had ever imagined. I had felt at times peace, love, joy, gratitude, and many other positive emotions in the church. What I had never felt were unexplainable miracles or spiritual experiences. Everything I had ever seen in the church could be explained by the placebo effect, power of belief, and the complexity of the mind. My astral projection experience was the type of experience that I had read about in scripture and I always believed would one day happen to me. It finally did, but all it took was 3.5g of a dried mushroom. A while later after pondering this experience I had another powerful moment I would have described as a spiritual experience when I believed. It was the most beautiful moment of my life. I had a vision in my mind when struggling with a complex mathematical idea. The moment of epiphany was that God is math. In this vision of my mind, I saw a visual representation of Mathematics, and the feeling its presence caused was pure bliss. I believe this moment was only possible after years of struggling with religious and philosophical ideas and really struggling to grasp complex theoretical mathematical ideas. The mind is a mysterious and beautiful thing. That day I decided I was a deist and that all religions are objectively false.

A month ago I started engaging with this community. I'm not trained in logic, but I did learn some about it in my math classes at college so the formal way that y'all argue made a lot of sense. The exmormon sub banned me after one post because I claimed that not everything about the church is bad. Apparently leaving the church isn't enough to join that community, you have to be angry and see them as the ultimate villain. I can not express in words how beneficial this community has been in helping me deal with my transition into atheism and sharpening up my belief system. After one post I made asking if you can believe in a creator and still be an atheist I was recommended the book A Universe from Nothing by Lawrence Krauss and that book was the nail in the coffin for my belief in any God. I have read every single comment made on all my posts and tried my best to reply to many of them. I have learned so much about belief, about reasons to live, and about finding meaning in life without God. Thank you all so much. Y'all are just one leg of my journey through life, but a truly vital part that has helped me process and make peace with the rest of my journey. I can't imagine trying to go through this before these books were written and before the internet. Thank you!


r/DebateAnAtheist • • May 14 '25

OP=Atheist Atheist, with terminal brain cancer

320 Upvotes

I live in London. I’ve got terminal brain cancer, GBM. But my atheism is not remotely challenged. In fact it’s reinforced and provides a comfort. I know there is no heaven or hell after death, just simple non existence, like before I was born. Religious people declare that I must do this or that before I die to avoid hell. I’m completely relaxed about. Just made up stuff. If you think I’m getting wrong let me know !😊


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Jun 09 '20

META This subreddit has signed the petition against hate.

319 Upvotes

There will be no debate on this. I own the sub, and I have taken a unilateral stand.

If this is something you feel is long overdue, and something you questioned why there was even any delay or debate - thank you for your support, and for being good people.

If you think doing so is such an egregious act that you cannot abide, the unsubscribe button is your best option. You are not actually welcome here.

We will NOT be making the sub private or invite only. We WILL be amending the rules to include a rule against racism, sexism, general fascism, and bigotry. (TBA later - likely today.)

That is all.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • May 18 '21

OP=Atheist Why wouldn’t an omnipotent God not prove his own existence?

318 Upvotes

Here goes: if an omnipotent God is so truly powerful, why not just hold a meeting (doesn’t even require Zoom, despite the pandemic) and be like, “Hello, everyone. I’m actually real and I made you guys. Okay, bye for now, then.”

I also find it hilarious that we think of God as a ‘he’. Surely an omnipotent, omnibenevolent and omnipresent God would have transcended gender? Or does God have some sweet pecs and abs that we just don’t know about yet? Is he the most ripped lad in Heaven’s gym?

Just saw a comment that if God does exist, he would have to be a totalitarian sadist, which made me chortle.

The cognitive dissonance of religious people really blows my mind. Religion makes zero sense.

Edits: obvious typos because I was sleepy lol


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Mar 11 '23

META Some advice for our theist friends

314 Upvotes
  • If you make a claim, we are likely to expect you to support it with neutral, reliable sources. If you can't do this, I advise you not to make it.

    • This includes claims such as "Jesus loves you," "God's purposes cannot be understood by us" and "The gospels contain eye-witness testimony."

    • Reliable sources are not religious (or for that matter atheist) propaganda, but scholarly and scientific articles.

    • wiki is o.k.

  • Your beliefs are not the basis for an argument. You get to believe them. You don't get to expect us to accept them as factual.

  • Before you make an argument for your god, I recommend that you check for Special Pleading. That means if you don't accept it when applied to or made by people in other religions, you don't get to use it for yours. Examples would be things like "I know this to be true by witness of the Holy Spirit, or "Everything that exists requires a cause outside itself." I hope you see why.

  • Most atheists are agnostic. It makes no sense to post a debate asking why we are 100% certain. Those posts are best addressed to theists, who often claim to be.

  • You can't define something into existence. For example, "God is defined as the greatest possible being, and existence is greater than non-existence, therefore God exists."

  • For most atheists, the thing that really impresses us is evidence.

  • Many of us are not impressed with the moral history of Christianity and Islam, so claims that they are a force for good in the world are likely to be shot down by facts quickly.

  • If you have to resort to solipsism to achieve your point, you already lost.

  • Presuppositionalism is nothing but bad manners. Attempt it if you dare, but it is not likely to go well for you.

  • And for god's sake don't preach at us. It's rude.

Anyone else got any pointers?


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Oct 31 '21

OP=Atheist Atheism isn’t a religion and it’s often incorrectly categorized as one.

313 Upvotes

Atheism isn’t a religion and shouldn’t be lumped into the same category as one. By definition atheism is “the lack of belief in a God”. Atheism doesn’t resemble organized religion in any way and there are no collective goals it seems. Christians often try to incorrectly categorize it as a religion to promote their own ideologies.

Atheism has no creeds and it has no collective goals or ideas to oppress onto others. Atheists don’t meet once a week to study a text or sing atheist songs. Atheists don’t give 10% of their money each month to an atheist preacher. There are no values to uphold or oppress onto others like religion.

Some people incorrectly claim that atheists “believe there is no God” which is completely incorrect. Atheism is the lack of belief in a God. Atheism requires no faith. At the end of the day, it should never be put in the same category as religion.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Jul 22 '21

Apologetics & Arguments Most atheists don't care about dying and disappearing from existence. It's psychologically a normal behaviour?

308 Upvotes

For some reason, most atheist on here seem to share the same ideology and mental traits in regard to a possible afterlife. Most don't seem to believe on it and most don't seem to care at all.

"Death is just death", "the non-existence after dying is the same as just not being born".. Seem to be some of the most commom arguments from atheists when you ask them if they care about what will happen to them after they die. ( Most but not all, some I know actually care).

Ok I get it, but is this really a normal behaviour from a human being? Shouldn't be the norm for a self-aware individual to be extremelly concern about the possibility of just dissapearing from existence?.

To clarify, I'm agnostic theist, I don't know what the fuck will happen to me after I die. BUT I am for sure, very terrified and at the same time fascinated of the topic, because big part of my subconscious doesn't want to die. It refuses the idea of stop living, stop learning, stop experiencing and being aware, shit is really, really scary.

To people who don't care. Is it normal and healthy from a human brain?

Edit: Based on most of the answers in this thread I can conclude that most of you actually care, so I didn't have the urge to debate much, perhaps I just had a big misconception. I would also not call abormal or mentally unhealthy to those who say they don't care, but I still find your mentality really hard comprehend.


r/DebateAnAtheist • • Apr 26 '20

Defining the Supernatural Do not argue for logic if you believe in something that defies logic.

299 Upvotes

Many traits given to most gods are logically contradictory, this is then further justified by theists using the following statement or something along these lines "God is beyond logic, we are like a tiny spec of dust in this universe, we can't comprehend his traits, if he wills, he can create a square circle or a married bachelor."

Theists need to acknowledge that the foundation they have their core beliefs on is illogical, they should not argue for logic and should not have an issue being illogical as long as it makes them feel happy and purposeful in life.

If you're a theist, Please do not make claims such as "my religion is logical" "my religion is so advanced that science is learning about the things my religion talked about in the 7th century"

As most of these religions rely on interpretations, interpretations rely on their interpreters, modern interpretations will bend the rules, do a ton of mental gymnastics to connect the dots. (for reference look at Islamic "miracles")

And when things don't make sense still, then it's because God defies logic and he's beyond logic.