r/community • • May 20 '12

"Joel McHale took an informal survey of college students helping him prep for a stand-up show on their campus. He asked how many watched his show Community. All 40 raised their hands. He asked how many watch it Thursday night at 8 pm? None. How many own TVs? Four. How many watch it online? All."

http://notnielsen.com/about
2.2k Upvotes

408 comments sorted by

367

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

It's not just overpriced, it's less convenient. Nobody wants to wait til 8 pm Thursday night to sit through ads and watch it with commercial breaks on their schedule when the option exists to watch it when it's a good time for them.

198

u/onemoredrink May 20 '12

Not to mention when you're in college there's Thirsty Thursday...

162

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Everyday is Thirsty Thursday

85

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Not when it's Wet Your Whistle Wednesday.

72

u/AdamBombTV May 20 '12

Not as bad as "Get Trashed Tuesday"

238

u/darth_aardvark May 20 '12

or "Severe Alcoholism Monday"

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Shorties May 20 '12

Messed up Monday, Tipsy Tuesday, Wasted Wednesday, Thirsty Thursday, Fucked up Friday, Sloshed Saturday, Shmammered Sunday

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/amarine88 May 20 '12

What about marathon Monday?

8

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I personally enjoy malt Mondays.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/TryingToSucceed May 20 '12

I already miss college....it's only been a week :(

→ More replies (1)

7

u/HugeDouche May 20 '12

Start drinking during Jeopardy (don't judge me)

Continue through til 30 Rock (or go to Parks and Rec if that's what you want)

Go drunkenly get ready cause anyplace you're going to for Thirsty Thursday is a sloppy slovenly shithole (and we love that)

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I enjoy Parks and Rec more with weed than booze.

6

u/PeterBanning May 21 '12

It's THORsday, let's get hammered!

2

u/extra_23 May 21 '12

aint that the truth. I missed the whole last season of Chuck because of college. stupid college...

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

...and Tuesday Night Ice. I can get pizza a dollar a slice.

16

u/CFGX May 20 '12

It's even harder sitting down early and having to deal with that horrid celebrity gossip shit as a lead-in.

1

u/peachgeek May 21 '12

ET = elbow tennis (?)

I had to see the end of Jeopardy last Thursday. It was Power Player Week, where political commentators competed. Awkward. I needed 2 hours of Lemon and Winger to wash my brain of it all.

1

u/1337and0 May 21 '12

Dr Phil for me. Ew

6

u/brokentoaster24 May 20 '12

Don't forget college students that work nights...

5

u/kralrick May 20 '12

Or regular people that work nights.

11

u/adolfojp May 20 '12

It's even worse where I live. They actually have popup ads on TV. And every once in a while they will shrink the size of your program to display and animated sidebar. And worst of all they will replace some commercials with local ones, but they don't always sync up with the TV show, so they make you miss parts of it. They only do this for high profile TV shows, but the experience gets so degraded that I just refuse to watch them on Cable.

21

u/Barbarossa6969 May 20 '12

Where the fuck do you live? Hell?

6

u/adolfojp May 20 '12

Pretty close, Puerto Rico. The cable provider is One Link. Here are some Yelp reviews.

The cable service insists on selling ad space during the actual shows (regardless of the fact that it might be a major network from the states) so, not only are they not satisfied with replacing American ads with local ones, they'll actually stick an ad during the freakin' show!!!

I don't use their services, but the ones that I use are only marginally better.

3

u/Barbarossa6969 May 20 '12

Wow... And I thought my small town provider was bad...

3

u/peachgeek May 21 '12

I was going to guess an Eastern Block country. But you're one of us. That's just wrong.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

This is the main reason why I don't watch TV anymore. My tv hasn't been on in a long while. Heck I don't even know why I bother keeping it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Plus I hate how t.v. always takes breaks for things like Superbowl or Oscars whatever. I can understand taking a break to film the next season; that's fine. I hate it, though, when programming is interrupted for stuff like sports or award shows. I mean, that's been unnecessary pretty much since VCR was introduced, definitely since TiVO was introduced, and these days it's just pointless.

1

u/thepupilindenial May 22 '12

I get this argument. I really do. Live TV is practically obsolete, and even if it wasn't, those Nielsen boxes can't possibly represent the entire country. I work for Nielsen, and I do get this.

But the problem is that everyone sees the ratings numbers and thinks, "that's what Nielsen does; they come up with these antiquated numbers, and that's how shows' fates are determined." Sure, that's a part of it.

But Nielsen absolutely tracks online traffic, especially where online commercials are concerned. I know, because it's part of my job. The ratings system is incredibly flawed, but instead of taking it out on Nielsen (not you, but the OP and many others), take it out on the networks.

Nielsen has a huge wealth of data -- who's watching shows, which devices they're using (smartphones, tablets, personal computers, DVR, etc.), whether they're paying attention, how old they are, where they live, etc. -- and advertisers pay for that data. Advertisers make a lot of decisions based on that data... more than they do using the arbitrary ratings scale.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I do.

591

u/Artifexx May 20 '12

Advertisers are streets behind.

34

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I work in a super hip agency and I'm the only one who watches Community. :(

3

u/pruwyben May 21 '12

Have they all had hip replacements?

61

u/designer_sunglasses May 20 '12

And to be fair, Community isn't an easy to advertise show in my opinion. If they show a preview on TV most people wouldn't get it or the appeal because they don't watch the show and obviously they can't advertise it as "Community: It's really great as soon as you get into it, granted you have to download the first seasons but everybody who watches it loves it."

The advertising for Community for me for example was just the foosball gif which is the single greatest thing in the history of everything.

98

u/IncidentOn57thStreet May 20 '12

I think that the advertisers in this sense is referring to the commercials in the commercial breaks - aka the source of the real money for NBC from Community. I might be wrong though.

You're right that Community is hard to advertise but I don't think that's the concern here.

39

u/Talman May 20 '12

You are correct. Advertising is what is paying for the television show. And if you're not watching at 8 PM on NBC, then you're not being shown the ads and the advertisers are wasting their money.

Hulu delivers so many ads just to pay catch up with the terrestrial broadcasts, because they (Universal/NBC) realized that people aren't following the formula that they thought viewers would, which is:

  1. Watch faithfully on NBC.

  2. If you happen to miss an episode, watch it on Hulu. Alternately, rewatch episodes on Hulu.

If you skip NBC all together and watch Hulu only, then... Well, you're "cheating" them out of their advertising revenue.

20

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I've seen plenty of ads for Battleship and Subway on my downloaded Community episodes over the last couple of weeks. There are ways to get ads through, even to the online audience.

→ More replies (14)

30

u/glorifiedfactchecker May 20 '12 edited May 21 '12

It really only matters if you have a nielsen box otherwise the advertisers won't count your view, so it's better to watch on Hulu as that is somewhat counted as something

19

u/knuxo May 20 '12

Sigh. The eternal Nielsen debate. It's an outdated system, but I have some friends who work for the Nielsen Company and they're adamant that the boxes really do represent an accurate sample.

23

u/jeremiahbarnes May 20 '12

But, who actually has a nielsen box here? I think it may be an accurate sample percentage wise, but not at all demographically.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (3)

8

u/Sniper620 May 20 '12

I've seen the foosball episode, I'm curious what the gif contains though. Do you have a link?

52

u/designer_sunglasses May 20 '12

10

u/Sniper620 May 20 '12

I could watch that for hours. Thanks!

8

u/jeremiahbarnes May 20 '12

I don't even know why it's so funny, it just is.

2

u/DiscoDonkey May 20 '12

It might be the anime part, for me it was the gif of Troy and the inflatable raft

20

u/eMan117 May 20 '12

not true, mention ken jeong and the young crowd goes "OMFG DUDE THATS THE GUY FROM THE HANGOVER LOL" show chevy chase and alot of interest would be garnered from all over. The show is about students, students are a very large market.

26

u/weezyjefferson May 20 '12

Yeah, but the people that would jump on for Ken or Chevy probably wouldn't stay for them. The show, at least at this point, is barely about "students." The show focuses more on TV Tropes, genre parodies and character development. If you're just tuning in, you probably wouldn't find it that funny. Hell, some of the most blatant jokes are so rapid fire that if you're thinking "I'm confused" for just a second, you'll probably miss them.

14

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I only jumped onto the community bandwagon for the second half of this season, but I found that I enjoyed pretty much everything. But then again, I AM a genius.

10

u/weezyjefferson May 20 '12

Haha. That's the thing, though: Since you post about things on the internet, you're not exactly the demographic that they need to advertise to.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/hulkman May 20 '12

i started watching community after i saw the library rap with troy and abed. i got my cousins hooked on it from that youtube video as well.

1

u/Gordondel May 21 '12

Funny, it's a simple trailer online (an official one, not fan made) that made me watch the show... I had never heard of it before...

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

the problem is extremely hard to solve because of the nature of control people have over digital content. right now i wouldn't even watch a show with limited commercials on hulu. they're already losing money on short advertisements. who is going to watch a show on a website if it lasts 30 minutes with 10mins worth of commercials? meanwhile you can mute and surf reddit while the commercials are on. so a lot of people pirate the show to avoid commercials.

→ More replies (4)

130

u/fhiz May 20 '12

Yeah, pretty much. Community is one of those victims of that grey period between the old and the new, where an old industry doesn't want to or know how to take advantage of a new technological market properly.

73

u/Bewbtube May 20 '12

As Neil Gaiman said, we're in a period of transition. Unfortunately, none of the movie studios or television networks want to change and even if they did, none of them would want to be the first to make a move. Optimistically, I feel like there's a lot of potential change riding on the success of Netflix's original programming. Realistically, I doubt their success will mean much, but I'd rather think optimistically.

Community just happens to be a show that was ahead of its time. I know it's not exactly the best parallel to draw, but I feel like Community is the Sega Dreamcast of television. I have little hope for season 4 of Community, but I enjoyed this show so immensely and while I feel like I've had the carpet ripped out from under me, I'm glad the show lasted as long as it did.

48

u/altergeeko May 20 '12

On Neil's Tumblr, he said he would have written an Inspector Spacetime skit if Karen Gillan (Amy Pond) was going to get on the show but since Dan Harmon isn't going to be on it anymore Neil is not going to do it.

I phrased this horribly.

http://neil-gaiman.tumblr.com/post/23349287653/dan-harmon-poops-hey-did-i-miss-anything

24

u/bajesus May 21 '12

OK, now I want to cry a little. The possibility of my favorite writer working with my favorite companion from my favorite show in a cross-over on my favorite comedy show was just obliterated. Darkest timeline indeed.

3

u/Bewbtube May 20 '12

Yeah :(. However, I kind of hoped Karen's offer also applied to the Inspector Spacetime project that was recently on Kickstarter.

10

u/fenwaygnome May 20 '12

Hulu's show "Battleground" was pretty good.

13

u/Bewbtube May 20 '12

Being good and being successful aren't the same thing, especially from a business perspective, and especially not from Hollywood's perspective. I don't know any of the numbers for Battleground and I've never seen it, so I can't comment on that. However, in order for the paradigm to shift the amount of success has to be massive. It has to be talked about every where.

If you need an exact example of what I'm talking about look no further than Joss Whedon. Buffy and Angel were great. Firefly was fantastic. Dollhouse was less than the previous three, but still good. These shows and Whedon himself have both critical acclaim and a loyal, vocal, cult fanbase. I mean a fanbase that's so strong they got Firefly a movie, Serenity (seeing the Community parallel I'm drawing here?). But for all of that, they weren't exactly network successes. Then Joss's Avengers did everything right. It was a critical success (it was GOOD) and more importantly (in Hollywood's eyes) it was a massive box office success. Now Whedon's name is on everyone's lips. Now he has more opportunities than any Whedon fan could have hoped for. This is the kind of success Netflix needs to really have the effect I hope it will.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/mirrth May 20 '12

i really enjoyed that show (Battleground). It took me about 3-4 episodes before i realized it was original content and not picked up from a major network. More shows of this quality please.

9

u/TheBakedPotato May 20 '12

I hope it has a Netflix rebirth like Arrested Development is soon to have. Netflix makes the most sense for the less broadly-appealing shows like Community which target a demographic not interested in watching TV as it's on live.

27

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Valve made the move first with steam.

It worked out pretty well.

26

u/Bewbtube May 20 '12

As much as I would love it to, the success of Valve and its Steam is in the video game industry and it does not translate very well to the film/television industries (at least not in their eyes). Of course it should, logically, but the networks and the studios aren't thinking or seeing logically. In fact, they're deluding themselves and trying to change the internet instead of making changes to themselves.

Edit: expanded my thoughts.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/deadpansnarker May 20 '12

That is one success story, there are plenty more stories of companies trying to make the first move and failing miserably

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Wait... Netflix is doing original programming!?

Well, I know who I'm sending my scripts to.

2

u/caitlinreid May 20 '12

Friday Night Lights is one I miss.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

The problem is not just that we're in a period of transition, but that the next era after this will (likely) involve many smaller companies each making less money than the behemoths that currently exist. It's easy to criticize the networks for not moving into the future, but you have to remember that doing so basically spells their death.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I don't want Netflix's original series to do well, because Netflix should be a neutral party, mediating the interests of content owners/producers and viewers. I'm worried that somehow Netflix Orginal Series will turn them to the dark side.

And this is coming from a huge Arrested Development fan.

25

u/directorguy May 20 '12

No. Community is a victim of being too smart for the room. Long before the file moving revolution network tv shows were getting canned over and over because the average person didn't get it.

Twight Zone couldn't compete, Orson Well's tv show was destroyed at birth, Star Trek never rated on CBS.

Good shows do not last on a national stage because the nation is looking for the median product, not the best product.

4

u/KennyEvil May 21 '12

After Star Trek got cancelled, the advertising department were furious. Even though it never rated too highly, amongst single men aged 18-35 it rated very highly, so they could actually sell the commercial time for a much higher price than anyone realised.

2

u/Kombat_Wombat May 20 '12

It might be inaccessible, but I wouldn't call Community's humor smart.

9

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

It's not intellectual, but the metahumor and self-awareness doesn't appeal to those who want to zone out in front of the television. You have to pay more attention to get that sort of humor.

11

u/sn1p3rb8 May 20 '12

It is when you compare it to similar shows on similar time slots such as BBT

→ More replies (2)

1

u/jmarquiso May 20 '12

Netflix all the way.

2

u/xDeda May 21 '12

This general form of consuming media all the way. If only I could pay monthly fees to get access to everything out there.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Networks are well aware of the new markets available to them and do track and keep up to date with their shows numbers when it comes to things like DVR viewings, online streaming, episode downloads, etc., etc.

However, most of the money they get comes from advertisers. Advertisers pay predominantly based on the 18-49 rating from the live airing.

So even when more people watch it in newer, non-traditional ways, the network isn't making as much money in the end.

Don't blame the networks, they do have to play nice with the advertising companies since the money they get from them does pay for the shows they air

37

u/mrpeabody208 May 20 '12

What we need is a Hulu that isn't owned by the old guard of network television. They accomplished a major feat by creating Hulu, but they don't trust its success and can't convince enough advertisers of its worth.

I can go on about what I think Internet TV needs to be successful, but I'm not the expert. So I petition Google to launch an Internet television network that produces its own content and buys other content. They're the undisputed champions of integrating advertisement and free Internet services. They're free of the constraints of conventional TV-think that prevent Hulu from monetizing their system better. They have the capital to start it. They have the servers to support it. The have the technical expertise to make it available on all potential platforms.

The fact that they haven't already jumped into this is what perplexes me. You know what I call the potential relationship between Google and television? No, not "codependent", a goldmine.

20

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

What we need is a Hulu that isn't owned by the old guard of network television.

The problem with a non-network Hulu is that the networks would change far more for the shows if they didn't own the service.

I posted here about it, but Hulu's profitability (even when it has multiple popular shows from multiple networks) is much lower than the profitability of even one single, mediocre (quality-wise) cable channel.

Meanwhile, Netflix lost $5 million last quarter (less than expected!) in part because of losing DVD customers, and in part because getting streaming content is expensive. It's lost most of its movies (from streaming) and while Hulu can make cheap deals with the people who own it, Netflix has to pay a lot -- it paid almost $20 million to stream one TV show... "LOST." And it will spend close to $2 billion to stream content in 2012, and lose money... a non-networks Hulu would be a great thing in many ways, but I can't see how it would survive. At least not anytime soon.

If the networks stop making money on expensive shows, they'll just stop making expensive shows. They already have been. If enough people don't watch scripted shows via cable/satellite, those shows will disappear. And nobody has figured out a way to generate enough revenue from online distribution alone to cover the cost of production as well as to turn a profit.

2

u/mrpeabody208 May 20 '12

That's an interesting aspect of the debate. You're probably as right as I am though. I'm sure there's a middle ground. I'm desperate to see an innovator emerge, so maybe that clouded a potentially damaging reality.

On the other hand, most shows are made by third-party production companies anyway. Dan Harmon didn't take Community to NBC. Sony acquired it and took it to NBC. I suppose it's about making deals with the producers of television more than anything. I honestly think it could work though. I'm not oblivious to the costs associated with producing a television show or the litany of contracts required to air what and when and where. I've made several posts on this sub explaining, for instance, why Netflix doesn't have Community, why Community doesn't air in Country X, and things of that ilk. I'll never claim expertise, but there's certainly a body of worthwhile content an emerging Hulu competitor can get for a reasonable price and a variety of new content that can get shown for a reasonable price.

We'll probably see most of this brought to bear in the next few years. It's a frustrating time to be a mostly (or totally) Internet-based viewer right now. I've defended Nielsen quite ardently as an accurate source of broadcast and cable viewership, but I still recognize the need for more TV to be online and for a new approach to monetizing Internet-based TV.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I'm sure there's a middle ground.

There might be... however, balancing profits with quality isn't possible with public companies. They have a fiduciary responsibility to their shareholders to maximize profits even if that means wall-to-wall reality TV (which is a sore subject for me, because I get my paycheck because of reality TV, but I prefer quality writing/acting in scripted series).

The two exceptions to this are not particularly likely or common. One is, a private company decides to stay private and produce entertainment. This requires a LOT of capitalization, and everyone on board has to want quality over maximizing profits. And they still are at the mercy of publicly traded companies (whether it's GE or Netflix).

The other exception is pretty rare, and that's when a person or property is so valuable to a company that they make exceptions. Such is the case with Christopher Nolan and "Inception." Warner Brothers did not expect "Inception" to do well; so imagine for a moment that it didn't make any money. That would have been OK with Warner Brothers because it was the price of keeping Nolan happy, to guarantee he'd do a third "Dark Knight" film. Internally it was considered a vanity project, sure to lose money. In fact it irritated some at Warner Bros. that it was so successful, but that's another story. In any case, these situations are exceedingly rare. Certain actors and directors can get quality films (or at least attempted quality films) made because they agree to the big-budget blockbuster sequels. Look at Steven Soderbergh/George Clooney for example... the "Oceans" series allowed them to get financing to make a lot of "little" movies... to keep them happy and on board with sequels.

But TV is even more difficult than movies in this regard.

23

u/Kinseyincanada May 20 '12

Advertisers are on Hulu all the time, it's just the market isn't on Hulu. Reddit lives in this bubble where they think everyone is on the bleeding edge of technology and no ones owns a tv

4

u/mrpeabody208 May 20 '12

Google exists with or without millions of people being on the "bleeding edge" of technology. There's a market there. I know plenty of people my age that don't know what the fuck a Hulu is, so consider your point made there. But there's a market, it is profitable, and it does have a built in audience. Google was suggested for a reason. Or are you saying emphatically that there is no market for Internet TV right now at all? Plenty of arguments against that, but I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt that you don't mean that.

3

u/Kinseyincanada May 20 '12

Of course there is a market right now, that's why Hulu exists. It's just that the market isn't large enough right now. Google absolutely is going to get into the tv market, google TV is just there first step.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/HagueHarry May 21 '12

What we need is a Hulu not just limited to the US.

1

u/happyscrappy Yam May 20 '12

The problem with Hulu isn't really Hulu, it's the owners of the content.

What you need is content that isn't owned by the old guard of network television.

And that's why Google hasn't jumped in, because the content providers own the content and call the shots. Google isn't free to innovate. Just look at what happened to Netflix.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/eMan117 May 20 '12

and sadly where it is offered for viewership online (legally), the stream is usually severely restricted to the US only.

9

u/[deleted] May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12

I own a TV. I even (gasp) pay for cable. I even pay for HD cable.

I still watch everything from hulu. I've got an HDMI cable going to my TV so I can just throw whatever I want up there.

It's absolutely about convenience. Money isn't the least of it.

3

u/boot20 May 20 '12

This is completely it. I have cable, I have a TV, I have a TiVo, and I use hulu. Why? I don't always have time to watch a show when it airs....so I watch it on my time.

I simply cannot dedicate a time slot to a specific TV show. It just doesn't happen. I travel to often and I am frequently working on odd hours....

I don't know why the old model has to be the way it is. It just doesn't make sense anymore.

1

u/happyscrappy Yam May 20 '12

So why don't you have a PVR? It's not inconvenient at all, you can watch the show any time you want after it first airs, same as streaming or torrents.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Why pay for a DVR when hulu is free?

→ More replies (5)

18

u/Kuma_Sanjuro May 20 '12

The only reason I ever got into Community was because I took a one month free trial of Hulu Plus. The real reason I bought a subscription is because of Community. And the other day I watched a Haagen Dazs ad maybe 3 or 5 times on Hulu and went out and bought two pints of ice cream and will be doing so again as it is a delicious comfort food for when your favorite show is taken into a back alley and raped and executed Indiana Jones 4 style.

3

u/wharpudding May 20 '12

I've gotten in a few new shows because of Hulu Plus. I watch Hulu FAR more often than I watch Netflix.

52

u/gambalore May 20 '12

Just a little bit of selection bias in that informal survey.

77

u/kevwaffles May 20 '12

I don't think anyone's claiming that it's representative of the entire market.

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted]

13

u/Kinseyincanada May 20 '12

How are randomly chosen people in markets not a representative statistic?

26

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Because they're not random.

→ More replies (12)

22

u/KnifeyJames May 20 '12

He's not saying "100% of college students watch Community!" What he's getting at is that a lot of viewers who fall right in the middle of the age group that advertisers want to reach aren't watching the show the traditional way, and some don't even have the option. TV is the new landline telephone -- fewer and fewer people under, let's say, 35 are using it because a new, better option has emerged.

4

u/jmarquiso May 20 '12

Subway reached them :)

→ More replies (3)

11

u/SKRules May 20 '12

The point still stands that there's a wide swath of viewers who are not being counted by traditional Nielsen ratings, yet do watch the show.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/sje46 May 20 '12

Well the point was wondering what percent of community fans watch it online. Doesn't matter if they all watch the show or only half did.

Certainly there's bias (there's always bias), but the fact that all of them watched it online heavily indicates that a similar result would be found with a formal poll.

3

u/hooplah May 20 '12

informal survey

2

u/verymuchn0 May 20 '12

My econometrics teacher would love you.

5

u/berlinbaer May 20 '12

i love the circlejerk post from yesterday so much...

also, outside of this little reddit bubble here, i am sure most people would still torrent the shit out of the show so they could watch it without ads.

5

u/Oneiricl May 20 '12

Or have no other way to watch it cos they don't live in the US.

5

u/wharpudding May 20 '12

I used to say that I'd never subscribe to Hulu because of the ads. But honestly, they were non-intrusive enough that I went ahead and subscribed.

I don't mind 2 or 3 30-second ads during a show. It's the commercial blocks that are 3-5 minutes each that make me start channel surfing.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Yeah, but.. live TV and Hulu are different things.

Why should we count Hulu viewing as well, when advertisers aren't paying for their ads to be on Hulu? They're paying for their ads to be on live TV. And they use Nielsen ratings to count how many people will see their ad?

32

u/theduderman May 20 '12

Yes and they continue to push relevant, poignant ads... like Internet Explorer with dubstep.

32

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I hate IE, but that ad is streets ahead

22

u/JonBenetRamZ May 20 '12 edited May 01 '17

deleted

→ More replies (2)

1

u/thieves_are_broken May 20 '12

The ads for the on demand season 2 finale were so off, that it still bothers me to these days. Specially because it was such a good episode. They have better ads for the season 3 ending but they added so much BS like a 3 minutes donna summers special, I am not exaggerating, how many community fans are worried about her?

3

u/theduderman May 20 '12

I joked about this when I saw the adult diapers commercial... but I was quickly corrected by a redditor that Chevy Chase does have a NUMBER of fans that watch Community.

6

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Correct me if I'm wrong, but if they advertise on Hulu, it's the site that gets paid not the tv network.

2

u/amarine88 May 20 '12

I mean the tv network gets something. They wouldn't be doing that for free to let Hulu make profit. At least I can't imagine them doing that.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I was thinking Hulu buys rights of the show to stream it online. Then it acts as middle man between advertisers and the network. They profit but with a cut. And I think it would be complicated to get the actual numbers since people don't watch at the same time.

Not as much as they could generate with tv ads.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Shorties May 20 '12

Hulu ads are on demand ads, they are paid for, and can be guarenteed on a per user basis. On air advertising is very expensive, and that's what is based off the ratings. So the live on air viewers are what matter the most because they have to sell that advertising. it's not neilson that is broken, it's the entire TV industry.

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted]

2

u/_oogle May 20 '12

..and Hulu pays the networks maybe a fraction of what TV advertisers do. Nielsen ultimately isn't the problem, because it measures what is the most important/relevant: TV viewership. I'm sure Nielsen's statistical sampling could be better, but that is applicable to ALL shows.

4

u/Kinseyincanada May 20 '12

They have ads on Hulu, they are sold at different rates then tv

2

u/caitlinreid May 20 '12

Thank you. It's retarded to put different ads on the internet when they could stream the damn show with commercials and all and count the views accurately to boot.

15

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I think perhaps that Community has been a casualty of being too ahead of its time. I think that this is best demonstrated by its use of Twitter isn various ways to drum up support for the show (the live tweeting of Annie's move was frankly genius). Clearly it has a big fan base, but we all watch on-line, something TV networks haven't seemed to realised yet. Hopefully, once Networks become more aware about the potential of having an internet (fan) based show, more shows will get a better shot without having to get so many millions of viewers every week. Community really was ahead of its time in the way it generated support and fostered a dedicated fan base, yet also seems to have been a victim of its own uniqueness. Hopefully where Community has led, other great shows will follow. #sixseasonsandamovie

9

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Hopefully, once Networks become more aware about the potential of having an internet (fan) based show, more shows will get a better shot

There's a potential for popularity, but the vast majority of people who watch TV still use cable/satellite. More importantly, shows cost a lot of money to produce, and networks haven't found a way to monetize shows online... they've tried (sometimes kicking and screaming) but they haven't found a way.

Here's a comparison that shows the apples and oranges problem. Hulu "broadcasts" many expensive-to-make shows from multiple networks (many of them good shows). SyFy broadcasts many VERY cheap-to-make shows. SyFy profits are now more than a half-billion dollars a year, while Hulu--a service that covers many hit shows from many networks--profits less than a quarter of that -- and a lot of people don't think it's even that high.

Networks look at SyFy and say "all this crap [if they think it's crap" nets a half-billion dollars on satellite/cable. Whereas all these hit, popular, magazine-cover shows are on Hulu... shows that it gets cheaper than the networks... and its profits are maybe 35% of $200 million (2010 numbers; maybe it's gotten better).

(And the problem with a non-network Hulu is that the networks would change far more for the shows if they didn't own the service.)

People have been trying since the late 1990s to create profitable, original "television" shows for the Internet, with barely any success and a lot of failure (anyone remember DEN or IceBox?) and for the most part what's happened is that the actual television networks themselves have been broadcasting less and less original content, as it's more expensive than reality TV, and it's harder to compete with all the entertainment choices people have.

1

u/peachgeek May 21 '12

As someone else pointed out here, Hulu's original show Battleground is pretty awesome. First season just completed, so you can watch entire season for free (start at beginning; it has an arc). Look forward to seeing numbers from it. Would like to know how it was funded.

4

u/djhworld May 20 '12

It's the same for people abroad like me, we can only get Community through some obscure Sony TV channel that I think is only available to people who subscribe to cable/satellite.

Also when I was at university (college) I pretty much watched all of my favourite shows via the internet.

Mainly because it's easier and more convenient, especially when your body clock is abnormal.

4

u/JustGotSmashed May 20 '12

I watch this show from Asia and I absolutely love it. It's funny how I understand the american parodies and satire!

Anyway, the main problem I have is the time it takes for the show to be uploaded, because generally when it is uploaded, the site that it was uploaded on takes it down immediately and I have to wait another day or two to watch it. Also since my internet is slow, my choice of sites I can watch it on is limited.

Like south park, it would be fantastic if Community could be broadcast on it's own website.

4

u/king_bestestes May 20 '12

The industry needs to emulate what Steam did for video games. No one buys a 'product' anymore, since we can get it for free. They need to sell a service.

Sure, I could pirate my video games, but Steam makes it really convenient to find my friends online, plus they support a community that gives recommendations, etc etc.

Netflix is getting there, but there's a lot more that can be done.

1

u/Kinseyincanada May 20 '12

Like iTunes or the many other ways to buy a tv show after it airs?

4

u/bootsmegamix May 20 '12

The same can be said of time slot viewers but advertisers are decades streets behind.

Fixed

4

u/Funkydunkie May 20 '12

I've watched every Community episode and I have no idea what channel it airs on here in the UK.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Sony Channel. Good luck finding it...I cant!

3

u/rospaya May 20 '12

Being a dirty foreigner, I don't know anyone who watches Community on thursdays. If it did air in my country, I would make a Community party every week, watch an episode, drink some beer... this way everybody watches it ten minutes after it airs.

3

u/Darth_Hobbes May 20 '12

pssst...guys....don't let the advertisers hear, but I just play plants vs zombies during commercials.

1

u/alwayspro May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

!!!!!! TO GET INVOLVED AND FURTHER INFORMATION: !!!!!!!!

SEE: http://www.notnielsen.com

SUBSCRIBE TO THE SUBREDDIT: http://www.reddit.com/r/notnielsen

MOST IMPORTANTLY POST A VIDEO: http://www.notnielsen.com/submit

SHARE ABOUT THE CAMPAIGN WITH FRIENDS: http://twitter.com/notnielsen | http://www.facebook.com/pages/Not-Nielsen/129039383898727

USE THE HASHTAG: #notnielsen

Thank you kindly.

(Also, I am not the launcher of this campaign just try to give a leg up.)

If anyone knows email address to send http://www.notnielsen.com too for press or anything else you can do to help spread the word, contact peachgeek

Cheers!

1

u/markh110 May 21 '12

Just a question: Where's the source on this? I want to quote this for an article I'm writing for a news publication, but I'm concerned about the lack of credibility this carries...

1

u/alwayspro May 21 '12

I'd suggest contacting peachgeek on reddit or using the links above to get in contact, as I am not involved beyond posting this thread. Hopefully it can be sourced somehow.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/runswithpaper May 20 '12

Sounds about right, out of about 20 people I know who watch it not a single one does so on an actual TV. (not counting people who are streaming it to their living room TV)

Heck I don't actually know anyone that has cable TV anymore, but this is Seattle so...

8

u/mayabuttreeks May 20 '12

I know a number of people who, over the past few months, have gone from watching "Community" exclusively through online sources to watching the show on Thursdays at 8pm. Not because they wanted to, or because it was convenient for them, but because they were desperate for the show to be renewed and believed that watching Thursday nights was the only way their views "counted" towards that magic Nielsen rating number.

Leaving aside the fact that a 1/2 hr sitcom which inspires viewers to alter their habits that much is fairly remarkable, that these people had to switch their life around to accommodate the Big Networks shows exactly how ridiculously shitty the current methods of data collection are -- if your method of data collection leaves out giant chunks of the population, or requires people to substantially change their habits, it's at best laughably inaccurate and at worst completely vulnerable to 'gaming the system'.

The reason the networks/Nielsen still measure stuff they way they do has a lot to do with the fact that that they are still receiving revenue from advertisers despite their inaccurate numbers. If advertisers started to realize that the "researchers" to whom they pay millions of dollars are doing no better job than a blindfolded dude chucking darts at a stats chart, I'm sure there'd be more pressure to create a better system of measurement.

12

u/Talman May 20 '12

There's only one problem. Without a Nielsen ratings box, they don't count.

1

u/Kinseyincanada May 20 '12

How is it inaccurate? Both online and "live" tv ratings are tracked. They are sold at different rate because online viewing is vastly smaller.

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

[deleted]

1

u/uninvisible May 21 '12

fuck. i was one of those people.

4

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Uh... source?

2

u/brownmatt May 20 '12

To be fair college students aren't exactly representative of the rest of the population.

5

u/onemoredrink May 20 '12

But marketing wise college students/ people in their 20s are an often targeted demographic because they're seen as tastemakers. I know this is an extreme example but just think of Facebook, it started with college students and spread to the extent that there are now people's grandmas on there.

3

u/Hogan_Ear_O May 20 '12

To be even fairer, Community viewers aren't exactly representative of the rest of the population.

Given a choice between playing a video game or watching television, I will choose the game, as I prefer interactive entertainment. When I do watch TV, it's rarely on an actual TV set, and it has to be good. Community, Parks and Rec, Game of Thrones.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

No shit. I've been saying it for some time on this sub, no one watches TV anymore and it baffles me that some of you still turn on your 1980s box t tune into the show.

2

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I wish networks would just hire so called "pirates" to distribute their content WITH COMMERCIALS, because they are the ones doing it most efficiently already.

2

u/BandBoots May 20 '12

I just want to note that if this is to succeed, you'll need more minds than are currently present on that subreddit. x-post to places like /r/geek. Also, the name 'Abed's Algorithm' isn't the best if you want this to be serious. No that the name is ridiculous or anything, but it isolates Community viewers.

1

u/Knows_where_waldo_is May 20 '12

Also /r/cordcutters might appreciate and support.

1

u/peachgeek May 23 '12

Thanks -- still new to this -- how do I x-post? I looked for info on it. Can I cross post if I didn't originate the post, but mod the subreddit? Both look like good places to post to -- thanks.

2

u/steinman17 May 20 '12

I'd gladly watch commercials if it meant i could download the show the next day in 1080

2

u/hhmmmm May 20 '12

“you can’t guarantee those people watched a Colgate ad”.

The idea that people don't go make a cup of tea, turn off/over or just mute ads on real tv is stupid.

With the potential for ads online with the right platform you could make sure they actually had the ad on and playing full screen before moving onto the next part of the show.

2

u/deathsquaddesign May 21 '12

TV watching is evolving, the industry is not.

3

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

This is just further proof that Nielson ratings are a terrible measure of a show's popularity. If the number of people who watch the show online could be taken into account, I think the network would see that Community is ALOT more popular than the ratings seem to indicate.

17

u/gambalore May 20 '12

It may be a poor measure of a show's overall popularity, but it's still a relatively good measure of the popularity of a show among the people that watch the commercials that pay for the show.

1

u/eMan117 May 20 '12

which is why networks should have sites that stream these shows with those ads for all to see (including those outside of US)

3

u/monoglot May 20 '12

How many advertisers are willing to pay for worldwide commercials? There's no point in paying to advertise in Estonia or New Zealand if you don't sell your products there.

2

u/Kinseyincanada May 20 '12

They do

4

u/eMan117 May 20 '12

including those outside of US**

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/directorguy May 20 '12

The point is to sell adds, not make a popular show

2

u/pregnantandsober May 20 '12

How do you sell ad slots for unpopular shows?

3

u/gambalore May 20 '12

Cheaply.

3

u/directorguy May 20 '12

ad slots are determined by ratings and demographics. Unpopular shows could be sell able if they rate. The PAX network was founded on this principle back in the 90s

The more disposable income the better, ads can also be sold to bolster image (ie. golf sponsorship .. not a lot of viewers, but a lot of prestige and image bolstering)

If 50 million people watch community it only matters if they are both rated and sell able. College kids who torrent/file share/online view don't count. They don't watch the ads that are on television and aren't rated.

Popularity doesn't matter, who watches the broadcast commercials does.

It's a game; regardless of reality, the game is what makes the money.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I never said otherwise. But considering how more and more people are watching tv online now, this seems like an antiquated business model for the networks.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

1

u/Kinseyincanada May 20 '12

Nielsen ratings are used to measure a shows popularity on tv because that's how ads are sold. Online viewership are tracked by Nielsen and sold at different rates because less people watch online

2

u/Delta_Blues May 20 '12

I also do not own a TV and watch all my shows on Hulu/Netflix. Unless it's a sports game I can't stand to watch TV. So many ads, you can't rewind or pause it, if your schedule isn't clear you missed it. I had a TV for a while but I realized I only watch Hulu/Netflix anyways and when I watch sports I usually do it at a friends hous or at a bar. I sold my TV and got enough $$$ to afford 15 years worth of Netflix and Hulu Plus.

1

u/trippysmurf May 20 '12

Does anyone else DVR it?

I start recording at 8, but also start cooking dinner and possibly doing something else, and by the time I'm done I can watch all my shows and just fast forward through the commercials (unless I want to get another drink/snack, then I let the commercials play until I get back and fast forward them again.)

1

u/pan0ramic May 20 '12

It doesn't matter who watches a show, it matters when a show is watched. Gillian said in her AMA that watching the show during it's regular air time is what really matters for show revenue. Unfortunately, broadcast companies haven't figured out how to monetize shows in other formats - their principle revenue stream come from commercials.

So it doesn't matter how many people watch and love a show, all that matters is how many people watch the show during it's broadcast spot.

How else can you explain shows like "two and a half men" being the "most popular sitcom".

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

I watch it on Hulu, comes out the next day. I just have to find a way to avoid Reddit for 24 hours

1

u/kbjay May 20 '12

I bought a season pass

1

u/BeefPieSoup May 20 '12

I'm pretty sure its no longer aired in my country. What's your excuse?

1

u/Clayburn May 20 '12

Why don't people own televisions?

1

u/nx_2000 May 20 '12

College dorms aren't represented by people meters anyway.

1

u/StuffLikeThisAccount May 20 '12

I watch it at 8pm at it's initial broadcast, via the interwebs. It's the only show on television I want to see the moment it's broadcast.

1

u/Vectoor May 20 '12

Pretty much, I don't even have a tv.

1

u/orion846 May 21 '12

do you guys just not play consoles too? i dont get the 36 out of 40 without a tv

1

u/GreenJesus423 May 21 '12

TIL Community is an actual TV show.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I don't even know what days/ times the tv shows I watch are aired.

1

u/oRyan_the_Hunter May 21 '12

Haha stupid advertisers!

1

u/Millennion May 21 '12

Once again piracy saves the day...oh wait!

1

u/BadIdeaSociety May 21 '12

Unfortunately, if Hulu Plus is your only Community-watching option, so much the better for NBC, but downloading the show illegally is more convenient than Hulu or live TV.

1

u/peachgeek May 21 '12

SOURCE & CORRECTION Thanks to everybody who jumped in on this, particularly alwaypro who posted the quote. Still new to Reddit so I'm floored. Thanks.

This is from the About page which I wrote a month ago from memory. Knew I'd have to dig the original out of my FB timeline (would it kill them to add search?!) and just didn't before launch. Forgive the error.

CORRECTION: It was 30 kids not 40. Source: TV Guide Fan favorite Cover reveal

Appreciate those who've gotten in touch -- you can ask questions through the site but if you need an email address it's just info @ ... [edit: format]

Please post videos! Just 12 seconds or so. Thanks, y'all!

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I saw commercials for community before it started airing, said, oh, chevy chase maybe that'll be interesting. Never heard about it again. D/L and up to date with it now as of like 2 months ago? Absolutely love the show - someone the other day circa 8 on Thursday asked if I was watching I said "oh, it airs at 8? no wonder I never catch it on tv" ... and that's the fucking problem with television. I HAVE A 42 INCH TV NEXT TO MY MONITOR I HAVE NBC I PAY FOR CABLE but I download the show anyway so I can watch it at my convenience in the same quality on the same tv... without commercials...

1

u/startselect3 Jul 31 '12

I watch it on Hulu Plus, am I the only one?

1

u/Tigeroovy May 21 '12

Seriously, take down the fucking region blocking of websites, air the episodes on the website, track the fucking numbers, put any damn ads you want to at the appropriate break points that you can't skip past, I'll watch it there EVERY DAMN WEEK!

Advertisers can still advertise their crap as much as they do now, just move it to the Internet, is it really that hard?

Numerous websites already play ads with their streaming shows, and I KNOW they track visitors and usage. ADAPT!

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I will even watch it again and again, sitting through ads again and again. While the tv episode airs...once.

1

u/Tigeroovy May 21 '12

Exactly. I tend to watch the new episodes several times through the week anyways.