The (CivClassics) Civ Mercantile Exchange is a commodity exchange that buys and sell commodities at different prices. This enables players to trade asynchronously and semi-anonymously. It also enables price discovery of the goods traded, since anyone can buy items they think are undervalued or sell items they think are overvalued. The result is a shop that is always stocked with fair prices.
In the post, I want to share some thoughts on what I thought went well and what didn't go well. I apologize in advance for the length, but I wanted to cover everything I ever considered so that anyone looking to expand on the concept can get a boost.
Value creation
The CME seems to have created a lot of value. It's hard to collect metrics on a civ server so I can't offer quantities. But people referenced the prices when making economics decisions, and it basically ended questions over what the diamond-iron exchange rate.
Many people also bought and sold from the exchange which implies they thought they were getting a deal, and meant that they were able to trades they otherwise could not have done.
I also spent some time every weekend for several weeks documenting the price of every good I was trading, which I posted to /r/CivCME. I don't know how valuable that actually was, but I think there is obviously value in a regular update on prices. Over time, this lets people see how prices are trending, and for people who are are distant from the exchange, it lets them see what market prices are at all.
One area I think I could have done better in was providing liquidity. By week 6, I was offering 21 different items, but I didn't have much to trade of any of them except arguably diamonds. (My original mission with the CME was to eliminate price checks for every item.) I think my effort would have been better spent reinvesting profits into a smaller set of say 5 items, but in larger quantities. Probably the most valuable people to attract are the power players, but they are only interested in trading if they can trade large quantities at a time. Additionally, people are only willing to travel if they can trade large quantities at a time.
(In fact, I think it would be interesting if we saw more specialized shops on the server that single single items in massive quantities. For example, a copy of the CME, but the only item it trades is sand. And it has a huge number of stacks of sand to trade, so that anyone interested in buying or selling sand knows there is one place they can go to get all the sand they'd need for months, and that that that place would be worth a 15 minute trip to.)
Another area I could have possibly done better is in encouraging people to set up chests with me. I had originally intended for anyone to be able to set up chests in the CME, and invited people to do so. The idea is that it would be easier to build up liquidity if multiple people were stocking chests. That would make it more valuable to traders, and so we'd all profit. Nobody took me up on the offer. I'm not sure why people were disinterested, but my main guess is that people just found other things more interesting rather than the idea being bad.
Value capture
I think I did a poor job capturing value.
The CME made money by capturing a spread on the goods it traded. A chest might buy diamonds at 10i and sell them for 11i. So every time we connected a buyer and seller, we'd make 1 iron.
This is great, because it requires no labor besides the initial set up to build wealth. It's one of the few, if only ways, you can invest wealth.
The problem is that the spread is sometimes too large for people to want to trade. Maybe someone would be interested in selling only to the CME only for 10.25i instead of 10i, or buying only for 10.75i instead of 11i. I made an effort to account this by selling 4 diamonds at time, offering 4 diamonds -> 41i or 43i -> 4 diamonds. However, by doing this I decreased the spread to 0.5i, which how much value I capture when I connect a buyer and a seller, and decreases the rate of return on capital.
Also, often times if someone thought 1 diamond was worth buying at 10i, they thought all diamonds were worth buying at 10i. That mean the CME often had a spread of 2i rather than one-- you had 11i -> 1 diamond or 1 diamond -> 9i, rather than 10i -> 1 diamond or 1 diamond -> 9 diamond.
In retrospect, I think the mistakes is that I was capturing value in an arbitrary way, rather than capturing based on the value I created.
If I were to do it again, I would do the following:
Buy and sell all goods in a "CME Token" which only I can produce
Sell CME tokens for iron, and charge a fee. e.g. Sell 98 tokens for 100 iron. And buy CME tokens 1 iron for 1 token.
This enables me to capture 2% of all volume that goes through the exchange.
One advantage of this is that this makes it easy to measure how much profit the exchange is generating. That in turn would make it easier to attract investors if I ever wanted to grow it.
One issue with this pricing structure is that someone could never redeem their CME tokens for iron and just use it to trade without fees. While possible, I don't think it's a serious issue since the only people who would do this would be people who actively traded on the exchange, and those people are creating value though by updating prices to reflect the best possible information.
A second issue with this pricing structure is that it makes it harder to open up the CME to people who might want to set up their own chests, since they would have to use CME tokens, but don't get a share of the profits. They would need to profit by using spreads, but I already showed that's not useful. This might be less of an issue if this other person was a large shareholder.
A third issue is that printing out enough tokens to make this work is extremely tedious. Once I realized that this was a better way to price things, I still put it off because sourcing enough paper to print all the tokens takes a long time, and then I have to update all the chests anyway.
One point to think about: you could combine spreads with this fee structure, or you can not. The two have advantages and disadvantages. If you remove spreads, the prices in the shop will be more fair and closer to the market value, since each chest would exchanges like: 10i -> 1X or 1X -> 10i. That means people can reverse trades if they regret their decision and would probably increase volume. If you keep spreads, you'd make slightly more profit, and you can also see which particular chests and prices are generating the most value by counting the profit in each chest. It's unclear to me which of the two is better.
Finally, there was an opportunity to monetize information about the prices on the exchange by selling books in-game containing the data. /u/Higgenbottoms published a weekly "MTA Price Guide" which actually sold pretty well proving the concept.
Security
The CME has been running for 5 months. In that time, the shop never lost any items or had any break-ins. A person tried to acid block the snitches once, but I was able to remove the acid blocks before any damage was done.
This can be partly attributed to the server doing a good job policing itself and removing the most dangerous players before I set up shop. So thanks everyone who took down Lexington!
I think this can be partly attributed to the design of the shop though. I calculated how much value per hour a person could generate diamond mining, and made sure the time spent cracking the chests was well below that value. If my calculation said a person could generate 100 diamonds per hours diamond mining, I aimed to reward an attacker with only 50 diamonds if they spent an hour cracking my shop. Unless someone had a personal vendetta against me specifically, they would be spending their time better elsewhere. (The downside to this is that it consumed a lot of diamonds in reinforcements. But there is no more secure approach than this.)
Marketing
Getting information out about the CME was important because it's a little confusing how it works, and people didn't always know it existed.
The location was less than ideal. I built the CME above a mall in the center of the city. The idea was that it would be convenient to travel to and easy to discover. I had talked with several other people when trying to select a location, but either they were unwilling to make a deal, or the location they could offer was worse than offer to build above the mall.
I also worked with Gobblin, an architect in the Maesters' Alliance, to design the structure to be made of glass so people could see that there were many chests inside, and to have the outside labeled with the letters "CME".
I also tried marketing the CME through the Weekly Updates, which I crossposted from /r/civCME into /r/civclassics.
Many people failed to discover the CME despite this effort. Shops on the ground floor of the mall selling the same items at worse prices got more traffic than the CME at times. Some people even complained they had checked all the shops in the city for items I sold and failed to find them, which meant even interested people were missing it.
I'm not certain how I could have done better given the circumstances, but if I had a second chance I might have pushed harder to have integrated it with the rail station or factory building.
Architecture
I had three goals for the physical building of the CME:
It needs to be vertically repeatable (in case I filled up the building and needed more space)
It should be reasonable secure. Most of the security comes from the chests, but it should also have a place to securely keep snitches.
It should use affordable and easy-to-gather building materials. (Especially if we need to vertically scale.)
Gobblin, of the Maester's Alliance, helped me construct the current iteration which accomplished all of these goals. The final design is here.
Gobblin also did a good job using the outside walls to advertise the CME, and making the walls out of glass so that players could see there were chests inside to interact with. I really was impressed! (Also shoutout to DarkJesus who built the first iteration with a cool Etherium-influenced design.)
Fun creation
Had I completely succeeded, I think the CME would have made the server a lot more fun, at least for some players.
Hauling
Most people know the CME in MTA, but there is actually a smaller diamond-iron + XP-iron exchange in the heart of Yoahtl as well.
I didn't succeed here, but if the two exchanges had enough liquidity, it would have enabled people to earn wealth by moving goods between the two whenever the prices for a good diverged.
For example, the cheapest source of wool was sold by a player in Yoahtl. Nobody sold wool in MTA though. So if the CME traded wool in both cities, then whenever wool became more expensive in MTA than it was in Yoahtl, someone could go to Yoahtl, buy a bunch of wool, and resell it for a higher price in MTA.
This only works though if the expected profit is greater than or equal to the profit someone would have gotten by spending that time mining for diamonds. And it's only possible for someone to make that amount of profit if there is a massive amount of wool they can buy cheap in Yoahtl and sell high in MTA.
I think this would have been tremendous fun if it ever became possible. But the amount of resources required to make this work is enormous. It might become possible if the server population grows, and if it's possible to take out a loan. Alternatively, if cities saw the value in building exchanges, they might be able to raise money from their citizens.
Short selling
Assuming the CME had massive liquidity and that it were possible to take out loans, we could also see short selling emerge. If you think the price of diamonds will decrease you can borrow a bunch of diamonds and buy iron, and then when the price drops, buy back the diamonds with some extra profit.
Front-running
If someone announces they are building a vault, you know they will need large quantities of diamonds. You could buy them before they do for a cheap price. Then if they buy enough to drive the price up, you can sell the diamonds you bought at a higher price and make a profit.
History
The CME originally started out as a a diamond exchange underneath a general store I built the city of Aquila in Devoted 2.0. When I realized what I had built, I expanded it into an "ore exchange" trading every type of ore. The idea worked, but I only used rows of 5 chests at most, and did not have much stock. (There were also inklings of the idea back in Civ 3.0 which preceded Devoted. I had tried to establish a log/coal trade route between a city that had a lot of coal and a city that had a log of wood by using chests that both bought and sold the same item.)
When CivClassics came out, I repeated the idea and constructed an exchange in Commonwealth next to their factory building, but expanded the length of the exchange to use some ~20 chests instead of 5. That ensured that the price always stayed within bounds, so the exchange would always be buying and selling at useful market prices. (Sometimes if someone buys out all of an item, then people can only sell which is no good.) During the Western Alliance - Lexington war, I stopped playing for a while. When I came back, many players in Commonwealth had left or relocated out of the city where I had built the exchange. MTA was the new most active city on the server, so I rebuilt the exchange there with the help of Romec, who owned the mall.