r/BuddhistSocialism • • Sep 07 '22

One cannot both be a capitalist and a buddhist

Thumbnail self.buddhism
30 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Jan 21 '22

Thich Nhat Hanh, Zen Master and Political Reformer, Dies at 95

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
25 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Jan 22 '22

A Buddhist Anarcho-Pacifist Flag

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Dec 07 '19

How Mindfulness Morphed from Ancient Spiritual Practice to Big Business

Thumbnail
jacobinmag.com
17 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Mar 01 '22

Stumbled onto this buddhist poet and activist. Has anyone read this book or any works about Han Yongun and found it beneficial before I seek it out?

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Sep 20 '21

I really feel a connection to having both Buddhist and Leftist thought in my life and I would love to see a more active sub since I know people have some great thinking to contribute. I don’t know reddit very well other than simply posting, any thoughts on how to make this sub more popular?

12 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Nov 26 '20

New Buddhist, And Fellow Comrade

12 Upvotes

Hello, I am happy I found this server. As a Buddhist, it has been hard to find people who follow the same political Ideology as me and uphold the Dharma. I hope to learn from all of you since I've been a Socialist for a year and a Buddhist for even less. Nice to meet you all and may you all find enlightenment and inner peace.


r/BuddhistSocialism • • Sep 11 '17

Read Buddha, not the Buddhists

Thumbnail
buddhistmarxism.wordpress.com
12 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • May 08 '22

Awakening Through Audre Lorde

Thumbnail
lionsroar.com
11 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Jul 09 '21

Uchiyama Gudō: Buddhist Anarchist Martyr

Thumbnail
noselvesnomasters.wordpress.com
11 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Oct 13 '20

Best works on Buddhist socialism (including anarchism, if there are any)? I’m interested early works as well as modern. Thanks!

11 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Jan 26 '20

Extinction Rebellion Buddhists

Thumbnail
facebook.com
11 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Aug 11 '21

An Anarchist History of Buddhism 1800-1920 C.E.

Thumbnail
noselvesnomasters.wordpress.com
10 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Jan 01 '20

I Vow Not to Burn Out

Thumbnail
lionsroar.com
10 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Jan 11 '23

Slouching Toward Gautama: Towards a Buddhist Politics of Freedom - Zach Dorfman (2011)

Thumbnail
theanarchistlibrary.org
9 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Dec 14 '21

Lin Qiu Wu, Marxist revolutionary and Taiwanese Chan monk

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Jan 28 '20

Seeking enlightened response to Dan Harmon's anti-nazi speech

9 Upvotes

The video in question is here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9VN9206cXI0

Knowledge clearly demands that we act vigorously to prevent a nazi uprising.

I find rhetoric like in the video really challenges my commitment to, and understanding of, ahimsa -- not least of all because I find his directness refreshing.

Hearing it, I find myself thinking, "well, there is that one sutta where the Buddha tells the king that kingdoms need armed forces", and "I wonder if killing nazis to prevent another holocaust is justified", and "what did the Buddha say about war" ....etc, etc. I'm sure many can relate.

But I find such thoughts to be unskillful. Upon deeper reflection, I find I don't agree with Dan's "solution". Instead, I remind myself that the fire can't burn without fuel, and the war machine can't run without our participation.

I'm interested to hear other people's reflections on this topic.


r/BuddhistSocialism • • Jan 19 '20

Chris Hedges w/ Ron Purcer on "McMindfulness" (new book)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Jan 26 '16

How do you reconcile the Buddhist message of nonviolence with the necessity of armed struggle?

9 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Sep 03 '18

My disillusion with Shambhala (Vajrayana Buddhism)

8 Upvotes

First I want to thank /u/mettaforall's post, it kind of inspired me to post this.

I've been a member of Shambbhala for the past 3 years and a student of the dharma for longer. It was the first serious Buddhist community I was ever a part of, mostly because it knew how make itself appealing to curious westerners. It met them where they were, slowly planting the seeds of their ideas, and wouldn't dare say something like "All life is suffering" until you signed up for around your 2nd or 3rd program. It presented itself as a place to practice and learn mindfulness but would slowly slip in their metaphors to explain so. Your mind is like a horse, and mindfulness is like training it with love and compassion. You aspire to be brave in confronting the things that you are scared of, like a warrior. And when you are ready, you and your horse will battle against all of the awful things in the world, on behalf of the kingdom of Shambhala, or an enlightened society.

The military/state metaphors that Shambhala lives and dies by I've always had a mixed relationship with as a leftist, I was never really won over by their slogan "Victory Over War" or the way they valued hierarchy as a core part of their philosophy. After all, what does a warrior do but take orders from someone who knows better than them? But as a leftist, I have to admit that most of my comrades seemed uninterested in discipline as a value to live by, and many things of their lives seem to me to be undisciplined: the way they spend their time, what they say, how they dress, their living spaces, what they ingest. For a while my Shambhala Buddhism would correct those tendencies for me and my Post-Marxism and my Buddhism didn't seem to contradict each other too much. Until those papers came out with many women's stories of sexual abuse.

If you go to a Shambhala Center, which I recommend you do, I suggest you hear their take on buddha-nature, which they call "Basic Goodness" or bodhichitta. As the story goes, everyone is basically good or enlightened; even the most hardest of thugs will help other people under certain situations. Their mirror has dirt on it, they just need to wipe the dirt off their mirror and they'll become more compassionate and shine like any other person. So they posit that humans are good & enlightened at their core but forming an ego in the early stages of life encourages defensiveness and amputates compassion. So non-dualness = basic goodness. With my Bachelors in Anthropology that taught me to problematize anything natural, that seemed too simple for me, but at times I could believe it because of its claim to nondualism. But I can't after the abuses.

If you're a serious student of Buddhism, you know that everything is empty, and you know that that means that there's no particular way that anything is supposed to be. That's another way of saying that everything is non-dual. Shambhala tried hard to declare that non-dual living was synonymous with good for others, but as the abuses show, from the perspective of non-dual living there is no vantage point to declare what is a good or a bad act. It's beyond concept. So Sakyong Mipham will rape you if he thinks it will help you break out of your ego.

I think I believe it when Sakyong Mipham does awful things he's acting from a place of non-dualism but I don't think the same can't be said for his followers, who warp around him and form a barrier against anything that's a smear against him. This is just another limitation, another thing to cling to. Sakyong Mipham would like you to melt the hard barrier ego that surrounds your heart, take that hardness and cast it again into a barrier around his name and legacy. But as Linji and the Zen people say, "If you see the Buddha on the road, kill him!" Don't look for a savior. Don't cling for a hero. That's just another thing that if it goes bottoms up, you'll get hurt by. Even one of the Lojong slogans is "Regard all dharmas as dreams." Yeah, I've got one dharma I'd like to wake up from.

The followers fell into a cult. There's no shame in that, everything's a cult. Consumerism is a cult. The economy's a cult. The cult is how we organize ourselves. They just thought that they weren't in one. They might have thought that the US economy and capitalism was a cult but they finally found the place that wasn't one. Bad move. In day-to-day life what's considered acts of compassion and what's considered acts of aggression play out according to power dynamics best explained by non-dual critical theory like Foucault, Nietzsche and Deleuze.

In conclusion: basic goodness is what people say basic goodness is. You can't take a hierarchical society at their word that they know what good is. And even though I've talked to Shambhala instructors who say that Shambhala teachers have abused their power and that abuse of power is NOT basic goodness, I have to question them because 1, when exactly did it not become basic goodness? Was it basic goodness when everyone was in the dark about it? And 2, Shambhala has been too blind to the social for me to trust an opinion like that, though obviously I'm still bothered by all of this. The teacher I've talked to seem to be sorry about this and not sorry about it at the same time, like they're saying "Sorry you're hurt, but I'm not sorry that happened to you."

For me, I think the only real solution has to be a Buddhism either without leaders, which I think there's a theological precedent for, or a Buddhism where all leaders MUST admit their shortcomings, publicly, like a sex offender. I personally think the 2nd option is good because a lot because Americans don't worship gods. It's not their style. Cut the shit, be honest with yourself, and don't let other people worship you because that only means you're giving them something else to stumble over. This is what Josh Korda said on the Dharmapunx podcast (I heard that Noah Levine wasn't a good author to begin with, I didn't know he was screwing his practitioners until today.)

Thanks for reading!


r/BuddhistSocialism • • Apr 20 '18

A big difference between Buddhism and Marxism - is it really an irreconcilable contradiction? What are your thoughts?

8 Upvotes

There are many interesting points of contact between the worldviews, such as the idea of dependent co-arising.

But there are also many oppositions. If anyone would like to, I've prepared some thoughts about two of these seeming contradictions. I'd be very happy to see replies (although I know this community is small).

Should society be transformed? How?

Although opposed to the caste system, and in that sense intellectually revolutionary, the social practice of the early buddhists consisted only in constructing a "break-away" social structure whose elements already existed, although it itself was a new phenomenon. The early Sangha was a communal form of living (communalism existed in the social structure of the villages / tribes), combined with contemplation (previously only the preserve of the Brahmin caste), supported by alms (already a part of the social constitution of the society buddhism arose in) and minimalist labour.

That eventually the Sangha was transformed (in certain areas more quickly or more intensely), and over time, into a closed community living off exacted tribute, part of the class structure rather than an abstentionist break-away, is another question, but we're talking about the ideas which founded the religion. A similar fate befell Christianity, for example. But this says more about the fact that these worldviews, although intellectually revolutionary, could not materially transform their context, and were destined inevitably to be "reabsorbed" by the stronger currents of the dominant class and social structure.

Historical progress

Buddhism arose at a time historically when very little social change or development occurred, and it was very difficult to even imagine a wholesale transformation of society to modify its class structure. The industrial revolution also had not modified human consciousness to make us aware of the potentially infinite progressive development of humankind.

Marxism is not opposed to the outlook of development and progress in history, in fact although it is not by any means naive about the contradictory and many-times violent way this occurs, being a viewpoint not just critical of capitalism but of the whole epoch of civilization, it nonetheless stands as a kind of inheritor of the legitimate idea of historical progress, of human beings making our world better, which was raised and then rejected in the course of development of the bourgeoisie.

The revolutionary bourgeoisie struggling against the intellectual fetters of the closed world of feudalism and the anti-life, stagnant philosophy of the church, put forward tremendous, world-shaking ideas of optimism and progress, of enlightenment. Marx and Engels in their youth were influenced, as any revolutionary youth, by the titanic historical event of the French revolution (and the revolutions of 1830), and by these ideas.

Yet once the same class whose philosophical representatives spoke so well had attained power, it just as quickly donned the mantle of the conservatism it had struggled against, showing that its opposition to stagnation, its belief in progress, were only relative, that although men dreaming in the clouds like Condorcet could in their minds be so optimistic, these men were clearly regarded by the bulk of the new social class, the bourgeoisie, as not only dreamers, but in fact dangerous, now that their ideas had seeped into the exploited classes and become a weapon against their assumption of the power.

The same philosophical trajectory of optimistic development, disavowal by the bourgeois risen to power, and recuperation by the communists takes place for the idea of "Liberty", which Rousseau for example put forward.

To get back to the point and to summarize, Marxism is definitively, for anyone familiar with it, a philosophy of progress and development.

But at any rate this outlook certainly contradicts certain interpretations of Buddhism (certainly supported by an enormous amount of the content of the Sutras), one could say the dominant interpretations, in which the aim is not development or progression or growth, but almost a kind of neutral fading-away of humanity, as if the project of being sentient beings was itself a kind of error which insight and effort could correct, nullify, and ultimately erase? This would be taken to its extreme in the idea of a "private buddha" who attains enlightenment and basically "checks out" from our world at the same moment.

Then again, the concept of the middle way in opposition to asceticism seems to indicate that it is not necessarily a problem for beings to exist, it's suffering which is the issue, due to a certain way of existence for our minds. In fact, the Buddha themselves clearly thought progressively in the sense that they aimed to spread the Dharma to all sentient beings and by that transform the world. The "goal" of history and humanity would be therefore to liberate all sentient beings. This seems very close to the view of freedom's development in history which Marx took from Hegel (and gave a material, concrete meaning, besides its more abstract mental / philosophical meaning).


r/BuddhistSocialism • • Sep 13 '21

My Socialism - Takagi Kenmyo (1904)

Thumbnail
theanarchistlibrary.org
7 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Dec 12 '17

“I don’t love them”—Meet a Buddhist Anti-fascist – Max Zahn – Medium

Thumbnail
medium.com
7 Upvotes

r/BuddhistSocialism • • Jan 19 '22

The Buddha's teachings on Social and Communal Harmony reading group?

Thumbnail self.radicalbuddhism
6 Upvotes