r/bestof • u/one_brown_jedi • May 28 '12
Indian guy explains "Why India is Poor Considering It's Rich and Wealthy History?"
/r/AskHistorians/comments/u6m6n/why_is_india_poor_considering_its_rich_and/c4stnpk-4
May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
I'm an Indian, and a layman, and it's very well accepted here that a major cause of India's underdevelopment today is the economic and political policies followed by the East India Company, and later the British Government.
So, it's "pretty well accepted" - in India - that the reasons for their economic woes are in the past, and someone else's fault?
India has been independent since 1947. That's 65 years ago. The vast majority of people who lived in India at that time aren't even alive today. The total population then was 350 million; it is 1,170 million today.
If these opinions are representative, India is blaming not merely foreigners, but dead foreigners, for the troubles of people who were born in India since then. People who live there, and who make and shape it into what it is now.
Does that sound like a pattern you'd expect in a half-dysfunctional country that hasn't used the past 65 years to advance itself a lot?
In 1950, India's inflation-adjusted GDP per capita was more than China's, and not far from Taiwan. But from 1950 until 1988, India's inflation-adjusted per-capita economic growth was 1.5%. From 1988 to 2003, it rose to 4.2%.
India is not quite there yet, but clearly, the problem was something it was doing from 1950 until 1988, which countries like Taiwan (rose from 920 to 16,500) did considerably better.
4
u/one_brown_jedi May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
I am sorry, I disagree with you.
The cause of current economic state and overpopulation was that the British didn't put much effort on education, health care, agriculture or industry.
When India and Pakistan became independent, daughters couldn't inherit properties. Majority of Indians and Pakistanis were illiterate farmers who wanted boys to inherited farms and more boys to serve as farmhands. Girls were shunned and are still shunned today in parts of India and Pakistan. Girls were considered a curse as marrying them off was considered costly due to the dowry system. This led to infanticides and later female foeticide. This won't have happened if British had laid the groundwork for an education system before handing the land to the people who had never run a government before.
A lot of expenditure came to health care after the two nations become independent. Frankly, the British didn't care about the tropical diseases that took several million victims in the subcontinent every year. The British did start a small pox vaccination program in India and Burma in early 1800s but in was stopped because of superstitions and suspicious. The majority of effort towards eradication after the 1960s because of the formation of WHO and other funding organizations. Still, it took until 1979 to eradicate small pox and 2011 to eradicate polio from India. Pakistan still gets polio cases. Things would have been much different if British had started some work in the direction during the colonial era. We had to make up for about 200 years of neglect. They just left the people to be cared by shamans and quacks.
British didn't care about the farmers and traders. In fact British used to think of India as a market to be exploited. Cotton used to be exported from India for peanuts. They were spun in England in mills and sent back to India. How were the poor artisans working on their looms supposed to compete with mills? Gandhi and others educated the people about this. He used to spin his own loin-cloth and shawl. He encouraged others to support local products and boycott imported ones.
The most disgusting and horrible aspect of British colonial rule was the Salt Tax. Under it, if you evaporated some sea water to produce salt, it was a crime. The British had total monopoly over freaking salt. You wanted salt for your rice gruel, you either bought it from the British or paid tax for making your own. Our land and our sea and we paid tax for salt. So, what else there is to take from us? Gandhi started the Salt March to encourage people to produce their own salt. It feels surreal and ridiculous to even think people were scared shitless of drying a pan of sea water and the police was actually trying to prevent people from doing so. Such was the heights of greed and oppression under British rule. Imagine a "Occupy Beaches And Make Salt Movement."
About farmers, British had established a high tax and tiered feudal system. By independence, all farmers had lost all their lands to moneylenders and serfs due to famines and high tax rates. Many were bonded laborers and were working only to pay off debts. The land reforms after independence put some land back in the farmers' hands. India's constitution originally had a right to property but it was removed to make way for land reforms. It was replaced by a "no person shall be deprived of his property save by authority of law" article.
Famine was frequent in India and Pakistan until 1960s. It was the Green Revolution that saved us and made us self-sufficient in food grains. Thank you, Norman Borlaug.
You want to know why we have such a large population? It is because a illiterate farmer doesn't know a tractor can replace ten sons. He doesn't know that diseases that killed his fathers and brothers can now be treated. He doesn't need ten sons as a safety policy. We have a big population because we are no longer starving to death or dying of mosquito bites. Of course population leads to poverty.
We still have come a long way by recovering from the economic rape of 200 years. After independence, we setup a paranoid socialist government because we were afraid of capitalistic greed. After 1990's economic reforms, we moved forward staggeringly. Come on, aren't we being accused of stealing American jobs? We are now on the verge of another series of economic reforms.
We take responsibility for our in-competencies but we won't take responsibility for the greed of British Imperialism.
17
u/parlor_tricks May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
The original post was in ask historians.
The answer was from a historical perspective and did the right job in answering the question in its context - ask history.
Now no one in India really goes about talking about the British and their loot and sack of our country from colonial times.
We mostly bitch about our government and deal with our problems.
Regarding your data. It papers over everything that happened immediately after independance, the prevailing ideologies of the time, the cold war, the leading development theories of the era, the Emergency of Indira and the policies that resulted.
Edit: Hind sight is 20/20. Please please note, that the cold war period was one where 2 ideas fought to see which was right. Communism or Capitalism. Capitalism turned out to be more efficient policy of allocating resources. But no one knew that for sure until the experiment was carried out. India tried socialism. It didn't work out as planned. Sucks. We work to fix this.
At the same time, during that era we created and nourished the IITs, whose engineers later went on to power the US machine, (Gates himself said if he could recruit from only one place it would be the IIT), we built a nuclear program, rebuilt our dams and generally eradicated polio and a few other minor achievements of the time. I guess you could even count the Non-aligned movement as one of them but thats neither here nor there. This was all done basically on our own, or with help from the soviets.
Anyway those were the lost years in many ways. Then fast forward to 1990 and the balance of payments crisis.
Thats when the markets were opened and reformed. And then our fledgling and miserable country as described in your stats, did a lot better.
TATA bought Jaguar and Land rover, Americans drive Mahindra tractors (theres an amusing country song about Mahindra tractors), we converted that labor glut into outsourcing and generally are building that standard of living back up.
Are we there yet? Nope, and everyone knows that. We don't spend our time blaming the British and our past either though. We blame corruption, lack of professionalism and atavism. But then that means you have to dig past the easy stories.
Tldr: You miss the context of the question - its an ask history question. Present day India blames its politicians. Not its erstwhile colonial opressors.
Also Your data is papers over the details and says "Oh you moved only 1 m" , when you fell 14 meters, and then climbed back up 15.
4
u/canyouseeitnow May 28 '12
If you're anywhere in the DFW area of the US, I'll buy you a beer bro! That was about the most succinct and to the point response to a troll question.
3
u/parlor_tricks May 28 '12
lol thanks man. Hope to be there at some point. :). Thank you for the offer!
1
u/Sniffnoy May 28 '12
There's two comments there; the proper way to link it is to link to the lower one and use context.
-15
u/skekze May 28 '12 edited May 28 '12
Maybe it's because they shit in their own drinking water. In all seriousness, perhaps their caste system is what's keeping them from improving their system of government. Of course, America is starting to create one of it's own. If a rich man's son always gets the job whether or not qualified, wouldn't that level of corruption choke a society and repress innovation?
11
u/parlor_tricks May 28 '12
Dear god this caste system thing gets brought out on Reddit so much its annoying.
Look - there is a collective sense of agreement Indian and Indian redditors have that the caste system is BS. At the same time we also don't think that the caste system is the cause of our problems.
We have so many different languages and cultures, that frankly you would need a passport to see the same variety you would travelling north to south or east to west of India.
Not everyone is blighted by casteism. And the caste system is being broken up as well. Its being fought against and the oppressed are doing it themselves. They are also using the system to achieve it. Guess what - they are using the same crappy government to make themselves better!.
To go out and say "I think casteism is the reason." is taking one out of a million reasons and putting a crown on it because it matches your opinion and not the facts.
Please lay off. Its a complex topic. Extremely so. Trust me, the EU issues are peanuts in terms of complexity for what has to be handled here.
-2
u/skekze May 28 '12
Ok, corruption does have a large part to play in how societies function. When one group of people are elevated, it redistributes resources that would have gone elsewhere. So you have a varied culture, so does everyone else. I live in the US. We got a few different types here too.
It's a complex topic that mirrors the same issues that most societies face. Your Ganges river is polluted as hell, and so are many in my country. The same issues are faced in both places, trying to tie together the broken pieces of a feudal society with a modern world.
People need to learn to have respect for their neighbors again, rather than creating generational toxic waste dumps. Someone else's kids will pay for the cleanup is what they always think. That bill just gets pushed down the road. Sooner or later, somebody's gotta pay it.
7
u/smart_mass May 28 '12
I am Indian and I live in Chicago. The racial segregation in Chicago is far worse than the worst castism I have seen in India. That does not mean we should bring up racism every time we discuss U.S.
1
u/parlor_tricks May 28 '12
I was going to tear the OP a new one, but fortunately I re-read his second comment.
His talking points taken on their own merits are fair enough and reasonable. In the end, we would agree that thats how corruption works, that people should be better at keeping their resources clean and so on.
Racial segregation and casteism, is not what the poster was talking about.
0
u/skekze May 28 '12
I only bring it up where relevant. I'm starting to notice America is no different. I live down the street from a college that no one in my town can afford. So, they educate kids from somewhere else for 50K per year. It makes me really happy that the resources of my region, should instead go to those who can afford it, rather than it's residents. Money makes the world go round.
1
u/parlor_tricks May 28 '12
Instate tuition rates are ridiculously low. Perhaps there is something I do t understand, but shouldnt it be pretty cheap for you?
-1
u/skekze May 28 '12
Actually, I've watched them raise prices on the state colleges at least 5 percent every year for 20 years now. It's actually snowballed a bit and is closer to 3 times higher than when I went back in the day.
The college I'm describing is actually a private university that teaches quite a few foreign kids. I have no problem with foreigners, as this country's founded on them and their strengths.
However, when you have nobody from your area attending such an institution, it speaks about our economic differences. Shall we export food and let the locals starve? Why not the same with education?
I now shop at the local farmers market in their town, because it has better food. I've tried applying for a job there, but I guess I didn't attend dishwasher college, so can't get that without experience. The funny part is, it's a liberal arts college, I'd make a good student.
Can't even do goodwill hunting with this shit, can't get a job at the college either. They seem to reject me with the letter of, we found a better internal candidate, so nepotism. They went with the sister or friend of whoever already worked there.
So, class does exist, oh yeah, even for white people. I'm Irish, so even though there's a massive amount of them in the US, I don't just get hired based off my race.
I only get hired if I'm the best applicant, or they take a pass. From my perspective, this society has an everybody for themselves type of attitude.
I tried the school thing, learned some outdated shit and made a wrong turn. Now I think I'll learn on my own. As fast as I could learn it, the wealthy will figure out a way to automate and lower the paycheck, so I better figure out how to do it old school and run a business.
1
u/parlor_tricks May 29 '12
Whats your area of focus, if I may ask out of curiosity?
1
u/skekze May 29 '12
None. I severely lack focus. I went to college back in the day and thought about majoring in English but was talked out of it, by parents, a recommendation actually made by my aunt and uncle who made a career out of teaching. Ahh, the irony. Go figure, everybody's wants their kids to be a doctor or something.
Then years later, I just wanted to return to a tech school or something and learn pc repair. I was again browbeaten into taking the programming course instead, as my brother-in-law made a nice career of it.
I now see, a man can do many things. Many a hat will fit yer head, but not every one is the right hat. So, I've gone a bit mad. Sorry to offend. I just hate when any group of people ruin their environment.
I've learned late in life, what is afforded to the poor. My parent's first apartment was built on a previous dump site. Then after years of fighting the city for repairs and substandard construction, we moved to another state. To buy again, housing built on a former dump site.
I fished streams in my youth, that I knew, you can't eat the fish. They're poison. I can take no livelihood from the land, which is cartoonish in fact. So, I'll study the world now, and try and find work doing anything that will be sane. Harder to find these days. I better go sell my stuff and buy a hotdog cart. Ain't life a gamble?
1
u/parlor_tricks May 29 '12
There are fortunately many avenues for some one who is willing to self educate. You could immediately start with using khan academy to up numeracy. Which is frankly learning a new language. At the same time you can also use code academy to up your coding skills.
Build something which you may use yourself. By the sounds of it, you would be a pretty handsy guy, so making something of value to you, using only your mind, discipline and code, must appeal to you.
And if it has value to you, it may for others.
→ More replies (0)
3
u/Reddonite May 28 '12
*its