r/bestof • • May 28 '12

And so it was: The Star Fox Principle of Irrationality

/r/gameofthrones/comments/u7kse/question_about_daenerys/c4t0huy
52 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

10

u/[deleted] May 28 '12

I've always hated this sort of rationale. Going along with this, it's perfectly fine for me to write a story that's completely riddled with plot holes and inaccuracies as long as I add some fantasy elements to it.

"You can't complain about it man, there's a dragon in it! So nothing has to make sense!"

4

u/bekeleven May 28 '12

Agreed. The whole point of suspension of disbelief is that the reader/viewer will give you anything you want, once. You can establish whatever rules you want, as long you hold to them.

1

u/Tonkarz May 28 '12

I agree. I think it comes down to the distinction between things that are made up for the story and things that exist in real life. Dragons can breathe fire or talking foxes can talk, because they were made up for the story. But ordinary water should still flow downhill, ordinary people should still act rationally, eating ordinary ground onion shouldn't let you breathe underwater and so on.

2

u/t7598 May 28 '12

1

u/Jagjamin May 30 '12

Exactly where I was going to go with this. I love fictional universerses, but only ones that are internally consistent.

1

u/MrCheeze May 28 '12

Really just a subset of the MST3K mantra.

1

u/Shadowhawk109 May 28 '12

"...also, the animals can talk."

1

u/Pandaemonium May 28 '12

I'm willing to concede the author the freedom to build their own world, but the characters within the world should act according to the rules that the author sets. I don't mind at all suspending my disbelief to accept the impossible (dragons, wizards, etc.) but what does irk me is the unlikely (e.g., five different characters being at exactly the right place at the right time, for no apparent reason.)

Being contrived is being contrived, whether it be in fantasy or realistic fiction, so I disagree that you should try to apply logic to anything once you introduce a fantasy element.

Or I could put it this way: fantasy elements draw you into the author's universe, but contrived plot devices pull your attention back to the real world.