r/bestof • • May 18 '12

[europe] A _really_ solid explanation of the European debt crisis by one of r/europe's resident experts.

/r/europe/comments/ts1tw/british_prime_minister_david_cameron_has_called/c4pgrnd?context=2
1.0k Upvotes

133 comments sorted by

32

u/chengiz May 18 '12

Great post - what r/bestof was made for. And the context is right too! I almost came!

34

u/boq May 18 '12

And look at all my sweet link karma. Even though all I did was point others towards it... That's how record labels must feel like.

6

u/Oda_Krell May 18 '12

Ah, as always, typical Southern German work ethic.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

[deleted]

7

u/boq May 18 '12

Um, I think you're wrong. I don't submit a lot so I notice all increases, and my karma did go up a few hundred points in the last hour.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

[deleted]

7

u/boq May 18 '12

Whoosh.

5

u/sweetafton May 18 '12

They do. Anything other than a self post accrues karma.

1

u/Wulibo May 18 '12

Sorry, misconception. Self-posts don't accrue karma, but links to the site are still links.

18

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

Give 'em a bit of time to enact reforms, and if markets stay calm they'll have some very impressive growth coming their way.

I think the idea that Spain, Portugal and Italy are doing all the right things and are just around the corner from "impressive growth" is a bit too flippant an analysis for my liking. The austerity, or "reforms," are wreaking serious havoc on those economies and the unemployment rates, particularly among the youth, will have devastating affects for many years.

The idea that Italy is right around the corner from impressive growth is almost laughable.

5

u/jetpackswasyes May 19 '12

Yeah, with youth unemployment at over 50% and overall unemployment at 25% Spain isn't going anywhere quickly. Let's see if their banks survive the next six months, maybe six weeks if Greece exits the Euro.

2

u/Very_High_Templar May 18 '12

I understand that pessimism and defeatism are very popular sentiments on reddit regardless of subject, so I am going to ask you why specifically you are confident there will be no growth in Italy?

2

u/the_prole May 19 '12

Economies can't grow forever. Italy has been slowing down since the 70s. Advanced mature economies especially have lower growth rates. I think Italy has reached it's steady state. I don't expect anything impressive in terms of growth.

2

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Italy has a negative birth rate.

15

u/jambarama May 18 '12

We've had some pretty good explanations in /r/asksocialscience too - this one was pretty in depth, this one is a bit more readable.

5

u/Oda_Krell May 18 '12

Those two comments take a very different perspective on the crisis than countvontroll's comment, who mainly pointed out the structural problems of for exampl Greece, while the comments you link to mainly place the blame on neoliberal policies and inherent problems of capitalism. I'm not entirely in line with that explanation, but I can still see value in seeing it explained like that. Thanks for the links.

3

u/jambarama May 18 '12

Just as a note, the author of the second linked comment is an econ professor. Plenty of other econ professors would disagree with him, but worth mentioning.

6

u/ItGotRidiculous May 18 '12

They wouldn't be economists if they agreed on anything. Thanks for the context.

1

u/Oda_Krell May 18 '12

Yes, I should have also said it differently. The first link mainly looks at Greece and the global crisis together and concludes it's a problem of neoliberalism (in a nutshell). The second link actually talks about the global crisis in general, and reactions by the EU, and seems to believe it is mainly a monetary crisis (as opposed to being caused by debt or structural problems).

2

u/omargard May 18 '12

The first wasn't a pretty good explanation but a "anti-neoliberalist" manifesto :)

15

u/iamathief May 18 '12

I think this graph, illustrating the yield on European government bonds (i.e. the price of borrowing) over time, is a far more succinct explanation of the European debt crisis. There is little to no explanation, in terms of economic fundamentals, for why the spreads should have converged like that. It isn't difficult to imagine what the ramifications of this convergence would be, when the whole Eurozone could enjoy the same low borrowing costs as the Northern European core.

4

u/Asco88 May 18 '12

Great graph.

There is a reason they converged like that. Investors aren't stupid, they didn't think Greece and Germany had equally good finances. It was quite simply a bet that the Euro zone countries or the European Central Bank would bail each other out and take over each others debt in a crisis.

However, that graph really makes it clear in how much worse condition Greece was before the monetary union than the other countries.

3

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

Great graph, really puts everything together now.

3

u/Oda_Krell May 18 '12

More succinct? Maybe. But actually better? Not really, since it doesn't explain anything, it just shows the quantitatve effects of some cause(s) that still require explanation. For the latter, I really suggest to read the comment linked to by OP, it's well worth the few minutes it takes to read and digest.

13

u/wtfadvertisersgd May 18 '12

It does not even touch on the issues. This is why I would not do research on reddit.

1

u/MustangMark83 May 19 '12

Well, nobody on reddit or in any liberal government wants to talk about debt issues. It's a naughty word and we'd rather pretend it doesn't exist.

1

u/wtfadvertisersgd May 19 '12

Nailed the head on the hammer, sir.

6

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

Didn't think it was such a great analysis.

When the reforms kicked in, there suddenly was a hyper-competitive Germany

Yeah, right. Magic reforms.

What made the German economy jump is the euro. "Suddenly", it could sustain high exports, with a relatively cheap currency.

4

u/omargard May 19 '12

What made the German economy jump is the euro.

Lol, the Euro was cheap ($0.90 in 2002) when Germany's economy was still bad.

It became more expensive ($1.30, just like nowadays) in 2005 when the German economy was picking up. The Euro was the highest in summer 2008 at $1.60 and Germany's economy was just fine. Nowadays it's back at $1.30, and by PPP it's still too high.

If Germany wanted a cheap Euro, they would approve a lot more "quantitative easing". The German fear of hyper-inflation is what keeps the Euro too high.

It wasn't the "cheap Euro"(lol again), but Germany's austerity reforms from the early 2000s*, and more recently the new markets in China, Brazil,...

* Exactly because the German economy was slow in the early 2000s did they not have their own housing bubble. For the most part that was a lucky coincidence. German politicians like to pretend it was all intentional because it makes them look competent, and conspiracy theorists like you also like to pretend it was all intentional.

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

The vast majority of Germany's export goes to France, the U.K., the Netherlands, and Italy. The $ plays a minor role. The EUR/USD ratio can vary wildly without significant economic repercussions or meaning. It's only really relevant in terms of foreign investments (are U.S. companies buying European companies or vice versa?), which usually constitutes only 1-5% of GDP.

Measured in British pounds, the euro has been stable 2000-2008, despite the German economy growing nearly twice as fast and exports skyrocketing. This would not have happened in the Deutsche Mark era. The market corrects such differences. Negative current account balances in Southern Europe are keeping prices down to Germany's advantage. Sure, reforms allowed Germany to take maximum advantage of the arbitrage created by the euro, but it would still be in the same poor state without the euro. From 2008, the British economy shrank faster than the euro economy. Logically, their currency collapsed versus the euro. Unfortunately for them, they are not an export economy and this doesn't really help them recover.

-1

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

If Germany wanted a cheap Euro, they would approve a lot more "quantitative easing". The German fear of hyper-inflation is what keeps the Euro too high.

Aha! A Krugman guy! Gotcha!

1

u/omargard May 19 '12

You're incredibly bad at reading comprehension. Seriously, you need to learn to understand what people are saying before replying.

50

u/canyouhearme May 18 '12

I'd have to say, I don't think it's a very good explanation of what's happening, or why. Confusing the temporary pain in Germany as a result of the cost of reunification with the rectification of faultlines through resolute action flatters the Germans (as it was supposed to do). Portugal or Italy better placed fundamentally to Greece? Corruption is almost the Italian brand.

The root of the problem was the forced monetary union, bought about by the desires of the political classes, as a prelude to political union. The differences in financial systems, culture, economic cycle - everything - was ignored for the chimera of a power block that would give those political apparatchiks the ability to strut on the world stage.

That the 'ever closer union' would eventually grind up to dust some groups was a worthwhile cost for France and Germany - who felt they could always dump the sinking ship if needed (akin to Texas in outlook).

Europe became less about empirically sensible trading markets, and more about ideology and political manoeuvring where the big boys could exploit the rest to win big. And now France, Germany, Brussels, are beginning to realise that the political game begats real world conflict - that those you tread on are wont to stand-up and knife you in the front; and what do they do when those used tear up the rule book and play a different game?

Contagion is the disease that Germany and France look on with horror. The only question is exactly where the line is that will cause them to dissociate to save themselves.

Only history will tell if they can play a good Madagascar - I'm betting not.

36

u/throwaway2481632 May 18 '12

The fundamental problem was the inherent assumption of credit markets that any euro country could be considered AAA because of the stronger economies, like france and germany, would back it up. so greece, who truthfully had a poor credit score, was able to take out a platinum credit card and went spending like there is no tomorrow, both lender and greece assuming germany would foot the bill.

9

u/Crafty_Dus May 18 '12

Exactly, It's a wonder this gets short shrift in these summaries. If you're missing the Goldman-Sachs derivatives events, you're missing an important lesson.

7

u/cppdev May 18 '12

Agreed. It's not like there was some massive conspiracy by the richer countries "exploiting" the rest as canyouhearme seems to be suggesting. There is a saying: "never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity". Because the EU became a financial union, it was assumed that there would be increased stability due to the stronger countries backing the weak ones. Of course, we've seen that this means nothing if there isn't the corresponding political union to create shared policy. Unfortunately people did not figure this out until now, when Greece seems more than content to drag the Euro down with it.

3

u/canyouhearme May 19 '12

Generally I'd agree with you - stupidity is a powerful force. But in this case I think the faultlines were so obvious that some malice WAS involved.

Back in the 1990s, when EMU, etc. first came up, I remember saying at a dinner that it was a disaster waiting to happen. The closer and closer you bound the very disparate economies and cultures; the greater the energy you give it when it pulls itself apart.

It was obvious that unification of a United States of Europe wasn't going to work. When the US did it the communication and interfaces between the states was much less than today's world demands - and they had a war or two over it before an uneasy peace occurred. Today the strains and mismatches are cast into much sharper relief with less time to fix - there is less scope for fudging it.

The political apparatchiks might have hoped that it would all somehow work itself out - but they can't have expected it. They knew some countries were going to suffer and the big boys arranged things such that it wasn't going to be them. Forget the 'it needs political union' meme that is being pushed today - if you are arranging a common currency you need a way of the bits that do well bailing out the bits that don't - but it is suspiciously missing (Germany made sure of that).

Now we seen Naomi Klein's 'Shock Doctrine' playing out - a naked power grab in a time of upheaval on spurious grounds (what's needed are less tight bounds, not more) that the apparatchiks are finding won't stick. We can only hope that the EU is reformed, back into more of an EEC - and that the centralising cancer of Brussels is dismantled and distributed - yielding an agile and adaptive structure that actually focuses on the real issues (what they hell is Europe for, how does it make money) and forgets the ideology.

22

u/icandoitbetter May 18 '12 edited May 18 '12

CountVonTroll's comment is full of ridiculous explanations, like

Spain had similar surpluses and low debt as Ireland (and we'd be in big trouble if they hadn't had them, or if their banking system had blown up similarly), and a giant housing bubble as well. They were over-reliant on construction, which due to said housing bubble lead to wages increasing above of what their productivity would have normally permitted far too quickly, and they have nothing to replace it with.

Yeah, Spain collapsed because the construction industry was destroyed. Makes perfect sense! It wasn't that the real estate bubble, driven by irresponsible bets from European (mostly German) banks, sent the Spanish banks to insolvency. It wasn't that the Spanish state needed to bail those banks out, and so it overborrowed and went from a primary surplus and very very low debt to a debt crisis. No, according to CountVonTroll it was just that the real estate bubble led to a fall in the construction sector hires, and then productivity suffered. I wonder how many people were employed in construction - 25% of the population? Everything according to the German morality tale is driven by productivity, not by a financial sector, riddled in moral hazard, that can act as irresponsibly as it wants and expect to be recapitalized by member states and the ECB, even at the detriment of the member states' economies.

And I won't even discuss in detail his moralistic explanation of the Greek crisis, which resembles the worst of Merkel's rhetoric, nor will I talk about his astonishingly ignorant statement that "nobody is complaining about the bailouts," apart from, you know, some fringe characters like Krugman or Stiglitz.

3

u/damunq May 18 '12

I feel that I really don't know enough about this subject, could you link to some opinions of Kurgman or Stiglitz which explain their views on the matter?

2

u/bokononon May 18 '12

I'm completely stealing a post from another forum here:

Frank Galton Says May 17th, 2012 at 6:30 pm http://www.irisheconomy.ie/index.php/2012/05/17/austerity-games/#comment-283763

A little birdie brings news of a Willem Buiter presentation and the following highlights therein.

Ireland: off the charts figures on debt and errors of historic proportions on policy, most notably our favourite evening in government buildings in September 2008 [the evening of the Irish blanket bank guarantee]. Despite all the adjustment, prognosis still bleak because public debt is in the danger range while household and non-financial corporate debt still far too high. Can’t believe that regulators and ministers missed the surge in household debt 2000-2008. Now an economy with 4 deleveraging sectors (households, firms, government, banks) — it can’t be done.

Greece: Euro exit alone will be useless or worse than useless — there will be immediate inflation and a rubbish currency. No resource boom to bail them out a la Russia and Argentina. Large scale debt restructuring throught out the economy the only option. Amazed that IMF signed on to the 2010 program and doesn’t know how they managed a debt sustainability analysis. 2010 was the time when a more contained restructuring could have worked.

Eurozone in general. No place entirely immune from debt concerns, even German has rising CDS spreads. Spain to be in troika program this year, Italy next year. Italy managing only because the ratio of PR to performance has been so high, but underneath it’s Monti working with the same political system that got them into the mess into the first place. Does not think that Italy can comply with the fiscal compact without severe disruption given the growth rate and size of debt. In principle Italy has the household wealth to support solvency but with chronic declines in tax administration capacity worldwide, not clear that this can be tapped.

UK: Has Irish style profile in some respects but being helped for now by inflation which is having significant impact on debt reduction due to the maturity profile.

US & Japan. Both fiscal basket cases being protected by special factors — home bias of Japanese savers and the reserve role of the dollar, respectively. Neither can last. Outsiders will be the marginal purchasers of JGB within 5 years and yields will have to rise. US is stuck between social democratic spending preferences and tea party tax preferences. Republicans going for another showdown on debt which will be bad economics and bad politics. Thinks that markets and pundits are too sanguine about dollar as a reserve currency — it can remain a reserve currency but at much higher absolute yields. Then the fiscal crisis will kick in.

Krugman and Summers: Complaints about both. Summers role in the US financial deregulation in the 1990s. Krugman too committed to the Keynesian cross — there is no Keynesian Laffer curve. Austerity is painful but it does reduce deficits. More austerity = more deficit reduction. The constraints are political, not economic.

Demand for “less austerity, more growth” is essentially a demand for non-market financing. Unless a specific kitty or Santa Claus is being identified, it’s meaningless.

Overall outlook: advanced economies need mass debt to equity conversion. Household negative equity becomes bank equity. Sovereign debt converts to GDP warrants. Huge agenda remains on banks — most Eurozone countries still have no special resolution regime for banks, let alone a pan-Eurozone one. Legislation needed to break the pari passu link between depositors and senior unsecured creditors. Household mortgages need to shift to Islamic finance — insane that the system worked for so long with highly specialized households being landed with such a rigid financial instrument like a mortgage. Massive deadweight losses to reposession and bankruptcy.

3

u/[deleted] May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

Austerity is painful but it does reduce deficits. More austerity = more deficit reduction.

Funny how they'd say that despite the fact that literally all the evidence thus far indicates the exact opposite. Austerity grows deficits by shrinking demand and the economy and tax revenues by extension. Even in cases where you do get some savings they come at extremely high costs wherein you only save $0.30 or so for every dollar you cut (if I'm remembering the figure correctly). So austerity ranges from a highly inefficient method of deficit reduction to entirely counterproductive. In short, it's bad policy.

Demand for “less austerity, more growth” is essentially a demand for non-market financing. Unless a specific kitty or Santa Claus is being identified, it’s meaningless.

How about the fact that bond yields have remained absurdly low, so the government can currently take out loans for free? The government could have (and should have) instituted a stimulus of sufficient scale to grow demand and kick off a genuine recovery without facing substantial interest payments on the new debt going forward. Or how about raising the inflation target to a level that actually spurs private investment since the vast majority of private firms are simply sitting on huge sums of capital because there's no incentive to move it? In fact, they've got so much excess capital and so few obvious investment options that they're buying government bonds that won't even beat an inflation rate that remains very low.

It seems completely insane that the government wouldn't take this opportunity to invest in public works projects (many of which are badly needed all over the country) on a grand scale. Instead I guess we're just going to wait until it's more expensive both in real terms (as things have degraded even further) and in terms of interest rates on bonds, and all because the deficit hawks insist that there's no alternative to their own failed policies and all we need to do is "grin and bear it" and, eventually, they'll be proved right after being wrong countless times before...

3

u/revolutionbaby May 18 '12

which resembles the worst of Merkel's rhetoric

Exactly what I was thinking while reading CountVonTrolls text.

2

u/mpness May 18 '12

Could you explain to me how Spain went down the tube and now has scary levels of unemployment when they seemingly were practicing responsible levels of spending?

Their unemployment is higher than Greece, which has endemic corruption and graft!

2

u/AndyRooney May 18 '12

You might find these articles interesting: on formation and other structural issues, Professor Krugman's take and Roubini's view on the inevitability of Greece's exit.

2

u/curation May 18 '12

The problem is a monetary union, but you could have stated your point better without all those rhetorical flairs! The failure of the EMU is directly contingent on the failure of the Maastricht Convergence Criteria. They attempted to harmonize the fiscal states of each member country, but one they were in on the Euro, things fell apart. Even then, France and Germany were the first to break criteria and Greece and Italy essentially cooked the books to get in. Now that they're in the ditch, their lack of monetary autonomy prevents them from adjusting the supply of Euros without affecting the rest of the Eurozone. Everyone saw this coming from a mile away. I don't think the cultural/language side matters too much. Sure, they won't reach a state of perfect transfer with these barriers, but the fiscal union suggested by many would largely overshadow such petty differences.

However, such a union is politically unfeasible and the governance would be a nightmare. Economically, it would be great, but it would be a political disaster.

1

u/Asco88 May 18 '12

The problem is the monetary union, but it is only partially because of the failure of the convergence criteria. Sounds public finances would have made the debt crisis better, true. However, these countries would still be in recession if they had lower debt levels.

Firstly: The eurozone is not, and has never been, an optimal currency area. Right now, optimal monetary policy in Ireland, in Spain or even Greece is miles away optimal policy in Germany. While the ECB has been targeting 2% inflation in the Euro zone as a whole, Ireland has been in downright deflation as measured by the GDP deflator. That is a disaster and can explain a big chunk of the debt crisis, and an even larger part of the recession.

1

u/Offensive_Username2 May 18 '12

Yeah, but doesn't Italy have that Monti guy who is trying to clean up the mess?

1

u/Parrrley May 18 '12

Having read through your post... out of curiosity, how would you describe the current economic situation in the US? Is the current situation completely down to 'foreigners' mismanaging their economies and the 'contagion' spreading over to the US? Or is a large reason for the US' current economic situation also down to gross mismanagement at home?

If the EU zone crumbles economically and the US follows, should most of the blame be put on the European Union, or should the blame be split (more) equally between sources both sides of the Atlantic?

4

u/canyouhearme May 18 '12

Thing to remember: the origin of this immediate problem is contagion FROM the US. The reason the debt situation of these countries is so bad stems from attempting to deal with the fallout of the US GFC1. I'm not saying there wasn't a debt problem before 2007 - but the US mismanagement of their financial fraudsters is less a straw on the camel's back; more a sack of cement.

Currently the US is benefiting from those same monetary gnomes considering the US is a 'safe haven' - but putting continued faith in that to save yourselves is like trusting a shark - you'll get bit eventually.

The probably answer is one that would have the repubs spitting out their dummies - you have to get firm control of the global financial community, simplify it enough that it's controllable, then tell it it has to act in society's best interest or the individuals involved get treated like terrorists.

They can't even get 'bonuses' banned...

1

u/lemonpjb May 18 '12

I'd have to say, I don't think it's a very good explanation of what's happening, or why.

Of course you don't. You're the top comment on a r/bestof sudmission. It's your job to be contrarian!

3

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

/r/europe is a great subreddit in general.

Great articles, nice discussions with a lot of different viewpoints. Sometimes a good laugh too, yet rarely beating a dead horse.

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

No beating the dead horse? They discuss the Euro all the time!

I'll see myself out now...

3

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

wait: this is not a good explanation at all! half of his arguments are completely random!

16

u/dugmartsch May 18 '12

Pretty good, I'd take issue with:

This all happened right after tax payers had to bail out banks that had made risky bets for high profits, and they don't distinguish between speculation and supposedly secure government bonds that hardly beat inflation -- Greek bonds yielded only very little more than German ones when banks bought them.

Greece forced Greek banks to buy government bonds, and paid them as if they were sure to repay them. Now it looks as if they're worth pennies on the dollar. Greek banks weren't in that bad of shape before it was known that they wouldn't be seeing hardly any of the money from their supposedly safest, and generally largest, investments. Oh and the Greek government lied about their economic numbers for at least a decade.

No sympathy from me.

6

u/saywhaaaat May 18 '12

Exactly. Greek debt (like most developed economies' debt) was considered "risk free", meaning that the banks valued them at 100 cents on the dollar. They were sold the bonds and (as banks do) used that debt as reserves (and collateral). If the value of those bonds are threatened (as they have been for the last 2 or 3 years) or worse, go to zero (which is basically the case), then their reserves/collateral are cut, which effects/crushes their ability to make loans, which effects/crushes the overall economy.

So it's not as much about "greedy bankers" so much as it's about irresponsible governments whose actions now threaten the banking system in Europe (as it wasn't just Greek banks who bought the debt).

Also, all of their obligations are in Euros, so if they drop the currency in favor of the Drachma (which would have to be heavily devalued), they then owe exponetially more. They think it's bad now? They don't know what bad is.

Edit: This is a bit simplified, but thought I'd add a little color as to why it's such a bad situation.

12

u/shomer_fuckn_shabbos May 18 '12

No sympathy for the Greek government or the Greek people? It seems to me that they are not the same.

23

u/dugmartsch May 18 '12

In this case, both. You can't flake on your taxes like it's some kind of national game for a decade and then go "ooops, those stupid bureaucrats! String 'em up!"

No one seemed to object when the only people paying taxes were the people the government employed, yet somehow services always got more elaborate.

12

u/throwaway2481632 May 18 '12 edited May 18 '12

Not only that, but the greeks were quite content to vote for whoever made the biggest promises.

"ooh ooh, and you'll give everyone a pony? i'm voting for you!"

i said this at the start of greeces crisis and i'll say it again, greece should have been kicked out of the euro when the whole mess started to begin with. back then, europe could have afforded a a bit of speculation as to why the harsh treatment, but they could have simply said that euro countries had rules to abide by and greece lied, but they are welcome to join again once they have their house in order. german banks would have taken a bit of a hit, but isn't that better than a whole monetary union collapsing (when it didn't have to)?

now, because europe decided to stupidly hang on to greece out of fear and it has conflated every single problem with member states to the point that everyone looks like a potential domino.

thanks a lot, greece, and thanks a lot, eurocrats.

7

u/eco_was_taken May 18 '12

Ideally Greece would have never been allowed in. They lied to gain membership to the Eurozone. At the meeting where they announced their new, compliant economic figures which were, frankly, an impossible turn around the other people at the meeting all gave each other sideways glances because they knew the figures were fictional but just sighed and let it pass.

It's too late to remedy that mistake but I hope the EU will have learned a lesson about actually enforcing the requirements they've laid for Eurozone membership.

2

u/icandoitbetter May 18 '12

But the crisis has nothing to do with tax evasion (which IS a problem). Damn, I'm tired of saying the same things all over again in this place... Why don't you guys actually try to read up on how the crisis was created instead of spouting nonsense?

7

u/drraoulduke May 18 '12

How does a lack of government revenue to make your bond payments have nothing to do with taxes?

4

u/brownmatt May 18 '12

The crisis might not have been caused by systematic tax collection problems, but isn't it a lot harder for a government to close it's budget gaps when much of their populace delights in evading paying taxes?

2

u/icandoitbetter May 18 '12

Yeah, the ill condition of the Greek state, both in terms of tax revenue and corruption, led to it being the first to fall among the southern countries. But the crisis itself started from the Spanish real estate bubble, which led to bank insolvencies across the south. The member states had to bail their banks out, and so they over-borrowed, which led to the sovereign debt crisis.

1

u/InABritishAccent May 19 '12

I'm not so sure about your analysis. It seem to me like Greece was building a big house of cards. Then Spain slammed a door and it all toppled down. It would have happened sooner or later anyway.

My point being, the Greeks don't get to blame it on the Spanish after slowly accumulating far more debt than any sane country would.

3

u/gameacct12 May 18 '12

I upvoted you just to help a contrary voice - but you need to link a source. Even if you feel you've done so a hundred times, your current post is just whining. No one cares enough to read through a crybaby's comment history.

3

u/landryraccoon May 18 '12

Greece is a democracy. You can only blame the "government" so much before you have to blame the voters who allowed it to happen.

1

u/watermark0n May 19 '12

I've always thought that one of the biggest problems with democracy was the fact that the people play a huge role in decision making and yet refuse to ever hold themselves responsible for anything. It leads to bad decision making. Representative democracy alleviates this somewhat (as it gives the people a scapegoat so that they can easily abandon their bad ideas), of course, but less so in the heavily partisan democracy you see in europe. And direct democracy is just terrible.

7

u/jesuz May 18 '12

Well the Greek people also decided not to pay taxes, so no revenue. And you get the government you deserve...

9

u/LordFoom May 18 '12

And you get the government you deserve...

Just world fallacy.

5

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

Here is the thing though, it doesn't matter in what country you are or where you are from. If there is a loop hole in paying taxes most people will go for it. You can't deny that.

11

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

Uh huh, but the Greek people weren't taking advantage of loopholes. They were just cheating.

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

Explain the difference.

11

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

Exploiting a loophole violates the spirit but not the letter of the law. I have no doubt Greeks did a lot of that, but they also systematically broke the law by not declaring incomes or reporting taxable transactions, by taking improper deductions, etc.

5

u/brownmatt May 18 '12

It might help to understand the huge cultural aversion against paying taxes that seems to exist in Greece.

It's hard to blame any individual for evading their taxes when they feel like it would be stupid to do so when none of their neighbors are, but collectively that kind of low participation is a huge problem.

1

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

So basically its the same as a spoiled child that is now learning the hard way. I just wish people would stop blaming said child and not the parents (the government)

4

u/[deleted] May 18 '12 edited May 18 '12

The government and people are both children of the culture.

1

u/InABritishAccent May 19 '12

There isn't really anyone you can conclusively blame except the people who lied about the numbers. Hey, yeah! Those guys! They can be the scapegoat.

In reality, the government should have sent the Greek version of the feds round and started evicting people who didn't pay. Sure, it would've caused problems. People damn well would have paid though, if the alternative is losing everything. All in all, it seems to have been an enforcement problem.

TL:DR Behold my amazing hindsight! Bask in its glory.

→ More replies (0)

4

u/shomer_fuckn_shabbos May 18 '12

I will certainly admit to not being entirely too familiar with the Greek situation, but I cannot agree with the sentiment that "you get the government you deserve".

As an American, it would seem more adept to say, "You get the government that's forced upon you". And, yes, of course - I understand that ours is by no means a dictatorship, but our republic gets further and further from its principle roots of democracy as power and wealth are continually consolidated toward the upper-echelons of the society.

I wonder how much choice the Greeks-at-large really have.

9

u/volofvol May 18 '12

I think jesuz was referring to the very common tax evasion in Greece. While I generally agree with your sentiment that in the US people don't have a complete choice, the situation is very different in Greece. Here is a good link on this: http://www.vanityfair.com/business/features/2010/10/greeks-bearing-bonds-201010?printable=true

2

u/anotherMrLizard May 18 '12

but our republic gets further and further from its principle roots of democracy as power and wealth are continually consolidated toward the upper-echelons of the society

But it is the people who are letting this happen.

2

u/VanFailin May 18 '12

Right, I'll just get the word out that we need to start voting for the other side of the coin and we'll fix it all up.

3

u/aj_reddit_gaybi May 18 '12

Ron Paul 2012? Nader? People talk about money being big things for elections. Well I don't remember candidates giving us money to vote for them, so how about tuning out their advertisement, and voting for the candidates if you really want change?

2

u/VanFailin May 18 '12

Closest we've gotten in the last century to a viable third party is the Bull Moose party. I'm asking why you blame voters, most of whom don't realistically have a chance of influencing elections, for the system's faults. Blather all you want about how every vote counts; if you approach it from a statistical perspective there is literally no point in showing up to vote in any election beyond perhaps the local scale.

2

u/aj_reddit_gaybi May 18 '12

Not trying to blame the voters, just pointing out that we as citizens have the freedom to vote. Even if your candidate or issue does not win, it still registers dissent. In India there was a movement to purposely write-in "Other" at the ballots to show dissent for the choices.

We can either rant about not have any choice, or actually do something. Every small thing if it builds could mean something.

3

u/VanFailin May 18 '12

I'm suggesting that "doing something" is actually a massive undertaking that requires a personal involvement that most people are not capable of making. I don't think small things will really add up, but rather just fizzle out as they always do.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/anotherMrLizard May 18 '12

You're working on the assumption that the people are also blameless for the fact that there is little to choose between candidates.

2

u/VanFailin May 18 '12

Are you suggesting that there is some way the average voter can actually improve the field of candidates? It is not reasonable to expect everyone to go out and canvass the town to get a different candidate on the ballot. If I had my way we'd put Calvin Coolidge on the ballot so he could do even less than he did last time (being dead and all).

3

u/anotherMrLizard May 18 '12

Not at all. Just that the current political climate has emerged from decades of apathy from the general populace. A society is reflected in its politics.

2

u/question_all_the_thi May 18 '12

It seems to me that they are not the same.

They are a democracy.

1

u/AwesomeLove May 18 '12

No sympathy from me.

I think he was asking sympathy for non-Greek banks buying Greek bonds based on lies by Greek government and said in this case it is not that banks made risky high profit bets and were bailed out by taxpayers.

4

u/delgursh May 18 '12

The real problem is that the Euro was flawed from the get go.

Its a single currency monetary union without a fiscal union and no central treasury. To join the Euro, you have to give up your nation's sovereign fiat currency and floating exchange rates. When you no longer are a sovereign currency issuer, you have added a solvency constraint to yourself.

Not every nation can be a net exporter, so its worse under a single currency union for nations who rely on imports.

Nations like Greece which are import heavy must export their Euros to Germany to buy their goods/services. Germany then has to lend them back to Greece to fund their deficits. Greece can literally run out of Euros at some point because they cannot issue them. Only the ECB can print new Euros.

If Greece was still using its own currency, it could run deficits at will because an issuer can never run out of its own currency. The deficits are there to support aggregate demand and combat the demand leakage caused by the natural trade imbalances. But when you dont issue your own currency, you have a solvency issue to deal with.

Why do you think it is that a nation like the US can have a silly huge current account deficit (we import a lot, thanks!) and never have a solvency crisis? Because as the sovereign issuer of the dollar, our government is never revenue constrained. We can run deficits at will because we create dollars (and therefore cannot run out) which support our own domestic demand and combats the demand leakage that results from being such a huge net importer.

The more you import, the larger the deficit you're going to need to keep the private sector healthy and aggregate demand up.

Its as simple as that and really not that big a deal, but 99.9% of the world do not understand fiat currencies and still has a primal, hard money way of thinking. Issuing your own sovereign currency and allowing that currency to float on the market is a huge, huge benefit.

5

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

I understood about 40%

Impressed with myself.

1

u/watermark0n May 19 '12

A lot of people have said that. I had no problem understanding this. O_o

I'm not even a european or an econ major. Perhaps I am in need of a life.

3

u/Palpatine May 18 '12

Structurally sound before house bubble bursted. I am amazed you can call someone expert when they blurt out rubbish like this.

1

u/TheJokerWasRight May 18 '12

Do you have any thoughts of your own to add? Or are you just one of those people who likes to make himself feel smart by calling smarter people dumb?

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '12 edited May 18 '12

This is in absolutely no way a solid explanation of Europe's debt crisis.

What it is is a biased, pro-German, semi-educated factory worker's interpretation of a crisis that, as he omits to mention, was born in no small part due to aggressive and downright greedy speculation by German, and to a lesser extent French banks.

The same banks that lent to obviously problematic nations, banks, organizations and individuals. They then made those loans safe by buying credit default swaps from, again, those same unstable banks.

No where does he mention that German loans to these nations allowed the German economy to prosper. From BWM's to Leopard tanks, from tooth implants to construction cranes - high quality and expensive German exports flooded Europe.

Hell, the Greek army has almost as many German main battle tanks as Germany itself.

To say that Greeks burning German flags is just misplaced anger and a national tantrum is about as truthful as saying that Mandela was over-reacting in his opposition to South Africa's apartheid regime.

Germany sponsored, promoted and benefited from Greece's financial irresponsibility like no one else.

10

u/Scarabesque May 18 '12

So you see his apparent pro-German biased stance and raise him a pro-Greek biased stance with really cheap irrelevant rhetoric to boot. Calling him a 'semi-educated factory worker' and comparing Europe's shady economic and financial policies to apartheid, really?

Everybody messed up Europe in a different way, we all have to take blame and fix it together. Your post is exemplary of why it has become near impossible to have a constructive and unbiased public discussion how to fix the European Economy by beating CountVonTroll both in bias as well as tone. Congratulations.

2

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

My favourite post was the one explaining that the EU is different to the US.

If this needs to be explained then I can finally understand why /r/AskReddit is full of posts asking for comparisons between Europe and the US when they're not, in reality, entities that can be meaningfully compared.

1

u/davidknowsbest May 18 '12

You get an upvote for teaching me about r/europe.

1

u/tidder95747 May 18 '12

This American Life broadcast an excellent explanation on this too.

link

1

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

Did Germany make a lot of their money on selling manufacturing equipment to China?

The US profited by doing the same, but it was a temporary profit.

1

u/SuperMongoloids May 19 '12

He mentioned that Ireland is in a relatively decent position. I stopped reading there.

1

u/c35 May 19 '12

I like his explanations. "They're working on it"

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I felt like somebody in this thread might need me...

1

u/legend11 May 18 '12

I can't believe I actually read all of that, and understood some of it too!

1

u/bluewhite18 May 18 '12

Just my two Euro-cents: the problem with Greece and countries like Italy and Spain is a political one. Esp Spain and Greece. Both coming from military dictatorship until the late seventies twentiest century still do have a very week middleclass ( besides the capital cities). A strong middleclass is a very important factor for a stabile state system. A strong middleclass will always create jobs, will have an interest in their surrounding and for the future of their kids. And there is a special point why Greece is in shit, kneedeep: their politicians are only puppets, their parties some kind of closed associations who simply do not care for the well being of their country in general. The really powerful people in Greece are not the prime-ministers and politicians. And those people who do have the power to make a change are just not interested. Because it would mean an end for their power and incoming money.

1

u/php4me May 18 '12

The take home message is that the Euro would have worked if they had originally offered Eurobonds and let the currency float. (it's too late to do that now)

The U.S. dollar is allowed to lose its value when the U.S. issues debt. But that's good because it makes American products competitive abroad and the system balances out again. It's a beautiful cycle.

Within the Eurozone's consistently strong currency, Germany had a competitive trade advantage and got rich off of Greece and all the other countries who had nowhere else to buy their products at a reasonable price (imagine a store that constantly sold everything inside at 85% of its normal cost). Germany got rich off this competitive advantage is now complaining they have to give back.

-3

u/MestR May 18 '12

tl;dr?

7

u/chengiz May 18 '12

Several countries in the EU have problems. They are dealing with it to varying degrees of effectiveness. Except Greece.

8

u/MisterMcDuck May 18 '12

Europe is fucked; Greece's government is shady as fuck.

3

u/Heaney555 May 18 '12

That's... not true or what he said.

1

u/watermark0n May 19 '12

It was actually a fairly bright piece on europes overall prospects compared to most of what I see today.

0

u/Pucker_Pot May 18 '12

We_who_love_freedom has another excellent post a bit deeper into the thread, particularly relevant to Irish redditors and what the fiscal compact means for Ireland and other Euro zone countries.

0

u/RexBeckett May 18 '12

The Euro Zone was predicated on nations not exceeding a pre-defined governmental debt limit, based on a set percentage of their GDP. The leaders of Greece, Spain, et al., long ago began pushing their nations to violate that crucial rule so those politicians could buy (union, especially) votes, and retain their hold on power.

Those nations have been helped already, despite their leaders' self-serving, irresponsible choices. Germany is fully within its rights if the time comes when it wants to de-link itself from those nations' economies.

-6

u/epitaphevermore May 18 '12

I come from Ireland.

I got through the second paragraph and said fuck you!

Just another informative article destroyed by opinionation.

9

u/kudoz May 18 '12

I am also from Ireland. I fail to see what your problem is.

3

u/Pucker_Pot May 18 '12 edited May 18 '12

Also from Ireland, I don't see how this was particularly opinionated at all. Relative to the other Euro zone countries in trouble, Ireland has a strong export-based economy, and it can eventually get out of the deficit crisis precipitated by a terrible bank guarantee (and other bad policies). If anything, your over-the-top reaction to a neutral, comparative statement shows your own biases.

edit: I should qualify that by saying that, relative to Greece, the pain Ireland is going to face in coming to terms with its debt problems is far less.

-1

u/epitaphevermore May 18 '12

By opinionation I mean... "They're in a temporary tight spot... and it's really just a matter of time."

Has OP got a crystal ball?... everything is really just a matter of time.

3

u/kudoz May 18 '12

No it isn't. Let's put it in a sentence: It is only a matter of time until kudoz murders epitaphevermore.

Things are only a matter of time when there are no major course adjustments needed for it to happen.

-1

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

0

u/Heaney555 May 18 '12

That was not just wrong, but moronic.

1

u/watermark0n May 19 '12

It was moronic? I have not listened to it yet myself, but I usually expect rather high quality content from TAL. Why, in your opinion, was it moronic? Could you provide a better analysis to justify your opinion? Thanks.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

Nope, it was absolutely correct and insightful. With commentary from many of the parties involved. You are the moron here.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

[deleted]

0

u/watermark0n May 19 '12

This seems awfully complicated.

It really wasn't.

In my experience - and as you know from your own upbringing, I did my best with what your father (god rest his soul) and I had - debt is a simple matter of saving money, and spending less than you make.

All this gobbledygook about interest rates and hedges, I just don't understand it! Just save your money, and don't spend your money on silly things. Like that motorcycle! You should have bought a sensible car. What about that Toyota your sister wanted to sell you? Oh, you didn't like the color? Please. That was very generous of her! You really hurt her feelings when you refused it.

This seems like an awful oversimplification.

Debt on a national level really isn't the same as debt on an individual level. For one thing, in many cases it can really be considered society lending to itself (this is why, for instance, Japan can stay solvent when they have a large comparative GDP/debt ratio - most of its debt is internal, so society is effectively loaning to itself). For another, there is no centralized debt enforcement agency when it comes to sovereign debt - the only thing securing sovereign debt is, effectively, their own reputation. No one's going to force them to pay it, people just not going to trust them in the future should they choose not to.

This is one annoying thing I see when people try to apply microeconomic ideas to the macro economy. It's nothing but the compositional fallacy - the thought that, since society is made up of individuals, society must necessarily obey the same rules as individuals. This is, again, nothing but a fallacy. A whole may obey different rules than those that apply to the parts. That leap from the micro to the macro is not self justifying.

And, now, after writing all of this, I see that you are a novelty account. Well, my mother is rather anti-intellectual and ignorant, so I suppose it is fairly accurate.

0

u/[deleted] May 18 '12

[deleted]

4

u/PersevereSC May 18 '12

Yes, governments aren't supposed to do fraud and lie about their capital

1

u/I_Am_Soulhuntre May 18 '12

What, in all of history, would have led people to think governments would not do either of those things?