r/bestof • • May 09 '12

Tuba_man eloquently explains why choosing not to make rape jokes is about more than the fight for free speech.

/r/TwoXChromosomes/comments/tdeh7/why_rape_jokes_are_never_ok_ive_got_some_guy/c4lqe5q
76 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

8

u/remmycool May 09 '12

The problem with this reasoning is that everything is hurtful to somebody.

If we're expected to self-censor with rape, is it still ok to talk about drinking in public knowing that someone nearby may have lost a loved one to a drunk driver? Can we still use drug references when they're the cause of so many deaths and broken lives? Taking it further, should I risk talking about going to the beach when there's a slim chance that some passerby just lost their mom to skin cancer? Where's the line?

10

u/waving_snail May 09 '12

I believe he was arguing that the line is common decency, and that since rape and sexual assault is something that's affected such a high proportion of the population, it is tactful and considerate to choose not to joke about this one particular subject.

It's not the talking that's the problem, it's the joking and normalization of something that may hurt people around you. Joking about cancer when a lot of people suffer from cancer? Probably a bad move. Joking about child abuse when lots of people have been hurt as children? Another bad move. It's about deciding to take responsibility for the flippant things we say, and acknowledging that choosing not to say them does not mean we are giving up on the fight for free speech, so much that we are choosing empathy for others over our need to make crude jokes.

-5

u/kznlol May 09 '12

I believe he was arguing that the line is common decency

That's not even close to sufficient. We are talking here about placing a limit on the things someone is "allowed" to say - we're talking about restricting someone's liberty, however you want to sugarcoat it. You don't get to do that when your line is as ridiculously vague as "common decency", which isn't common, shares little with any precise definition of "decent", and is culturally relative on top of everything else.

It's about deciding to take responsibility for the flippant things we say, and acknowledging that choosing not to say them does not mean we are giving up on the fight for free speech

There is an important difference between someone choosing on their own not to make a joke they think is off-color, and someone bitching that someone else is a bad person because they made the same joke.

One is a choice, the other is an attempt to compel a particular behavior.

5

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Oh, no, fine. Go ahead and make these jokes and be an asshole. I forgot that this was your first amendment right. Go ahead and make rape jokes in front of possible rape survivors. Go ahead and make pedophilia jokes around strangers you don't know who could have suffered extreme abuse.

I mean, who cares after all, am I right? We haven't experienced those kinds of things, and it's the people who experienced it who need to toughen up, am I right? I mean, we after all do live in a just world. And any depression these people get from these events - well you know what, they should just get over it. Because that's something that's suuuuuper easy to do.

-1

u/kznlol May 10 '12

Do you have an argument or is ad hominem the extent of your reasoning?

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Seriously, you're an idiot. It's not censorship. It's not liberty-restrictive. We have no way to stop you from being a complete dick if you want to. We can still tell you you're a dick, though. Normal humans at least try not to be total assholes, and pointing out when they fuck up makes them want to change.

-2

u/kznlol May 10 '12

Except for the fact that every argument that establishes the connection between making rape jokes and being a dick has an instant and obvious rejoinder that attaches equivalent selfishness to those complaining about the jokes.

I'm not saying that making off-color jokes doesn't make you something of a dick, because it does. But bitching about them also makes you something of a dick.

13

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

You're free to say whatever you like, but just recognize that if you make tactless jokes about sensitive subjects and someone gets hurt that it's ultimately your fault, especially on sensitive subjects like cancer, drug abuse, rape, etc.

Dark humor is fine and dandy but there are some life experiences that just fucking suck. Consider that every 2 minutes, someone is sexually assaulted in the US (taken from the RAINN website). Chances are that you know someone who is/was a victim. How would you feel if you inadvertently hurt them? I know I'd feel like shit, so I just don't take the risk.

-5

u/LucifersCounsel May 09 '12

if you make tactless jokes about sensitive subjects and someone gets hurt that it's ultimately your fault

So? If I make a joke about rape, and you're offended by it, feel free to fuck off. You do not have the right to not be offended.

6

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Did you not read the second paragraph I typed at all, or..?

0

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I'm rather offended that you would accuse LucifersCounsel of not reading. I know many people who died because they didn't read warning labels.

3

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Being offended isn't the same as being hurt.

But I see what you did there.

-1

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I'm hurt as well. Can't you tell?

I guess you didn't think about what your words could do.

-3

u/LucifersCounsel May 10 '12

I read it. I simply do not care. No, I wouldn't intentionally tell rape jokes to a rape victim, but I'm not going to walk around assuming everyone I meet has been raped, and I'm certainly not going to self-censor myself just in case someone within earshot might be offended.

4

u/VanillaLime May 10 '12

That's fine. Reddit isn't the PC police; we're not going to come to your house and arrest you for not being polite. But when you offend someone with a tasteless joke, don't act indignant when you are criticized. Too many people seem to think that their right to free speech also means they are immune to the consequences.

-3

u/LucifersCounsel May 10 '12

don't act indignant when you are criticized.

As if. When someone complains to me about how offensive I am, I simply show them how much more offensive I can be if I'm really trying.

If you don't want me to tell you rape jokes, the last thing you should do is tell me rape jokes offend you.

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

So your plan is to intentionally antagonize rape victims with reminders if they ask you to stop?

That's just being a dick.

-2

u/LucifersCounsel May 10 '12

No, my plan is to tell people that asking me to stop is a guaranteed way to make me not want to stop.

If the "victims" here had just ignored the post, then they would not be seeing me tell them to get over it.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

So you don't want to stop triggering rape trauma.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I'm not saying you should assume anything like the sort, or even censor yourself. It wasn't my intention to imply either of those things, sorry.

All I'm saying is that I don't like to hurt people I care about, so I have a little tact. Being offended is stupid, IMO. But being hurt isn't. There's a big difference between the two.

You're free to conduct yourself however you like, and I apologize if I came off as trying to censor you or anyone else.

-1

u/LucifersCounsel May 10 '12

All I'm saying is that I don't like to hurt people I care about, so I have a little tact.

I see the problem here. You're talking about people you care about. I'm talking about everyone else. As I said, I wouldn't tell a rape joke to someone I know was raped, but I do not concern myself with people I neither know nor care about.

That includes everyone here.

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

I do respect your opinion on saying harmful jokes to people you know are victims, don't get me wrong. I know a lot of people who won't do the same and it irks me.

You're free to say whatever you like on the Internet, but backlash doesn't equate to an attempt to censor you, or even hostility.

1

u/LucifersCounsel May 10 '12

I agree that a comment calling me an asshole is a "backlash" that doesn't amount to censorship.

However, a comment calling for my comments to be banned, does, if it is enforced by the mods/admin. So when I see someone calling for censorship, I try to nip it in the bud, before it develops into real censorship.

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

Everyone has the right to be offended, just as you have the right to make rape jokes.

Telling jokes like that makes you look like a twat, but you're well within your rights to do it ... just as people have it well within their rights to be offended.

Your statement absolutely reeks of the "fuck the world, I do what I want, if you don't like it fuck off" attitude most of us dropped in high school. The fact that you think someone doesn't have the right to be offended at a rape joke is absolutely laughable. Don't be a moron.

-1

u/LucifersCounsel May 10 '12

Everyone has the right to be offended

True, but they don't have the right to not be offended, which is what I said. You have the right to take offence at what I say. You do not have the right to stop me from saying things you might find offensive.

Your statement absolutely reeks of the "fuck the world, I do what I want, if you don't like it fuck off" attitude most of us dropped in high school.

There is also an element of "I don't give a shit what you think, so you can't insult me." That's how I avoid being offended by what other people say. (In this case your attempt to belittle me by implying I'm childish.)

-4

u/kznlol May 09 '12

but just recognize that if you make tactless jokes about sensitive subjects and someone gets hurt that it's ultimately your fault

Not by any remotely common definition of "fault" it isn't.

6

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

This is really deep. So you're saying that if this universe is completely deterministic that the "choice" to make a comment that is potentially harmful to others is really just an illusion. In that case the person who "chose" to insensitively joke about rape around potential rape victims shouldn't be blamed for "choosing" to make that comment but rather all history should be blamed for forcing him to be insensitive.

I'm personally more into holding people accountable for their actions, but I applaud you for your metaphysical liberalism.

2

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

But it goes back around, right? Decades of social conditioning have lead most of us to adopt moral systems which differentiate people as "good" or "bad" depending on their disposition. Sure, we can't fault them for being adapted into being dicks, but we can still choose to ostracize them for their form of existence, which is understanding given our psychology.

Still, a valiant effort at argument by kznlol.

0

u/kznlol May 10 '12

Actually, no, I'm saying that conventional definitions of "fault" require that you know that your action could have had the effect that you're being blamed for.

So either you're saying that I'm "at fault" for offending someone every time I make a rape joke even if nobody was offended by it, or you're saying that I'm "at fault" for offending someone with a rape joke despite not having any way of knowing that that particular joke would offend the person it did.

3

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

If I'm drinking and decide to drive. This is reckless, but there's actually a very small chance that I will harm someone. But if I do get into an accident who's at fault? I think most people would say I am because I took a greater risk.

Rape jokes have a greater risk of hurting people. Making them is reckless and I would be at fault if I hurt someone. It doesn't mean I meant to hurt anyone, but I did choose to take that risk.

0

u/kznlol May 10 '12

But if I do get into an accident who's at fault?

That's not a question that can be answered on the basis of what you've just told me.

The mere fact that you were drunk while driving does not automatically make every accident you could possibly have your fault. If you're drunk, sitting at a traffic light, and someone rams you from behind, that wasn't your fault.

Fault, as a concept, does not work when you start talking about actions which have only probabilities of causing certain consequences.

Rape jokes have a greater risk of hurting people. Making them is reckless and I would be at fault if I hurt someone. It doesn't mean I meant to hurt anyone, but I did choose to take that risk.

And yet, there exists an option (not an easy one, but an option nonetheless) for the person you hurt to have avoided that outcome, without avoiding you, or indeed doing anything to anyone else.

If I know that some people drive drunk and still choose not to put my seatbelt on, its my goddamn fault when I find myself flying headfirst into a tree.

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I'd say that it's easier to control what you say rather than the reactions of other people.

4

u/spacedout May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12

I lost my cousin to a base jumping accident 8 months ago. I never really noticed how often people joke about someone jumping/falling/being thrown off a cliff until then.

I'm not claiming I've suffered anywhere near as much as someone who's been raped, but every time someone uses some falling/cliff related metaphore, I get a little knot in my stomach.

19

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I'm not sure what this has to do with free speech. Free speech means that the government can't censor what you say, or retaliate against you because of what you say.

People being offended by what you say or getting mad at you for what you say has nothing to do with that. You can say whatever you want, and they can have the right to criticize you for what you say. You have the ability to speak out, just as others have the ability to speak out against you.

This is a discussion of social "decency" or courtesy. It has nothing to do with freedom of speech.

10

u/tuba_man May 09 '12

You are absolutely correct. The problem to me is that there are a distressing number of people on Reddit and elsewhere who at least seem to mistakenly conflate the two. Being scolded for acting discourteously is not censorship.

Just as one person is free to say what they wish, another is free to respond as they wish. Scolding (and depending on persistence, shunning) in response to hurtful speech is free speech at work.

6

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

You are absolutely correct. Unfortunately, people use "free speech" as an excuse to say shitty things all the fucking time.

-2

u/kznlol May 10 '12

The connection to free speech is not made because there's some mention of government showing up in the discussion.

The connection is made because the logic that defends the right to free speech on legal grounds applies at least partially in this case as well. At root, the idea of "social decency" is laughably subjective, and the arguments seen in the linked thread consist mostly of "you should consider other people's notions of decency", which amounts to arguing that other people's notions of decency are supposed to be more compelling than your own.

Everyone is being a dick in this argument. There's not much that can be done about it, and I'm not sure I'd want to do anything about it even if that was an option.

4

u/[deleted] May 10 '12

What I'm saying is that freedom of speech only applies to government actions. To bring it up in this setting is just silly. It's not a matter of free speech. It's a matter of what people find socially acceptable, which again has nothing to do with freedom of speech.

You have the ability to say anything you want (socially acceptable or not), and others have the right to say whether or not they think it was socially acceptable.

Yes, the idea of a social moral standard on speech is silly because of the relative nature of morals. The phrase "freedom of speech" shouldn't come up in a conversation like that, though, because it smacks of the idiot who claims freedom of speech when someone criticizes his speech. The argument simply has nothing to do with 1st Amendment rights.

People will occasionally be dicks, and you're allowed to call them dicks.

3

u/kznlol May 09 '12

I'm just going to point out that he didn't explain a goddamn thing.

He told a story, with the intent of manipulating the reader's emotions and then posed a question that amounted to a strawman fallacy.

Maybe its bestof material, maybe it isn't. But it's not an explanation by any stretch of the definition.

-3

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Why did you make me read that pointless rambling?

-6

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

What is the difference between jelly and jam?

I can't jelly my cock down your throat.

-3

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

So a child molester and a little kid are walking down a dark path... The kid looks up to the child molester and says gee sir these woods sure are scary... The child molester looks at him and say how do you think I feel, I have to walk back by myself.