r/bestof • u/waving_snail • May 09 '12
Tuba_man eloquently explains why choosing not to make rape jokes is about more than the fight for free speech.
/r/TwoXChromosomes/comments/tdeh7/why_rape_jokes_are_never_ok_ive_got_some_guy/c4lqe5q19
May 09 '12
I'm not sure what this has to do with free speech. Free speech means that the government can't censor what you say, or retaliate against you because of what you say.
People being offended by what you say or getting mad at you for what you say has nothing to do with that. You can say whatever you want, and they can have the right to criticize you for what you say. You have the ability to speak out, just as others have the ability to speak out against you.
This is a discussion of social "decency" or courtesy. It has nothing to do with freedom of speech.
10
u/tuba_man May 09 '12
You are absolutely correct. The problem to me is that there are a distressing number of people on Reddit and elsewhere who at least seem to mistakenly conflate the two. Being scolded for acting discourteously is not censorship.
Just as one person is free to say what they wish, another is free to respond as they wish. Scolding (and depending on persistence, shunning) in response to hurtful speech is free speech at work.
6
May 09 '12
You are absolutely correct. Unfortunately, people use "free speech" as an excuse to say shitty things all the fucking time.
-2
u/kznlol May 10 '12
The connection to free speech is not made because there's some mention of government showing up in the discussion.
The connection is made because the logic that defends the right to free speech on legal grounds applies at least partially in this case as well. At root, the idea of "social decency" is laughably subjective, and the arguments seen in the linked thread consist mostly of "you should consider other people's notions of decency", which amounts to arguing that other people's notions of decency are supposed to be more compelling than your own.
Everyone is being a dick in this argument. There's not much that can be done about it, and I'm not sure I'd want to do anything about it even if that was an option.
4
May 10 '12
What I'm saying is that freedom of speech only applies to government actions. To bring it up in this setting is just silly. It's not a matter of free speech. It's a matter of what people find socially acceptable, which again has nothing to do with freedom of speech.
You have the ability to say anything you want (socially acceptable or not), and others have the right to say whether or not they think it was socially acceptable.
Yes, the idea of a social moral standard on speech is silly because of the relative nature of morals. The phrase "freedom of speech" shouldn't come up in a conversation like that, though, because it smacks of the idiot who claims freedom of speech when someone criticizes his speech. The argument simply has nothing to do with 1st Amendment rights.
People will occasionally be dicks, and you're allowed to call them dicks.
3
u/kznlol May 09 '12
I'm just going to point out that he didn't explain a goddamn thing.
He told a story, with the intent of manipulating the reader's emotions and then posed a question that amounted to a strawman fallacy.
Maybe its bestof material, maybe it isn't. But it's not an explanation by any stretch of the definition.
-3
-6
May 09 '12
What is the difference between jelly and jam?
I can't jelly my cock down your throat.
1
-3
May 09 '12
So a child molester and a little kid are walking down a dark path... The kid looks up to the child molester and says gee sir these woods sure are scary... The child molester looks at him and say how do you think I feel, I have to walk back by myself.
1
8
u/remmycool May 09 '12
The problem with this reasoning is that everything is hurtful to somebody.
If we're expected to self-censor with rape, is it still ok to talk about drinking in public knowing that someone nearby may have lost a loved one to a drunk driver? Can we still use drug references when they're the cause of so many deaths and broken lives? Taking it further, should I risk talking about going to the beach when there's a slim chance that some passerby just lost their mom to skin cancer? Where's the line?