r/atheism • • Jun 19 '12

A Saudi man was executed for witchcraft and sorcery today. Today. In 20 fucking 12.

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-middle-east-18503550
1.9k Upvotes

894 comments sorted by

365

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Happens in African nations all the time.

Remember when they held a goat for robbery because the police stated that one of the criminals used witchcraft to disguise himself as a goat?

189

u/keeblur Jun 19 '12

Prove it wasn't a person disguised as a goat?! Checkmate!

→ More replies (10)

87

u/pdx_girl Jun 19 '12

You should look up the documentaries on killing little children for being witches in Nigeria.

8

u/ramsrgood Jun 19 '12

do you have a link? that sounds interesting.

edit: found one

→ More replies (30)

57

u/Quorgol Jun 19 '12

I think the biggest question is how in the world The Ministry of Magic will respond to this.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Send in the Dementors

→ More replies (2)

27

u/tiyx Jun 19 '12

In April 2008 in the Democratic Republic of Congo, 13 men were arrested for attempted penis theft as a wave of panic and public lynchings spread across the capital Kinshasa after rumours of a spate of penis snatching swept through the city’s 8 million inhabitants. The penises of the victims were snatched or shrunk by witchcraft and held hostage pending payment of a ransom.

Source

45

u/andr0medam31 Jun 19 '12

I DON'T HAVE A SMALL PENIS, A WITCH SHRUNK IT!

15

u/Andrewm319 Jun 19 '12

Does the penis weigh more than a duck? Yes?

WITCH

5

u/TimeZarg Atheist Jun 19 '12

I WAS IN THE POOL! I WAS IN THE POOL!!!

31

u/tiddercat Jun 19 '12

When you have an ignorant uneducated population, any technology looks like magic and inspires fearful magical thinking. The best defense against this insanity is education.

74

u/Swipecat Jun 19 '12

Educated as in America? Where according to a 2004 ABC News poll, the percentage of Americans who believe in Noah’s Ark -- this is Noah’s Ark, now, so we are talking about people who believe that one guy built a 450-foot wooden boat and somehow put two of every animal on it, including the animals living on continents that hadn’t been discovered yet (which means he also must have discovered and explored all of the Americas and Australia, not to mention climbed the Himalayas what for to fetch the yaks), and kept them all alive and fed and playing nicely with one another for forty days, and then got them back to where they all lived -- is 60%

23

u/ceri23 Jun 19 '12

Sounds about right. You left out the part where God sent the animals to Noah. Round about day 113 of ark construction the animals came around the bend 2 by 2 in perfect order. Thanks to cutting edge Whovian technology, Noah packed them into the boat and on came the flood. What's so hard to understand?

Witchcraft though, that's ridiculous.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/ChesterD Jun 19 '12

Less than the percentage of the population that believes a divinity without a corporeal body impregnated a young girl with his mythic penis and celestial semen.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

47

u/sometimesijustdont Jun 19 '12

Many Africans believe eating people will give you their power. In 2012.

32

u/lurker1101 Jun 19 '12

many people believe eating the body of a ghost will make you more likely to get into paradise after death. In 2012.

13

u/Narmotur Ignostic Jun 19 '12

A zombie, not a ghost! It's like you don't even know anything about the supernatural. Next you'll be telling us werewolves can't cross the threshold if you don't invite them, and you'll get us all killed.

→ More replies (4)

54

u/jij Jun 19 '12

Ahem. Africa is fucking huge. You need to be a little more specific.

212

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Many HUNGRY Africans...

→ More replies (2)

69

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

in africaville, the capitol of africa.

39

u/Grizzalbee Jun 19 '12

is that a Zynga game?

→ More replies (5)

13

u/sometimesijustdont Jun 19 '12

The reports are usually around Central Africa and Congo.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

3

u/DierdraVaal Jun 19 '12

Thermodynamically, you are correct.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

I'm Somali. My family up north in Maine had a issue earlier this year, where my aunt(who was more than likely schizophrenic) was said to have been possessed by a devil. She talked to herself, was very paranoid, etc. So they brought in an Imam to read the Qu'ran to her. They don't speak about her, she's probably dead now or falling deeper and deeper into insanity.

Its a shame that this belief in black magic, sorcery, etc is ingrained even in the Somali diaspora. It's not just African countries. I can say without a doubt that many Somalis in America would do the same thing trying to punish people within their social circles(i.e; a friend displays symptoms of a mental disorder--Qu'ran reading instead of hospital).

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

two words: uneducated religious.

→ More replies (27)

66

u/aneelio86 Jun 19 '12

Probably not a good place to vacation for Daniel Radcliffe

44

u/sbsb27 Jun 19 '12

I don't think "Saudi Arabia" and "vacation" occur together too often. Just viewed Saudi Arabia on TripAdvisor.com and every page has a TRAVEL ALERT: SECURITY CONCERNS at the top. Nuff said.

24

u/TommyPaine Jun 19 '12

They do for all observant Muslims with the means to make the Hajj.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

63

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

That's why I love living in Canada. I can practice all the sorcery I want.

8

u/QJosephP Jun 19 '12

But in America, we've got the inter-dimensional highways going for us.

3

u/bronkula Jun 19 '12

but they move so much faster through canadian brains. it's like a shortcut.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/Dirtyrobotic Jun 19 '12

Cheese was once thought to be the work of witchcraft. Many dairy farmers refuted the existence of cheese.
A few of them practiced the sacred art and cast their wicked spell on humanity. They were sought out and burned in vicious retribution for the curse they had unleashed.

Now, you can buy cheese at most stores. It is delicious and full of calcium.

18

u/TBSJJK Jun 19 '12

It is delicious and full of calcium.

I've had enough of your magic-talk for one day.

3

u/doctorcrass Jun 19 '12

cheese is made up mostly of calcium, toad's eye, and dragon blood.

3

u/Solkre Jun 19 '12

Behold, the power of cheese!

2

u/noawesomenameneeded Jun 19 '12

The Wisconsin cheese lobbyists is a power group

47

u/random_hero90 Jun 19 '12

Welcome to Saudi Arabia, where oil is the only thing we have going for us, and we still live like it's the 13th century.

30

u/Mr_Scatha Jun 19 '12

"Outraged? I'm barely surprised. This is a country where women aren't allowed to drive a car. They're not allowed to be in the company of any man other than a close relative. They're required to adhere to a dress code that would make a Maryknoll nun look like Malibu Barbie. They beheaded 121 people last year for robbery, rape, and drug trafficking. They have no free press, no elected government, no political parties. And the Royal Family allows the Religious Police to travel in groups of six carrying nightsticks and they freely and publicly beat women. But 'Brutus is an honorable man.' 17 schoolgirls were forced to burn alive because they weren't wearing the proper clothing. Am I outraged? No. . . . That is Saudi Arabia, our partners in peace." (C.J. Cregg, The West Wing)

12

u/TimeZarg Atheist Jun 19 '12

Thus proving that the US doesn't always ally with 'freedom-loving countries', and that we have no compunctions about making alliances out of geopolitical convenience :P

→ More replies (2)

25

u/ChairmanMeowth Jun 19 '12

The oil money could have been used to create a free, open, and happy society.

.. But nope.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/MegaFuckerSupreme Jun 19 '12

I always find stories like this odd.. I mean we are advanced enough that information such as this can be converted into electricity and sent across the world, yet it is a story about someone being executed for witchcraft..

14

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

In the Saudis' defense, a panel of 12 doctors agreed that the man weighed as much as a duck.

It was an open-and-shut case.

13

u/Golemfrost Jun 19 '12

But his Magic was really powerful, the bastard could turn lights on and off simply by clapping!!!!

→ More replies (2)

44

u/KnightOfCamelot Jun 19 '12

did he weigh the same as a duck?

10

u/imamonkey Jun 19 '12

And what about they guy that he turned into a newt? I'm pretty sure that the execution was justified.

→ More replies (3)

180

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Yet another reason to not visit those shit hole countries.

5

u/MaximilianKohler Ex-Theist Jun 19 '12

Those are real people over there suffering from bullshit like this... just because they're in a different country doesn't make their plight less important.

21

u/european78 Jun 19 '12

You don't have to visit... they're all immigrating here!

→ More replies (4)

53

u/speakeazy Jun 19 '12

Thanks for saying what I actually think. Not sure how there can be so many oblivious, overly politically correct first worlders out there. Especially as a nonreligious woman who hates warm environments, those places - to me - are shit holes. I got no time for a zealous nation.

→ More replies (48)
→ More replies (43)

4

u/okayifimust Jun 19 '12

"Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live."

It is perfectly okay to teach children that they should hold in high esteem a book that contains that little tidbit of information and that they should trust and worship its alleged author.

To then be outraged when somebody does precisely this is nothing but hypocritical.

Cue the wailing apologetics of how this has not been what was actually meant by those words since about 1750.

Yes, in 20 fucking 12. It's sad and shameful, but our own societies aren't much smarter, really, even though they may be a little nicer about it, usually.

4

u/allenizabeth Jun 19 '12

I don't see much hypocrisy in being outraged by this from an athiestic standpoint, but maybe I'm misunderstanding you.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/winto_bungle Jun 19 '12

You missed the fact that being a witch is not illegal in most countries.

The victim in this story was executed by the government.

"Mr Asiri was beheaded after his sentence was upheld by the country's highest courts... No details were given of what he was found guilty of beyond the charges of witchcraft and sorcery."

→ More replies (8)

6

u/NuclearOops Jun 19 '12

Here's something to mull over:

"Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live." Is a mistranslation.

A "witch" in English and according to tradition is a wise woman who uses herbs to heal the sick. In Judaism there's nothing wrong with that, it's only the mistranslation carried over into Christianity and Islam that causes this issue.

But let's focus on Christianity for a second.

The word we translate into "witch" in Hebrew is "chasapah" (in the english alphabet) and is meant to describe a poisoner, or someone who uses black (read: unnatural) magic to go against natural course of the world (read: G-d's will.)

Now let's take a second to look at Jesus Christ.

  • Turned water into wine

  • Bread into fish

  • Brought a dead man back to life

  • Cursed a fig tree that was out of season for not specifically bearing him fruit *Reversed the course of a storm

I'm sure you good folks have put the rest together yourselves.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (3)

94

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

"Witchcraft", "Sorcery", "Religion".

It's all the same.

51

u/kapiteinkaalbaard Jun 19 '12

Except that it would be superneat if witchcraft and sorcery actually existed!

65

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

"You're on my property? FIREBALL, MOTHERFUCKER!"

→ More replies (4)

16

u/QJosephP Jun 19 '12

I had a dream where in high school, my Bio class taught magic for two chapters. People were still bored and saying things like, "When am I ever going to need a spell that resurrects me if I die next turn?"

→ More replies (7)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Yeah, but this dude used sorcery to commit "adultery" with two women.

I'm just going to assume it was two women at the same time, using some kind of wacky sex mind-control spell, making it TOTALLY worth the beheading.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/airsoftdavid Jun 19 '12

I don't know about that... The third one seems the worst

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

57

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Honestly, if their religion was real and Jesus came back tomorrow, they'd probably fucking execute him.

22

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 20 '12

I was about to correct you with a 'Well actually, Saudi Arabia is predominantly Islamic, meaning that their prophet would be Mohammad, not Jesus' but then I remembered that JC has a bit-part in the Qur'an somewhere.

Fuck, why can't you be 100% wrong instead of only-a-little-bit wrong?

Edit - Jesus Christ guys, I wish I never said anything now.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Jesus is a prophet in Islam.

6

u/malmad Jun 19 '12

I guess it is a bit part. Then again, his name is mentioned more times in the Qur'an than Mohammed's.

http://www.islam101.com/history/people/prophets/jesus/christ_in_islam2.htm

9

u/cynognathus Secular Humanist Jun 19 '12

He has a little bit more than just a bit part.

In Islam, Jesus' story is much the same as it is in Christianity: Born of a virgin, prophet to the people of Israel, had disciples. The differences being that he's seen as neither the son of god nor god incarnate and he was not crucified but rather ascended into heaven. Additionally, he's seen as the messiah and is expected to return to Earth to usher in a period of peace and justice.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (7)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

if their religion was real

Are you saying that their mosques are CGI and that they don't actually kneel on prayer mats while reciting the Quran?

→ More replies (20)

144

u/ozymandias2 Jun 19 '12

To be fair, in Saudi Arabia, he might actually be guilty. Given the lack of details, it is entirely possible that the man actually thought he was a witch, and was trying to use magic to harm others. WE know that it does not work, but many times the people in the countries with these sorts of laws do not know that. That is why education is so important.

As to his guilt, if he thought of himself as a witch, and engaged in actions that he honestly believed would bring harm or damage to another through the use of magic, well, is that really all that different than attempted murder, or attempted assault? Keep in mind, that he may have thought his magic was as effective as shooting his victim.

Please keep in mind, I find this barbaric, and I am against capital punishments in all forms, but this man may not be the innocent victim we assume he was because we understand that witchcraft is not real. He may be a very guilty man.

44

u/Kaluthir Jun 19 '12

Upvoted for making me think!

17

u/ozymandias2 Jun 19 '12

Thanks. I was a little worried that people were going to spam me with down votes because they disagree with me -- or misunderstand what I was saying.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (30)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Actus Reus. One cannot be held criminally liable simply for having a guilty mind. The mental state must be coupled with an overt act commited in furtherance of the crime.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

In the educated world we call that mental illness.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Kodix Jun 19 '12

Sort of. Finding talismans and books (if there were even such) means absolutely nothing even if he thought witchcraft was real, though.

It's like finding a knife. It does not prove any malicious intent. Surely, there's other possible uses for witchcraft than cursing people, even in the small minds of the saudi.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/noawesomenameneeded Jun 19 '12

As to his guilt, if he thought of himself as a witch, and engaged in actions that he honestly believed would bring harm or damage to another through the use of magic, well, is that really all that different than attempted murder, or attempted assault?

Yes, it is very different. In attempted murder I have made an attempt in ending your life, which can actually happen. No matter how much he thought his magic could harm someone the end result is never harm to that person. By this logic, me laying in bed and wishing/praying/daydreaming harm on you would be punishable by death even though they would never happen unless I took physical action to make them happen.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12

If someone attempted to conjure up some voodoo on me and failed, and stopped short of actually doing anything serious, I would totally laugh it off, and I would not say that that is a guilty man. I might suspect that there is another issue at hand, but it isn't my issue.

People should not be held accountable for hateful thoughts alone; they can hate all they want (I am reminded of a wise proverb from our time: "Hatters gonna hate."). It is when someone attempts dangerous actions that we must take action. However, we ought not simply lock people away simply because we fear the might of their voodoo, we must also see whether their actions actually bear a reasonable causal link to potential harm.

→ More replies (38)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

deep man. have an upvote!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JohnFrum Jun 19 '12

Education doesn't always help. Look how popular chiropractic is in the US or homeopathy is in Germany. Some of the most well educated people I know swear by acupuncture.

2

u/dblthnk Jun 19 '12

Or he could have been taking off his socks before a storm blew in, cause that's another way you can tell.

2

u/unwanted_puppy Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12

On the point of guiltiness by the law, it sounds like you are suggesting Saudi Arabian authorities convicted him b/c they lacked education to the degree of believing his witch craft was dangerous?

I would just like to point out that this is extremely unlikely. The superstition alone would be considered heresy in Islam. Though we lack details, I would wager that the basis for his guilt was neither the man's intent nor his threat of power, but his instead his participation in a practice considered 'idolatry' (and breaking the first pillar of Islam) under Shariah Law.

Sorry, if I misunderstood.

2

u/toodrunktofuck Jun 19 '12

But then they were "right" (apart from killing him) for the wrong reasons and that is a very, very bad kind of being wrong. If he committed actual crimes (in our sense) then charge him accordingly.

4

u/BornAgainNewsTroll Jun 19 '12

It doesn't matter what his state of mind was, his witch craft could not have the intended effect. It was impossible for his actions to have the intended result, therefore no crime can be done. The crime is a figment of his imagination. His misunderstanding of the world around him and its lack of an effect on anyone does not mean society should punish him. If he was mentally ill, but as of yet diagnosed, should he be charged with a crime if he actually thinks he can pull it off just by thinking so?

I realize, that in Saudi Arabia, his actions likely were a crime, and he probably knew that he could be executed for them. The legal system of Saudi Arabia does not protect his thoughts, like many other countries do. This occurs often in countries that have a religiously influenced government. The US is also guilty of condemning many for impossible actions. Examples: catch a predator setups, drug deals by cops, and hiring cops as hit men. No one knows for 100% if any of those people charged/convicted under these laws would have acted the same in a different scenario. Many states in the US don't allow such setups for the reasons I state here.

No one should be punished for thought crimes. Our mind is the only place we are really, truly, free. Our thoughts do not hurt anyone else until we act or fail to act on them. I think punishing people for thought crimes is a violation of basic human rights. Humanity deserves better government than what we have created to date.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (61)

6

u/ChonkyWonk Jun 19 '12

Did everybody miss the part where he admitted to two counts of adultery as well? In Saudi Arabia adultery can be punishable by death so while it's fun to make it all about witchcraft it's not the full story.

6

u/saleh353 Jun 19 '12

As a Saudi I feel obligated to explain

the question is: even if sorcery was a criminal activity by Islamic law why the strongest possible punishment?

it is mainly due to the fact most of these who hide as fortune tellers or faith healers or whatever, used to be nothing more than assassins, hired guns, poison dealers, kidnappers and the like, some of them actually still exist.

not to mention the human sacrifice which was very common in the pre-Islam era, and now it's coming back due to the lack of education especially in the southern part of Saudi, which the government paid no attention to during the oil money boom in the 70's

Most of the rituals those people conduct are orgies and defecating on/burning the Qur'an, you can imagine how the response to that might be in very militant society like ours.

yet currently they are nothing but scam artists who travel the kingdom looking for the ideal target, uneducated women with lots of money looking for revenge of another woman who stole her loved one and so desperate to get him back that she is willing to spend all her money on those thugs.

sorry for the long comment but I hope I gave you guys some perspective.

3

u/domestic_omnom Jun 19 '12

Does that actually happen, or is it just propaganda that is thrown about to scare people into exterminating the undesirerables like christians used to do in Europe.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (7)

14

u/LeSpatula Anti-Theist Jun 19 '12

It's okay, Reddit keeps telling me that Religion isn't bad and we should respect it.

5

u/NuclearOops Jun 19 '12

While it's sad and upsetting to hear of this happening anywhere, some places I feel are less shocking than others.

I have low expectations set for Saudi Arabia, and sympathy for the unstable and war torn nations in Africa. So when I hear of events like this in those places I'm more willing to accept it.

But whenever I hear about something like this in India it baffles me. There have been too many reports from India of an entire village stoning a person to death (usually a woman) while police looked on not 100 ft away. Maybe I've set my expectations too high for developing nations.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/q8ty Jun 19 '12

As a citizen of Kuwait, I can tell you that being charged with using "black magic" and "sorcery" is quite common among immigrants, especially from Bangladesh. Although the punishment is not as extreme as an execution, they do get deported and/or earn a lengthy term in prison.

Edit: Repeated "the".

8

u/chazysciota Jun 19 '12

Oh come on... it's not 2012 in Saudi Arabia.

26

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Oh, and this is the religion of peace...

→ More replies (8)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

I'm sorry, but... I don't find this that surprising in the least bit...

2

u/unwanted_puppy Jun 19 '12

Yea that's how I felt. Reading all these bewildered comments makes me realize how little context people have about the ME, esp. the extent of Islamic Law. As crazy as it is, convicting adulterers and "heretics" is pretty much all in a day's work in SA.

3

u/Slurm28 Jun 19 '12

And how do you know they were not a witch?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Can you prove he wasnt a sorcerer?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Dude, my Country makes it illegal to see a breast in public, and take a pledge to trust in fairytale wizards. Humanity is fucked up in a lot of places.

3

u/draxxis Jun 19 '12

They found Voldemort. We're all safe now.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

You think just because it's 2012 witchcraft and sorcery just up and vanished??

3

u/eternallyscrewd Jun 19 '12

The scary part here is that there are people in the USofA that would do the same thing if it weren't in our Constitution to allow religious freedom. This thread alone would warrant a death sentence.

5

u/Revolutionary2012 Jun 19 '12

Surely we should be invading to 'promote democracy'? We HATE regimes that murder and kill it's people, especially Islamic one's.. Oh no wait.. They're ok as long as they're out friends and sell us oil at the right price, I always forget that last bit.

5

u/thunnus Jun 19 '12

Whenever I read something like this, I am reminded to be grateful that I wasn't born in that fetid armpit of the world.

5

u/JonWood007 Humanist Jun 19 '12

It's Saudi Arabia. They also think beating their wives is okay. What do you expect from a fundamentalist Muslim country?

→ More replies (2)

8

u/redditreset Jun 19 '12

It isn't 2012 everywhere.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Yeah seriously its 2012, sorcery?

2

u/P3T3RK3Y5 Deist Jun 19 '12

Since we have a dependence on oil from Saudi, I don't see the us (e.g. the US State Department) speaking out very much on this. Love to be wrong. We're pro-human rights when it's convenient for us. And when it's not - we're not. Which is another way of saying we're not really pro-human rights we just like to think we are. I now return you to your regularly scheduled moral high ground.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/der_muellmann Jun 19 '12

He oughtn't have been practicing sorcery in a place that looks so lowly upon it.

2

u/unisorN Jun 19 '12

It's so sad, because if he was practicing "witchcraft and wizardry," he's be at Hogwrts performing so cool shit.

2

u/Crossbowshootr Atheist Jun 19 '12

Stuff like this makes me doubt the intelligence of Middle Eastern people sometimes.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Animal_King Jun 19 '12

You don't understand man. You've never been there. THIS SHIT'S ACTUALLY REAL ಠ_ಠ. You ever notice that all the major religions come from the desert one way or another?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

fortune telling and faith healing

I see nothing wrong here.

2

u/Dookiestain_LaFlair Jun 19 '12

Should have rolled barbarian.

2

u/PubicWildlife Jun 19 '12

When the oil runs out, may you fucking suffer.

2

u/marler92 Jun 19 '12

Did they at least give them the fair trial of throwing them in the river? If they float- they're a witch. If they drown- not a witch

2

u/lorax108 Jun 19 '12

saudi arabia america's best friend! we have started two wars to "protect" that asshole fucked up morons of the royal saudi family... fuck those people.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

funny how believing in witchcraft and sorcery is funny and stupid, but believing in an invisible man who lives in the clouds and talks to you via various shrubberies is completely normal...

...Go go humans for being so fucking stupid...

2

u/Samuriguy Jun 19 '12

Well what do you all expect with religion existing in the world? If it weren't for religion, education could have gotten to these countries a lot faster, preventing this.

2

u/QuestionAnything Jun 19 '12

So maybe I should cancel that Free Spirit festival I booked in Medina?

2

u/Evil_Morg Jun 19 '12

Who would have thought that forty three years after we landed on the moon we would still be executing people for sorcery.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Hope he cast soul stone resurrection first.

2

u/redditor9000 Pastafarian Jun 19 '12

In defense of Saudia Arabia, they are in the dark ages still.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Fuck cultural relativism

2

u/brnitschke Jun 19 '12

Muslim's don't use the year of our lord. It's actually only 1112 for them.

2

u/abaddon82 Jun 19 '12

Explains a lot.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

So what?

You do know it's Saudi Arabia, right?

2

u/roberto429n Jun 19 '12

Man, the sorcery in Essos must make it a crazy place to liv-- wait, where did this happen?

2

u/Bobby_Marks Jun 19 '12

How is this any different from the United States helping Israel continue the crusades to keep Muslims out of the holy land?

2

u/HeisenbergSpecial Jun 19 '12

He knew that sorcery was against the law, and yet he did it anyway! Therefore, he should accept whatever punishment he's been given.

/sarcasm

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

I grew up in the middle east so maybe I can shed some light. Many people, and by that I mean most muslims I know, believe in "Jinn" (I think thats how its spelled) They are little spirits/demons that run around causing problems, I like to picture the little guys from the game show Whammy. They believe that people can communicate with them, and many say that they have friends or relatives that can talk to them regularly, and some said they have talked to them directly. I believe it is some part of Islam, but I'm not exactly sure because my friends never really talked about it much. They say it is against theyre religion to talk to the Jin or even to try to talk to them. So this guy might have been trying to talk to the Jinn to do bad things or something and he most likely legitimatly believed he was able to do so, as well as the people that killed him.

Tl;Dr: They think they can talk to the little guys from the game show Whammy.

Edit: Here is the wiki page on the Jinn

2

u/MisterFlibble Jun 19 '12

"Bullshit make-believe system executes a man for practicing another bullshit make-believe system."

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

We're in 2012, they're in 612.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

We're all going to shit bricks when it comes out that sorcery and magic are real things and that us non-magic users have really been slaying witches and sorcerers because of their devil magic.

2

u/big_onion Jun 19 '12

The man, Muree bin Ali bin Issa al-Asiri, was found in possession of books and talismans, SPA said.

Note to self: do not play D&D in Saudi Arabia.

2

u/wayndom Jun 19 '12

In 20 fucking 12.

In Saudi fucking Arabia.

2

u/SilverCrutches Jun 19 '12

another chemist bites the dust. =(

2

u/PsiAmp Jun 19 '12

Some, he explains, have repeatedly called for the strongest possible punishments against anyone suspected of sorcery - whether they are fortune tellers or faith healers.

I'm OK with that.

2

u/GanoesParan Jun 19 '12

In 2150 being executed for witchcraft will be more common than dying of old age.

2

u/vespian_pickles Jun 20 '12

Well, I'm not using his wizard build for the inferno level. I can tell you that much.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

Let them kill each other, I don't care anymore. They want to let themselves be ruled by backwater religious fanatics that's their own damn problem not mine. Yes, I am American and I don't care about other countries problems because guess what, it's not my country we have our own issues to fix. One for one and all for none!

2

u/Depression-Unlocked Jun 20 '12

I'm sorry but WGAS? As long as the news is religious killing religious I don't care. If it was a scientist, doctor or secular humanitarian it would be a different story.

2

u/Sunny1261 Jun 20 '12

Don't forget the time change. If it's 2012 here, it's at least 1600 there. Easy.

2

u/daddyhominum Jun 20 '12

[email protected] On the tragedy of the change in rule in Saudi Arabia

To: Mr. Osamah A. Al Sanosi Ahmad, Ambassador

This is a note of sympathy to the people of your nation in their misfortune to replace the old ruler with a new ruler as cruel and ignorant as any man whoever lived on this earth. I am, of course, referring to his failure to prevent the murder of a man on the ridiculous charges of sorcery and witchcraft. I am ashamed to live under the same sky as he does.

2

u/nugz85 Jun 20 '12

Well, it is only 1433 in the Muslim calender. Seems right on track.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12

This is the country US is constantly exporting masses of weapons into. I don't even want to imagine how many people will eventually suffer and die because of these weapons in the hands of the Saudi royalty.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

It isn't because they believe that shit, they just didn't like the guy and didn't have a solid reason for killing him. You know like US didn't have a solid reason for invading Iraq and just made shit up.

2

u/doctorcrass Jun 19 '12

couldn't they have planted drugs on him or make someone falsely testify that he raped someone or something along those lines like we do in the civilized world? We didn't invade iraq to stop them from conjuring up demon's we made up a more convincing reason.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ithinkimlogical Jun 19 '12

Do atheists believe in the super natural? What about sorcery and witchcraft or the ability to somehow control or call upon super natural forces? I'm curious to know.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Oh, noes, people in barbaric countries act in barbaric ways! What a surprise! I would have never seen this coming!

Now, if someone was executed today in Texas for witchcraft or sorcery I might be able to muster some outrage.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Islam is about 300-400 years behind the Christians.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/holy_paladin_irl Jun 19 '12

Look man in the middle east using your phone to watch a movie makes you a wizard. The school of magic used is western.

Fuck Islam and muslims who follow it this fundamentally

2

u/grecy Jun 19 '12

In other 20 fucking 12 news:

  • Gay couples are banned from marriage and are actively protested against
    and

  • Millions of people in the richest country in the world can't get the basic medical care they need because they don't have enough money.

2

u/BowlEcho Jun 19 '12

Fucking religion.

1

u/Knotcher Jun 19 '12

In the immortal, sarcastic words of Adam Carolla: "Can't judge"

Although, I did hear he turned a man into a newt.

2

u/MustangGuy Jun 19 '12

Last report is he got better.

1

u/DocDerry Jun 19 '12

Note to self- Do not move to Saudi Arabia.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/munch_the_gunch Jun 19 '12

Every time i start to think about how things are going badly in America, i read some awful shit like this and it makes me feel better about where i live

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

I don't want to live on this planet anymore.

1

u/infernusx0 Jun 19 '12

Sorcery and witchcraft? I guess you could say.... He lost his mind!

1

u/conundrum4u2 Jun 19 '12

It really should be Witchcraft OR Sorcery, since they are basically the same thing...unless you are GW Bush, and count Wiccans as people who believe in witchcraft...(yes, he was asked why he did not think a Wiccan soldier should be allowed a requested wiccan symbol on his headstone in Arlington Cemetery...he said "because I don't believe in Witchcraft" - (but then, he has a lot of friends in Saudi Arabia)

1

u/grackychan Jun 19 '12

Yer not a wizard 'Arry..

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Well the government could be demon-possessed. Even if not, it's legit to kill the person because after all, "do not suffer a witch to live".

Did I mention that religion is organized superstition?

1

u/MasterStevans Jun 19 '12

Well he shouldn't of used Witchcraft...

1

u/zerophewl Jun 19 '12

I see Saudi Arabia is still in a full blown dark age. I am excited for them, in a century or two they will enter the enlightenment age, a very exciting age.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Are we sure that whatever word Saudis use is being correctly translated to "witchcraft and sorcery?"

1

u/Hraboskyjr Jun 19 '12

You're telling me there was a sorcerer that we killed?? WTF!

1

u/idontgivetwoshits Jun 19 '12

funny shit going on around the world

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Is this the chick that tries to interview you in Mass Effect? I think they have the same name.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Stupid muggles

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

And they are a US ally? Dafuq?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/PinguWithAnM Jun 19 '12

I know, it sickens me too that it took them so long.

1

u/rylos Jun 19 '12

" says there is a very strong prohibition of some practices from the country's powerful conservative religious leaders.

Some, he explains, have repeatedly called for the strongest possible punishments against anyone suspected of sorcery - whether they are fortune tellers or faith healers. "

So it doesn't count as "faith healing" when the religous pray for someone to be healed?

1

u/_Yugen_ Jun 19 '12

This should tell you something about "progress" that so many people seem to ignore. History is a tale of one step forward, one step back. Sorry.

1

u/chadsexytime Jun 19 '12

Yeah, I thought we got them all back in the 1600's.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

This is why we don't go to Saudi Arabia

1

u/Sepulchural Jun 19 '12

People in power labeling people as witches (or whatever synonym you choose for it) is old hat. What's even more messed up is they are often tortured into "admittting" that they are witches in order to secure prosecution.

1

u/fotiphoto Jun 19 '12

I guess they found his "magic; the gathering" cards.

1

u/modsherearefags Jun 19 '12

Witches and atheism? I am confused, religious fanatics kill themselves at a high rate every day. They are crazy and chopping each others heads off. Nothing new. Not atheist relevant.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

What makes you think it's 20 fucking 12 in Saudi fucking Arabia?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

entire countries are being destroyed because of resources in 2012

1

u/DID_IT_FOR_YOU Jun 19 '12

Guess what not every country is a 1st world country or even a 2nd. I consider Saudi Arabia a 3rd world country when it comes to human rights and just common sense.

Doesn't matter the year when each country is developing at its own pace and on its own path.

1

u/tits595 Jun 19 '12

I suppose it's used there as a way of framing/getting rid of political enemies and the like

1

u/deaft Jun 19 '12

BARBARIANS, we haven't done that for the last 0.0075% of human civilization!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

But if they believe in their god being able to triumph all, and that no other forces are as powerful, then his witchcraft and sorcery shouldn't really be an issue right? And if he was so good, why wouldn't he sorcery them.. and make them not kill him? And I want all of these people to suffer and die with their convictions and become civilized. I hate them and I wish they were dead.

1

u/EvOllj Jun 19 '12

I dare you to tell me a religion that does not involve faith healing.

1

u/oldboyy Jun 19 '12

remember it is saudi arabia, people get wipped there, women aren't allowed to drive and walk around by themselves...

1

u/Flashfight Jun 19 '12

I could have fucking sworn we killed all those sorcerers off years ago. God damn it.

1

u/post_post_modernism Jun 19 '12

How do you know he wasn't a sorcerer?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

When I took anthropology we watched a video where a boy goes missing in rural africa and they are questioning his friend about it.

His friend claims a which turned the boy into a warthog. They then ran the witch out of town.

1

u/MysterVaper Jun 19 '12

For the briefest moment I thought nothing could surprise me...then this article....wtf really.

1

u/i3unneh Jun 19 '12

Runescape is now officially a game about religion and swords.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

Doesn't matter what year it is when the country you're in has a government that basically teleports you back to the dark ages, but gives you guns.

1

u/camnaron Jun 19 '12

Im starting to think the Human race had a good run but its time for us to go...

1

u/Hyper1on Jun 19 '12

In these countries it isn't 2012. It's 1212.

1

u/HugeDongOnYou Jun 19 '12

It is sad to see that Wizards don't have equal rights in 2012.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12

see Kim Jong Il and Than Shwe atheists. want me to keep going? this is the same way you persecute christians. doesn't feel so good does it :)

1

u/Amytherocklobster Jun 19 '12

Reason shall set us free.

1

u/What_am_I_even_sayin Jun 19 '12

What if I told you that witchcraft and sorcery were what is now known as technology?

1

u/boomer15x Jun 19 '12

"In 20 fucking 12." This part pisses me off the most, its like only religion has to do with bad shit happening, have you been living under a rock? did you hear about a man eating another mans' face?

1

u/helalo Jun 19 '12

sounds like a good vacation sport for chris angel.