r/atheism • • Jun 17 '12

/r/atheism, this is a bigger deal than memes. For the first time in history, the legal entity behind the Jehovah's Witnesses was found to be responsible for the repeated rape of a 9 year old girl.

I saw the news article briefly pop up on the radar of /r/atheism a few days ago, and I was surprised that it didn't even make the front page. As you can see, this story is starting to get a tremendous amount of coverage: Google News, as it should.

There is more to this story than just how it affects Jehovah's Witnesses. Being an ex-Witness myself, I'll admit that I have a dog in this fight. But even though this ruling has the potential to affect me in a positive way (by helping more JWs come to realize that their religion is not the "Truth," at minimum), this is a bigger story than just the Jehovah's Witnesses.

This is, as I understand it, one of the largest monetary awards to have been given to someone who had been abused, at least partially because of a church's malicious negligence. Is this what starts to help people realize that culpability of the Catholic Church? Does seeing a religious institution held responsible cause people to realize that perhaps religion in general shouldn't have such a privileged place in society?

I hope that it's a step in that direction. And, I hope that this story continues to gain traction. I know of people who have had their eyes open as a result of this story, along with others like it. This one is unique, though, in so many ways, and is a better opportunity than some that have come in the past for some of the reasons I've mentioned.

I think that this HUGE group of people within /r/atheism predominately want to see our society move closer to secularism. I think most of us want to see religion lose it's position as an unquestionable entity, and it seems to me that we're seeing that happen, one step at a time. A case like this has the potential to move these efforts forward in a big way. I hope we are able to give it the exposure and attention that it deserves.

1.9k Upvotes

679 comments sorted by

416

u/BantamBasher135 Anti-Theist Jun 17 '12

"Jonathan Kendrick was not a leader or a pastor, he was just a rank-and-file member."

Your title is a bit sensationalist. Which is a shame, because this is a big deal.

58

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

And the ruling found the Watchtower Bible and Tract Society of New York to be partially responsible for some of the things he did, and because of their willingness to sweep this, and other, horrible people and actions, under the rug, the jury ruled against them to the tune of around 21 million dollars. The big deal to me is the fact that the policies of the Watchtower organization were recognized as contributing toward an environment that protects pedophiles. I didn't mean to be sensationalist in my title, and I'm sorry you feel that way, but this is a huge deal that goes beyond just the Jehovah's Witness organization. I'm happy to see a few steps toward justice being done, and I'm happy to see that the wishes of the victim are being fulfilled, at least to some extent.

7

u/BantamBasher135 Anti-Theist Jun 18 '12

You truly are one uplifting mofo.

→ More replies (5)

173

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Perhaps it is a little sensationalist, however the article does state that the congregation acted under a policy of keeping sex abuse secret. The judgement reflects that they may have known his previous conviction and yet not informed parents or others who may have been in a position to help her or understand changes in her behaviour.

85

u/Kind_Of_A_Dick Agnostic Atheist Jun 18 '12

Do a search for Amish sexual abuse to read about a policy of keeping things secret.

56

u/gimpwiz Jun 18 '12

And now it's a lot harder to think of them as cheery hard workers who just happen to dislike technology. Bah.

54

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Repeated rape of an 8-year-old girl by her family members happened in an Amish community near where I grew up. The elders of the community vehemently protested that the DA had no right to prosecute because the guilty parties had already been justly punished. Their punishment? Two weeks of banishment from church...

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (5)

22

u/Faltriwall Jun 18 '12

Ms. Conti also said in her lawsuit that the Christian denomination’s national leaders formed a policy in 1989 that instructed the church’s elders to keep child sex abuse accusations secret. Congregation elders followed that policy when Mr. Kendrick was convicted in 1994 of misdemeanor child molestation in Alameda County, according to Mr. Simons.

Information from the plaintiff. Maybe true, maybe not. Also, it states it applies to allegations. Allegation /= Conviction.

29

u/Bobby_Marks Jun 18 '12

Not defending the bastards, but I have worked in children's programs for over a decade I can explain those policies.

There are good folks who spend years getting educated to teach children. Many of them get teaching degrees. One accusation of abuse, regardless of whether or not charges are pressed and even if the court rules in favor of the defendant, can end your career. As a result, churches often have non-disclosure policies regarding these things.

However, apparently Kendrick admitted in 1993 to the church that he had touched his step-daughter's breast. They demoted him, kept him away from children, interviewed the family... But did not publicly announce his actions to the church. The family initially chose not to press charges, which means the church could have been legally liable for slander had they drug him in front of the congregation.

The family had him charged in 1994, and he was convicted of a misdemeanor. The church claims they never knew of this. I am inclined to agree with them for the simple reason that most churches won't let a convicted molester anywhere near children, because they are more concerned with their money than they are with their friends. It's the exact kind of thing that leads to a church paying $30 million dollars for tolerating one volunteer worker.

Again, not an excuse and I'm glad that will probably put them out of business, but some insight into the business of working with kids.

→ More replies (29)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (12)

56

u/JWTA Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

I apologize for the "wall of text", but this is all very good AND important information.

This is how the Watchtower Society and it's members handle child abuse:

Child Abuse Handling Notice it says "never suggest to anyone that they should not..." which also means "never suggest anyone that they should. Their first point of action is to call their headquarters, not the police. It's wrong from the beginning.

After being in court so much they finally changed their procedures to that shown above. As if it helps at all.

What child molester has more than 1 witness to his actions? "only one witness" The very idea of that is ridiculous. Everything about pedophilia revolves around secrecy and patient grooming.

Jehovah's Witnesses are often neglected and just viewed as a crazy religion with good hearted people, and while the people may be just that, the doctrine and rules they follow have done unimaginable harm to many and don't let anyone tell you otherwise. Much more harm is done than possibly waking you up a little early on a Saturday morning. The more exposure we can gain with this the more members we can get out of this cult.

We're a small force over at /r/exjw but we will be sending this new information to our local news outlets, any help from /r/atheism would be greatly appreciated.

PLEASE HELP us get exposure to this issue. The procedures for dealing with child abuse make this religion a HAVEN for Pedophiles, due to their "1 Witness" business.

For an EXCELLENT summary please take maybe 5 minutes and read this page:

JW Facts - Pedophilia

For more information on this specific issue please visit:

Silent Lambs

Watchtower Documents

*The images are directly from the Jehovah's Witness Elder's Manual entitled "Shepard the Flock of God"

It would be great to see more News Stories such as this one

NBC News Coverage

Here's an experience from a former Elder in the congregation. Taken from the Jehovah's Witness Recovery web site in the CHILD ABUSE FORUM. Yes, it's so rampant that it has it's own section.


"Here's a little story that helped me decide that I didn't want to be an "elder", and helped me away from the borg.

A man had moved into the congregation a few years before. His letter of intro. (letters of introduction by the way are worthy of a whole other discussion) indicated that many years ago he had spent time in prison. The letter didn't say why and no one really thought to ask. The letter indicated that he was an "exemplary" publisher.

"He was clearly "reaching out" and after a year and a half or so was recommended as a ministerial servant by the elder body. Someone told him that he had been recommended and that based on the circuit overseers comments it was likely to go through. He was very happy about this.

The circuit overseer sends the letter to the "branch", a letter comes back a few weeks later saying that his appointment was not approved because he was a child molester! Come to find out he had raped a little girl, and that is what his prison time was for.

Here's the behind the scenes:

Two elders were assigned to talk to the molester and tell him that he wouldn't be appointed. You should also know that all the elders in this cong. had been called in from different parts of the circuit because of their experience etc., to help this cong. that didn't have any "elders" and had been through some turmoil.

At the next "elders" meeting they reported what happened. The molester was very angry and said "Why can't everybody just move on!". I was immediately outraged and thought to myself that it was a good thing that I wasn't there when he said that. Bastard!

Here is the response of the "experienced elders" (possibly 50-60 years "eldering" between the two of them): "The poor man is frustrated. You can't blame him. He just wants to serve Jehovah." This was said very emphatically btw. Not one thought of the victim.

All they could see is that this guy wanted a "position" in the congregation. I felt like I was the only one that could see how repulsive the molesters' arrogant behavior was.

The next time the circuit overseer came around, the subject was discussed and I expressed my strong disgust and my desire to tell the molester how horrid his attitude was.

I was told, "When you sign on as an "elder" you become a company man. The Society tell us that we have to treat all of our brothers with kindness no matter how disgusting we may think what they have done is."

I realized that I wouldn't be able to live up to such "high" standards."

→ More replies (14)

13

u/seeingredagain Jun 18 '12

There really is no "rank and file" member in JWs, though. Men can all claim that they cannot serve in the military as they are all ministers and everyone going from door to door is a "publisher". Witnesses are not taught that they are rank and file. This is a huge for the leadership to call them as such. It goes against everything they've been telling the "rank and file" for generations. Granted I was never a Witness, but I did study the bible with them and this is what I was taught.

6

u/NovaeDeArx Jun 18 '12

Join the JWs, where every janitor is a Senior Sanitation Technician, and every housewife is a Domestic Engineer!

...No, you still do all the same work. But you get an important-sounding title! Just like everybody else!

5

u/Deadlyd0g Jun 18 '12

Good post to ask this question, wtf is a Jehovah's witness?

11

u/mjkarleskint Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

They're technically "Christians", but they don't believe in the Trinity (they don't believe Jesus was "God" or a part of "God"). They don't celebrate holidays or birthdays. They go door-to-door knocking to proselytize and hand out short magazines and pamphlets. They have their own version of the bible, which isn't surprising as there are dozens of versions. They don't accept blood transfusions or give blood. The religion was founded in the late 1800s (1890 I believe) by Charles Taze Russell. They predicted the end of the world and were wrong a few times. They no longer predict the specific date of the end of the world.

So, if you want any other information, I suggest Google. Please forgive any mistakes; I'm just going off memory here.

Edit: Added italicized phrase (see below comments).

9

u/radiohaed Jun 18 '12

The way you said "They no longer predict the end of the world" doesn't sound right They just don't make specific predictions anymore. They still constantly preach that armageddon is getting closer and closer, and that it could happen literally any day, even tomorrow.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

I wish people would understand that this is not simply about the abuser being a Jehovah's Witness, it is about the Jehovah's Witness organization coercing the victim not to report him to the police and failing to protect other children from him. If you're going to tell someone not to contact the police because it should be something the organization handles internally, and the organization doesn't handle it, there's a problem.

3

u/Theocritic Jun 18 '12

The Watchtower has actually had policies in their organization that has led people to suffer. Not allowing people blood transfusions, not allowing people to vote

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

[deleted]

41

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

Thank you for explaining it to everybody. I've mentioned this in r/exjw but I grew up a witness and have had several members of my family molested by a then believing uncle and a cousin molested by her father.

As nobody besides the victims and the perpetrator were witnesses to the crime the elders did nothing with the information. The guidelines the society has put forward keep child abuse and spousal abuse secret. Their first duty is to the society itself so it is not blamed and then to the elders. There is never a thought for the victim.

Now, because the congregation has its own rules and the family is given strict orders to follow jehovah's(god) direction then they will not violate those orders et forth for fear of discipline. I can see why they got awarded money, this law of theirs supersedes the law of the land and that helps wrongdoers get away.

7

u/IConrad Jun 18 '12

As nobody besides the victims and the perpetrator were victims to the crime the elders did nothing with the information.

witness to the crime... (Not to nitpick, just... yeah.)

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

[deleted]

18

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

If they didn't report it to the police, they are an accomplice.

→ More replies (4)

184

u/gratuitous_italics Jun 17 '12

I would much rather see the Jehovah's Witnesses be brought to justice for their medieval attitudes toward modern medicine in general, and blood transfusions in particular.

Abuse of a child is a terrible thing, but no matter how you look at this the Jehovah's Witnesses are related to this tangentially at best. I wish you had been a little more honest with the title of your post.

35

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

I'm sorry that you feel that I was dishonest. I agree that Jehovah's Witnesses should update their thinking with regard to blood transfusions, but the difficulty there is that adults choose whether to accept medical treatment or not, and for the most part, minors receive blood transfusions when they are needed, because a court order will generally be issued.

Child abuse is a HUGE issue for the Jehovah's Witness religion. I've seen their correspondence with regard to policies related to child abuse, and I've seen the way the policies actually work out. People are put in harms way because of the way the Watchtower instructs their followers to react to issues like this. This ruling is a big deal, and it affects potentially millions of people. I know people that have, in the past few days, taken positive steps to reevaluate their beliefs because of this case. Not just the ruling, but also some of the details that the case has brought out and made public. According to the plaintiff, this was one of the major reasons she decided to bring this case to trial - to affect a change. Obviously her ordeal was horrific, but I'm glad to see the outcome that she had hoped for begin to take shape.

45

u/gratuitous_italics Jun 18 '12

No, I'm at fault here. I looked into the issue in greater depth and had no idea how prevalent the abuse is, or how underhanded the Jehovah's Witnesses are in covering up allegations. The idea that you can use a system which presupposes if it went unwitnessed, it didn't happen where child abuse is concerned is morally disgusting.

I was wrong to call you dishonest, and I hope you'll accept an apology.

23

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

I can't believe that "someone on the internet" gave me an apology, but I will gladly accept it. Thank you for looking into it, and for replying. I don't know what else I can say, this basically blows my mind. . .

17

u/JWTA Jun 18 '12

No offense or anything meant, but could you edit your original comment saying this? Just so people don't get the wrong idea?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

19

u/JWTA Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

I apologize for the "wall of text", but this is all very good AND important information.

This is how the Watchtower Society and it's members handle child abuse:

Child Abuse Handling Notice it says "never suggest to anyone that they should not..." which also means "never suggest anyone that they should. Their first point of action is to call their headquarters, not the police. It's wrong from the beginning.

After being in court so much they finally changed their procedures to that shown above. As if it helps at all.

What child molester has more than 1 witness to his actions? "only one witness" The very idea of that is ridiculous. Everything about pedophilia revolves around secrecy and patient grooming.

Jehovah's Witnesses are often neglected and just viewed as a crazy religion with good hearted people, and while the people may be just that, the doctrine and rules they follow have done unimaginable harm to many and don't let anyone tell you otherwise. Much more harm is done than possibly waking you up a little early on a Saturday morning. The more exposure we can gain with this the more members we can get out of this cult.

We're a small force over at /r/exjw but we will be sending this new information to our local news outlets, any help from /r/atheism would be greatly appreciated.

PLEASE HELP us get exposure to this issue. The procedures for dealing with child abuse make this religion a HAVEN for Pedophiles, due to their "1 Witness" business.

For an EXCELLENT summary please take maybe 5 minutes and read this page:

JW Facts - Pedophilia

For more information on this specific issue please visit:

Silent Lambs

Watchtower Documents

*The images are directly from the Jehovah's Witness Elder's Manual entitled "Shepard the Flock of God"

It would be great to see more News Stories such as this one

NBC News Coverage

Here's an experience from a former Elder in the congregation. Taken from the Jehovah's Witness Recovery web site in the CHILD ABUSE FORUM. Yes, it's so rampant that it has it's own section.


"Here's a little story that helped me decide that I didn't want to be an "elder", and helped me away from the borg.

A man had moved into the congregation a few years before. His letter of intro. (letters of introduction by the way are worthy of a whole other discussion) indicated that many years ago he had spent time in prison. The letter didn't say why and no one really thought to ask. The letter indicated that he was an "exemplary" publisher.

"He was clearly "reaching out" and after a year and a half or so was recommended as a ministerial servant by the elder body. Someone told him that he had been recommended and that based on the circuit overseers comments it was likely to go through. He was very happy about this.

The circuit overseer sends the letter to the "branch", a letter comes back a few weeks later saying that his appointment was not approved because he was a child molester! Come to find out he had raped a little girl, and that is what his prison time was for.

Here's the behind the scenes:

Two elders were assigned to talk to the molester and tell him that he wouldn't be appointed. You should also know that all the elders in this cong. had been called in from different parts of the circuit because of their experience etc., to help this cong. that didn't have any "elders" and had been through some turmoil.

At the next "elders" meeting they reported what happened. The molester was very angry and said "Why can't everybody just move on!". I was immediately outraged and thought to myself that it was a good thing that I wasn't there when he said that. Bastard!

Here is the response of the "experienced elders" (possibly 50-60 years "eldering" between the two of them): "The poor man is frustrated. You can't blame him. He just wants to serve Jehovah." This was said very emphatically btw. Not one thought of the victim.

All they could see is that this guy wanted a "position" in the congregation. I felt like I was the only one that could see how repulsive the molesters' arrogant behavior was.

The next time the circuit overseer came around, the subject was discussed and I expressed my strong disgust and my desire to tell the molester how horrid his attitude was.

I was told, "When you sign on as an "elder" you become a company man. The Society tell us that we have to treat all of our brothers with kindness no matter how disgusting we may think what they have done is."

I realized that I wouldn't be able to live up to such "high" standards."

→ More replies (2)

14

u/JupitersClock Jun 18 '12

I asked my parents when I was 15 if I ever needed a blood transfusion would they give it to me. They said no.

Religion kills.

42

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

As an ex-witness, I know someone who was effected by her parents stupid-ass opinion about blood transfusions. Poor kid.

7

u/sorrowerthe Jun 18 '12

Some J's witness, whom I buzzed in without looking, replied that nowadays they are being permitted by their faith to have 'synthetic' blood transfusionS... Kinda sounded weird to me but hey, I just can't br mad at people that just don't really know better...

5

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Gotta love religious logic. The blood that "God" put into other humans is unholy, but the man-made shit is fine. Can't we just inject them with wine? That should be holy enough.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

[deleted]

21

u/Aulritta Jun 18 '12

So, there is very likely a document or policy book that contains instructions to cover up child abuse and molestation? I would imagine the Watchtower's appeal would be over very quickly once the motion for discovery produced it...

Actually, such a motion ought to have been in the initial trial, since that was part of the prosecution's argument. Hmmm...

Also, congrats on getting away! I just hope it didn't cost you everything to do so.

39

u/Popcom Jun 18 '12

(39)If the accused denies the accusation, the investigating elders should try to arrange a meeting with him and the accuser together. (Note: If the accusation involves child sexual abuse and the victim is currently a minor, the elders should contact the branch office before arranging a meeting with the child and the alleged abuser.) If the accuser or the accused is unwilling to meet with the elders or if the accused continues to deny the accusation of a single witness and the wrongdoing is not established, the elders will leave matters in Jehovah's hands.

From the "Sheperd the Flock of God" book, page 72.

→ More replies (16)

17

u/tacofeet Jun 18 '12

There is such a document. You can read it on the ex jw subreddit.

7

u/seeingredagain Jun 18 '12

Look on r/exjw. There are excerpts from a "secret" elders' book there that tells the elders how to deal with any legal situations, not just in cases of sexual abuse. Here is only one such link.

http://imgur.com/a/IDaPo#0

This is on the front page of r/exjw now.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/TheLateThagSimmons Ex-Jehovah's Witness Jun 18 '12

Can't say I've ever met an ex-bethelite turned atheist/ex-JW. I mean, sure, they must exist. But you're probably the first I've personally come across (even if it is just over the internet).

I was two month out from going to MTS when I decided I couldn't believe it anymore.

I'd love to pick your brain for a couple of hours over some beers. And I don't associate with many ex-JWs.

2

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 19 '12

Well, we haven't technically met, but I know we've had a good amount of interaction over in /r/exjw. but I'm also an ex-bethelite turned atheist/ex-JW, for what it's worth.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

So it's a catholic church style scandal? I wonder how people will respond to yet another religious institution with a reputation for kiddy fiddling. Can we start calling this a trend?

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (9)

6

u/fwowaway Jun 18 '12

Let me tell you a story about a JW I once knew...

In my first year of university (Comp Sci) one student stuck out a bit - he was 61. Everyone else was less than 25.

He was a JW and tried to preach a bit, but was given a stern warning by the university to keep his mouth shut about religion.

One day he left class early. Turns out he was going to give evidence at his sons inquest.

His son, who was 18, was found dead in a homeless hostel haven taken a lethal cocktail of drugs.

Five years before this, the JW fellow arrived home and smelled marujana in his sons roon. He chucked him out immediately. He made his only child homeless at 13 because he'd had a spliff. There was no mother in the family as she had died some years previously.

As you can imagine the coroner tried to rip the JW a new one. He was told that had he not chucked his son out and had been a proper dad his son would probably still be alive. He responded to the coroner that he had no regrets as he was unwilling to live with anyone who would not abide by the 'truth'.

The local media made him a hate figure for a short while, but his congregation rallied around him and supported him for doing 'the right thing'.

He was a horrible person and I refused to have anything to do with him after that.

1

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

Sadly I've heard other stories with similar endings.

36

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

/r/atheism, this is a bigger deal than memes. For the first time in history, the legal entity behind the Jehovah's Witnesses was found to be responsible for the repeated rape of a 9 year old girl.

Compared to the Catholic church, it's nothing. As sad as it is to say it, this is just "news as usual" for religion.

13

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

I know that Jehovah's Witnesses are smaller than the Catholic Church. It was my understanding that this was one of the larger (if not one of the largest) individual rulings against an organized religion specifically because they enacted policies that created the opportunity for an abuser to abuse again. I hope that this sets a precedent, even if it only means that more cases are brought to trial.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Hopefully now the Catholic Church can be prosecuted as the criminal enterprise it is.

→ More replies (1)

55

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

Yes, but to ex-Jehovah's Witnesses (such as myself), this is a HUGE deal. Something that could make a HUGE impact on millions of lives.

43

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12

I'm also an ex-JW, and I am also extremely gratified to see these people be held accountable for at least one of their terribly long list of grievous crimes.

16

u/MagicBob78 Jun 18 '12

could you expound on some of their terribly long list of grievous crimes? My mother-in-law is JW and I just want to know the bad about this particular religion.

→ More replies (45)

6

u/MrCheeze Secular Humanist Jun 18 '12

It may not be that meaningful, but it IS the kind of thing that can actually change someone's mind.

2

u/weird-oh Jun 20 '12

Yes, with the Catholics, it's usually boys. I can't help but think that, as an ex-JW myself, the perpetrator thought it was OK because he wasn't being "gay" with anyone. What a reprehensible way to run a "religion."

→ More replies (1)

4

u/quicklookleft Jun 18 '12

Welcome to Catholicism wow. New sect, oh my!

4

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

I've heard similar comments from ex-catholics who have converted to become Jehovah's Witnesses, years ago, only to circle back and realize that they left Catholicism for another religion far too similar to it.

4

u/quicklookleft Jun 18 '12

Yep, if you break Christianity down its all the same, catholics, Mormons and johovas witness are often seen as cult like.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

What I want to know is, when will the government go after the religious organizations who openly harbor child predators and abusers? Why are these organizations allowed to exists if their policy is to hide the fact that members prey on children? If it becomes a known fact that it is policy to ignore children being molested and raped, and if the pedophiles are not handed over immediately for prosecution, these organizations should be forced to lose tax exempt status.

3

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

I don't know, and I want to see this changed, very badly. I hope that cases like this, and the awareness they generate, bring us closer to a time that ANY organization, religious or otherwise, is culpable for hiding people who prey on children.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/D_as_in_avid Jun 18 '12

Would be a great AMA - "I am a Jehovah Witless - AMA."

Sorry but I'm too lazy to google any info on these people. Who... Who exactly are they? I know of them, every month or so they'll ring my doorbell, but being in a private school all you learn about them is that they are a cult and are brainwashed. (Ironic that a private school said that)

What's it like being one? Do you think clearly? It seems as if they aren't humanized and they just lost their sense of reality.

I apologize again - this isn't an AMA, it's about allegations of the "cult." I'm just curious to where this cult came about and it seems you know of them since you were one.

3

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

I've done a couple of AMAs in the past. I was a Jehovah's Witness elder for a little while, and have "served" in a wide variety of capacities as a JW. I'm glad to answer any questions you have.

Who are they? If you go back far enough, you'll see that they branched from the Millerites after the Great Disappointment. Charles T. Russell "started" the group, or I should say, started the Bible Students. After he died, Joseph Rutherford took over, in a somewhat sneaky fashion, and around 2/3 or 3/4 left. However, he held on to the real estate and much of the money. With that, he made drastic changes (including the name) and made the Watchtower what it is, basically, today.

They practice shunning (called disfellowshipping), and refuse blood transfusions. Most converts seem to be lower income / relatively uneducated. However, many members are genuinely good people, interested in being the best they can be. They're expected to follow everything that the leadership tells them to do, though, and sometimes that works out less than ideally.

What's it like being one? You feel like you have all the answers, and that the rest of the world is sadly on a course toward imminent destruction. If you have a moral question, you can find an answer in a book written by the Watchtower Corp. You do, it turns out, dehumanize non-JWs by calling them "worldly," or worse, ex-JWs, you think of as being led directly by Satan himself. You think they are 'mentally diseased.' If anything is wrong in your life, or in the congregation you attend, you think that you're not giving enough of yourself, you're not active enough, or you just need to wait on Jehovah, and he'll take care of it.

They have a pretty varied history, of which most active JWs know little about, since they believe that 'the light gets brighter,' so they don't review older publications, always assuming that the most recent publications contain the real truth, while the older stuff might have not been quite as correct.

3

u/TheFlyingBastard Jun 18 '12

You know what you should do? Check out our subreddit: /r/exjw.

In short, you think you think clearly, but you really don't. You're being taught a view of the world that is completely opposite of reality. It creates an atmosphere of "everyone in the world has been deceived by Satan except the six million of us, that's why we are hated, be happy and smile and don't talk back because we'll take away your family."

We all have had different experiences, so please, do stop by, browse a bit, ask questions, we're very open to sharing.

3

u/PortlandME Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

I prefer when r/atheism is a gathering place for people who don't have god as part of their lives rather than a recruitment center for the war on religion. I feel better knowing there are others like me, atheism was a very independant choice and finding this forum helped ease a loneliness I didn't know I carried. I just want to be respected as someone who chose not to have God in their life, not seen as a threat to all things holy. Religion helps many get past the uncertainty, hardships and enormity of life, it can be a scary world to face every morning, and I can name several who have turned to God as a tool to redesign lives that were going down unhealthy paths. I may see religion as a crutch, but crutches help you move forward. I want to defend children, you're on your own taking down the church.

3

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

I don't disagree with these sentiments, but many, many posts here have had much to do with making fun of religion or the religious. The /r/atheism sub is just as often about religions as it is about being non-religious, it seems to me.

And, when I posted originally, the majority of the front page was made up of memes that mocked religion, and I got a bit frustrated that something that seemed to me to be actually REALLY newsworthy barely made a blip on the radar. Not only that, but the victim herself wanted this story to be published far and wide, because she wants to see these policies change, and the only way that there's a chance they might, at least in my opinion, is to raise public awareness of them, which it seems reddit in general is fairly good at.

I have family that still belongs to this religion, and I fear for their safety. I know they have abusers in their hall, and I've told them who it is. The problem is, I only know this because I was a JW elder, and as an elder I was privy to this information. In the Jehovah's Witness community, you are taught to blindly have faith in anybody that's a fellow JW. This creates a bit of a perfect storm, from the perspective of an abuser. I want to see people know of these risks. If, in the process, they stop believing the religion, all the better, but I'm not at war with the religion. I think people are better off viewing the world as it is, but I don't really care what they believe until it puts other people in danger - especially little kids.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/MOABADM Jun 29 '12

If this had been an Atheist, do you think it would be such a big deal? A girl was raped. Who gives two shits about the rapist's religion?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Humidity is rising - Barometer's getting low According to all sources, the street's the place to go Cause tonight for the first time Just about half-past ten For the first time in history It's gonna start raining men.

Some of the post titles here make my eyes turn. Surely if this is the first time it speaks for the organisation rather than against it... Most (probably all) organisations of any form above a certain size have rapists within them, as can be inferred by probabilistic logic.

2

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

It's the first time because they have always settled cases like this, and included gag orders. And I'm sorry that you don't like the title.

5

u/ForcedToJoin Jun 18 '12

What a weird place to put "for the first time in history".

Were you really expecting there to be another case in history of a legal entity behind Jehovah's Witnesses being found to be responsible for the repeated rape of a 9 year old girl?

That would be an amazing coincidence.

12

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

I'm sure I could have worded it better. I have a limited worldview, I'm sure, and was approaching this from the perspective that the Jehovah's Witness religion has never lost a case related to abuse like this, even though their policies seem to create an ideal scenario for molesters. Spokesmen for the JW religion have pointed that out on occasion, so it seemed like it was noteworthy. My intention wasn't to be sensationalist (though I've certainly been called that a number of times in this thread).

10

u/SecretAgentX9 Jun 18 '12

There have been many, many attempts. I know of people personally who have had very similar experiences and either settled or lost in court.

It might seem dumb but it's a very big deal to us XJWs.

→ More replies (1)

446

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

"This is a tragic case where a member of a religious group has brought liability on the group for actions he alone may have taken."

Fuck you, Jim McCabe, this is a tragic case where a child was preyed upon.

I couldn't give two shits about Jehovah's Witnesses' reputation.

If a Ronald McDonald clown molested a kid and his manager tried to skirt around it I bet you'd be pissed.

154

u/Pups_the_Jew Jun 18 '12

Just imagine how many children have been hurt because of this attitude. Can you imagine the widespread abuses in the Catholic Church would be nearly so vast without a hierarchy willing to develop systems to hide the abuses simply to protect their reputation?

66

u/question_all_the_thi Jun 18 '12

And this is when one must not separate the attitudes of the members from the attitudes of the institution.

As a parallel, when the US occupied Europe in 1945, general George Marshall, the supreme commander, set an explicit order that all cases of rape committed by American troops should be investigated and punished. In this case one could say the US Army should not be guilty of the rapes eventually committed by American soldiers.

As an opposite example, the Serbian troops were instigated by their superiors to rape the opposition civilians during the Yugoslav civil war in the 1990s. In this case rape was an act of war ordered by the Serbian high command.

When the institution protects the rapists, as was the case of the Serbian military, as is the case in the Catholic church, and now the Jehovah Witnesses, then the acts of the individuals become the acts of the institution itself.

23

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

The funniest part of this whole thing is that the JWs LOVE to lambast the Catholic Church for their pedophile scandal.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/canteloupy Jun 18 '12

The parents of the children also often told them to shut up. Endoctrination is a powerful drug.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

89

u/a_flyin_muffin Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

Isn't it so sad that the church might get a bad name because of this? They are concerned for the wrong freaking people. It pisses me off. This reminds me of a Russian joke (loosely translated): "Honey, stop hitting your brother in the head with that shovel, you might break a sweat." Edit: typo Edit: apparently I'm the worst speller on reddit.

76

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Ah yes....the rare Russian biting shovel.

57

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

In soviet Russia, shovel bite you.

→ More replies (8)

12

u/labialuncheon Jun 18 '12

Not as rare as you'd think.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

How is clown molestation different than regular molestation? ;)

Seriously though, I love how people seem to be failing to grasp that the JWs are being help culpable because they put the child in danger on purpose. They're being charged because they were in a position to prevent the abuse but instead decided to focus on their own asses. If it were anyone else who couldn't claim clergy privilege, they'd have their asses in jail for obstruction of justice.

3

u/BUT_OP_WILL_DELIVER Jun 18 '12

It's insidious how supposedly moral religious institutions are prepared to cover up the hineous crime of child rape in order to protect their public image. Fuck those people.

5

u/ToastintheMachine Jun 18 '12

Willard Scott was the first Ronald McDonald clown. Google "willard scott creepy". Weep for humanity.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

No the clown is a HD20 soulless abberation from the depth of the 13th circle of the abyss. Micky Ds do serve delicious fries though, also found to be insoluable to the rigors of time.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

And if a Ronald McDonald clown molested a kid, we wouldn't be attributing the blame to the entirety of the McDonald's organization.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

We would if the McDonald's organization, knowing what happened, not only kept this Ronald McDonald on the payroll and in regular contact with children after the incident, but actively threatened and coerced the victim and his/her family not to call the police.

The issue is not simply that a Jehovah's Witness molested kids. There are bad people in any group. That's not why the organization is being help culpable. They're being held responsible because they regularly A) coerce victims not to contact the police and "let the organization handle it," and B) fail to "handle it" and allow these monsters regular contact with children for years afterward. The Jehovah's Witness organization is a pedophile paradise. There are an incredible number of people who have come forward as victims of abuse and in so many of those cases, nothing happens to the abusers. The Watchtower organization even keeps a database of accused pedophiles, so they are well aware of the problem. Check out silentlambs.org

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

While I certainly see your point I don't think you are completely understanding what it is he is trying to say. He isn't condoning what happened he is simply stating that this asshat that did this heinous act will make is seem to the general population that all JW's are child rapist. Look at the Catholic Church and the vast mistrust of their priest now, due to a few sick whacko's for sure. Can you imagine people perceiving you as a child rapist simply because you are a member of a group? What happens when a child rapist is found within a group of atheist friends? Does this mean all atheist are rapist? I think not.

13

u/bumwine Jun 18 '12

The criticism against Catholics is the shuffling around of pedophiles and the fact that we hear about these things years later because of how well they've been hushed (like with the Ireland story recently) .

The JWs are actually very similar as Catholics in this regard as they believe that things like this should be handled internally and that god and the holy spirit will sort them out. Its exactly why Elders are only instructed to report child molestation in states where it is specifically required by law to report it, they keep it internally whenever they had to (as they did in this case).

46

u/ShadowMongoose Jun 18 '12

Look at the Catholic Church and the vast mistrust of their priest now, due to a few sick whacko's for sure. Can you imagine people perceiving you as a child rapist simply because you are a member of a group?

False.

The Catholic Church is perceived as fully frelled-up because they used their influence to protect child rapists rather than their victims. Regardless of how you prioritize the two acts, they are two different acts. No one is arguing that the Catholic Church as an entity raped children, they are arguing against the ex post facto actions of the organization which, for you or me, would land us a fast conviction for aiding and abetting.

The same applies here, if an organization is more concerned over its own reputation than the well-being of its members, it deserves to be... pardon the ill-humor... crucified.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/jimicus Jun 18 '12

Look at the Catholic Church and the vast mistrust of their priest now, due to a few sick whacko's for sure.

Yep. The sickest whacko of all is the Pope.

Why, you may ask, do I say that? Well, when this all blew up in Ireland not so long ago, the government took strong, immediate steps. They apologised profusely for having allowed it to happen, put laws in place that made it abundantly clear that the church was not above the law and basically did everything you'd expect of a government that had just been hugely embarrassed by the biggest child abuse scandal in Europe.

Reasonably enough, they hoped the Church would take a similarly strong stance. Which it did - the Pope immediately announced that there was no room for child molesters in his institution, his office in the Vatican worked with Gardai to set up a freephone number that connected directly to a special team whose job it was to record any such allegations in the strictest confidence and pass them on to a unit tasked with investigating them.

(quickly checks my sources to make sure I'm remembering all that correctly)

Ah... no. My mistake. The pope did nothing of the sort; he called upon his flock to pray for both the victims and their attackers.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

I think you are missing the point. If the church had a policy of zero tolerance for child abuse and molestation, people would have more trust in the clergy. Knowing that it is the policy to hide and ignore it while continuing to allow these pedophiles to work with kids is what destroys the trust, not the fact there one priest or clergyman is a child rapist.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/heimdal77 Jun 18 '12

I had a "aunt" (just called her aunt wasn't really) was the sweetest old lady you ever meet. Then one day brought up about other religions in front of her and you never saw such a 180 in a person just out of nowhere turned evil and full of anger/hate and going on about Witness is the only true religion. Needless to say was a real shock to me and even a little scary to see such a sudden change.

→ More replies (1)

95

u/Phosfene Jun 18 '12

Oh thank the gods. They were responsible for returning me to a physically and sexually abusive home after going to them about my step father's abuse.

→ More replies (4)

38

u/JWTA Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

I hope this isn't too late to get buried. I apologize for the "wall of text", but this is all very good AND important information.

This is how the Watchtower Society and it's members handle child abuse:

Child Abuse Handling Notice it says "never suggest to anyone that they should not..." which also means "never suggest anyone that they should. Their first point of action is to call their headquarters, not the police. It's wrong from the beginning.

After being in court so much they finally changed their procedures to that shown above. As if it helps at all.

What child molester has more than 1 witness to his actions? "only one witness" The very idea of that is ridiculous. Everything about pedophilia revolves around secrecy and patient grooming.

Jehovah's Witnesses are often neglected and just viewed as a crazy religion with good hearted people, and while the people may be just that, the doctrine and rules they follow have done unimaginable harm to many and don't let anyone tell you otherwise. Much more harm is done than possibly waking you up a little early on a Saturday morning. The more exposure we can gain with this the more members we can get out of this cult.

We're a small force over at /r/exjw but we will be sending this new information to our local news outlets, any help from /r/atheism would be greatly appreciated.

PLEASE HELP us get exposure to this issue. The procedures for dealing with child abuse make this religion a HAVEN for Pedophiles, due to their "1 Witness" business.

For an EXCELLENT summary please take maybe 5 minutes and read this page:

JW Facts - Pedophilia

For more information on this specific issue please visit:

Silent Lambs

Watchtower Documents

*The images are directly from the Jehovah's Witness Elder's Manual entitled "Shepard the Flock of God"

It would be great to see more News Stories such as this one

NBC News Coverage

Here's an experience from a former Elder in the congregation. Taken from the Jehovah's Witness Recovery web site in the CHILD ABUSE FORUM. Yes, it's so rampant that it has it's own section.


"Here's a little story that helped me decide that I didn't want to be an "elder", and helped me away from the borg.

A man had moved into the congregation a few years before. His letter of intro. (letters of introduction by the way are worthy of a whole other discussion) indicated that many years ago he had spent time in prison. The letter didn't say why and no one really thought to ask. The letter indicated that he was an "exemplary" publisher.

"He was clearly "reaching out" and after a year and a half or so was recommended as a ministerial servant by the elder body. Someone told him that he had been recommended and that based on the circuit overseers comments it was likely to go through. He was very happy about this.

The circuit overseer sends the letter to the "branch", a letter comes back a few weeks later saying that his appointment was not approved because he was a child molester! Come to find out he had raped a little girl, and that is what his prison time was for.

Here's the behind the scenes:

Two elders were assigned to talk to the molester and tell him that he wouldn't be appointed. You should also know that all the elders in this cong. had been called in from different parts of the circuit because of their experience etc., to help this cong. that didn't have any "elders" and had been through some turmoil.

At the next "elders" meeting they reported what happened. The molester was very angry and said "Why can't everybody just move on!". I was immediately outraged and thought to myself that it was a good thing that I wasn't there when he said that. Bastard!

Here is the response of the "experienced elders" (possibly 50-60 years "eldering" between the two of them): "The poor man is frustrated. You can't blame him. He just wants to serve Jehovah." This was said very emphatically btw. Not one thought of the victim.

All they could see is that this guy wanted a "position" in the congregation. I felt like I was the only one that could see how repulsive the molesters' arrogant behavior was.

The next time the circuit overseer came around, the subject was discussed and I expressed my strong disgust and my desire to tell the molester how horrid his attitude was.

I was told, "When you sign on as an "elder" you become a company man. The Society tell us that we have to treat all of our brothers with kindness no matter how disgusting we may think what they have done is."

I realized that I wouldn't be able to live up to such "high" standards."

18

u/DerpTheGinger Jun 18 '12

Before reading this thread, and your post in particular; "Oh, JWs are just really annoying religious pushovers." Now: "WHAT THE FUCK!?!?!?!" Thank you for realizing how fucking awful JWs are.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Go to silentlambs.org for more info about JW child abuse.

12

u/BooUrns24 Jun 18 '12

My ex boyfriend is a Jehovah's witness, and he is so incredibly messed up by the upbrining he had. He was molested by his cousin and was told by his mother and a JW Brother that he was making it up, They didn't even try to help him with it or try to stop it. He left the ' truth ' for quite a few years and has recently gone back to it. I have no idea why anyone would go back after what he went through. we have a three year old daughter who he is drilling it into her about how she needs to grow up as a JW. It makes me sick really. Witnesses talk about how they are so much above every other person, it pisses me off when they think they never do anything bad, when it is obvious that they do!!

11

u/Supervisor194 Ex-Jehovah's Witness Jun 18 '12

Make sure you give your daughter all the love and support she needs to stay the HELL away from her father's ridiculous religion. This is a mind control cult as I'm sure you know all too well. It's a dangerous mind virus. Your ex could infect your daughter and it could lead to very bad things. Don't let that happen. Stay on the alert.

5

u/BooUrns24 Jun 18 '12

I am hoping that simple things, like celebrating Christmas and Birthdays will help her stay away from it. That might sound childish, but it could work! I definitely want her to grow up with the knowledge that she doesn't have to believe something just because her Father does. I already pick up a few things that she says, which I can tell are just words from her Dad repeating bullshit to her.

Another terrible things, my Ex's 4 year old niece said to me, " If you don't believe what me and my family believes, God is going to kill you and your baby and your Mum. " It shocked me so much to hear these words come out of a 4 year olds mouth. It is SO wrong!!

8

u/rachamacc Jun 18 '12

If you ever need to vent, there's an r/exjw. I know at least a few are unbelieving with JW partners. it's a strangeness not a lot of people are familiar with, but we are.

3

u/BooUrns24 Jun 18 '12

Thanks for that, that will actually help! I even just got a message from my Ex about some JW stuff. So annoying!!

→ More replies (1)

66

u/benderrific Jun 18 '12

My dad used to be a Jehovahs Witness. God what a horrible 12 years that was. No holidays, no birthdays, no sports, nothing. Parents were always fighting, violence, almost divorced because of those people. They kept telling my dad to divorce her and he wouldn't. Since then we have moved 4 times, and they always find us and come to our house every other Sunday to give my dad The Watchtower, even though he hasn't attended a single meeting in 10+ years and repeatedly tells them hes never coming back. I hate those people. And I don't use the word "hate" loosely.

33

u/JupitersClock Jun 18 '12

I'm with ya there bro. We moved at least a dozen times. 7 different schools. Being a JW didn't help with those matters as you become an outcast with each new school you attend. No brithdays, No holidays, Parents discouraged me from playing sports (didn't stop me), Making friends, hanging out with said friends. I truly despise this cult.

19

u/Deadlyd0g Jun 18 '12

Why can you not play sports...the hell...

24

u/JupitersClock Jun 18 '12

They felt if you have free time it should be devoted to Jehovah. Also you would be associating with "worldly people".

Feels bad man. I don't want any kid to go through that bullshit like myself and others have.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/dorkydragon Jun 18 '12

"Worldly influence." Can't have you making ties with anyone who isn't also in the congregation. You know, because then you'll "stray from the Truth."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/RoadWarrior043 Jun 18 '12

I don't know about that. As an ex-JW myself, I know that divorce is heavy stuff that most JW's won't even talk about, it's usually just out of the question. I can't see congregation members actively encouraging a member to divorce their spouse. I'd like a more thorough explanation, if you would.

10

u/benderrific Jun 18 '12

I've shared my story with people before and there were some ex-JWs that said the same thing. They said they had never heard of Jehovah's witnesses doing that sort of thing. Was my dad a member of a bad group or something? These JW's would come to our house and try and persuade my dad to leave, or sometimes i would overhear them talking before or after a service. I can't remember if it was a friend of my dads from the Kingdom hall or if it was the leader or what. My mom was catholic, which is reason #1 why they didnt agree with the marriage. My moms problem was that they would make my dad take us, the kids, out "door to door" to talk about the religion and stuff and she thought it was a bad, dangerous thing to make us go to strangers doors. Also, those giant conventions that we had to go to occasionally (the ones that lasted an entire weekend) were often held in stadiums that weren't air conditioned, or partially outside. (we lived in southern florida) And to drag my sister and I there when we hated it, it was hot, boring, and stupid. We were never allowed to even bring anything to do. I slept a lot.

In the end, after much inner struggle I decided that I dont want to be a part of any religion.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

They probably encouraged "separation".

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Deadlyd0g Jun 18 '12

You can get a restraining order...or just point a gun at them and tell them to fuck off.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

shit, no birthday or x-mas presents and they rape you? fuck that.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/JtiksPies Pantheist Jun 18 '12

This will probably get downvoted, but I honestly don't think the actions of some people who are religious should reflect the belief and what it is. Sure the organization may be at fault, but you don't have to a member of the Catholic church to believe in Catholicism (for example). So if members of Jehovah's Witnesses were responsible for this, then prosecute the people for the action, not the belief as well. I understand and agree with the move towards secularism but doing so because of the abusive actions of some religious members is not right. Religion was not abusing the girl, some of the religious followers were

11

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

I don't disagree with your comment, but in this case the leadership had put in place policies that made it easier for abusers to have access to children, and policies that made it less likely that abusers would be caught.

I don't think that Jehovah's Witnesses are, in general, more likely to be abusers , but the policies of Jehovah's Witnesses makes it a safer place for abusers to hide, and decreases the likelihood of actually being arrested, since so much is handled internally. And, I think that's a pretty bad thing.

8

u/HerVajesty Jun 18 '12

I absolutely agree with your point. That would be absolutley unfair, my extended family are all JWs and they certainly do not deserve to be stereotyped or affected by this one man's actions.

However, in this case the religious organisation was responsible for not reporting and handling the issue properly i.e. letting the bastard get away and letting Jehovah deal with it instead. SO I think the religion is responsible by setting up a culture of secrecy instead of "no-tolerance".

6

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

It's a fuzzy line to be sure. Your extended family may be all good people who have never a direct party to child abuse or coverups. But if they're part of a group and support a culture that permits such things and they remain complacent and all of their brothers and sister do as well and the church gains it's authority from the support of its members? From a certain point of view the blame can cast a pretty large net.

Evil persists when good men do nothing. And if your family does nothing to affect change the consequence is living with the baggage the JW organizations earns for itself.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/rachamacc Jun 18 '12

Their rule for having two witnesses for any judicial action is straight from the bible. Their policy of previously pressuring victims to not go to the police is straight from the religious leaders. They are taught to not bring reproach on their religion by making problems public. They are taught to go to the elders first with any problems and that the whole world outside their religion is controlled by Satan. The elders are instructed to call headquarters first with any allegation of sexual abuse, so hq can tell them if they're required to report it. Not all states in the US require reporting. They do not tell congregation members about members who convicted sex offenders. They believe god's holy spirit will protect them and keep their congregation clean. This is what they believe and they believe it's the only true religion. Their beliefs created the environment that allowed this girl to be abused.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

If ever I get a terminal disease. I will spend the remainder of my days hunting down and torturing child rapist/molesters/abusers. Mark my fucking words.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

Sigh. This hurts me.

I...don't even know where to begin to reply to such vileness. All I know is I'm going to continue to love people and not impose my way of life on others. I'm not a Jehovah's Witness, and I'm not going to sit here and be like LOOK AT ME I'M RELIGIOUS, because usually that ends with being a hypocrite, which admittedly I am because I'm not perfect and I strive to live the way of life that I live.

I love you all, whether you are agnostic, atheist, buddhist, hinduist, nontheist, etc.

I feel so bad for this child. And it makes me livid beyond reason to see things like this happening.

EDIT: misspelled non-theist. Oops

7

u/LindseyKorea Jun 18 '12

As someone who is not religious in the slightest and constantly judged for being that, I appreciate that you don't force your opinions upon others. I appreciate that you look at religion and are able to say that some things are imperfect. Your open mindedness is great and I wish more people were like you. I never mind what someone else believes and I think everyone has that right, but it's especially nice when someone religious doesn't judge others.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

I hate religion. I grew up in "religion" and "church", and was taught that alcohol/smoking was of the devil, that being a Christian was all about "doing my good deed for the day, being a good boy and dressing nicely on Sunday", and that was my ticket to heaven.

It wasn't until two years ago that I started really questioning what I believed, and how screwed up some of my beliefs were. I was disgusted with myself and with my peers, and definitely disgusted with the private school that I attended at a young age, up until I graduated.

So many things didn't make sense, and when I asked, I would get disgusted replies like "BECAUSE THE BIBLE SAYS SO" or "I'm not much into apologetic arguments" or the best one "because that's what I was taught". So for a while I really questioned myself, and I dug for information, and made my personal choice.

I strive to not judge those who don't think like me, because in the end, I'm no better than anyone else. I came from the mindset, as I grew up, that Christians were better than everyone else, which also disgusted me, so much so that I don't associate with many of my "Christian" friends anymore.

I have more friends of a secular mindset than I do of the "Christian" mindset. I would rather have friends who love me, than friends who judge me every step of the way. And I know that I see the comment of "well, if you were a Christian and you really believed there was a hell, and you believed I was going to it, why wouldn't you tell me about your Christ?! That must mean you don't care about me." I do care, and I do love despite what I believe, and you know what? I do believe there's a hell, and a heaven, but that's not my choice to make for anyone, and that doesn't change the way I perceive anyone either, consciously or subconsciously.

I believe and do what I do because of my own choice. People should be free to make their own choices in life. People can mock me for what I believe, but that doesn't change how I feel about them, and it won't ever change how I feel about them, even if said people killed me. I know, sensationalist, but I mean every word.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/conundrum4u2 Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

If someone could explain this to me, I have always wondered - (from Wikipedia - Jehovah's Witnesses is a millenialist restorationist Christian denomination with nontrinitarian beliefs distinct from mainstream Christianity.[2] The organization reports worldwide membership of over 7.65 million adherents involved in evangelism,[3] convention attendance of over 12 million, and annual Memorial attendance of over 19.3 million.) - but apparently ONLY 144,000 OF THE ELITE GET INTO 'HEAVEN'?? How does this work? Why would they keep recruiting people, and what would make someone follow THAT deal??? Btw: I lived in Fremont for many years - these are probably the SOB's I had to chase away from knocking on my door at 8-9am all the time (I worked graveyard shift - even had a DND sign on the door)

11

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Unlike most denominations of Christianity, for Jw's(I was raised in the faith until high school) Heaven is a special place reserved for a very select chosen few. The rest of those deemed acceptable by god would still be immortal, but as regular humans on a perfect Earth, rather than as angels living with god in heaven. While everyone is supposed to strive to be the best they can due to the nature of the ideologies of the religion, you don't really "try" to earn a spot in heaven. It's more of a preordained thing where certain people we already worthy of it from birth, and it should be reflected in their actions while alive. It's not like god hands out a few tickets and everyone else is out of luck. It's just that a certain few get a different responsibility than the rest of god's chosen.

As a side note, my grandfather is supposedly one of the 144k, but he used to molest my mom and my aunts, so.... yeah.

4

u/SaltyBabe Existentialist Jun 18 '12

How do the assign/how would you know if you were one of these special people?

10

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

That's the kicker. It's a personal "I know" type situation, like God spoke to them in a dream type deal. There's no evidence or direction from the leadership in the congregations or anything. Every year during the memorial of Christ, bread and wine is passed around. The chosen 144000 are supposed to partake just like the disciples did at the last supper. The rest of the people are just supposed to continue passing it around the congregation.

So if you see someone partake, they're making a statement that they are one of the chosen. Beyond that, nothing. You just take it on good faith that the people saying they are chosen really are.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

144 000 go to heaven as lords, the rest return to a resurrected perfect Earth.

I know, right?

2

u/JupitersClock Jun 18 '12

Basically everyone who follows the teachings will be resurrected after Armageddon to a paradise. While a select few (144K) get to remain in heaven. I have been told different reports about being one of the 144K. Some say you have a dream or vision. The other one is you read certain scriptures.

→ More replies (8)

7

u/ActuallyNot Atheist Jun 18 '12

Props to the woman for naming herself.

That must have taken so much guts.

7

u/Gregoric399 Jun 18 '12

I just hope this leads to more people coming forward and more compensation being awarded

13

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

upvote for the subtle meme rant

6

u/Theocritic Jun 18 '12

ALL HAIL SPARLOCK!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

The warrior wizard!

6

u/algiz14 Jun 18 '12

I was surprised that it didn't even make the front page.

The gay agenda is much more important to these people.

6

u/JupitersClock Jun 18 '12

The truly sad thing is this is happening and these Elders know about these individuals and they do not disclose information to the rest of the congregation.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

JWs LOVE condemning the Catholic Church for pedophilia scandals. That's really the sweet irony of the whole thing.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Those people who meet JWs on their doorsteps over the next few months would do well to pass on news articles about this to them - the church will without a doubt strongly condemn members reading about this.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

I understand your qualms with the Church and religion in general, but can we step back and have some reverence for the poor girl who will forever be scarred by rape. This should not be treated as a mere vindication of your beliefs or a chance to win. I highly doubt you are so callous at heart, however it is important to be cognizant of the way your writing comes across.

All people should have a "dog in this fight", if only because we abhor child rape. Any further consequence should be acknowledged as secondary. We don't celebrate when a little boy is raped by the Catholic Church because it proves they are shit, even if it does.

TL;DR A child was raped, keep that in mind and don't act so celebratory.

11

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

I'm happy to see that the victim's wishes are coming to fruition. She has spoken out about her reasons for taking this to trial.

"Nothing can bring back my childhood," Conti told the Oakland Tribune. "But through this (verdict) and through, hopefully, a change in their policy, we can make something good come out of it."

"The ultimate goal of the lawsuit was to have a change in policy, to be able to ID these people, child molesters, to the congregation to protect children,” Conti told MSNBC. “Secondarily, to have silent ones come forward and tell their stories and to bring to light that overall issue of violence and the hush-hush policy.” www.inquisitr.com/256379/jehovahs-witnesses-found-guilty-in-unprecedented-molestation-case-must-pay-21-million/#4EiZ2KQOoyUg0ZFc.99

I am happy to see that what she had hoped for in taking this to trial seems to be at least getting closer to fruition.

12

u/Mewshimyo Jun 18 '12

We're not celebrating her rape, we are celebrating that justice was served for the girl.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Reoh Jun 18 '12

You've gotten a lot of downvotes for this; but as a kid that was in a similar situation once before, a long time ago, thanks.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Kevenz Jun 18 '12

This should be moved to WTF

5

u/Samloves209 Jun 18 '12

I'm starting to wonder if one of the reasons behind people's religious choices is to sexual abuse children? It is becoming a consistent theme...

5

u/sufrt Jun 18 '12

holy shit.... i think you just blew the doors off this "religion" thing

5

u/handmetheteabag Jun 18 '12

Also former Jehovah's Witness here. All they're going to say is he's a wolf amongst sheep.

5

u/hardlyaware Jun 18 '12

In the congregation I grew up in, there was a man who was disfellowshipped for having child pornography on his computer. I was only privy to the information because my mother was best friends with this man's wife. The incident ended their marriage, but he was still allowed to come into the Kingdom Hall and attempt to reinstate himself. And no one batted an eye. He was never reported to the police. Of course not, though, that would look bad on everyone else, right? It's fucking sick. Jehovah's Witnesses pretend they are better than everyone else. It's a joke.

9

u/AwesomePaedoGuy Jun 18 '12

We need children to be taken seriously and treated with respect and as "equals". I put equals in quotes because clearly true equality is impossible however the general attitude needs to be that people don't look down on them just because they are children.

One of the biggest obstacles in achieving this is religion. Which views children as property to indoctrinate. Then be used as self-affirmation of religion.

When children are not kept ignorant, when they are given a voice, when they are not taught to be obedient "just because" then it is incredibly more likely they will stand up for themselves if they are being abused.

2

u/DerpTheGinger Jun 18 '12

Luckily, the generation that tries to keep their children ignorant don't know much about the internet. That's how many of my childhood friends escaped their parents suffocating views on religion and politics. 60 1NT3RW3BZ!

2

u/TheFlyingBastard Jun 18 '12

Equals in an "All Men Are Created Equal" kind of way, you mean?

2

u/Barking_at_the_Moon Jun 18 '12

Really. I'm no fan of organized religion and God knows JW can be more cult-ish than many. I'm glad you escaped but clearing your head may require that you find something - anything - other that JW (and religion in general) to focus on. Teach First Aid for the Red Cross. Volunteer at a food bank. Stalk a rock star. Do anything except obsess.

Sometimes you gotta climb down off the cross and use the timber to build a bridge to a new life so you can GET THE FUCK OVER IT.

9

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

Thanks for the advice! I'm not really the obsessive type, and I actually do volunteer quite a bit with some local non-profits; I even sit on the board of one! It's really helped me build a social support structure, which I certainly needed, not to mention the inherent fulfillment that comes from devoting efforts to something bigger than yourself. I guess I'm not sure where you're going with this. . . this case was a big deal, the victim in this instance wants to draw attention to what happened, and more specifically the reasons it happened. . . Does drawing attention to this case mean I'm obsessed, and I need to "GET THE FUCK OVER IT?" I really doubt it.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Stalk a rock star. Do anything except obsess.

Wouldn't this be counter-intuitive to not obsessing?

2

u/Idocreating Jun 19 '12

Would you tell a holocaust survivor with reoccuring nightmares, who had developed a slightly unhealthy obsession with making sure the perpetrators were brought to justice to GET THE FUCK OVER IT?

"Saw your parents and everyone you knew walk into a gas chamber? GET THE FUCK OVER IT!"

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DannyboyO1 Jun 18 '12

Never understood: Proof of intent to hide sex abuse comes to light in various religious organizations... and it doesn't even warrant a conspiracy charge?

Oh, wait, when Ratzinger, a cardinal, pushed that... he was hiding in a non-extradition country... the vatican city. :(

4

u/GTAIVisbest Jun 18 '12

Whoa.... what a fuck-fest... the top comment is at -1 points and people are ripping each other apart in the comments, yet the post is still on the front page. There is a disturbance in r/atheism...

2

u/albinomex Jun 18 '12

I know right? who would've thought that r/atheism would stop their circle jerk TO DEFEND CHILD MOLESTERS AND A FUNDAMENTALIST RELIGION

4

u/GeneraLeeStoned Jun 18 '12

I feel like the priest pedo episode from south park is more and more true every day. It's like religion is just one giant child raping cover up.

4

u/TitRaisinNippleZombi Jun 18 '12

All I heard was knock knock...

jk sorry

4

u/gothicarsehole Jun 18 '12

The documentary, "Deliver Us From Evil" deals with the corruption of the Catholic church, it's really fascinating but pretty disturbing. It's about Father Oliver O'Grady, a priest and active pedophile that the Catholic church protected for over 30 years, allowing him to abuse dozens of children in Northern California. Church officials were completely aware of what he was doing but protected him by moving him from parish to parish.

Highly recommend it as it's interesting but it is incredibly frustrating at the same time. This "policy" that the church elders have to keep child sexual abuse accusations secret is appalling and I really hope this court case changes things.

4

u/bungoton Jun 18 '12

This isn't the first time the Watchtower Society has been forced to compensate sex abuse victims. They paid a multi-million dollar settlement in 2007 to victims of abuse that was covered up by the church. Some members were expelled but the underlying problem will never be addressed. Cult leaders have the power to do almost anything they like to their followers once they are properly under their control. The JW cult leaders are experts at mind control.

4

u/belladonnatook Jun 18 '12

This $28M jury award is exactly why the Roman Catholic church is fighting state efforts nationwide to extend statutes of limitation for sex crimes. I think 23 is an unreasonably young age by which a victim should have to have his act together to prosecute the sexual abuse that occurred when he was nine. But church money is on state legislators who'll keep the status quo.

12

u/noah_arcd_left Jun 18 '12

If enough people came forward and started more of these lawsuits, it could financially cripple JW

3

u/HerVajesty Jun 18 '12

I thought this, too. Maybe they'll have to stop printing the Watchtower for a while! On the other hand, they do have free labour and plenty of people who donate.

4

u/noah_arcd_left Jun 18 '12

Imagine how the image of the entire Church would look if there was a legitimate melee of the molested children coming forward and bringing it this far. It would start looking more and more like a cult. Future statements could be: "I'm Christian, but I don't fuck children."

→ More replies (1)

12

u/666ThrowAway666yeah Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

I was molested by my father twice, told the elders, they pulled the two witnesses rule. Nothing was done. Now my father is an elder. His wife has physically abused me too. I told the elder. Nothing has happened. I was called a demon, though. I'm too tired to sue these people.

→ More replies (7)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

The secret elder's book: Shepherd the Flock of God, has all the protocol spelled out in it for protecting the accused. The JW cult is all about reputation. The book says it all...

Email: [email protected] for a full copy. This book is only for JW elder's, not for the rank & file.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/manicrysis Jun 19 '12

I am an ex JW. So, my question is...it's kept hush hush when there's an accusation, but when I light up a cigarette, I get "marked", or even "worse" disfellowshipped? WTF.

1

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 19 '12

Yeah, it's kept hush-hush from the general public, and the same rule would apply if you were seen smoking a cigarette; if only one person saw you, and you denied it, they wouldn't do much more about it. The difference of course is that smoking a cig is not illegal, nor a horrible thing to do to another human being.

1

u/weird-oh Jun 20 '12

I am so ashamed to have ever been a member of that cult. I was born into it, and got out as soon as I could. But thinking out it still makes me cringe.

1

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 20 '12

I am so ashamed to have ever been a member of that cult. I was born into it

I think you've offered plenty of reason to not feel ashamed right there. I wish I hadn't been raised as a witness, but I'm pretty proud of myself for finding my way out of it, even if in retrospect it did take longer than I would have preferred. Don't beat yourself up for things you had no control over!

3

u/Eppsmayne Jun 18 '12

A BIGGER DEAL THAN MEMES? ARE YOU CRAZY? HERE ON R/ATHEISM, NOTHING IS MORE IMPORTANT OR THOUGH-PROVOKING THAN MEMES.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Duthos Jun 18 '12

There is no justice in the justice system. We know how to handle predators, we have simply been civilized too long to remember that there are times when violence is the only answer.

We can deny it, and sex, as much as we like, they remain, and forever will, parts of life. I consider repression of healthy violent tenancies to be as dangerous as repressed sexual desires (and we all know what effect that has).

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Inamo Jun 18 '12

When you think you have authority from the Almighty Creator, no-one can convince you that the earthly authorities are important.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Just one more step in the right direction.

6

u/skeptix Jun 18 '12

I'd like to see religion phased out of humanity entirely (through organic social pressure). I know it won't happen in my lifetime, but I'll do my damnedest while I'm still here.

Good post, thanks for caring.

1

u/Xiryz Jun 18 '12

my teacher is jehovah's witness. she seems nice. is she just playing or can they be actually nice to u? :P

2

u/Upliftingmofo Jun 18 '12

I'm sure she's actually nice. Lots of JWs are nice, good people. The leadership, I'm not so sure about.

4

u/thefugue Jun 18 '12

Why Du U spell Like Prince?

Religious people are usually very nice in a superfifial way- just like other salesmen. They don't small talk- they pitch.

2

u/TheFlyingBastard Jun 18 '12

Many JWs are genuinely good people. They're just poor saps who have been cheated into becoming part of a cult.

1

u/indianadarren Jul 15 '12

http://thirdwitness.com/childabuse/default.html Child Sex Abuse is abhorrent and those practicing such things do not deserve to live. But before you make your personal judgement about Jehovah's Witnesses or the Watchtower Bible & Tract Society it would behoove you to invest an hour of your time and read the whole truth on the matter, not the half-truths and outright lies that are spread by people who hate JWs.

2

u/Upliftingmofo Jul 16 '12

An hour of my time? I spent months of my time looking into this. I WAS an elder. I personally experienced how things were handled by the local body of elders, the Legal Department, the Circuit Overseer, and the Service Department. You think that reading the propaganda on that site is somehow going to erase my own personal experiences, along with the conversations I had with active elders at the time across the country in various congregations, who also saw that what was going on was clearly wrong, but didn't know what they could do about it?

Sorry bud, you're barking up the wrong tree. You're picking a side that you want to be true and you just don't want to consider anything else. I had to do something really extremely difficult when I found out that the organization was horrifically dishonest and wrong about so many things, including child abuse. I had to admit that I was wrong, that I had lived my life for something that wasn't real - and not only wasn't real, but was actively harming humans throughout the world. I wanted to believe that my 30+ years of 'service' had meant something, that I wouldn't have to give up relationships that had meaning to me and forge new social circles from scratch. But I'm thankful I was able to recognize that just like anyone else, I could be wrong - even about the biggest thing in my life, and I'm extremely glad that I had the strength to do what was right in stepping away from the Jehovah's Witness organization.

Now, I do my best to actively help people as much as I can, and in ways that actually provide real help to people. It's a wonderful, rewarding experience.

The time will likely come that you will reach that conclusion as well, and I hope for your sake that you don't have to deal with the shunning and the ugliness that I had to deal with from the 'loving brotherhood' when I stepped down as an elder and withdrew my support from the organization. No one deserves that sort of abuse. Best of luck to you; I hope that you have the strength to deal with that change when it comes.

2

u/origabob Jun 18 '12

So nothing has changed? Big surprise.

2

u/dopescope Jun 18 '12

the problem is that churches and corrupt people give religion a bad name. its pretty obvious that there can be only one true source to this mess, whether is be creative design or chance. the only way to figure it out is to search for truth and never quit your journey. dont get too caught up in your ideas or beliefs, for they may one day change. always keep an open mind.

6

u/Supervisor194 Ex-Jehovah's Witness Jun 18 '12

Unless you're one of Jehovah's Witnesses, then keeping an open mind and/or changing your beliefs will get you disfellowshipped.

For those who don't know, disfellowshipping is a harsh form of excommunication, you are shunned by your friends and your family. Frequently this takes away everyone you ever were close to, because Witnesses are constantly exhorted to associate with non-Witnesses as little as possible. In the Witness religion you can get this punishment simply by voicing an opinion about doctrine contrary to the accepted beliefs as published by the Watchtower Society.

2

u/quicklookleft Jun 18 '12

Welcome to catholisism wow. New sect, oh my!

2

u/Music_Saves Jun 18 '12

I wish there were better descriptions of this because I'm not exactly sure why the church should be held liable. Was it they knew it was going on and didn't stop it or was it they helped it to happen?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Policies regarding the handling of accusations such as these, policies set by the Watchtower Society, enabled a known abuser to remain in a congregation with access to children he could abuse, and forbade those who knew about his crimes from letting parents or children know what he was.

It's the same story as in the Catholic Church: the institution is more concerned with protecting its own reputation and keeping abuses quiet than with stopping abuse or helping the victims.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

2

u/TheHatist Jun 18 '12

It's funny because even the highly religious dismiss them as batshit crazy, I feel sorry for the good people deluded and enslaved by this bullshit. I'm hoping the religion is dismantled and destroyed. It isn't even a religion it is a joke.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

So I thought like, Jehovah was the entity behind the JW?

2

u/CaptainJester42 Jun 18 '12

I think you're hopelessly optimistic in thinking this will lead people to see culpability in any other church. No offense to the JW but most christians regard them as a fringe group if not just outright calling them a cult. This is only going to marginalize the JW more, not show others the error of their ways.

5

u/polar_bear_cub_scout Jun 18 '12

Religious members engaging in sexual acts with children. What a surprising plot twist.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Fucking finally! My parents are both JWs and its horrible here :/. My childhood totally sucks and I guess I missed my best years as a child because of them... Hell, fuck this shit. My mother knows, that I dont believe I guess, but still I gave to pray with them every time (when we eat, when we go to sleep)... I dont know if my father knows that Im an agnostic atheist, and Im really afraid to come out to him. I would describe much more, but that requires throwaway I guess. But one thing I can tell, is that few times I saw him watching porn, in the living room, while I was watching TV, and this fucking prick thought I cant see him! He sometimes acts like he is big JW, like he knows many stuff from the days of Jesus, he knows the bible and shit like that... But I can tell you, that from my POV, most JW are nice only to strangers and them selves... But not at home... Fuck, I have so many stories about this shit... This post made my morning! Thabk you! Sorry for grammar and styling, Im on mobile

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

All I can tell you is that when you become an adult it gets better if you want it to. Focus on the things that will allow you to get out from under your parents.

And whatever you do don't get baptized if you aren't already. It's a lot harder to shun someone who was never actually technically a JW. It's the loophole in the system.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

You know who else represented an entire religion and repeatedly banged a 9-year-old girl?

4

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

My mom?

→ More replies (5)

4

u/SpellingGust Jun 18 '12

As a current Jehovah's Witness, I feel any opinion I give on the matter will be firmly rejected, or simply be called "biased". But as a witness for 22 years now, I'd gladly help clear up some misconceptions about "us" and if allowed, give my .02 cents on this.

10

u/JWTA Jun 18 '12 edited Jun 18 '12

I'd be willing to hear you out.

Could you clear up any of these misconceptions?

http://www.jwfacts.com/watchtower/paedophilia.php

EDIT: Ok. I guess not. I will continue accepting these facts.

10

u/albinomex Jun 18 '12

If you are a current Jehovah's Witness then you are not in good standing. What do you think your elders would do to you if they found out you were checking out atheist forums with apostate information?

5

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

You raise a compelling argument.

2

u/clitwasalladream Jun 18 '12

Wait just a minute there... you're 1.98 cents short of the going rate!!

2

u/mrjoekick4ss Jun 18 '12

Memes are all trash. I come here for stories like this one.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12

Hey guys, I'll be back browsing the front page for kittens and gaming related laughs. Let me know how this develops.

2

u/nonesounworthy Jun 18 '12

If there be no hell let these savages fall to the hand of man, the darkness of man, and they will know fear.