r/atheism • u/TheBigGinge • May 19 '12
Good Guy Rabbi
http://www.quickmeme.com/meme/3pcw42/12
u/johntheChristian May 19 '12
Sorry, hate to break the circlejerk (well, no that's a lie), but Jewish theology does not say the eating of pork is inherently evil. They believe that God has commanded the Jews, and only the Jews, to abstain from certain foods. Gentiles eating pork, shellfish etc. is perfectly acceptable to them, they would never wish to stop it, and it does not displease God.
Israel is given a special burden and a special blessing. Jews believe that Gentiles are held to a different and much less strict standard.
5
May 20 '12
This is how all religions should work. Believe what you want, but don't force it on everyone else.
6
u/TheOG_CRow May 20 '12
Good guy Jews.
Believe in magical God.
Don't get mad at you for not believing in magical God.
292
May 19 '12
False. Orthodox Jews are constantly trying to impose religious restrictions in Israel.
118
May 19 '12
But orthodox jews would be bad guy rabbi, not good guy rabbi.
52
May 19 '12
Um, this is a picture of an orthodox Jew. Black hat? Beard? Peyos?
43
May 19 '12
He may be orthodox, but that doesn't immediately mean he's an asshole forcing his faith onto others.
→ More replies (54)→ More replies (1)8
May 19 '12
you can be conservative and have black hat beard and peyot.
also not all orthodox try to force their views on others
35
u/fastsauce May 19 '12
Israel is a "Jewish state." It makes sense that Jews would try to impose their religious restrictions in their own state. America is NOT a Christian/Jewish/Muslim or any religious nation. The comparison does not make any sense.
→ More replies (18)8
u/KeyboardChemistry May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12
I'm not sure I find the idea of a religious state remotely ethical, unless perhaps if it only consisted of adults who chose to emigrate after birth in a nation which allowed them to experience a wide range of values.
13
u/Droi May 19 '12
It's not very ethical. But it's not only religious, Judaism is a culture as well as a religion, and it's a constant battle between removing religious rituals vs. leaving a cultural Jewish Israel intact.
→ More replies (8)17
u/fastsauce May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12
I somewhat agree, but that is pretty unrelated to the point at hand.
Edit: Also, although Israel is recognized as a "Jewish state," there is no law establishing Judaism as the state's religion. The "Jewish state" refers more to the fact that it is a cultural safe haven for people of Jewish heritage.
→ More replies (3)5
May 19 '12
Radical Orthodox Jews make up a fraction of the population. Kinda like WBC.
→ More replies (5)2
1
1
u/marmaladeskiiies May 20 '12
I believe OP is referring to America with its issues with gay marriage being banned, in a nation that's supposed to have a separation of church and state.... but I could be wrong. Haha
→ More replies (32)1
58
u/tbasherizer May 19 '12
That is because in Western, non-Israeli societies, Jewish people haven't been a large portion of the population. In Israel, the rabbis, as is mentioned by others in this thread, play the same role as the evangelists in America. Judaism's non-acknowledgement of Jesus doesn't change much about the behaviour of its zealots in comparison to their Christian counterparts.
6
2
u/Whelks May 20 '12
Israeli Jews are the political reverse of American Jews. (In the sense that Israeli Jews are very conservative, and American Jews are liberal.)
→ More replies (2)2
11
u/spiffypanda May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12
What this really comes down to is that:
-Judaism is a non-proselytizing religion (unlike Christianity or Islam)
-Jews are a very small minority of the population
2
u/TheBigGinge May 19 '12
It's times like these where I'm proud of my jewish background
5
May 19 '12
Really? You're going to downvote him because he is proud of his roots? He isn't saying Judaism is superior to your beliefs, he is just (rightly) proud of a rich cultural heritage.
→ More replies (1)0
May 19 '12
[deleted]
→ More replies (15)3
May 19 '12
I dont think thats broadly true. /r/atheism is pretty non-discriminatory in its antipathy toward religion as a whole.
→ More replies (2)
12
u/urnbabyurn May 19 '12
That's because Jews don't care if non-Jews eat pork. That's the burden of being one of the chosen people.
Christians on the other hand are eager to convert others, which goes along with restricting everyones behavior. Imagine a Christian saying "get an abortion, I don't care because you aren't Christian."
→ More replies (9)1
u/cunninglinguist81 May 19 '12
Yeah it's interesting...in theory I like a religion that is all-inclusive ("anyone can be a Christian!") more than one that has an elitist "chosen"...but in practice, when it allows for things like "conversion by the sword"...
→ More replies (5)2
u/Whelks May 20 '12
People can convert to Judaism. My grandfather did it. It involves bathing in a Mikva and other things.
→ More replies (5)
47
May 19 '12
Kind of a straw man.
Christians believe that they own marriage. Jews don't believe they own food. Most Christians want to keep marriage hetero, not because it's God's will, but because they believe marriage is a Christian institution, like baptism. And ya know what, if it was, then fine. If marriage was Christian, then gays shouldn't get married.
But it's not.
Married people get more benefits (shared healthcare, easier adoptions, etc.), a lot of which are from the government. So marriage can either be recognized by the government and be open to all adults, or a Christian institution, but not at all recognized by the government.
10
u/idownvotemyposts May 19 '12
I really do like how Christians seem to think they invented marriage and can somehow dictate it's meaning. It cracks me up to no end.
15
u/ojfrown May 19 '12
Thank you. These kinds of posts are why /r/atheism is called a circlejerk; it's not because everyone has the same opinion, but because people present strawman caricatures of opposing arguments and then congratulate each other for knocking them down.
That's not to say that opposing gay marriage isn't wrong, but rather that confronting the arguments against it needs to be done in a way that fully recognises the nuances of the objections, and counters them accordingly, otherwise it won't convince anybody.
4
May 19 '12
Exactly! I also hate all the pro-choice posts here. I've talked to many pro-life people, and not one has used God as the reason for being pro-life.
When confronted about this, r/atheism will likely say that there's no reason to be pro-life besides religion. That's simply not true. Don't get me wrong, I'm pro-choice, but pro-life =/= religious.
→ More replies (7)6
u/ojfrown May 19 '12
I absolutely agree with you. I'm pro-choice also, but it's an incredibly difficult issue and both sides have valid points; abortion should certainly never be taken lightly. If you genuinely believe it's murder (rightly or wrongly) then you can't be blamed for wanting it banned. To portray pro-lifers all as religious nuts does everybody a disservice.
→ More replies (9)8
u/fastsauce May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12
I think it needs to be pointed out that marriage began much before Christianity. Even in early Christianity, marriage was seen as a private matter that was not religious.
Edit: Edited to not make it look like goofygoobarock believes marriage is owned by Christians.
→ More replies (2)2
u/Ze_Carioca May 19 '12
Marriage is not a christian institution. It predates christianity, and was widespread over the world without any christian influence.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (3)2
u/Dismantlement May 19 '12
So it's not a straw man then...we appreciate Jews for not thinking they own food. We want Christians to not think they own marriage.
9
May 19 '12
its actually forbidden in all 3 religions. not just for jews.
2
u/ffffffffuuuuuuuuuuuu May 19 '12
It's true. Pork is strictly prohibited in Islam and yet it seems nobody in this thread are talking about Good Guy Muslim.
→ More replies (1)5
→ More replies (12)1
4
u/AddictiveSoup May 19 '12
This just makes it look like we target only Christians more.
2
u/Ze_Carioca May 19 '12
I am not christian, but I have noticied that /r/athiest mainly targets Christians, and is often apologist toward Islam. I think it has to do with redditors here having to deal mainly with christian fundies.
17
u/dessicatedfetus May 19 '12
6 months to a year ago someone tried making circumcision illegal in san francisco and it was the jewish community that stopped that law from getting passed.
→ More replies (33)
3
9
u/qkme_transcriber I am a Bot May 19 '12
Here is the text from this meme pic for anybody who needs it:
Title, Meme: Good Guy Rabbi
RELIGION DOESN'T ALLOW PORK
DOESN'T TRY TO MAKE IT ILLEGAL
This is helpful for people who can't reach Quickmeme because of work/school firewalls or site downtime, and many other reasons (FAQ). More info is available here.
2
2
u/orgy_porgy May 19 '12
Finally, an /r/atheism post that isn't smug faith bashing or Sagan/Dawkins/NdGT/ worship. Its great to believe in a higher power, as long as that higher powers asks you do good things with your faith.
2
May 19 '12
kind of a crappy counterexample to gay marriage because Israel does not allow Gay Marriage, and Orthodox Judaism supported bans on it in the US, right alongside Fundamentalist Christians.
2
u/TenNinetythree Agnostic Atheist May 19 '12
...and you cannot get the delicious bacon within city limits. And inter-religious marriage in certain circumstances is not allowed...
2
2
u/burf May 19 '12
There is a vastly larger number of Christians in the United States (where I presume you reside) than Jews. Unfortunately there aren't any numbers that I'm aware of specifically for "right wing lunatic Christians" vs "right wing lunatic Jews", but I think we can reasonably assume that, if the number of Jews of that sort is proportional, there's no way in hell there are enough of them to make the legality of pork a political issue.
2
u/kylemoose May 19 '12
I knew I should have posted this in r/atheism rather than r/adviceanimals several weeks ago.
2
2
u/youni89 May 20 '12
good guy rabbi turns into bad guy rabbi when Judaism becomes the majority religion in the nation, like the state of Israel.
2
2
2
u/tellam May 20 '12
Since when does not being a dick to everyone make you a good guy? It should be the norm.
5
5
u/-Tyrion-Lannister- May 19 '12
As someone raised Jewish, I can tell you without hesitation that this guy is a much bigger asshole than you might suspect.
6
u/funyun2 May 20 '12
Like all things, it varies from person to person. I went to a Jewish school growing up, and one of the teachers there was a rabbi who was one of the nicest, funniest, most tolerant people I've ever met. And he was extremely religious, (for example he can't listen to women singing because there's a sexual aspect to it).
2
u/aron0405 May 20 '12
as an atheist who was raised orthodox, i would have to disagree. i'm sorry you had to put up with some assholes, though.
→ More replies (2)
3
2
2
2
u/FoundPie May 19 '12
The equating marriage law to eating pork thing needs to stop, Reddit.
It's a bad argument and you should feel bad.
→ More replies (2)4
1
u/poorfag May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12
Buses and most ATM's don't work in Saturday and Friday night.
Illegal to drive through some neighborhoods in Saturday.
Pork illegal.
Shellfish illegal.
Bible-studies mandatory in every school.
State-sponsored religious schools.
The Ultra-Orthodox don't serve in the army.
The Ultra-Orthodox don't work and live from welfare.
Make settlements in the middle of the West-Bank because "god told them to", and effectively putting back the peace talks 20 years.
Segregated buses.
Ads with no women.
EDIT:
Impossible to marry somebody from another religion (or somebody without one).
Impossible to marry somebody from another sex.
There is no such thing as a good guy rabbi. In the US they seem that way because they have no political power, in Israel they are free to do as they like.
3
May 20 '12
But again, they had a female prime minister. How did that happen with all this supposed subjugation of women? Just curious..
2
u/poorfag May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
There are 2 israels:
The secular, with a booming economy, technological advancements, served in the army or the civil service, peace seeking and tax payer.
And the orthodox, who don't serve in the army, don't pay taxes, segregate buses, burn flags and settle in Palestinian land.
So we may have had a female prime minister, but a scarily big part of her knesset had views so radical that would've made Santorum blush.
2
u/dndplosion913 May 19 '12
Do any of your points apply to non-religious cities like Tel Aviv and Petach Tikva, or just Orthodox places? For example, Tel Aviv is about to have a gay pride parade that is being opened by the mayor, and is expected to see 100,000 people, and that sort of doesn't mesh with your points on the country.
→ More replies (1)2
u/NewWorldOrderftw May 20 '12
Impossible to marry somebody from another sex.
Do you mean sect?
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (5)1
u/GreatLookingGuy May 20 '12
Israel is a Jewish country. The US is not a Christian country. It's like criticizing Vatican city for its religious policies.
0
May 19 '12
Jews don't have the majority in this country and they know it, that's the only reason they're not imposing their faith on everyone.
10
u/carriegood May 19 '12
except the ones where they do have the majority, like areas of brooklyn, where they try to ban bicyclists, billboards, underwear stores, etc.
→ More replies (2)2
u/iMissMacandCheese May 19 '12
Um, no, they don't impose it because Judaism doesn't expect non-Jews to follow their laws. The rules of Judaism as for Jews only, non-Jews are only expected (by Judaism) to follow the seven Noahide laws.
→ More replies (2)2
u/GreatLookingGuy May 20 '12
The Jewish religion is explicitly applicable only to Jewish people (the chosen people). They do not proselytize nor do they believe that not abiding by the religion results in a trip to hell. Jews believe that god gave them the bible for their own good. As in, following the religion leads to a more fulfilling life. It's not about forgiveness and salvation like Christianity and Islam.
→ More replies (1)4
u/Mookster13 May 19 '12
thats a bit unfair, dont you think? Your saying this without any basis. It says quite clearly in the torah that there are 7 Mitzvos that Hashem wants all non-jews to do: (please note these were for people that believed in the jewish God but didnt want to be Jewish themselves)
dont serve any idols dont murder do not commit adultery do not steal do not blaspheme Gods name do not eat flesh from a live animal you must set up a proper law system and follow it.
as long as the prohibition isnt one of these, jews have no reason to protest for it. and since its something for people that believe in God but dont become jewish, the jews have no right to force these laws on non-jews.
→ More replies (5)
-1
u/im_not_a_troll May 19 '12
Yet:
Wants to fully "judaize" Jerusalem.
Supports the loyalty oath where non-Jewish Israeli citizens have to pledge allegiance to a "Jewish state".
Supports settler violence against Palestinians.
Supports IDF violence against Palestinians.
Thinks starving out Gaza is a good idea.
Thinks Jewish settlers should re-colonize Gaza.
Wants the Israeli government to deport Ethiopians and Sudanese.
The list goes on...
3
u/samasamasama May 19 '12
Can I get a source for "Wants the Israeli government to deport Ethiopians and Sudanese", please?
→ More replies (2)2
May 20 '12
Wants Americans to fight wars for Israel and attacks anybody who is not willing to do this as an anti-Semite.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (8)1
1
May 19 '12
my neighbor's small business was blackmailed by local Rabbi and his gang, they demand owner label his food as kosher and paid them religious tax or they will spread bad publicity and use their local power to boycott him and his suppliers so they drop him.
3
May 20 '12
Well, this is how rumors start. There's many people on reddit who would make something like this up.
1
1
u/lewko May 20 '12
Wow. Really? I shall spread this far and wide at once!
This story about Jews is almost as bad as the one I was told by a friend, who heard from his brother, who had a cousin, whose friend heard from his boss, whose Father read on the Internet, that there was this guy who said that he'd overheard some Jews talking about doing some bad stuff. Truly sickening! Quick. Let's kill Jews!
→ More replies (1)1
u/johntheChristian May 20 '12
Today two atheists told me that if I didn't stop praying at lunch time they'd wait by my car and stab me to death.
This story has exactly as much evidence as yours. Considering the history of anti-Jewish propaganda regarding manipulation of money and businesses, and the type of results that propaganda has had, I'm going to need more than your say so.
1
1
1
u/Zymum May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12
Actually there are areas of New York were the ultra-orthodox law is pretty much de-facto law.
As for Israel, the Knesset has three openly Ultra-Orthodox parties including the fourth largest one. And the ruling parties tend to deal with them over some of the non-religious ones.
1
1
u/DumNerds May 19 '12
I didnt know we were on circle jerk, I mean damn, this same joke has been said at least 10 times within the last week. Please, for the love of science /r/atheism stop reposting and post something with actuall originality and substance. this reached number one on the front page. the fuck is wrong with you people?
1
u/MrCheeze Secular Humanist May 19 '12
It's because Judaism is a cultural thing, not just a religious one. They don't eat pork because of the cultural identity, not because they find it wrong.
1
u/beaverteeth92 May 19 '12
It's partially because Jews have been forced into "practice X alternative religion or die" situations throughout history. There are no Jewish missionaries for the same reason.
1
u/atomic1fire May 19 '12
I'm fairly certain a lot of those don't eat this laws were made because people couldn't cook them right and would pretty much die or get parasites or something.
1
u/0hi May 19 '12
I know "Good Guy Rabbi" - and he IS a good guy :-)
He has probably one of the most interesting stories I've ever heard.
1
1
May 19 '12
The Polynesians and Melanesians in the South Pacific called Europeans 'Long Pig' because they claimed their flesh tasted sweet like pork. probably one reason it is forbidden to eat, along with the sickness from under cooked meat.
1
1
1
1
u/Love-is-our-Weapon May 20 '12
I'm Christian, but damn do I love r/atheism. I actually think everything posted here is either sensible and reasonable or totally freaking funny. Yeah, i agree that some people in my religion are completely bonkers, but that's why I love this subreddit. It's amazing xD
1
1
May 20 '12
Again the problem is not people who are religious it's politicians who claim to be religious. D:
1
u/rbcrusaders May 20 '12
On top of that, people were arrested for offending jews online. This meme is bad.
1
1
u/bmaffitt May 20 '12
Interesting that for a picture of a "typical" Jew, you chose comedian Yisrael Campbell, who was born a white Catholic in Philadelphia and converted to Orthodox Judaism in his 30s. Not that there's anything wrong with that but I thought you might be interested. We went to grad school together and he's a swell guy, and his act is hilarious. And now I guess he's a meme... I wonder if he knows?
1
1
1
1
May 20 '12
I have to call bullshit on this.
If you've ever seen interviews of the well known atheists against Rabbi's, you'll know they're as bloody crazy as can be.
People who believe in magical things from a fairy tale book are not your friends, and they never can be or will be because they're insane. You'd have to be insane to shut your mind to everything and just believe a book despite zero evidence to the contrary.
Rabbis are no better than any other religious idiot. Serious.
1
May 20 '12
Just imagine if they put worldwide bans on pork. Just imagine what would happen to those peoples.
1
May 20 '12
How can someone who propagates a myth as truth be a good guy? I guess if he doesn't know that it's a myth and he means no harm, but this is r/atheism. We frown on religion around here and do not laud the accomplishments of those who perpetuate religion.
1
u/Dartimien May 20 '12
Yeeeah, their religious leaders are not really in a position to push their beliefs on anyone, and they haven't been for like the past 2000 years. So calling them good guys is like calling a mass murderer in prison good, because he is locked away without access to people or weapons.
1
1
May 20 '12
Well, I am a Christian. I do not believe gay marriage is right.... I ( me myself ) do not, I don't think it should be illegal. People need to stop making a judgment of the whole religion because of what some of them think.. I don't like walls with holes, doesn't mean they're bad doesn't mean people don't like them..
1
u/Dark_Waters May 20 '12
It's pretty sad, considering the fact that Judaism is based on the Old Testament whereas Christianity is supposed to be based on both, but mainly the New Testament, and yet Christians are the ones using the Old Testament to control others.
1
1
1
u/hullloser99 May 20 '12
I'd prefer: Good Guy Rabbi: Descends from JUST ONE of the many tribes that discarded the nomadic life at the end of the last ice age - doesn't expect the rest of humanity to give a shit.
1
1
1
u/ENRICOs May 20 '12
White steak, still popular, despite religious proscriptions.
Everything is good, other than the oink.
1
u/dodli May 20 '12 edited May 20 '12
Orthodox jews are every ounce as dangerous to civil and personal liberty and to human rights as evangelical christians or fundamentalist catholics muslims are. Everyone who lives in Israel, like me, is eminently aware of it. The only reason it sometimes doesn't appear this way to people not living in Israel is that elsewhere 1) orthodox Jews are a tiny minority 2) the availability of constitutions that protect civil and personal liberties and guarantee freedom from religion and most importantly 3) they are too afraid to show their true color for fear of retaliation. In Israel they are not encumbered by any of these constraints and they are - as a political force (of course there are individual exceptions; there are ALWAYS individual exceptions) - as dangerous, vile and backward as religious people come. Unfortunately, like every villain, they could never flourish without the complicity of the silent majority and of stupid, corrupt, power-hungry politicians.
EDIT: catholics -> muslims
1
u/DudeIjustdid May 20 '12
This is where I live. They mostly just keep to themselves except when they look down on you.
1
u/clawDEEuss May 20 '12 edited Dec 29 '15
This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy.
If you would like to do the same, add the browser extension GreaseMonkey to Firefox and add this open source script.
Then simply click on your username on Reddit, go to the comments tab, and hit the new OVERWRITE button at the top.
1
1
u/Loafie May 19 '12
You've never seen the Orthodox Jews protesting gay marriage on the news?
5
u/carriegood May 19 '12
some orthos are against it. however, every single one i know (and that's a lot) don't give a crap. live and let live. as long as you don't force them to perform gay marriages in shul, go ahead.
3
1
u/lt_hindu May 19 '12
Bad example is bad.
If the majority in the US were Jews then I'm pretty sure pork would be banned.
In India your allowed to eat beef even though a majority are Hindus would never,probably cry.
3
u/Ze_Carioca May 19 '12
That is a bad example too, since it relies on speculation.
I could just as easily say,
good example is good.
If the majority in the US were jews then im prety sure pork would still be legal.
Or I could say anything.
If the majority in the US were jews then im pretty sure the price of orange juice would go down.
3
u/johntheChristian May 19 '12
It is not a sin in the Jewish religion for a Gentile to eat pork. Jews are held to a different standard than non-Jews in Jewish theology.
1
u/Droi May 19 '12
Don't be mistaken, as an Israeli, I can promise you that religion stays religion, even if it is under a different name. They all still have imaginary friends, with ridiculous outdated rules, and they can't simply ignore them - which means that it will make it better for them if everyone else does it, they are told that if they can get others to uphold these laws, then it is a great thing to do for god, and they will be repaid.
They follow their religious leaders blindly, in Israel they can't even make a simple decision of whether or not they should greet an opposite sex co worker without explicit decisions from their leaders.
tl;dr crazy is crazy.
1
1
1
1
1
1
May 20 '12
The funniest thing about this is that the jews come out of the woodwork to propound the "virtues" of Israel/judaism.
It sickens me.
The top comment basically says
"if you can ignore, racism, sexism, religious prejudice, etc etc, it's a nice place!"
Sorry but how can you accept those things and call something "nice" I cannot fathom.
547
u/lurebat May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12
Actually it's illegal to grow pigs here in israel, though people are doing it through a loophole of growing them on platforms (because it's technicaly not on "the land of israel").
People here in israel for years try to make religon seperated from state, but no luck, though the non-religous and lightly-religous are the majority, most of the people seem to enjoy the status que, while the other have to suffer from teching bible class at schools, not being able to grow pigs, no public transportation on a saturday and not being able to be married in a non-religous weddings, so if you think banning gay marrige is bad, try living in a country where you can't marry someone from a diffrent religon or just marry without bringing two friends to say that you are a strict jewish man.
Anyway, that's a small lesson on how living in a somewhat relligious country can be tedious.
Edit: thanks for the positive feedback, by the way, i left out the worst one - in certian bus lines in israel, usually ones that are inside extremly religous cities, but sometimes normal ones that just happens to pass on one, there is segregation between men and women, yep, you heard right, like the old USA race laws, women have to go and sit in the back of the bus, dosen't matter if they have husbands they want to talk to or whatever, women have to give up their sits for men, because it hurts some people relligous views.
But other than that it's not a very bad country.