r/atheism • • May 12 '12

What I think of whenever I hear someone ask where do I get my morals?

http://imgur.com/QT03P
1.7k Upvotes

465 comments sorted by

128

u/[deleted] May 12 '12

Grasshopper disassemble. Re-assemble, Stephanie.

74

u/yillian May 13 '12

Noooooooooo! No disassemble Johnny 5!

31

u/siggplus May 13 '12

21

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I forgot how most of his comments come out of fucking know where. I'm glad I have it on DVD so I can now satisfy my urge for some Short Circuit.

7

u/ThunderYahtzee4 May 13 '12

SHORT CIRCUIT! Thats what this is! I knew I recognized it! I remember watching this as a kid and it somehow came to my memory the other day, and for the life of me I couldn't figure out what the title was. Sweet, Sweet Nostalgia.

→ More replies (6)

6

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

two extra letters used to misspell no where. I hate it when my hands do that.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/Carwheel May 13 '12

Johnny 5 alive!

11

u/constablepotato May 13 '12

Number 5 is alive!

3

u/flapjackboy Agnostic Atheist May 13 '12

That's Mr. Johnny 5 to you.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/OCDMedic May 13 '12

We all got a lump in our throat when we saw that part as kids, right?

11

u/SophieWho May 13 '12

As kids?

Still gets me. :c

8

u/jdk May 13 '12

Nice software!

8

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Your momma was a snowblower! Best line from that movie. Still cracks me up.

84

u/Sahloknir74 May 13 '12

I loved those movies. If they do end up rebooting the franchise, they better have a functional Johnny 5, not CGI. It would be the first time I'd ever been outraged by puppetry taking a back seat to CGI.

55

u/drageuth2 May 13 '12

Heh, just imagine if it ended up being a sort of reverse Roger Rabbit. Everything else would be a pixar-ish 3d animated cartoon, but Johnny 5 would be a real puppet filmed on greenscreen and put into it all.

...

Actually, that sounds kind of awesome.

11

u/feilen May 13 '12

Blues clues agaaaaaain?

9

u/drageuth2 May 13 '12

You know, I never thought of Blues Clues like that.

5

u/Tyler_the_Cremator May 13 '12

I didn't until I read about Steve being chosen as the host because he was so good at working in front of a green screen with no other human participants, just talking to himself and using body language, etc. to seem like he was actually interacting with the animated world. That made the whole concept of filming the show seem very strange.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Now make it directed by tim burton...

16

u/A_Cat_ May 13 '12

no, because the robot would have to be johnny depp

9

u/wkrausmann Atheist May 13 '12

And they'd make Stephanie played by Helena Bonham Carter.

12

u/hoodoo-operator May 13 '12

The first time I was outraged by puppetry taking a back seat to CGI was yoda in the star wars prequels.

3

u/Munkeyspunk92 May 13 '12

as popular as it is to have that opinion, I respectfully disagree. Phantom menace yoda was hideous, and the cgi flipping yoda from the later two really showed that this was more than an old coot. That being said, if (and unfortunately, when) George Lucas decides to cgi yoda into the original trilogy, I'll be distributing pitchforks in the greater Rock Hill area.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

This. Jim Henson can never be out-done.

11

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

The newest "The thing" movie already had all the robotic aliens built but they just scraped it all and used cgi instead. Fuck hollywood.

7

u/DeepRoot May 13 '12

Careful what you wish for. Don't be surprised when "Short Circuit" in 3D is released and then... then come the sequels. For the internet record, I'm thinking remakes of the "Six Million Dollar Man" and "Buck Rogers" are in our near future. Late 70's early 80's sci-fi will surely be in the remake pool soon, I'm guessing.

9

u/QuitReadingMyName May 13 '12

Hollywood already ran out of ideas, it's only a matter of time before they remake those movies within a year or two.

Doubt there will be any sequels though.

3

u/PsychoAgent May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

Why are people surprised that movies and television shows are being remade? It's always been this way. And not just with movies. Stories are told and retold in new and different ways since... ever. Re-envisionings are often great as they are terrible or even mediocre.

Sometimes some ideas are ahead of their times. Personally I love most of the remakes of this decade. There's just no way to do some of the movies that exist now believably without state of the art special effects, film techniques, recording technology, etc.

3

u/mysticrudnin May 13 '12

i don't think i've seen more than one completely novel movie per year for about ten years

it's all been an adaptation, sequel, or reboot, save one movie every year or so

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (28)

7

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

We can remake them. We have the technology.

2

u/CaptnKristmas May 13 '12

Hell they're re-releasing The Yellow Submarine by the Beatles. Be afraid... Very afraid.

4

u/Grimlyn Other May 13 '12

Functional Johnny 5, yes.

Steve Gutenberg again...HELL YES!

4

u/NM05 May 13 '12

I dunno if it counts as puppetry but the original Thing was still way more awesome than the new CGI ruined version. I liked the new one too, but the CGI was so bad compared to the props.

4

u/Sahloknir74 May 13 '12

Yeah, sometimes puppetry or models are so much more convincing than CGI. One example that comes to mind was near the end of back to the future 3 where the train goes off the unfinished bridge. The right lighting and camera angles made that model look incredibly real.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/hardcoremorning May 13 '12

you know what's even more retarded? they did most of the effects practically first for the new one and then "spiced them up" with CGI. Look at the behind the scenes stuff, it's amazing.

2

u/vegetaman May 13 '12

The original "The Thing From Another World" (1951, I think?) was awesome. CGI would be the ruination of that flick.

3

u/imaunitard May 13 '12

CGI Johnny 5 teaches kung-fu to a troubled Jayden Smith.

Johnny 5 voiced by Justin Bieber.

CGI Jenny 5 voiced by Taylor Swift.

Carlos Mencia voices the smart-assed toaster.

A heart-warming tale about robot love and saving the environment. Coming Summer 2013.

shudder

2

u/allenizabeth May 13 '12

Are there plans to?

2

u/Grimlyn Other May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Oh gawd, just think the cgi goof off robot in 3d running around like yogi bear or the chipmunks with zany cartoonish actions to appeal to the g rated masses.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Asimo should star in it.

8

u/LittleBlessedVillain May 13 '12

Well, firin' up Netflix now.

6

u/Windows_98 May 13 '12

It isn't on Netflix :(

6

u/LittleBlessedVillain May 13 '12

I found that out. Very unhappy. Watching Louis C.K. instead.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/johntheChristian May 13 '12

And many people have decided rape/murder is perfectly acceptable.

9

u/sandwichhands May 13 '12

What movie is this from?

30

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

short circuit

13

u/happycadaver May 13 '12

fucking love these movies. Oh childhood...

8

u/Kafke Ex-Atheist May 13 '12

these movies

O.O There was more than one?

9

u/stilldash May 13 '12

There were two. The second one holds up well in my opinion.

7

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

The second one is actually a lot better.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/hardcoremorning May 13 '12

Wall - E (jokes)

3

u/MrJuwi May 13 '12

Whatever happened to the Gutenberg?

2

u/thebendavis May 13 '12

The rest of his career.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Ryanami May 13 '12

He lost the support of the stonecutters.

3

u/DoctorLost173 May 13 '12

But wouldn't insane people pick and choose morals that would be considered be bad by others in society?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

And wouldn't that apply equally to theist and atheist alike?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

How do theists know what morals to cherry pick from bibles?

7

u/SkaTSee May 13 '12

Is that Wall-E?

9

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I'm glad I'm not the only person who thought this. Apparently you and I need to watch Short Circuit.

12

u/xAbaddon May 13 '12

WALL-E + E.T = Short Circuit. Great film.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Meet Johnny 5, an awesomebot.

4

u/nd4spd1919 Atheist May 13 '12

I get my morals from Star Trek. And reddit. And something called Common-Friggin-Sense!

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

"I think atheists may be more moral than religious people because a truly good person does not need the promise of heaven to see the merit it performing good deeds." - I don't remember who said this but I think it's relevant.

5

u/stinkcheese May 13 '12

It seems you have perfectly defined the problem of subjective morals. What if you told you that it was right? Certainly as a society we would be right to punish you.

But not because what you did was wrong. Just because what you did harms others. Where there is no God, there is no objective way to determine right and wrong. That isn't an argument for God. Its just a fact of life.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

All morals are subjective. Because even if moral commandments are from God himself, they are still subjective to God.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/madslug17 May 13 '12

INNNNPUT

2

u/unnecessaryCAPS May 13 '12

This rules. Mort Short Circuit memes!

2

u/honestlyimeanreally May 13 '12

This may be a silly question...but is there hard evidence that we inherently know these kind of things are wrong? I'm not saying I disagree, I'm just a paranoid skeptic redditor.

2

u/vargonian May 13 '12

It's just evolutionary psychology. Having a sense that killing is wrong is a survival trait, or at least an easily deduced moral standard based on our instinctive desire not to be killed.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/DevestatingAttack May 13 '12

Is there hard evidence that we inherently know these kind of things are wrong?

If you don't believe in a god, then all bets are off. If you don't believe in a god, "wrong" becomes a relative norm and "know" becomes more like "believe".

2

u/jefferson987 May 13 '12

NEED INPUT. JOHNNY 5 IS ALIVE!

2

u/csolisr May 13 '12

I. Told. Me.

And if you're wrong? ;D

2

u/lycan123 May 13 '12

where is this from?

2

u/dankula May 13 '12

Johnny kicked my balls into outer space. I'm coping.

2

u/FUCK_YOU_BRO May 13 '12

Oh yea...So the social context you were brought up in had no influence on you. If you're trying to argue that you can just grow up in a bubble and develop morality, I'd laugh at the incompatibility between that notion and atheism.

2

u/ScienceOwnsYourFace May 13 '12

Because I have no other way to brag about my video game alias for the last 15 years, I'll leave this here. Maybe 0.01% of all gamers know what it is. http://i.imgur.com/Z1hKF.jpg

2

u/SenorStabby May 13 '12

Your morals are a product of your environment regardless of whether you're gnostic, agnostic, or an atheist

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

You picked one of the worst movies ever, to make your point?

2

u/namblaotie May 13 '12

Came here for mushroom foraging advice, left without a single morel and smelling of dissapointment.

2

u/HolyPhallus May 13 '12

Killing someone isn't inherently wrong, it's just become rather counterproductive with a few exceptions.

2

u/mechanate May 13 '12

"You know who else had his own morals? Hitler." (Typical response.)

43

u/lazydictionary May 12 '12 edited May 13 '12

Except you didn't. Society already told you killing is wrong, that's why it's against the law.

Your morals come from the culture you are raised in and the society you live in. You don't really just come up with them on your own.

28

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Society is NOT the only place morality comes from, otherwise where would moral progress come from if not for a need to advance our morality? There are many, many different things that come into play, society is only one of them.

→ More replies (6)

134

u/SkipToTheEnd May 13 '12

I strongly disagree with this. Morality comes from universal, applicable reason. (This is the first time I feel my recently-completed dissertation has been relevant to anything)

Kant develops this argument further with his 'universal imperative'.

94

u/AnOnlineHandle May 13 '12

Morality (or moral action) possibly mostly comes from DNA, shaped by evolution of a social species. Relevant TED talk

20

u/TheMeddlingMonk May 13 '12

Monkeys sure do love grapes

4

u/DoesntBrian2Gud May 13 '12

If I had a lot of money I would just buy a lot of monkeys and lavish them with an insanely decadent lifestyle including being fed grapes at poolside like a roman emperor would be fed.

10

u/miparasito May 13 '12

Bonus points if you use trained monkeys to feed your empires monkeys grapes.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/light24bulbs May 13 '12

The three parent comments to this one remarkably sum up what I believe are the three contributing factors to what we call morality. From most internal/low level to external they are: Evolved Behaviors Logic Societal pressures

→ More replies (1)

18

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Can you elaborate on how one can derive morals from reason alone and a set of axioms? I'm awfully curious.

26

u/SkipToTheEnd May 13 '12

Well, a shamefully over-simplified way of putting it is, to some extent, viewing an action's morality by judging "Is this how I would wish everyone to act in this situation?"

We can rationalise the outcome of all agents acting the same way to decide if we can deem something moral. The best example is promise-keeping. I have a choice to break a promise, would I wish all agents to break promises? ; the concept of promise would become valueless.

It does require a respect for the general concept of morality and the idea of an innate need to preserve it. This is equally explainable rationally, as a sort of utilitarian judgement that a moral society has greater happiness than an immoral one. I believe this to be self-evident.

Its sort of a variation of 'do unto others as you would have them do to you' (the bible, ironically, providing us with morality's alternate source).

Like I say, not meaning to dodge criticism, but this is all horribly nutshell-ed. Best read Kant, he's all, like, good at writing philosophy and shit, whereas I have probably failed my degree :)

5

u/dancon25 May 13 '12

Well, a shamefully over-simplified way of putting it is, to some extent, viewing an action's morality by judging "Is this how I would wish everyone to act in this situation?"

It does require a respect for the general concept of morality and the idea of an innate need to preserve it. This is equally explainable rationally, as a sort of utilitarian judgement that a moral society has greater happiness than an immoral one.

First, categorical imperative. Then, utilitarianism. Does not compute.

5

u/snacknuts May 13 '12

I believe this to be self-evident.

You are arguing for the existence of self evident morals by assuming self evidence exists?

→ More replies (71)

2

u/VerilyAMonkey May 13 '12

There are hundreds of ways (utilitarian, superrational, categorical imperative) to tackle the question from logical standpoints, and they all have failings but these failings can match up surprisingly well to failings of ethics we encounter anyway, meaning that it may not be impossible to describe human ethics logically. However, in the same way that nobody actually wants to really understand things like 'the mystery of love', etc, it becomes obvious while answering the question that it isn't actually the question we want to ask.

→ More replies (19)

5

u/daboyz12 May 13 '12

This logic Kant be beaten!

5

u/sturg1dj May 13 '12

we live in the safest point in human existence. The point where we collectively have the most reverence for human life. Yet there is still debate on whether or not executing someone is murder or abortion is murder. There are entire groups who believe that killing is ok if it is for a good enough reason (like god or war or both). There are still societies who think rape is the woman's fault, and not too long ago we collectively let rapes go as long as it wasn't too brutal. A couple of generations ago is was almost universally seen as ok to beat your wife and children. 70 years ago we put people in camps because they were different, Germany put people in camps and then murdered them because they were different, and the Japanese systematically murdered and raped thousands. 100 years ago we put our kids to work for more hours than our adults work now. Thousands of years ago Spartan warriors had sex with pre-teen boys before battle. I am skipping around a lot, but I put all of these down just to pose the question how are these ideas not societal? Our actions may have began with satisfying urges or answering questions, but eventually we, as members as a larger society find better way to solve our issues and satisfy our urges. If we look at history we see a long line of brutal military and law enforcement. It took a change in the way society sees violence to change the way we treat our enemies and criminals. It is not perfect yet, but there is a pretty huge difference between now seeing a cop beat someone up and the same thing 200 years ago.

5

u/forr May 13 '12

I think Kant was talking about the root of morality as a whole, not how individual person acquires it.

Also, Nietzsche would disagree with all of that (like a lot of other philosophers).

3

u/monopolymonocle May 13 '12

Cross culturally, the prohibition on homicide is far from universal. For example, infanticide is common in Brazilian slums (see Death Without Weeping, Scheper-Hughes), endemic warfare among the precontact Yanomamo or Maori, or senicide practiced by the Tamil Nadu in India. That doesn't even touch fatal forms of ritual combat or human sacrifice. Even our culture, as a general rule, permits killing under diverse circumstances such as self-defense, military action, capital punishment, and (depending on your political predilections) natal abortion.

tldr: Kant was empirically wrong.

3

u/adius May 13 '12

What's that universal reason worth when it's so often not applied? "Well they COULD figure out how to not be assholes. Theoretically"

pointless

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Unless you go about raising children outside of society how could you prove this? Before we even have recall-able memory of our childhood a part of our morality has been put in place by our parents. Young children kill things and feel no remorse for the action until someone comes up and explains it to them.

Would it not be possible at that first moment to tell them that you did the thing you killed a favor?

Fully prepared for your explanation (or not if you so choose), this is not a gotcha.

6

u/QuitReadingMyName May 13 '12

Nope hes right, if you were brought up and seen your dad/mom randomly killing people and not holding themselves back you would be doing the same thing they were doing as that's how society operated.

The reason you refrain from doing anything because you grew up seeing thats normal in society and adapted to it.

2

u/PeonSanders May 13 '12

That's easily one of the most bankrupt parts (and there are many) of Kantian ethics.

There's very little that's rational about ethics in any practical sense. We can see the absurdity of such a view of ethics when they are turned on the very things they are meant to address, for example, just war theory. It would be a very uncontroversial and almost universally agreed upon precept that killing babies is wrong, however people will agree with policies that do just that. The proverbial devil is in the details of how those various policies and discourses are managed, mixed with a host of other factors as other people point out. It's very poorly understood, especially by the most boring of all enlightenment philosophers.

2

u/DevestatingAttack May 13 '12

And the idea that reason should guide morality is what... taken for granted?

2

u/emote_control Ignostic May 13 '12

Kant failed utterly to ground morality in reason.

Which makes sense because morality isn't rational. Altruism is built in to the species, and doesn't require rational justification. If it did, it wouldn't function properly.

5

u/adds_a_maths_pun May 13 '12

However social anthropology would argue there is no universal applicable reason; in short we're just entrenched in western (read: ancient Greece onwards) reasoning (based on dogmatically justified (and therefore in my view unjustified) axioms such as 'something cannot be both p and not p'). Surely on the grand scale morals stem from the self-preserving nature/optimisation inherent to life?

4

u/VerilyAMonkey May 13 '12

The current and trendy "think outside the box" ideas - like questioning 'something cannot be both p and not p' - came about because people have indeed questioned it. People have explored p being not p. Even when successful this questioning does not lead to an entirely radically different logical system where up is down and red fish are blue fish. It does lead to interesting new ideas as opportunities overlooked because of false assumptions become open. But the results are not inconsistent with what has come before; they may tweak them at most.

Einstein totally revolutionized physics, all of the originally sacrosanct laws put forth by Newton were changed, and yet all of science did not collapse to ground. This is because both systems were attempting to describe the same world, and Einstein's was just a little closer.

Western mathematics, for example, are very different from other forms of mathematics that have popped up throughout time. Greek math was incredibly geometric, Egyptian was very practical. Those two are terrible examples but they're the only ones I know about. Across the board, though, questions asked and methods of solving them are vastly different. Even so, every single one of these mathematical systems are 100% consistent with modern math, if context is properly taken into account.

Our perception of the world is entirely based on our analysis of sensory input. Perception is man made. What it attempts to describe - the world - is not.

Mathematic techniques, abstractions, rules are man made. The phenomena they attempt to describe are not.

The man-made-ness of logic systems does not jeopardize the universality of what they attempt to describe.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/lazydictionary May 13 '12

Yeah, except 99% of the world doesn't study Philosophy or Ethics. All the morality most people learn or have they received from their culture and society.

→ More replies (13)

19

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

And what about smoking trees? My morals are telling me that it is okay but it is against the law.

15

u/Cheeseyx May 13 '12

Well, smoke is caused by fire, and trees burn, ergo only you can prevent forest fires.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/filenotfounderror May 13 '12

I don't think and quite seriously doubt that is true at all. The notion that "Killing is wrong" is far more likely an evolutionary human trait in general than something anyone told you.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I always thought it was an inherent thing to like other people for the companionship, and if you like people you want them to be happy, and you know that if they killed you you'd be unhappy, and you assume you're reasonably similar to them, and therefore they like being alive, and... well, you get what I mean.

2

u/asdfman123 May 13 '12

You do what your parents, siblings, peers, authorities and other role models do.

People like to think of themselves as so intellectually independent. Really, though, what we believe has so much to do with the womb we popped out of and the people we knew when we were growing up. They're the basis from which the large majority of our values spring.

It's hard for the ego to accept that fact, but it's pretty real. While some intellectual freedom is possible--and I consider myself a bit of a freethinker, too--for the most part we're simply going around imitating the people our brains have told us we should imitate.

3

u/znk May 13 '12

Empathy has much more to do with it. Sociopaths lack it and dont have the same morals. At it's core if you have a high degree of empathy you wont do to others what you wouldnt want done to you. Regardless of culture. No adult needs to be thought that kicking a baby in the face is wrong. Those who do it still know it's wrong.

4

u/Space_Ninja May 13 '12

Well somebody fucking came up with it without being told, at least once. How would you explain that? Magic?

You don't need to be told to avoid pain, and death. You don't need to be told that it would suck if someone caused you pain, and death. Empathy teaches you the rest.

Oh, and society also told me to love God and hate gays, and I refuse. Believe it or not, some people are capable of discerning right from wrong all on their own.

2

u/QuitReadingMyName May 13 '12

No, we learned it from evolution. We know how sensless it is to kill another through the natural selection process and feel empathy/apathy depending on the society we live in.

Hell, the only reason Gladiator fights were accepted in Ancient Rome is because the entire society accepted it.

It doesn't happen anymore because, our New society no longer accepts it that rose up from Rome's ashes.

2

u/onefoot_out May 13 '12

This is actually a really good point, why are you so pissed about it?

3

u/Space_Ninja May 13 '12

As a child, someone once told me to be bitter and angry, so I've been that way ever since.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/prattle May 13 '12

Your opinion of right, and your opinion of wrong. These may widely differ with what somebody else comes up with.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/MilitaryFuneral May 13 '12

I question morals all the time. So this pretty much throws your hypothesis out the window, sorry.

2

u/Greenei May 13 '12

Then why don't we all have the same morals? We are living in the same "society". I derive my morals mostly from thinking about it. If something does more harm but no good to others it can not be moral and if something does no harm to others it can not be immoral.

Hence I believe that homosexuality/fetishes/incest are perfectly moral while others would disagree. I don't see how that can be if everyone derives his morals from "society".

→ More replies (1)

1

u/miparasito May 13 '12

To your point, Johnny 5 told himself this after watching a lot of television.

1

u/strongscience62 May 13 '12

A person who can't create their own unique moral code is mentally underdeveloped. Children get the morals society, culture, and parents put on them. Adults, thinking people, create their own as they learn to think critically.

1

u/dumnezero Anti-Theist May 13 '12

both; society helps by giving you the tools to think (words)

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Show me evidence that this is true about OP, and we have a deal on our feets.

3

u/lazydictionary May 13 '12 edited May 13 '12

Until you learn to critically think, your morals are absorbed from your surroundings. Once you can critically think, they change and evolve. No one is born with some innate "killing is bad". Perhaps they'reborn with an instinct to not kill their family, friends, and relatives. Humans are fond of war, throughout all of their history. We like to kill each other.

4

u/LittleBlessedVillain May 13 '12

We also like to form tribal groups. The problem is once we're forced to deal with the concept of too many people we stop thinking of them in terms of actual people, and then the killing can commence.

You're both sort of right.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

"I have gained from this philosophy: that I do without being commanded what others do only from fear of the law." -Aristotle

→ More replies (7)

3

u/CmonTouchIt May 13 '12

Honestly, if anyone asks me, I say its as simple as: Think of what you wouldnt wan't someone to do to you...and there's your morals

2

u/seanflyon May 13 '12

That answers the question "what are your morals?" but does nothing to answer the question "where do your morals come from?"

→ More replies (4)

1

u/thehappybirthday May 13 '12

very clever... short circuit and morals...

1

u/Warpedme May 13 '12

Honestly, I get most of my morals from Sci-fi. All I have to do is be one of the good guys, it is that simple.

1

u/zephyy May 13 '12

Is this the movie where the robot kills the cat? Cause that made me cry as a kid and I couldn't watch the rest of it.

Robot looks familiar.

3

u/vargonian May 13 '12

I believe he kills a grasshopper but I don't think he ever kills a cat. Also: Apparently I'm old.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/atomsapple May 13 '12

JOHNNY NUMBER 5... IS ALIVE!

1

u/Kochen May 13 '12

This reminds me of my favorite quote in the Bible. 'And He said, 'who told you that you were naked?' Gen 3:11

1

u/logspriggan May 13 '12

Iron Giant helped me a lot.

1

u/AFrpaso May 13 '12

This has been argued for thousands of years.

1

u/prattle May 13 '12

I think you've missed their point. They are asking for evidence which is the same thing you might ask for in a different situation.

1

u/oOQCc_ May 13 '12

I know people who need religion to answer this very question...which makes me think religion isn't always a bad thing. Were it not for the fear of punishment or possible reward they expect after death, they would kill those who they'd deem less deserving of life...whether it be because those people are less considerate of others (in comparison to themselves) or are just people we'd all regard as "bad" (rapist, murderers with malicious intentions, etc.). What do you guys think? At times I think that corporal punishment and religion would work well together.

1

u/kumochisonan May 13 '12

I recently watched Sam Harris give a talk in relation to his most recent book 'Free Will'. In the talk, he proposed that the concept of Free Will is an illusion, and that he could scientifically prove that we are entirely deterministic in the way we make choices moment to moment. Everything we do is determined by external causes, be they cultural or biochemical.

As an aside to this, he stated that people who do "bad" things have no real choice to be good, as their mental state at the time of committing the deed is an end result of of events completely outside their control such as upbringing or neurochemistry. In his model of determinism, it is a far better thing to rehabilitate than punish, and to address the root causes that made the "bad" people who they are over the course of their lives.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/lihaoza May 13 '12

Didn't he get his morals from a bolt of lightning?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

What movie is this?

1

u/The_Pseudonym May 13 '12

what is this movie. I remember seeing it as a child.

1

u/aschesklave Atheist May 13 '12

What is this from?

1

u/10thTARDIS May 13 '12

It's from Short Circuit, or its sequel, Short Circuit 2. I can't remember which.

1

u/Grimlyn Other May 13 '12

It's the Gute!! You can never have enough Gute!!

1

u/pimpin_cowboy May 13 '12

sooooo, what movie/show is this?

1

u/liquidxlax May 13 '12

my parents once asked me where my morals come from if i don't believe in teh bible ( not christian parents, or any relgion), and then i asked well where did teh people in the bibles get their morals from?

1

u/aceusprime May 13 '12

Johnny 5. oh god, this was the movie of my childhood.

Short Circuit 2 almost made me cry.

1

u/QueenNavy May 13 '12

he also could've told himself that murder is right so...

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

...Does this unit have a soul?

1

u/-_-readit May 13 '12

Is that Wall-Es dad?

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

There's a simpler answer to the question of where we get our morals: "It appears that such actions are more likely to survive over time."

1

u/sef3000 May 13 '12

A touching moment, and then BOOM! Antisemitism!

1

u/Batrok May 13 '12

Whenever I get asked that, I say 'from... my... brain.'

1

u/Fuckstupidppl May 13 '12

Even a robot can understand!

1

u/lungbuttersandwich May 13 '12

INPUT! MORE INPUT.

1

u/bleakreserve May 13 '12

anyone else thought this was live-action wall.e?

1

u/donaldrobertsoniii May 13 '12

Just a heads up to anyone who is going to re-watch the Short Circuit movies: the Indian character is actually Fisher Stevens painted up to look Indian. Apparently he was banned from India for twenty years because the portrayal was so offensive.

1

u/Logophagi May 13 '12

Animals that like to be with one another tend to have instinctive morals they do not need a reason to be kind to on another, if they were killing each other every day obviously they would go extinct.

1

u/JustGotSmashed May 13 '12

Is that C.H.E.E.S.E from Mac and C.H.E.E.S.E?

1

u/MooCowMilkshakes May 13 '12

When does anyone ask you where you get your morals? ._.

1

u/redbaboons28 May 13 '12

my civics teacher said in the past people attending the event dress up with angel wings and drape white sheets over them and stand in a circle around the protesters to block them so no one can see them but they can exercise their right to protest. It would be hard to organize but if you could pull it off im sure it would mean the world to your friend;

1

u/shtrudl May 13 '12

the robot looks like C.H.E.E.S.E.

1

u/Hides_In_Plain_Sight May 13 '12

Short Circuit always brings such fond memories back; rather than lambast the large number of people here who don't know the film, I would instead eagerly recommend that you make time to watch the two films. Even now, they're fun, they're heartwarming, and... well, the robot hasn't actually aged too badly, all things considered.

1

u/qwerty622 May 13 '12

it's more likely that societal norms told you

1

u/Sniper_Echo May 13 '12

Heart wrenching stuff

1

u/painperdu May 13 '12

Morality comes from evolution and environmental fit. That is, if other things in the environment don't like what you're doing then it will let you know by killing you off.

1

u/MrMercurial May 13 '12

I find this description a little confusing. Suppose, for example that I believe it's moral to steal from people. So, (I assume) the story would go that people like me will not tend to survive, because we will be ostracized.

If this is right, then where did I get my beliefs about it being moral to steal from people, before I was ostracized?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Radico87 May 13 '12

And because your morals are internal rather than external in origin, you're probably a better person.

1

u/Randyh524 May 13 '12

Need input!

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Wouldn't you like to be a pepper too?

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Classic.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Is that Wall-E?

11

u/ImGumbyDamnIt May 13 '12

No, Johnny 5 from Short Circuit.

2

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Did they base Wall-E off Johnny 5?

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

3

u/jonny_five May 13 '12

nope.

2

u/atomsapple May 13 '12

I'll allow it.

1

u/sturg1dj May 13 '12

you just made me feel my age. Now I'm sad.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Even if you're an atheist (I am too) a lot of your morals derive from Judeo-Christian values. When you live in a society where 90% of people are Christian it will happen one way or another, social pressure is far too high for you not to follow it.

6

u/Ploppy17 May 13 '12

Even if you're an atheist (I am too) a lot of your morals derive from Judeo-Christian values.

I think the relationship goes the otherway, that "Christian morality" is really just a reflection of the values of certain societies, which is why it seems to have been so flexible historically.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ozzymandias May 13 '12

This is perhaps the best thing ever. Combining childhood with powerful philosophy. Can't get much better than that.

2

u/Ryanami May 13 '12

This is actually very weak philosophy. How do I know? I told me.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/alwaysmorelmn May 13 '12

God I love this movie.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

i am completely terrified of people who say they get their morals from heavy religious chains.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Game theory is a better answer. You can model various societal structures and figure out which one ultimately fares better.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Actually, your parents told you. A child has no inherent sense of morality. A 2 year old can drop a clay pot onto someone's head and kill them without giving a shit.

1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Soooo profound. - Checkmate again, Christians

-3

u/Harbinger_of_Cool May 13 '12

Right and wrong are just ideas. The only reason we don't go kill each other is because we're not allowed.

8

u/Chaosflare44 Secular Humanist May 13 '12

Wrong. If that were true what stops other social animals (e.g. Lions, wolves, etc) from killing each other. Last I checked they had no system of laws.

Its all about the choice that is most beneficial to survival. At some point on the evolutionary timeline a group of organisms came to the realization that working together gave them a better chance of survival then going solo. This is what eventually leads to concepts like 'murder is wrong' and so forth.

Not killing each other has nothing to do with what is 'allowed'.

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

They kill each other all the time, strictly out of convenience.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (12)

3

u/ImGumbyDamnIt May 13 '12

A lot of empathy studies on infants and toddlers would refute that. Citation, more citations.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/spacecadetzen May 13 '12

I'm not even much a fan of killing bugs, though I do feel like I'm defining my territory. I do not feel like I have the right to take the life of anyone or anything. You must understand the implications. What if reincarnation is true and you squashed your former grandfather on the sidewalk?