26
u/asthepalacesburn May 09 '12
(*women)
21
u/Jungle_Is_Massif May 09 '12
Whenever I read the 'woman' where it's meant to be 'women' I end up reading the rest of the passage in a stereotypical African accent.
11
0
u/vanduzew May 09 '12
I actually thought i might have been the first one to say this. Damn you ctrl F.
18
u/Niyeaux Anti-theist May 09 '12
If only it were true. Unfortunately, it's going to take much more than a single generation to do away with the ubiquity of bigoted religious doctrines.
13
u/Philo_T_Farnsworth Agnostic Atheist May 09 '12
This is true. One of my friends for high school lives in North Carolina and he has been spouting off on his Facebook feed all week urging people to vote FOR the Amendment. He was fucking overjoyed when it became obvious it was going to win in a landslide. Makes me sick.
4
2
u/Iarwain_ben_Adar May 09 '12
Especially so when you factor in the undermining of the educational system in the US, currently in progress.
Several states have placed religion (intelligent design) side by side with evolution in the science classroom.
9
May 09 '12
I never comment in r/atheism mostly because i'm Australian and i'm never really bothered by religious fanatics. I'm sure there are some in Australia but i never see them, but this quote is exactly what i've thought for a long time. Just the kindergarten rules that you should mind your own business and let other people make decisions about themselves, especially if it doesn't affect you. I understand how people can think they have a right to choose how someone else lives their life. If politicians announced 'hey everyone we're gonna pass this bill on gay marriage and there's nothing you can do about it' people would be in an uproar, because they didn't get to vote and choose it, which almost ironically is what they're voting against, the right for people to make their own decision, however in this case it's about marriage. Just my two cents..
2
May 09 '12
Democracy works and everything is hunky dory.... Only when the liberal vote goes their way.
9
May 09 '12
I was in the south about two months ago. Southern VA actually.
I was in a coffee shop and someone asked where I was from.
I said San Francisco.
They made a comment about how it must be "horrible" living with all "the gays" ...
And I said no it was awesome. That gay people are cool!
And they said that I was going to hell with the gay people (YAY for me apparently) ... and that gay people deserve to be in prison.
I told him this exact same thing. That he would be remembered as an ignorant excuse for a human by future generations just like the men who said that blacks didn't deserve the same rights as whites.
To my surprise he dug DEEPER and said that blacks DON'T deserve the same rights as whites.
Seriously... some people are just fucking retarded.
2
u/mleeeeeee May 09 '12
To my surprise he dug DEEPER and said that blacks DON'T deserve the same rights as whites.
He 'outsmarted' you.
1
u/bstone99 Atheist May 10 '12
good ol' virginia... I try to tell my friends that even though it's the most northern state of the southern bible belt it's just as bad. NOVA by DC and some parts of Hampton Roads isn't too bad, but everywhere is else is indistinguishable from AL, MS, TX, GA, NC, TN
42
u/furryspoon May 09 '12
Someone asked me the other day about 100 years in the future and how stupid we might now seem. On that score, I nominated our treatment of gay people as something that will seem barbaric - like slavery does to us now.
8
u/55555 May 09 '12
The problem as I see it is that we are even treating "gay people" differently as though the qualifier matters. In the future, the robot armies will enslave all people equally without prejudice.
21
u/DeadOptimist May 09 '12
It is not always progress which the future holds. The dark ages were not limited to one time or one culture.
15
May 09 '12
The Dark Ages actually was pretty much a European Era. Heck, my dictionary defines Dark Ages as:
The period of European history encompassing (roughly) 476–1000 .
Unless you're attempting to use the phrase to describe any regressive move in society?
27
u/DeadOptimist May 09 '12
I am indeed. Arabia was the scientific centre of the world for a long time (it is where we get numbers from, algebra, 70% of the star names etc.) until a very stringent re/interpretation of Islam pushed them into their own dark ages.
It might not be labelled as such, but the similarities are for me enough to think of them under an over arching name.
→ More replies (1)5
u/Jeffy29 May 09 '12
From what I have read turn to more conservative interpretation of Islam caused Arabs unseccesful attempts to defend themselfs against crusaders.
It's really fascinating to think how would world look like if crusades never happened, would europe now be a third world region? Would arabs be first to discover new world?
→ More replies (7)6
u/mezofoprezo May 09 '12
any regressive move in society
I imagine this is the case.
Hell, look at Iran over the last 50 years. The country was gaining its feet during the "Pahlavi Dynasty" and then all hell broke loose in a fit of Islamic Radicalism.
In refreshing my memory on Wikipedia, it saddens me to look at Shah Pahlavi's attempt at reform and see the same trends in America..
→ More replies (1)1
u/Bitshift71 May 09 '12
We're in a Dark Ages now because of the Internet. I hardly ever turn on my lights, it makes it more difficult to read the screen. Please pull the shades on your way out.
2
May 09 '12
This is what I think about when I think of how I asked questions to my grandparents about black people not having rights and if they supported it or not. I'm sure my grandkids will be asking me if I supported homosexuality or not.
Then again, who knows. The future is always uncertain.
1
u/TheyCallMeTomSawyer May 09 '12
Really, I feel like it's a fair point. Through all the different rights movements in the past few centuries, those seeking fairness and acceptance have gradually gained just that. Granted, there are still racists and sexists that don't hide their views. However, simply telling them that it's the trend so they should just give up is like saying hipsters are becoming more popular, so you should just be a hipster. (On a side note, fuck hipsters.) We have our beliefs, they have theirs, and I'm pretty sure whenever I come to r/atheism, top comments are always saying how the community should be about voicing why we believe what we do, not trying to impose our ideas on anyone who disagrees.
1
May 09 '12
Well since homosexuality is genetic, perhaps we can cure heterosexual bigotry through genetics.... Or cure homosexuality through genetics.... Take a pick
14
u/whynotdan Agnostic May 09 '12
I've always said this. We cringe now when we hear someone say something with racist undertones. Often, I find, it's an older person and we chalk it up to being from "that era", but really, that era is happening right now, just with a different group.
On the other hand, I find it refreshing when I talk to an older person who knew it was wrong and stood up against it at the time.
I want my grandchildren to know that when there was still screwed up discrimination towards gays in this country, I was against it.
0
May 09 '12
Racism is not dead, it just went into hiding. The majority of the people I meet are racist in some way. Mostly, its just the "I don't know any better" racism, like saying someone "acts white," because they aren't ghetto.
Black people are racists. White people are racists. Brown people, and Asians too. It's far too easy to associate behavior with appearance.
3
1
u/whynotdan Agnostic May 09 '12
I didn't say it was dead, nor do I think that. But there are no obvious racist laws anymore (like the Jim Crow Laws of the first half of last century) , as there are against the civil rights of gay couples now.
You kind of went on a tangent about subtle racism, but that too will fade with time.
Obviously, there will never be a complete extinction of a thought (look at Scientology), but they can be diminished to being held by only a few people.
1
May 09 '12
I actually agree with you. My point was that even after the laws are changed, and the attitude subsides within society, the thoughts are still alive and well.
→ More replies (1)
54
u/thesorrow312 May 09 '12
If you want to actually be a free thinker, then we need to start advocating for the rights for Polyamorous relationships to be able to get the same benefits and recognition as traditional marriage.
Marriage is an exclusionary system in which benefits are only given to a specific set of pre determined type of relationship.
If the gay marriage advocates want to be true advocates and true revolutionaries, they would not be trying to get themselves a place within the exclusionary system, but instead advocate for all relationship types to be seen as equal under the law.
If you believe that two men should be able to get married, then why not 3 men who are in love with each other, in a mutual, consenting relationship, or any other combination of genders / sexual preference in a relationship that includes more than two people?
22
u/youonlylive2wice May 09 '12
Because at that point you really do have legitimate differences in relationship structure. If a person has one SO, regardless of gender, you don't have to change anything regarding health insurance, hospital decisions, next of kin, non-prenup'ed marriages.
Change that from 2 people to 3 and suddenly each one of those is significantly more complicated. Who gets to make which hospital decisions when? What is the companies obligation in regards to health insurance? Can one party bankrupt the other 2? In the case of divorce, what if it is a 3-way split? What if 1 leaves and 2 stay together? what if a 4th joins in then later they all split up? Sorry, but at that point the conservatives have a point, that the possibilities and potential confusions are endless... not marrying your goat endless but legal battle and time wasted endless.
The gay marriage thing is saying that their relationships are fundamentally the same thing in the eyes of the law and should be treated as such. A poly relationship is not the same in the eyes of the law.
3
May 09 '12
Obviously, in a more ideal society, we would have universal health care coverage so that it would be cheaper to pay for extra insurance for individuals. That or companies can decide to give benefits to employee + one named beneficiary, and X amount of children. Course, the rate paid would go up since most things should be covered anyway.
Divorce is already pretty ugly in a lot of cases, and there aren't going to be a lot of polyamourous relationships. Many people who claim to be poly just want an excuse to cheat on their SO, so I don't think the population is that incredibly large.
1
u/youonlylive2wice May 09 '12
Agreed, the quantity will be low, but rememberthat laws aren't written with the assumption they'll rarely be used and the few cases they are used "we'll figure them out then." In fact, those laws which will be rarely used must be even more clearly defined as the judge will be less familiar with the intent of the law. Thus we end up w/ monster tax codes...
1
May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Wanted to upvote until that last part. You really don't understand what it means to be poly.
Edit: I should have said "I am upvoting everything but that last part...".
2
May 09 '12
No I don't. I should say I have met a couple of people who claim to be poly and used that an excuse to cheat on their husband. Just two people though, so it's not representative of the population and I only harbor resentment because of a bad experience of that claim.
Still, the population compared to homosexuality probably isn't that large, so I was making an argument that the courts should battle it out because despite being incredibly ugly, there may only be a few cases in a district or so.
Then again, I don't know any real polyamourous people, so I don't understand that aspect relating to size of population.
1
u/thesorrow312 May 09 '12
We definitely need a radical redrawing of our marriage / civil union laws. They can definitely become more streamlined so that people, regardless of whether they are married or not, can decide who their will goes to, who gets hospital visitation, and so on.
What if you want your nephew or best friend to get hospital visitation? People should have that right.
This is my whole argument, marriage is an exclusive system, which is inherently unfair. People should be fighting to have the entire system changed fundamentally. Now that would be something to march in the streets for. Inclusion of minorities into such a system is only going to make the problem harder to fix in the long term.
I have nothing but love for homosexuals and lesbians, but I don't really "support" the gay marriage movement. I don't stand in the way of it either, but I honestly feel like it is only going to bolster an already extremely flawed institution.
1
u/youonlylive2wice May 09 '12
And your idea works, IF PEOPLE DO THE PAPERWORK. But that is a MAJOR if.
How many people would have DNR's but don't because they don't even have a will? What do you do in a case of 3 people being legally married and then a Terri Schiavo happens? One person wants to pull, the other doesn't, who gets the legal authority... Well if they'd filled out their paperwork... but they didn't.
What about health insurance? Yes, if we had a universal system this would be a moot point, but we don't. So is a company required to provide health insurance to all of a persons spouses? We already have people getting married just to skirt around this right now... imagine if you could marry indeterminately.
Is marriage exclusive? In a sense, yes. In a sense it was also intended to be. That it was a legal union of two people who intended to be together for the rest of their lives.
So how would you tackle each of the numerous marriage issues which arise once you add in extra people while maintaining that the courts can make sense of it recognizing people are lazy? Because without such a plan it reads to me like "wouldn't it be awesome if you could do this?" but its just wishful thinking and what if's. And if my tone made it unclear, that was a serious question about what would you propose.
3
u/doiten May 09 '12
That is certainly a strong point you bring out, one that i have not thought of yet!
Also, it bugs me that we try to push something into christianity and marriage i.e. gay-marriage. Is it not their religion with their rules? What am i missing? Why do people have to force something that they don't want happening. Can't be married as a gay-christian? Bo-hoo. My solution: Get the fuck out of the church, you don't need marriage to get the benefits of marriage.
Now, let the butthurt flow trough you!
2
u/papa-jones May 09 '12
Marriage is not a christian institution. The purpose isn't to force churches to do something they don't agree with, they don't have to marry a gay couple if they do not want. It is to give the legal right to marriage to same-sex couples. Get the church out of our laws.
1
u/diaperboy19 May 09 '12
This is a dispute about civil marriage not religious marriage. Catholics don't believe in divorce so the Catholic Church does not recognize any divorces. This doesn't mean that no one else is legally entitled to get a divorce, or even that Catholics aren't legally allowed to get divorced. The church simply doesn't acknowledge them. If you're religion is opposed to same-sex marriage then don't marry some one of the same sex, but trying to apply your religion's standards to everyone else's lives is unfair and a blatant disregard for the separation of church and state.
5
u/xoites May 09 '12
Please don't muddy the waters with whining about extraneous crap.
"If the Abolitionist were actually free thinkers why didn't they fight for Animal Rights?"
One pain in the ass step in social evolution at a time, please.
→ More replies (2)1
May 09 '12
"If the Abolitionist were actually free thinkers why didn't they fight for Animal Rights?"
Some of them did. (Jeremy Bentham, for example.) In general, people we remember for one thing actually did lots of things. Many suffragettes were vegetarians, many socialists were free love supporters, many 60s anti-war protesters were also anti-racism protesters.
I know this isn't really the main point of your argument, but I wanted to point out that when the stuff is happening it's messy and muddled, and then in the history books it gets categorized way more than it really was.
1
u/KeyboardChemistry May 09 '12
I'm very interested in trying to be as future-minded as possible.
This is one of the conclusions I have come to and feel strongly about. Are there any other big ones you can think of?
2
u/thesorrow312 May 09 '12
moving past capitalism
moving past states
anti nationalism (it is tribalism)
seeing as we are in /atheism, I guess I hardly need to mention getting past religion
discussions of ethics on a national scale, completely devoid of appeals to emotion, authority, tradition, faith, religion and so on.
1
u/KeyboardChemistry May 09 '12
I agree with all of those. =)
And then the rather cliche: global effort to fund scientific advancement, so that we can do whatever we can to get humanity off of this rock-- even if it means having AI-guided spaceships filled with human DNA travel through space for thousands of years towards an Earth-like planet-- so that we do not go extinct due to the course of one single planet.
Edit: Question: Where are you positioned on animal rights? I'm not quite sure myself. In terms of broad-strokes future-trends.. ie: will everyone in the future be a vegetarian/synthetic-food eater so that we don't have to cause animals suffering?
3
u/thesorrow312 May 09 '12
I honestly do not know where I am on Animal rights. My position currently is, I'll be honest, I love meat. I think we should treat them as humanely as possible while alive, for both their sake, and our sake (you are what you eat), they need to be healthy so that when we consume them, we will be as well.
I think making the first step to taking care of healthy livestock in good loving conditions that do not lead to problems in human beings, is a good start.
→ More replies (1)1
1
u/itsadok May 09 '12
While you're at it, why stick with the dichotomy of Married/Not Married? Human relationships can be far more complex. Maybe I share my income with four people, my children with two and my bed with one. It's really not far fetched. Using the Marriage stamp as a condition to the myriad tax issues, inheritance issues, custody issues and more is too simplistic.
If (due to a series of unfortunate events) me and my father are sharing a household and raising my two children there's no reason we shouldn't be considered "married" for whatever benefit a couple would enjoy.
1
-8
May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
there always has to be a limit. you're already saying there should be a limit by saying they should be consensual, and that is a very good limit to have. having sex with children has also been proven to do physical, developmental and psychological damage to them. so no, just because i accept adults getting married out free will doesn't mean i should accept all forms of marriage.
edit: wow, don't know why this is such a horrible thing to say. i never said polyamorous relationships were wrong or that gay marriage leads to pedophilia. i just said that we shouldn't say "all relationship types" should be equal because "all" includes all the shitty ones as well as the good ones. we should be standing for consensual relationships that do no harm, but we can't just call it a free-for-all when we do have standards.
10
u/thesorrow312 May 09 '12
I didn't say all forms, or at least mean it.
Obviously I am not advocating marriage with minors.
I am talking about multiple consenting ADULTS.
People should be allowed to do whatever they like as long as it doesn't hurt them or anyone else. 3 men, or 2 women and 1 man, or whatever other combination, who love each other, should not be discriminated against for their love, and if there are going to be legal benefits for "marriage", then it should not be exclusionary, because we are all supposed to be equal. If only 1 man and one 1 woman can get married, and thus receive benefits, then equality no longer exists. Same if it was extended to a pair of gay individuals. Civil unions and the benefits of marriage should be available to any set of consenting adults who wish to receive them. Simple as that. Equality for all.
→ More replies (6)1
u/firex726 May 09 '12
It's a matter of agency and consent.
Can a minor? Nope
Dog? Nope
Toaster? Nope (Cylons excluded)
It's a non-argument meant to put you on the defensive when they bring up that kind of BS.
→ More replies (4)6
u/MrsAnthrope May 09 '12
"having sex with children"
Fucking really? That's the parallel you want to suggest?
3
May 09 '12
i don't think you understand my point. a lot of the homophobes keep saying "but if we legalize gay marriage, next they'll want to sleep with their dogs or their children", completely ignoring that the reason why people are opening to gay marriage but closed to pedophilia is because pedophilia has been proven to do great harm, whereas homosexuality has been proven to be harmless.
1
u/itsableeder May 09 '12
in a mutual, consenting relationship
That's the important bit, as you acknowledged before your bizarre tangent. Consent isn't a limit. Consent is what stops people from doing harm.
→ More replies (4)0
May 09 '12
[deleted]
1
May 09 '12
exactly. "as long as it's consensual" is what we really should care about, not "accepting ALL relationships", because "all" includes all the nonconsensual ones as well.
0
0
u/weak_game May 09 '12
This is a red herring worth of Rick Santorum. "Why not allow men to marry cats and women to marry their grandmothers?". The reality is that there is a sizeable group of people in our country with a somewhat shared identity (homosexuals). They are fighting for equal rights. That's the issue.
Any other semantic arguments about the definition of marriage are just smoke-and-mirrors to (badly) bolster the religion-based aversion to homosexuality.38
May 09 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
36
u/firex726 May 09 '12
Why give tax breaks and the like to married people at all?
So if two people say thy will spend the rest of their lives together that entitles them to pay less taxes then two people who did not.
I fail to see what about that would warrant lowering their taxes.
10
u/DestroyedGenius May 09 '12
I agree. In a joking way I always refer to this as a "tax on ugly people" in the sense that if some dude who wants marriage is forever alone and can't find a chick willing to rub nuptials with him he never has access to these tax breaks that are available to others.
→ More replies (1)9
u/firex726 May 09 '12
Find a lesbian.
I got married to a lesbian friend of mine for at the time tax reasons. I don't agree with it, but I'll take less taxes if it's being offered.
4
u/DigitalOsmosis May 09 '12 edited Jun 15 '23
{Post Removed} Scrubbing 12 years of content in protest of the commercialization of Reddit and the pending API changes. (ts:1686841093) -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/
→ More replies (4)5
u/Rackemup May 09 '12
Except that all big companies (insurance to health care to whatever) recognize that married couples are more stable and therefore cost them less money (therefore "encouraging" them to be married is good).
Encouraging stable families is a good thing, and the only way the govt can do that is by offering some tax incentives.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (4)2
u/Cloberella May 09 '12
I agree. Why do we even grant marriage rights? Let's just do away with the marriage requirement and let anyone who lives communal home with another individual, or individuals, receive some sort of group rights bundle package. Then people can get the rights they need without having to get married, and married couples aren't granted elevated status that can only be attained through religious rites.
→ More replies (1)3
u/firex726 May 09 '12
From a government standpoint I agree.
Of course I would qualify it by saying that if any private religious groups want to still honor such ideas such as marriage it's their business.
→ More replies (1)7
u/thesorrow312 May 09 '12
I don't even have any stake in this game. I am a monogomous, strait guy, but I care about other people and their happiness.
Yes I believe this would be literally 20 times harder than gay marriage, because unlike homosexuality, there is no scientific evidence that shows a specific person may be hardwired or born to be monogomous or polyamorous, although it is of large note that our species (known due to anthro / evo psych and bio) seems to be inherently polyamorous. Our early societies were, and it reflects in our genetics and phenotypes.
Anyways, yeah it would be an extremely long, and hard fought out battle, but I feel it is definitely worth it, it has to and will be done sometime, and during the gay marriage debates and legislative changes can be the best time to work in the narrative / dialogue.
6
u/YesNoMaybe May 09 '12
there is no scientific evidence...
Who cares? We aren't talking about defining what is biologically normal; We're talking about the rights of consenting adults to define their own relationships.
If you start making that as the argument for legalizing gay marriage then you give credit to anyone to use scientific evidence that homosexuality is not genetic or in-born as an argument to not make it legal. That's not the issue.
1
u/KeyboardChemistry May 09 '12
Have you read Sex at Dawn by any chance?
2
u/thesorrow312 May 09 '12
Yes, I just finished writing a 7 page essay about polyamory, as well as read the excellent journal article I cannot recommend more " Monogamy's law: Compulsory Monogamy and Polyamorous existence".
Sex at Dawn is excellent. So is "Evolutions rainbow".
→ More replies (1)1
u/havocs May 09 '12
Don't forget power of attorney in the case where people haven't worked it out beforehand
19
u/xRigorMortisx May 09 '12
Couple grammar errors but still a badass quote. Sent shivers down my spine. "So long as men die, liberty shall never parish!" -Charlie Chaplin
2
2
u/tigerfam1 May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
"Soldiers, don't give yourselves to brutes! Men who despise you and slave you! Who regiment your lives; who tell what to do, what to think, and what to feel! Who drill you, diet you, and treat you as cattle, and use you as cannon fodder! Soldiers, don't give yourselves to these unnatural men! Machine men with machine minds and machine hearts! You are not machines, you are not kettle, you are men!"-Charlie Chaplin
3
-2
u/Flynn58 May 09 '12
If your thinking about being a grammar nazi, please, just look at the comment above. It will not serve you well.
0
0
4
u/typtyphus Pastafarian May 09 '12
I'm having trouble finding this older reddit post.
It was a quote, it said something similar, it was something along the line like this: we progress little by little whenever the older generation dies with their old ways.
1
4
May 09 '12
I consider myself a devout follower of Christ, and I'm absolutely dismayed at what North Carolina did (and other southern states have previously done). Where is the love of Jesus in that legislation? Imagine how absurd it must seem to a gay person when they hear that God is love, but those who supposedly follow Him want to make sure they can't even do something simple like get spousal benefits.
When Jesus returns to earth and I'm sitting on the seat of judgment, I know in my heart that He's not going to ask "How well did you enforce the law on others?" He's going to ask "How well did you show my love and sacrifice to others?"
To everyone out there who has been deeply and profoundly hurt by the church, I'm sorry. God really does love you, even if some of His alleged followers can't understand it.
1
u/H_C_45 May 09 '12
By the same sentiment, we do our brothers and sisters no help if we allow them to live in sin. 1 Corinthians 6:9-11.
23
u/Boom_Boom_Crash May 09 '12
I wonder if you're aware that not everyone that voted for this amendment was a christian?
11
u/Flynn58 May 09 '12
Don't know why this is being downvoted, it's obviously true. We've had some atheists on here vote for the amendment and announce it on here.
11
u/Jeffy29 May 09 '12
Did they explain why?
8
18
u/johnsweber May 09 '12
Do they need to? Religion isn't generally the cause of bigotry, people just use it to defend their bigoted views.
→ More replies (2)2
u/Ethanol_Based_Life May 09 '12
Correct. Morals instilled by your parents via their life experiences aren't any better or worse than morals instilled by them via the bible. Hell, a lot of people develop their personality from books they read and music they listen to. Is letting Catcher in the Rye affect your view of adolescents any different than letting the bible affect your view of prostitutes?
→ More replies (8)2
u/jimcrator May 09 '12
They just had a whole thread on it over at askreddit...
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/tcw5j/are_there_any_nonreligious_arguments_against/
4
u/coooolbeans May 09 '12
What would you estimate the percentage is of people who voted for it that were Christian?
I'd put the over/under at about 90-95%.
1
u/Boom_Boom_Crash May 09 '12
I'd say it is significantly less. I am not originally from the south, and am not a religious person, so I can give a relatively unbiased opinion. I would say the percentage would be closer to 70%.
You have to realize that A LOT of people just don't like the homosexual community. They see what I refer to as "the raging homosexuals" that are the stereotypical ones, (Don't lie, everyone knows who I'm talking about) and they assume the entire community is like that, and they don't like it and they don't want it around. Lets be honest, the LGBT community has done a really shit job with PR over the years. They have this "we're different, fuck you if you don't like it attitude" which is all well and good, but if they want the majority to take them seriously and let them have equal rights they need to have more of a "we aren't so different than you" approach.
A huge amount of people are trying to make this be the same as the black fight for civil rights, and it just isn't. African Americans approached (mostly) with a brotherhood mentality saying that we were all the same, just different colors. And the LGBT community is saying "we're different than you, but you have to accept us anyways," and struggle as they may, it just isn't going to work out like that for the next 20 or so years.
//End Rant
Edit: While I said I'm not originally from the south, I would like to note that for the better part of a decade I have been in NC where this whole situation took place
1
u/coooolbeans May 09 '12
I think you underestimate how Christian NC is. From here, NC is at least 84% Christian. And multiple surveys have shown that the more religious someone is, the more likely they are to disapprove of homosexuals. So even if religion played no role in this vote, the people who voted for or against would be at 84% Christian. Then add in the skew that the people voting for the amendment would likely be more religious, and I think my original estimate of 90-95% is probably accurate.
Also, I'd have to disagree that "the LGBT community has done a really shit job with PR over the years."
For example look at this graph showing public opinion to same-sex marriage over the years. Either the American public is rapidly shifting their opinions despite such shitty PR, or you should give them a little more credit.
→ More replies (1)
7
May 09 '12
"You are on the wrong side of history and your bullshit will die with you."
FUCKING YES, I fistpumped when I read that.
6
3
May 09 '12
Made me think of the book The Forever War.
A thousand year in the future and to limit population, people get "realigned" to be gay and most of the population is gay. Totally normal. Hetero are the weird one.
I wonder if this book is banned in some churches in the Bible Belt...
1
May 09 '12
Pretty sure churches, at least in America, don't ban books, and even if they were to do so, it would be a purely symbolic gesture, since they don't have any power to enforce such a ban.
The AFA has a list of books that have, from a Christian perspective, highy questionable material for children (Heather Has Two Mommies, etc), but that doesn't constitute a ban. Just lets parents know that there are materials they would find objectionable in the children's section, and what they are.
3
u/TheFaceOfBeau May 09 '12
I've said this for the longest time. In 30 years time we'll be looking at this like women's sufferage or Jim Crow laws. The people who were against it will be hated and the people still against it will be shunned. It seems like there is always a turning point where in the mind of the public all fears and hope are realized or not. If we get an amendment in the us constitution saying that gay marriage is a right people have that cannot be denied by the states all the people against it will have to sheepishly have to crawl back to their holes waiting for the catastrophe that never happens. It has happened before in the quest for total human freedom and it will happen again.
Tl:dr Republicans suck and I'm awesome and poetic.
3
u/beingTOOnosey May 09 '12
Sure. Thats not the brightest way of putting it, but they can say whatever. There arr lots of misconceptions surrounding "Christians" and homosexuality.
I'm gonna hop on my pedestal for a second. The Bible is clear about homosexuality being a sin. It is also clear that salvation is not achieved by following a list of rules. How does this pertain to this situation? Simple. It means that Christians are not responsible to the sin of non-Christians. Since being a Christian is NOT simply following some rules, the rules themselves don't apply to non-Christians. Its only after becoming a Christian that the rules become relevant.
So, example. Lets say someone I cross everyday is gay. Yes, I believe thats a sin. But that sin is not his biggest sickness. The priority, as I am explicitly commanded, is to evangelize to him/her so that they know the good news that I know. The same could be said of your stereotypical good guy. Ya know, 30 years of charity. Soup kitchens. The whole deal. If he is not a Christian, he's going to hell just the same.
So my only reaponsibility is to bear witness to the unsaved. This does not mean condemning them, calling out their flaws, or anything of the like. It means showing them the same love that was shown to me. Because my works and deeds have no effect on my salvation, I cannot brag in my deeds or believe they make me any better. Again, salvation is not following some rules. I can tell you all that I am purposed to love everyone I pass. What I believe at the very core is that, left up to me, I would die and go to an eternal damnation. It wasn't by condemning me or explaining my faults that someone else showed me this good news. It was love, and thats what I mean to show as wrll.
2
May 09 '12
You described a very narrow (and relatively modern) view of Christianity held by "born again" Evangelical Christians mostly in the US. For much of Christianity's history salvation was at least partially achieved and possible by doing good works while alive. Catholic doctrine for example (which was practically synonymous with Christian doctrine for the majority of the Church's existence) says that even virtuous non-believers may be able to enter heaven.
The modern Evangelical doctrine is just the opposite: that no matter how good or bad a person you are, as long as you've accepted Christ as your personal Lord and Savior that you will be rewarded with heaven when you die. Nothing else that you do, say, or think matters. And you would think this interpretation would lead to a more hands-off approach on social policy but we see just the opposite. It's the Evangelicals, not the Catholics, that are most interested in seeing the Bible used to create secular law that everyone, even non-Christians, must follow.
4
6
2
2
2
2
2
May 09 '12
For copying purposes: "To everyone who opposes gay marriage and believes your Bible gives you the moral authority to dictate the rights of others, your children will look at you like we look at those who told blacks and women they didn't have the same rights as white men. You are on the wrong side of history and your bullshit will die with you".
2
u/Parmeniscus May 09 '12
I refuse to support such depressing illiteracy. If you can't communicate a coherent thought in a single paragraph, I will not upvote. Read one book or take one class on writing and you'll be surprised with the improvements.
2
u/Kiacha May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Your bullshit will die with you. I want that tattoed on my forearm.
Edit: Bullshit
2
u/Faux_Show May 09 '12
As a Conservative and registered Republican, I too can't wait for the homophobic religious nutbags to die off and that one day I might proud of my political affiliation. I believe that everyone is entitled to live their life as they choose, without the Government being involved in every single aspect of it.
2
u/RonaldFuckingPaul May 09 '12
Sure. It's the typical stupid shit that's usually in this sub. Circle up.
4
2
u/glutenfree123 May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
As someone who studies, loves, and is just all-around interested in history, this is exactly my feelings. History will not judge these people well at all. Especially when you consider all of this is just political bullshit and dog whistles. In 10 to 15 years, these same people are gonna look back and realize that they were completely taken advantage of by politicians for their vote. Theres no way a group of people can be fooled today using tactics like this for that long. Eventually, some of those people are going to start thinking for themselves and they are gonna realize "holy shit I have yet to create a single authentic thought of my own."
2
u/fiddlenutz May 09 '12
Ok. I admit it. I posted a modified version of this on my Facebook account. Will I burn in reddit hell now?
2
u/JohnWayneDildo May 09 '12
It's been said before and I guess it bears repeating: Religious white men fly you to the moon. Nigger fag atheists steal your bike.
1
1
1
u/fsckit May 09 '12
Go and post it in r/Christianity.
17
May 09 '12
Little known fact: /r/christianity isn't the home homophobic, bigoted, die-hard Christians.
6
u/awesomechemist May 09 '12
/r/christianity is actually very nice (for the most part), and I think it would do a lot of /r/atheism subscribers good to just lurk over there for an hour or so...maybe even contribute, if they can be mature about it...
→ More replies (6)1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/bouchard Anti-Theist May 09 '12
There are many in the US that still think women shouldn't have the same rights as men.
1
1
1
u/Cali-Kal May 09 '12
This does belong because their God hates gays and he forbids them from joining in holy matrimony that he invented before sliced bread. This is further proof that God exist and Gays are his top priority. Don't forget he hates sodomites, he said it. The pact is sacred and till death, we can't expect gays to have that sort of commitment.
1
u/trampus1 May 09 '12
Why not? Everyone other whiny ass facebook post that mentions religion does. Maybe this will be the post that gets gay marriage legalized!
1
May 09 '12
"believes your Bible gives you the moral authority to dictate"
There were people who did this in the Bible, and they were called Pharisees.
Mark 7:5-7 The Pharisees and religion scholars asked, "Why do your disciples flout the rules, showing up at meals without washing their hands?" Jesus answered, "Isaiah was right about frauds like you, hit the bull's-eye in fact:
These people make a big show of saying the right thing, but their heart isn't in it.
They act like they are worshiping me, but they don't mean it.
They just use me as a cover for teaching whatever suits their fancy, Ditching God's command and taking up the latest fads."
1
1
u/Rockends May 09 '12
The real bullshit is what you spew. Get religion out of law and out of government, marriage IS a religious institution. You will NEVER have equality until you get religion (marriage) out of politics, out of government, out of tax law.
1
1
1
1
1
May 09 '12
I say this exact thing all the time. You worded it much better; think I'll upgrade to your version.
1
1
1
u/Zebba_Odirnapal May 09 '12
While I suppose there are anti-gay-rights atheists even here on Reddit, this topic doesn't really have a whole lot to do with atheism.
It's OK by me though!
1
u/Losiris May 09 '12
I love The Superficial. I came for the celebrity boob shots and stayed for the poignant social commentary and comic nerd-gasms.
1
1
u/serpentsss May 09 '12
Over the line. Prophesying and including someone else's children into his insane delusion like it's any of his business is over the line. I can not take his speech of hate seriously.
1
1
u/BigFatMooCow May 09 '12
I think opposing gay marriage is irrational but I don't see a basis for saying why somebody's Christian views cant inform how they vote . The idea of a democratic government is that people should be able to express their views secular or not so long as the Constitution isnt offended. Unfortunately at least 4 of the current justices subscribe to the view that on the basis of tradition and history we cant redefine the right of marriage has always been between a man and a women. Unfortunately this means that the denial of rights to the homosexual couples might come down to historical accident rather than a more universal vision of equality.
1
May 09 '12
sadly the bs wont die with them until natural selection becomes a reality. bigotry tends to get passed along to the next generation more often than not
1
u/rizzlybear May 09 '12
i think it's a mistake to call this a religion vs atheism issue.
The issue is that people are prejudiced. that's it. Some people use their religion as an excuse for this but the two are unrelated.
you will find people playing the religion card on the previously mentioned items as well. it's nonsense.
1
1
1
1
u/Carwheel May 09 '12
This is my favorite chain of logic to use when someone starts getting righteous about how same-sex marriage is "wrong." Pulled this out the other day when my dad started going on a rant about how there were pictures of two men getting married in The New Yorker. I argued that:
If a man and a woman getting married can have their picture in a magazine, why can't two men?
Same-sex marriage is legal in NY.
People were saying the same thing about interracial marriages.
He stopped ranting pretty quickly :)
1
1
u/hello__kitty May 09 '12
Who would have thought that Celebrity Gossip Blog "The Superficial" would be so righteous?
1
u/unikcycle May 09 '12
I remember being stepping outside a post office to see a older gentleman asking people to sign a petition to ban gay marriage. As my wife and I walked past he did not ask me to sign the petition. I was 23 at the time. I walked 10 feet turned around and asked him why he didn't ask me to sign his petition. He said he figured I wouldn't sign it and didn't bother. I asked him how it felt to know that no matter how successful he is at banning gay marriage the younger citizens will merely grow up and be better than their previous generation and undo any bullshit you accomplish. You have already lost. Give up.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/JackRawlinson Anti-Theist May 09 '12
I have said this to many of these asses. They usually have the decency to be slightly annoyed/troubled by it.
1
1
1
u/sruffenach May 09 '12
No. It's a stupid Facebook post describing a sentiment that has been repeated over and over and over again on this subreddit and it also has a blatant spelling error. It contributes nothing so no it doesn't belong here.
1
u/JurassicParkerr May 09 '12
I feel like the only one who's never had to deal with homophobic bullshit in life or on Facebook. I guess that's Canada for you.
1
u/meatwad1987 May 09 '12
uh, you do know that God simply asks you to serve him right? God doesn't demand that you do anything. God gave us all have free will to make are own personal choices. some of you atheist are just as stupid as those unrighteous Christians
1
u/MJZMan May 09 '12
I think you need to look up the definition of "commandment".
1
u/meatwad1987 May 09 '12
sigh...those are commandments to become one of His. those are the requirements to being a christian. God gave us all free will to do what we want. He doesn't require us follow His commandments unless we choose to become one of His
1
u/igloo_master May 09 '12
I don't believe in same sex marriage.
...but I don't think I will get one then. To each his own.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/SoleilSocrates May 10 '12
Each generation has its troubles and its fighters of freedom. There was Martin Luther King Jr, and Gandhi, and I plan to fight for those who time has come to be free! For I am the Lorax you see? I speak for the oppressed, and I sing a song of hope for the voiceless. It is actually time for freedom to become real! and it starts with us! <3 -SoleilSocrates
1
u/oxym0r0n May 10 '12
It sucks having to live everyday in the same house as my father and everytime i look at him have to think about how bigoted he is.
1
u/lafkak May 10 '12
I suppose it does, if r/atheism is the home for self-righteous, intolerant, and unloving treatment of others' views :/
1
1
May 10 '12
I would just like to point out that plenty of women and blacks do not support gay marriage.
1
u/Flavorysoup May 10 '12
Just posted this to facebook, waiting for all my fundie friends to start commenting.
1
1
1
u/hrothgar_the_great May 09 '12
Don't miss the real reason behind this. The government has taken the legal representation of 2 persons joining as 1 legal entity (which is a civil union) and slapped the name 'marriage' on it. That was a huge mistake from the start. We are stuck in this paradigm that the churches 'marriage' and the governments 'marriage' are inherently linked. They should NOT be.
The church is protective about the word 'marriage' because it was a church institution from the start. By historical definition, marriage is between man and woman. The government decided they wanted to legally recognize it (ok) so they would call it marriage too (ok) but then they wanted to change it (problem).
If the government wanted to adopt a similar concept as marriage that's fine, but to take the churches idea, and then push it to conform to non-christian morals is ridiculous. You can't ask for separation of church and state and then demand that the Christians adopt the governments standards for marriage.
The government needs to simply pick a new word for it (maybe simply a 'union') and leave the church out of it. Make it a completely separate process from a 'wedding' and then they can make whatever rules they want around it. They could allow gay, strait, and anything else they could ever want. The church would calm down because you wouldn't be taking the word marriage which describes something holy to them and 'defiling' it and homosexuals would get all the rights and privileges of marriage simply under the name 'union'
9
u/Gileain May 09 '12
the "church" did not create marriage it was around a lot longer than that.
1
u/hrothgar_the_great May 09 '12
Ok, forgive me for my slight there. I succeed that point. The point still stands that in modern history marriage is a religious institution.
But, even if you don't believe that, if the government will separate their legal union from the idea of marriage, it would calm a lot of people down and some rational progress could be made. Marriage shouldn't have any legal implications to it. The state should recognize 'unions' and the church can choose to recognize 'marriage' however they see fit.
1
u/IsABot May 09 '12
If that is the case, then only 'civil unions' should be accepted by the government as a legal entity/union. And with it comes all the rights and benefits that it carries. 'Marriage' should be allowed in religious institutions, and they maintain full control over that. So even if you get married in a church, that is not recognized by the government as a legal entity/union. So anyone can get have a union, and the bigot of a church can keep their archaic ways.
2
u/audidmutt May 09 '12
I absolutely agree. I've been saying this for a long time. The state should not and is not involved in the religious and ceremonial aspects of marriage. It is just the co-opting of that term is what is causing the issue.
1
May 09 '12
I've been thinking the same thing. If marriage is a sacrament, a covenant with God, and all that other mumbo jumbo, then let the churches have it. No reason for a secular government to touch it. No more legal marriage for anyone. Civil unions for those that choose, without regard to gender. The churches can marry, or decline to marry, whoever the fuck they want.
-2
u/MufasaJesus May 09 '12
No, it belongs in /r/Antitheism, along with so many of the posts in /r/atheism, if you're going to circlejerk against religion, please do so in the appropriate area.
0
u/Graviest May 09 '12
Totally belongs. So glad Im Canadian today
2
u/Flynn58 May 09 '12
Yeah, we've been legal for 7 years! Under a Harper government, of all the parties.
-1
u/rolfsnuffles May 09 '12
Can we stop posting passive aggressive facebook posts? This is some childish shit. We get it, idiots use facebook...
-1
u/stmichael71 May 09 '12
I don't believe the Bible "gives me a right" to do this; I think a conjugal definition of marriage is normative for purely natural reasons which, however, I also believe are in line with the Bible. It's also a bad analogy to compare this to interracial marriage laws: interracial marriage was about WHOM to marry, not WHAT marriage itself is. The people against interracial marriage were not arguing for different water fountains for whites and blacks because they believed blacks were unable to drink water. Sex, unlike race, IS critically important to marriage because the question of sexual relations is a fundamental part thereof. http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1722155
1
u/Original_Woody May 10 '12
If marriage didn't have financial, tax, and personal implications, you may have an argument. But in this day and age, marriage is more than what you present.
1
u/stmichael71 May 10 '12
But WHY does the government offer those incentives unless to encourage a particular way of life because it has a vested interest in it? In the case of marriage, the US gov't has an interest in promoting stable family life and children.
→ More replies (5)
52
u/marrakoosh May 09 '12
Interesting that the last time NC amended their constitution on marriage, it was in fact to ban interracial marriages: Relevant tweet here