r/Ask_Lawyers • • Feb 14 '25

Shouldn't this be considered a blatant case of treason and also the basis for an immediate impeachment?

11.8k Upvotes

r/Ask_Lawyers • • Apr 25 '25 Helpful

Why was a call from Hunter with Biden in the room illegal, but literally selling access to Trump by way of the Trump altcoin is legal?

6.6k Upvotes

It's all over the news, buy enough Trump coins, get a dinner with Trump. That's literally selling access to a sitting President. And somehow for republicans that is 100% legal. But Biden being in the room during a call was somehow illegal.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Oct 02 '25

How is what is happening in Chicago even slightly legal?

6.2k Upvotes

An apartment building in Chicago was raided. EVERYONE, including children and US citizens were zip tied and forced out. No warrants. ICE agents in masks saying cruel things like “F those kids”. Citizens who were yanked out of their beds found their doors busted, their homes ransacked, and their electronics seized.

How is this not illegal search and seizure? No warrants were shown and people were detained for hours and were not given access to legal counsel.

https://chicago.suntimes.com/immigration/2025/10/01/massive-immigration-raid-on-chicago-apartment-building-leaves-residents-reeling-i-feel-defeated


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Sep 15 '25

Trump's lawyers are arguing that Trump’s power is “unreviewable.” If that's the case, wouldn't that mean his investigations into Biden are all illegal because everything Biden may have done is unreviewable?

5.8k Upvotes

No court is going to let him have it both ways and hold him above the laws and say every other President doesn't enjoy the very same protection.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Jun 17 '25

This weekend ICE arrested Javier Ramirez of California, an American-born citizen, with no criminal record, and refuse to release him. It's been a few days. Does the no Due Process actions this administration is taking extend to Americans? Do we all los Due Process, too?

5.7k Upvotes

Here's the story. My wife is a Latino, naturalized, and people said this whole time if you are an American, or even if you have a Green Card, you don't have to worry because there are laws protecting those people (even though Due Process' text literally applies to everyone). But the Trump administration is proving that's not true, that if you are not White, that is potentially a criminal offense. Why haven't the courts stepped in and stopped this? The Supreme Court should be telling him you cannot have ICE arrest American citizens with no charges, no Due Process, and refuse to release them or even give them access to an attorney.

My father told me the other day if it keeps going this way I should maybe look into moving to Italy. I told him I wanted to move to Finland or Sweden if it gets too crazy but, apparently Italy is better for some reason.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Oct 22 '25

Trump has threatened to send federal troops to the city if Zohran Mamdani, a democratic socialist, wins election in two weeks according to an article I just read. Are we at the point where simply not being a republican qualifies for the Insurrection Act?

5.3k Upvotes

Is the Supreme Court going to block anything at all he does or clear the way for any future Democrat to do everything Trump has been doing with impunity?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Sep 28 '25

Is it legal for Donald Trump to post a fake AI generated FOX News report where he announces a fake technology that isn’t real?

3.3k Upvotes

Because that’s what happened last night.

Donald Trump posted on Truth Social: a fake AI Generated FOX News Report where he announces MedBed Hospitals and that every American will soon have their own MedBed Card.

Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/BoomersBeingFools/s/uJIICmjC4C

Not only that, a website “MedBedCard.com” has been found which is an obvious scam/grift website which matches the card in the video EXACTLY.

I posted this to r/law but it got removed for not being about the “law” which I highly disagree with.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Aug 21 '26

Twice now I wasted two mornings in court but my cop didn't show.

3.3k Upvotes

Got a ticket for not fully stopping at a stop sign, even though I did, not sure how I am going to prove it though...

Went to court, sat in the back, and watched everyone’s cases get called—except mine. Everyone then left but I stopped the lady calling names and told her my name didn't get called. She said, “Your cop is at a seminar. Come back in two weeks.” Why did nobody tell me that?!

Two weeks later I'm in court, there were twice as many people. Before court started, I tried to walk to the front and ask a question, but the judge yelled, “Sir, sit down!” When I tried to explain, he threatened to have me removed, and two armed cops started walking toward me. So I sat down.

Six hours later, my name STILL wasn’t called and everyone left. I tried to catch the lady who was calling names, but she ran into a room and wouldn’t open the door when I knocked.

Took two days off work. Wasted two mornings. Not sure what to do, the court doesn't pick up the phone.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Oct 26 '25

Are Trump's on-going bomb attacks on civilian fishing boats outside U.S. waters murder, as alleged by the NYC Bar Association and other Heads of State?

3.2k Upvotes

r/Ask_Lawyers • • May 02 '25

If the SCOTUS can reverse Roe v Wade…can they not reverse their Presidential Immunity decision?

3.2k Upvotes

r/Ask_Lawyers • • May 23 '25

How was Biden being on the hone with Hunter illegal and selling influence, but a crypto dinner with Trump is totally above-board?

3.0k Upvotes

Literally everything republicans have accused Democrats of that Democrats were innocent of, Republicans are doing. Again. Like Trump hotel last time around. Is there some law that says the mere accusation of impropriety of Democrats is proof of wrongdoing, but overt acts by Republicans are benign?

If anyone takes Trump to court over this stuff and loses will that set precedent for the next Democrat to be legally corrupt in the White House? It's my understanding the reason no one can get him for violating the Emoluments Clause is no one as standing to bring such a suit. Is that true, and was it intentional if it is to make it toothless?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Feb 02 '25

If govt officials swear an oath to the constitution and scotus says the constitution guarantees federal employees due process in firing, how are they firing people without due process? What’s to keep FBI agents from returning to their desks or arresting the security that removed them?

2.8k Upvotes

When following senior directives violates the constitution, which is the obligation and what are the consequences for failing that obligation?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Jul 17 '25

If Democrats win in 2028, and have the House and Senate, can we just add a bunch of Liberal Justices and end the conservative majority we've had for over 50 years?

2.7k Upvotes

Republicans are not playing fair with things like Bove. They've already rigged the Supreme Court. So maybe we start taking things back? Is it just a simple majority we'd need on the Left to increase the number?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Feb 26 '25

Does Trump banning MSM from the White House violate the First Amendment?

2.7k Upvotes

I'm not sure if the AP was first, but now Huff Post is banned, too. Probably others, as well. Doesn't this violate the Free Press? Or is it literally just if Congress does it?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Jul 21 '25

How is this deportation of an 82 year old man with no record who has a Green Card legal?

2.6k Upvotes

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/ice-deported-grandpa-green-card-b2792290.html

I mean he lost his Green Card and was going to get a replacement, but I am not aware of any laws that say if you lose the card you can be deported when you go to get a replacement. Zero laws broken by this guy his whole life and just deported.

Can he come back, or would they have revoked his Green Card and is now barred from the US? Don't they usually have to give a reason if they deport senior citizens here legally who have never broken our laws? Does he have any way to fight this?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Jan 25 '25

Jury Duty Will Bankrupt Me.

2.5k Upvotes

Jury Duty Denied My Financial Hardship.

I got called into jury duty. It will be a three month trial, every day, all day. I explained that I am self employed and run a small business. I cannot miss work or else my employees and self won’t get paid and my legally bound contracts with clients on projects will be affected. The judge said this was not a sufficient financial hardship and said I must go for second round of jury evaluation on Monday. Missing this much work will potentially get me sued over contracts, my employees won’t be able to afford bills or rent, and neither will I. I will potentially lose my business.

What are my options?

(posting on behalf of someone else)


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Jan 04 '25

When a rich person on Law and Order tells the cops, "talk to my lawyer," are they implying they have a criminal defense lawyer already retained and ready to go just in case?

2.4k Upvotes

Does this happen in real life. Do rich people retain criminal defense lawyers just in case?

Is there like a lawyer equivalent to a family doctor that people use for small things throughout the year who could know enough to tell you to shut up while they get you a specialist?

Or is it 100% fiction?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Oct 25 '25

An AP story today says Costa Rica is prepared to take Garcia when he gets deported, but the Trump administration is planning to send him to Liberia instead. How is that legal, and how is it not punitive?

2.3k Upvotes

Here is the story. I mean, the whole time we were told the US demands justice for his many imaginary crimes. But it really seems like they just want to get rid of him, but in the way most cruel to him that they can get away with. Apparently the government agreed to deport him to Costa Rica, but only if e pled guilty to the imaginary charges and as punishment they're sending him to Liberia. I was under the impression deportation was not supposed to be punitive. Doesn't doing this violate the 5th Amendment?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Sep 23 '25

Could Johnson & Johnson successfully sue the government for defamation over their incredible claims that Tylenol causes Autism?

2.3k Upvotes

r/Ask_Lawyers • • Aug 30 '25

Prosecutors in D.C. are being told to deny people bail even for non-violent offenses and trial dates are backlogged out to 2027 or later. Isn't that a violation of the 6th and 8th Amendments?

2.3k Upvotes

Is it legal to not allow a speedy trial and to hold non-violent people with no bail? I mean Trump's fine was reversed because that was apparently an 8th Amendment violation but locking nonviolent people up indefinitely with no bail passes the smell test?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Jan 24 '25

ICE is doing warrantless raids and arresting American citizens. How is that legal?

2.1k Upvotes

https://www.axios.com/2025/01/24/ice-raid-newark-new-jersey-immigration-us-citizens

I THOUGHT they had to show a warrant signed by a judge, and that no American citizens could be detained by ICE. Isn't this a clear violation of the 4th Amendment and possibly also the 14th Amendment? Do the people arrested illegally have any recourse, is there fruit of the poisonous tree in these cases, or however they are caught legal or not they just stay in custody?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Feb 10 '25

What would happen to a Justice Department Lawyer who told a Federal Judge, "No I won't do what you order because the President of the United States told me to?

2.0k Upvotes

A team of Lawyers from the US Justice Department appear in court to defend one of Donald Trump's Executive Orders. The Federal Judge makes a decision that the Order or Actions connected to it is unconstitutional and illegal and orders the Lawyers to do things that apply to the Judges Order.

The Justice Department Lawyers then tell the judge NO, they won't do it because they have been ordered by the President of the United States- Donald J Trump- to ignore the order.

What can the Federal Judge do to see that his or her order is followed at that point? (Disbar the Lawyers, Fine them every day, Jail Them? Or just order the people in government who would carry out the order to appear in the court room and order them to be jailed or fined for their inaction?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Oct 06 '25

Since Trump is firing all the immigration judges and any other judge he feels isn't loyal to him above the Constitution, could the next Democrat one-up him and fire every single Republican Federal judge in America?

2.0k Upvotes

I mean if you're going to do stuff like this, go big, right? We can start with a purge of every republican in government that serves at the pleasure of POTUS, then move on to the judges and get rid of all of them. I'm not even suggesting they cannot do their jobs, but if this is where government is headed then we should probably make sure we do it the right way an maximize our gains.

And if we have the House and Senate in a supermajority add 9 Liberal Justices, but also change how cases are assigned, 9 judges at a time but by lottery. This way you'd have to buy them all off to get the results paid for.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • Aug 10 '25

Tim Cook recently publicly gifted gold to Trump, why isn’t this bribery?

2.0k Upvotes

I assume it’s not illegal, because, well they did it publicly not trying to hide it at all.

I just wonder, what DOES qualify as bribery if gifting a gold bar isn’t?

https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/s/6nBFUQKYWj