r/Arendellefiles • • May 09 '20

Canon (Discussion) Arendelle castle interior from Disney: A Frozen world

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/Arendellefiles • • May 05 '20

Elsa Is Elsa Left-Handed, Right-Handed, or Else?

30 Upvotes

My observations comprise only main canon sources: F1, FF, and F2.

Selected notable instances of her left-handedness:

  • Striking Anna when they were younger,

  • Both times she made Olaf,

  • Throwing her crown away,

  • When attacked in the ice castle, note the precision of the ice usage with her left hand, versus the blunt force aspect of the ice from her right hand,

  • Dress color change from blue to green,

  • Putting a bracelet on Anna's wrist,

  • Casting ice-fireworks (Anna is holding her right hand),

  • Parting the mist (Anna is holding her right hand),

  • Shooting ice magic at the mist,

  • A subtle emphasis on the left step on her 2nd attempt at crossing the Dark Sea,

  • Sending the truth to Anna,

  • Patting Olaf's head.

Selected notable instances of right-hand usage:

  • Original ice dress,

  • Creating Olaf's flurry after the Great Thaw (Anna is holding Elsa's left arm),

  • Cake decoration,

  • Lassoing Nokk in the Dark Sea (granted that Nokk had her left hand in its mouth, nonetheless, still an impressive throw!),

  • Catching Anna's game night invitation.

Extra points for leftness:

  • IRL Idina Menzel is left-handed. Sometimes animators do consider that, but mainly:

  • IRL Kristen Bell is right-handed, and from interviews, it seems that they conceived Elsa to be the complete opposite of Anna, therefore, Elsa would be left-handed. Remember that Frozen was meant to be just Anna's movie.

Therefore I believe that Elsa was supposed to be left-handed, but when you are animating, depending on the scene blocking and the camera angle (generally in Frozen, in wide-shots where directions matter, North/away from Arendelle is to the left), the animators have the luxury to just have the character use the other hand instead. But otherwise, Elsa does favor her left hand.

TL;DR: Elsa is left-handed and quite ambidextrous. And if you're wondering, Anna is clearly right-handed, but, Disney has books out there saying otherwise on both of them. I guess watch what they do, not what they write/publish.

P.S. While "researching" into this, when Elsa is running away from the party, I couldn't tell which foot Elsa uses to test the ice forming over the water. Can anyone tell?


r/Arendellefiles • • Apr 05 '20

Arendelle (Kingdom) Is Kristoff now the King of Arendelle, or is he the Prince Consort?

25 Upvotes

If we look at for example the UK, the title King is reserved for King Regents. Only the male ruler could be "King". However, while female regents are Queens (Regent), so are the wives and Mothers of King/Queen Regents, they are known as either Queen Consort or Queen Mother, respectively. However, a husband or Father of a Queen Regent is simply a Prince.

So based on that, Agnarr was King and Iduna was Queen (Consort). Then Elsa was Queen (Regent). Then Anna became Queen (Regent) and Kristoff would become Prince.

Now what is the rule though in Frozen. Someone mentioned on the main sub that since Kristoff is not of royal blood, in Norwegian law, he cannot even be a Prince, but is rather a Count.

However, in Rapunzel's Tangled Adventure, episode "Queen for a Day", Flynn becomes "Temporary King of Corona"; but this is also played for laughs.

So, bottom line, what is Kristoff's title?


r/Arendellefiles • • Apr 12 '20

Map Frozen map

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/Arendellefiles • • Feb 22 '20

Anna Anna has super strength

22 Upvotes

Boring theory in that it is one of the most common one's out there. But I am a big promoter of it. There is multiple evidence for this:

  • She punched Hans overboard

  • She accidently flinged a stone statue across a room

  • She kicked Olaf's head waaay into the air. (compressed snow is a lot heavier than people realize)

  • She could catch Olaf w/ no difficulty when he fell from above in "Some Things Never Change". Kristoff was struggling when Olaf jumped into his arms

  • She could easily move a track switch like it was a light switch.

  • She slashed a thick rope w/ 2 swipes of her knife

  • She pushed up a pine tree that was covered with a lot of heavy snow; she essentially flicked it back up.

  • She easily sent a wolf flying by hitting it with a flaming sleeping bag and hitting the other with a lute

  • She paddled a canoe with a twig (Olaf's arm)

  • She ripped an ice sword of an ice sculpture

  • In a deleted scene, she saved Kristoff who was drowning at the bottom of the lake (pulling up a drowning person from a seabed is ridiculously difficult, to the point of being essentially impossible)

  • Also, she can outrun a rail handcar. Not strength but looks like special speed is there as well


r/Arendellefiles • • May 03 '20

Canon (Discussion) Why is there debate over Olaf's Frozen Adventure being canon??

20 Upvotes

The only reason I could find is that it was made by different people, which is a really weak reason in my opinion. Using that logic, 95% of the MCU isn't canon because Jon Favreau didn't direct it.

It's the most notable thing to come out of Frozen after the two films. It's far more substantial than Frozen Fever in terms of it's content. I find nothing that directly contradicts anything that happens in the films. It would be stupid if it wasn't canon.

Is there something I'm missing here? I just think it's kinda dumb that a 20+ minute short animated by Disney animation studios, with all the actors reprising their roles, isn't considered hard canon.


r/Arendellefiles • • Jun 08 '20

Elsa Are Elsa's gloves an example of placebo effect?

Thumbnail self.frozen
18 Upvotes

r/Arendellefiles • • May 03 '20

Canon (Discussion) Forest of Shadows canonicity

17 Upvotes

I wanted to isolate the discussion on canonicity, so I could refer later to the single posts. So I will report here some points and discussion we had here: https://www.reddit.com/r/Arendellefiles/comments/g980bh/frozen_canon_version_2 Please add comments if I have forgotten something or if you want to add to the discussion.

Points in favor of higher canon level

This whole interview with the author is full of points in favor of higher level of canon. https://thedisneyblog.com/2020/01/24/magic-myth-and-science-frozen-ii-forest-of-shadows-interview-with-kamilla-benko/

  • editors at Disney [...] reached out to see if I would be interested in crafting a bridge between the Frozen movies

  • [the author knew] Anna’s ultimate role at the end of Frozen II

  • I was really lucky to have a lot of guidance from the filmmakers, who spent years thinking about the emotional psyche of the sisters.

  • Certain deleted scenes and character traits were shared with me when I first start brainstorming Forest of Shadows, including how much the sisters’ childhood affected their adult perception of the world.

  • I had Frozen, the short films, and the Frozen Broadway cast album on background almost every time I wrote. I was also aware that director Jennifer Lee allowed the actors to inform and influence the characters, and so I listened to many, many interviews, both Frozen-related and non-Frozen-related with Idina Menzel, Josh Gad, Jonathan Groff, and of course, Anna herself, Kristen Bell.

  • Finally, Forest of Shadows was a huge team effort, and my editor and I would sometimes go through multiple rounds with the filmmakers to get a line just right!

There are some references in Frozen 2 to Forest of Shadows, albeit subtle. But Disney surely didn't want to spoil the book or to add information not explained in F2.

  • harvest festival

  • there is an epilogue that is the beginning of the harvest festival

  • description of travel dresses

  • secret library (from deleted scene)

  • Elsa feeds the wolf constellation her nightmares is depicted in one deleted scene of F2. Elsa is dreaming, her powers materializing the dream, and when it turns into nightmare she actually throw it out of the window.

  • ITU the line "I've had my adventure, I don't need something new" sounded strange to me. The events in Frozen 1 couldn't really be called an adventure. While Forest of Shadows could be considered an adventure.

  • Gran Pabbie remark “never a dull moment with you too” (u/Spinju) In Frozen 2 there is no major event or problematic circumstances mentioned of course other than what actually happens in the movie. Meaning there’s absolutely nothing that Grandpabbie could possibly be referring to since the last major incident was three damn years ago. You don’t say something like “never a dull moment” when those moments are spread years apart. BUT you certainly do say that when something had just taken place a week before which coincidentally is exactly how long ago Forrest of Shadows took place in relation to the start of frozen 2

The clues are subtle, but they make sense. We should consider that: (u/Spinju) In Forest of Shadows there are no loose ends. Elsa cancels her grand tour. Pretty much the entire kingdom doesn’t even know what happened and those that do know it’s better to be swept under the rug. And a detail you might have overlooked that in Frozen 2 Grandpabbie Who was definitely aware of what happened said

Points in favor of lower canon level

  • Anna and Elsa would still have been dealing with the trauma after the end of the book, they went through a lot in FoS, and I find it hard to believe they had gone back to normality so soon after. (u/wittyusername64)

  • If FoS was canon, then when Anna was recapping the events of F1 to Elsa to show she was capable of protecting her, I would have expected her to recount FoS as for my money, that's far better proof of her capability to protect her without powers than the events of F1. She would've said something like "also remember that time I saved you and the kingdom from a giant nightmare wolf and a curse that turned everyone into sleeping zombie things". (u/wittyusername64)


r/Arendellefiles • • Mar 27 '20

Timeline Timeline (Revision 5) Agnarr placement in royal timeline fixed + Reign lengths added

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/Arendellefiles • • Apr 27 '20

Canon (Discussion) Frozen Canon (version 2)

16 Upvotes

Ahtohallan - Hard Canon

Things that are directly from the authors, no doubt about canonicity. Also things that are confirmed by other Ahtohallan level canon (but I don't think there is anything, or it is?).

  • Frozen (2013) Jennifer Lee, Chris Buck

  • Frozen Fever (2015) Jennifer Lee, Chris Buck

  • Frozen II (2019) Jennifer Lee, Chris Buck

Frozen - Canon

Things that had some collaboration with the authors (or songwriters), does not contradict Ahtohallan level. There could some interpretation due also to a different medium.

  • Olaf's Frozen Adventure (2017) Stevie Wermers, Kevin Deters

    • due to there being different creators and song writers. Discussion: is there anything in Frozen II that could confirm OFA?

  • At Home series (2020)

  • Junior Novelizations

  • The Art of Frozen (2013) Charles Solomon, with also Chris Buck and Jennifer Lee

  • The Art of Frozen II (2019) Jessica Julius, with also Peter Del Vecho, Chris Buck and Jennifer Lee

  • Forest of Shadows (2019) Kamilla Benko

    • There seems to be a high involvement of authors, some details foreshadow F2. Note that is in Anna's POV so not completely reliable.

Cold - Soft Canon

Things that are probably not canon. No involvement of authors, songwriters, etc. Or things that were scrapped out the movies. Still, some people could consider them as headcanon.

  • Broadway Musical Frozen (2017) Jennifer Lee

    • Discussion: I haven't seen it (only the Jr. version). From what I could infer, the only non-canon thing is that the ice-havester sing the Fixer Upper song. But this could be considered as difference in medium.

  • A Frozen Heart (2015) Elizabeth Rudnick

  • Outtake Songs

  • Deleted scenes (but not alternative versions).

  • Comic books

  • Frozen stories collection, etc.

Warm - Not Canon

Things that are surely not canon.

  • Deleted scenes of scrapped versions, such as the Evil Elsa scenes.

  • Once Upon a Time

    • AU serie

  • Lego Northern Lights (2016) -Discussion: I haven't seen it, so why it's not canon? I've read the novelization and didn't seemed too different from other stories.

  • Conceal, Don't Feel (2019) Jen Calonita

    • Explicitly a "What if?"

-----------

Notes

I've added the descriptions of the various levels. Let me know what you think.


r/Arendellefiles • • May 30 '20

Update 200 Members!!!

14 Upvotes

Holy Snow Queen!

This sub is growing and growing fast! 200 members in 3 months for a niche genre? Thats something!

I've done this in the past couple "Update" posts and you guys seem to enjoy it so here are the current standings of all Frozen related subreddits (That are active)

I keep finding more and add them to my list which is getting longer and longer. I now have 43 on there with 7 currently active.

r/Frozen - 21,982 Members

r/Elsanna - 15,589 Members

r/anna - 657 Members (Not Dead but Stale)

r/Arendellefiles - 200 Members

r/elsa - 184 members

r/jelsa - 105 Members (Not Dead but Stale)

r/everythingJelsa - 4 Members (new)

Now taking data from the last month this here is the growth of these Subs from highest to lowest: (no data for jelsa and everythingjelsa)

r/Frozen - 472 Members

r/Elsanna - 427 Members

r/Arendellefiles - 64 Members

r/elsa - 64 Members

r/anna - 20 Members

The 2 biggest Frozen related subreddits have really picked up in the last month while 3rd place r/Anna is slowing down and might be dead soon.

As you can see we are still in the top 3 fastest growing sub reddits but r/elsa is gaining on us. It has grown the exact same amount as we have so while we still have more members if we slow down they'll overtake us!

Lets keep this sub growing! so that when r/anna Eventually dies WE will be the 3rd largest Frozen subreddit, period!

Not a call for war or anything just a fun competition and I have my heart set on winning! Do you?


r/Arendellefiles • • May 04 '20

Update We're the 2nd fastest Growing Frozen Subreddit!

14 Upvotes

I know I just made a post about this a few days ago but the race is just too exciting and there have been many updates since.

I have once again made sure that I found every single existing sub Reddit directly relating to Frozen And I found MANY more. I now have a list compiled of 33 and I do think I have found all of them. of those 33 there are only 7 that are active While 2 of those 7 are decreasing in posts over a few months (r/HateKristoffBjorgman has been deleted).

The current standings are

This Technically puts us at 6 out of 7 but look at this:

Average growth PER DAY (Last 3 days)

I gathered these numbers myself and they speak for themselves. We are the fastest growing Frozen related SubReddit right below that shameful pit of Neckbeards. And honestly I can't say I haven't worked hard to make that happen but also I think this is because theorizing about a franchise you love and watching the discussions happen is truly the biggest fun second only to actually enjoying the Franchise. That is why I think we are growing so fast Along with my thorough Ad campaigns of which I've initiated 3 in the life of this Sub (last one 3 days ago).

Just to give you a bit of an idea on how advertisement has impacted the sub let me give you the rough numbers (most numbers are estimated)

  1. Late February - (beginning of sub) from 0 - 21 Members within 1 week

  2. Late March - From 49-85 members within 2 days

  3. Early May - From 134-161 members Within 2 days (And counting)

We are still experiencing the growth of my latest campaign and with the exponential growth that has happened with each passing one I suspect we'll pass 200 in no time and (If my math checks out) We'll reach 300+ After a month from now.

Honestly this is just a fun thought experiment but getting slowly but surely to the top does bring some excitement of its own so if you want to help make that projection into reality definitely let people know and advertise as much as you can.

Anyway! Have a good day and I hope those theories are brewing! Keep up the good work!


r/Arendellefiles • • Mar 31 '20

Kingdoms Other Kingdoms Confirmed in Frozen

14 Upvotes

In Frozen II: Forrest of Shadows multiple kingdoms are mentioned. In this post I will cover the names of those kingdoms along with what I have discovered so far:

  • Zaria: Possibly Trade Partners of or trying to establish relations with Arendelle (Anna has received at least one gift form a dignitary from Zaria). Zaria's Flag Features an apple and it is custom to bring an apple when traveling to Zaria

  • Chatho: (tsha-th-o) The language is called Chathoanese, things from Chatho are Chathoan and the people are mostly Black haired. They are known for ballet and speak a different language or VERY different dialect.

  • Weselton: (Weasel-town) Former trade partner of Arendelle. Home of former Duke of Weselton.

  • The Southern Isles: Collection of islands with one big main Island. Home of Prince Hans (Imprisoned)

  • Royaume: No Info yet.

  • Tikaani: Anna knows their National Anthem very well.

  • Eldora: No Info yet.

  • Torres: No Info yet.

  • Corona: Kingdom Featured in Tangled. Home of King Eugene and Queen Rapunzel. Located in Germany. (More info in all Tangled related lore).

I intend on Exploring these more as I continue to carefully restudy Frozen II: Forrest of Shadows with pen in hand. For that I created the "Kingdoms" Flair and will be adding flairs for each Kingdom seperately.


r/Arendellefiles • • Mar 27 '20

Update A message from your Chief Inspector regarding the Coronavirus

14 Upvotes

r/Arendellefiles • • Jun 12 '20

Anna It seems to me, or is it a copy of the symbol of the four spirits on the floor? Only instead of the elements there are Arendell flowers. And Anna lies exactly in the center. Very suspicious.

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/Arendellefiles • • Jun 11 '20

Timeline Argumented case on Anna's birthday

Thumbnail self.frozen
12 Upvotes

r/Arendellefiles • • Apr 15 '20

Arendelle (Kingdom) For the 1840s, the reliance on swords and shields is strange. Could Arendelle survive a war with another kingdom?

12 Upvotes

If the sisters' grandfather was a bad guy, why don't we see muskets or rifles in Arendelle?


r/Arendellefiles • • Apr 15 '20

Map Pretty accurate map (digitally removed all locations and markings for clean look) {HIGHER QUALITY VERSION TO FOLLOW SOON}

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/Arendellefiles • • Mar 21 '20

Timeline Agnarr was born in 1798

12 Upvotes

According to this post, Agnarr was 14 when he became king of Arendelle. u/Spinju establishes 1840 as the year of Agnarr and Iduna’s deaths, so the dam was built in 1812 and Agnarr was born in 1798.


r/Arendellefiles • • Oct 12 '20

Arendelle (Kingdom) How old is the Arendelle Kingdom?

11 Upvotes

This has been on my mind for years. All the Frozen books say Arendelle is way older than it says it is in the movie. So which one is it? Did King Runeard build Arendelle Castle and the city around it or did someone way older?


r/Arendellefiles • • Apr 25 '20

Canon (Discussion) At Home With Olaf (Canon?)

11 Upvotes

Hello Detectives! It has come to my attention that new fully animated mini shorts are being released on a regular basis.

The At Home With Olaf series started along with the trend of content being released for the Millions stuck at home due to the virus.

I features mostly sets where events shown in Frozen 2 took place. They are fully animated by members of the original team of animators and even voiced by Josh Gad.

Here is my question: Is it canon?

Arguments for Yes and No:

Yes: Because it was released by the same studio and creators without serious deviation from the established canon.

No: Because it is a one time series only intended as a bonus for Disney/Frozen fans and nothing more.

I personally think they should be considered canon. Not only because of the argument in favor stated above but also because some of them ("Brush", "Sunrise", "Candy) display areas we were not able to have a good look at before and if established as canon could be used to support theories and overall provide some much needed additions into the canon.

Edit: I'd like to add that the "At Home With Olaf" Series has now come to an end and it is revealed that It was not only animated and voiced by original staff but also directed by Jennifer Lee.


r/Arendellefiles • • Apr 11 '20

Update 100 Members!!!

11 Upvotes

This Sub Is Only 50 Days Old!

With this very niche subject matter we still managed to gather a large group of like-minded people with determination for the goal of uncovering all the secrets the Frozen Universe has to offer!

This Detectives office is lucky to have you all and while not all have achieved their status as "Detective" yet I still look forward to the lively discussions we'll have. And I definitely look forward to bestowing the "Detective" title upon each and every one of you. Though it has to be earned I believe all of you deserve it. Prove me right!

Back to work and Godspeed, Detectives!


r/Arendellefiles • • Oct 26 '20

Timeline Once Upon a Snowman Timeline Placement and Canon.

10 Upvotes

I think it goes without saying that Once upon a snowman is Ahtohallan Level of canon due to it being literally parallel to the Events of F1.

As for the Timeline. Well I just said it didn't I? Right along side F1. Specifically from when he gets created in "Let it go" to the scene where Anna and Kristof first meet him.


r/Arendellefiles • • Oct 26 '20

Elsa How Olaf Got his memories! And how Elsa creates life!

10 Upvotes

I just watched the new Frozen Short "Once upon a Snowman" And I think it very well shows how Olaf was able to have so much basic knowledge while only being alive for a short time.

As we learned in Frozen 2 water (And thus Ice and snow) has memory. At the end of the short Olaf REMEMBERS Anna and Elsa and their exchange in the opening scene of F1 triggered by feeling something similar to a warm hug which establishes the connection in his mind. I think that along with Elsa's Ice manipulation as well as Ability to create life she must have given Olaf the memories and knowledge that he needed without knowing it. How? Well think about this.

Olaf was a big part of their childhood. Not only a memory from the day she almost killed her sister but as we saw in OFA it was a long running character for Anna and Elsa. So I believe during "Let it Go" when she was playing around with her powers she had the Mental Image and Idea of Olaf and what he represented in her mind while making him. So just like that she infused the snow with those Ideas and memories unintentionally but the result is clear.

And this brings me to a much bigger discovery. As I stated above the way Olaf became how he was was due to Elsa and what she thought while making him SO.....I conclude that:

Elsa can create life based on a mental image of the life form and how it should behave. This Image is infused into the snow while the body is constructed creating the end result of a living thing with inherent Knowledge, Intelligence and Purpose.

I see this in Marshmallow as well. She thought of something to protect her and so a big, Dumb but strong life form was created. It all corresponds with her mental Image at that moment.


r/Arendellefiles • • Jul 28 '20

Arendelle (Kingdom) What happen to villages around Arendelle at the end of Fronzen 2?

10 Upvotes

I would start saying that I have not read any Frozen books... but I am quite sure there should have mentioned about small villages in Kingdom of Arendelle... logically thinking, human habitat should close to water source, and if they are placed next to the Fjord (or should I call it "strait"?), they will most likely being washed away by the big wave at the end of F2 .

so, anyone know any map that contains the villages? just out of curiosity.