r/apple • • May 21 '12

A friend of mine got annoyed with the docking station options available for the MBP. So he made his own. He's now trying to start his own company doing it and I told him I would post the pictures of it on Reddit and see if there was any interest.

http://imgur.com/lfJkQ
2.4k Upvotes

380 comments sorted by

83

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Just to make sure, he is aware of the other docking solutions out there, right?

http://hengedocks.com/

http://www.bookendzdocks.com/

15

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Came here to post this. Still, a competitor might force these guys to innovate some more. Just make sure your friend knows what he's getting into.

26

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I think OP's friend needs to innovate more if you want any chance of the others innovating.

Docking really requires a first party solution though. When you look at how Thinkpads and other business laptops dock it is quick and easy because of the port on the bottom of the laptop. Apple has Thuderbolt now and it seems like that is their docking solution, but as of now it requires that you have a new Mac and a new Apple monitor. You aren't getting into a docking solution for less than $2k, you are still manually plugging in 2 wires (even if one is a magnet), and you're locked into a 27" screen.

If OP really wants to make something (I'm not sure what licensing it like), but I would love to see a Thunderbolt dock. 1 small box on the desk with Firewire400/800, USB2/3, Thuderbolt, Displayport, DVI, maybe VGA and HDMI, audio in/out (maybe even a nice speaker), ethernet, and power. I could hook up whatever monitor I wanted and connect it to my Mac laptop just like the Thunderbolt display with just a Magsafe and single Thunderbolt cable.

It's more work than just gluing a bunch of extension cables together, but it would be a much better product and he'd sell a fuck ton of them at the right price. Hell, he could even throw a drive enclosure in there so you can just slide in a HDD or SSD for some extra storage when docked.

4

u/TriathlEnt May 22 '12

i want to investigate this project. Could all of this really be pulled out of one Thunderbolt port?

9

u/pudquick May 22 '12

Yes, except for power.

TB is literally an external PCIe 20 Gbps connector with some extras. Anything you could imagine in a standard PC connected via PCI / PCIe is a candidate for the types of expansion ports / devices / features you could connect there (audio, USB, eSATA, etc.) - with the exception of higher end data devices (like GPUs that use 16x PCIe).

However, it provides 10 watts of power (to attached devices) - it is not a port that the machine could be charged through.

1

u/kcbnac May 22 '12

Most GPUs can sit on 4x or 8x just fine - go take a look at most SLI and Crossfire-enabled boards; the 2nd slot (often) doesn't run at full x16...it would really only be if you're using it for massive computations passing info back and forth that you'd want the full bandwidth.

2

u/pudquick May 22 '12

Very true! But even so, Thunderbolt would still be hard pressed to host one :)

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Power would be a separate break out. I was thinking you'd have 2 cables coming out of the box to your laptop.

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

[deleted]

1

u/rbart65 May 22 '12

How does that work with bootcamp? I can't keep my macbook shut when running bootcamp or else my macbook will go to sleep.

3

u/henlin May 22 '12

Obvious question, but you have checked the lid shut setting in Power Options, yeah?

1

u/rbart65 May 22 '12

See I was thinking of doing this, but then a small issue occurred. When I shut the lid while running OSx without being plugged into an external display, it goes to sleep. When I shut the lid while running OSx with it being plugged into an external display, the screen just transfers to the external display.

With bootcamp, I want it to act the same way. I can't accomplish this if I just change the lid shut setting, or at least I don't think I can. Do you understand what I mean?

1

u/0157h7 May 22 '12

Hmm. I've never tried it with bootcamp.

1

u/rbart65 May 22 '12

If you do try it, can you report back?

1

u/0157h7 May 22 '12

Yes but tbh I doubt I will. I do not currently have a bootcamp partition because I switched to virtualization and to set that up and test it is a lot of effort for some random stranger on the Internet. Sorry but I don't want you to get your hopes up. I will still consider it though.

1

u/rbart65 May 22 '12

No problem!

4

u/Cueball61 May 21 '12

Henge is very different, the MacBook isn't usable from what I can see.

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

The Henge is made to dock with an external monitor/keyboard/mouse. The Bookendz are made to use like a traditional dock... more like OP wants.

1

u/Cueball61 May 21 '12

Hmm, may have to take a look at the Bookendz, the Henge ones looks pretty cheap and plastic.

1

u/proudcanadianeh May 22 '12

I have one. It is very "meh", it is starting to scuff up my macbook, and there are problems of possibly damaging your macbooks ports if you are not careful with the dock.

1

u/Cueball61 May 22 '12

Looking at both of them, the Henge looks cheap and the Bookendz looks like a lot more than I need. I just want what OP posted really, not a whole station.

3

u/B1GJu1cy May 22 '12

Thanks for the heads up but these are our only 2 competitors and like you have seen so far ours beats in cost, look, and versatility all day long. We hope!!!

2

u/jessek May 22 '12

both of those are hideous, i like the one posted here much better.

1

u/dsn0wman May 21 '12

I use the hengedock, and it's nice, but I think his design is a little better for not bending/breaking USB ports accidentally.

The real tricky part will be guaranteeing the power adapter gets seated properly every time, as is the case with hengedock.

The one thing all the solutions are missing is a way to power cycle the thing while it's docked and the OS freezes up.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

The one thing all the solutions are missing is a way to power cycle the thing while it's docked and the OS freezes up.

BookEndz should have no problem with that. You can have the laptop open and use it as normal... the power button is there.

I guess the bigger question is how often does your computer lock up where you need to power cycle it by holding the power button down?

I have 3 Macs at home and while I have done it, it's very rare. It was also rare on my Windows computers in the past several years. I work in a hosting center with well over 7,000 systems (probably well over 10,000 now, I stopped looking at the numbers a few years ago) and while I have pressed a whole lot of power buttons there, I still wouldn't say it's the norm.

I would look into what's causing the problem. That should happen often enough for it to be a consideration.

I guess that goes with what I saw saying in a different comment about needing a first-party solution though. Both the Thinkpad and HP docks I had at work had power buttons on so you could control power without actually using the buttons on the laptop. I only really used it to turn the thing on without actually opening the laptop up.

2

u/dsn0wman May 21 '12

The need to power cycle is not rare on my 8,2 Macbook Pro running OS X Lion.

I guess I didn't really look at the BookEndz which you could easily power cycle. The problem with the BookEndz is that you'll have to dock it, then also attach the power cable.

The only first party solution is to buy a $1000 monitor (3x the price of others) which is possibly worth the money, but hard to swallow after spending $2k - $3k for a laptop.

3

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I'd try repairing permissions and maybe a re-install if you're still having issues. It shouldn't be doing that.

I wish Apple made something that wasn't a monitor. I'm hoping a 3rd party makes something soon that is just a Thunderbolt hub. Most non-pros don't need the quality Apple provides in a display.

I have an old 23" ACD that I got when a company was going out of business in town. I'll say, it is the best monitor I've ever owned, but I don't know if I could justify the Thuderbolt display @ retail.

1

u/neutronicus May 22 '12

I have to power cycle my MBP like once every day or two.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Something is wrong. You should look into why that is. I generally only power cycle the thing when there is an update that requires it. It's regularly up for a month at a time.

1

u/EthicalReasoning May 22 '12

yup, already exists.

has to be better, cheaper, or both

→ More replies (5)

245

u/Deejster May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

I admire any inventor, however I have two criticisms:

  1. Its design is restricted to THAT MacBook. If the design changes even slightly in the next generation, it's scrap.

  2. The problem has already partly been solved with a better invention - Thunderbolt. The whole purpose of Thunderbolt is that you just plug in two leads, Thunderbolt and power. Thunderbolt has enough bandwidth to carry video, USB, audio, SD card data, etc.

A better solution would be the same thing but with a single thunderbolt plug instead of the multitude of connectors, which is effectively what they built into the Thunderbolt display. This would also make it work with future models of MacBook.

EDIT: It looks like Belkin have already made what I'm suggesting. Personally, I think this is a much better solution I'm afraid, albeit quite expensive.

40

u/robotevil May 21 '12 edited May 22 '12

Well, I'm waiting to hear back from him, but I think the idea is he wants to mass produce these for all MBP, not just his. The thing you see here is just the prototype, which of course fits his MBP.

Anyway, I emailed him and I'm waiting to hear back from him and I'm trying to get him to register on Reddit directly, as I have to go back to work here soon. So hopefully he can give you a better answer than I can.

Edit: Also since the 1st comment I made is now buried so many comments in: Yes he has a kickstarter page here , He is also on here now answering questions directly now: http://www.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/ty15x/a_friend_of_mine_got_annoyed_with_the_docking/c4qrvc4

34

u/Louis_Farizee May 21 '12

Current MacBook Pro models will be floating around for years and years, because people are able to hold on to them due to the build quality (and, let's be honest, a new MacBook is quite a hefty investment).

I recall a third party accessory manufacturer that tried to introduce a cheap display port to HDMI adapter, only to discover it didn't work on older models because older models didn't output audio on the display port. They didn't really mind because how many older MacBooks are out there? A lot, as they discovered.

5

u/Pinewold May 22 '12

Most doc purchases are at time or computer purchase. Next MBP is coming out in three weeks.

Would have loved this 2 years ago.

if price was Under $50, it could sell anytime.

14

u/ramp_tram May 21 '12

I've got a late '06 MBP (the first model with c2d) and I'm pretty sure I could still get a couple hundred bucks for it. Apple hardware lasts forever and retains crazy value.

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

[deleted]

5

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Still a nice amount for a 6 year old computer.

3

u/Leroy_J May 22 '12

Definitely. Sold my 07' 13" MacBook for $460 on Amazon last month. Damn great resale value. I think I paid 12,13, or 14-something for it in Jan 07'.

I love Apple resale values. I buy apple products, and resell them all the time to buy new models. Practically nothing out of pocket.

2

u/Leroy_J May 22 '12

Also, screw Gazelle, and other companies like that. They rip you off. You get the best money back from selling stuff on Amazon.

→ More replies (10)

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

But is it wise to start a company with a product that only focus's on the needs of legacy mac users? (as thunderbolt will make this device obsolete)

1

u/Louis_Farizee May 22 '12

There's lots of aftermarket auto parts makers out there. Treating computers as essentially disposable is Windows thinking.

I don't think it's wise, necessarily, but I don't think it's undoable, either.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Deejster May 21 '12

I guess I would be reluctant to buy one in the first place if I knew it was specific to my Mac model. Whereas if it's just the same thing but with a Thunderbolt plug instead of the myriad of connectors in just the right place it would be compatible with any MBP with a Thunderbolt port.

1

u/Talman May 21 '12

How long do you plan on keeping your older MBP?

1

u/Deejster May 22 '12

2 years?

1

u/drgradus May 22 '12

I'm more of a five year guy. I'm still on my late '08 MBU and my desktop is a '06 mini, with a new processor waiting for summer to get installed.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Oh, that's nice!

→ More replies (2)

8

u/hyperkinetic May 22 '12

While 1 and 2 are both valid criticisms, this design has the advantage (for now) of being much cheaper. High speed busses like PCIe (which Thunderbolt is based on) are more expensive to bring to market.

Thunderbolt isn't carrying any of the other signals available exposed on the edge of the Mac. This means to provide the same functionality, a Thunderbolt dock system would have to re-implement USB, ethernet, audio, and firewire. These costs are reflected in the price of the Belkin unit.

The design above could easily be manufactured to retail for under $100.

4

u/palijer May 22 '12

They said the same thing about USB. "It's the 'Universal Serial Bus', we won't have to have a million types of connectors anymore.

12

u/thatmorrowguy May 22 '12

To be fair, USB did effectively replace the PS/2, Parallel, and Serial ports on most PCs. Most computers only need USB, Ethernet, and 3.5 mm jacks. Netbooks and Ultrabooks even drop the Ethernet ports.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

It also replaced the "game pad" port on sound cards, if anyone remembers that thing.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Are you kidding? That's exactly what USB has done over the past 10 years, and it's worked wonderfully. USB is the standard when it comes to connecting a device to a computer.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12 edited May 22 '12

Looking at my desktop PC:

  • Standard A/C power cable. Nobody expects that to be replaced.

  • Optical audio connector. USB is capable of provide the same functionality.

  • Ethernet cable. You can use USB for wired networking, if your router supports it.

  • Video cable. Your point is valid here.

  • 3.5 mm audio cables. Digital ports cannot replace these, since they need to be compatible with all sorts of audio systems and carry an analog signal. USB is available for external DACs, such as those used with high-end headphones or those built into USB headsets.

Everything else is USB.

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

I like this solution - if only it could also adapt to this idea...

1

u/Deejster May 22 '12

Personally I'm not so keen on this because you can't use your MacBook's screen.

2

u/B1GJu1cy May 22 '12

Deejster your absolutely correct in that the thunderbolt has changed the game quite a bit, however after much consideration we have decided to continue down this path with the pre-thunderbolt design and when successful will move on to offer one of the first W1PPS that is thunderbolt capable. So please stay tuned. If you want to learn more check us out, http://kck.st/K6VJPF.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

His complaint isn't that your dock doesn't support Thunderbolt - it's that Thunderbolt can completely replace your dock. One thunderbolt port is capable of replicating everything on your dock, with the advantage that when you upgrade, it will still be compatible.

If I buy your W1PPS, then it's good for as long as I use the one laptop you've designed for. As soon as I upgrade, I have to buy a new W1PPS.

1

u/Deejster May 22 '12

Best wishes to you. As I said, I admire any inventor.

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Docks and thunderbolt do not solve the problem, they just move your cablecrap away a couple of feet. Wireless connections can only do the trick.

→ More replies (4)

0

u/[deleted] Jul 11 '12

[deleted]

2

u/Deejster Jul 12 '12

Intel own Thunderbolt, not Apple; Thunderbolt was developed with input from Apple which gave Apple an exclusivity period to the technology. Intel license Thunderbolt just as they license USB3.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '12

I kinda like the inventor's better. I've owned a couple of Belkin devices and didn't like them much. I don't trust them anymore I guess.

Edit: I guess what I'm saying is the Belkin device might look better but not actually be as good as a direct pass-through of each port, which is what the inventor appears to be doing.

→ More replies (19)

41

u/fnordo May 21 '12

Good idea but wont having the dock plugged in trick the MB into thinking headphones are plugged in bypassing the internal speakers?

9

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I THINK you may be able to go into settings and change sound output to the internal speakers manually. I know that I have to do this to switch to the usb DAC/amp that I use for my headphones, not sure if it would work for switching from headphone jack to internal speakers though.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

[deleted]

14

u/LactoseGalaxy May 21 '12

Ran a google search for you, and this might interest you:

SoundSource app or PTHVolume app for software solutions. Also read this:

Also in Snow Leopard if you hold option and click the sound icon in the upper Right of the Mac it will bring down a menu similar to what the above mentioned 3rd party plugins do.

Hope this helps...

8

u/intensenerd May 21 '12

6 year die hard Apple user here. I learn something new all the time. Thanks for the tip on the option key.

7

u/LactoseGalaxy May 21 '12

Sure thing, or just press option+soundkey and it will open up your sound prefs. I didn't have a sound icon to click on...

5

u/Arve May 21 '12

Another hint for the volume keys is that you can press shift+volume key to avoid the bleep sound when changing volume.

7

u/LactoseGalaxy May 21 '12

Or just plain disable it in the sound prefs. I can't stand the bleeping sound.

2

u/intensenerd May 22 '12

Every time I get a new Mac that's the first thing I change.

2

u/deadlyspoons May 22 '12

Thanks for the tip!

I like the blat-blat-blat sound when I'm ramping the volume UP, but if it is late at night and the house is silent and I need to push the volume down, I always wince as the speakers go BLAT BLAT BLAT BLAT blat blat blat...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

3

u/turkeybiscuits May 21 '12

Thanks for this, I have the same problem as the other guy. Commenting on my phone so I can remember to download this when I get home.

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Thanks for searching! Unfortunately both of the things you linked me to didnt work. The internal speakers simply weren't an option (even though they make the chime during startup)

It's gotten to the point that even headphones / external speakers don't work anymore. Thankfully the new MBP is right around the corner!

1

u/FredFnord May 22 '12

Actually there are some procedures you can do that can fix this. Can't remember offhand exactly what they are but a quick googling should find them.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

It may be the whole "put a toothpick into the headphone jack and wiggle it until the stuck switch gets free" thing. I tried that but to no avail. I wish there was a way to disable it with software like in windows

3

u/B1GJu1cy May 22 '12

fnordo, this is one of the design issues that we are currently working on solving. As it stands now you can not change that however our W1PPS 1st model we are thinking that majority of people that use it are either using headphones because of the office atmosphere or have external speakers that will always plug into the hub end of the unit. Thanks for your feedback this is really helpful stuff.

1

u/lorrenzobuey May 22 '12

On this theme. I am someone who uses headphones and my built in mic. SO plugging something into the mic socket will override my internal microphone.

Don't know enough about these things, but maybe make it so that the plugs can be removed from the docking station so that you can still dock but not have to plug into the computer.

→ More replies (3)

136

u/Kramsu May 21 '12

There needs to be an option to take the second audio jack out so that it can work with the 13" (which happens to be apple's best selling model, BTW).

Otherwise, this is a fantastic idea.

118

u/themysteriousfuture May 21 '12

Actually no, this is a horrible idea NOW.

It would have been great two years ago, but now a ThunderBolt breakout adapter makes much more sense. Device agnostic.

0

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

[deleted]

21

u/mantra May 21 '12

There's a window still open if he works fast. I agree ThunderBolt will eventually obviate it but that isn't happening yet and there's still enough pre-ThunderBolt computers out there to make some money. Not an empire but some good business.

10

u/robotevil May 21 '12

I just got off the phone with him (giving him a tutorial how Reddit works) and he explained pretty much what you just said. That there's way more MBPs with this design than the ThunderBolt, and they might consider it in the future, but right now it doesn't make sense.

Anyway, I'm going to let him answer, as I am no means an expert on this and I'm going to go back to looking at pictures of kittens. I'll be in /r/LOLCATS if anyone needs me.

32

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Honestly, this is such a classic mistake that startups make, he's planning a company around this older technology that's being faded out.

You can't just ignore it, because it will be a very expensive mistake.

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

[deleted]

→ More replies (6)

1

u/couchmonster May 22 '12

Not if it's kickstarter'ed ;)

2

u/ElvishJerricco May 22 '12

Here's my advice for him: Thunderbolt is either gonna take off like USB or be used for very specific things like firewire. But neither of those are gonna happen for a while. If i were him, i'd keep it in the back of my mind and if thunderbolt does start to get popular, i'd start building thunderbolt stuff

1

u/treebox May 22 '12

I agree, also Thunderbolt is pretty much in it's infancy as a connection standard, there is a severely limited amount of peripherals that support the connection currently when compared to USB or even FireWire.

4

u/vinod1978 May 22 '12

There are a ton of people that have old MacBooks.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Sarah_Connor May 22 '12

Except for the multitude of machines that are available NOW without thunderbolt.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

And if this were available today, for more than one single model of Macbook Pros, that might be relevant.

This won't be available till September based on the kickstarter page, and even then it will be limited to the 15" MBP with that exact port configuration. This is almost assuredly changing in a month, so it won't even be usable by the 15" Macbook Pro you can buy from Apple. It will be a $100 accessory for something not sold at retail anymore.

There are already popular docks for Apple products. The people who are willing to buy a MBP dock and have this single model that's supported have already bought a dock.

You don't design an accessory for a product that's not sold anymore and you don't design an accessory that competes with other products without doing anything special.

1

u/alittler May 22 '12

Is it device agnostic enough for us to not have thunderbolt ports?

→ More replies (2)

20

u/B1GJu1cy May 22 '12

Well this is OJ the creator, and you pose a constant fight that I have had in the development of this product. However our goal is to come out with the 15" first and very shortly after launch the 13" and 17" model.

4

u/robotevil May 22 '12

^ There he is, welcome!

2

u/bonestamp May 22 '12

I really love the design. I'm hoping you'd have an option for vertical mounting too (like the hengedocks).

Can you take another look at the two USB ports though? As far as I know, the port closer to the back of the computer has more internal devices attached to the same bus. Making that the direct port is not ideal for external devices that really push the bandwidth of usb. It would be ideal if you swapped it, so the other port was the direct one.

For example. I have an Access Virus TI2 (16 part midi over usb dual DSP processor) and it actually warns me when I plug into that port that I should use another port... I get the same warning on the other port, but it measures the latency as lower, so the port closer to the front is the preferred direct port.

1

u/B1GJu1cy May 22 '12

That is really good to know I will make sure that we are looking into that! Thank you so much. So your saying that the plug closest to the power cord is the best one to carry down to the HUB because of # of internal devices that Mac has given them? This is great info this is why I needed to do this.

1

u/bonestamp May 22 '12

That is really good to know I will make sure that we are looking into that! Thank you so much.

No problem, I want to buy one so I want to make sure it's as good as possible. :)

So your saying that the plug closest to the power cord is the best one to carry down to the HUB because of # of internal devices that Mac has given them?

Yes. From what I have seen, that port already has a slightly lower bandwidth because of the internal devices, so it makes sense to use that one for the dock's hub and leave the other higher bandwidth port as the direct port.

1

u/okboy May 22 '12

I'd encourage you to get a product like this out there as soon as possible. Once you do, you've created an asset for your start-up, with an invention and income and a brand. After that, you can seek financing from investors to create the later models, or better yet, a Thunderbolt-only option.

Others have pointed out a Thunderbolt option, but none of them have USB 3.0, just 2.0. That could be a great differentiating factor to add.

Also, be careful how you implement the power adapter, as Apple has come down on people who recreate the mag-safe connector.

1

u/B1GJu1cy May 22 '12

We are trying to get it out there! check this out http://kck.st/K6VJPF. Also we are not working at all with the power cable ours allows the user to use there current power cord by just plugging in the W1PPS right over it and also gives the ability to press it into the cables oversold for a more simple look.

1

u/couchmonster May 22 '12

"Come down"? Pretty sure you mean "threatened to sue because they didn't license the patent rights/do it legally" (no matter how broken patent law is, it's still law)

You can't "recreate" it, but you can license rights with official blessing for reasonable cost. Unfortunately "reasonable" might only be true once you get past 100k units annually. Patent licensing sucks for startups and small players. (initially, X. Commit to minimum Y and we'll make that X/2. Renegotiate to Y10 minimum with an expectation of Y50? Oh, lets settle with X/5.. Sign here)

→ More replies (2)

7

u/robotevil May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

Thanks, I will let him know. Although, I'm trying to get him to register an account. I thought it was a cool idea, but I'm on an iMac and I have a PC laptop, so I wasn't sure if it was actually a good idea or not.

I figured if there's any place that's going to be brutally honest, that's going to be Reddit :-).

edit: just got an email back, he's going to be online in like 45 minutes (just got off work and needs to run some errands for the wife).

13

u/pmrr May 21 '12

There is already a product like this. It allows you to dock your Macbook (lots of models) when closed by sliding it vertically into the docks. The male ports are just like this, but you can retract unused ones and slide them about for different configs iirc. I can't remember the name unfortunately. Whether they do a sideways product (which actually I prefer) I don't know, but definitely look into them.

11

u/NeededANewName May 21 '12

9

u/ICouldBeTheChosenOne May 21 '12

It is $65, and cannot be used as a laptop at the same time like this one though.

4

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Yeah the henge dock forces one to close the laptop. I like to keep mine open to use as second monitor since Apple uses such gorgeous displays in these units.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

This is really awesome.

Does the headphone jack in the dock support optical audio?

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

[deleted]

4

u/twentyafterfour May 22 '12

Thirded, I too would need an optical jack to plug into my surround receiver.

10

u/robotevil May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12

I thought this concept was cool and I asked him if he posted it on Reddit to get the word out (he has a Kickstarter campaign up). He's actually never heard of Reddit before today (seriously)... so I said I would put something up for him.

If there's any interest in this let me know and I can post the links to his stuff with more info.

edit: Sorry, meant to link to the smaller Imgur gallery version: http://imgur.com/lfJkQ .

edit 2: This appears to be getting some upvotes. I have to go back to work soon, so I'm going to see if I can get him to register an account in case anyone has questions about this.

3

u/Inked_Cellist May 21 '12

I actually saw his kickstarter campaign, although I didn't fund because it wasn't available for 13" MBPs.

4

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

I didn't fund it because he wants to raise $115,000. That's on the high side if you ask me, and I have experience in this area.

2

u/jabb0 May 22 '12

Depending on what he is trying to accomplish with that money. I don't think 115 is a lot but it all comes down to if people buy it or not.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

kickstarter doesn't fund if they don't meet their goal.

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

I understand that but I could see him possibly getting funded if the amount he was asking for wasn't so high.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/waxjar May 21 '12

Unfortunately this won't be possible due to the patented magsafe connector.

7

u/tsdguy May 21 '12

Henge gets around this by having only an opening molded into the dock and you need to insert and lock in your own power adapter.

5

u/blorg May 22 '12

This guy gets around it in the same way- look at the bit labeled 'power plug cavity' at the bottom.

1

u/FantasticMikey May 22 '12

Also, this design only accommodates for the newer design of magsafe connectors. The initial unibody macbook pro was shipped with the old style (not low-profile) magsafe.

1

u/tsdguy May 23 '12

I'm not sure which you're referring to about "this design" If you mean the Henge, then you're incorrect. They supply adapters for all 3 types of Magsafe connector to use in their docs. I'm currently using the oldest Type 1 in mine.

If you mean the OP's docking station, then I'm sorry I misunderstood your reference.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/dafones May 21 '12

The MBP is going to get a significant redesign and will be out within a handful of months. I suppose conceptually it's a functional idea, but this particular version is almost out of date before it's even been released.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/robvas May 22 '12

Nice idea, but there's already the Henge dock. Which also isn't very good because it's not a real docking station - it's just a port extender. Lenovo, Dell, HP all made real docks, and their laptops have a special port in the bottom for them. Easy in/out and you can plug two external monitors into them.

3

u/gizm770o May 22 '12

Awesome, but my question would be about the audio out port. Will it carry the optical digital signal as well?

3

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Newer MBPs have a combined audio jack that takes headsets with built-in mics AND outputs optical. That'll be a little tricky.

3

u/kyzen May 22 '12

Ditch the fugly channel cut out for SD access and just build in a cheap SD reader running off one of the USB hub ports; will look better.

4

u/ActualContent May 21 '12

Hate to be the bearer of bad news but this has been done before:

http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/29222207/landingzone-the-docking-station-for-the-macbook-ai

Slightly more versatile design that supports plugs on both sides of the machine. This project has been funded and is now in production. I understand that this one is only for the Macbook Air but it is fairly likely that if this product is successful that it will have versions for both Apple notebooks.

4

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

it still looks incredibly ugly to me, i'd stick with the wires arranged neatly. besides, don't thunderbolt docks exist?

4

u/drweezyfbaby May 22 '12

good idea, terrible timing. apple has already addressed this issue with the thunderbolt port, which essentially does the same thing without a bug hunk of plastic on the side of your laptop. sure, some people will still want this for an older model, but given the fast rate at which apple updates its laptops and apple fans buy computers, this will be practically obsolete before it is on the shelves. you should be designing with future models in mind. this product is designed for a model at least 2 generations old.

1

u/ripter May 22 '12

Where do you get a device that plugs into the thunderbolt and gives you video, usb, firewire, internet, and audio?

1

u/jimicus May 22 '12

You're right, there aren't many of those on the market - and that's the obvious thing the OP should be doing. Otherwise the whole thing needs to be redesigned for every Apple laptop on the market (they all have slightly different port configurations).

Makes far more sense for the OP to make such a device.

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

That's really good-looking. I like it.

2

u/tsdguy May 21 '12

It's not really a dock but more accurately described as a port replicator. However, I would certainly get some legal advice on that as I can't imagine that Henge doesn't have a ton of patents on Macbook docs/port replicators.

1

u/blorg May 22 '12

Probably want to be more concerned with Bookendz, who make something pretty similar and have already sued Henge.

2

u/forgotmydamnpassword May 21 '12

MIght want to wait until the next MBP refresh before putting too much money into this design.

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I'd use it

2

u/Cueball61 May 21 '12

Thoughts:

I have a 17" MBP, you could make one of these and mass produce it for all three devices by having the connectors slide and lock, then you never have to worry about the different placements on each model. Plus, make the connectors each flip down, some people may not want the headphone slot used, or may not have 4 USB slots like the 17" does.

2

u/AlsoNotForMe May 21 '12

This is what my Thunderbolt display does.

2

u/Zombiefoot May 22 '12

A great product, but very close to a horizontal version of this:

http://hengedocks.com/

I bought a Henge Dock, and did not like it. Was given a full refund, a solid company. I would certainly give something like this a try if he offers a refund to customers who do not find a good fit for them.

2

u/jwhite878 May 22 '12

I'm sorry. I don't quite understand this. Could someone please explain to me how this setup works?

0

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

[deleted]

1

u/ripter May 22 '12

None of those look like they solve the OP problem.

2

u/smithclan May 22 '12

Plugin isn't a verb.

/pedantry

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

I like whenever people are trying to sell their shit on reddit they just post memes everywhere and then people are all like 'omg memes! i like memes lol upvote!'. Seriously cool product though.

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Ok, I'm a little confused. Don't I still need a place to plug in all of my shit? I mean yes the docking station is there, so I plug all my crap in there. There is still a shit load of wires everywhere.

Forgive me for my vulgar words, however I feel it gets the point across. Either I am missing something or that this is useless.

2

u/iSteve May 22 '12

Isn't this what the Thunderbolt Apple Cinema Display is for?

2

u/dar512 May 22 '12

I don't see this going over. Too many issues and the win is not big enough for the cost. I've already got a usb hub. So plugging everything in this morning took less than a minute. I'm not going to pay $112 to save myself less than a minute.

The headphone thing has already been mentioned. And HDMI output? I already shelled out money for the mini-displayport to dvi adapter. Why would I want HDMI output? He should have just put a passthrough to a female mini-displayport.

2

u/porkchop_d_clown May 22 '12

It's a great idea - but it has the same basic problem these things always have: Next month Apple is going to release an updated MBP and all the ports will be in slightly different spots, and your device won't fit.

A better idea is to create a Thunderbolt device that provides all the other ports.

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

I love the idea but as some have mentioned, it is pretty much built for one type of MacBook. Has your friend considered making the connectors separate and linkable like Legos? Then it would not matter which Mac you had since you could make your own. Just my two cents. Very clever though.

6

u/ramp_tram May 21 '12

Kickstarter that shit.

6

u/robotevil May 21 '12

2

u/ramp_tram May 21 '12

Fuck yeah.

Unless he decides to try to include magsafe he's in the clear, too.

(Ninja Edit: Just saw that he has a little hole for your power plug to go, very smart move on his part.)

Do you know if he has any plans to support older Macbook Pros?

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Not sure if that video (on the Kickstarter page) was made before they actually had any prototypes built, but I would like to see an actual one in action. With wires plugged in, in real scenarios, etc.

1

u/swimtwobird May 22 '12

why? i'm coming back up the thread in reverse - but given how obvious thunderbolt is in this context - why are we talking about everyone on this thread considering kickstarter?

what's exactly is going on?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/binford2k May 21 '12

Wow. Am I the only one who doesn't like to plug in a shitpile of things to my laptop? Seems like that's kind of the point of a laptop...

3

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Front facing headphone jack:

SHUT UP AND TAKE MY MONEY (Seriously, why do so many laptops lack this feature?)

5

u/blorg May 22 '12 edited May 22 '12

I certainly prefer it on the side. I've had laptops with it on the front and it's annoying. You can't tilt the laptop up for one thing. Using it on your lap or lying in bed is made difficult. All ports on the sides please.

2

u/KingNick May 21 '12

Alright, I'm gonna be the confused guy and ask this: if this dock plugs into every single outlet of your laptop, why does it only have 1 cord coming from it? I mean...sure, that cord is most likely the one that plugs into the wall to charge, but wouldn't you still have to hook cords up to this dock if you wanted to use any of THR other outlets???

I just don't get it. But then again, I'm more confused than anything.

1

u/jewdass May 21 '12

The cord leads to a breakout box with all the plugs. The idea being, you plug everything into this breakout box, and put it somewhere inconspicuous. Then, you plug this one device into the laptop to connect everything at once.

2

u/KingNick May 21 '12

OH! Ok, that's way better than the mass of cords. Dunno why downvoted...I was sincerely confused, lol. Whatever though, thanks for helping

1

u/dblairjohnson May 21 '12

i have no need for this, but it is brilliant. If i was ever in an office situation, i would buy immediately.

1

u/robotdinosaurs May 21 '12

pretty great solution there, only things I would change would be having the headphone connector support inline mics (like on the iphone earbuds), and putting another USB hub on the side of it, rather than just on the other end so you can still plug in stuff like flash drives.

1

u/natemc May 21 '12

This is exactly what I need for my business computer. However it's just a MacBook and not a Pro.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

I never use any of the ports, but this would be awesome if i needed it.

1

u/facetheduke May 21 '12

I'd support the kickstarter at the high-ish level, but I have a 13" machine and no need for a 15" dock.

1

u/WafflesInTheBasement May 21 '12

Since it's meant to work with the computer sitting on a table, I'd be more inclined to buy if it had a coolng solution on the bottom as well (dunno if heat is still an issue on the newer models, but my '08 mbp gets toasty). But very cool design.

1

u/Cueball61 May 21 '12

They get toasty at the back, but that's why it's a heat sink.

1

u/popeyoni May 21 '12

I would buy one. (if it's not ridiculously expensive)

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Cool concept but I don't really see how this de-clutters that mess in the first picture since you'd have the same cords plugged into the dock.

1

u/Cueball61 May 21 '12

They're out of the way, and you only have one thing to plug in to dock it.

1

u/yaleman May 21 '12

Looks cool bro. Henge docks are similar but don't allow you to use your screen. I'll have one if he can make one for non-pro's too :)

1

u/TEG24601 May 21 '12

The only thing I can suggest is that the output on the "hub" end should be TB/mDP, not HDMI, or just ignore that port, and have a pass-through. Otherwise, it is a good idea. Now for the TB to ExpressCard 54/34 adapter.

1

u/[deleted] May 21 '12

Really good idea, but don't different laptops have different configurations on the side?

I have 3 laptops, all different.

Could the dock be customisable?

1

u/bullcit May 22 '12

I dont see a need for something like that. I rarely have anything plugged into my macbook pro. Usually its a external HD for daily backups and maybe an iphone to sync.

Also apple has a patent on the power plug, so wouldn't you be infringing on on their patent if you were to incorporate a charing option ?

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

I'd fund the fuck out of that if it was on kickstarter for around $50 and worked with my 13" MBP that was the last model before thunderbolt...

→ More replies (1)

1

u/l0lbuttz May 22 '12

Genius. I'd definitely be interested if he ever gets it off the ground.

1

u/quixotik May 22 '12

Thunderbolt hub!

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

I don't see what the advantage is. All those things you will need to plug in at some point, and if you have to plug that in everyday, why wouldnt you just have a desktop?

1

u/RedundantTautology May 22 '12

Portability of his files. He may need to do work on the fly. Granted cloud storage is a better option, some people may not want to have to buy a separate desktop.

1

u/gordyguy May 22 '12

Admire invention.

But ethically I'm opposed. What is the problem with cords? And are not you just moving the problem a few feet away?

Sorry, but junk.

2

u/RedundantTautology May 22 '12

No. The problem was having to find and plug in multiple cables every time. He simplified it into a single dock.

1

u/jimicus May 22 '12

With a real docking station (rather than the bodge jobs us Mac users have to put up with - I'm sorry but they're all bodges), you solve a real problem because you can have a separate keyboard, mouse, screen, various USB devices, wired ethernet and anything else that takes your fancy all plugged in with a single dock.

You don't risk damage to connectors that aren't really designed for constant plugging/unplugging because you keep all the desktop guff plugged in constantly.

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

Kickstarter it.

1

u/robotevil May 22 '12

I did link to originally in the comments, but now it's burried so many comments in, it can be found here: http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1251721352/w1pps-the-cord-integration-solution-for-apple-macb/

1

u/[deleted] May 22 '12

love it. No longer a mac user, but Ill share it out. looks like a solid product, good luck.

1

u/swimtwobird May 22 '12

this is coming up weirdly often. why are we kickstartering it?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/aazav May 22 '12

There might be patent licensing fees you have to pay for using certain connectors.

If that is the case, and you don't want to pay the fees, you'll have to incorporate overseas (Curacao, etc) and ship into the US from some other country. Good luck with that.

1

u/dicb May 22 '12

I would buy one, as long as it was moderately priced. I have this frustration every day.