r/amiwrong • • Feb 01 '22

Am I wrong for cutting off my mother-in-law for not telling us if she has covid?

Before I tell the story I just wanna emphasize that I am by no means a writer and this is my first post. Also, this story involves Covid 19 but I do not care for views or any bashing on anyone's views. The story is about lying and I don't wanna hear anything about my mother-in-law's personal beliefs.

Me (21 F) and my boyfriend (20 M) visit my boyfriend's mother (55 F) twice a week every week. We enjoy watching movies and eating dinner and just spending time laughing and talking. His mother has a very conservative view about the vaccine and the Covid situation overall, she refuses to get vaccinated but wears a mask. This is also very out of character of her as she has very liberal views on almost all other topics. We don't mind her views and opinions as long as there's no safety risk, although we have differing views. She's a beautiful and amazing woman and we love spending time with her, she is truly one of the most amazing women I know and I look up to her a lot. I have a lot of respect for her even though we may disagree.

Some backstory: My mother (52 F) got really sick last year with an autoimmune disease called Goodpasture disease which caused my mother to have total kidney failure. Now she
permanently lives having to do dialysis multiple times a week and struggles to do most things. and of course, with all sick people, it's vital to not be exposed to covid. Also, my mother lives close to an eight-hour car ride away, which makes it very difficult to get time off to visit her and travel to see her.

So here's where the problem comes up, my boyfriend today told me that his mother will not tell us if she tests positive for Covid, which comes to the shock of both of us. Within the last few weeks, she has had a cold and assured us that she takes a rapid test every few days and they've all been negative, so we've continued to visit her and spend time with her. But with the information that she might have been lying to us, I am infuriated. I booked time off next week to visit my mother, her knowing this chose to potentially lie to us. What I'm even madder about is that I might potentially not be able to visit my mother, I refuse to visit her if there's any chance that I could get her sick; it could be life-threatening. So I am thinking about cutting off spending time with her cold turkey, if she does not want to respect our health and safety despite her views, then I don't wanna be around her. The biggest problem is that I know I will be made out to be "taking it too seriously" or reading into something in the wrong way by her. So am I wrong for cutting her off until she respects our safety?

127 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

71

u/jaiderouge Feb 25 '26

For anyone that might be reading this now! Me and this man broke up. Turns out my ex and his mom were sleeping together. And I caught them and she broke into my apartment in the middle of the night. We’ve been broken up for 3ish years now sooooo yeah.

17

u/Effective-Soft153 1d ago

Holy shit! Wow.

8

u/CauliflowerFar7058 1d ago

I really feel you should report her to the police (or should have, I dunno).
She’s likely been grooming him since he was way younger

15

u/dan_jeffers Feb 01 '22

There are some issues going on here that are worth looking at. First, your MIL has apparently been telling you she's getting tested. But BF says something that contradicts that. How did he come to know this and how do you know it's true? You don't know if she's lied to you, just that she "might." Second, I can't imagine that your MIL is your only risk. It might make sense to get tested before you go to see your mother in any case.

People make mistakes, even really bad life-threatening mistakes. The question is whether one mistake means you should cut that person off permanently. Maybe, if that mistake springs from who they are. Not so much if it stands out as unexpected, etc.

But first I would really go back and explore this communication thing. MIL tells you she's taking a rapid test ever few days. Tells you they've been negative. What happened between her and your BF? That's too unexplained.

11

u/jaiderouge Feb 01 '22

So to answer your first question, she had confessed to him today on the phone. what she had said was she was thankful she was not sick anymore, he said he was happy it wasn't covid, and she said she wouldn’t tell us even if it was. She said she didn't wanna tell anyone because she doesn't wanna scare anyone, she also took all of her rapid tests in private. My MIL is very nonconfrontational so if I did bring it up to her and tell her that I wouldn't feel comfortable coming around if she wasn't completely transparent and honest she most likely deny and tell us what we wanted to hear. I do not want to cut her off forever, but I do wanna distance myself until she understands that we take it very seriously. Also, me and my boyfriend are planning to take a rapid test before we go, but rapid tests aren't fully accurate for people who are fully vaccinated, and in our area, we are unable to get the PCR tests unless we had covid like symptoms, therefore we try to take the most precautions before we visit my mother.

4

u/melonlollicholypop Feb 01 '22

Ultimately, it depends on what your goal is. Certainly, not seeing her while she refuses to divulge her Covid status is reasonable, even just for your own protection.

How you go about that is where the options are. You say "cut things off with her cold turkey" and that could be taken as punitive. I tend to think you might get further in the context of preserving your relationship if you were to approach a reaction through conversation instead of deciding in advance and then delivering your verdict.

You could start by telling her that you are really hurt by her actions. That you have suffered deeply watching your mother suffer with her diagnosis and subsequent treatment, and that having those things happen in the midst of a pandemic has also given rise to fear and anxiety that you are trying to control.

From there, you can move on to the concession that you have made to her, in being respectful of her difference of opinion. You have not maligned her, nor made any room for others to malign her. You have acknowledged the independence in her response to the pandemic in the way that best served her own feelings on the matter. It sounds like you thought that everyone had arrived at a place of compromise, wherein they were respecting each other's differences while still honoring each person's need to feel in control of their own decisions and well-being. She chose not to vaccinate, but you also chose not to isolate her for that decision if she could provide evidence that she was not a danger to you.

From there, you could move into trying to build a bridge of empathy. Ask her to see how in a time when everyone is simply cutting themselves off from family when their opinions on how to handle this diverge, you on the contrary worked hard to find a solution that would allow the family to still spend time in each other's lives. Ask if she can't see how her refusal to make a small concession makes your fear and anxiety spike? Ask if she thinks it's fair in a relationship for one person to be the one who makes all the concessions?

My suspicion is that she fears that if she contracts Covid ("when" is the more likely) that you will then do what you are talking about doing now: cut her off. Discuss with her what it will look like if she develops Covid in terms of the impact that will have on your visits, the length of time you will distance yourselves from her, and then the path back to regular visits after her recovery. If that is her motivation in wanting to hide her status, perhaps a developed plan will alleviate her fears and make her more compelled to be compliant with your wishes.

1

u/timotheesfruitloops Feb 02 '22

you’re not in the wrong at all, you are doing it purely for your mothers health. i’m so sorry that she’s adding an extra element of stress to you. she should have some understanding of the situation and be respectful not just for the sake of your mother but for you and your boyfriend too! i would have done the same

0

u/[deleted] Feb 02 '22

You are not wrong. Good luck. You have a nightmare MIL. Good luck.