r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/darrenjyc • Mar 27 '25
Prominent Yale professors flee Trump’s America for new roles at University of Toronto
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/darrenjyc • Mar 27 '25
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/phileconomicus • Oct 01 '25
(via u/chopoclock) This seems very relevant to the decision of whether or not to study an undergraduate degree/major in philosophy.
It also links to research about how philosophy studies are almost the best (after physics) at raising your cognitive skills. PRINZING M, VAZQUEZ M. Studying Philosophy Does Make People Better Thinkers. Journal of the American Philosophical Association. Published online 2025:1-19. doi:10.1017/apa.2025.10007
r/AcademicPhilosophy
•
u/[deleted]
•
Dec 06 '24
Left a two decade career in international business, decided that in my end days I'd be happier I sought intellectual challenge over money. Most people think this is bonkers. Anyone here understand my decision?
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/Zambonisaurus • Apr 16 '26
Years ago I met Jürgen Habermas and he was one of the nicest people I've ever met. I'd heard that he was a jerk, but he was very sweet and kind.
Ron Dworkin was also super friendly when I met him.
R.I.P. to both of them.
(Keep it nice... save trashing jerks for another post.)
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/PhilosophyDelivered • May 07 '26
Throughout my time studying philosophy, I found a recurring theme. When people would ask what I studied and I told them philosophy, they would always ask, “What are you gonna do with that?” While I knew they were coming from a good place, the question became tiresome and repetitive. I couldn’t help but wonder: have we really come to a place in society where we have forgotten the value of thinking deeply?
As modern people, we tend to think we are superior and more advanced than every civilization that came before us. But this is an illusion. We confuse technological advancement with moral, ethical, and contemplative progress. As 21st-century people, we have abandoned the very thing that has held our societies together. Wisdom.
The word philosophy originates from two Greek words. Philo, meaning love, and Sophia, meaning wisdom. Together, the word means “love of wisdom.” As Edmund Burke put it, “Wisdom is the foundation upon which the greatness of nations is built.” A society that prioritizes technological advancement over wisdom loses the very foundation on which it stands. What happens to a house without a foundation? It slowly begins to crumble.
Despite all this technology, we live in arguably the most isolated, depressed, and unwise generation that has ever existed. The same internet that was supposed to bring us together has driven us further apart than anyone could have imagined. Rome was not sacked in a day. It hollowed out from within, slowly, as wisdom gave way to spectacle, virtue gave way to appetite, and reflection gave way to distraction. We are not so different.
Philosophy is not some abstract subject reserved for academics debating the meaning of life. It was, and has always been, the bedrock that holds civilization together. It is the discipline that asks whether anything we believe is actually worth believing. It is what stands between a powerful civilization and a dangerous one.
So when someone asks, “What is the purpose of philosophy?” Tell them: philosophy is what a civilization looks like when it takes itself seriously.
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/Adventurous_Bug9696 • Feb 10 '25
He warned us. Without belief, meaning collapses. Some people replace God with money, ideology, or science. Others fall into nihilism. But here’s the truth: No one chooses. Their intelligence chooses for them."
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/thenousman • Sep 16 '22
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/ploploplo • Apr 21 '24
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/phileconomicus • Jan 25 '18
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/IrishShaman1 • Mar 05 '20
It's not imposter syndrome but there is so much philosophy I haven't had the time to study. I haven't read Leibniz or Spinoza, barely know Locke, know nothing about scholasticism or formal logic or Seneca, etc etc. There are so many gaps. I know my own speciality (ethics) well enough to teach and publish, but am thin outside it.
Who - in your opinion- are the essentials every professional philosopher should know?
r/AcademicPhilosophy
•
u/pieckfingershitposts
•
Feb 15 '25
Recently, I responded to a post here asking whether majoring in philosophy is still worth it. My reply seemed to resonate, but the question stuck with me--not because I doubt philosophy’s value, but because there were things I left unsaid. Things that need saying.
I was a double-major at UC Berkeley, by many measures one of the top philosophy programs in the world. I took courses with faculty who’d been widely published and cited, whose names carried real weight in debates on ethics, logic, philosophy of mind, epistemology, and more. By all accounts, I was learning from the best of the best.
Yet the further I went, the more I felt something was missing. Not in the material itself, but in how it was taught--and how it wasn’t lived. At first, I couldn’t quite put my finger on it. There was just this slow, nagging sense that the academic practice of philosophy didn’t match what I had always imagined it to be.
That slow realization drove me to write this—not just to share what I experienced, but to offer some hard-fought advice to anyone in the field or considering it. Because if I had known back then what I know now, I would have approached both philosophy--and academia--very differently.
What I Expected vs. What I Found
I didn’t expect philosophy professors to hand us answers. I know academia has its constraints; universities are institutions first, intellectual battlegrounds second. But I believed, naïvely, that if any field would carve out space for unflinching inquiry, it would be philosophy. Out of all the disciplines, this would be the one where intellectual courage mattered.
I saw philosophy as more than just a subject; it was supposed to be a way of thinking, a way of engaging with the world that demanded rigorous honesty. Professors wouldn’t just teach theories, they’d embody them, showing us how to carry the weight of what we studied.
Instead, I learned that academic philosophy isn’t about the pursuit of truth; it’s about survival. It’s about learning the right terminology, structuring arguments to satisfy a grading rubric, and churning out papers that engage with the literature but rarely with reality. I soon realized the goal wasn’t necessarily to think deeply, but to perform philosophy in a way that reinforced the institution.
One moment, in particular, made this painfully clear. In an upper-level introductory class, my graduate student instructor repeatedly dismissed my writing, marking me down and insisting I didn’t understand grammar. When I pushed back—pointing out that this was how I’d been taught—she offered no real feedback, just irritation. “Get good,” essentially. Other students got the same cold detachment; I vividly remember one classmate leaving the room, hurt and furious, after getting that same “You don’t know grammar” line. It wasn’t just criticism; it was a warning: get in line, or get left behind. At the time, I couldn’t articulate exactly why this felt so wrong, but I knew, deep in my gut, that it was.
Years later, I heard how David Foster Wallace approached teaching undergrads who’d been failed by the very system that was supposed to prepare them. Instead of blaming the students, he blamed the institutions. He told them to sue their school districts for letting them down. In other words, he actually cared. Because that’s what a real teacher does: sees the gap and helps you cross it, rather than sneering from the other side.
And that was just one example. Again and again, I watched professors and GSIs, often overworked and under pressure themselves, choose rigid structure over nurturing real thought. The hard questions weren’t simply left unanswered; they were sidestepped entirely. And that’s when I realized it wasn’t just that academia failed philosophy. It failed us. It failed me. And it will fail anyone who still thinks this field is about truth.
The Institutional Reflex to Protect Itself
Philosophy, at its core, is about truth. Relentless, uncompromising truth. It thrives on scrutiny, not convenience. But in academia, it’s no longer about truth; it’s about survival. I saw this firsthand. After a semester spent dissecting moral theories, I asked a professor what he actually believed. He looked uncomfortable, shifted in his chair, and answered with the careful neutrality of someone who’d long since learned to dodge:
“I don’t like to preach.”
At the time, I felt embarrassed and ashamed, like my belt snapped and my pants dropped in front of my crush. Later, I realized it wasn’t an answer; it was an evasion. A refusal to commit, not because he lacked knowledge, but because he lacked willingness. Engagement means risk, and risk is something academia avoids at all costs.
What does it say about a discipline built on interrogating ethics when even its leaders won’t take a stance?
This pattern wasn’t unique to philosophy. In my other major, I worked with a leading sleep researcher who studied participants in a windowless basement. I pointed out the obvious: how unnatural the setting was, how much more valuable our data could be if we used the rooms upstairs with windows. I emailed the professor. No response.
Moments like that showed me how thoroughly academia demands conformity over curiosity. Don’t ask too much. Don’t threaten anyone’s position. The system doesn’t reward those who truly seek the truth; it rewards those who uphold the illusion that it’s being sought.
That’s when it hit me: I was playing the wrong game. Academia wasn’t it—it was never going to be it. The wisdom I craved wouldn’t be found in a system built to preserve itself at all costs.
Philosophy didn’t fail. The people who were supposed to uphold it did.
The Consequences of This Cowardice
When philosophy refuses to engage with reality, it doesn’t just lose relevance. It betrays itself. If it’s supposed to be about the pursuit of wisdom, what does it mean when the very people who teach it dodge basic moral questions? These professors spend their careers dissecting ethical frameworks and refining arguments about right and wrong, yet when asked what they actually believe, they radiate discomfort instead of confidence. The same people who train students to interrogate moral claims often refuse to take a stand themselves.
And that raises an even more uncomfortable question: What’s the point of a discipline if those who dedicate their lives to it won’t risk anything for it?
Instead of sharpening how people think and act, academic philosophy becomes a performance. The incentive structure is simple: publish in the right journals, cite the approved thinkers, frame your arguments so they satisfy your peers, and you’ll be rewarded. Just don’t push too far. Don’t make people uncomfortable. Don’t take a real position.
I saw this firsthand. Bright, capable students came in wanting to wrestle with life’s biggest questions, believing—as I once did—that philosophy was about pursuing wisdom. By the time they left, something had changed. Not because the material was too difficult, but because it had become hollow. The big questions were still there, but nobody was truly engaging them.
That hollowness is the real betrayal. A discipline meant to dismantle illusions becomes an illusion of its own. A field that once demanded rigor collapses into self-referential gamesmanship. Instead of shaping people into thinkers, it conditions them to be functionaries in an academic machine built to sustain itself.
So of course professors avoid taking real stances. Of course they treat philosophy as an abstract exercise rather than a way of life. The system is designed that way. It doesn’t need truth-seekers; it needs people who can perform the appearance of seeking truth while keeping the machinery running.
And that’s how philosophy—once meant to cut through illusions—turned into one of the biggest illusions of all. Because if philosophy won’t engage with reality, something else will. When rational people refuse to fight for truth, the irrational will fight for lies, and once that happens, it won’t matter what the philosophers think.
History isn’t a story of moral progress; it’s a cycle, broken only by those willing to confront it head-on. But philosophy, the discipline meant to challenge power, became just another system justifying itself—and in doing so, it ensured its own irrelevance.
The Philosophers Who Actually Mattered Didn’t Play by These Rules
Socrates was executed. Spinoza was excommunicated. Nietzsche was dismissed as insane. Wittgenstein, frustrated by academic limits, walked away from it multiple times. None of these thinkers treated philosophy like a comfortable, tenured career path. They knew real truth demands risk, forces confrontation rather than retreat, and cannot survive where institutional safety outweighs intellectual honesty.
And yet these are the philosophers who shaped history.
Contrast that with today’s philosophers—the ones who pause before saying anything too bold, too risky, too real. The ones who write papers so dense and self-referential that they alienate anyone outside academia. The ones who measure every word not for its truth, but for how colleagues—equally trained to toe the line—will receive it.
If the great philosophers of history had followed the logic of modern academia, they’d never have mattered at all. They would’ve produced well-cited, carefully neutral papers, debated politely at conferences, and retired comfortably. Their ideas would have vanished without a trace.
Because philosophy isn’t supposed to be safe. And if it is, it’s already failed.
What I Did Instead
By my final semester, I’d already seen the cracks: evasions, polite silences, professors more interested in guarding their position than tackling real questions. Still, I held out hope that somewhere, deep in the structure of this field, the truth was waiting.
One of my last classes was on Later Wittgenstein. I’d heard he was one of the greats—the last truly relevant philosopher. Philosophical Investigations was supposedly a masterpiece of clarity, exposing the limits of language and the deep confusions baked into how we think and speak. I expected revelation. Instead, I found despair.
I’d sit for hours in front of a blank page, my mind racing through every way a sentence could be misunderstood, every way meaning could cave in on itself. I had panic attacks over commas. I rewrote the same paragraph a dozen times, trying to convey what I actually meant—until I realized I wasn’t even sure what that was anymore. The more I pushed for clarity, the more language itself resisted.
And it wasn’t just Wittgenstein’s ideas; it was everything that had led me to that moment. I’d already seen what happened when I asked direct questions: 'I don’t like to preach.' I’d seen what happened when I pointed out inconvenient truths: unease at being called 'practical.' I’d seen what happened when I raised what I thought were minor methodological concerns—questions that should have been easy to address: silence.
Then I heard about David Foster Wallace. He’d studied Wittgenstein too, walked the same intellectual minefield, felt the same vertigo—and emerged unscathed. He saw what Wittgenstein saw, but unlike my professors, he didn’t let it paralyze him. He didn’t let it stop him from saying something real. He took what he learned and did what none of them had the courage to do: he left philosophy. He went to literature. Because philosophy, as academia practiced it, was too cautious, too self-protective—too afraid to commit to saying something that actually mattered.
That’s when I realized: real thinkers don’t just theorize about truth. They risk something for it.
Where I Actually Found Philosophy
I found it in literature, in the minds of people who didn’t just analyze reality from a safe distance but wrestled with it; who saw clearly and spoke plainly, even when it cost them.
I found it in David Foster Wallace, who understood alienation so precisely that reading him felt like having your mind flayed open, every modern contradiction laid bare. He refused academic riddles, writing with clarity because he wanted to be understood, and never hiding behind neutrality.
I found it in Jonathan Franzen, who didn’t just critique the world’s failures but exposed them. Relentlessly, unsparingly. He dissected self-deception, ideological purity, and the quiet betrayals people commit every day. He didn’t just analyze human nature; he forced you to confront it.
I found it in Attack on Titan by Hajime Isayama. A story that refused to lie or comfort its audience. A story that made you sit with the weight of history, the inevitability of cycles, the hard truth that knowing better isn’t always enough. A story that forced you to see yourself not just in the heroes, but in the followers and justifiers who keep the system running because it’s easier than fighting it.
And it wasn’t just them. Didion, Orwell, Saunders, Zadie Smith—writers who stripped away illusions in different ways, who saw that literature wasn’t just about telling stories but about telling the truth in the only way people might hear it.
I found more truth in their words than in all the seminars, lectures, and carefully footnoted journal articles written for an audience of ten.
But more than that, I found something else: I realized philosophy—if it has any worth—must be lived, not just studied. It isn’t a set of theories to memorize, a career path, or a game where you score points for citing the right thinkers. It’s a weapon, a tool, a way of cutting through noise, of seeing the machinery behind the world, of noticing when people lie—to others or to themselves. Most importantly, it’s something you have to act on.
Because knowing the truth is meaningless if you never use it.
All those logic exercises—truth tables, logic trees, validity, and soundness—are meaningless if you don’t apply them in real life. Because in the real world, nobody hands you a neatly structured argument with premises labeled P1, P2, and P3. Nobody pauses to ask if their reasoning is sound. People will lie, sometimes without realizing it; institutions will justify contradictions and call it policy. Entire systems will operate on bad logic, but as long as they produce the right results for the right people, nobody questions them.
So what’s the point of deconstructing an argument if you won’t do it when it matters? What’s the point of years of training in formal reasoning if, when confronted with real-world contradictions, you look away?
Philosophy teaches you how to think. It’s on you to do something with it.
From Me, To Me and You, Ten Years Ago
To the professors and grad students who recognize themselves in this
If you can’t acknowledge real engagement—if you silence deep questions rather than encourage them, if your first instinct when confronted with discomfort is self-preservation—then what exactly are you doing? What is your purpose?
You were supposed to be the stewards of this discipline. The ones who defended philosophy not just as an academic field, but as a way of life. You were meant to sharpen minds, not dull them into submission. And if you’ve ever felt that flicker of dissatisfaction, that quiet, gnawing sense that something is off—that the field you love has become something smaller than it was meant to be—then ask yourself, honestly: What would it take for you to be the kind of teacher you once needed?
I already know the defenses you’ll reach for: that I don’t understand how academia works, that avoiding personal stances isn’t cowardice but professional necessity, that philosophy is about arguments, not beliefs, that a professor’s job is to guide students, not tell them what to think. I get all of that. Truly.
But here’s the thing: If philosophy isn’t meant to mean something—if it isn’t meant to shape how we see, act, and live—then what exactly is the point? If the best minds in this field, the ones who dedicate their lives to studying truth, won’t risk anything for it—what are they even doing?
And if you, reading this, felt even a flicker of recognition—even a second of discomfort at what I’ve written—then you already know the answer.
Acknowledging the Good Ones
Not everyone was complicit. Some of you tried to make a real difference, to see students as thinkers rather than cogs. I remember a GSI who stumbled over his words while trying to offer me genuine encouragement, despite the institutional pressure weighing him down. He knew the system was broken—and even if he couldn’t fully escape it, he did what he could. If you’re one of those people, please understand: none of this is meant to lump you in with the rest. I only wish there were more of you.
To the students who are interested in studying academic philosophy
It is immensely valuable; but only if you treat it as a tool, not a religion. Use it to see clearly. Use it to act. Theories mean nothing if they don’t sharpen your ability to navigate the world, to make sense of contradictions, to move through life without getting trapped by easy answers.
If your professors won’t guide you, find your own mentors. Read the ones who aren’t safely dead. Read Wallace. Read Franzen. Read Isayama. Read Orwell, Didion, Saunders, Zadie Smith—the ones who don’t just write philosophy but live it. Because the truth is out there. It always has been.
And finally, to whoever is still reading
This isn’t bitterness. It’s not a petty takedown of academia or a performance of disillusionment. It’s what happens when you take philosophy seriously: you cut through polite evasions, say the quiet part out loud, and risk something. I say this because I know I’m not the only one who felt this way. If you’re honest, maybe you’ve felt it too. So this is me being the person I wish had been there for me. And if you’re a professor or a grad student reading this, maybe this is me being the person you wish had been there for you, too. Because I realized I had no other choice. Because at the end of the day, somebody has to do it.
A Rumbling You Can’t Ignore
The world is moving. The ground under your feet is shifting. The institutions you thought would always be there? Dismantled. The systems you believed would protect you? Hijacked. The warnings you once dismissed as paranoia? Happening in real time.
Philosophy, at its best, is supposed to prepare us for this—to give us the tools to see clearly, to recognize patterns, to cut through the lies before they become something worse. But what happens when the very people entrusted with this responsibility retreat instead of confront? When they choose safety over truth? When they perform the rituals of intellectualism while the world outside burns?
Look at what’s happening right now. The authoritarian playbook is unfolding step by step, right in front of us. Institutions gutted, not by accident but by design. The Department of Education? Dragged out back. USAID? Hollowed out. Treasury data? Handed over to unelected billionaires. Federal agencies repurposed to serve private interests. Laws rewritten to consolidate power and punish dissent, turning democracy into a shell of itself.
The people who spent years discussing the fragility of democratic institutions, who wrote papers on authoritarian creep and the erosion of rights—where are they now? Are they using their knowledge and influence to sound the alarm? Or are they sitting in offices, refining arguments for an audience of ten, murmuring, “I don’t like to preach.”
The consequences of intellectual cowardice aren’t theoretical anymore. They’re here. Now. This was never an abstract debate. The question was always whether people would recognize the danger before it was too late—whether those who claim to value truth would stand by it when it mattered.
There’s no running from this. No amount of detachment or neutrality can insulate you. The world is changing whether you engage with it or not, and you have a choice:
Look away. Pretend it isn’t happening, tell yourself philosophy is just an academic exercise, that you have no obligation to act. Or face it.
Because the real test of whether philosophy matters isn’t in a seminar room. It’s here. It’s now. And there is no neutrality in a moment like this.
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/birkir • Jul 04 '18
I have two:
Imagine you're in a philosophical conversation with someone. If you could do something that would make the other person more coherent, holistic, integral and complete, would you do it?
My teacher taught us that there is such a thing. It's called radical listening, and she literally made us practice it in class like a kindergarten exercise:
She paired us up, put a metaphilosophical question on the whiteboard and asked us to contemplate it in silence for two minutes. Then she asked one of us to explain their answer or thoughts about the question. The other was supposed to sit in complete silence, just to acknowledge that they're listening (quick clarification questions were allowed but no interjecting with opinions). Then reverse roles and repeat.
I've practiced this religiously ever since. When you just shut up and listen, it always turns out that the person you are speaking with has way more elaborate things to say than what first appears. They usually don't even know about it themself, but when you give them silence you create the only space where it could happen, something that would never happen without the combination of your silence and your attention. This isn't just a trick for psychologists to use to get their patients to open up.
Radical listening is listening with the intention to be a vessel for your partner, to be a sympathetic witness so that unspoken meaning may have room to find words. Perhaps no philosopher has ever defined it well enough to do it justice, but there's a children's book called Momo that did:
... And what Momo was better at than anyone else was listening. Anyone can listen, you may say - what's so special about that? - but you'd be wrong. Very few people know how to listen properly, and Momo's way of listening was quite unique.
She listened in a way that made slow-witted people have flashes of inspiration.
It wasn't that she actually said anything or asked questions that put such ideas into their heads. She simply sat there and listened with the upmost attention and sympathy, fixing them with her big, dark eyes, and they suddenly became aware of ideas whose existence they had never suspected.
Momo could listen in such a way that worried and indecisive people knew their own minds from one moment to the next, or shy people felt suddenly confident and at ease, or down-hearted people felt happy and hopeful. And if someone felt that his life had been an utter failure, and that he himself was the only one among millions of wholly unimportant people who could be replaced as easily as broken windowpanes, he would go and pour out his heart to Momo.
And, even as he spoke, he would come to realize by some mysterious means that he was absolutely wrong: that there was only one person like himself in the whole world, and that, consequently, he mattered to the world in his own particular way.
Such was Momo's talent for listening.
This one is, incidentally, also a method to make conversations better. It is very simple and, I think, the best way to promote beneficial discussions and prevent wasting time.
The principle of charity requires interpreting a speaker's statements in the most rational way possible and, in the case of any argument, considering its best, strongest possible interpretation.
In its narrowest sense, the goal of this methodological principle is to avoid attributing irrationality, logical fallacies, or falsehoods to the others' statements, when a coherent, rational interpretation of the statements is available. According to Simon Blackburn "it constrains the interpreter to maximize the truth or rationality in the subject's sayings."
It's the easiest way to judge whether someone is participating in an honest way in any discussion. Saves you a lot of time on the internet to know when to disengage.
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/phileconomicus • Jan 02 '17
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/Acceptable_Map_8110 • Jul 09 '26
As an undergraduate student who’s taken classes in social science and STEM there seemed to be a prevailing opinion among some STEM people
That humanities people tended to be less intelligent. But overall this type of thinking doesn’t seem to be applied to philosophy majors, who are often put alongside physicists and mathematicians in terms of being considered uniquely intelligent. Why is this?
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/DataLythe • Mar 14 '16
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/pkmckirtap • Mar 10 '23
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/byrd_nick • Jan 23 '17
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/ashok • Apr 28 '14
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/NihiliotheDamned • Aug 03 '24
Is this a sort of cultural issue where certain views are discriminated against? I’m not sure here as younger philosophers seem to bring these types of stances back around. Is it a possible case of knockdown arguments just being ignored to keep debates going or to deny awful implications?
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/phileconomicus • Mar 16 '15
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/randomusername76 • Mar 21 '24
Hello
I don't know if this is the right place to put this, but reckoned it makes more sense here than anywhere else I can think of. I'll try to be as succinct as possible; I'm an undergrad in philosophy, returning to put the last few finishing touches on my degree after having to take a break for a few years due to some life circumstances. I've been intending to continue my education in philosophy, and am just getting my applications to grad schools sorted now. Unfortunately, I just became rather uncertain about the whole affair.
I received an email a few weeks ago about some volunteering opportunities for a large philosophy conference in my city, and decided to sign up, just getting done with my first volunteer shift yesterday, and also getting the chance to catch a few talks. And...it was terrible. The single word that kept popping up in my head was 'anemic' - hundreds of people, talking about problems that were interesting thirty to forty years ago, but have since then been beaten into the dust. Or, alternatively, folks constructing such bizarrely baroque and hyper specific models and arguments, for seemingly no purpose (not even the seeming pleasure of making the argument! No one seemed like they were enjoying explaining their positions, more they were just obligated to do it and couldn't care either way) beyond publishing demands. And all of it suffused with this air of extreme opportunism and pettiness, where folks seemed to be just waiting for someone to screw up in their talk or with a question so they could quickly shoot them down.
I get that academic philosophy, and the academic world in general, is part of the corporate world (as much as it likes to position itself as it's opposite) and it's got all of the banalities and idiocies that run through corporate culture, on top of some of its own. I spent a few years working in the corporate world, and I've never been under any illusions that academia was somehow spared from the eternal grudge matches and squabbling, that it stayed as some kind of bastion of goodness against the evuhhlls of the world or something. But I can't deny that after walking out of the conference (which I still have to return to tomorrow), I immediately got hit with an overwhelming sensation that I've made a huge mistake in studying philosophy, and having an immediate desire to just get as far away from it as possible. Which is a pity, because I love philosophy, reading it, writing it, and especially discussing it with people. For a long time, it's what I was absolutely certain I would wind up doing. And while I admit this is probably only a momentary, and necessary, questioning of that career track that I'll get over in a month or so....I dunno.
Has anyone else had this experience with philosophy conferences, or just certain aspects of academic philosophy in general?
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/TonyH122 • Jul 18 '15
Dear All, I am a recent PhD graduate in philosophy from the University of Sydney, and now looking out to the wide world of the job market I am all too aware of the things that I did right and the things that I did wrong during my PhD. In order to help people avoid the issues to which I now must attend, or just to advise people on what they need to do to set up a promising future career, I thought that I would write up a quick guide of the things you will need to do during your paper to set you up well for the academic job market. These are not, of course, all things that I have done, but they are all things to which you will need to attend. Although the antipodean experience differs in certain ways from those in the Northern Hemisphere (sometimes for the better, sometimes for the worse), there are some pressing requirements relevant to all students.
Write a great thesis. This one is sufficiently obvious, and considerable resources are available at every university to help you with this. As such, I will not linger on it here, except to note the following: In many ways writing a great thesis is the most important thing you will need to do to set yourself up for a career. But in certain respects, it is only the tip of the iceberg. There is no ivory tower, and just like in every other working field, sometimes it's not what you do, but who you know. A thesis is all for naught if no one knows you, and if this is all that you have to base your research profile on. I want to focus here more on the supplementary things that you have to do to build your career.
1a) Supervision. Just an addendum about writing a thesis, this time concerning selecting a supervisor. It is important to recognise here that academic philosophy is constitued by four general tasks: i) research; ii) teaching; iii) supervision; and iv) administration. Each of these tasks demands an entirely different skill set, and there is nothing to say that an academic, despite being a world-leader in one, is worthy much more than a spit in the other. Of course, all academics will be great at research, as this is why they are hired. And they are probably more than passable teachers, particularly among younger researchers given the way that hiring is going (see below). However, this does not make them good supervisors. Of the six supervisors I have had in my time, all have been great, world-leading researchers. But I have had supervisors who have been either entirely uninterested in my work, or completely unwilling to give me anything more than the vaguest thought, on the one hand, and on the other people who love my project and go out of their way to a) give me advice, b) give me encouragement, c) think about my thesis outside of our meeting times, d) look forward eagerly to our next chat, etc. And I can say this: if it came down to the choice between a world-leading scholar in their area, admired by all, but without the time or inclination to help me with my thesis to a reasonable degree, and a less renowned scholar who is passionate about helping me with my project, I would go for the latter every time. Having a great supervisor is ESSENTIAL for writing a great thesis. Nothing else comes close. It's NECESSARY if you are the kind of scholar who need motivation to stay focus, or even has the occasional (even slight) crisis of confidence. But even for those rare few who just could get it done with whomever, the qualtiy increase that comes with a good supervisor will always be better than the recognition that comes with being the student of famous Prof. X (not an X-men reference, sorry). I do not exegerate when I say that my thesis improved 10-fold because I was lucky enough to have a person who in my experience of scholars form all around the world is easily the most dedicated supervisor I have ever known. So ask around other postgrads and trusted academics who they think will be a good supervisor (not just a renowned scholar). I am always happy to do this with my students, and although I never say anyone is bad, I am forthcoming with who put in the extra effort.
2) Get publications. In certain ways this is almost more important than having a PhD. In order to be attractive to employers, either for post-doctoral or other junior fellowships, fixed term, or permanent positions, you need to demonstrate that you can develop a strong research profile of which the university can be proud. The best way to do this is to start before you even finish your PhD. This is, of course, easier said than done, as publishing is really hard in a crowded market as the academic world has become, but I have some tips.
To begin, I think that you should set yourself a goal of publishing at least two papers in journals of a high standard, even if they aren't tier 1, before the end of your degree. The best way to do this, I believe, is to write conference papers - which I will get to in the next section - and to write these conference papers with a mind first and foremost to their publication. This will give you the opportunity to get good scholarly feedback from a good variety of scholars unfamiliar to you. This gives them a good critical distance that your supervisor and fellow students don't enjoy. But ask everyone you can for advice, and spend time polishing it.
When you have something you think is of value, send it off to the best journal that you think is appropriate. Appropriateness is important here, as journals take a long time to get back to you with a decision, so don't waste time on journals that you don't think publish the kind of thing you are doing just because they are great. For example, as an Ancient Philosophy, I don't bother to publish with the Philosophical Review or the Journal of Philosophy. I don't even bother with Phronesis, often considered a top Ancient Philosophy journal, because they're too narrowly analytic for my research. Instead, I send it to places like Classical Quarterly or Apeiron.
You will inevitably get rejections, but don't be disheartened. Consider the editor's reports, and make the necessary changes. (Note, if a journal doesn't give good editor's responses, it might be good not to submit there in the future, as it's just a waste of time.) Then send it off to the journal next down your list. Don't go too far down in quality, as a publication in a bad journal will actually be a mark against you, as it makes people wonder why you don't publish in a good journal. More obscure journals are ok, provided reputable people publish in them at times. A good limit is when you stop recognising the name of the journal, and have never read anything there. The best guide is to try to publish in journals you have cited.
3) Go to conferences. Going to conferences is great for a number of reasons. First, you get to meet other scholars and get your name out there (more on that later). Second, you get helpful critique of your research. Third, it allows you to pursue projects that are not entirely in line with your thesis, showing research diversity. But I think that the best thing is that they provide you a great opportunity to work on an article. I always write conference papers with a mind to a publication, and try to get them to a publishable stage BEFORE the conference (time permitting). And then any advice given is either gravy, to help you improve the quality, or people can flag that this really isn't worth publishing yet.
With this in mind, try to go to at least two international conferences a year, in addition to departmental and postgraduate seminars in which you give papers. By 'international' I mean conferences that attract scholars from around the world. No need to travel overseas for this. The flight to and from Australia is notorious for keeping international scholars away, but always some are willing to come. So despite the fact that I have gone to Italy, France, UK, China etc. for conferences, there should be plenty of international conferences in your country. One final point to keep in mind is not to take the critique of audiences too personally. Some audiences are genuinely helpful - the majority - and are happy to entertain your ideas. Others are deeply adversarial. If the latter, the comments are generally useless, and should not be taken too much. Be aware that certain scholars will reject you out of hand. People like this are not always avoidable, and they are not there to help you. With a bit of luck they wont be reading your paper when you submit it to a journal. It can be disheartening. At a big Plato conference I had no less than THREE of the world's most prestigious professors of ancient philosophy dismiss my paper out of hand. I then went on to get it published.
4) Teach! Increasingly, academics are appreciating that, regardless of whether they're in the private American universities, or public Australian/UK/Canadian systems, students pay their salaries. And students do so through teaching, so teaching is important. With this in mind, with the exception of the last run in which you finish your thesis, you should ALWAYS by aiming to teach. Every semester. This isn't always possible, of course, as opportunities vary from institution to institution, and year to year, but you should always be putting up your hand. I have worked at four universities in the wider Sydney area (and even the nearby city of Wollongong) in order to develop my profile. Tutoring is where most of the work will be, but try to get in any lecturing, and even course co-ordinating if you can. I've been lucky to do all three for five years, although that has dried up recently. But this is essential, as everyone applying for jobs has a great research profile. It's really in teaching where ties are broken. Another important point here is to apply for teaching awards. A lot of people are not aware of these, so look them up at your institution. They are usually available for tutors as well as lecturers, and you should always be applying for these. Keep all of the nice emails and positive comments students send you. And always get your courses formally assessed if you can for even more comments.
Again, there are many resources available to learn how to be a better teacher, although a lot comes with experience. But you should always be trying to improve your teaching, and getting recognition for this, so that you can show a great teaching profile for future employers.
5) Networking. This is really where I fell down in my PhD, and where I have worked to improve most. I got to the end of my PhD and really only my supervisor and associate supervisor knew my work. Being in Australia really didn't help, as we're a bit incestuous in our academic dealing, particularly in certain fields like Ancient Philosophy. (Fun fact: there have only ever been about 4 ancient philosophers hired in Australia anywhere ever.) THis is less the case in America/UK/Europe, as there are naturally more institutions, closer cities, and less travel time for visiting overseas scholars. But also a certain academic shyness kept me away from this. Or to be honest, a distaste for the social retardedness of a lot of academics (actually a smaller percentage than I originally thought).
But it is so important to network. It helps most obviously when you come to write an application, so that you have great referees. Employers don't just want to see references from your supervisors, who will of course (or at least, hopefully) be positive. They want to see you making a much bigger splash.
The first thing to recognise is that people don't have to know ALL of your research to be a referee. This is something I assumed for too long. But they do need to be familiar with you. They need to know your work to a moderate degree, and they need to know your character. So how do you do this? My advice: publications. But not in the way you think. Every conference paper, as I said above, should be a potential publication, and you should be making AT LEAST TWO A YEAR. And every time you write one, you should send it off to EVERY PERSON YOU REFERENCE (who is still alive). Although there are plenty of arseholes out there, most scholars actually like being sent things. They are flattered that people hold them in esteem. When you do make sure that you don't just send generic emails. Tailor it to each scholar. Make sure that you state a REASON why they would want to read this. The second thing here is, if/when they respond, try to show a bit of yourself. Be polite, grateful, and even a bit funny. Use this as a basis to show a bit of yourself as, not just a great scholar, but a friendly person who they wouldn't mind working with for 20 years.
This then leads into the other big area: meeting people at conferences. Despite being a gregarious person in general, for some reason I find it tought to talk to people at conferences. I've been trained to be too polite to 'drop in' to conversations uninvited. American and UK scholars tend to do this better, or at least more aggressively, and sideline me from conversations that I do join. And being form the other side of most people's world (in Australia), I don't always have the most obvious or natural 'in'. And whereas people are excited to know the new Yale scholar, they aren't too excited about some squib from Sydney. Even though I think Sydney philosophers can kick most people's arses :). But it is a great opportunity to meet people, particularly in a more 'human' context. I find that conferences, between the talks, are the best place to show yourself as an attractive colleague in a social sense. As a funny, happy person. Keep those smiles on people.
But really any excuse is a good excuse to contact someone. I had a friend who, in a stroke of pure genius, when having a student plagarise a paper, contact the person whose paper was plagarised to ask them their motivation for writing the paper, so as to then show the student how real scholarship is done. The scholar in question was so over the moon that my friend treated this as a learning exercise, and made a great academic connection.
6) Online components. This being a global, fast-paced world, you need a good online profile. My suggestions here are simple. Get a website. Get on academia.edu, and get a linkedin account. Immediately. Keep your CV details up to date, on academia.edu put up all your papers and publications (and eventually your thesis). And on your website show a bit of yourself by sharing interests and hobbies. Show that you are a person (if indeed you are) and not just a research-machine.
7) Psychological Necessities Here is where I get to the 'motivational' section, although I hope to keep the wishy-washy stuff to a minimum. But it is still necessary to say:
a) Academia is fundamentally a lonely enterprise. Unlike most workplaces, you are expected to be off doing your own thing with minimal supervision most of the time. For some this is great, but if you're like me and you need company, always work to be talking to other postgrads/staff, meeting international scholars when they come, and eventually organising opportunities to collaborate with other scholars. This can be in joint publications, getting together at conferences, and organising reading groups. Even if you're an introvert, it's always important to lift your spirits by sharing your love of philosophy with others.
b) Dedication is as important as skill. There is so much to do in a PhD: not just a thesis, but all of the above. It can be so easy to fall into despair with a feeling of being overloaded, but if you take things one at a time, and work on them consistently, and do a good workload every week, you will be surprised by how much you can achieve. The hardest thing in philosophy easily is finding motivation to keep going. This isn't maths, where you solve little problems step by step every few minutes. Your ultimate thesis goal can be years away, and your closest deadline may be months. You have no manager looking over you, no set hours, and few formally structured demands on your time. Given this, every day looks like a good opportunity to slack off, and just as yesterday you always said today, today you can always say tomorrow. But it's important to ensure that you do a little something for your career every day. This doesn't just include writing your thesis. But give 30 minutes after that to working on your tutorial, or emailing a scholar with some idea you've had, or writing down an idea for a paper, or researching a new conference, or working on your website. Chipping away like this, you'll be surprised how productive you actually can be. And in the end, a scholar who gets work finished will always be more impressive than a greater intellect who, for any number of reasons, never gets anything finished.
c) Stay positive. Academia, and particularly philosophy, is quite adversarial, and people are always pointing out your mistakes. And yes, it's a very crowded market where funds are shrinking, and demands are being raised. It isn't for everyone, and if it is all too much then you should seriously question whether you are cut out for this, either intellectually (there are plenty of great philosophers who don't make great academics, so be aware of that) or emotionally, as you might want a more collegial, co-operative work environment. And you will have many rejections in publications and jobs, and even the odd rebuff to an email reach out. But for all of that never forget this: philosophy is one of the noblest enterprises that a person can undertake, and one of the most rewarding career paths. It is a rare gift to pursue a career that you love, and which makes a genuine contribution to the civilising of our all too barbaric species, so be sure to work hard for that privilege!
With that little segway into Anthony Robbins territory I might leave it there. Hopefully people find this helpful, and please add in the comments your own experiences, or anything that I have missed.
Best, Tony
EDITED to add a discusison of supervision.
r/AcademicPhilosophy • u/CallRevolutionary432 • Sep 27 '25
i’m 17 and just left school - i’ve recently been watching some youtube,reading and listening to podcasts about philosophy and it sparks my interest although right now i have very limited knowledge of the topic i was wondering about studying it. thanks