r/whowouldwin • • Oct 26 '18

Challenge The penguins of magadascar have 72 hours and the US military budget to find bin laden

15.4k Upvotes

They are sent back in time, they only have access to the intel acquired so far, they also get extra time to study it, they have no backups, and their only ally are Julien and mort.

They can use the budget however they want and are also provided with all existing infrastructure, however they cant use fire guns apart from those riko stores inside his stomach, 2 packs of dynamite, first aid kits and a bunch of metal tubes (he cant swallow any other item prior to the operation).

They cant just bombard the place, they also cant be detected as bin laden may escape.

Bin laden is provided with his security guards and basic weapons (AK-47, knife, etc) and he is sleeping, he also has a suicide best that he hasn’t to put on put on yet.

The penguins have to capture him, letting him die would be considered a failure, do they fail?


r/whowouldwin • • Oct 03 '18

Battle 10 average sized twelve year old American boys vs 1 average American adult male.

6.7k Upvotes

So, I got into it with some guys in askreddit and I just want to see what you guys have to say about this. I'm being 100% serious.

Specs for our 12 year olds are going to be based off my google results for the average stats for that age, so it's looking like our 10 unsung heroes will be standing at 4'9 and weighing in at a whopping 88 lbs. Let's also say that our 12 year olds aren't necessarily cream of the crop ball players but that they all have experience being forced to play various sports throughout their younger years. No athletic freak future nfl anomalies among them, but they're all decently familiar with physical exertion and there aren't any McLovins out there just waiting to get murked. Since we're talking averages here, let's say none of them have physically fought anyone at this point in their lives, so no real fighting experience. But, assume they've all seen every avengers film, they each have an older brother that's forced them to watch Dragonball Z (cell and frieza sagas), and they each saw the second Rush Hour on Tbs when they were children and went through a brief period of pretending they were kung fu practioners as a result.

For our beloved average joe I'm gonna take the literal average American male. This means our fearsome apex predator is going to stand 5'9 inches tall and his weight will round out at 196 lbs. At the time of the altercation Joe will be 36 years of age, and despite repeated assurances from his wife that she still finds him attractive, for the past 7 years he's found no success in his desperate attempts to decrease the circumference of his 40 inch waist. According to Joe, he peaked athletically at age 23 after having played intramural soccer for several years while pursuing his bachelors in Business Administration. He also lifted weights in college off and on but was largely inconsistent outside of a few disciplined and motivated 3 month stretches. Although admittedly sporadic, when Joe did weightlift he was always sure to steal his roommates well reviewed protein powder, and would often resort to using the cheap walmart brand powder to replace what had been taken. He was never caught. Sadly, Joe's white collar desk job and soul crushing commute have left him largely sedentary for the past 10 years. Over this time period Joe's physical fitness accomplishments have consisted of signing up for the local annual 5k and subsequently failing to attend, as well as his consistent yearly gym appearances immediately following increasingly desperate, regretful, and overconfident New Year's resolutions.

R1: The fight will occur in a gladiator style arena with our combatants starting opposite of one another. Everyone involved is wearing standard athletic gear (gym shorts, jogging shoes, t shirt). This is a fight to the death and everyone present is aware of this. The 12 year olds are not necessarily blood lusted but they are committed to the fight and will only stop if incapacitated. All I mean by this is that even though they can't be scared into running away and abandoning the fight by maiming one of them in front of the others, they're still normal 12 year olds and won't be attacking like World War Z zombies with complete wreckless abandon and disregard of their own safety. But like I said, the kids are 100% down for the cause and fully understand the life or death stakes. Neither side is given prep, the situation is revealed just before the fight begins.

Who wins R1? Is it a close fight or a curb stomp?

R2: Joe is given 4 weeks to prepare mentally and physically for the battle. He is informed that he will fight 10 twelve year olds to the death and is given a photo of the venue but everything else in the prompt remains the same. The children will still enter the arena with no idea of what's to come.

Does this change the outcome?

R3: The Rock has decided to volunteer as tribute in place of our sweet Average Joe. He is not aware of any info about the fight and will be 100% clueless until the fight begins. The 12 year olds however are given 8 weeks to prepare for the battle but cannot receive outside strategic counseling from anyone other than one of the 10 that will fight. They will know that The Rock is their opponent and they'll be allowed to practice in the arena before the battle. Nothing else changes. Can they smell what The Rock is cooking and live to share the tale with their children's children?


r/whowouldwin • • Oct 04 '18

Battle An army of 50,000 12 year olds hopped up on Mtn Dew and led by Alexander The Great .V. 35,000 average 20 year old adults high on cocaine and led by Napoleon

6.5k Upvotes

Both are fighting for control of Italy. It will be modern day Italy. There will be no people in it, and no outside nations shall interfere. Both generals have basic knowledge of it's geography, along with current day infrastructure, and both will be given 2 months to prepare. The one who gets the most territory first wins.

Edit: Mtn Army will be using mid 90s US Army weapons and vehicles while Cocaine Army will be using Royal Army mid 90s weapons and vehicles. Both generals will be up to date with how the weapons and vehicles work.


r/whowouldwin • • Oct 22 '18

Battle Count Dooku with no arms vs. the Younglings.

5.9k Upvotes

Title says it all.

Canon versions only.

Both bloodlusted in the Jedi Temple during Order 66.

WWW?


r/whowouldwin • • Oct 24 '18

Challenge Can Batman guide a tortoise across the US during the zombie apocalypse?

5.8k Upvotes

It's 5 years into the zombie apocalypse. Resources are scarce and the humans are losing the battle, but there is hope. Bruce Wayne is holed up in LA with a tortoise. In this tortoise's veins flow the key to developing a zombie vaccine. However, the scientists who can develop the vaccine are in New York City, and the reagents needed to create the medicine have a shelf life of 2 more years.

Can the Dark Knight save humanity by guiding this tortoise across the country in 2 years?

The rules:

-The tortoise is a full grown and healthy male Galapagos tortoise, weighing 500 pounds. It will need to be fed and taken care of like any other tortoise. Batman also needs to feed himself, find water, etc.

-The zombies act like most movie zombies, but they want to bite the tortoise as well. They can be knocked out temporarily, or killed by destroying the head/decapitating.

-Gas-based vehicles (cars, planes, motorbikes, ships) are out of fuel and can't be used.

-If the tortoise gets bitten by a zombie, game over.

-If Batman gets bitten, he becomes a zombie within 48 hours.

-The tortoise understands the situation, wants to get to NYC, and will mostly obey Bruce Wayne's commands, but is otherwise limited to tortoise-like skills.

-Bruce Wayne starts with a fully equipped batsuit, but with no refills to weapons.

-The tortoise cannot be fitted with armor or protective gear of any kind.

Round 1: Normal, slow zombies. Easy to incapacitate.

Round 2: 28 days later zombies. Fast, harder to incapacitate.

Round 3: All the zombies have been replaced with bloodlusted 5 year olds who understand that they have to stop a tortoise from getting to the other coast. Also, the tortoise can only move by walking, or by being carried on Batman's back.

Round 4: Same as round 1, but replace the tortoise with 2 perpetually black-out drunk Kramers, and replace Batman with Napoleon.


r/whowouldwin • • Oct 17 '18

Challenge You are sent back in time to September 4th, 2001. Can you stop 9/11?

5.1k Upvotes

You appear in the situation you were in on that date. House, money, relationships, everything. You can not take anything back with you.

Round 1: You are the age you were in 2001 but have your current knowledge.

Round 2: You remain your current age and no one would question it e.g. if you were a kid then but an adult now, you would be an adult in 2001 and everyone would treat you like one, including people who know you.

Round 3: Round 1 but you have 1 week research/prep time before you get sent back in time.

Round 4: Round 2 but with the extra time of round 3.

You do not have to give a binary answer of if you could completely stop it or not. Can you save one person? Can you stop one plane? You also do not have to survive the scenario for it to be successful.

Edit: Now I feel like throwing in some special rounds.

Special round 1: The age you were then, but you are not allowed to be found guilty of any crimes and are not allowed to die. You can be arrested, but it must be a situation where you are released for doing it to save lives or something. I'd assume that a lot of this would hinge on the police discovering the 9/11 plot later on. TL;DR: No sacrificing yourself or reputation.

Special round 2: Special round 1 but with your current age.


r/whowouldwin • • Oct 21 '18

Challenge Who in the absolute hell can defeat Flashgod (Flash highballed to his absolute limits by people on this subreddit)?

4.7k Upvotes

This is Flashgod, a bloodlusted version of Wally West who has the combined capabilities of every ridiculous feat I've seen people on this subreddit claim about him. According to what certain individuals have said about Flashgod, he:

  • Posesses speed completely without limit so that ANY character with a concept of speed will be frozen in time to him, making him omnipresent if he puts in the effort

  • Can steal the speed of anyone and everyone in the universe at any moment as well as dumping anyone within eyesight into the speedforce

  • Can redmist the likes of Galactus with a single infinite mass punch

  • Can outrun death and therefore never be traditionally killed, even by the end of all reality

  • Can travel back in time at will instantly with pinpoint accuracy

  • Posesses infinite stamina and never loses focus, combined with a genius level intellect

  • Is assumed to have already consumed and entirely comprehended all information on DC's Earth as well as being trillions of years old mentally

  • Can run through space and does not need air or sustenance to survive

Who the hell can defeat this absolute monster? Can anyone?


r/whowouldwin • • Apr 09 '20

Challenge A Silverback Gorilla has mastered every form of martial arts. What is the strongest creature in the animal kingdom that he can defeat?

4.5k Upvotes

An adult male Silverback Gorilla, who will be henceforth called Kong Fu, descends from an ancient monastery shrouded in mist atop a mountain. He has attained complete mastery of every real-world martial arts tradition.

What is the strongest creature in the animal kingdom Kong Fu can defeat in a 1v1?

Round 1: Any creature alive today, in that creature’s natural habitat.

Round 2: Any creature that ever lived in Earth’s history.

For the concept’s sake, he can survive in the creature’s natural habitat (underwater, high altitudes, etc)


r/whowouldwin • • Oct 13 '18

Challenge Napoleon has an entire hour to devise a battle strategy at defending Helms Deep against 2000 Uruk-hai. With the help of John Wick, MCU Black Widow, Legolas, 100 loyal Polar Bears, and SpongeBob SquarePants, does he succeed? Can they win?

4.5k Upvotes
  • As sponge bob is in the real world, his toon force is limited and he'll turn into an average sponge in approximately 120 minutes

  • Napoleon has an hour to come up with a plan of attack as he's the only one aware of the incoming threat.

  • After the hour is up, the Uruk-hai appear in the field from a mile away

  • Wick is fully loaded and has his rifle and hangun. The rifle has a scope so he can aim from afar.

  • Legolas with 1000 arrows. Natasha from infinity war

  • The bears will be loyal to napoleons every command.


r/whowouldwin • • Sep 15 '20

Battle Who is the Strongest Person my Son can beat using his Claimed feats.

4.4k Upvotes

My 3 year old makes some interesting claims, who is the strongest person he can defeat if they are true.

Strength -

• "I can Jump to the Moon"

• "I can beat up your Barber for taking your hair"

• "Im going to cut my vegtables with my carrot"

• Owns a Childs Punch Bag he enjoys.

Durability -

• "im Ok" post walking into a door.

• Doesnt notice the feeling of walking on his lego.

• "You cant hurt me" while play fighting i am apparently unable to hurt him.

Speed -

• "Im going very fast, like lightning mcqueen" (LM moves around 200mph).

• always wins but its "Very Close" while racing me, according to him.

• "im Fast like Spiderman Zoooom"

Endurance -

• He's 3, dude doesnt stop unless there is food.

Misc -

• Knows the Alphabet backwards.

• "I can hear mommy" shes over 10 miles away working.

Edit - Big thank you to everyone for being pretty dam wholesome on the post btw, i shall inform the little world ender he has pleased many. many shall be spared upon his Judgement Day for this.


r/whowouldwin • • Oct 23 '18

Battle Mike Tyson with arms of a gorilla vs a Gorilla with Mike Tyson's arms

4.4k Upvotes

R1 Mike Tyson has gorilla's arms and gorilla has Tyson's arms

R2 Mike has gorilla's arms and head and gorilla has his arms and head


r/whowouldwin • • Oct 16 '18

Challenge Who would win the presidency? A man who must use as many terms from Urban Dictionary as possible, or a man who can only speak in 17th century English.

4.1k Upvotes

Lets assume that they are both from the same party.

Edit: OH GOD WHAT HAVE I DONE

Edit 2: Oh, hey, I'm on the front page.


r/whowouldwin • • Oct 11 '18

Battle Elsa (Frozen) vs. Spider-Man (MCU)

4.1k Upvotes

Respect Threads:

Searching that on Google Images might make you cringe.

Spider-Man is in-character and doesn't know anything about Elsa, Elsa is bloodlusted and fully aware of Spider-Man's powers.

Fight takes place in Arendelle. Starting distance is 10 meters.

  • Round 1: Spider-Man without his suit, takes place in Elsa's castle.

  • Round 2: Spider-Man with his suit from Homecoming. Elsa is given 24 hours to prepare in any way necessary, including the use of her ice monsters and other conjurations.

  • Round 3: Same as Round 2 except Peter has watched Frozen.


r/whowouldwin • • Oct 04 '14

Battle The army of Mordor took a wrong turn and goes up against the Roman Empire at its height..

3.9k Upvotes

Their army camps in Germania (their base of operations) and prepares to annihilate all human kind. We assume the barbarians (Franks, Germans) have been wiped out or have fled to Rome. Rome responds by sending its entire army to face off against the enemy.

It is currently 117AD under Trajan's reign. Rome has scouted at their foe and deduce that Trolls, mumakil, goblins, orcs, wargs and so on are killable yet are obviously still terrifying and foreign.

The battle takes place on a flat land in Northern Italy. Both armies being everything they can muster.

Rome has amassed every professional soldier in the empire (no sudden influx of recruits due to drafting)

Round 1: No retreat, the winner of this battle conquers.

Round 2: Rome can fall back and use attrition and fortifications. The army of Mordor needs supplies to feed its army.

Round 3: Julius Caesar leads the Roman army, Sauron (without the ring) leads Mordor.

Edit: This really blew up and I saw a lot of great comments and points on both sides. Fucking awesome everyone :)

Edit 2: shit we made it near the top spot.. Can we push through? Oh, as for my opinion..

Rome takes it baby ;) Legionaries smash orcish mobs all day

Edit III: I wanna thank everyone who made a point and joined this epic discussion.. 700+ comments as of right now! It seems like Rome has this taken.. But not for lack of Mordor trying. Maybe if I have time I'll count up every vote and see what /r/whowouldwin thinks :) thanks again guys and gals


r/whowouldwin • • Dec 03 '25

Challenge A man is stuck in a repeating 4-year time loop until he can be elected president of the United States. How many attempts does it take him?

3.7k Upvotes

A 39-year-old American male accountant has a one bedroom home, a sedan, a $37,500/yr income and a Bachelor's degree in Business Administration. After going to bed on the night of November 8, 2004 (one week after election day), he wakes up to find that it is now November 9, 2000.

The man is stuck in a Groundhog Day style time loop. If he dies, he goes back to the start of the loop. If he stays awake on November 8, 2004, he is automatically sent back to 2000 at 6am on November 9. The only way for him to escape the time loop is to be elected president of the United States; he is innately aware of this requirement.

He is not allowed to cheat in the election, invest money in stocks, or enter the lottery, or else the task is automatically considered a failure.

How can he accomplish this goal? How many attempts would it take him?


r/whowouldwin • • Sep 23 '18

Challenge Videogame logic no longer applies to video games. How far can the protaganists of their respective games get?

3.7k Upvotes

Every videogame now has realistic rules. FPS-protaganists lose their wolverine superpowers, Mario is no longer able to outperform olympic gymnasts and Sub-Zero wont get up and fight after having both eyeballs impaled by Baraka's arm blades.

Of course the rest of the game world is also realistic now. Enemies are no longer bullet sponges for example but 3 shots to the ankle won't cause instantanious death. Also stuff like walking over a medkit to heal your wounds won't work.

The exception to this is if the lore permits it. This includes magic. For example Adam Jensen is able to jump 3 meters in the air because he has augmented legs, but Mario the regular plumber can't do that anymore.

The protaganist has to play through the entire game.

Round 1: Which protaganist has the highest chance of beating the game.

Round 2: Which protaganist will probably die somewhere along the way.

Round 3: Who will encounter a section that is now literally impossible to complete.

Round 4: Which protaganist won't even make it past the first level.

Round 5: What game will change the most.


r/whowouldwin • • Apr 21 '20

Challenge Gordon Ramsay can breathe underwater. Can he fix The Chum Bucket

3.6k Upvotes

Some rules and reminders:

  • The Kitchen Nightmares cameramen are present

  • Gordon will not help Plankton steal the secret formula. He's willing to help, but not break the law

  • Gordon has access to his pool of money

  • Gordon can take as long as needs to fix the Chum Bucket

  • Plankton is fully aware of how poor his food is

  • While Gordon can't help Plankton steal the formula, that doesn't mean Plankton won't attempt to


r/whowouldwin • • Oct 18 '18

Battle Napoleon Bonaparte with an army of 1000 Napoleon Dynamite Vs Napoleon Dynamite with an army of 500 Napoleon Bonaparte

3.6k Upvotes

The military strategy must come from the leaders, the soldiers must act according to their leader's plan. The battle takes place at an open grass field with 200 m apart. 1 hour preparation.

Round 1: No weapons allowed.

Round 2: Only Musket Model 1777 allowed.

Round 3: Only nunchucks allowed.


r/whowouldwin • • Jun 21 '16

Challenge The yellow Hulk. Instead of getting stronger when angry, he gets more slippery. Who can defeat Bruce Bannaner?

3.5k Upvotes

Exposed to radioactive bananas during a routine shopping trip, Bruce Bannaner is surely one of the most powerful characters.

  • Resembles the Hulk, only is bright yellow instead of green.

  • When he gets angry, he gets more slippery. In fact, he has the potential to become the slipperiest force in the Marvel universe.

  • He is exactly as indestructible as the Hulk, as agile, but not as strong

  • Though slippery, he never loses control of himself.

R1: Strongest he can defeat?

R2: Strongest he can cause to slip up?


r/whowouldwin • • Apr 14 '20

Challenge George Lucas gets immortality, a sledgehammer, and magical knowledge of the current location of every copy of the Star Wars Holiday Special. Ignoring the internet, can George destroy them all?

3.3k Upvotes

More specifically, every internet copy is deleted and the internet can no longer be used to transmit the program. Copies must be made using physical, non-internet means. If a physical copy is moved, Lucas knows.

George will do what he must.

Or, at least,

he will try.


r/whowouldwin • • Jul 12 '17

Meta You vs Net Neutrality

3.3k Upvotes

Today is the Internet’s day of action regarding Net Neutrality.

We at Who Would Win do our best to stay out of politics, cuz you guys are a diverse bunch with a lot of nuanced opinions. There’s plenty of places you can go to keep up to date and have political discussions, but everyone needs a break from that and Who Would Win is meant to be a casual place to relax and pedantically argue hypothetical combat.

But we do all use the Internet. Net Neutrality is a non-partisan issue, and a very important one.

Reddit and many subs are joining Google, Facebook, Twitter and several others to talk about what losing Net Neutrality would be like.

So we’re posting a banner to be a part of it, because paying a premium rate to Comcast so we can discuss what would happen if the Roman Empire fought the armies of Mordor would be awful.

The website battlefortheinternet.com has a pre-written letter you can send to the FCC. You can also contact your representative and tell them to protect net neutrality.

The deadline for FCC comments is August 17, so we only have a month to get involved. Please contact the FCC and your representatives asap.


r/whowouldwin • • Oct 10 '18

Challenge Kevin McCallister (Home Alone) is now a youngling in the Jedi temple during Revenge of the Sith. Can he beat Anakin?

3.3k Upvotes

Kevin, protagonist of Home Alone, is now a Jedi Youngling with the appropriate level of training for his age. He is reasonably talented but not some sort of force genius.

The moment all the adults in the temple are out of reach, Kevin intuits, via the Force, that Anakin has betrayed them and is coming to kill everyone. Can he set up traps capable of stopping the future Darth Vader?

Kevin has been putting together partial, incomplete traps for the past year (just for fun, without knowing what it is for) and rapidly puts them all into effect when he realizes he needs to stop Anakin. Assume that Kevin is favored by many Jedi and extremely resourceful and was therefore able to obtain anything a Jedi could plausibly give him to use for his traps.

Kevin himself cannot flee the temple. He must either kill Anakin or incapacitate him in some lasting fashion.

If Anakin's precognitive abilities and danger sense make this a stomp, assume that all of Kevin's traps contain some sort of special material or cloaking field that prevents them from being predicted by the Force, or that Kevin has some sort of unique force ability that makes it impossible to predict traps he set up using the force. Anakin can use his speed or other abilities to try and escape them, but will receive no precognitive warnings about them whatsoever and is unable to search for them using the Force even once he knows they're there.

In all rounds, there are no Jedi Masters or adults in the temple (even after Anakin enters, of course). Anakin will not receive, and cannot draw on, any outside help whatsoever - he has his standard gear and nothing else.


r/whowouldwin • • May 10 '19

Battle Since this has become an MCU sub, Lets bring it back to basics. Which would win: A very large crab, or a very small elephant.

3.3k Upvotes

For argument's sake both are bloodlusted. The Crab is about the same size as the elephant, but the elephant is smaller. Let's say Golden Retriever sized.

R1: Near a water source in the desert.

R2: The Crab has a gun. The elephant has Mjolnir.

R3: The Crab is actually Thanos as a crab. The elephant is actually Darkseid as an Elephant.

Bonus: The crab has an army of regular sized crabs. The Elephant has an army of crab sized Elephants.

Bonus 2: The crab is assisted by 5 elephant sized crabs. The elephant is now as large as a Walt Disney World's Cinderella's Castle.


r/whowouldwin • • May 20 '21

Challenge Strongest character my Roommate can defeat if Girlfriend's Insults are taken as Feats

3.2k Upvotes

I overhear my roommate's girlfriend say a lot of things to him. Who is the strongest character Roommate can defeat if he gains literal feats based on his Girlfriend's statements. If you have a different interpretation of a statement, that's fine too.

"You don't listen! It's like you don't hear anything I say!" Roommate can block out and avoid hearing any words spoken by an individual of his choice.

"Pay Attention! Get your head out of the clouds!" Roommate can levitate to average cloud heights in earth equivalent atmosphere, but he must maintain focus while doing so.

"Fine, go drink all the beer with your friends, I don't care!" Roommate can consume an infinite quantity of refrigerated or room temperature liquid, as long as he has one person present that he can call a friend.

"Sometimes you can be a real jackass." Roommate can transform into a donkey at will, with all the powers of a normal donkey.

"I heard you were all over town with Candy last night!" Roommate has travel speed to go everywhere in a normal sized town during a 10 hour period provided he has sufficient Sucrose based fuel or is able to acquire it as he goes.

"You might as well own that strip club, you go so often!" Roommate possesses a bludgeoning weapon that if he successfully makes contact with an attack, the weapon will magically remove all his opponent's clothing and/or armor.

"You are always late! You never plan for anything!" Roommate has no prep time.

"You don't care about anything but sitting on your couch and trying to beat those stupid games!" Roommate is bloodlusted.

"Go F*** Yourself!" Roommate can F*** himself. (shrug)