1.2k
u/jlbecks May 31 '12
its called snap-back. it happens all the time on ships when they get tied up with nylon rope. nylon will stretch almost twice its length under pressure. when it breaks it sounds like a gunshot as it collapses back to its original length, severing limbs that are in the way.
239
u/aletoledo May 31 '12
So it wasn't that the pulling action pulled their arms off, but rather that when the tension was released, the whip of the rope?
I just couldn't get my head around why this happened, so thank-you.
113
u/BALTIM0R0N May 31 '12
I'm still confused
217
u/aletoledo May 31 '12
The rope stretched so much that it sprung back. So lets say the rope laying on the ground is 10 feet long. During the tug-of-war the rope stretches to 20 feet. When the rope broke suddenly, it went from 20 feet to 10 feet in a second, so for each side from the middle is a 5 foot shift. The guys wrapped their arms around the rope, so the shift took their arm 5 feet behind them in a second.
I think the important question here is why they were using such a stretchy rope?
143
175
u/pigvwu May 31 '12
To have 1600 people involved, you need a really long rope. If it's really long, a rope needn't be particularly stretchy to do this.
→ More replies (23)→ More replies (58)60
u/stevesan May 31 '12
I imagine just having it wrapped around your arm would be enough to cut it off! Like..hey lemme wrap this rope around my arm and have 800 people each side pull on the ends.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (5)59
u/freedomweasel May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
Yep. It's like pulling a rubber band and having it break and slap back on your fingers.
I had a college professor who managed to break a climbing rope and when it snapped it broke his ankle. He wasn't attached or touching the rope at all, it was just the force if it breaking and snapping back towards him and hitting his ankle.
→ More replies (8)13
u/rtkwe May 31 '12
o.O How in the world? Those ropes are really freaking strong. Must have been worn or the rope was seriously overloaded.
→ More replies (11)42
u/freedomweasel May 31 '12
To be fair, he was using an old static rope to pull out a stump with his truck. He also had a beer in his hand. It was not one of his brighter moments.
→ More replies (9)18
u/wootmonster May 31 '12
The ships and barges I have dealt with all use hemp rope not nylon. Same thing happens though, it stretches quite a bit and, of course, will break if stretched too much.
→ More replies (5)9
u/lukeatron May 31 '12
Hemp ropes are unable to release the stored energy as quickly and violently as nylon, which is why they're used for high loads and long spans.
4
May 31 '12
Nylon line is no longer use on modern ships because of snap-back. I've seen modern lines break, once in 12 years at sea, but without snap-back.
105
u/ThereOnceWasAMan May 31 '12
This is the 7th most upvoted comment, and the first non-pun, non-meme one. Awesome, reddit.
211
u/Andoo May 31 '12
The larger subs suffer from the youtube/digg effect. They can't help it. The masses are, for lack of a better term, retarded.
27
u/lrn2ply May 31 '12
The IQ of a crowd is the IQ of its most stupid member divided by the number of people in it.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (20)57
5
u/GAMEchief May 31 '12
It is the top comment at the moment. I'll take that to mean that the majority of comments are puns/memes, while the comments of substance are the ones that get upvoted.
→ More replies (12)3
2
u/PanaReddit May 31 '12
This video shows the energy released by a line when snaps back. Enough energy stored to kill or dismember a human being.
→ More replies (22)2
121
u/ERECTION_OF_REDDIT May 31 '12
49
u/PCsNBaseball May 31 '12
"The severing of their limbs was believed to have been caused by sheer rebounding force of the broken rope rather than the men's having wrapped the rope around their arms, as was sometimes reported."
That's a lot of force behind that rope. Who fucking thought that was a good idea?
→ More replies (29)→ More replies (7)11
u/brainburger May 31 '12
Phew. At least they had them sewn back on.
25
u/aletoledo May 31 '12
Lets just hope they didn't mix up each others arms!
36
u/The101King May 31 '12
Well if it isn't my old friend Mr. McCraig, with a leg for an arm and an arm for a leg!
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)12
u/balorina May 31 '12
Wonder how many times the surgeon double checked to make sure he wasn't putting it on backwards.
THAT would be embarrasing.
→ More replies (4)
63
u/LyushkaPushka May 31 '12
That's funny, I'm glad I learned my lesson in tug of war as a kid. I wrapped the rope around my hands to better the grip (like the moronic child I was) and it was some of the worst pain I've ever felt as the rope crushed my little hand. The power of so many people pulling at this rope totally dwarfs the strength of just one.
→ More replies (1)28
u/Casey77 May 31 '12
Holy shit, you just blew my mind, the power of many dwarfs the power of one... Thats totally unexpected
→ More replies (2)137
u/dd_123 May 31 '12
power of many dwarfs
→ More replies (1)32
14
u/jWalkerFTW May 31 '12
70% control?? Modern medicine man... Really awesome stuff
5
u/SkepticJoker May 31 '12
Actually, 15 year old medicine. Still impressive though.
→ More replies (1)2
u/shaker28 May 31 '12
Yeah, it's amazing how far we've come with medical technology. What used to be a grave injury is now practically just an inconvenience.
74
u/Devilheart May 31 '12
I like that one cameraman right in front of him who is busy filming something else.
→ More replies (2)101
41
u/kaiserwong May 31 '12
TIL, fuck tug of war.
6
May 31 '12
Yup, never playing that ever again. Just like I'm never arm wrestling anyone since I watched my brothers arm wrestling and one snapped his arm in half.
→ More replies (1)
469
u/drunk_otter May 31 '12
Not so much a war - it's more of an arms race.
37
152
u/TheHotpants May 31 '12
This ain't a scene, it's a god damn arms race.
18
→ More replies (4)26
u/fiction8 May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
Brave man. We all thought the same thing. I brought you back up from negative.
→ More replies (7)16
u/StendhalSyndrome May 31 '12
That's what happens when your arms are Made in Taiwan. :ba-dum-tish:
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (11)7
u/colorless_green_idea May 31 '12
Is this the beginning of the 2012 armageddon everybody has been predicting?
→ More replies (3)10
28
u/altoid2k4 May 31 '12
Dedication.
9
u/IFuckedABearOnce May 31 '12
Decimation.
→ More replies (4)0
May 31 '12
[deleted]
14
u/MonkeysDontEvolve May 31 '12
It's interesting how the word decimate evolved. The practice of decimation started in roman times to punish a unit who had fucked up. Each soldier in the unit was put into a group of 10. Each group "drew straws" The person who "drew the short straw" got beat to death with clubs by the other nine guys. Thus killing off 1/10 of the unit. Now instead of 1/10, decimation means complete destruction. It's funny how things get exaggerated overtime.
→ More replies (1)2
17
May 31 '12
And that's why you don't wrap the rope around your arm.
13
May 31 '12
Exactly. Unfortunately, I had to witness a friend learn this lesson the hard way (albeit, not quite as traumatic). During high school, we had a tug of war between the sophomores and the juniors. A friend had his hand wrapped in the rope and as soon as it was tugged, four fingers on his left hand, from index to pinky, popped off like snapped twigs. The science teacher nabbed them up and got them on ice right away, but the damage was too bad from the ripping force to reattach them.
→ More replies (11)8
u/JalopyPilot May 31 '12
Not to downplay how bad wrapping the rope around your appendages may be but: "The severing of their limbs was believed to have been caused by sheer rebounding force of the broken rope rather than the men's having wrapped the rope around their arms, as was sometimes reported." Source.
→ More replies (1)2
2
u/futureperfecttense May 31 '12
And that's why you don't wrap the rope around your arm.
j. walter weatherman
41
u/ZsaFreigh May 31 '12
This image is so old, it's still against gay marriage.
2
May 31 '12
It was called "Tug of War Tragedy" on rotten.com when rotten.com had about 40 images total.
3
140
u/SquidLoaf May 31 '12
This should definitely be NSFW
39
u/FlyingDutchkid May 31 '12
It's WTF, you watch at your own risk.
→ More replies (1)25
u/poptart2nd May 31 '12
oh i'm sorry, where in the sidebar does it say that this is a NSFW subreddit? that's right, nowhere, because not every link is NSFW and the NSFW posts need to be tagged.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (39)9
u/niperwiper May 31 '12
While I agree, I want to elaborate. It shouldn't be NSFW because anyone in their right mind would be browsing /r/WTF in their workplace; I still prefer being prepped for gore while browsing at home, which a NSFW tag would help with.
→ More replies (4)
11
4
4
u/kensomniac May 31 '12
I'm pretty sure this was the very first "gore" pic I viewed online. Good ol' Rotten.
4
4
u/slartibarter May 31 '12
I can't be the only person that read to the end of that and was baffled that 45 OTHER PEOPLE WERE INJURED! I understand the gruesomeness of the dismemberment but 45 other people were injured during Tug-of-war?!
3
u/ignite May 31 '12
Wow, I honestly never knew that medical technology has advanced such that a severed limb can be reattached such that 70% of its use can be regained.
4
u/Armstrong0 May 31 '12
TIL Never wrap the rope around your arms when playing tug-of-war.
5
4
u/JalopyPilot May 31 '12
From Snopes: "The severing of their limbs was believed to have been caused by sheer rebounding force of the broken rope rather than the men's having wrapped the rope around their arms, as was sometimes reported."
2
2
u/durandal May 31 '12
Seen a few of those. Seems people try this from time to time, and underestimate the cumulative force. The rope breaks and the recoil of the rope ends tears into the foremost contestants on both sides.
2 dead, 102 injured, 1995 - link in German, at the bottom
I remember the last one, lots of media attention and obvious legal repercussions, sad story. Google "tug-of-war accident" for more. People need to learn more about physics.
→ More replies (3)
2
May 31 '12
There was once a tug-of-war competition with scouts in germany, the rope was also not suitable for tug-of-war, it killed 2 children and hurt 102 other. FYI: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tauziehen (Caution: German Wikipedia )
2
2
2
u/eb_went_to_pixley May 31 '12
one guy almost hit by a flying detached arm said "Hey! I thought it was arm-missed-us Day!"
2
u/Overtime69 May 31 '12
[and thats why you always leave a note] (http://inconvenientbluth.blogspot.com/2009/07/j-walter-weatherman.html)
2
2
May 31 '12
I was going to comment on this image the last time I saw it, but my mom picked up the phone and kicked me off AOL
2
2
u/blade2000 May 31 '12
Older than the Internet!!!! I remember this article and photo from the old rotten.com days.
2
2
2
2
u/ciscomd May 31 '12
I remember seeing this in a magazine probably ~10 years ago, and feeling really ill when I realized that he isn't wearing a red shirt - it's a white shirt stained with blood.
I knew what the pic was going to be as soon as I read the title, and clicked it to see if it would still affect me that way. It did.
2
u/The_Bravinator May 31 '12
The real WTF part for me was that they were expected to recover 70% of the use of those arms. That an arm can be TRAUMATICALLY TORN FROM THE BODY, reattached and work at a significant percentage of its original ability is just completely amazing, no matter how many times I hear of it happening.
2
u/paperboat22 May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12
"The men were expected to recover 70 percent of the use of their arms"
Can I just say modern medicine is amazing in that we can do this. Just imagine, having your arm ripped completely off your body and then being able to use it again. My hat is off to all the doctors!
2
u/FredFredrickson May 31 '12
I don't want to sound like the prude of Reddit, but honestly... why do people like looking at shit like this?
Maybe I'm just not normal, or just not normal for Reddit, but I hate seeing people get disfigured or have limbs severed.
2
May 31 '12
TIL doctors can reattach severed arms. I am tempted to call BS on this.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
22
u/ronin1066 May 31 '12
From 1997, thanx for being so contemporary
74
May 31 '12
I don't get it.
Have you seen this before or something?
Is it easier to relate to arms-being-ripped-off-stories if they are more recent?
Were the 90's a boring time for arms-being-ripped-off?→ More replies (7)→ More replies (5)2
u/contextsdontmatter May 31 '12
i came here to say this... this is so old that I was in 1st grade when I heard about it. Now I'm a college grad.
3
3
u/NBninja May 31 '12
It makes me sad that I didn't even flinch when I saw the picture. What have you done to me, Internet?!
14
May 31 '12
And all this time I thought Tug of War was a bit of 'armless fun.
→ More replies (3)14
May 31 '12
Super job, repeating a comment off YouTube. You're a real internet pro.
→ More replies (1)
3
2
u/2wolves1moon May 31 '12
This was the first gnar image I saw on the internet - Rotten.com ca. '97. Brings back memories.
2
May 31 '12
People downvote you because they think you're being sarcastic. Seriously, I remember seeing this in my HS English class while surfing rotten.com in 97.
2
May 31 '12
dude NSFW. Am I the only one around here who doesn't like looking at pictures of violently disfigured people?!
2
u/TedFuckingBeneke May 31 '12
Mr. McGreg: Dr. Nick Riviera. Remember me?
Dr. Nick: Why, if it isn't my old friend, Mr. McGreg. With a leg for an arm and an arm for a leg.
1
u/lud1120 May 31 '12
At least a NSFW warning would be needed here... But seriously, tag it NSFL/Gore <_<
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/FartSnob May 31 '12
I've seen this pic before... the most disturbing part is that his shirt isn't red, but white and nearly completely stained with blood. If you look closely by his pants you can see areas where his shirt is still white.
1
1
1
u/TheMediumPanda May 31 '12
As someone living in China, I can tell that the Taiwan brothers seem to suffer from similar problems. Didn't anyone consider how much force 1600 people will apply to a simple rope?
1
1
u/Stephoria May 31 '12
I'm really surprised neither of those men saw the EXTREME folly in wrapping the rope around their arms.
I've got to HAND it to them, that was the stupidest thing I've heard in weeks.
1
u/phosphenedreams May 31 '12
This happened at my school once. No lost arms, but we were playing tug-of-war for field day and some girl got all the skin on her hands ripped off when the rope snapped.
Why don't people realize ROPES BREAK
1
u/VertigaDM May 31 '12
It seems like the Japanese blade cuts through its foes even in the afterlife.
1
1
1
1
1
u/mielove May 31 '12
Thought this would be sexy until I read the warning. Good too since I hate gore...
1
1
1
1
u/novum_vipera May 31 '12
Point to take away from this: modern medicine is so awesome that they have their arms back.
1
1
1
1
u/Firath_the_Druid May 31 '12
What the fuck did the guys expect? 1600 people involved, and you bind yourself to the rope, that's been pulled on, without any means of escape.
1
1
1
u/makeroomforpancakes May 31 '12
I wonder what that man in The picture is taking pictures at. Gotta be amazing
1
1
May 31 '12
Whats amazing me to me is the fact that they regained 70% of use back. That is mind-blowing, modern medicine is fucking awesome.
1
u/Black_Apalachi May 31 '12
Heh, I just saw that gore warning for the first time. I can't help thinking it's kinda a waste of time if it's only visible to those actually browsing /r/WTF, as opposed to the front page.
1
u/Black_Apalachi May 31 '12
Why can't doctors just stop being so mean and let these people collect the Darwin awards that they are entitled to!
1
1
u/rockerbabe28 May 31 '12
The Japanese won...just cause you're free doesn't mean you are allowed to keep your limbs attached
1
u/well_golly May 31 '12
I like that the guy in the background is video recording something off to the left. It makes me wonder what is going on to the left? Something more amazing than severed-arm guy? Now I really need to know!
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/KoopaTheCivilian May 31 '12
Wait... am I the only one completely amazed by the fact that the doctors were able to reattach severed limbs and restore nerve function to such a great extent (70% full functionality)?!
1
1
1
u/Jesse_757 May 31 '12
Everyone in Taiwan is rocking those 90s jeans 20 years late, but that is '98 ..
1
1
1
1
May 31 '12
I remember when this happened! The initial news reports DIDN'T censor the gore, so as a kid I'm like, "Whoa... when did news get SO RADICAL?!"
This news bit happened YEARS ago, though. Over a decade.
The horrible thing is, there was tons of video footage PRIOR to the mishap, and everyone was all smiles and laughs. Then in the matter of seconds, BOOM, cries of horror.
1
1
1
u/iambecomedeath7 May 31 '12
Taiwan in a tug of war? Physical maiming? It's almost eerily metaphorical.
1
u/Glebun May 31 '12
The most incredible thing is that they reattached the arms. I love modern medicine.
1
1
1
1
u/eb_went_to_pixley May 31 '12
if anyone asks you to join a tug-of-war .... keep them at 'arm's length'
1
1
1
u/Flurryyea May 31 '12
I remember back in elementary school, we had a a tug-of-war that resulted in a a severed finger off one of the other kids, along with 10 other kids getting hurt from the snapped rope.
1
u/amkmercedes May 31 '12
I wonder what the expressions looked like on the faces of the guys that got their arms ripped off?
"The quote seems accurate"
1
1
1
u/Targetbag01 May 31 '12
Why is it that the front page of reddit feels the need to put the Gore Warning at the end of the title, in a smaller grey print?
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/PeterMus May 31 '12
Reminds me of a 6th grade tug of war during a field day. It was two 6th grade classes facing off and when the announcer shouted "Go"! all but one student on the right side slipped and fell (about 23 people). This one massive 6th grader, easily 250lbs held the rope at a stand still for a solid 10 seconds against 24 others...then he flew forward. It was impressive.
1
1
u/rodriguezlrichard May 31 '12
Wait, they're going to gain 70% use of their arms after they get torn off? Is that possible?
→ More replies (2)
1
1
u/JerBear1979 May 31 '12
Reminds me of that old SNL sketch, "All Drug Olympics" : http://www.nbc.com/saturday-night-live/video/update-all-drug-olympics/1198068
1
1
1
u/Blackie_chanMan May 31 '12
I thought I was a bad ass,these dudes lost a arm AND got them re-attached.Let's just say they pulled they're way through.They deserve some respect I think.
1
u/misssnowflake May 31 '12
OMG, look at the snoops, already posted on this thread but posted again http://www.snopes.com/photos/gruesome/disarmed.asp. What we have here is a repost that CAME FROM AN EMAIL CHAIN. loser. It's almost new again I guess
1
May 31 '12
Im worried now becuzse when i saw the name of it i said to myself "seen it" 0___0 too much internet
1
1
May 31 '12
I feel so bad for them. They were celebrating something great, and it ended like this. I read this months ago on Snopes, and when I saw that picture the only thing I could say was ''I'm glad that's over for him.''.
Man, i'm such a pussy.
1
u/creme_fappuccino May 31 '12
Why do people keep posting not-safe-for-lunch shit as "NSFW"? I clicked on this thinking it would be a group of Asian hotties, half-naked and sweaty, panting and grimacing and tugging on that rope like they're jerking-off an elephant.
1
u/your_dickless_cousin May 31 '12
Is it really that easy to sew arms back on? These seem like pretty serious injuries.
→ More replies (1)
23
u/down_vote_magnet May 31 '12
The only video I could find of the incident