r/UnlearningEconomics • • Dec 27 '25

Why are do people react so negatively to the concept of degrowth?

50 Upvotes

Why are do people react so negatively to the concept of degrowth?

It seriously seems like the mere mention of degrowth causes people to lose their shit and think you proposed baby shredders. Helpful parodied by this comment.

"Maybe we should sometimes think about sharing lawnmowers rather than everyone owning one individually." "This is the most evil fascist malthusian totalitarian communist and somehow Jewish thing I've ever heard. My identity as a blank void of consumption is more important to me than any political reality. Children in the third world need to die so that my fossil record will be composed entirely of funko pops and hate."

https://www.reddit.com/r/IfBooksCouldKill/comments/1g4zy95/comment/ls7rqgm/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

The sheer mentions seems to think you said you believe in killing babies.

Like you did know that GDP as a metric was critiqued by its own creator

Also heard people say it’s bad like “defund the police” and toxic masculinity and I cast really understand. Like the police don’t help people and cultural ideas of masculinity are harmful


r/UnlearningEconomics • • Apr 01 '25

I never understood the accusations of “price gouging”

14 Upvotes

Isn’t it taught in Elementary school, that the economy/(aka capitalism) works as companies would set the prices as high as customers are willing to pay.

That’s the oversimplified capitalism for babies but it’s typically true.

Companies would set the price as high as people are willing to pay.

Why is this called “price gouging” it’s basic capitalism that children learn about.


r/UnlearningEconomics • • Apr 13 '25

Wrote a response to one of UE's videos

Thumbnail
satoruelric.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/UnlearningEconomics • • Oct 14 '24

Has Unlearning Economics ever addressed the arguments against the idea that there is such a thing as a natural monopoly?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/UnlearningEconomics • • Sep 28 '24

UBI Failed and Everyone Is Pretending It Didn't - Pete Judo

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/UnlearningEconomics • • Oct 06 '24

The mainstream 2% (price) inflation goal is _by definition_ one of impoverishment: 2% price inflation is by definition becoming 2% more poor. Price deflation _arising due to improved efficiency in production and in distribution_ is unambiguously desirable. Do you agree? If not, why not?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/UnlearningEconomics • • Sep 27 '25

LTV vs. Fully Automated Neo-Feudalism

4 Upvotes

I've come around to UE's critique of LTV, though I did so by imagining what the economy would actually look like if it became increasingly automated while remaining privately owned.

The limiting case of the proposed tendency of the rate of profit to fall (TRPF) is that labor is no longer a factor in the productive economy which according to LTV "implies" that the rate of profit be zero.

I think that's naive. You don't need to add labor to something in order to profit. A fully automated economy is equivalent to an artificial renewablr resource as far as I can tell. It's obviously possible for the owner of e.g. a fresh water source to simply charge consumers for access to that renewavle resource. They could offer services directly to the owner which Marx considered "unproductive labor": butlering, cooking, cleaning, sex work. "One hand job for a bucket of water". This would still work if we replaced the natural renewable resource with an artificial renewable resource: the fully automated economy.

This case would either disprove the LTV or prove its unfalsifiability: Even in a case that contradicts the one prediction of LTV, you can interpret the consumers' labor as being the only source of value.

So yeah, all models are wrong but some are useful. The problem with the LTV is thus one of usefulness: it lead to the (imo wrong) prediction of the TRPF. Capitalism will not face inevitable crisis as automation progresses. Rather, it will smoothly transition to neo-feudalism because capital was always just a special case of rent extraction. (Unless we stop it).

Equivalent exchange

One of LTV's strengths is supposed to be that it explains industrial capital accumulation under the assumption of equivalent exchange. However it allows for unequal exchange to explain other profits which all ultimately originate in labor. The avove example then rests entirely on unequal exchange.

If we instead consider all sources of use value to be sources of value, we can view both present industrial capitalism and neo-feudalism as operating on equivalent exchange. The owners of value producing objects privately appropriate the surplus value those produce and exchange it for equivalent amounts of other people's labor. Needless to say, this is "unjust" (or rather, undesirable to wage workers). Non-human sources of labor "ought" to be appropriated socially and the only way to become entitled to other people's labor "ought" to be to exert one's own labor.

When Richard Wolff explains socialism, he does so using money, not "value". The normative (though not necessarily moral) stance of wage workers to want to institute socialism in no way hinges on the LTV; on the idea that we already receive the value of our labor power but not the value of our labor product, and that labor is the only source of value.

EDIT:

As I said, the profit rate not falling is reconcilable with LTV, and I just found some Marxists arguing against the TRPF:


r/UnlearningEconomics • • May 16 '23

Who is this?

0 Upvotes

Who is the person UE mentioned in his Free Stuff Stream at 25:27?


r/UnlearningEconomics • • Mar 18 '24

Economics is irredeemably sexist - Yanis Varoufakis

Thumbnail
diem25.org
4 Upvotes

r/UnlearningEconomics • • Jan 17 '22

Help with a fictional currency?

2 Upvotes

Sorry if this is out of place. I genuinely don't know anything about economics, but I've liked the grounded nature of UE's videos a lot, so I thought this community might be the place to post this concept and get feedback.

I'll explain it as best I can. The edges are fuzzy. Like I said, I don't really know what I'm doing. :P

Concept:

The government comes out with a new currency. This is in addition to the normal currency, which works more or less as it currently does.

Working name for the currency is Laudits.

It is a highly regulated digital currency. It MAYBE could be physically minted under very specific needs cases? But given how it functions I’m not sure how that would work in practice.

To access it/download the app/service/bank is an opt-in process that involves extensively proving that you are a single individual and that this is your only account/access.

In general the government doesn’t mint this currency.

The public does. Using the app/service.

People who have the app can mint one Laudit at a time to give to others with the app.

There is likely some kind of cooldown timer or rate controller, so people can’t mint infinitely. You can only mint one Laudit at a time, and you can only mint [X] Laudits per [Time frame]. Also a limit on how often you can Laudit the same person in a time window.

It is easier (and faster) to mint Laudits for local gifting that it is to gift them non-locally.

So, it’s easier to Laudit a street performer or kind person at the store than it is to Laudit a youtuber or influencer. Maybe local transactions and distance ones use a different cooldown?

You cannot Laudit yourself, and the number of Laudits you can mint at a time doesn’t stack – you can only ever mint one at a time.

There is a maximum number of Laudits you can earn in a [time period], and a maximum total you can have, after which you cannot receive more, and others’ attempts to mint them for you just won’t work and won’t reset their cooldown.

When you receive a gifted Laudit, you now have a spendable Laudit.

You cannot exchange Laudits directly for cash. You cannot invest them into stocks or speculation. Laudits are for exclusive use for approved Goods and Services. Businesses that wish to be able to accept Laudits have to also prove who they are prove their product/service is what it says on the tin.

When you spend a Laudit, its conversion rate to dollars (or whatever normal currency) is highly contextual to both yourself and the transaction. Laudits are automatically converted (or given a set dollar value which they can be traded in for) when spent. A Laudit might be worth anywhere from $.01 to $500,000 (as made up numbers) depending on your situation and how you are spending it.

Laudits are an extremely regulated currency. Theoretically regulated by an incredibly democratically elected government. (Though the obvious interests at play in this part would probably comprise much drama and intrigue).

A combination of your personal information (things the IRS would already know, mostly, plus any information you might willingly offer in addition) and the good/service being offered would set your exchange rate at a custom level for each transaction.

The goal (ideally, but probably imperfect in practice) is to turn material need or an estimation of actual value into spending power. So someone who doesn’t have a place to live would obviously get more value from a house than someone who has two houses, meaning that their Laudits might have a really good conversion rate when it comes to things like housing. Whereas the other person might have such a poor conversion rate that it would make more sense just to use dollars.

No matter who you are, things like food and necessities have a decent conversion rate. But that rate is set per-transaction, maybe with a cap on certain transactions depending on the nature of the good/service being procured.

Meaning that maybe your food conversion rate tends to get worse after you’ve spent your first [X value] on food that month, on a gradual scale. So it won’t be that easy or cost effective to hoard handsoap or pumpkin spice speculatively (though I imagine it would still happen). But the point is, when you are filling what the Laudit formula defines as an unmet need, that gets better rates. The rates quickly deteriorate afterwards.

Childcare, education, healthcare/medicine, food, shelter, utilities, veterinary care and similar tend to get the best rates.

If something is a matter of life and death, it basically always results in a conversion rate so generous that it becomes basically free to the spender.

Of course this also means the government is paying for all these purchases made with Laudits. When someone spends Laudits on a house, the government is converting those into cash for the seller. How much that would end up costing them would likely depend a lot on how rates were set, but I imagine it wouldn’t be cheap. Presumably they’d set aside an estimate for what they think people will spend with Laudits in the annual budget, and then have to correct for what actually happened the next year.

I’m also not sure how this system would keep those currently holding vital assets from using this opportunity to price gouge the government. I do think there should be some kind of system for like – IDK. If you bought a house for Laudits, you can only sell it for your Laudits back for [X] time, or something. You can’t get cash for it right away.

So, okay, firstly. Could something like this ever work? If it could: What would it need to become relatively stable? What would be the most likely and/or best methods for deciding exchange rates? How could that play out, both in the immediate execution and over time? Both good and bad outcomes? How much money would it actually be? What kind of taxation rate would be necessary to pay for it? What numbers are actually reasonable (I threw around some made up numbers, but I imagine if you put them together as-is this idea would break immediately). Is this already an economic concept or theory I could read somewhere? I don’t know anything about economics, so I imagine I’m missing some glaring holes. I’ve also probably used terms wrongly. I also imagine this idea isn’t all that new and other people have proposed similar systems, in which case I'd love to be pointed in a good direction to where I could read about that.

Hope this was an okay first post, and thanks for any input.


r/UnlearningEconomics • • Oct 08 '26

"I Can't Believe It's Not AI!" Starter Pack

Post image
6 Upvotes

Based on the intro to this video.


r/UnlearningEconomics • • Sep 26 '25

Labour Theory of Value

47 Upvotes

I'm having trouble understanding the critiques of the LTV in the video "Value".

From my understanding of the theory, Labour produces things, and productive tools amplify the productive capacity of that labour. Labour produces commodities, and then realises the value of those commodities on the market, with the means by which people value things being it's utility value. If the utility value of an item is lower than the price charged by it (which is influenced, if not outright dictated by the accumulated value of dead and live labour) then it's value cannot be realised whatsoever on the market.

UE says that a big problem is that there is no means to understand the value of socialy necessary labour time other than wages.. but you can measure it by the utility value of the produced commodities, surely?The value of things aren't necessarily their price, ergo the entire point of 'surplus value'.

UE also argues that capital can create value, but not only is capital merely "dead labour", but the productive system utilises tools in order to amplify the productive capability of labour. Indeed, an amplifier for a band would create a more enjoyable experience, and a more valuable experience, than if it had not. If the amplifiers had just sat there, unused, then they're of no use whatever, other than perhaps looking cool.

I don't really understand the bushells and apples exchange.. why is this meant to be ridiculous?

Also on the transformation problem: I don't get the sense that LTV is meant to actually calculate prices or do anything meaningful in the economy. I was always under the impression it was a means to describe where profit came from, and furthermore plugs into the analysis of the capitalist system as a whole. For instance, it's impossible to realise the value of a commodity on the market below what it is actually valued at.

Lastly, the Tendency for the rate of profit to fall: I thought this was in relation to the amount of capital invested?


r/UnlearningEconomics • • Apr 09 '25

Why is “the environment” not factored into economics?

64 Upvotes

Having a functioning biosphere is necessary for life and therefore our civilization and economy.

But it seems that people put the economy cs the environment. Despite the fact that without an environment there can’t be an economy.

You never hear on TV say “the effects of fossil fuel emissions would cause a sixty decrease in the GDP, we got to close this oil plant for the good of the economy”

You don’t hear “the effects of environmental pollution could cause fishermen to lose their jobs”


r/UnlearningEconomics • • Aug 06 '22

Wikipedia takes cue from White House and re-defines ‘recession’

Thumbnail
unherd.com
0 Upvotes

r/UnlearningEconomics • • May 31 '22

The Myth of Mondragon | Louis Proyect

Thumbnail
louisproyect.org
4 Upvotes

r/UnlearningEconomics • • Jan 27 '26

Why Does Inequality Keep Growing? whatispolitics?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
28 Upvotes

r/UnlearningEconomics • • Mar 23 '24

When politics and economics clash

12 Upvotes

So I’m a fan of unlearning economics, but sometimes I get the feeling that, while his analyses of socialist political economy (non-economist) are valuable, it does a disservice to the political movement.

The political goal of socialism is revolution, in the civil, intellectual, and real sense. All theory in political economy can be critiqued and declared as fallacy to some extent. When revolutionary institutions are formulated there is never a perfect theoretical blue print, it is on our socialist principles and values of egalitarianism that drive the possibility of change. If we wait for perfect economic theory to save us, socialism will never happen. Pointing out Marx’s labor theory of value as inherently flawed does not take the teeth out of socialism. It does not mean our vision is doomed.

While watching UE I feel that socialist political principles of egalitarianism and the value of worker ownership of production are undervalued for economism. This has it’s place obviously, and I know that the channel name is ‘unlearning economics’ but economics is not absent of politics.

I hope my concerns make sense.


r/UnlearningEconomics • • Apr 28 '21

Biden Tax Plan is a DISASTER for Stocks

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/UnlearningEconomics • • Sep 11 '23

Economists lean to the left, right?

20 Upvotes

So why does it feel like I'm in a forum with a bunch of conservatives when I go on any subreddit about economics?

Like i always get this underlying feeling that they might as well rename themselves to r/capitalism

The thing i hate the most and what makes me question the ideas in the sub is that they seem to dismiss common grievances in our contemporary economics system.

Sometimes I think its more of a feeling but I feel it everytime I go on one and since I am getting more interested in economics this is rather discouraging.


r/UnlearningEconomics • • Sep 29 '23

Why are professional economists rarely successful businessmen while practically every effective businessmen and investor esp billionaires have learned some of the fundamentals of economics?

13 Upvotes

There is almost no professional full-time economist who are on the Forbes list to put one example. But every big name businessmen from Warren Buffer to Peter Lynch to Robert T. Kiyosaki and Trump have taken a 101 economics course in college. At least Buffet took enough credits he graduated with a Masters of Science in the field. Even self-made men who never went to college or even graduate with a high school diploma do a lot of reading on economics and follow journals, newspaper, and magazines on the subject. So its obvious understanding economics is a gigantic help to doing well in business. But why is the reverse position so rare? Do economists lack some knowledge for running business? I'm just perplexed how such brilliant academics are not out there making the dough in the stocks or creating public companies?


r/UnlearningEconomics • • Jun 19 '26

Is there any scientific basis for “Green Growth”?

13 Upvotes

I hear that Degrowth means your eco fascist that hates the poor and we really need green growth.

But it seems there is little scientific consensus on “green growth” some places have economic activity decoupled from carbon emissions but carbon emissions are one part of a bigger crisis involving fresh water depletion, biodiversity loss, pollution, PFAS.


r/UnlearningEconomics • • Mar 13 '24

Could surge pricing be good?

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/UnlearningEconomics • • Aug 25 '23

Suggest video topics

1 Upvotes

What’s the best way to give UE suggestions for video topics? There are some concepts I want to know more about and I think he would be qualified to present it, if he’s interested.


r/UnlearningEconomics • • Sep 02 '21

Just 100 companies responsible for 71% of global emissions, study says

Thumbnail
amp.theguardian.com
8 Upvotes

r/UnlearningEconomics • • Jan 27 '26

Are corporate taxes regressive?

14 Upvotes

In his famous video on taxing the rich, 1Dime says that higher corporate taxes are actually regressive because they cause price inflation and create downward pressure on labor compensation. The common leftist argument is that, in the past, higher corporate taxes coincided with higher investment in worker retention and R&D, and there are some prominent studies supporting this. Instead, as Thomas Piketty also argues, we need a global wealth tax. However, the economics field overall seems pretty agreed on the idea that lower corporate taxes improve worker welfare. Is this a poorly researched question? What is the heterodox view?

As an asterisk, 1Dtime acknowledges that taxes on the rich can still serve the purpose of reducing inequality, but I don't see how that's consistent with the blanket statement that corporate taxes are regressive. Another element I think 1Dime definitely misses is that completely abolishing the corporate tax or making it lower than taxes on individuals would lead to the rich setting up shell entities as honeypots. So at the very least corporate taxes shouldn't be lower than other taxes. What does this subreddit say?

Edit: unfortunately none of the responses so far have substantively engaged with the claim or the evidence around this debate. To be clear, 1Dime identifies as a socialist and is a big proponent of MMT, so I think regular criticisms won't work here. If there are people on this sub familiar with the arguments of MMTers or adjacent scholars on this topic, I'd love to hear an explanation. Hopefully Cahal will cover this topic on his channel at some point.