r/ulysses • u/[deleted] • Jan 25 '20
r/ulysses • u/madamefurina • Jan 25 '25
r/jamesjoyce is hosting a read-a-long of Ulysses! More information in the links in comments.
r/ulysses • u/Ill_Sheepherder_6060 • Nov 13 '24
Finished Ulysses and want to talk about it. Is there nothing in between the best and the worst book in the world?
Yeah. So after 20 years dusting away on the shelf, i finally grabbed Ulysses and this time finished it.
Now, obviously, i wanna talk about it. Because i did quite enjoy parts of the book; others... not so much.
Looking at reviews in trying to find if others have similar opinions and maybe further insight into the book is a tad frustratring, as there solely seem to be 2 camps regarding Ulysses (apart from the obvious third camp, who haven't bothered to read it): either the book is the holy grail of literature, topped in allusional density only by finnegans wake by same author or completely pretentious horseshit.
I don't think Ulysses is either.
Let's start with the stuff I liked:
First of, the language can be sublime, I'll give JJ that. Then I really dug how intimately you get to know the three main-ish characters, more than any other fictional character and possibly more than most of your fellow humans. How the story/backstory of said characters (the death of rudy, the absent sex life of the Blooms, the suicide of Blooms father, the poverty and downfall of the Dedalus family, Stephens breaking with the faith etc) is unraveled en passant, like almost accidentally (which of course it isn't) is something quite genius. How this seemingly mundane day, is a transformative point for both Stephen and Bloom. In Cyclops there is some over the top humour, which literally had me laughing out loud. There is some humour in the rest of the book too, but never as pronounced. Or maybe I just didn't get it. The 3 starting chapters from Stephens perspective i actually didn't mind. Not that I entirely get Proteus, but i just tell myself that that is the point of the chapter. I was 16 when I first started reading Ulysses, so naturally it was much easier identifying with Stephen than with Bloom. That surely has changed. The first 2 chapters with Bloom are a kind of breezy fun, after the heavy lifting of Proteus. The one on the beach was interesting and in Circe finally there is some stuff happening (if mostly psychological). Imo Circe is one (if not THE) high points of the book. Ithaca is awesome mainly for introducing something to the novel much needed: linguistic restraint. And then of course Penelope to end everything with the female counterpoint to Bloom and Stephen.
The stuff I didn't like as much:
It's a tad pretentious, innit? Of course it is, and I don't mind pretentiousness that much, but sometimes he's really killin it. Joyces erudition is something to marvel at, but it does get old pretty quickly. That the author and by proxy the book cares about events and people i have just vaguely heard about comes with the territory, I guess. With the book taking place over a hundred years past, and me not being Irish, not even english or at least a native english speaker. the most politicians and events of the time are akin to ancient history for me. I am open to being educated nevertheless, but i don't need to know every exact street adress of every corner shop in dublin. As soon as the first marvel wears off, it leaves you with an ocean of useless facts you don't care about. In other words unnecessary fluff, which (and this is the worst part) gets in the way of the actually good parts, like story orwhatyouwannacallit. Aelous? A lot of hot air. Hades and Oxen of the Sun? Yes, death and birth had to be in the book of course, but I don't need to know the price of the ferry ticket so to speak. Lestrygonians is kinda funny, like a long snickers commercial, with all the food themed thoughts invading the stream of consciousness. Half of it would be even funnier. The random sidestories or riddles/chiffres: who is the guy in the Macintosh? What is UP? Simply, I don't give a damn and please someone tell me, why I should. Earnestly! To me it seems, JJ was LOSTing (after the tv series) it: just throwin in random idiosyncracies without any further relevance to appear smarter or deeper or more profound or whatever.
I have, like the commendable reader I am, supplemented the reading of Ulysses with some guides to further my insight: UlyssesGuide.com beforehand, the Bloomsday Book by Blamires afterwards, and i even made it halfway through Ulysses Annotated by Gifford. Some connections i can get, others seem like the kind of confirmation bias one gets after drinking way too much coffee and looking at network static until pictures start to emerge. One interesting insight however are the parallels of Joyces Life to the happenings in the book. Like, both Joyce and Stephen lived in the Martello Tower, Buck Mulligan is supposedly a caricature of Oliver St John Gogarty etc. Truth be told, I think Buck Mulligan is the way more likable fellow of the Martello Tower Dwellergang. (When Haines and Mulligan are later in the book talking about Stephen being on a kind of mental episode, I'd second them). The whole episode with the keys to the Martello Tower as well as the Library Scene feel like JJ is out to settle a score, to write his own alternative history of events where he comes out as the one on top.
TL;DR:
I think Ulysses is quite a fine book, if badly in need of an editor. (Forgive me, I know it's a bit of a cliche, but I honestly believe that cutting almost half of the book, would make it better). And I almost forgot but among all the linguistic and structural marvel there is actually some quite insightful gold to be found here. What it means to be an outsider, being ostracized, how this is kind of everyday life for jews, how every nation seems to need its jew (or some other minority) as public scapegoat. Some quite progressive views on christian religion etc.
Sorry for the rant. Interested in your opinions nonetheless!
r/ulysses • u/[deleted] • Jan 04 '20
“Preparatory to Anything Else”
Some thoughts on reading Ulysses and what you need to do so, by an aspiring Joycean.
Step 1: Read “Araby” first from Dubliners. Pay attention to paragraph 5 in particular. If you have time read “The Dead” and “The Sisters” as well.
Step 2: Read don’t skip Portrait. It has vital information for the episodes of Ulysses that center on Stephen.
Step 3: Use Gilbert’s James Joyce’s Ulysses a study. Otherwise you won’t finish Ulysses the first time.
Step 4: Choose your text carefully. There are two great choices, the Gabler (1986 text) or the 1961 Vintage. IMO Gabler is best.
Step 5: Take your time and enjoy Ulysses.
I just spent a semester with this amazing novel and I’m rereading it now for the third time.
r/ulysses • u/[deleted] • Jul 18 '24
As far as Ulysses goes, I don't think you should "just read it" on its own
I wanted to make this post mostly to enter it into the body of Google history for people looking to get into the book. I bounced off of Ulysses 7-8 times, always around Hades. I had searched around looking for advice on how to read it, and the consistent byline was not to worry about understanding every reference, and just to read through for what you can get. This didn't work for me at all. With that strategy, long sections of the book just turn into meaningless subvocalization, sounding out words that don't signify anything, which is incredibly boring.
I just finished the book, and the strategy I instead adopted for my successful runthrough was to make maximal use of secondary sources. I read the book on Joyce Project dot com, and every time there was a hyperlink embedded in the text I clicked it and read it. I eventually even started reading these articles completely the first time I encountered them, rather than trying to avoid spoilers about later parts of the book. I also read Potrait to get a good handle on Stephen Dedalus, as well as Joyce's wiki page and a bunch of random blog posts. I skipped Dubliners, which I regret, and I will go back to read it before I reread Ulysses.
This approach transformed my relationship to Ulysses. Previously I had been picking up maybe 30% of the obvious meaning of each chapter, sometimes much less or more. After making use of secondary sources I feel I've gotten 90%+ of the substance of the book. I just read Nabokov's lecture on it as a coda, and he didn't drop anything detail-wise that surprised me.
Reading Ulysses properly– e.g. understanding the racial undertones of the soap advertisement that Bloom has stuck in his head throughout Calypso and later on in Circe– is basically like taking a college class. It took me about 4 months, though it was spaced out by the fact that I always read chapters in 1 or 2 sittings of 6-8 hours, except for Circe which is a monster of a chapter. I feel like I learned as much from this period as I did from the best classes I took in college, about a huge array of subjects. In my opinion, doing it this way is absolutely worthwhile, because the book has a huge amount to teach us; I've even been thinking about it frequently with respect to issues in my real life. Reading it shallowly, on the other hand, sounds to me like an exercise in frustration, mouthing out sounds and skipping over whole paragraphs because the references are too dense to parse at 100 years' remove.
Anyway, these are just my thoughts in the matter. Like I said, I wrote this post because I got the opposite advice when I went looking for it over the past few years, and would have read the book a long time ago if I had found a post like this one.
r/ulysses • u/jjgalaxy37 • Jun 16 '24
Happy Bloomsday
Happy bloomsday. If anyone has any fun adventures for the day I’d love to hear em.
r/ulysses • u/Altruistic-Airport28 • Feb 20 '23
I read somewhere that “The Man in the Macintosh” is supposed to be Joyce. Is that the prevailing theory?
r/ulysses • u/neorehud • Apr 05 '23
The Joyce Project
I'm new here and have just made a quick scan of the threads. I do not see any mention of The Joyce Project
r/ulysses • u/[deleted] • Aug 09 '24
Stately plump Buck Mulligan. ‘Oh no, what now?’
A man’s disrupted attempt to read Ulysses before the end of the world. This time, I am going to succeed! ‘What’s that? Oh for Fucks sake!’
r/ulysses • u/jjgalaxy37 • Mar 08 '19
I just finished the trek
I finally traversed the streets of Dublin through Leopold Bloom's shoes, and decided to write some thoughts. I did not keep thorough notes or follow a how-to guide I just jumped right in and powered through. I did however read the Linati and Gilbert schemas, written by James Joyce to help his buddies, before and after each chapter. Things I did not like: hard to follow through parts of each chapter, chapter themes were each different making it hard to find consistency, and super long explanations for obscure details while short explanations for many of the important details, and I felt as though over half the book was a chore to read. What I did like: narration resembling real thought process (as opposed to linear like many authors of the time), different themes for each chapter (contradicting I know, but also shows his abilities to capture different styles), his extensive references to many people I had never heard of.
I never knew the Guiness brewery was actually a family, which is practically Irish royalty. I didn't know the creators brothers were so different, their unique attributes resembling usurpiant nature of England overIreland. I cant believe how many different references between the Hebrews and Irish there could be. I also didn't realize how honest and friendly people of the time were and how they reenacted. From start to end I was fascinated by the book. It was part mad genius part lunatic. What was weird though was after many people told me to just stop reading it, I just couldn't. There was something about the narration that pulled me in, and left me intranced. This was a visceral experience I will not forget soon. If anyone ever asks me if they should read it 10/10 I will say YES. You may not get it or appreciate it in the present, but to finish is totally worth it! Please leave comments/ bashing remarks/ anything if yall think I was right in any of this or far in left field for anything I said!
r/ulysses • u/dauntingwalnut • Jan 13 '18
Gilbert Schema for Ulysses - intensely useful
r/ulysses • u/[deleted] • Jan 04 '20
Top 5 favorite Ulysses Episodes
My top 5 Ulysses episodes are:
Penelope
Telemachus
Calypso
Sirens
Cyclops
What are your top 5 episodes?
r/ulysses • u/piccinini02 • Nov 11 '25
Livestreaming myself copying Ulysses by hand
I saw a lecture on youtube by american poet Kenneth Goldmisth about uncreative writing in which he mentions that Hunter Thompson copied (typed) whole chapters of Hemingway and Fiztgerald just to feel how it was like to write those words.
So, I've been copying Ulysses by hand for a few months now, 2-4 pages on each section, to get a sense of how it feels to write those words in that order. Got to Wandering Rocks and decided to livestream it. Unwatcheable stuff, of course, but felt like sharing the journey with others fanatics like me self.
That joke: "What did you do in the Great War, Mr Joyce?". "I wrote Ulysses. What did you do?".
I copied it.
Or that anedocte:
“I've been working hard on [Ulysses] all day," said Joyce.
Does that mean that you have written a great deal?" I said.
Two sentences," said Joyce.
I looked sideways but Joyce was not smiling. I thought of [French novelist Gustave] Flaubert. "You've been seeking the mot juste?" I said.
No," said Joyce. "I have the words already. What I am seeking is the perfect order of words in the sentence.”
r/ulysses • u/TheMythofNarcissus • Apr 09 '18
Best Way to Read Ulysses?
I’m trying to read the entirety of Ulysses and capture every bit of elegance and beauty (or as much as I can capture in the first reading). I’ve tried reading it before but I always stopped after encountering massive paragraphs of French and bits of Latin that I don’t know. Any tips, like if there are any books I should get to guide me or if any websites would help me better understand it?
r/ulysses • u/dommingdarcy • Nov 22 '22
Recommendations for books on the relationship between The Odyssey and Ulysses?
Both texts are resources for a project I’m working on. Academic papers and digital resources would be great, but I’d prefer printed texts where possible! I’m an annotater. Thanks in advance!
r/ulysses • u/[deleted] • Jul 20 '19
Annotated edition of Ulysses
New to this subreddit. I am looking for a recommendation of the best annotated version of the book, versus simply the definitive text. One that explains or footnotes the things I am not smart enough to know. : ) Thanks.