r/TrueReddit • u/impotent_rage • May 29 '12
What teachers really want to tell parents - Educators are leaving the profession in record droves because they just can't handle the parents any more
http://www.cnn.com/2011/09/06/living/teachers-want-to-tell-parents/index.html302
May 29 '12
My mother is a high-school teacher and had an ongoing issue with a overbearing-micromanaging parent. Constantly wanting extra credit for her child, even going as far as to ask for the exact test questions before the tests were given.
Long story short, it ended with the parent sending a fake email from the email address of the superintendent saying that there had been many complaints from parents about her and that she should be quicker to give the parents what they want. My mother immediately contacted the superintendent to find that the email had never been sent.
TL;DR a parent sent a fake email pretending to be the superintendent asking my mother to give parents leeway on whatever they want.
230
u/mazbrakin May 29 '12
This makes me wish schools could give detention to parents.
→ More replies (6)77
u/ZorbaTHut May 29 '12
Maybe private schools should just kick the kid out if the parent is that awful?
I mean, it sucks for the kid, acknowledged, but it's a huge benefit for the remaining kids.
21
u/Fearan May 29 '12
Those kids pay for the privilege to be there... doesn't seem like that'd go down well with parents.
68
u/ZorbaTHut May 29 '12
The parents pay for the privilege to be there - it's high school.
If the parents don't want to get their kids kicked out, then the parents shouldn't forge emails from the superintendent.
→ More replies (13)10
u/luxoflax May 29 '12
I work for a private language school and it takes something really serious for a kid to be removed, especially if their parents are influential. The best tactic is finding a way to foist them onto another teacher. I've gotten rid of a few awful brats that way, but I've also earned a few that way too. Just gotta hope the unknown evil will be the lesser of two.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)3
522
u/inm8num2 May 29 '12
My mother is a middle school teacher getting ready to retire. She cannot wait. Parents simply don't take responsibility for the kids anymore. Between that and the state government trying to tear apart teachers' unions, she's getting out at the right time.
Oh, and while I admire and respect the hell out of all teachers, middle school teachers especially are saints.
118
u/ALoudMouthBaby May 29 '12
Between that and the state government trying to tear apart teachers' unions, she's getting out at the right time.
I always find this confusing. Firefighter and Police Officer's unions are considered sacrosanct. State governments refuse to even go near them. But teachers? We are totally ready to cut their pay/benefits/etc. They contribute far more to society at large yet they are some of the first government employees that who states cut benefits to.
152
u/Reddit_Alien9 May 29 '12
The difference is that wealthy people depend on the services of police and fire departments and have an interest in funding them. Selfish rich people send their own kids to private schools and then vote to defund public education.
→ More replies (14)17
97
May 29 '12
to be fair, firefighters and police officers are more associated with hazardous conditions, and if there were a strike for even a few hours, people could die.
just saying that's probably WHY those unions are left mostly alone.
66
u/hotmonotremeaction May 29 '12
To be fair, firefighters and police generally caucus conservative, teacher's unions liberal. And it's the right calling for cuts, not the left.
→ More replies (5)65
May 29 '12
to be fair, firefighters and police officers are more associated with hazardous conditions
Middle school is a hazardous condition if there ever was one.
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (9)6
May 29 '12
They are state institutions with a lot of influence in the government, so they generally get left alone for tending to their infrastructure.
Out here in the UK, firemen have possibly the cushiest benefits for any job, despite spending the overwhelming majority of their time working out and training. In my opinion, we can get better value for money if our fire service was more like the french system. On the other hand though, the government out here have recently been slashing the police force, which is brave of them.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (8)3
u/fiercelyfriendly May 29 '12
When government doesn't value education and educators, you have to ask yourself why that might be. The future for the masses is not utopian. Dystopian rather I think.
233
May 29 '12
I teach middle school art. I will never forget the mother I met at a school open house who grilled me relentlessly about my class, flat out said "I'm concerned my son might be bored" and asked to come sit in on the class to check it out before her son signed up for it to make sure that it would be worth his time. O_o
416
May 29 '12
Sure, that's insane. But at least she took an interest in her kids education. Unlike many parents I've dealt with.
29
u/mennojargon May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12
It's not terrible, but it sets a bad example. I know lots of people who have had bad experiences with "Helicopter Parents". They just can't let go. Sadly, it is the child that ends up in a state of forced dependence, which leads to some pretty terrible decision making skills later on in life.
I'll never forget this university tutorial that I was a TA for. This lady would read all of the course readings and then phone me up to ask why it was relevant. For the longest time I had just assumed she was a mature student, but when she started showing up at the seminars I was plain dumbfounded. Her son was in the class and she had concerns that I was being too harsh on what was expected for a good participation mark. Crazy.
I'd just make sure that there were just enough chairs for the students by hiding any extras, ensuring no place for crazy mom to sit. Passive aggressive solutions! Oh yeaaaaaaaaah!
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (1)137
u/smithsknits May 29 '12
I see what you mean here, but it's insulting to the art teacher. The parent isn't letting her son figure out if it'll be worth it for him. It's the son that's getting the education, not the parent.
I teach college art and I also had a helicopter parent come into my classroom to watch me teach. The student was 20 years old; a college sophomore; an adult.
→ More replies (8)130
u/dem358 May 29 '12
This is so incredible, I can't even believe 80% of the stories I read here. I had a very different experience going to high school in Eastern Europe and primary school in Turkey. In Turkey, being a teacher means you are adored and respected no matter what. The society views teachers as saints, they get to ride public transport for free, go to summer houses and restaurants that are specifically built for them and when somebody says his/her parents are teachers, then that means he/she must be a good person.
→ More replies (40)106
May 29 '12 edited May 30 '12
K-8 art teacher here. I've had a parent sit in on every class for 2 weeks assessing my teaching skills after her son flipped over 5 chairs in time out (the son needs an IEP badly (edit) but the parents refuse, think he'll "grow out of it"). I've seen parents hit their kids in front of me and then blame me for their child's behavior. Parents who refuse to advocate for their kids but have no problem blaming teachers drive me nuts.
Parents seem to think that because they had a kid they are just as qualified as a teacher who spent 5-8 years studying education and best practices. They don't teach their kids to play well, tie their shoes, left from right, how to clean up, etc. We are not a day care, we are a team. Parents need to do their part so we can do ours.
43
u/micls May 29 '12
Why on earth did your school allow this? No fricking way would I accept that in my class.
→ More replies (23)→ More replies (47)20
u/I_DUCK_FOGS May 29 '12
God, I'm so happy my parents were teachers. I think it gave me a bit of a guilt complex, but I think I see a lot of things more objectively than many people. Whenever I came home complaining about a teacher, they (nicely and respectfully) pointed out why I was completely fucking wrong (most of the time). And they were right. Basically it has made me grow into a person who looks at my own behavior and decisions first. Did I suck on a test? I should have studied more. Did I get in trouble? Well, it may not have been all my fault (though most of the time it was), but certainly there were decisions I could have made that would have been better. Basically I am unable to blame doing poorly on a test or in a class on anyone or anything besides myself. I probably blame myself too much for some things, but I'd rather it be that way than the other way around. Strangely I'm still fairly confident about myself. Sometimes I think my parents may have actually known what they were doing.
→ More replies (4)41
u/Kinbensha May 29 '12
As a person who skipped years of high school and went to university, I assure you that not all parents who are concerned about their children being bored are just assholes.
Sometimes schools really just don't challenge students and you need to know if you need to look for other options. American schools especially have extremely low standards pre-university.
→ More replies (22)34
u/ShakaUVM May 29 '12
To be fair, a lot of classes are pretty boring.
My art teacher wasn't boring, though. She'd scream so loudly at the substitute teacher next door that she'd reduce the poor girl to tears.
26
u/newpua_bie May 29 '12
I have been thinking that making the classes extremely non-boring might actually increase attention disorders. Patience is an attribute that can be improved and being bored is not dangerous.
This comes from someone that was very bored in school.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (1)37
u/NeverxSummer May 29 '12
My art teacher put a bucket over students' heads and told them to empty their brains of preconceived ideas about reality. She had gotten teacher of the year in the past decade. Total nutter, probably could have been sued shitless, but damn did I learn A LOT from her. When another teacher told our class to "empty our head of preconceived ideas" I was offended that he even used the phrase... didn't understand it.
→ More replies (5)55
u/Elanthius May 29 '12
Wait, being concerned that your kid might be bored in an elective class seems pretty reasonable to me. I mean if the little shit is bored in English or Math class then tough tits but why not steer him away from electives he won't enjoy?
→ More replies (4)127
u/aka317 May 29 '12
Really? She could just let him try it on, and decide by himself afterward... It's not like he won't know if he were bored or not !
→ More replies (54)4
May 29 '12
I don't see why this is a problem, but can understand how this intimidates you. A parent that takes such an interest in something so specific is bound to be a pain in the ass, right?
Did they sit in on a class? How did that go? At least they're interested. I've found that when people challenge me at my job, it only makes me stronger, albeit a bit more annoying.
→ More replies (2)3
u/praxeologue May 29 '12
What exactly is so strange about that, if you don't mind me asking? I think it pretty admirable that a parent would make absolutely certain that a teacher/course is worth her child's time. Maybe I'm just lacking some details, but teachers should be scrutinized as much as any other person offering an important service, especially since the parent has to pay for your services either way. Can you maybe elaborate as to why this parent was so out of line?
→ More replies (7)9
u/OpenShut May 29 '12
I would always want to sit in on my kids classes. Some of my teachers were horrible and I wish my parents knew.
→ More replies (1)10
May 29 '12
A horrible teacher will be less horrible if they know they are being watched.
→ More replies (2)14
u/Chocobean May 29 '12
The author seems to be way more upset about the rude parents who care, rather than the parents who don't take responsibility at all.
12
u/TexasWithADollarsign May 29 '12
The parents she describes care about their kid for all the wrong reasons, though. Caring about red marks left by washing permanent marker? Expecting a teacher to provide extra credit to push a score from 79 to 80? What are these actions teaching our kids?
→ More replies (3)2
May 29 '12
My mother has been teaching elementary school for decades and is at her wits end. She is fed up with the classroom and is leaving at the end of this school year, even without a new job lined up because she cannot stand dealing with parents and with the bureaucracy of the school system that is largely in place because of pressure from the parents.
2
u/GypsyPunk May 29 '12
Not in my experience. I had awful middle school teachers and high school teachers. Terrible, apathetic people who relied on favoritism. That said, I had some geniunely great teachers too.
I see a lot of people here praising teachers, but it's not fair to label anyone who teaches as great. Some are good at their job and some are awful at it. I honestly don't know of a solution to the crisis that is public education but teachers need to be evaluated on an objective case by case situation. Do teachers still get assessed once a month by an administrator sitting in the classroom where everyone fakes it for the day?
→ More replies (34)9
u/geodebug May 29 '12
It's hard because I respect the profession but believe that unions are part of the problem. Teachers like the union because they feel safe but the union model is outdated and not in the best interest of improving schools.
There is no reason to think that teachers would make less as professional contractors and no reason the public money should be supporting a large retirement pool.
We pulled our daughter out of school because she had an insane teacher. Won't go into the details but we weren't the only ones who complained or pulled their kid out. I believe there were four kids out by the end of the year.
After homeschooling her for the rest of the year I've learned how upside-down and unproductive our state-system is. Our kids get the basics in in 3 hours what it takes the school all day to accomplish (and we move faster). That leaves tons of time for creative and personal interest persuits.
Our neighborhood school spent most of it's time teaching to tests an taking tests. They had grade school kids take a 4-hour test this year. No breaks, kids 8-9 years old. Exactly what do they think they are testing after the first hour? Endurance?
→ More replies (25)39
u/RedHotBeef May 29 '12
Well of course 1-on-1 homeschooling is way faster than classroom instruction!
→ More replies (2)18
u/AimForTheHead May 29 '12
Get your logic out of here! You mean it doesn't take longer to teach 20+ kids at once?
145
u/captevil May 29 '12
I've told this story before, but here goes again: I was briefly a middle school humanities teacher. Had a meeting with the mother of a boy due to his ongoing behavior problems in class. Bright kid, very creative, just couldn't stop distracting some of his classmates. No biggie really.
Mom brought our meeting to a premature close by announcing "reading is for fags" and storming out of the room, yanking her kid along behind her.
Her behavior, while certainly extreme was in no way unique.
TL;dr: poor kid never had a chance.
6
u/dem358 May 29 '12
Yes, there are awful parents, but there are also awful teachers. This seems like there is a contest between whether teachers are better people or parents, and I don't think that is the issue. The issue is that parents forget the role of the teachers and don't give them enough responsibilities. Somebody saying "reading is for fags" doesn't fall under this, I think, it just shows that there are some horribly ignorant people. But teachers can be horribly ignorant too.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (12)23
May 29 '12
"reading is for fags"
A Reddit clasic.
→ More replies (1)46
u/reelaizer May 29 '12
Have you ever met a gay person that can't read? She might be on to something.
→ More replies (1)7
52
u/Daephex May 29 '12
So I double-checked on the "teacher wiping off a kids' face" story. You can read about it here:
http://www2.wnct.com/news/2010/nov/24/20/former-daycare-teacher-faces-judge-in-january-ar-566112/
In a nutshell, a 3 year-old kid had his face wiped off with Clorox wipes and then scrubbed with one of those Mr. Clean brand "magic erasers" leaving a good-sized burn on his face. The article calls it a "chemical burn," which I suppose could have been caused by the Clorox wipe, and was certainly agitated by the magic eraser, which is made of melamine foam: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Melamine_foam
Snopes has an article about the lack of dangerous chemicals in the magic eraser-- the stuff works basically like sandpaper. In other words, not the sort of thing you use on a three year-old's face.
→ More replies (3)
74
May 29 '12
One of my biggest pet peeves is when I tell a mom something her son did and she turns, looks at him and asks, "Is that true?" Well, of course it's true. I just told you.
I know the author goes on to list various other ways parents are trying to verify things but there's two points I'd like to make: 1) confronting my child immediately and having them admit to me that they did it is important. I'm not questioning the teacher. 2) I've had teachers report things to me that they didn't actually see.
20
u/southernbelladonna May 29 '12
Very good points.
Also, at the end of the article, the author says the parent should ask the teacher about problems rather than just believing the child because kids "exaggerate." I'm not saying some kids don't, but what are you teaching your kid if you automatically treat them like they are lying when they tell you about problems in school?
→ More replies (2)3
May 29 '12
but what are you teaching your kid if you automatically treat them like they are lying when they tell you about problems in school?
It horrifies me to think that I could create an environment where my son has troubles that he would think twice about sharing with me. I grew up with a fear of sharing that I still struggle with today.
3
u/NoMoreNicksLeft May 29 '12
confronting my child immediately and having them admit to me that they did it is important. I'm not questioning the teacher
But you're not obsequiously obeying them either. You're acting like you're their equal.
I've had teachers report things to me that they didn't actually see.
What, you think they need witness infractions? Their report of one is enough. What's wrong with you?
→ More replies (4)2
May 29 '12
I can only hope the author never goes into law enforcement. I'd hate to have him/her as an opposing lawyer or interrogating officer...
→ More replies (3)2
May 29 '12
a significant portion of the article is really an expression of the insecurities of teachers generally -- they have succumbed to a culture of fear, and their sensitivity to any kind of question or challenge is a manifestation of the resulting paranoia.
but i'd also point out that profound (and apparently spreading) parental insecurity is the driver for much of the authentic misbehavior of parents that the author laments. their repressed sheer terror of failure -- their own potential or perceived (or even actual) failure as a parent, then projected onto the child, the teacher, the school -- drives them crazy.
i'm a parent of three, and you see this bullshit manifesting everywhere in our society. parents who can't simply encourage and support their kid at little league, instead loudly ripping the umpiring and coaching for perceived failures. parents who demand teachers be turfed out of our private school for trivialities and non-issues. parents who demand administrators be turfed out for not acting immediately on their demand to fire teachers. and these seem invariably to be the parents who are the most disengaged from the school -- they usually haven't spent the time working with the teachers or coaches that would yield trust, and i imagine they're further repressing feelings of guilt for that lack of involvement which again end up projected onto their imagined antagonists.
as so often is true, a lack of simple self-assurance is at the root of most of it.
→ More replies (1)
180
May 29 '12
Shitty teachers lead many parents to distrust all teachers.
Shitty parents lead many teachers to distrust all parents.
3
u/JustHadToSaySumptin May 29 '12
Indeed! No group of humans has a monopoly on jumping to stupid conclusions.
9
May 29 '12
It's not a matter of trusting parents it is about receiving support from parents. It needs to be reinforced at home that schooling and following directions is important. I do not enjoy phoning parents for poor student behaviour and constantly hearing excuses rather than a proactive reply. Of course not all parents are difficult but your statement isn't fair, teachers experience many more parents as opposed to parents who experience less teachers.
5
u/etherreal May 29 '12
On the flip side, we do not enjoy phoning teachers because their homework instructions make no sense, are incomplete, our are missing.
0
→ More replies (6)2
May 29 '12
More like, communities are getting the teachers they both want and deserve. You can squawk all you want about "There are bad teachers too!" but there's no getting around the fact that teachers are given a horribly difficult job and we've disrespected it for years. It's not a respected career, so you don't get (as many) good people working in it.
→ More replies (1)
75
May 29 '12
I'm a sophomore in college, extremely interested in going into education, and this is my biggest fear.
I hope to teach elementary, but after years of seeing the parents of my peers vehemently defending their child's abhorrent behavior, while simultaneously medicating away all their youth and personality.... I'm really not sure if I can handle it.
36
u/jimleko211 May 29 '12
My mother is a kindergarten teacher, and used to be a first grade teacher. Now, it depends on the school, of course, but she finds that if you treat parents with respect, and follow the old adage "in one ear and out the other", you can safely move on from the parents and focus on giving the kids the education they deserve.
→ More replies (1)11
u/CthuluSings May 29 '12
Exactly. My god. I've heard of teachers who were fired for the stupidest little things, and I can just imagine making a SINGLE mistake that would end my career.
3
u/Andernerd May 29 '12
To be fair, there are a lot of professions like this. And even if you don't lose your job, can you imagine being the engineer responsible for the Challenger shuttle?
→ More replies (1)5
u/ShakaUVM May 29 '12
A friend of mine quit teaching over the parents. He's still unemployed, which sucks, but he still wouldn't go back, it was so bad in the OC.
Then again, I'm friends with lots of teachers that haven't quit either. But they are pretty aggravated by entitled parents, too, I guess.
23
u/ModerateDbag May 29 '12
Medication saved my academic life, and the academic lives of many others. Kids who weren't medicated 50 years ago simply were taken out of the system instead of being given a chance.
Does misdiagnosis occur? Yes. Does the problem of misdiagnosis outweigh the benefits of kids who otherwise might not have had a chance? Highly unlikely.
→ More replies (2)31
u/RedSolution May 29 '12
Kids who weren't medicated 50 years ago simply were taken out of the system instead of being given a chance.
Are you sure about that? I think that kids are being medicated as an easy out, rather than devising a way to teach these kids and hold their attention. If there are so many of these kids with these disorders maybe it's not really a disorder and just a personality type.
16
u/canadas May 29 '12
you are both right I think. Some kids obviously do need it. Others really need their parents to step up and take responsibility and get their kids to pay attention in school. It might not be easy, but most people won't claim its easy being a parent.
→ More replies (1)20
u/Thermogenic May 29 '12
The dropout rate in 1960 was ~27%. Today it is ~8%. Granted, society was different then, but I'm sure at least some of that is due to "problem kids" flunking out of school. I'm not even sure its possible to flunk out of school anymore.
→ More replies (11)→ More replies (20)5
→ More replies (4)2
u/runningraleigh May 29 '12
I wonder if there isn't a certain amount of expectation setting that could help with the situation. If parents know ahead of time all you had to do to qualify to teach, what you will be covering, what will be expected of their children, how you will grade, etc, then they would be less likely to react badly when their child does poorly because they will know "the system" you have.
Maybe this is common sense, but in business when we know we have to deal with difficult people, we work extra hard on expectation setting so that later they can't come back and say "well you didn't tell me it would be like this."
12
u/OnlySlightlyBent May 29 '12
Ron Clark has been named "American Teacher of the Year" by Disney
Really? I know I go to Disney when I want teachers evaluated.
→ More replies (1)
116
u/schoogy May 29 '12
I have two kinds of kids. One perfect, one perfectly rotten. I never expected anything other than bad news when going to see the teacher's of Rotten. I would always be polite and apologize for her behavior. Fuck people these days. . . you know your kids a little asshole. Own it.
59
u/BioSemantics May 29 '12
Why is the rotten one rotten?
111
u/schoogy May 29 '12
Difficult baby and toddler. Stole alcohol at 12, and we caught her smoking (we don't smoke). Complete and utter retaliation against any and all authority. Any educator that challenged her was her enemy. She was graduated just to get rid of her. . . she did not earn it. At 19, now out of the house, she's completely out of control doing everything short of meth and needles. I'd think we were complete parental failures if we didn't have a complete angel of a 10 year old boy.
25
u/embrigh May 29 '12
I have a friend who is the equivalent of the angel of a child for his parents with a crazy older sister. He also has close to zero ability to fend for himself since he has no concept of facing opposition. I've known him for over a decade as well.
Does your son have independent motivation as well? Not just the desire to do something, but also the follow through to accomplish it without assistance (for better or for worse, i.e. cooking, campfires, drawing, etc.)?
→ More replies (3)18
u/enuffings May 29 '12
I have been to a teacher/parent meeting where everyone but the kids were attending. One teacher revealed that some of the pupils were drinking alcohol at the age of 14, and this was spreading throughout the school, gaining accept.
Then one of the parents spoke up:"So, what's the problem?"
I quit the same year.
→ More replies (9)59
→ More replies (18)7
→ More replies (16)7
May 29 '12
This is funny, your rotten one sounds like me, and my younger sister is the angel. I was always a little cunt. Age ten I started screaming at my parents telling 'em what to do. Smoked cigarettes from age 13, drank like fuck, beat up some guy and his brother/dislocated one of their shoulders and threw the other ones phone in the river when he called the cops(in my defense, they started the attack, but that will tell you how much of a cunt I was. Was quite funny though, they took martial arts stances, and one actually knocked himself unconscious), got kicked out of school 2 months before my exams (completed 'em anyway).
I wound up normal by the time I was an adult.
Don't worry, your little shit will find herself.
→ More replies (4)13
24
u/lordlicorice May 29 '12
It may be rare, but I'm an exception to the article.
In 5th grade, there were two math teachers. One was awesome, the other one was awful. I was placed in the awful section, where I consistently got Cs on my tests. My mom really went to bat for me and insisted to the school administration that I wasn't being challenged, and that I could do better in the other section. They said that it wasn't the teacher's fault that I was doing poorly, and that I just wasn't cut out for math.
Well, she wore them down and they finally switched me to the other section to get rid of her. And I started pulling As. In fact, I was such a surprising success that halfway through the year they shuffled all of the students around so that the smart kids went to the awesome teacher's section and the troublemakers and dumb kids went to the awful teacher.
From that point on, the year was awesome. We had competitive mental multiplication drills. We memorized the decimal equivalents of the fractions from the halves up to the elevenths, and chanted them like experts. We studied divisibility rules. After hours many of us would go to Mathcounts and compete to get the highest score on old 8th grade Mathcounts tests.
Anyway, the point was that the teachers were wrong, and the mother was right. She saw me doing 20 by 20 long multiplication for fun one day at home, which the teachers didn't see. She saw my frustration with class.
20
u/lolitsaj May 29 '12
So your administration said "fuck the dumb kids, we'll send them to a worse teacher since they can't understand it to begin with." Sounds like a wonderful decision.
→ More replies (1)6
u/lordlicorice May 29 '12
Well it's good for the kids if the smart students are segregated from the dumb students. That way the most children get instruction that's not too fast for them and not too slow.
And when you have a limited supply of good teachers, it makes sense to have the more skilled teacher handling the section which moves most quickly and covers the most material.
→ More replies (5)2
u/seznec May 29 '12
I had the same experience. In my opinion math can be something wonder full with a good teacher and really frustrating and awful with a bad one.
28
u/Bustedpussy May 29 '12
My parents always held me accountable for my shit. I hate most of the parents of today, just because of this "my kid can do no wrong" b.s.
But, I did actually get punished more than once in high school because of my lying, bitchy, geometry teacher. My parents finally believed me when my twin brother and sister also had her, and backed everything I had said.
27
u/UNCbassbone1 May 29 '12
Same situation here. One if my teachers accused me of essentially being an ass in class, so my parents emailed all of my other teachers to see if I was acting out in other classes. Not a single one said I acted out.
Tl;dr - 98% of the time I blame the parents, 2% are vicious cunt teachers (male or female)
→ More replies (2)12
u/Bustedpussy May 29 '12
Agreed.
Man, I wish my parents would have done this. I had to wait two years for my parents to apologize for ground me three separate times for a month each. It made even less sense because I was a good student, especially in high school.
193
May 29 '12
This article is patronizing and belittling to parents. It makes for an engaging read because it taps into a lot of the blame culture that has permeated American educational discourse right now, but the author also comes across as having a complete lack of respect for the families he's serving. He commands that all parents give him a default, unquestionable level of respect but then fails to extend that same courtesy. He characterizes parents, if left unchecked by articles such as this one, as being incompetent or undermining.
I'm not a parent, but as a teacher I've learned that parenting is seriously undervalued and underappreciated. It's a job that requires an incredible constancy. Unlike teachers, parents don't get to walk away from the kids in the afternoon or on weekends, and a parent is there for more than just one year of the child's life. It's also something that requires an incredible skillset which is not taught or passed down formally in the US.
Anecdotally, I've had plenty of incredibly difficult students who have had present, loving parents who were just as perplexed as we were about how to address their child's behavioral issues. I've also had plenty of, hard-working, well-behaved students who were homeless or in foster care. I'm aware of the communal disdain for anecdotes, but I put those out there to act as counterpoints to the equally anecdotal support he chose to include in his article. The issue is not as simple as he makes it out to be, and he's not doing anyone any favors with divisive rhetoric like this. When he says that parents should "be a partner, not a prosecutor", it carries no weight for me in an article full of relentless prosecution and little to no partnership.
50
u/miss_kitty_cat May 29 '12
So true. I was a teacher before I was a parent, so I've been on both sides. The truth is that there are parts of the educational system which are just horrible for children. Lack of respect for children's intellect and creativity; overcrowded classrooms; dumbed-down, lowest-common-denominator work; one-size-fits-all education. Teachers are victims of the system as much as parents and children, but I don't always see a lot of partnership in the way teachers have interacted with my children. They're not entitled to unwavering support from parents just because of their role ... though it's certainly nice when the partnership works.
→ More replies (1)14
u/ModerateDbag May 29 '12
Public education policy is largely being decided by people who have no background in education and typically went to private school. And there is very little in our government that corrects for this. It's an incredibly frustrating situation.
28
u/ShakaUVM May 29 '12
Teachers put up with a LOT of unnecessary bullshit. Source: I am an evaluator for many school districts around the country, and gather data from a lot of teachers.
It's not just the one thing, and it's not parents in general. There's a certain type of entitled parent that is a fucking nightmare to deal with. From my own high school career, the year I graduated, a parent went on a warpath and got the rules for how Valedictorians were calculated so that her daughter could be one. (How many did we have my year? 43.)
Then you have things like BITSA, endless paperwork, pointless PD sessions that are also mandatory, grading (during your own, unpaid, time) and so forth.
It's not all bad. Teachers are actually paid really well in my area, and they only work 9 months a year, so there's definitely benefits. But I look at all the shit they have to deal with, and don't think it would be worth it to myself, personally.
→ More replies (14)8
May 29 '12
To me the writing doesn't seem to say that all parents are bad, but that a substantial and increasing number are. This is an article about them not the number or amazing parents I'm sure the writer worked with. The writer starts complaining when the patents openly question the teachers in front of the children. The writer doesn't say, or imply imo, that all parents are out to ruin teachers.
5
u/jswens May 29 '12
I think one interesting thing to note from the article is that the author is not suggesting that parents shouldn't disagree with teachers, simply that they should not do that in front of their children. Doing so compromises their ability to be respected as an authority figure. This is the same as parents not arguing with each other over the raising of a child in front of that child.
4
u/Yaverland May 29 '12
I agree that this balance may well be missing from the article. I couldn't help but contrast it with this article from the UK (The day I lost a child on the Tube), which contrasts how the same event - losing a pupil on a train during a school trip - is handled completely differently twenty years apart. It illustrates the same issue (the changing relationship between parents and teachers) but the former headteacher writing it comes to very different conclusions about the parents he is forced to deal with in the aftermath:
These days we all – the public that is - have a different attitude towards "professional people". The relationship between professional groups and their clients has undergone a transformation and this is something we should welcome – both as members of the public and professional teachers.
Not so long ago, we were very deferential to the likes of doctors, lawyers, accountants, social workers, architects and believe it or not, teachers. These days we expect, quite rightly, that professional people are accountable to us for their actions, especially when they take important decisions on our behalf.
[...]
And that's all these parents were expecting – a dialogue. It was a challenging dialogue I grant you, but it was a dialogue.
12
u/I_hate_whales May 29 '12
I agree. What bothered me is how they stated that parents shouldn't ask their child if an accusation was true, but then later said parents should ask a teacher for their side first if they're ever accused of anything. It's belittling. Not every teacher deserves blind respect, and not every child is as bad as they're made out to be.
→ More replies (3)3
u/canadas May 29 '12
I agree, I'm 25, literally just got my masters in electrical engineering, had more or less the best parents in the world. But im still kind of screwed up, smoke, drink too much, drugs (although rarely now, and never was a big "problem for me". But by drugs i dont mean mean just pot, but no needles ever. But i feel bad for my mom, she knows i smoke and it really bothers her, so i try to hide it. We are going on a 2 week trip together soon so i might take this as my chance to quit, i always said once im done school i will. Anyways im rambling...
my point a parent can only do so much for their child. But for those out there crying really helps (at least for me) to get your kid to better themselves, yelling (while Ive never experienced it) i assume would be counter productive.
8
u/Scodo May 29 '12
Word of advice, the two weeks spent couped up with your mother is probably not the best time to start trying to kick a habit
→ More replies (1)3
3
u/althius1 May 29 '12
These three paragraphs are 1,000 times more well written than that entire article.
→ More replies (12)7
u/sleeplessone May 29 '12
Unlike teachers, parents don't get to walk away from the kids in the afternoon or on weekends
No just during the school hours.
There are an increasing number of parents that treat school as nothing more than a state funded day care.
14
u/RecQuery May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12
I have no kids, I dislike children in fact. Still I don't think it's unreasonable for parents ask their child and classmates to confirm a claim made by a teacher.
EDIT: Accidentally a word.
→ More replies (1)6
u/mycleverusername May 29 '12
Or to force the child to confess to their actions, which is typically the reason for: "is this true?"
94
May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12
The problem is neither the parenting or the teachers, the problem is the whole school system. I think that the only correct educational model in the world is the Finnish one:
Finland does not give their kids standardized tests.
Individual schools have curriculum autonomy; individual teachers have classroom autonomy.
It is not mandatory to give students grades until they are in the 8th grade.
All teachers are required to have a master's degree.
Finland does not have a culture of negative accountability for their teachers. According to Partanen, "bad" teachers receive more professional development; they are not threatened with being fired.
Finland has a culture of collaboration between schools, not competition. Most schools, according to Partanen, perform at the same level, so there is no status in attending a particular facility.
Finland has no private schools.
Education emphasis is "equal opportunity to all."They value equality over excellence.
A much higher percentage of Finland's educational budget goes directly into the classroom than it does in the US, as administrators make approximately the same salary as teachers. This also makes Finland's education more affordable than it is in the US.
Finnish culture values childhood independence; one example: children mostly get themselves to school on their own, by walking or bicycling, etc. Helicopter parenting isn't really in their vocabulary.
Finnish schools don't assign homework, because it is assumed that mastery is attained in the classroom.
Finnish schools have sports, but no sports teams. Competition is not valued.
The focus is on the individual child. If a child is falling behind, the highly trained teaching staff recognizes this need and immediately creates a plan to address the child's individual needs. Likewise, if a child is soaring ahead and bored, the staff is trained and prepared to appropriately address this as well.
Partanen correlated the methods and success of their public schools to US private schools. We already have a model right here at home.
Compulsory school in Finland doesn't begin until children are 7 years old.
edit: I took this from here
edit 2: My point is also that the present educational system is always in search of villains: now it's the parents turn -- which were educated by this same system-- ADHD, bullies, videogames, drugs, there is always a cop out, there is always an excuse, in the end the problem always remains: the kids (and now the teachers) are completely demotivated. No ritalin will resolve it unless the system changes.
47
u/newpua_bie May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12
This is mostly correct (according to my experience as a Finn). The schools do assign homework after 3rd or so grade. Also, there are inter-school sports competitions in many team and individual sports, but those are in no way a big deal result-wise, just fun for the participants and the audience. Nobody trains specifically for them. However, we do have competitive sports teams, but they are not being run by schools, but instead by non-profit organizations. Many Finns are crazy about sports and very competitive.
School, however, is quite non-competitive until university.
Edit: I was reading something linked from the page you linked, and I just want to tell people that don't trust everything you read. For example, there was this:
There is only one mandatory standardized test in Finland, taken when children are 16.
This is not accurate. I vaguely remember there having been some kind of a nationwide test when I was 15 (i.e. 9th grade), but it had zero impact, because it didn't affect the high school admissions. Then, for the 50% of the population that go to the academic track of high school, when they are 18 there are two weeks of very high-importance nationwide tests that have a lot of weight in university admissions. And while semantically correct to call them standardized tests, it does mean a very different thing than what Americans may think (SAT, for example). The tests take 6 hours and have 10 or so problems to solve. No multiple-choice questions, just normal, hard, test questions. The exams are taken at the same time everywhere in the nation, and they are scored in a standardized way.
→ More replies (5)9
u/Pas__ May 29 '12
Finland does not give their kids standardized tests.
There's nothing wrong with SATs, but using only them creates a proxy problem. (For example we have centralized tests in Hungary for high-school diploma tests, they're not automatized, but the evaluation/scoring guide is basically an all-bases-covered manual. Yet these tests are usually quite good in quality, cover the curricula well.)
Individual schools have curriculum autonomy; individual teachers have classroom autonomy.
This works well in a culturally and socio-demographically homogeneous country, which the US is not. So a basic framework might be a better idea. But yes, it's very important to have teachers work on their own class plans.
All teachers are required to have a master's degree.
Indeed, people responsible for our future generation should be held to a higher standard.
Finland does not have a culture of negative accountability for their teachers. According to Partanen, "bad" teachers receive more professional development; they are not threatened with being fired.
Of course accountability shouldn't be confused with witch-hunts. The important problems here are using the SATs (or class average, GPAs whatever) for measuring (or even rewarding!) teacher performance, because this creates a (very) unhealthy incentive for teachers. Accountability is important in every system, yet policy makers are quick to forget this.
Finland has no private schools.
Findland is more equal in terms of wealth and income. But yes, the private school system in the US directly influences policy making, again by creating incentives for people without stake in the public school system.
Education emphasis is "equal opportunity to all."They value equality over excellence.
Again, works well in "equal" societies, where 99% of kids come from a loving-caring educated family. However the no child left behind policy is rather counter-productive because gifted kids are predestined to be bored in class. (So segregation vs. integration comes up again. The best integration solutions directly involve the fast learners to help their slower peers. By putting some responsibility on them they don't feel bored and at the same time get a lot of motivation, not to mention they likely won't start disturbing the class and causing even more problems for the teacher.)
A much higher percentage of Finland's educational budget goes directly into the classroom than it does in the US, as administrators make approximately the same salary as teachers. This also makes Finland's education more affordable than it is in the US.
This is a rather interesting problem. Here in Hungary school principals are teachers themselves, the only administration personnel are usually responsible for infrastructure and finances, and have no say in what gets taught. Bureaucracy is never a good idea if it can be distributed and avoided; however, there are serious mismanagement problems, but I'd wager that by creating more management positions won't help it, because Management (coordination, organization, local policy/rules setting) and related skills are just not important enough, management trainings/courses are rather shallow and very corporate oriented. (And school administration courses are just not high quality enough, so this is a cultural problem in my opinion.)
Partanen correlated the methods and success of their public schools to US private schools. We already have a model right here at home.
Well, yeah, it's not that no one ever recognized these problems. There are tomes of papers published on the subjects from psychologists, economists, and who knows by who else. Yet the problem is just completely lost on its way to the Houses. And for why is that? Just read Republic, Lost.
→ More replies (2)9
May 29 '12
comparing scandinavian models to the united states is never a fair comparison
→ More replies (3)10
u/warboy May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12
Finland's system is very unique. Look at Finland and then look at the U.S. They are very different countries. If you brought a system tailored to Finland or say Japan (another very good school system) it just won't work because of the ethnic and cultural differences. I'm not saying that the U.S. system couldn't learn from the Findland system, but saying that the "only correct educational model in the world is the Finnish one" only leads me to think you read that one article and saw the top school system list and didn't do very much other research.
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (27)2
u/sirbruce May 29 '12
Finnish education sounds horrible. No wonder they only have four Nobel laureates.
→ More replies (4)
17
May 29 '12
I have been on the other side of this. I recently approached my 7yo's teacher and ask her how he was doing at school. She just unloaded on me.... my son is annoying, gets in everyone's face. Apparently the other little boys don't want to sit with him, so she has him sitting in the middle of the girls, while the boys sit on the other side of the room. He never smiles, is always negative. This was totally out of the blue and I had no prior warning of these problems. My son's teacher last year was a man, and he had nothing but awesome things to say about my son, and he thrived. I honestly believe my son's behaviour is a direct result of how she is treating him in the classroom.
→ More replies (18)
12
u/Il_Baffo May 29 '12
I have something to contribute to this but it will probably be lost in this sea of comments because I'm a little late to add something. I went to school to be a teacher. For the majority of my life I wanted to be a teacher so when I got to college it just naturally followed that I studied history and secondary education to be certified to teach in the US. My last semester in college was student teaching and I got assigned to a local urban high school. It was a tough assignment but I went to a pretty rough public high school myself so I assumed I could handle it. What really happens inside those classrooms would be pretty unbelievable to the average American- especially the average wealthy American white family who sends their kids to private schools.
There is an absolute lack of respect all around coming from the majority of kids I tried to teach. They didn't respect themselves and their ability to do anything with their life enough to actually try or apply themselves at much of anything. They didn't respect each other. The guys didn't respect the girls' right to sit through a class without being sexually harassed and the girls didn't respect themselves enough to do anything about it. The administration didn't respect the students or the profession of teaching to be serious enough to swiftly put down and punish kids who had absolutely no right to be in school anymore (a 19 year old guy still in the 9th grade with 14 year old comes to mind who was either asleep and would curse me out for trying to wake him out or sexually harrassing the girls around him, sometimes physically by grabbing on their breasts by the way. When I saw him doing this to a girl in the hall I ordered him to stop and tried to pry him off of her because he had one hand in her bra and another in her pants and she was trying to resist him. When i finally got him off of her he looked me dead in the eye and said with confidence "If you ever touch me again I will say you touched my booty and sue you for every dollar you have.")
All of these things worked together to make this environment a totally toxic one to work in and noobs like myself with grand notions of changing all my student's lives and teaching them about the world and culture by expanding their horizons in my World Geography class were quickly put in their place when reality sunk in that in this job the name of the game is surviving, not actually teaching.
The main point I want to say is that I completely agree with this article. I believe that despite everything against me I had a positive impact on some of the kids; when I went back to the school a semester later to be a judge in a social studies fair a horde of students ran up to me yelling my name and wanted a hug (that was a great feeling btw). The kids who ran up to me and hugged me, the kids who I had a generally positive impact on, the kids who came up to me after class and told me they would like to travel the world after seeing my personal slideshow of photos from traveling to Europe and South America (even though the majority of these kids had literally never left their city); ALL of those kids had good parents. Or at least decent parents. Or at least a somewhat stable situation at home living with an aunt or a grandmother who cared about them despite the lack of solid biological parents.
You can generally tell as a teacher who's going to succeed in your class and be a joy to work with very early on by who's parents come to open house and who's parents respond to your desperate attempts at parental feedback throughout the year (most parents didn't respond but a lot of that was probably the kids refusing to show their parent/guardian any of the things I sent home).
I find that the root cause, something which is at the fundamental core of the problems in education in the US (which is all I can speak about because that's the limit of my experience) is bad parenting. The worst kids in all of my classes would have parents who would come defend them and storm up to the school when they made an F, screaming, "my baby didn't make an F, there's no way!" not realizing that while doing this they are completely destroying any view in the student's head of the teacher's legitimacy and authority. We had a girl who was failing several classes but she was on the school dance team. One day she had tests in 2 classes but she didn't show up to school. 1 hour from the end of the day, during the last class, her mom checks her in. The front desk administrator said it was too late to check the girl in and asked where she had been. She had been at the hair salon getting her hair done to look pretty for the night's football game which she would be dancing in. When the principal had to be called to tell this mother that her daughter couldn't dance that night because she had pretty much missed the whole school day and she had 2 tests that day, the mother was livid. She threatened to sue and threw all kind of mean-spirited and hurtful comments at the principal, administrators, and any teachers who happened to walk by. This woman was that upset about her daughter not dancing but had refused throughout the year to come to school to talk about her daughter's poor grades and other problems. When a kid in that situation sees her parent's attitude toward education, how do we expect that kid to really care at all about applying themselves/learning anything? It was an eye-opening experience for me.
After I graduated I looked around half-heartedly for some teaching jobs and I got a few offers but I didn't take any of them. I ended up working in a chemical plant doing quality control work and as boring as my job can be it's very comforting to know that I'm responsible for my own actions and not the actions of 100-something 14 year olds and their crazy parents. I love the idea of teaching but the reality is never that great. When it really works and it actually clicks between you and the students and you get to teach something you're passionate about and you see the little spark of interest and enthusiasm light up in their eyes it's a magical experience. The problem is that in the current state of education those experiences are few and far between. There are also a bunch of other things I didn't mention which ended up being serious factors for me not teaching such as the low pay, the fact that when you add up all the grading papers, lesson planning, and extra-curricular activities teaching comes out to about 70 hours per week of work with no overtime or incentives, and the low societal respect you get from people when you tell them you're a teacher. Sorry for going on and on about this topic but, as you can tell, it's something I'm passionate about but feel very mixed emotions on.
TL;DR- I'm a former student teacher and person who wanted to be a teacher for many years but student taught for a semester and realized how crazy teaching is. Everything this guy said in his article about parents is true and was even worse in my limited experience
4
u/lurkerwife May 29 '12
After I finished student teaching in November, I never want to teach. Ever. A lot of the reasons, if not all, are because of things you mentioned.
I didn't mind the paperwork, the grading, the planning or the promise of low pay. It's the parents. It's the administration. But, above all, it's the kids. Seeing kids who had been left behind, who got the shit knocked out of them by his/her girlfriend's mother's boyfriends, the sheltered kids affected by his/her helicopter parents. I knew they wouldn't be perfect, but some of them were just plain awful.
I feel stupid that I wasted the time. I'll go back for something else sometime, but I feel like my education was a sham. sigh
2
u/MrsChimpGod May 29 '12
I think the thing that you forgot and that the author of the original article forgot was that 'some parents' are not 'all parents'. Also, 'some teachers' are not 'all teachers'.
Sometimes it's good for parents to be involved in their child's education. Sometimes there are bad teachers.
Overgeneralizing that all parental involvement is bad helicopter parenting is just argumentative drama that does not solve the problem at all, especially when both you and the original author admit that parental involvement/partnership is important to the education process and you both admit that some teachers hate their jobs or are bad at it.
→ More replies (1)
10
u/gorillapoop May 29 '12
I think there is blame on both sides for this issue.
90% of my teachers throughout public middleschool and highschool were uninspiring, unmotivated, ignorant, and in some cases cruel.
My history teacher tried to tell me that Benjamin Franklin was a US President.
210
u/shoguning May 29 '12
Controversial opinion
Modern education (especially college, in terms of its expense) is the equivalent of 1984's 'floating fortresses', in the sense that it soaks up all of our extra productivity and keeps people at a lifetime of 'school or work'. As modern means of production increase efficiency, years in school has extended from 8 to 12, and is now stretching to 14-16 & beyond. You may argue that with an increasingly complex economy, more knowledge is required. I would assert that a modern 12-year education is comparable to an 8-year education in years past. Calculus and most practical learning (trades, accounting etc.) has been shifted onto post-secondary schools. The result is that about $10,000 is spent per year per student and let's not forget about the opportunity cost. (Mindfuck: taxpayers spent ~$120,000 to put you through school, was it worth it?)
Also, I think that sectioning off kids into buildings with ~1000 people their own age group is crazy. When in the history of the world has any civilization ever done this? And more to the point, when, in the rest of your life, will this experience be useful? The experience was, for me and many others, traumatizing and at a few points, humiliating. Not necessary, not helpful and expensive.
Also, the guaranteed success/snowflake/medals-for-showing-up culture is nurtured by schooling. "Wow! You filled in a worksheet.", "Wow! You graduated from high school, what an accomplishment."
My $0.02
194
May 29 '12
Also, I think that sectioning off kids into buildings with ~1000 people their own age group is crazy. When in the history of the world has any civilization ever done this?
Are you really arguing that because public education is relatively new that it is bad? Should we go back to when only the rich were educated by private tutors?
And more to the point, when, in the rest of your life, will this experience be useful?
The calculus I learned in high school I used in my high level maths in college which I use in my career. I don't see how you can say schooling wasn't useful. I don't think you could just cut 4 years off k-12 and send 14 year olds to college. Sure maybe we can cut a class here and there but to pretend that school is completely just a scam?
Not necessary, not helpful
I guess you got nothing out of it but I certainly did.
14
u/enfieldacademy May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12
Are you really arguing that because public education is relatively new that it is bad?
i don't think the OP is saying it is flat-out bad, just that there are problems with it, and some of those problems are probably due to the fact that human kids are not adjusted (by evolution) to living in the environment of a public school.
this does not sound unreasonable to me. many novel things humans have introduced which were not screened by our evolution have turned out to have some pretty damning unintended consequences (or problems associated with them).
examples include the advent of processed food, products which feed on our insecurities, products which suck up all our money but whose only value is to signal status, and so on.
Should we go back to when only the rich were educated by private tutors?
probably not, but maybe we don't have to go backwards and take education away to make the setting more natural - maybe we can make education to the masses more natural with the help of modern technology (that's what a lot of people are thinking anyway..). of course resources like the khan academy are already changing how some kids are getting their education, and arguably in a direction that is better for their health/happiness.
4
May 29 '12
I guess you got nothing out of it but I certainly did.
You get out what you put into it.
There will always be people who cut class to play WoW who will sit there and say "college was a waste of time, I didn't learn shit". Really? With an attitude like that it's no wonder you didn't learn anything.
→ More replies (49)38
u/shoguning May 29 '12
You're right, eventually my rant runs into reality, in the sense that I know that people actually running schools don't have the luxury of spitballing what is a leviathan of inefficiency. They have to deal with the system that exists and improve it incrementally rather than putting something brand new in.
That said, continuing my rant in hypothetical-land, I think that many, maybe even most 14 year-olds could be ready for college-level material. I think a lot of time in elementary & middle school is wasted covering & re-covering the same material and even doing things that have dubious educational value.
My problem isn't with public education, which I think is good, but with its tracking and compartmentalization of age groups and subjects. I think a mixed-age classroom of kids on something like kahn academy would probably be better than the traditional lecture format, but I'm not a teacher and don't claim that's anything other than an opinion.
Sure, you learned calculus in HS, but is that typical? The problem is with the extension of what should be an 8-year curriculum or shorter (3 Rs) to 12 years.
It's not that I got nothing out of my time in public schools, but with the number of years spent there, I don't think it's wrong to expect more results, or less years.
59
u/froderick May 29 '12
I think that many, maybe even most 14 year-olds could be ready for college-level material
Hahahahahahahahahahahaha.
....
Hahahahahahahahahahahaha.
I have to ask, do you have any experience in teaching at all? Have any kind of sustained interaction with 14 year olds (when you were already an adult)?
I'm not a teacher (yet), but I'm part of the way through my masters degree, and for my professional experience component, I was placed in a school which.. isn't bad, but isn't good either. It's average for the area, which is socio-economically "ok". I have been taking and instructing Year 9, Year 10 and Year 11 classes (14, 15 and 16 year olds). I've only been doing this for a few weeks, and I was initially blown away at just how small you need to break things into, the constant rephrasing and simplifying of things you need to do, the constant asking of questions to promote thinking, all just to get them even close to the right answer at times. Even with stuff which you could determine via simple logical deduction is often a struggle with people that young.
If you think most, or even just many 14-year-olds could be ready for college-level material, you are shockingly out of touch with reality.
→ More replies (23)→ More replies (19)20
u/uptightandpersonal May 29 '12
I agree that K12 education in incredibly inefficient since it's become so standardized, a complete cut and dry system where everyone must follow the mold. They account for this by letting students skip ahead in math (or even complete grades), and this seems to tackle a lot of the problems with the system. I think the biggest flaw is that K12 public schools do a really shitty job of teaching individual study habits. Let's face it, most kids probably won't remember all of the useless standardized facts they memorized in grade school. The real value of the standardized system is that it allows students to gradually progress through math, and it gives them time to read, which are arguably the two most important skills students need to learn in school (imo). If they have those, they can go off on their own and learn anything else that interests them. But public schools don't seem to encourage that extension beyond the classroom. The boring and tedious nature of K12 drives home the concept that learning is a chore, a 7 hour a day job that doesn't leave the classroom. This seems incredibly stupid to me since I've learned some of the most interesting things exploring books nad the internet on my own time, just trying to learn about various shit that I find vaguely intriguing. But I didn't develop this motivation to explore beyond my in-school curriculum until the latter part of high school, when I felt a pressing need to find some area of interest so I could pick a college major. My primary education did nothing to prepare me for personal research or independent education.
→ More replies (2)44
u/borderlinebadger May 29 '12
School is mostly a day care that keeps children occupied so parents can work until the children are ready to become workers. Them learning the occasional thing is just an added bonus.
→ More replies (11)28
u/Bearasaur May 29 '12
I work in education (assistant teacher, not formally educated).
I believe that what gives people meaning in life is work. If you're not fulfilling that need to work, you become unhappy. However, there's also what appears to be a constant drive to not work as well; you see this in people's desires for retirement or time off, in a child's love of school cancellation. But even when someone's not doing their mandated work, you notice that they begin to replace it with other kinds of work. People play video games because they give the brain the same pleasure that doing work does; things that a strict rationalist would consider "meaningless" are really just ways to convince your brain you're doing work. So I would argue that what appears to be an instinct to avoid work is really just an instinct to do different kinds of work, or perhaps to do work of your own volition. It's still a developing hypothesis.
Anyway, what I'm getting at is that school is a way to provide work for people to do. It does so in a direct sense for children and young adults; you go to school, and you work. However, it's also a way of priming people, making them able to work in society in a way they might not be able to without an education. Society is constantly changing, as are its labor needs. As factory work becomes largely mechanized, the need for unskilled labor decreases, and the need for educated technicians to operate and maintain the machines increases. Therefore, if someone receives no education, it will be harder for them to find an outlet for their subconscious desire to perform work, and they will be unsatisfied. That's why there's a need for an education system. I do wish that we could train kids to be auto mechanics or plumbers, and leave the science, management, etc to those who actually show talent in those fields; however, on a societal level the drive to work translates into a drive to advance, and advancement means we're going to need our workers to become more and more skilled with each generation.
That said, there are certainly problems with the way kids are being educated. Classes need to be smaller. Logic needs to be taught from Kindergarten. One of the major problems that I see is that many parents and teachers alike have no empathy for their kids. School becomes a very me-against-you issue for the child, despite the fact that kids learn better and work harder when thy feel that they're working with you. This guides my approach to teaching. I'm in a unique situation that I can play video games with my students; everyone enjoys it, and it makes it so that when we're in the classroom the student-teacher relationship is less "having to listen to me" and more "getting to learn from me." Along the same lines, if I make a mistake, I own up to it. If you cover your ass, it only reenforces the idea that they can never be as smart as the grown-ups and there's no sense in trying. I feel that more parents and teachers need to take the "we're on the same team" approach.
So anyway, that my $0.02.
9
u/shoguning May 29 '12
Interesting way of looking at it and I agree that work can provide meaning.
I think the structure imposed by schools tends to destroy whatever natural love of learning that kids might have. So although it does provide 'work', it can also be hurtful to them as learners.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (4)4
u/Chocobean May 29 '12
to do work of your own volition
I agree that people need work to survive. But it needs to be work of one's own volition. School is the antithesis of work in that sense, and champion of work in the slavery sense: you must attend, you must not doodle while listening, you must also work at home, you must do exactly what is assigned.
school is a way to provide work for people to do...priming people, making them able to work in society
That's exactly OP's point: school produces mindless worker-bees who never question "why" because they've had it beaten out of them. You just work. You always work. There will never be alternative to work you don't enjoy. There is no such thing as work that is enjoyable, because you have never had the time to discover such a thing on your own. The only alternative to slavery-work-given is "free time", called play, called useless time wasted, called a game, called escape from real life. You find that you enjoy this "free time" more than slave work. You are told that that is the incorrect attitude, report in the morning for more slave-work. You have no choice. Everyone works, for the greater good.
The truth is: not everyone needs to slave at an undesirable job to make a productive society. The truth is, managed, direct work, even professional level work, is undesirable. So a kid goes to school, earns his degree, and work as a [insert prestigious title]. He's still doing it because it pays the bills. He still feels cheated and undervalued and that he was meant to do more. But he has no recourse, and everyone tells him that's because you aren't doing enough, so go back to school and try harder.
→ More replies (2)5
u/smacksaw May 29 '12
Also, I think that sectioning off kids into buildings with ~1000 people their own age group is crazy. When in the history of the world has any civilization ever done this?
We just moved so our kid could go to a school with a few dozen kids. Out of the city and into the country.
24
u/2518899 May 29 '12
Well said. I don't think parents are the big problem in education. The biggest problem I have with parents is how complicit they are with the current system.
Schools and districts are too big, inefficient for the majority of students, and a huge waste of money.
And I say that as a public high school teacher. I think all kids should be educated, but trying to do so in the current system is a losing battle.
→ More replies (19)4
May 29 '12
While I agree with the sentiment, several of the examples given are pretty terrible. Like the son who hasn't started his assignments two weeks before school starts again. This might be a completely valid complaint about a lazy bum who doesn't do jack shit until forced to. Or this might be an actual case of family-horror in which the mother made the right call and didn't treat her son like some sort of object, or premature wageslave who has to learn his "value" in society is primarily gauged by adhering blindly to rules and regulations thrust on his shoulders by an indifferent higher power.
Look, I've not been an adult for THAT long (nearly 30) and I vividly remember my school years, and very often teachers fucked me over, not the other way around. I was a quiet, non-assuming kid who did what he was told, and that propensity to please ruined my late childhood. I repeatedly asked for help and got none, and I'm pretty sure at least some of my old teachers have discussed me and dismissed me as a lazy SOB who didn't even try.
I can't begin to tell how many times I slaved for 4-5 hours over a single math assignment because I was so terrible at it (later turned out to be dyscalculia, hurrah :-/), only to have the teacher scold and berate me in front of the class for "not doing my best" or worse, "not even trying".
Of course I did end up quitting... you can only hear it's your fault so many times before you actually start to believe it.
But in 11th form I was "saved" by a "rogue" math teacher who actually saw that I really tried and still failed... and with his help and patience I managed to pass my tests and graduate high school. Every single other teacher had just ascribed my issues to an attitude problem and didn't even care enough to see if it was something else. That one teacher changed the way I view life, and especially teachers.
My entire point being, teachers are NOT ALWAYS RIGHT, no matter how much they may wish it was so. And the ones who truly want to do their jobs, namely educating people, rather than just having them tick off boxes and copy something from a handbook, are unfortunately a minority. It pains me to say it, but practically every teacher I've ever known (and that's quite a lot, considering my SO is a teacher herself) is in it for the long holidays and other benefits; they don't give a fuck about the children.
That said, I definitely believe that a lot of parents make life insanely difficult for those few "good" teachers.
3
u/GruxKing May 29 '12
"Wow! You graduated from high school, what an accomplishment."
Hey don't bash high school graduating! It's all I've got!
leaves, sobbing, to go cuddle his diploma8
u/neutronicus May 29 '12
Yeah, I laughed at this:
For starters, we are educators, not nannies.
That's what you think. There's a reason public school happens at the same time as work, and it ain't 'cause kids want to be awake then.
→ More replies (4)6
u/istara May 29 '12
I would assert that a modern 12-year education is comparable to an 8-year education in years past. Calculus and most practical learning (trades, accounting etc.) has been shifted onto
I fully agree. You only have to look at old exam papers and textbooks to see how far things have fallen.
Also I love this:
Controversial opinion
It's a useful way to express: "please read my potentially controversial opinion before you downvote it to oblivion due to your poor reddiquette/lack of comprehension/lack of agreement" without getting downvoted-to-oblivion for expressing it.
A big upvote from me, anyway.
→ More replies (2)2
u/zorno May 29 '12
Also, the guaranteed success/snowflake/medals-for-showing-up culture is nurtured by schooling. "Wow! You filled in a worksheet.", "Wow! You graduated from high school, what an accomplishment."
So if a kid fails often at school, and they give him a medal for something silly, does it makehim spoiled, or give him some sort of positive feeling about school that he might not get any other day he goes there?
→ More replies (19)2
u/glass_canon May 29 '12
WOW! You filled out your TPS report! Gold star employee of the afternoon, go pick a prize out of the bucket in your supervisor's office!
4
u/Nevuhmindthat May 29 '12
Most head shaking moment as a former principal:
After numerous previous meetings where Johnny's poor behavior was discussed, multiple broken promises from him, time outs given, in house suspensions,a behavioral contract made and broken, multiple group meetings with teachers and administration sabotaged by Johnny, we finally decide to expel Johnny from our (private) school. His mom, knowing this has been coming for almost a year, suddenly goes ballistic and angrily accuses us of ganging up on her kid and being way too hard on him.
In a moment when she stopped to get her breath in the middle of her venomous tirade, bashing everyone from the teachers to the food in the cafeteria, I asked, "So, why is it that you enrolled Johnny in this school in the first place?"
"Because this school has a reputation for very good discipline."
hard forehead smack
We came to refer to this phenomenon as the Momma Bear complex. You can discipline a kid, but if Momma Bear feels threatened, look out - normally passive moms will attack and tear you limb from limb.
7
u/aidrocsid May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12
I can understand where he's coming from, but some of this is sort of bullshit. Teachers are not equivalent to doctors when it comes to childhood behavior, psychologists are. Teachers are not psychologists. Well, some of them may also be psychologists, but that's not what they've been hired to do. Teachers may deal with children a lot, but they're still laymen when it comes to childhood behavior. My second grade teacher, who herself had serious rage issues, convinced my parents to send me to a specific doctor who would diagnose me with ADHD and put me on ritalin. She says we should trust teachers to know what's going on in their classrooms, but what about when they don't? Should a parent's relationship with their child's teacher be better and more trustworthy than their relationship with their child? In the case of a kid who's an asshole and whose parents won't believe anything negative anyone tells them about the kid, okay, I can understand the frustration. How about the kid who's being bullied that the teacher doesn't know about but who only ever gets caught reacting to it, though? Many teachers may know their students very well, and understand their behavior, but many do not. For a parent to tell the difference between the two can be very difficult, especially if the kid portrays the teacher in a negative light.
Again, I really want to drive this home teachers are not psychologists, they do not have qualifications suggesting that they have special insight into their behavior and its motivations, that's why schools have councilors on hand (and even some of them are shit). Teachers are just as capable as being full of shit as anyone else. They are qualified to teach. They are not qualified to be some sort of domestic judge of what goes on outside the classroom. If I don't think it's psychologically healthy for my kid to have homework during his or her 2 months of unmitigated enjoyment of childhood, I'm going to tell him that he doesn't have to worry about it if he doesn't want to. Personally, I think it's kind of screwed up to give a kid work to do over their vacation. School does enough to suck the joy out of a young person's life with its institutional atmosphere and its oppressive crush of smelly, intolerant cretins. Many teachers seem to forget that they're dealing with children, or their ideas about children are a bit backward, and are inordinately harsh. Who wants to think about all that shit during the 2 months of free time with no obligations a person has for those few short years? And as far as including the kid in the conversation if you're standing in front of him having it, it would be disrespectful to do otherwise. You don't just talk about people who are standing right there as though they weren't, and you don't just take one person's word over another without question because they have some semblance of authority. That isn't a lesson I want to teach my kid. As far as holding back negative opinions, forget that. If I know somebody's a jerk, I'm going to tell my kid they're a jerk and they shouldn't worry that much about them. Why? Because if you're a jerk and you're messing with my kid I want to cushion the impact, not sharpen it. I'm not a parent, but I was a student, and I experienced a number of the reasons that one might not implicitly trust the word of the school system and its employees. There are shitty teachers that you shouldn't trust. Everybody lies; teachers and principles don't magically become superhuman truth machines, they have their own biases and agendas just like everyone else. You're not infallible just because you try to teach things to children.
3
u/brokenex May 29 '12
Psychologists are often so narrow in their examination of the world that their advice is riddled with practical problems, and they often fail to taken into an account the larger contexts of society and culture. I was at one point on track to enter academic psychology, but I found the field to be wholly malformed.
Psychologists, by their nature, focus on the problems within the individual, when most of the problems are of a systematic, cultural nature.
→ More replies (5)
3
u/Farfromthehood May 29 '12
I teach college and hear the same sort of complaints from the students, which goes to show the kids are just doing as they were taught: if you don't like a grade you earned: bitch about it.
Also, this article is from sept 2011....kinda old, no?
3
May 29 '12
I can understand this, but is it really because of the parents? Not the lack of teaching jobs or cutting of benefits?
3
u/4thstringer May 29 '12
I feel for the teachers and the administrators in this, but it is also clear that the permissive nature towards these parents creates this atmosphere. From the Article: "My mom just told me a child at a local school wrote on his face with a permanent marker. The teacher tried to get it off with a wash cloth, and it left a red mark on the side of his face. The parent called the media, and the teacher lost her job. My mom, my very own mother, said, "Can you believe that woman did that?" Well, that sounds like the administration did not stand up for the teacher at all. And most likely, neither did her fellow teachers. Administrators, if you will not stand up to these parents, your teachers will continue to leave. Teachers (and the teachers union), if you do not stand up for your fellow teachers, then be prepared for it to be you next on the chopping block. And parents, when you hear about another parent who is trying to get a teacher fired for something trivial, stand up for them. None of you are helpless victims, and your own cowardice feeds this problem.
2
2
May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12
That permanent marker example does sound like a reason for a parent to get angry. I've used washcloths my entire life, and I've never scrubbed so hard that it left a red mark for the amount of time it'd take for a kid to get from school to their home.
Edit: just read another comment about this. Apparently they used Clorox wipes and Mr. Clean Magic Erasers on the kid's face. Clearly this is the kind of person who should be trusted with the well being of children. How dare that parent call out that teacher before they could put furniture polish in the child's hair.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Banana223 May 29 '12
My mother has been a kindergarten teacher for 20 something years, and is retiring after this year. While these parents definitely exist, it's far less a problem than the administrative decisions caused by budget cuts. These parents have always existed. But when, in a grade level that requires constant supervision and a high adult:kid ratio, the school days have gotten longer (by hours), the class sizes have gotten bigger, and the number of hours a paid aide is present has decreased, that's a far, far bigger problem than annoying parents.
3
May 29 '12
My brother's girlfriend is a teacher. She just recently got hired on and in less than a week of being hired (and during the summer), a parent came in and ripped her ass for something that she had absolutely no control over. This is a common thing with parents. They just love to come in and yell at teachers. One problem is that teachers don't seem to have the right to yell back when the parent is clearly in the wrong.
9
u/WhatMakesYouTick May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12
While I found this article to point out one of the biggest issues facing education workers, which is the parent's determination to undermine their child's teachers' authority, I think it also misrepresented the effectiveness of some of those teachers.
For example, the author claims that good teachers usually hand out the lowest grades, while poor teachers are more lenient and thus grant higher grades. While this may be true to a certain extent, in my personal experience I have witnessed the opposite. The classes that my least favorite teachers taught often had unfair grading methods and I, as well as many of my classmates, suffered both in terms of knowledge acquired and grades received. They didn't seem to care about the kids and it showed. My favorite teachers by far were the ones instructing advanced placement courses, and through their powerful communication skills and sturdy educational foundation, they were able to dole out a reasonable distribution of grades.
I had an unusual time in school as I had several teachers complain to my parents as well as many others who praised my workmanship. Some of those criticisms were warranted, however, I believed plenty to be biased due to the teacher's own prejudices. When I felt this was the case, my parents (my mother being a teacher herself) usually heard out my case and eventually saw I was right. It is a must for parents to honestly talk with their children.
That being said, I do believe that a large percentage of parents with disruptive and/or lazy children are too quick to dismiss the advice of their teachers, and should instead (as is the case in all quarrels) listen attentively to both sides of the story and use logical judgement to come to a conclusion regarding their child's behavior and the best way to remedy the problem. Parents have got to realize that unruly conduct is a normal occurrence in children, however, instead of denying the possibility that their kid is in need of correctional measures, they should acknowledge the fact that their child will stay immature as long as their behavior is constantly supported by them. No child is "perfect," and it is silly to think they don't make bad decisions every once in a while, including in school. Straight-up leniency is simply not the answer. There has got to be discernment on the part of the parents.
7
May 29 '12
It is a must for parents to honestly talk with their children.
THIS. ONE THOUSAND TIMES.
When I was going through high school, I would witness parents blatantly ignoring their 15/16 year old children, treating them like idiots, and not passing on certain information to them. It was a policy in my school to hide our grades from us, and to only let our parents see them, leaving them to the choice of allowing us to see them (as my parents were fairly normal, they just gave me the report to look at and analyse myself).
This often made the kid behave worse, as they thought they could continue the childish behavior. Their parents stuck up for them, but they completely ignored them in the process.
It is a possibility that the parents may be over sensitive about it, because they are ether living vicariously through their children, or think that their grades reflect badly on them.
→ More replies (2)
5
May 29 '12
As a student that has been screwed over by shitty teachers who think they know what happened but either DON'T or saw part of a fight or what have you, and told my parents I did something to get me punished, I don't see the problem with asking a teacher to confirm what happened. It's like how in court you have to prove the guilt of a suspect.
I still remember how much I hate my 5th grade teacher, Miss Silva (not a wonder why she wasn't married, the woman was rechid). She made me AND MY MOTHER clean off some graffiti in the bathroom because it said "Alison". You'd think the awful cunt would know what the fuck my handwriting actually looked like, after all, she was my teacher. (my handwriting was obviously terrible, while the handwriting in the bathroom was bubbly, perfect, and well-practiced) My mother knew it wasn't me, but we cleaned it off anyway because it was easier than dealing with that awful pill. This was not the only incident that has lead me to not respect this woman. She was just bitter, even though she was attractive and only 26-30. I still remember how awful and impatient she was with the (diagnosed and medicated) ADHD children. That woman should not have been teaching. Put her behind a desk in a basement somewhere she doesn't have to deal with people.
6
u/Todamont May 29 '12
This is a terribly poorly-written article. Instead of explaining the causes of friction between parents and teachers, she makes on long plea to parents to understand teachers' plight. Well, I'm not a parent, so I'm instantly alienated and feel left out of the audience. Now I have to dig through the article to extract the meaning around pointless pleading that is non-topical. I give it an F for effort.
18
u/Axana May 29 '12
I was bullied by teachers from elementary school all the way through high school. My third-grade cunt of a teacher often mocked me in front of the class causing me to go home crying on more than one occasion. I still have insecurities about my appearance to this day thanks to the nasty comments she made about me back then. Additionally, my openly gay friends in high school were often treated very unfairly by the teachers. So when I read shit like this:
If we give you advice, don't fight it.
My gut reaction is, FUCK YOU. Teachers aren't all-knowing gods who can do no wrong. For every good teacher I had, I had two more who were unprofessional fuck-ups that made my childhood life hell. So I welcome the trend of parents telling their children's teachers to go to hell, and wish my own parents did the same when I was growing up. Teachers are just pissed that they can't get away with as much shit as they used to.
5
u/NoMoreNicksLeft May 29 '12
My gut reaction is, FUCK YOU. Teachers aren't all-knowing gods who can do no wrong.
But they are. Only evil republicans like yourself dare oppose their wondrous educational talent.
→ More replies (3)2
May 29 '12
i had good teachers i had bad teachers, I lived through all of them and then only time i did poorly in school was when it was my own fault
4
u/isthatagoodidea May 29 '12
I think (most) teachers do an terrific job. I don't know how they do it. Amazing. But to basically say 'listen to us...don't question us' is a wee bit wrong. A good friend of mine was told her son was slow because his spelling was terrible. He is now a doctor. Anecdotal I know, but I think it's great when a parent knows her/his child well enough to question a teacher. Of course, some parents do really need to listen to some advice as well.
→ More replies (1)
4
May 29 '12
Most of the teachers I've had interactions with over the years - even when I was a kid going to school - were various degrees of crazy, uninterested, hostile, or creepy. I can count the number of good teachers I've met on one hand.
If teachers are getting such hostility from parents, they might want to stop always blaming the parents and start taking a good hard look at themselves.
2
May 29 '12
Exactly this. I've had so many mean-spirited, control-hungry teachers over the years that I'm convinced that the majority of teachers don't care about education as much as they care about having authority. I was actually a really quiet kid, but constantly found myself being picked on by teachers. I can't imagine how shitty my experience going through school would have been if my mom didn't stick up for me and just went blindly with whatever the teacher said instead. I probably would have killed myself by middle school to be honest.
5
u/xSleyah May 29 '12
In middle school, a teacher accused me of plagiarizing something that I hadn't. My mother and I had a conference with her over it, but she refused to believe I had actually come up with it on my own, despite her apparent lack of proof. My mom came in again to speak with the principal, and they really made it difficult for her to get an appointment. I seriously think they saw a black woman come in and thought, "Oh God, she's going to come in here and curse us out." The unfortunate thing is I bet it's happened before, and there was probably some justified reasoning behind it.
→ More replies (1)
12
u/fish619407 May 29 '12
Civility has declined rapidly over the past couple of decades.
37
May 29 '12
Every generation thinks this. Watch 'Tokyo Story', a classic from 1953 that explores this: its themes feel just as relevant today, which is amazing given how it feels like a completely different era.
23
u/Thermogenic May 29 '12
"What is happening to our young people? They disrespect their elders, they disobey their parents. They ignore the law. They riot in the streets inflamed with wild notions. Their morals are decaying. What is to become of them?"
-- Plato
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (8)17
2
u/Markymark36 May 29 '12
My mom teaches and I hear the wildest stories about asshole kids and their dick parents. It's ridiculous how rude they all are. If your kid is a lazy good-for-nothing, it's not the teachers fault
2
2
u/psiphre May 29 '12
how is it that a teacher can lose their job for leaving a red mark on a child's face after trying to wash off marker, but teachers that verbally, emotionally or even physically abuse their students get to keep theirs? something's fishy.
→ More replies (2)3
May 29 '12
The difference is the presence of a helicopter parent.
Like it or not, a helicopter parents gets shit done.
2
May 29 '12
I would love to see a private school where the parents, not the students, are interviewed and this kind of behaviour is discouraged. I feel like that would really attract a lot of good, earnest teachers and result in a considerably richer and better experience for kids.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/thankfuljosh May 29 '12
I have a lot of teacher friends, and wife was a teacher for 8 years.
The issue is usually the behavior of kids and lack of respect and lack of work ethic, all of which impacts the classroom and kids every minute. This is, of course, the parent's fault. These things are much more important than the annoyance of parents engaging (or not engaging) the teacher every few weeks.
2
u/hotmonotremeaction May 29 '12
I teach health at the middle and high school level. There are some bad parents. Parents who'll deny their child did what you just saw them do, who'll blame you if you're not the total pushover they are. Most, though, just aren't present. Parent teacher conferences are a joke. District wide mailings/emailings for helpful workshops on student time management and anti-bullying resources go out to >3,000 parents/guardians and ~20 show up. Calling home is pointless, I rarely even reach an adult.
This next year will be my last teaching. More and more the blame is being put on teachers. Why aren't teachers helping raise scores, doing more to address bullying, etc. Doing more? I work 10 hour days, volunteer my time elsewhere to educate inmates, and offer workshops to parents. Don't ask me to do more if I can't get you to do the bare minimum. It's called showing up to your child's shit, answering the phone when I call, taking a basic interest in your spawn's education, and taking some personal accountability. Do that, then ask me what more I can do.
And to be fair, there really are some bad teachers. It's a quick burnout profession, some teachers have been there for only five years and should already have quit. Administration doesn't really have the power to do much, and in my experience doesn't really want to do much. That doesn't mean the blame falls everywhere equally.
2
May 29 '12 edited May 29 '12
Teachers I know hate teaching because of retarded polices pushed by the administrators, not because of the parents.
2
u/thestonedonkey May 29 '12
While I understand parents and kids can be tremendously difficult to deal with, I have news for them, once they enter any other job in the workforce they are bound to meet some of the same parents.. and they are just a big a pain in the ass there.
Good luck I say to them though.
2
u/AdonisChrist May 29 '12
Hm.
I wonder if the government would like to pay for a master's in education.
Because I can handle parents.
2
May 29 '12
My father has been a teacher for 28 years. He gets all the problem kids because the other teachers don't want them. The worst a kid has done was egg our house, poorly. Parents? We've had abusive phone calls, threats, and a few times physical altercations. Parents are fucking idiots.
2
u/Anomaline May 29 '12
Definitely not contributing is the fact that teachers are overworked, underpaid, and generally extremely replaceable due to the overabundance of education majors, with the exception of some specialized science teachers.
I agree that a lot of parents are idiots, but blaming them entirely for making teachers' lives difficult is childish and thoroughly oversimplifies the issue.
2
u/junkit33 May 29 '12
Radical idea - eliminate grades from schools. Just go to a pass/fail system.
It seems like many of the problems stem from the intense pressure for these kids to be flawless students and get into top colleges. Parents bring lawyers into meetings to protect their kids 'resume'. Parents try to squeak out the extra few points on a test because they understand the difference between Harvard and State U is sometimes that one B+ in 10th grade.
These issues did not exist in the past because college was never this competitive.
Colleges don't need high school grades - they're all over-inflated anyway, and comparing one school to another is full of flaws. They can just start relying more on SAT scores, admissions essays, etc.
Basically the system needs a reset back to focusing on learning and away from a focus on the bottom line.
2
u/kinokonoko May 29 '12
No, they are just not being paid enough to work with the parents to involve them with their children's education.
2
u/Lmkt May 29 '12
I call bullshit on that teacher fired over removing black marker story. But if it's indeed true... Then you seriously have to sort your fucking shit out, America.
2
u/Aiyon May 29 '12
a child at a local school wrote on his face with a permanent marker. The teacher tried to get it off with a wash cloth, and it left a red mark on the side of his face. The parent called the media, and the teacher lost her job.
That's not just bad parents. That's bad parents coupled with a corrupt media who would lose someone their job for no reason whatsoever.
Who is so blind as to do something like that? Surely they didn't go straight to the media without saying something...
2
u/Vandimar May 29 '12
Sensationalist Headlines.
The article was correct about parents being out of control, but teachers are not leaving in record droves, that is absurd.
2
u/purplearmored May 29 '12
Meh. While teachers do need to be paid better and do need more respect, I saw a lot of contempt from faculty as well. I'm sure the school would label my family as problem parents because they actually questioned why my little brother was being treated so harshly by his teachers. I mean, it's been proven that black boys get disproportionately harsh punishments for the same problems. Once he got to a Catholic school where there was a different teaching philosophy, the problems disappeared completely.
Also, most of my teachers loved me, but again my parents would probably be labeled 'helicopter' or problem parents when they fought the middle school over my being tracked into a lower level English class when I'd been scoring 99th percentile on every exam and had been in the ' gifted ' class in elementary school.
Parents of minority children, children with special needs and children who have been bullied need to be on extra alert, because the school system is notorious for casting children like this aside. I don't advocate bitching out teachers, but surely teachers have to be aware of this environment.
2
u/asljkdfhg May 29 '12
It is severely embarrassing when a parent emails a teacher about how to get better grades. My dad sent two emails so far on how to go from a B+ to an A. These were both honors classes, and aside from participation(which I lost 5 points on and I think that's really stupid, considering participation should only occur when you have something meaningful to say but nonetheless), I feel I deserved those points. Those were honors classes, and both my weaker subjects(English and History), so I felt I deserved those grades. I made sure to apologize for my dad on both occasions, because a grade is between the student and the teacher, not a parent. Even if I feel I got an unfair grade, I make sure to tell my dad that I'll handle it so he doesn't interfere. No teacher deserves that.
2
u/SurferGurl May 29 '12
from the article:
And if you really want to help your children be successful, stop making excuses for them. I was talking with a parent and her son about his summer reading assignments. He told me he hadn't started, and I let him know I was extremely disappointed because school starts in two weeks.
His mother chimed in and told me that it had been a horrible summer for them because of family issues they'd been through in July. I said I was so sorry, but I couldn't help but point out that the assignments were given in May. She quickly added that she was allowing her child some "fun time" during the summer before getting back to work in July and that it wasn't his fault the work wasn't complete.
Can you feel my pain?
Some parents will make excuses regardless of the situation, and they are raising children who will grow into adults who turn toward excuses and do not create a strong work ethic. If you don't want your child to end up 25 and jobless, sitting on your couch eating potato chips, then stop making excuses for why they aren't succeeding. Instead, focus on finding solutions.
hmmmm...
reading assignments when school's not in session, rather than a "recommended reading list"? since when? and why do reading assignments over summer break take precedence over "family issues," or anything else?
no, i don't feel the author's pain.
and, in this economy, a strong work ethic doesn't necessarily equate to having a job.
4
May 29 '12
I don't think the issue is necessarily parents, here.
Back in "the day", women and blacks were just getting rights. They had to fight for their education and they had to fight hard. Many became very educated, had very advanced degrees... But nowhere to go because nobody "up high" would hire them. So what did they do for a living? Teach.
So we have teachers who are literally the experts in their field(s) teaching kids. And we had some "golden years" to come. But once the jobs opened up and the talented/educated were given better opportunities, they left for greener pastures.
Nowadays, the only people who become teachers are people who failed at everything else, or really just wanted to be a teacher as some sort of goal. When I was a kid, the saying was rampant: "Those who fail, teach."
I don't know if this is necessarily true or not, but it does say something pretty terrible about our culture as a whole and how it treats education. Why would we think the failures should teach our kids? Why don't we want to give them the best?
→ More replies (2)3
May 29 '12
My university had an incredible College of Education and teacher-training program. In my state, teaching positions are generally very low pay and also highly sought after at the same time. Students work through a vigorous program and complete a huge deal of classroom training for what is generally a thankless job where parents repeat that same old "Those who fail, teach" mantra and question everything they do. Many of the education students I knew ended up teaching overseas because of the many, many reasons being a teacher in the US sucks so much.
My mom was a teacher for I believe 7 years. She had a BS in education and was halfway done with her master's. She made 34,000 a year at the end of that 7-year period, in spite of her education and the ridiculous amount of training (she spent 4 years in college as an adult, then 2 more years working on her Master's and substituting/completing professional training programs). Even then, the rude/disrespectful/totally disinterested parents and the administration that only cared about test scores burned her out. She taught in an incredibly economically depressed area and could have moved to any school she wanted to, but she taught at that school because she loved kids and wanted to inspire them, help them learn. This system just chews up well meaning teachers and spits them back out again. So many people have no idea how challenging teaching actually is and I wish more people respected the profession.
3
May 29 '12
The thing is, immigrant parents tend to blame the kid for bad grades, and nonimmigrant parents tend to blame the teacher.. that's how that fat spoiled kid meme gets started, yo.
2
u/Ashweee May 29 '12
My parents never defended me against teachers, having said that, I only had problems with unfair ones. I went to school for a year to become a teacher, the college I went to couldn't get their shit straight, I realized, why the hell do I want to teach in an environment where I have absolutely no control, especially within the public school system, I highly disagree with how school has become nothing but daycare for older kids and religion still prevails in Biology class, (that might just have to do with living in South Carolina). But overall I just realized how messed up our schooling is. Sometimes I feel like learnt nothing in high school and often find myself reading things that contradict what I was taught, particularly when it comes to history.
2
May 29 '12
I TA'd at university so I got the aftermath of those helicopter parents. Those kids didn't make it. They failed out, or coasted along until the money ran out. The whined and complained and bitched when I failed their horrible papers and tests. At university the professors won't change your mark because Mom calls. Every year some one's parents would call to complain. Or the student would whine because they worked really hard despite those drunken FB pictures of the party the night before. Those special snowflakes were everywhere, probably a third of the class.
You know who had good parents? We have a very large middle eastern community that lives here and attended the school I taught at. Those kids had good parents. They focused on education and schooling. They had a great work ethic and good grades. Every kid was awesome and I taught hundreds of kids. Not all had fantastic marks but they didn't complain and they consistently put the effort in.
Then you'd have a guy like Josh who came back from Afghanistan, had a 3.9, never a complaint. Just wanted to get his degree and start his new life.
2
u/MagiesNoms May 29 '12
Articles like this annoy me. There are good parents, there are bad parents, just like there are good teachers and bad teachers. I would think that a parent that just doesn't care, and never contacts the teacher would be a lot less invested in their child's education.
Once my 6-year-old son was sent to the principal's office. I asked why, and they said he was yelling "STOP IT" in class. I asked why he was yelling "stop it" and they said they didn't know.
When I showed up, I asked him about it, and he said it was because the girl across the table from him kept taking his pencil. I asked the teacher if she told the girl to stop taking his pencil and she said she didn't know anything about it. The thing is, how do you hear a child saying "STOP IT" and not think to yourself, what is being done to the child that they want stopped?
So I talked to my son about it after school, and explained to him that if someone takes his pencil in the future, he needs to inform the teacher instead of yelling. But still, this could have all easily been handled in the classroom. Why was my son sent to the principal's office over something so silly? Why is it the teacher couldn't have handled the situation herself? If I hadn't been an advocate for my son and gotten to the reason he shouted, no one else would have.
I'm sure my son will have good teachers some years, and bad teachers other years, and I think teachers should expect that some years they'll have good parents/students and bad parents/students. My dad was a teacher for just a couple years before he became a chemist, because he found out he didn't actually like dealing with people that much. Perhaps it's best that teachers who don't like their jobs move into a different career.
2
May 29 '12
there is all the flip side to this, teachers that dislike/given up on students and purposely accuse and attack a student
and when the parent goes along with that, instead of this approach, its even worse
we need to find a middle ground.
1
u/canadas May 29 '12
This might be the closest to perfect post to ask this, I have been wondering ever since I got detention i dont know how many years ago for playing in a snow bank:
Teachers: why can't kids play tag (or just in general physical contact type stuff). Is it the "education system" saying its not acceptable, influence from parents, legal concerns (and if so is this due to crazy parents?), or other?
2
u/warboy May 29 '12
Legal stuff. Same reason PE is nerfed to hell.
Administrators currently have no balls.
1
u/MrXBob May 29 '12
My 8 year old cousin has moved schools twice because my aunt believes everything she says.
We all see that it's my cousin who is the brat, she wants to be the centre of attention and if she doesn't have her way she makes things difficult for those around her.
And every time my aunt gets called into school to discuss these problems, she blames it on the other kids. She believes her lies, even that the teachers "pick on her".
She's one of these very deluded parents that won't hear a bad thing said about her child. And my cousin is going to be the biggest bitch in the world when she's older, thanks to her mother being this way. Teaching her it's ok to be a brat and she can get anything she wants. I cannot wait for her to become a teenager, go to a 'real' school and then see how she reacts.
→ More replies (1)
1
May 29 '12
Teaching in China, same shit here. I don't teach kids simply because I've had two very big arguments with parents and I don't want to deal with them ever again.
1
u/Hurkleby May 29 '12
This is exactly why my sister left the teaching profession after just 3 years. She worked in a private school and every parent thought they were entitled to have a child with straight A's. Any low grades and behavioral concerns were immediately taken to the school administrators. Being a private school administration would side with the parents, EVERYTIME. Parents would just complain about all the private school tuition that they were paying. These parents didn't want an education for their children, they just wanted a nanny who would somehow magic them into a good college. What good does it do you to go to a good college when you can't even make your way through the middle school years?
1
1
u/vitaminmary May 29 '12
My nephew has the same teacher I had in 6th grade. My sister constantly complains about her and how terrible she is. Now, mind you, my nephew can be a handful due to some tough home circumstances, but he's a good kid. I couldn't believe this teacher was so awful years later. Fast forward, my mom chaperoned a field trip with him and sat on the bus with said teacher. The teacher discussed with her how parents had changed, how she was looking forward to retirement, just how crazy things had become. It made me happy to know she hadn't become some mean tyrant, but I think rather my sister is one of those annoying ass parents.
1
u/MendedSlinky May 29 '12
And please, be a partner instead of a prosecutor. I had a child cheat on a test, and his parents threatened to call a lawyer because I was labeling him a criminal. I know that sounds crazy, but principals all across the country are telling me that more and more lawyers are accompanying parents for school meetings dealing with their children.
That is so true. In Southlake Texas (neighbors my city) if a teacher requested a meeting with a parent in regards to their child, there was a 90% chance that the parent would bring a lawyer.
→ More replies (1)
1
May 29 '12
I read this:
My mom just told me a child at a local school wrote on his face with a permanent marker. The teacher tried to get it off with a wash cloth, and it left a red mark on the side of his face. The parent called the media, and the teacher lost her job. My mom, my very own mother, said, "Can you believe that woman did that?"
And thought it explained this story. You see, people (and schools) risk getting in trouble when they try to help. It's safer to do nothing in our crazy culture.
1
u/CaptZ May 29 '12
My ex does the "helicopter" to both our children. I keep telling her kids are kids and they will get in trouble at times but she always backs them up to no end. Kids feel like they deserve so much these days and don't want to work for anything. It's a sad generation that will be taking care of the world once I am out of the workforce. I only hope I don't survive to see it. Idiocracy is where we are headed.
1
u/throwawaysmoker May 29 '12
As a person who had responsible parents, but is "25 and jobless", I wanted to cry.
1
u/mike_chary May 29 '12
Nowhere is the politics so petty as in academia (or cul-de-sacs) because nowhere else are the stakes so small. Oh, the stakes are usually small? But, that means most of these machinations are petty.
348
u/iffraz May 29 '12
There was an email list serve at my high school to which all parent, student and teacher could participate in. A huge debate started about cutting down a tree where certain students would all gather and smoke during lunch (we had open lunch and would go all over the neighborhood to the malls and squares in the area). It was interesting as first, students weren't supposed to smoke on campus anyways as it was a "drug-free" zone, but then all they had to do was take two steps and they were on Giant's property. So it wouldn't have made a difference anyways. But we, living in a rich area, had a multitude of very snobby, overprotective, stuck up parents who felt very entailed to their offsprings lives as well as how the school should work for their kid. But I digress, it ended up spiraling into a heated debate between the insane mothers and the administration and teachers all the way up until a certain mother sent very nasty emails questioning certain teacher's credentials and their "legitimacy" as an educator and a parent. It got so bad that it only ended when a student (a writer for the school newspaper) finally chimed in, calling the parents immature, disrespectful and ridulously delusional. It stopped that day. The paper even did a satirical article about this entitled "Argument over cupcake colors ends after a mature 125 email debate."