r/tolkienbooks • • Dec 26 '25 Diamonds are Forever Obsessed Hooray WOW Sad Heartwarming Bravo

FINAL UPDATE: Try not to make fun of me. I bought my boyfriend a gift and epically failed.

Thumbnail
gallery
23.2k Upvotes

ORIGINAL POST.

UPDATE POST.

Many of you requested a final update after my boyfriend opened his Christmas gifts, and here it is. But bear with me: if you’re not already aware, brevity is not a strength I possess. 

Initially, I wasn’t sure what order to gift the books that u/overhillunderhill so generously sent. I thought it might feel repetitive to open Tolkien after Tolkien, back to back, so I staggered them between the other gifts I had gotten him. Each time he got to a Tolkien, he was fascinated and in shock. There were multiple books he hadn’t even been aware existed. Once he opened a few gifts, he asked if we had gotten to any of the “Reddit lore” yet, and I repeatedly pled the 5th. I wanted his suspicion to grow organically, and it did. He commented that he was astounded by how much money he thought I’d spent, as he knew I couldn’t afford any of that, and worried I had poured all of the purchases onto a credit card.

I decided the 2nd to last gift would be the print signed by Andy Serkis. I knew then, for sure, he’d know a gift like that, and thus the overall theme wasn't accomplished alone. He had already been speechless and in awe over the other books, but the print just baffled him. He asked how I could’ve pulled something like that off. That’s when I confessed I couldn't have done this alone, and that u/overhillunderhill sent the print, and all the Tolkien books he had opened until that point.

Lastly, I had him open my original gift, the 1973 Ballantine set. I shared in detail how I had come across it, and how devastated I initially was when I thought his gift was damaged and incomplete, and how much encouragement I received from Reddit to gift it anyway. Tucked underneath the set was what I framed as the book that truly started it all, which was the missing book in the set, The Hobbit.

I admittedly lost it a bit when sharing how I felt about how these books came into my possession. This has all meant so much to me. He choked up as well, especially reading u/overhillunderhill’s comment on my update post, and numerous other comments from other Redditors thereafter. 

Alright. I guess truly last, I gave him a little box of printed QR codes that linked to the multiple posts that have led up to this point. He saw that my prior update hit 14k upvotes, and we both laughed at the absurdity & kindness of it.

He’s so moved by the reception this saga has received. He also expressed that if any community would show up in droves with kindness, integrity, and support, it would of course, be the Tolkien community. Your collective moral compass and generosity are unparalleled. You are all gems. 

He hasn’t gotten through even a fraction of the comments as of yet, and has his work cut out for him over the next couple of days. He’s read some of his favorites so far out loud to me, and it’s clear how much all of you impacted him.

We both genuinely loathe being in front of the camera, so just know we did our best to rally beyond our anxious tendencies to post a photo of us for y’all.

MERRY CHRISTMAS, EVERYONE! And u/overhillunderhill, please brace yourself for even more of a flood of gratitude from him and I, and honestly, if we’re lucky, my boyfriend and I would love a private Q&A from you. We have so many questions, comments, and accolades we're tempted to inundate you with. 

TL;DR: I bought my boyfriend a vintage Tolkien set for Christmas that I later realized appeared damaged and was missing a copy of The Hobbit. I felt foolish, since I'm completely broke and wasted what little money I had. I posted asking for advice. A Redditor said he'd send the missing book for free. Wouldn't even let me pay shipping. To my surprise, he also sent all of the other books included in the photos, as well as a print signed by Andy Serkis. Not knowing what was in it, I opened the package he sent and started sobbing, because u/overhillunderhill's generosity not only saved my Christmas, but basically guaranteed it would be an unforgettable one. My boyfriend finally opened his gifts today, and long story short, it blew his goddamn mind.

EDIT: Forgot to mention, another Redditor is sending two more books if you can believe it. And they're legendary, too. They should arrive this weekend.


r/tolkienbooks • • Dec 20 '25 Diamonds are Forever All Seeing Upvote Wholesome Seal Helpful WOW Heartwarming Bravo

UPDATE: Try not to make fun of me. I bought my boyfriend a gift and epically failed.

Thumbnail
gallery
16.5k Upvotes

ORIGINAL POST HERE.

I made a post awhile back sharing that I’d epically failed after taking a risk and buying my boyfriend a Tolkien book set for Christmas at a vintage shop without being able to do research on it first. With my luck, I discovered later that not only were the edges of the pages well beyond the usual shade of vintage book yellow, but worse, the set was also missing The Hobbit. 

Well… the plot has since massively thickened, and the story gave way to a crescendo I was not expecting. I’ve got updates for you, the first 2 nowhere near as thrilling as the 3rd:

  1. Most of you commented on my original post, saying that my set was never meant to include The Hobbit, even though my slip case listed it. And man, I’ll hand it to you — some of you had me properly doubting myself for a moment, thinking “wow, maybe I didn’t make much of a blunder after all?!” Then, multiple Redditors commented saying they had the same set when it was brand new or nearly new, and all 4 books did in fact originally come with, and fit in that case. That is, apparently, only until you open/read the books. Once read, they’d expand and become difficult to get back into the case without damaging it. Hearing that, it doesn’t surprise me at all that so many of you own a set that only includes the trilogy. If all 4 couldn’t fit, The Hobbit is unfortunately the perfect book to detach from the set.

  2. Regarding the chain-smoker-esque yellow hue of page edges: To those who said that the pages weren’t far off from how vintage books simply age over time... I think if you could see them in person, you’d get my initial panic. I’ve loved old books my whole life and had never seen pages that yellow before unless there was damage present. I still figured there was something wrong until multiple Redditors commented that even when the set was brand new, the edges of the pages were originally printed with color-stained yellow edges! That makes infinitely more sense.

  3. Again, those two things and posting a few more photos of the set I originally purchased are not remotely the reason I’m even posting this update: it’s to share how this whole saga reached some unexpected heights. A Redditor read my original post about how much my boyfriend reveres Tolkien’s work, as well as how, despite my good intentions, my foolish optimism led to both Christmas gift misfortune and a financial setback, particularly due to my meager barista salary. In response, this Redditor sent me not only the missing copy of The Hobbit that belongs to the 1973 set I purchased, but also some truly incredible items I could've never dreamed of being able to gift my boyfriend. For free. He would not even allow me to pay shipping. I'm not often one to shed happy tears, but without knowing the contents of what he had even planned to send in the first place, other than The Hobbit, I opened the boxes this Redditor sent me… and I sobbed. Any photos I included in my post today, aside from the 1973 trilogy and its slip case, are what he sent to me.

I've already thanked him profusely in a DM, but I want to again, thank u/overhillunderhill. Your generosity has truly left me in awe, and the words to properly thank you have continuously failed me. I would've been thrilled even to have been given The Hobbit, but all of the other books you gifted are absolutely incredible, and will be deeply cherished by my boyfriend. The print signed by Andy Serkis might genuinely break his brain. It broke mine.

I also wanted to thank the rest of you for responding to my original post and encouraging me to gift the set to my boyfriend despite its flaws. I appreciate the helpful information, plot twists, generosity, laughter, and even the asshole comments (because it truly wouldn’t have been Reddit without them). 

I can't even fathom what my boyfriend's reaction will be on Christmas Day. He’ll know immediately by the sheer number of presents under the tree that I wouldn’t have had enough money to purchase all those things for him. He has no idea what the nature of his gifts is; he just knows there's tons of lore involved, and extra gifts as a result. I at least had to spoil the fact that the Reddit community came together for him for Christmas, simply because I didn’t want him stumbling on any of my posts by accident. So the poor man agreed to stay off Reddit until Christmas.

I was feeling down about Christmas this year because I could afford so little for my boyfriend, but now I’m genuinely excited. I CAN’T WAIT for him to open his gifts… and to send him a link to the original post so he can read this entire saga for himself.

Merry Christmas, everyone!!! 

[EDIT] TL;DR: I bought my boyfriend a vintage Tolkien set for Christmas that I later realized appeared damaged, and was missing a copy of The Hobbit. I felt foolish, since I'm completely broke and wasted what little money I had. I posted asking for advice. A redditor said he'd send the missing book for free. Wouldn't even let me pay shipping. To my surprise, he also sent all of the other books included in the photos, as well as a print signed by Andy Serkis. Not knowing what was in it, I opened the package he sent and started sobbing, because u/overhillunderhill's generosity not only saved my Christmas, but basically guaranteed it would be an unforgettable one.


r/tolkienbooks • • Jan 09 '25

I painted the edges of a LOTR set!

Thumbnail
gallery
2.9k Upvotes

These were really fun to paint! Made for a birthday present.


r/tolkienbooks • • Dec 08 '25 Heartwarming

Try not to make fun of me. I bought my boyfriend a gift and epically failed.

Thumbnail
gallery
2.2k Upvotes

I kind of deserve to be made fun of for this, but hear me out... I am not particularly a Tolkien fan. Not because his work isn't absolutely legendary, and deserves all of the reverence that it gets. It's simply because I'm not much of a fan of fantasy novels. However, my boyfriend deeply loves Tolkien's work, and I love that for him. And the man is such a gem that I want to spoil him rotten.

Anyhow, I was at a vintage store, and I came across this book set, which I had never seen before at any other used bookstore. I was nervous about the purchase and wanted to research it better before going through the checkout line, but of course, just my luck: I had no cell service in this small town. I even tried walking two blocks away from this vintage store, praying a cell signal would make itself known and save my life. No luck.

So I decided to just be a brave girl and purchase it. Mind you, at the store, this book set is saran-wrapped. I was not allowed to open it and get a closer look at the books before purchasing.

I get it home, and immediately feel devastated upon discovering the pages are as yellow as an agoraphobic chain smoker's walls. I thought it couldn't get worse.

UNTIL, to humiliate myself further, once I finally regain cell service, I Google it and discover that the set is missing a goddamn book. I am so completely, entirely, deeply embarrassed and ashamed for not knowing any better. I literally cried.

And no, the vintage store did not accept returns.

I don't have enough money to repurchase the correct set for him. I spent $50 at the vintage store, and even that was already getting outside of the budget I have on my pathetic barista salary at the moment. But god, one of my absolute favorite things about my boyfriend is how much he loves to read, and how much he cares for his books. He doesn't dog-ear pages, he carefully mends any tears, meticulously organizes them on his shelves. I was really, really hoping to knock one out of the park with this one, and instead I wasted my money and embarrassed myself. I told him I bought him a gift that ended up being a fail, and I vowed to never tell him what it was, and I mean that.

That being said... would it be a crime against Tolkien if I repurposed this book set into some sort of art piece? I do collage work, and I've been brainstorming some ways I could use excerpts of the text and/or the covers to make something for him in the future. Should I just sell it for pennies? Should I just burn it? Put it on a street corner for free? I'm kidding about that, but truly, the pages are a traumatizing shade of yellow, and although my boyfriend would not expect perfection out of a vintage set, even for my taste, the damage and missing book is too severe to gift to him.

I feel SO DUMB, but because the "shell" that the books came in didn't look like they had much wiggle room, I would've never thought a book was missing. I can barely fit my thumb in between the books and the shell, so it just didn't dawn on me that The Hobbit should have been there.

TL;DR: Bought my boyfriend a vintage Tolkien set. Was unable to get a good look at it before purchasing, only to discover super yellow pages, and humiliated myself into oblivion when realizing that The Hobbit should've been included. Wtf do I do with it now?

EDIT: Good heavens, thank you so much for your responses, everyone!!! I did not expect to get unanimous encouragement to give it to him. This has totally made my day. Despite its imperfections, I'm so excited to gift it to him after all!

Thank you to the redditors who confirmed that the set I got actually should not have come with The Hobbit after all! Right after I brought it home, I searched eBay, and saw a vintage set in a red box did come with it, so I assumed mine should've as well... but I just revisited eBay and saw a few red box sets that don't have The Hobbit included.

Also, thank you to the redditors who confirmed that when this particular set was brand new, the edges of the pages were intentionally color-stained yellow. Because although I have quite a few old books myself that have pages that have yellowed due to age, these pages seemed to be an unnatural shade of yellow, so the color stain makes so much sense!

Christmas is saved, y'all!


r/tolkienbooks • • Dec 10 '25

Found today at a thrift for 5$!

Thumbnail
gallery
2.1k Upvotes

Someone linked me to here from r/bookcollecting and I thought I'd share my newest find. I was at a used bookstore with a friend just celebrating my college graduation and it looked so cool I couldn’t pass it up. It was only 5 dollars and I'm so happy with it!

It also has a typo on the cover in elvish in the right bottom corner that I guess got corrected in later versions one of my friends in another state has a much newer version and hers doesnt have the typo, how neat! Itll be a lovely addition to my fledgling collection


r/tolkienbooks • • Jan 03 '26 Hooray

My sister made these by hand for me for Christmas. Only got to open them today. I have tears in my eyes.

Thumbnail
gallery
1.7k Upvotes

r/tolkienbooks • • Dec 13 '24 Bless Up Take My Silver Heart of Silver

Tolkien Collection

Thumbnail
gallery
1.4k Upvotes

Updated with a few new editions.


r/tolkienbooks • • Apr 12 '25

My Tolkien Collection (~600 books) 15+ years in the making

Thumbnail
gallery
1.4k Upvotes

r/tolkienbooks • • Aug 07 '25

Does anyone know if this is rare?

Thumbnail
gallery
1.4k Upvotes

r/tolkienbooks • • Nov 03 '25

I think I’m done 😂

Thumbnail
gallery
1.3k Upvotes

I think I’m done collecting now 😂

Still need to find a black spine paperback The Lord of the Rings - A Reader’s Companion. Might take some time as it seems a bit uncommon.

90% of it collected over the last three years, but started 24 years ago after seeing the first movie.


r/tolkienbooks • • Mar 09 '25

For $2 at an estate sale, I picked up a 1977 first printing hardcover copy of The Silmarillion

Thumbnail
gallery
1.1k Upvotes

Not much info about it online. Think it often gets confused with the 1978 BCA version.


r/tolkienbooks • • Aug 23 '26

Walking through a charity bookshop and found these!

Thumbnail
gallery
882 Upvotes

Went for a wander through a local charity bookshop and found this set for only $30

Have no idea if they're worth more than that - I assume they would have been snatched up by an actual collector immediately if so...

they're in pretty decent condition other than a bit of wear on the dust jackets, I thought it was a fun find for a Sunday afternoon 😁

Edit: Found in Australia if anyone is wondering, they were in a Lifeline bookshop!


r/tolkienbooks • • Jul 20 '25

This old Hobbit book sat on my shelf for years… turns out it’s something special.

Post image
842 Upvotes

Around 20 years ago, a friend gave me a copy of The Hobbit that his mom—who was a big Tolkien fan—passed along for my birthday. I was already a fan too, so I kept it safe, but I never really looked into what edition it was until recently.

Turns out… it’s the 1965 first U.S. mass-market paperback edition from Ballantine Books.

The inside says “First Printing, August 1965” and includes the now-famous note from Tolkien himself, urging readers to support this edition after unauthorized copies had previously been released.

The cover art is wild—it has a lion, two bird-like creatures (they look kind of like emus or ostriches), hills with hobbit-holes, a strange tree with pink bulbs, and no sign of Smaug. I’ve learned the artwork was done by Barbara Remington, who hadn’t read the book before illustrating it. Tolkien hated the cover, but it’s become legendary among collectors.

It’s been kept in a protective sleeve all these years, and it's in surprisingly good condition for being nearly 60 years old. I’ll never sell it—just thought I’d finally share this little piece of Tolkien history that’s been with me most of my life.


r/tolkienbooks • • Jan 05 '25

Christmas Present to my son and I and a thank you to this subreddit!

Post image
841 Upvotes

So I decided to get my son (and I) a set of Tolkien's LOTR books for Christmas. I quickly became overwhelmed, relatively speaking, with the number of versions, publishers, illustrators, sets, compilations, etc...which left me looking for information trying to figure out where to start...what would give us a reasonably complete collection...I wanted to get something nice and comprehensive, but not go crazy initially.

As I went down this rabbit hole there was information overload to some extent and it was the posts in this sub that provided the most trusted and valuable information. This allowed me to figure out, compare, etc all the differences and options that I was seeing when researching and shopping.

Very happy with our starter collection and looking forward to exploring Middle Earth with my son this year.

So thanks ya'll ;)


r/tolkienbooks • • Sep 20 '25

The deluxe section of my Tolkien collections starts to look good after yesterday's massive purchase 😂😍

Post image
789 Upvotes

r/tolkienbooks • • Sep 30 '26

I think I finally managed to complete the whole set!

Post image
751 Upvotes

It's been a few years...


r/tolkienbooks • • Jul 22 '26

Already time for my annual re-read cycle, in true hobbit fashion this year.

Post image
751 Upvotes

r/tolkienbooks • • Sep 18 '26

Arrived today!

Post image
710 Upvotes

r/tolkienbooks • • Mar 25 '26

Happy Tolkien Reading Day

Post image
696 Upvotes

As it's Tolkien reading day thought I'd share my collection.


r/tolkienbooks • • Feb 13 '26

My Tolkien shelf is legit full.

Thumbnail
gallery
676 Upvotes

It took me a while to arrange this but I'm very happy now.

When/if WM release the orange UT later this year it will replace the LotR on the top left and then, my friends, I will have mastered Tolkien Tetris.


r/tolkienbooks • • Jul 13 '26

A thing of beauty

Post image
672 Upvotes

Mostly complete Tolkien deluxe collection. Easton Press, Folio Society, and Collected Poetry sets not pictured.


r/tolkienbooks • • Mar 14 '25

My collection and my cat Gandalf

Post image
668 Upvotes

r/tolkienbooks • • Mar 07 '25

Goodwill find

Thumbnail
gallery
666 Upvotes

12th impression. I'm amazed


r/tolkienbooks • • Aug 17 '26

My Tolkien Book Collection

Thumbnail
gallery
645 Upvotes

Pic 1: main collection
Pic 2: Deluxe collection
Pic 3: Movies/TV books
Remaining pics: close ups of main collection

I’ve been collecting for a few years now and I’ve assembled most of what I’d like to collect of Tolkien books.

I focused on US printings and really like my Houghton Mifflin collection. I also collected the UK printings that I liked the most (and could easily obtain). I haven’t ventured into first edition territory for LotR or Hobbit (my Hobbit is a 3rd edition). I would like an India paper LotR, but I’m waiting for the right one at a good price. I will also be picking up the new releases (I’m waiting for Black Friday/holiday sales).

Bottom shelf of main collection contains duplicates which I’ll gift to friends/family, donate, or sell.

There were several sites that I used to assist in collecting, which I’ll list a few here (these are all in the subreddit info). Of course this subreddit was invaluable as well - I am in awe of the collective knowledge here!

Tolkienbooks.us
Tolkienbooks.net
https://www.tolkienguide.com/

Next, I am putting dust jacket protectors on all the books. Also, anyone have recommendations for bookshelf lighting?