We now know through the Aang movie novelization (mostly in the Tagah chapter about his backstory.) Tagah mentions there were kids from the South Pole that came to Jharana. So at the very least it kind of highlights that the South pole having people there is from at least before basically going further back than 5,000 years. This would also mean that both water tribes were likely formed before the lifetime of Avatar Sonam.
Also more is that we know that within the Era of Sonam itself and this could also apply to the prior eras before Sonam. humanity lived in many disparate tribes scattered across the world, each of which wove two or three elements into a culture of its own, with no single leader, shared laws, or borders between their lands.
To give an idea on the state of the world Airbenders likewise varied greatly in philosophy and lacked a unifying creed, many of them living in mixed tribes alongside other benders such as Tagah tribe which also composed of waterbenders and earthbenders. Although not stated it is likely that the Lambak clan and other five clans of Lambak Island within the Fire islands likely formed around this time period.
The reason why I bring this up is because previous the lore goes like this waterbenders first unified at the North Pole to build Agna Qel'a before a civil schism sent secessionists to the South Pole. While but I feel that there is more to this than what we previous thought given the context of the world at the time with the elemental tribes?
Like we know that one of the reasons for the schism is their inability to agree on certain social and cultural practices.
Here what the lost scrolls water book describes the situation
“Originally the southern and northern tribes lived as one at the North Pole.
Following civil unrest, a group of warriors, Waterbenders, and healers let to start a new tribe at the South Pole. From that time on, the two tribes evolved very differently. Before the Fire Nation War, the Southern Water Tribe lived in a beautiful, bustling city built out of the ice by Waterbenders. It was destroyed by the war, and since so many Waterbenders died fighting, the art of Waterbending practically disappeared because there were no trainers left. The Southern Water Tribe split into smaller groups and scattered across the South Pole, building simple sealskin tents or igloos made of ice to live in.
— The lost scrolls: water, page 27 of The Lost Scrolls Collection.
We also know from the old Nick website about the origins of the foggy swamp tribe.
“Character: Due and Tho
These are two of many swamp folks living in the swamp. While neither of them is all that bright, Tho is less dim. Originally from the Southern Water Tribe, Due and Tho are both Waterbenders. Their ancestors migrated from the Water Tribe thousands of years ago and found these swamps. Because of all the water in the swamp, the Waterbenders felt at home and decided to stay. The swamp folks are often considered strange because of what they eat (like possum chicken and giant bugs) and how they talk with funny accents.”
— The Lost lore of Avatar Aang - Character: Due and Tho.
But that is all lore before the Aang movie where we learn about the Era of Sonam and the elemental tribes. Hence why I think maybe some of this lore could retcon or at least there is a lot more going in terms of the impact of Sonam era across the old lore and we originally thought.
Like for an example Tagah’s tribe lived in a swamp and while it not stated The swamp inhabited by the tribe is reminiscent of the Foggy Swamp featured in Avatar: The Last Airbender episode “*The Swamp.”*as both are described similarly and grant visions to those within them. Although Tagah mentions to Team Avatar in the novelization that is his tribe was attacked and their land seized by the armies of the first earth king. But keep in mind it likely Tagah is what he thinks happened to his tribe given well he was mostly with the Air Nomads in Jharrara. Not to mention if it is the Foggy Swamp Tribe that Tagah’s tribe was living then I just can’t see the Earth Kingdom army being able to conquer the foggy swamp given well logistically it is kinda hard not to mention with the whole visions and dangers from there basically think of say the Earth Kingdom version of Vietnam hence why I doubt Tagah claim here?
What I’m proposing here is that although it likely the airbenders and Earthbenders from Tagah’s tribe didn’t survived what if the surviving water benders would go on to deeper in the swamp and becoming the ancestors of the Foggy Swamp Tribe as we know them today if true then it is hilarious like we go from Tagah who is pretty strong guy to well two pretty skinny guys in the original series and that is 5,000 years from each other?
Which leads us back to the North and and South although we don’t know the exact status whether it is cancelled or put on hold we know that the triple a game that takes place 7,000 years ago and it was code name Ice Wars which would about the ice age. The reason I bring up is in one of their interviews Mike and Bryke mentions that one of their excitement of this triple A game is the fact it will tie to Water Tribe lore which I find very interesting.
Like I said we don’t know what is really the current status of the game given it is very debatable as I point out not to mention we don’t know the plot of the game. But if we take Bryke word on the game likely tying water tribes lore to the volcanic ice age.
I could see the plot being something like this there was global glaciation event around 7,000 BG which would naturally turn waterbenders into an apex superpower and expand across frozen seas before the climate eventually warmed and fractured their reach.
Either during this time period or after the ice age this allowed both Northern and Southern settlements to formed within the poles separately as well as settlements in the great continent. Basically they are remnants of a much larger water tribe superpower.
So by Sonam’s era it likely you have the Northern water tribes living in the north, the central continental waterbenders integrated into mixed tribes like Tagah’s mostly living on the great continent and then you have the Southern Water tribes being in the South.
Granted this maybe a bit rambling hence it maybe not perfect but still I thought sharing my theory on the water tribes and their origins. But what do you think my thought experiment or in this case this table of nations style theory. Let me know in the comments below