r/talesfromthelaw • • Jun 06 '25

Medium A lawyer I knew was fired for coming to work too early

3.9k Upvotes

A young lawyer I knew was fired not for slacking, but for being invisible. That’s Big Law for you, and it’s one of the reasons I don’t work downtown.

At the firm where I articled, I’d show up at 6, maybe 6:15, me being a morning person and awake by 5, no alarm needed. But there was a lawyer there at the firm, a young early riser, who was always at work before I got there.

Early Riser was in by 5:30, he told me, and sometimes earlier. He had a wife and a young kid, and liked to spend evenings with his family. He’d put in his time, eating lunch at his desk, and not long after 5 p.m. he’d head out to catch the train home.

Other young lawyers would roll in at 7:30, 8:00 or 8:30. They’d work until 5, then they’d hit the pub downstairs for an hour or two, then come back and work hard until 9 o’clock. They put in as much time as Early Riser (maybe) but they understood something that Early Riser did not. Working long hours wasn’t enough downtown; you had to work the right hours, the hours that got you noticed.

The three hours Early Riser put in before the sun was up did not count, because no one was there to see them.

When the recession hit in 1990 and the defence insurance bar was gutted by a set of No-Fault rules, the firm went looking for lawyers to chop, and the axe fell on Early Riser.

When he got the bad news, Early Riser and I went for a beer at the pub downstairs. Early Riser was staying late for a change because he didn’t know what to tell his wife. We sat in a corner away from the rest of the associates, the ones that worked the right hours.

“They said they didn't know where I was half the time,” Early Riser told me.

His billables were fine, the partners told him, but still, they knew he wasn’t working hard enough. They were positive, because he wasn’t around after 5. He wasn’t a team player, not one of the guys.

A few months later the firm told me and all the other students we would not be kept on. None of us was surprised. I’d already started making plans, and in no time I had another job in a good downtown firm.

But at the new place I noticed that I was often the first guy to come in. The place was usually dark when I arrived. I was newly married, just like Early Riser, and I liked to head home by 6 p.m., when the other associates were still at their desks.

“This isn’t going to work out,” I told my wife, “I can see where this is headed.”

Six months later I moved on and started my own practice, not because I was ready for it, not because it was a good idea, but because I didn’t want to get called into a partner’s office and be told I wasn’t a team player because I got in too early and left too soon. I didn’t want to be told I was working the wrong hours.


r/talesfromthelaw • • Aug 09 '25

Short Unrepresented Woman’s Endometriosis Case Against the State Clears Major, Nearly Unprecedented Legal Hurdle

3.0k Upvotes

In April 2022, while working as a Juvenile Court Counselor Trainee for the North Carolina Department of Public Safety, Christian Worley requested a workplace accommodation for severe endometriosis. Her request was ignored, and she was later threatened with termination for raising the issue again. A supervisor admitted in writing that he denied the request because he would have to offer the same to “every woman in the office.”

After being unable to find legal representation due to skepticism about endometriosis qualifying as a disability under the ADA, she represented herself in a lawsuit alleging disability discrimination and failure to accommodate. Despite having no formal legal training at the time, she conducted depositions, drafted legal documents, and reviewed evidence herself.

Now a law student, Worley has successfully survived summary judgment. The court has recognized that endometriosis can qualify as a disability under federal law, and six of her seven claims are proceeding to trial after three years of litigation. Her case is helping push the legal system to take women’s pain seriously. This is the first time a federal judge in North Carolina has ruled that endometriosis can be an ADA disability, and the first time in the country where a plaintiff has been allowed to proceed.

Sources: https://www.wfmynews2.com/article/news/local/2-wants-to-know/endometriosis-lawsuit-nc-disability-ruling-period-pain-pms/83-a9dd9f55-397b-40e5-b84c-29e588d0d474

https://www.wral.com/story/nc-woman-s-fight-with-the-state-over-menstrual-pain-could-help-others-disability-advocates-say/22105428/

https://www.linkedin.com/posts/activity-7358123289619177473-HSN-?utm_source=share&utm_medium=member_ios&rcm=ACoAACNqco8BG7RV5nFVE4OxVqybuillo9cCSk4


r/talesfromthelaw • • Sep 19 '25

Short When your client thinks a deposition is a podcast…

2.9k Upvotes

I told my client the usual before the depo: “Answer only what’s asked. Don’t volunteer. Less is more.” Simple enough.

About an hour in, he’s giving the defense attorney a full autobiography. One sentence questions turned into ten-minute monologues. At one point I stopped the depo, looked him dead in the eye, and said: “Are you out of your mind? He asked you one question, not for a Netflix special. We’ll be here until midnight at this pace.”

He finally got the message at least for the rest of that depo.

Anyone else have a “client who wouldn’t shut up” story?


r/talesfromthelaw • • Sep 03 '25

Short Getting My Own Client Arrested

2.3k Upvotes

Twice I’ve caused my own client to be arrested. The first time was easy: he’d consulted me about a future and not a past crime. When I got off the phone, my next call was to the police.

But the second time was a bit tricky.

The police claimed my client had beaten a man with a baseball bat. My client was sitting with me at court, trying to get his bail conditions changed so that he could play in a father and son softball event.

We’re waiting, and this guy walks in, suit and tie and shoes all shined, and he goes up and chats with the crown, chats with the cops, shares a laugh or two.

The guy's obviously a cop himself, and my client says to me, “Oh, I know that guy. I didn't know he was a cop.”

I just acted like it was nothing. A few minutes later, I stepped out of the courtroom and I waited for the cop to come out. And when he came out, I said to him, “Someone in that courtroom knows you’re undercover.”

“Who?” he says.

“The guy that’s getting his charges dropped, that’s who.”

He asked me if the charges were serious.

“No big deal,” I said, “just assault with a weapon and assault causing bodily harm.”

So he says ok, and we go back and speak to the crown. It takes about 30 seconds to work out a deal, because we have to move fast.

“Good news,” I said to my guy, “I got the charges dropped. But the bad news—“

My client wasn’t thrilled about getting arrested again, but they held him only for long enough for the careless under cover cop to tie up some loose ends. After that they let him go, charges dropped.

I don’t do criminal law any more. For one thing, the pay sucks. But it was a lot of fun. I really miss it.


r/talesfromthelaw • • Jul 31 '18

Short The Only Time I've Actually Wanted to Kill a Client

1.3k Upvotes

I was hired as a litigation associate right out of law school, and one of my duties was to handle all of the pro bono cases that the partners didn't want to do. This generally meant I did a ton of family law, despite my main practice being in civil litigation.

One of my first clients lost her 6 kids, that she had birthed between the ages of 14 and 23, because they were living in the filthy basement of a 2-bedroom home along with my client’s sister’s 6 kids, as well as 2 other children from some other relative. 14 kids, on a handful of dirty mattresses in a dank basement.

When we interviewed everyone, we found out that the oldest male cousin (15 years old) routinely molested my client’s oldest daughter (11, I think) and nobody ever bothered to stop him, despite every adult in the house knowing about it. All the adults said it wasn’t a problem because the 11-year-old girl wanted him to do it.

When we asked the little girl why the others might have thought she “wanted” it, she said, in the smallest voice: “If I let him do it to me, he doesn’t touch any of the littler girls.”


r/talesfromthelaw • • Jun 19 '25

Long A judge chewed me out for doing my job

1.2k Upvotes

A few months after the pandemic ended I had a trial coming up. I was looking forward to doing my first trial by Zoom. The matter was simple, scheduled for three days at most, and for a change I would not have to drive to the courthouse on what is literally the worst highway in North America and perhaps the worst in the world.  But then an email shattered that expectation.

“The trial will be in person,” my inbox told me in an email from the judge.  When I objected he pushed back.

“How can a judge assess credibility without the witnesses being there in person?” That’s what the judge wrote.

I knew the judge, or at least knew of him. He’d never been to court as a lawyer.  Never, not once, at least not for anything that had been reported. He’d worked hard inside a government ministry for twenty years for not much money, at the end of which he was rewarded with a judicial appointment.

The judge was smart. He knew his law. But he had never conducted a trial, not once, in all his years at the bar. He had no knowledge of the law of evidence, and even the court rules were something of a mystery to him when he was first elevated to the bench.

So the day of trial came and I got into my car and I fought traffic all the way to the court on the worst highway in the world, leaving very early to avoid being late.

I was ready for an old-school trial, with paper and live witnesses and briefs and tabs, and I brought everything, just like in the old days, with extra copies too, in case the court staff lost the copies I’d  filed for the court.  

The trial started, and I began the examination-in-chief.

“What bookmark,” the judge said when I referred to a document,

 I held up my brief of documents and told him the tab.

The judge scolded me, pointing out that he wasn’t using the hard copies I’d filed. He was using the court’s file management system. He was staring at his computer,  trying to find a document on his screen.

 But I could not help him with that. I had come ready for old school, not new. I had no computer with me. The judge sighed at my error and told me to continue.

My client’s examination-in-chief took fifteen minutes, and opposing counsel could not touch him on cross. Now it was the defendant’s turn.

The man gave evidence-in-chief, and gave it badly, his face and his eyes not matching his words. His face said he was a sneak, and at times I wondered if he was trying not to smile.

But the judge saw none of this. His head was down, and he was typing furiously on his keyboard, trying to catch every word.

“Your witness,” opposing counsel said.  I waded into the witness, and after a few simple questions the defendant’s face was beet red.

But the judge did not see this. He was typing away, looking at his computer screen. Justice was not deaf that day, but it was totally blind.

“Why is your face so red?” I said to the witness, forcing the judge to look, to actually turn his gaze to the man in the witness box and assess the credibility of the lying defendant.

“That’s not appropriate,” the judge said to me, admonishing me not to make comments on a witness’s demeanour, protecting the witness, wanting him to feel safe and comfortable.

 I reminded the judge of his email to me, ordering an in person trial so that the judge could assess the man’s credibility. 

The judge did not care for my remarks.  They were offensive, he said, and when he dismissed my client’s case he made specific reference to comments, weighing my unprofessional conduct in the balance along with the evidence, and finding in the defendant’s favour.

A few months later I was in the Court of Appeal.  The court asked responding counsel to speak first, and when he was done, the panel said they did not need to hear from me, setting aside the lower decision and granting my client judgment with costs in the lower court and on appeal.  They gently reminded the trial judge of the importance of credibility, and the role of counsel in helping the court assess it.  They were old school, too, all former trial counsel, and they did not approve of how the trial judge had conducted himself.

But I learned my lesson.  I no longer point out to the judge that they are missing key information when they cannot even be bothered to look at a witness who is melting down on the stand.   There’s no point.

But I have to ask, why is the court dragging lawyers and parties to court to assess credibility, when more often than not the judge spends the entire trial staring at a screen?


r/talesfromthelaw • • Apr 26 '18

Short Overheard at Court: Pedo edition [NSFW?] NSFW

1.1k Upvotes

Partner at a small family law firm in New England.

I overheard the following gem in the Court lobby as a few parties were preparing to enter a child protection hearing.

Counsel: "We cannot make that argument."

Litigant: "Why not? It's not like I hurt her or anything! I just had her suck my dick."

Counsel: "Yeah, okay, see the problem is that she's eight. Do you see why the judge might not want to hear that?"

Drinks began promptly at 5:30 pm that day.


r/talesfromthelaw • • Jul 11 '25

Short I Watched a Judge solve the Trolley Problem today Spoiler

1.1k Upvotes

In case you aren’t familiar with it, here’s the trolley problem in its purest form:

A runaway trolley is heading toward five people tied to a track. You can pull a lever to divert it onto another track, where it will kill one person instead.

Do you actively intervene to save five lives at the cost of one, or do nothing and let five die?

I'm in court as I write this. My judge today had a Trolley Problem.  The list was short, only six cases.  One was an emergency injunction, and the rest were minor procedural matters.

The judge had to make a decision: Hear as many cases as she could, or focus on the injunction, and leave many counsel and litigants disappointed.  

It was a classic Trolley Problem, translated into courthouse terms.  The judge wasn’t sure what to do.

One of the unimportant cases was brought by a man who lost his professional license five years ago, and who is suing the government and his former governing body and the parties who had complained about him, along with the witnesses that they called. He's suing his former lawyer, and opposing counsel as well.  He named the judge that dismissed his case, and the judges who refused his appeal.   He was suing everyone for everything all at once.  

It was a nothing case, a case made to be dismissed.  The kind of case you put to the back of the line.  But the man had no lawyer, and that changed everything.

“I’m a self-rep,” the man said, “and I just want to say a few things.”  He was the respondent to a motion to strike. It wasn't even his turn to speak. But he just wanted to say a few things.

“Go ahead,” the judge said.

That was at ten a.m.  It's past noon, and the man is still talking.  

So the judge solved the Trolley Problem.  We have a precedent.  Save the self-rep, and send all the other parties home.


r/talesfromthelaw • • Aug 05 '21

Short Mother with early-stage dementia destroys defense's cross-examination

1.0k Upvotes

A number of years ago, my mother was sitting in her car in a grocery store parking lot when someone ran up, reached in the open window, grabbed her purse, and ran away with it. At the time, my mother was in her late 70s and in the beginning stages of dementia ("now sweetheart, please remember to call collect when you call" every time I called her on my cell phone, that sort of thing).

My mother later identified the robber in a lineup. When she appeared in court, the prosecutor did the usual thing:

Prosecutor: Mrs. —, do you see the person who stole your purse in the courtroom?

Mom: Yes.

Prosecutor: Will you point to the person, please?

(Mom points at defendant)

During cross-examination, the defense tried to establish doubt about the accuracy of her identification. The usual stuff for people her age: how are your eyes, how's your memory, etc. Then:

Defense lawyer: Mrs. —, are you sure that this is the person that stole your purse?

Mom: Yes, I am.

Defense lawyer: And how are you sure about that?

Mom: Because the man who took my purse had a head shaped like a zucchini.

(Entire courtroom looks at defendant's head, which is one of those long oval heads, and is indeed shaped rather like a zucchini.)

Defense lawyer: No further questions.

The man was found guilty.

My father, also a lawyer, said that during examination, you never ask a question that you don't know the answer to, and that this was.a textbook example of what can happen when you do.


r/talesfromthelaw • • Jul 18 '19

Medium The police were uncooperative, my only witness died, and I won the case by doing nothing

937 Upvotes

The following case is not thrilling, but it is a typical case that an insurance defense firm would handle on a regular basis.

One of the partners, as happens sometimes, handed me a small subrogation case for our insurance client, and I told me to resolve it. Our insured, a man of around 75, was driving his car on a four lane road in the left lane. The defendant, a lady who had been involved in a grisly murder as an accomplice about fifteen years ago when she was a 18, was in the right lane. The lady side swiped our insured's vehicle, causing like $4,000 in damages.

At the scene, our insured said that he was just driving, and then he was side swiped. The defendant said, "I don't know what happened, officer."

The lawsuit was about six or seven months old when I got it, and the partner who was initially handling the case had spoken with the insured on two occasions and sent him a letter.

When I received the file, trial was a few weeks away, so I printed out the pictures of the vehicle, sent a subpoena to the police officer, and tried to call the insured. I got a busy signal, so I put the file away. A few days later, I got a call from the police officer who filed the report.

"I'm not going to make it to court because I'm off on the court date."

"Alright, well, when are you available?"

"The police report is hearsay. You don't need me anyway."

"Ma'am, what I need you for is not hearsay. I'll reset this for a date that you are available for."

That wasn't helpful. I called the defense attorney, and we pushed the trial out about a month and half. I issued a new subpoena on the police officer. I tried to call our insured again. I got a busy signal.

I pulled up LexisNexis and looked up our insured...he died the previous month. I'd never had this happen before. I called the insurance adjuster handling this claim.

"Hey, I hate to tell you this, but our guy is dead."

I talked to the partner who had handed me the case. He suggested that we fake it. I'll take the adjuster to court. I'll call the defendant as my witness, then I'll call the cop, and then I'll get pictures of the vehicle into evidence using the adjuster. The adjuster could also testify to damages. The adjuster is willing to try.

About a week later, I get a call from the cop.

"I can't come to court. I have training, and I'm major surgery that's been scheduled for a long time on that day."

I really wanted to call her sergeant and complain, but it wasn't worth the trouble.

So, it's going to be the adjuster and I. We'll probably lose since I have no impeaching evidence against the defendant now. I have no witnesses to impeach her version of events.

Suddenly, I get a phone call from the defense attorney, and they agree to pay the claim in full. I've never told that attorney that my guy was dead, but some day I kind of want to.


r/talesfromthelaw • • Jan 02 '26 Popcorn

Short Won small claims court because plaintiff didn't show

918 Upvotes

Backstory: located in bumheck Ohio. I represented myself in my dissolution from my ex back in July 2025. Dissolution was final, July 2025. Ex had a history of having a hard time keeping a job, showing up for important events, being dependable. Come the day for the dissolution I had to help him find the court room in a small courthouse located in Ohio.

Since September, he's been trying to sue me in small claims court for a joint bank account I had closed with his knowledge. It was closed and he felt it was split unfairly, after the dissolution final decree. I ignored him and he tried serving me unsuccessfully for 5 months due my work and travel. Finally, I was served mid-December, I filed an answer and motion to dismiss then a motion (judge overruled) then a summary judgment, citing Ohio law, dissolution decree, and so on. I was well prepared for the court hearing, ironically on December 31 (NYE). I showed up with 3 friends of mine, were all looking dressed to the nines, ready for this trial. My ex, the plaintiff, who has spent already $250 between filing and trying to serve, didn't show. I'm still in disbelief but, once called to the podium, I sit at the defendants table and the judge looks at me like I have 3 heads and asks, "you're the defendant"? I respond, "yes". Judge asks, confused, "the plaintiff isn't here"? I respond with, "correct". And the judge promptly and befuddled dismisses the case.

I'm still in disbelief why someone wouldn't show to their own case, I'm fairly confident, my answer and motions scared the pants off my ex.


r/talesfromthelaw • • Sep 18 '18

Medium "Your draft violated my human rights!" and the funniest letter I've ever written to the court

893 Upvotes

I'm a family lawyer. I was in court representing a mom of two young kids. Dad was representing himself, as was Grandma, with whom the kids were staying for several months while my client finished a college program. Dad took issue with this arrangement, despite being unable to take care of the kids himself because of a disability.

At our first appearance, the judge suggested something that everyone actually agreed to. I was the only lawyer there, so I was tasked with drafting the order. I sent copies to Dad and Grandma, asking them to let me know if they remembered the agreement differently, or if they are okay with my wording.

When he gets the order, Dad calls me right away. He says that he takes issue with my lack of professionalism (no explanation) and he doesn't consent to the wording of the order. He doesn't suggest alternate wording though. He says that my draft has violated his human rights (no explanation) and he will be forwarding this to the Human Rights Commission, who will be his lawyers from here (they won't). I decide not to point out that that's not how this works, and just go with a "Thanks for letting me know". I point out that the Family Court Rules require me to file the order within a certain amount of time, which is rapidly running out. I ask him when I can expect the HRC to contact me (they won't). Dad tells me that they usually take 3-6 months to deal with things. I tell him "Okay, well I'm just going to write the court a letter explaining this, so the judge is in the loop."

I write the letter, explaining briefly what has happened. I say that I'm unfamiliar with the HRC getting involved in Family Court cases (they don't), and particularly in the drafting of orders (ditto). I point out that I'm hesitant to file the order since Dad has said he was going to consult counsel, so "I await direction from the Court" (code: You see the crazy in dealing with? Can you help me out here, Your Honour?).

The Court office calls me the next day and asks me to send them the draft order, for the judge to look at. The day after that, I'm in front of that judge on an unrelated case, and she says "Oh, and Mr Goodplan, I signed that order from the other case. If he doesn't like it, he can appeal."


r/talesfromthelaw • • Jul 04 '17

Medium "Where the F### is your boss? I want to talk to your boss.", said crazy to the domestic Judge

826 Upvotes

Custody dispute in which I helped a low income man seek full custody. His ex was pro se, and refused to communicate with me in anyway. Apparently, she knew the law, and knew she didn't have to talk to me without a lawyer. No amount of explaining that I was a lawyer, not an officer, and my purpose in trying to communicate got me anywhere.

Come hearing day, she hadn't submitted anything to the court, and decided that she should get whatever she wanted simply by telling the judge to do it. She was after all the "mother" and more entitled to the child, benefits, and child support that went along with the child. Despite what she was saying, she spoke sweetly and was very petite.

When the judge explained that she hadn't submitted any pleadings, and that she wouldn't prevail unless she asked for a continuance, submitted pleadings, and tried her case- she lost her shit. I must have romanticized the memory, because I swear she was flailing her arms around so fast that I couldn't keep track. Her entire body was twitching, arms flailing, hands flopping, and head back screaming. She demanded to speak to the judge's boss immediately. She repeatedly made offensive racist comments about the judge. A non-stop river of psychotic-entitled-bullshit spewed from her mouth. She wasn't doing the insanely high-pitched-bird-from-hell-that-is-unintelligible scream. She was doing a full on drill sergeant bellow. The yell was loud, clear, forceful, and disconcertingly deep.

I deal with pro se in domestic and custody issues. I've seen some shit, but this left me opened mouthed and staring. My client, however, was familiar with this brand of crazy. He stood up to loudly and politely asked the judge if he could say something. Side note: I felt like a jackass at this moment for not staying on point, but I was completely caught by surprise. The judge allowed my client to speak. My client used both arms to gesture to crazy and yelled, "This is the shit I'm talkin 'bout right here. You see this crazy. Nah. Just nah.". For the second time that hearing, I didn't remain professional and couldn't contain my laughter. I think laughter, or any sound of happiness, must have been a trigger for her, because Crazy then started to attempt to physically attack my client. My client ran to the witness box and ducked down inside in an attempt to shield himself from the attack.

There should be officers in each domestic courtroom during hearings, but we all know it'll never happen. Crazy was arrested, and screamed the entire time she was drug away that she was going to talk to the judge's boss about her being disrespected. My client was awarded full custody, and the mother wasn't awarded any parenting time.


r/talesfromthelaw • • Jul 26 '18

Long The Crooked Attorney

821 Upvotes

I was told to post this from r/prorevenge and here I am! I am not an attorney, but my boyfriend is and this tale took place a few years ago in NYC...thus, here is The Tale of (throws dust in campfire)

"The Crooked Attorney"

In looking up this guy's information, he really was a POS. A local paper described him as (reworded for privacy):

"These con artists are cutthroat and will do anything to get their money. They prey on unsuspecting victims and take out loans and falfisy information. They take off with most of the money. The con artists are very skilled, and few of them are ever sent to prison."

...until my boyfriend came along!

My boyfriend (BF) moved to NYC from a state in the South. Freshly out of law school and riddled with student debt, he found a low paying personal injury firm and settled in. Since money was tight, he found a roommate on Craigslist named "Julie."

Julie is a fiesty Latina, and my boyfriend is pretty much Wonder Bread, but they hit it off very well. My boyfriend would go to Julie's job after work (she was a bartender) and they developed a very strong friendship.

During this time, Julie meets a server, "Luis." They hit it off and begin dating. My BF clicks with Luis, and they become a trio. Drunken tequila nights, peeing on the Subway platform, my BF being taken to Latin clubs...they become the best of friends.

Something that will play a role in this tale is that both Julie and Luis (and their families) are in the USA undocumented. Please don't turn this into a political post.

So, Julie and Luis are getting serious, but don't have a lot of money, so they move in with Luis' elderly parents. My BF finds another place to live and they all still keep in touch.

During all of this, Luis' dad had suffered an injury at work. He lost part of his finger and had hired a personal injury attorney (aka POS). Apparently he was supposed to recieve a $100k settlement but some time had passed and still no update.

Julie (since neither Luis or his dad spoke English) called Luis' father's insurance and asked about the status of the settlement.

The insurance said "Oh, the settlement's already been paid out....?"

That's when Julie called my BF, freaking out. Apparently this "personal injury" attorney had a history of being an ambulance chaser, and sought out clients here illegally. He held that over them and took their settlement money by forging documents. While there had been reports, the guy had been getting away with fraud for years.

So, my bf tells Julie to tell the POS that she knows what's up. Apparently this guy thought his clients were too stupid to seek retribution.

POS told Julie that he would return the money if she dropped her complaint against him. My boyfriend was livid at this POS taking advantage of immigrants and decided to get payback. He told Julie to record all of her conversations with him and keep records of any type of contact. Apparently POS was using other embezzled funds to hush clients like Julie.

Julie met up with him a few times, always recording interactions and "getting money from him."

With evidence in place, my BF took all the evidence to the NYS Supreme Court who investigates and told them that he was representing Luis's dad.

Apparently reports had happened for years but nobody ever gave a damn until an attorney became involved. It turned out that POS had stolen over $400,000 from clients for years.

It was a long trial, with my boyfriend representing Luis' dad and he having to testify. POS knew my BF had reported him and would glare at him from the stand.

Long story short, POS pleaded guilty to charges of identity theft, fraud, grand larceny etc. He was stripped of his ability to practice law and was sentenced to seven years in jail.

Luis' dad gave my boyfriend $1,000 (he worked pro bono for them) and now my bf is the Godfather to Julie and Luis' son. Luis' dad moved back to his native country and bought a beautiful house. All of POS' victims got their money back through the Lawyer's Fund for Client Protection.

Tl; dr: POS lawyer steals hundrends of thousands from immigrant clients. My BF the attorney incriminates him and POS loses his license to practice law and is sentenced to seven years in jail. Also, all victims got their money back

Edit: typos, clarity


r/talesfromthelaw • • May 10 '18

Short Keeping it Casual, Darling.

789 Upvotes

I'm a partner in a small New England area law firm.

I had Court this morning with one of my clients who is a very sweet older lady (around 70 years old). We were helping her with an old judgment from her divorce - long story short, ex-husband failed to pay something, we were helping her collect. But that's not the star of the show.

She has a habit of calling everyone 'Darling.' E.g. "Do you need my bank statements, darling?" when calling the office. I don't really care what she calls me, she pays and is mega sweet, so we brush it off.

She is also a tad bit hard of hearing. This is relevant.

We had the final hearing today. The judge was keeping things pretty casual and conversational, and asking the parties different questions to clarify things before closing the hearing.

He asked my client something about her finances, and she didn't hear him. "I'm sorry, Darling, what was the question?"

Oh my God. Help me.

There was a moment's pause, and he burst out laughing.

"I'm sorry, did you call me... Darling?" He leaned back in his chair, beet red, grinning.

She also turned a shade of scarlet. "I... I did, Your Honor."

He laughed again, shook his head, and the rest of the hearing proceeded. Upon closing the record, he mentioned that it was the first time he had ever been called 'darling' by anyone.

I think we did well, though. Darlings and all.


r/talesfromthelaw • • Dec 07 '17

Medium The lady who wanted both dogs in the divorce...

754 Upvotes

tl;dr - lady wants both dogs, lies to judge, loses both dogs for being an asshole.

All of my stories will probably be about clients who fired me. I don't want to give the impression I'm a bad lawyer, but these make the better stories. Divorce attorneys get fired because people are mostly unreasonable and family court is mostly fair.

So this couple has two dogs. My STBX client tells me that she wants both dogs, and she won't have it any other way. She explains to me that the dogs love each other and NEED to be with one another. She is sobbing uncontrollably in my office, which is something I can normally deal with, but not in this case. She was hysterical.

I often use the Socratic method to explain things to people. First, I told her I love dogs (I do) and I totally understood her situation. I told her that it would really suck to break up my two dogs, so I understood her.

Then I said, "But I have to ask you something. If you were a judge, and there were two dogs and two people, how would you divide them up?"

She realized what I was saying and she almost screamed, "Nooooo! You don't understand! They love each other and they can't be broken up!"

I said, "I totally understand. I'm just asking you what you think YOU would do, if you were the judge...and there were TWO people and TWO dogs. How could the judge easily settle this matter?" (I was just trying to get her down to reality, so I could maybe figure out if she preferred one dog or if there was another way to settle this.)

Then she says: "Okay, I get it. Dogs are property. Even though they are my children, the law says they are property."

That's right. At this point, I had mistakenly thought she had seen the proverbial light.

"Okay, so then how about this: I will sell the dogs and that way, the court can't order me to give her the dogs. The dogs will be gone." (This was a same-sex marriage.)

Ugh.

I said, "Ma'am" (I always say ma'am or madam when I'm about to scold somebody.)

"Ma'am, it sounds like you are saying that you are going to try to pull the wool over the judges eyes."

"I can't even entertain that notion. You think the judge hasn't seen this kind of stuff before? You think you're the only couple who has two dogs? Do you think this is an original idea? I'm not telling a judge that you sold the dogs."

I got her spouse served with the petition and then, of course, I was fired before trial. She went in without an attorney.

When she told the judge she sold the dogs, she actually thought he would just say, "okay, well that's that."

The judge said: "Who did you sell them to?"

Excuse me?

"WHO DID YOU SELL THEM TO? I want a name and a telephone number. We can make the call right here, from the courtroom. I'm going to verify your story. I know you love these dogs very much, so I know you didn't give them to a stranger. Tell me who you sold the dogs to NOW."

Oh gee whiz. She wasn't expecting that. I guess this judge has been a judge before!

Rather than have the judge call her accomplice, who was hiding the dogs and NOT expecting a judge to call, she admitted that it was a con. She crumbled under the judge's cross exam.

Judge gave BOTH dogs to the respondent in the case. (Respondent's attorney was an acquaintance of mine.)

Full justice boner achieved, plus happy ending: Dogs get to stay together, and they surely would have been broken apart.


r/talesfromthelaw • • Mar 24 '20

Medium Pro se is never good - how to end up wrongfully accused and in prison for life.

749 Upvotes

This is the most insane case I've ever been apart of. I'm a courtroom assistant in a south east asian country.

We had a case where the defendant was charged with premeditated attempted murder, resisting lawful detention, criminal battery with intent to kill. The (pro se) defense was making an argument that on it's surface seemed pretty ridiculous - a security guard chased him off the property they were guarding, detained him, brought him back to the property, and tortured him - which caused him to protect himself.

By "protecting himself" - he gouged the eyes of a security guard, beat her into getting a depressed skull fracture with exposed brain, broke her neck, stabbed her multiple times, and ripped hair out of her head.

The evidence on him seemed pretty bad against him, looked like he was completely bullshitting everything - to the point the judge actually stated in open court that it's the worst fabricated story he'd heard. He was convicted as charged and sentenced to life imprisonment in lieu of death penalty.

He ended up getting a trial de novo after he hired a private investigator which found some new evidence.

This evidence?

CCTV camera evidence was pulled from 82 different cameras, police reports, and tow records painting a very obvious picture.

It showed a security guard attempting to pull him over on private property (legal) where he fled. He fled on rural public roads, where the security guard was chasing in a car with lights & siren. She utilized a PIT maneuver on the car, which made him roll, and then forcibly removed him from the vehicle. She tied him up with rope & zipties to transfer him back to the private property.

She then proceeded to beat him with a bat while he was restrained, held him captive for 6 hours, tased him for a total of 1403 seconds (just over 23 minutes) total, or approximately 200 times over a 6 hours time period. He escaped restraints, to which the security guard responded by beating him with a bat.

The defendant took the bat from her, struck her multiple times, gouged her eyes, and fled.

The case against him was dismissed with prejudice.

The prosecution service ended up opening a case on the security guard who was in intensive care after barely surviving his response.

She ended up being charged with reckless driving, reckless endangerment, vehicular battery, impersonating a police officer, unlawful imprisonment, kidnapping, criminal battery, battery with intent to kill, and torture.

She died in ICU the day before she was scheduled to be tried


r/talesfromthelaw • • Feb 15 '17

Medium How to get the jury to learn about how f***ked your client will be if they vote guilty

745 Upvotes

In civil cases, damages are front and center. Sometimes, the defense even concedes liability and the jury is there to determine whether the plaintiff gets awarded $50,000 or $5,000,000.

Criminal law is totally different. The jury is unaware of what punishment your client may (will, if you're in a mandatory minimum jurisdiction like Arizona) receive. They even get a jury instruction specifically telling them not to consider punishment in rendering their verdict.

A colleague of mine recently related the following story about how he nonetheless managed to sneak this information to the jury, to his client's great benefit.

Client is charged with selling drugs. A moderate quantity--he's a street level dealer probably supporting his own habit, not a kingpin, but Arizona law makes no such distinction. Evidence is overwhelming--it's a dead loser of a case. Defense attorney is reduced to asking lame questions desperately trying to impugn some aspect of the police investigation:

Q: Officer, did you send in the baggie to the crime lab for DNA testing?

A: No, due to limited resources, we only do DNA testing for serious cases.

Q: Your honor, may we approach?

At sidebar: Your honor, this officer has just essentially testified that this is not a "serious" case. I believe that this has falsely conveyed to the jury the impression that if my client is convicted, he is not looking at a very serious punishment. I would like permission to address this issue with the witness.

Judge: (reluctantly but apparently impressed by defense counsel's cleverness) I'll let you ask one question, counselor.

Q: Officer, my client is looking at a mandatory prison sentence of between 10.5 to 35 years if convicted--is that not enough time to make this a "serious" case?

He said he could see all the juror's jaws drop when they heard what the guy was facing. They convicted him of simple possession, not sales--pretty much straight-up nullification.

I will incorporate this technique into all my future cases where my client is looking at a disproportionately long sentence due to our draconian legislature.


r/talesfromthelaw • • Apr 10 '19

Short Diabetic emergency in court

717 Upvotes

Was representing a defendant being tried for a probation violation, criminal trespass to government property, and posession of drug substances in a criminal court case. My testimony was going to be focused on the police department that arrested him failing to follow proper procedures.

(They entered his house without a warrant when no exigent circumstances existed, they lied to the phone company about having a warrant to track his phone when they didn't have it, and the interrogation was improper + violent)

I was feeling tired, but it didn't really compute that it's because I'm a diabetic in crisis. We go through the court case, I'm behaving badly in court being reprimanded by the judge repeatedly, and I eventually start slurring my words and having single sided weaknesses.

The judge recognizes something was wrong and put court at recess, and the court police thought I was having a stroke.

An ambulance was called for, and I was unconscious by time they got there. My blood sugar was 30, which is very low especially for me. They give me my own glucagon, which is an injectable hormone that forces my blood sugar to go up.

10 minutes and several snacks later, I manage to keep going to eventually finish (and win) the case


r/talesfromthelaw • • Dec 22 '23

Long My courtroom encounter with a Sovereign Citizen

706 Upvotes

I run across sovereign citizens now and again, the kind that like to file bogus legal documents, filled with Latin phrases, and notarized with a red seal to make everything official. These guys think legal terms are like incantations or spells; if you just say the right thing in a document, your legal problem magically disappears. Lawyers and judges hate these guys. They are super annoying.

Years ago I took on a case for a friend. It was a family estate squabble, and my client’s brother owed him money. The Sov Cit brother got his greedy hands on his father’s money outside of the estate process by getting himself made joint with his elderly father on some bank accounts. Pulling that stunt is a no-no in Canada. Definitely frowned upon by the courts. But so far as Sov Cit man was concerned, it was finders keepers all the way, and his father’s will be damned.

I sent Sov Cit man a letter demanding that he pay, and he stuck to the Sov Cit playbook: he “paid” my client with a “check”. The “check” was not your normal check, drawn on an actual bank account. Instead, it was some weird bullshitty thing that he got off the web. The bank the check was drawn on didn’t exist, and the check had all kinds of strange wording in fine print on the back.
The thing about these Sov Cit guys, is that they have no notion of the consequences of the bogus documents and bad advice that they get off the web. Sov Cit man made a huge mistake by sending me the bogus check.

“Can I cash this?” my client said when I showed him the check.

“Go for it, but tell the bank in advance that you know it won’t clear, so that they won’t think you’re pulling a scam.” So my client cashes the check, and of course it bounces with extreme prejudice.

After the check bounced, we sued the brother for the money he stole from the estate. It was a short, simple lawsuit, just a few pages long. We served the brother at the house he owned, free and clear thanks to the money he stole from the estate. The guy had thirty days to defend, and on day thirty, I got his defence, filled with the usual Sov Cit nonsense. The defence also had a huge mistake in it, one of the biggest I’ve ever seen, and I’ve been doing this a long time.

Sov Cit man started harassing me and my staff. He sent emails. He sent letters. He left voicemail messages. He came by the office uninvited, demanding to see me and making threats. He kept it up until the cops said they’d arrest him if he came by again, but by then, it was time for his court date.

So I’m in court, asking for judgment, and the Sov Cit genius is there, talking his legal babble, saying words he doesn’t understand. The judge shut him down after about ten seconds, and gave my client judgment. Sov Cit man has a meltdown, and is escorted out of the courthouse. Of course he appeals, but I don’t care, because of the mistake the guy had made right out of the gate.

His mistake was serious and fatal. I don’t know about other countries, but in Canada if e someone gives you a check and it fails to clear, you can sue for that. All you have to do is prove that a check written to you bounced, and that’s all you need. The court will give you judgment. So when Sov Cit man sent my client the bogus check, he handed my client an airtight cause of action, and easy win of a lawsuit. And of course I pounced on it.

When Sov Cit man’s check bounced, my client sued him for that, too, in a separate legal proceeding that we started on the same day as the estate case. The two claims looked almost identical, at least on the front page. My client’s name was the same, the defendant’s name was the same, and the court file number was identical but for the final digit. When we served Sov Cit man with claim one, the estate claim, we also sued him on claim two, the bad check claim.

I think he thought that the second claim was just a copy of the first, because he only defended the estate action; on the bad check case, he didn’t defend, and I had default judgment after thirty days.

So a few months later Sov Cit man wants to negotiate. He’s feeling magnanimous, he says, and even though the estate case is under appeal, an appeal he said he was sure to win, he was willing to throw his brother a bone. He’d pay, but nowhere near the amount of the judgment.
It was then that I let him know that we’d sued twice, and that I had a judgment in the second action as well as the first, and that now the man’s home was totally tied up with the writs I filed.

“You better hope you win that appeal,” I said to him, “because you’re literally betting your house on it.”

Sov Cit man did his usual meltdown thing, but once he was finished with the screaming and the threats, he had a bit of a come to Jesus moment. We “settled” with him, sort of. He paid back all the money he stole from the estate, plus all my client’s legal fees, plus some more, just for being a bit of a dick and a sovereign citizen to boot.

Later that year he was at my client’s house for Christmas dinner. Go figure. Families can be pretty weird.


r/talesfromthelaw • • Feb 20 '20

Long My lawyer has about half a dozen problems with that

702 Upvotes

The following takes place at an old workplace. I no longer work there, which I am grateful for almost every single day when something else reminds me of the old insanity.


The CEO had a lot of pet projects up his sleeves, some of which he would deign to share with me - usually when they were so broken or behind schedule that it would require nothing less than a minor miracle to get them done on time.

And I was his personal miracle worker.

CEO: Hey Gambatte...

ME: (Here we go again...) What do you need?

CEO: I had a guy helping me out with a program, but he's pulled out.

ME: Okay... Back the truck up here, please. What program?

CEO: Oh, the program runs on a computer hooked up to the paging receiver and logs messages.

ME: Okay, the paging receiver is a pretty simple serial port connection...

CEO: Oh, and you can configure the receiver through the program too.

ME: Configuring the receiver should be possible, assuming we can drive it through serial port commands.

CEO: And it creates a text file with all the day's messages in it, then on the first of the month, zips them all into a single archive. It also displays today's messages, color-coded based on keywords in the pager message.

ME: Well, it's certainly doable.

CEO: Good!

ME: What's the timeframe?

CEO: Oh, ASAP. I want to start distributing the software early next year.

ME: Wait, so you're going to be distributing the software? The previous developer must have been work-for-hire, so where's the source?

CEO: No... He was doing it in his spare time, for free. He just got worried that his full-time employer {major competitor, an enormous multinational corporation that would crush us like a bug} would find out he was helping us.

ME: Wait, he works for the competition?

CEO: Yeah, but I know him from when we worked together thirty years back, so he was helping me out.

ME: So... about that source code...

CEO: Oh no, he's not releasing any of it.

So we don't own or have any right to distribute the software. I later discovered that the developer had not just backed out but had also formally requested (in writing, no less) that the CEO delete any copies and return any and all install media with his software on it.

ME: So your plan was to give away copies of this software that you don't own, and have no formal right to distribute?

CEO: I don't follow...

ME: ... Okay, so we need to rebuild the program from scratch. What's the main point of this software?

CEO: To monitor the pages that {enormous competitor} is sending to the contractors.

Messages sent to the contractors. Not to us.

ME: Wait, what?

CEO: So that we can make sure our messaging format is consistent with {the competition}.

ME: Wait, wait, wait, wait... What? Would they release that information to you, if you asked them nicely?

FYI, we had several other industry standard protocols that all entities in that particular business sector openly shared information about, so to ask such a thing was not entirely unprecedented. A clever businessperson could have sold it to them as a way to standardize on their messaging formats, which would have almost certainly resulted in the entire industry using them.

CEO: What? Don't be stupid, of course not.

ME: Have you asked?

CEO: No! Why would I do that?

ME: Because you want this information, right? Surely the easiest way to get it would be to ask for it; to get it directly from the source?!

CEO: They would never give us that. Stop asking, it's not going to happen.

ME: So, as I understand it, your plan is to deliberately monitor telecommunications of which you are not the intended recipient, in order to determine the structure of our biggest competitor's outgoing messages, which you have already admitted is information they would not freely share so may legally be considered a "trade secret". And your plan to do this involves distributing copies of software that is the intellectual property - sorry, the copyrighted work - of an employee of the competition, to various contractors throughout the country with documentation from us, from this company, on our letterhead with our logo emblazoned on it, on how to set up the hardware and software in order to perform such monitoring?
And you see no potential issues with this plan? No possible ethical, or legal grey areas?

CEO: No. Why? Do you think there might be an issue with my plan?

ME: ... Yes. Yes, I do.

CEO: What's the problem?

ME: You know what, why don't you email me the specification for the program you want built, and I'll put my response in writing.

I never did receive that specification.


For the record, a good friend of mine and practising lawyer took the "hypothetical" question I posed him and discussed it with a few fellow legal professionals. They came back with breaches of the telecommunications act, the privacy act, corporate espionage, copyright infringement, and a few more that I don't currently recall.
When I took my "independent legal advice" to the CEO, his response - which I'm certain in his mind was 100% ironclad and would absolutely hold up in any court of law - was "If the paging providers don't want us to monitor other people's pagers, they should have better protection against it!"



I work somewhere else now.
Almost every single day, something will remind me of my old job, and without fail I will be gladdened that I no longer work there.


r/talesfromthelaw • • May 07 '19

Epic Of course the judge can read it!

682 Upvotes

I'm a clerk at a civil court in Brazil. My job includes dealing with lawyers and parties who walk up to our counter, as well as dealing with all the stages of a lawsuit. A civil clerk's day-to-day work consists in mostly dealing with everything a judge would be supposed to deal with, like reading petitions, documents and other legal stuff submited by the litigants, type orders and other legal documents, which will get our initials, submit the text to their supervisor, who will check if everything is OK, and then either get the judge's signature on it or, if something is wrong, correct it and then get the signature. In almost every court, the judge doesn't even read what they're signing if they didn't type it, since they are supposed to trust the supervisor they directly appointed, after all. There are, of course, exceptions: If something submitted is very important or involves complex matters, we must send the case files directly to the supervisor and if it's incredbly important, to the judge, who will then read everything carefully between hearings and their other work. If we sent everything directly for the judge's consideration, a huge bottleneck would be created and no one would have any work.

One wet behind the ears lawyer who showed up at our counter a few years ago, however, didn't seem to understand that it's a judge's prerogative to delegate whichever tasks they may seem fit. The moment she opened her mouth, I knew she would be trouble. She had the classic "get me your manager" tone which I'm sure everyone is familiar with. She also emphasized every last word in her sentences. One last thing before the story: Everything here is digital, so when we "submit something to someone", we actually just move the digital files in our system from one queue to another. Everyone, even judges, is mandated to obey each queue's order, unless something is urgent.


The parties in the story are as follows:
Me: A smiling, zealous and upright clerk.
Supervisor: The closest thing I have to a boss. Awesome non-confrontational man who loves to maliciously comply and pretend like he didn't.
The Judge: Aloof and busy, I've only seen her at our office like three times.
Dr. Important: She will talk to your manager and she will have your job. Probably.


The story starts in the morning of a 10-hour day for me. At this time, the courthouse building is closed to everyone but lawyers. There she comes. Blonde, mid-40s, with an impatient demeanor and her BAR ID in hand. She waits 30 seconds before barking "is there no one to serve me?" I get up.

Me: Good mor--
Dr. Important: I need to talk to [My initials] and I need it now.
Now, that never happened before. No one ever bothers about the initials on files, they just want to "talk to a clerk".
Me: That would be me. What is the matter?
Dr. Important: You were the one who typed this order, right?
Me: Sure. Is anything wrong?
Dr. Important, after a scoff: Of course there is something wrong. You typed it, not the judge.
Me: Um... And what's wrong about it...?
Dr. Important: You're just a clerk. You can't possibly do a judge's work.

Now, not only do I do part of a judge's work, I probably know more about that kind of order than my judge herself, since it's a menial job with which she doesn't bother. Her case: She made a very abusive contract with a client, who then didn't paid her what she expected to be paid (80% of the client's monthly earnings for 2 years), and she was pro se filing for losses, with a claim of urgency. My order: Not urgent. Citation to be served via mail. The very first step in a lawsuit after the initial claim. My supervisor heard the drama brewing and came up to us.

Supervisor: Everything is made under the judge's supervision, Doctor.
Dr. Important: I don't care. I want to talk to the judge and have her read my petition.
Supervisor: I read your petition and Deprox followed the correct procedure.
Dr. Important: Is he the judge? Are you the judge?
Me: I wish.
Dr. Important, after a scoff: He is so rude. Can't you do something about it?
Supervisor, completely ignoring her remark: No, he is not the judge, and neither am I. What is the matter?
Dr. Important: Oh, my God, can no one here understand such a simple thing? I want the judge to read my petition and issue an order!
Supervisor: You mean the exact same order Deprox issued, I checked and she signed?
Dr. Important: YES! Because then it will be an order issued, checked and signed by a judge.
Me: The only thing that matters is the signature, though.
Dr. Important: WHAT???

I thought she would burst. She got red and she started ranting about public workers' incompetence, how her taxes are funding our laziness and how is her right as a citizen to have the judge read her petition. While she's ranting, my supervisor looks at me and I can see the malicious compliance brewing. We wait patiently until she stops repeating the word "absurd" every other sentence.

Supervisor: OK, Doctor! I think I understand now. You want me to put your case files in the judge's queue.
Dr. Important: And do it fast! It's very important! I will come back in the afternoon to check if she read it.
Supervisor, with a huge grin: Sure, ma'am. Please do.

Now, my judge hates to be bothered with a passion. When someone enters her office, be them workers or lawyers, they better not be wasting her time with something my supervisor or one of the clerks could have dealt with. Just so you can get the picture, we celebrate her birthday in our office and she never shows up. She pays for the cake and the celebration but she doesn't attend.

Me: You're not... Actually gonna send it to the judge's queue, are you?
Supervisor: She did ask it, didn't she? We're hereby forbidden to touch the case, no matter how many requests she sends. Unless she gives up on her claims...

The dreaded judge's queue. Most lawyers do their best for their case not to end up there. The judge's queue is meant for complicated matters that makes a case come to a halt. Not urgent matters, which is a separate queue. It's about matters that will require the judge to pore over the entire case's file while consulting every law known to man. It's so low-priority that at the time, that queue's first case in line got there one year ago - and that is a very good date considering some judges have their queues last three or more years.

So my supervisor sends it to the judge's queue and we go back to work. My judge arrives (we only know that because she logs in to Skype) and my supervisor gives her a heads up about Dr. Important. She replies "I'll talk to her". My supervisor shows that to me and we share a look. This is very rare. The judge would normally reply "don't let her near my office". By 3PM, when our counter is full of litigants and lawyers, Dr. Important comes back. She pushes people on the queue and screams she has very important business with the judge. My supervisor quickly walks up to her.

Supervisor: Your case is in the judge's queue now, Doctor.
Dr. Important: Did she read it yet?
Supervisor: Please, follow me. She will talk to you now.

Now, this part of the story was told to me by my supervisor, so I'm paraphrasing his paraphrasing. They went upstairs, with Dr. Important complaining about everything in the building ("the handrails are too high", "the steps are too big", etc) and shaking a copy of her complaint around. My supervisor knocks on the judge's door and opens it. Instantly, Dr. Important's demeanor changes to a very sweet and smiling lady.

The Judge: Yes? How may I help you, Doctor?
Dr. Important: Your Honor, I humbly request you to read my case.
The Judge: Didn't you read it, Supervisor?
Supervisor: Of course I did. It's for losses in a lawyer contract.
Dr. Important: It's very important bec--
The Judge: It's not important at all.
Dr. Important: But... But it's urgent!
The Judge: Not urgent.

Now, this was told by my supervisor who likes to tell stories, so take it with a grain of salt. He said the judge took the copy of the complaint off Dr. Important's hand, read the first three sentences aloud, said "Not urgent at all", crossed out the big bold "URGENT" typed above the claim and returned it to Dr. Important.

The Judge: Anything else, Doctor?
Supervisor: She demands you to read her entire complaint, Your Honor.
The Judge: Is it in my queue?
Supervisor: Of course it is.
The Judge: I will get to it, then. Anything else, Doctor?
Dr. Important: Can... Can my case go back to the regular queue?
The Judge: I will get to it and then see if it needs to.

Some say Dr. Important is still waiting for The Judge to read her case to this day.


r/talesfromthelaw • • Apr 03 '22

Medium Sometimes the clients are too clever for their own good...

679 Upvotes

My first real law job was at a small law firm. While we called ourselves a boutique firm, we'd also do simple tasks for friends of the owner.

One of the friends was a gruff man I'll call Gary.

Gary reminded people that he had a bunch of businesses involved in commercial real estate. Gary thought that anything he didn't understand was a scam. Most of Gary's businesses seemed to revolve around a large parking lot with mobile equipment. Gary had a snowplwo business and another replacing HPS (High Pressure Sodium) bulbs in office park and mall parking lots.

Up until now, he'd just walk to the owner's office and they'd deal with one another. One day, my boss emailed me and asked me to handle Gary's problem. I agreed to help where I could.

Gary showed up and dropped into one of the two chairs in front of my desk. To prevent people from hanging out, I had purchased unpadded, pressed wood seats from Ikea for my client seats. Think the seats you had in high schools, but in un-yielding plywood.

Gary was angry about something.

me:"so, what can I help you about?"

Gary:"Ok. I got divorced about a year and a half ago. Because I didn't want my bitch wife to get my businesses, I quick-claimed them to my buddy. Now that the divorce is over, he won't give me it back"

me:"Let me see if I got this right. You were getting divorced and you sold property to your friend with a quit-claim deed"

Gary:"It's called a quick-claim, because it's fast"

I keep my mouth shut. I got a B+ in Property, but I'll leave Gary to his opinions.

me:"I see. What property did you transfer to your friend?"

Gary:"All of it. My lot, my trucks and my employees"

Me:" Ok. So let me get this straight. Your ex filed for divorce and you transferred your lot and equipment to you friend."

Gary:"Yeah. And now that the divorce is final, he won't give it back"

me:"And the giving back part was a handshake deal, right"

Gary (Realizing that I'm not on his side, either):"So you're on his side?"

me:"Um. No. I'm on your side, but I hate to tell you, you fucked up. You sold all your property to prevent your ex-wife from getting any of it, but now it's gone. Sorry"

Gary did not take this well. He stomped out of our offices before I had time to grab the keys to the gun rack in the reception area.

I poured myself an afternoon cup of coffee and went back to work. By the time my coffee was cold, my boss called.

Boss:"So, I understand Gary left unhappy.

me:"Yep. From what I gathered, he transferred all his property to a drinking buddy in a botched asset protection play. Buddy isn't willing to give it back."

Boss:"so anything you can do for him?"

me:"Sorry, no. I think he's broke. His ex may have a claim under a constructuve trust theory"

Boss:"Yeah. well, I guess we'll leave sleeping dogs lie. Fuck that guy, anyway."


r/talesfromthelaw • • Sep 03 '25

Short The night I realized I hadn’t filed a Notice of Claim…

662 Upvotes

PI lawyers all have that nightmare where you wake up at 2am wondering, “Did I file that paper on time?” 99% of the time you check the next morning and it’s fine.

This time, it wasn’t.

Big case. Municipal defendant. I tore my office apart on a Saturday morning and finally had to admit it: I never filed the Notice of Claim.

So I did what most lawyers dread: I called the client in, sat him and his wife down with me, my partner, and my assistant, and told him the truth. No excuses. I told him he had every right to sue me if he wanted. I apologized. Then I told him the path I still saw forward, if he’d trust me to keep fighting for him.

He didn’t take five minutes to think. He looked at me and said, “We’re staying with you.” His wife nodded.

I’ll admit it, I teared up. Might’ve cried.

Fast forward: three years later, we settled for high six figures.

Lesson? Mistakes happen. But if you’ve built the right foundation with your clients, the relationship carries you through storms that would sink you otherwise. No ad, no SEO, no shiny branding saves you in that moment just trust.