r/Stormlight_Archive • u/pliskin42 Truthwatcher • Jan 22 '25
No Spoilers We need to have a discussion about allowed links in this sub. Other fantasy subs are doing so to. Musk is literally flashing nazi salutes and we as a community need to decide if we are okay giving him traffic.
/r/dresdenfiles/comments/1i7eatu/poll_to_banremove_links_to_xtwitter/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button38
u/rollover90 Windrunner Jan 23 '25
How many times does this even happen? I mean I support the ban but it seems performative If no one uses it anyway
148
u/pliskin42 Truthwatcher Jan 23 '25
Sure. But sometimes being performative matters. Specifically when it comes to showing solidarity and standing up to fascism.
→ More replies (18)30
u/benbernards Jan 23 '25
"taking a stand is so performative!"
well then get out there and perform, what are you afraid of?
→ More replies (1)
1.7k
u/Roger_The_Cat_ Ghostbloods Jan 23 '25
Mods: “WOULD YOU LIKE TO DESTROY SOME EVIL TODAY??”
459
u/SigmaQuotient Jan 23 '25
THAT SOUNDS DEEVY
322
u/Smighter Windrunner Jan 23 '25
Lift says, “Don’t just punch Nazis, steal their lunches while you’re at it!”
48
41
23
608
u/talondigital Jan 23 '25
I saw on some other communities, that when needed, they would accept screenshot from X, when related to official announcements, but no direct links. I found that an acceptable solution to restrict X without eliminating legitimate news about the topic when from official sources.
171
u/SomeLameName7173 Skybreaker Jan 23 '25
When has Brandon even announced something on Twitter and no other sources?
97
u/Buckets-O-Yarr Skybreaker Jan 23 '25
And if Brandon chooses to continue using a Twitter account, I will disagree with that decision, but can acknowledge that there are reasons why he and others wouldn't want to jump ship there. I just happen to think that this is yet another "line too far" from the owner and CEO of that company.
Because I haven't said it elsewhere yet, I fully support this sub banning Twitter links.
24
u/gd5k Larkin Jan 23 '25
I mean just for the sake of argument, Brandon’s posts aren’t the ONLY things that get shared here. So if it was from some other source that truly only used Twitter… well I agree that sharing a screenshot best allows that hypothetical news to still be shared without directing traffic to a site run by nazis.
19
u/Inlacou Journey before destination. Jan 23 '25
I have agreed on that on other subreddit, but here... When do we get info only from Twitter? I see Brandon more active on Instagram honestly.
→ More replies (1)13
2.2k
u/Adept-Bet-817 Jan 23 '25
Yes, please. Ban X. Show ourselves and each other that the values of acceptance and love we read in these books actually mean something to us.
750
u/BumbleLapse Jan 23 '25
Ban Twitter.
The Nazi salute at an inauguration should be the end of discussion.
→ More replies (3)117
85
105
64
26
213
u/Paranoid_Japandroid Jan 23 '25
In the spirit of the how the US government actually works I’d like to tack on an addendum to ban sandershelfs
46
47
u/DracoCustodis Windrunner Jan 23 '25
In the same spirit, I would like to add an addendum that everyone's reading status must be displayed in their public bio to promote a sense of broader community and to help this community with spoiler engagement.
Also, in the spirit of bipartisanship, we should ban all TikTok links.
10
u/learhpa Bondsmith Jan 23 '25
that's some nice logrolling, there.
they're currently restricted in /r/stormlight_archive to desolation day only, and are allowed in /r/brandonsanderson. what would you like to us to do different?
955
u/sunsetclimb3r Jan 23 '25
At this point i think it'd be weird to NOT ban X.
I stopped going there ever once I had to have an account to do it.
46
u/t6jesse Jan 23 '25
Yeah the wall made it easy haha.
Which is weird - I guess it makes more money from subscriber data than from randoms seeing advertising
279
u/lala_machina Jan 23 '25 edited Jan 23 '25
Fuck Elon, even more than Moash
Edit: I didn't mean to potentially spoil things for people, updated to hide a name
172
u/spunlines Willshaper Jan 23 '25 edited Jan 23 '25
Man, I like your comment, but can you spoiler guard that so we don't have to remove it?
edit: please come back we miss you.
53
u/lala_machina Jan 23 '25
I am so sorry!! I didn't even think about it. I made the edit, did I do it right?
28
129
u/ElseCaller3000 Elsecaller Jan 23 '25
These Words are accepted
→ More replies (2)20
u/bakedredweed Lightweaver Jan 23 '25
Oh no what did it say 😭
→ More replies (1)20
Jan 23 '25
I didn't see it but, going by my experience with reddit policies, I'm assuming it was similar to something my great grandfather would've said while sitting in a foxhole in the Ardennes.
9
440
u/breadandbirds Jan 23 '25 edited Jan 23 '25
I find value in this community in the content they post, not the links they post. I absolutely support banning Twitter/X links. I would rather not see links to a platform owned by a nazi, as being a nazi is antithetical to the morals espoused by the books we are all passionate about.
178
u/WilNotJr Jan 23 '25
I get pissed when I don't notice and accidentally click a link from that site. Any site with a login requirement to view should be banned, but particularly that one.
24
u/OozeNAahz Jan 23 '25
I seriously wish they would add an icon to show what site a link is from to make it easy to make sure I don’t click on something from Twitter. Or YouTube or some others too. Less about flipping Musk off (which I am here for don’t get me wrong) but rather those sites being annoying to pop into when you aren’t trying to.
126
u/cloux_less Skybreaker Jan 23 '25 edited Jan 23 '25
What's really wonderful about this, from a mod's standpoint, is that if you're somehow unsold on the numerous justifications for tunning off this sub's ability to generate engagement and revenue for the Neo-Nazi forum owned by the pro-Apartheid, anti-semitic (this one's from before the Salute, mind you), transphobe, well then you can also just ban it for practical reasons, since links there basically don't work anymore.
Anyway, Hoid Quote from WAT "The dirty secret is that all governments are quietly republics—the voting is simply done with the sword or with coin. Everyone conveniently neglects to tell the lower class that it's their coin, and their lack of swords." Don't give it your coin.
271
246
u/Shinjetsu01 Windrunner Jan 23 '25
We don't need the discussion. I've never seen an X link here in the 5+ years I've been a member of the sub.
214
u/RaijinDragon Edgedancer Jan 23 '25
Then, there is no harm in making sure it stays that way.
→ More replies (36)→ More replies (1)53
u/FallenAngel7334 Jan 23 '25
Good, let's keep it that way. Not that it matters, the platform is locked behind having an account, and I doubt folks here will volunteer their data to a known nazi.
104
u/Dyllbert Jan 23 '25
Ban Twitter for moral reasons AND usability. Posting a link that doesn't work unless you sign in is unbelievably stupid.
54
u/ashriekfromspace Jan 23 '25
I don't even think I've ever seen a post here linking to Twitter at all.
65
58
u/Calderis Elsecaller Jan 23 '25
Haven't used my Twitter account in years, but logged in and deleted because of this.
Also ceasing any revenue generation for meta or Amazon.
NGL folks, already seeing a lot of things impacted by what's going on, and things are going to get scary remarkably fast.
Haven't read this thread, but want to say something here's a lot of "it was a roman salute" going around. The Roman salute, also known as the fascist salute, was later adopted by the Nazi party. So saying it's a Roman salute means you know it's a Nazi salute and are a coward, or parroting out of ignorance.
Others are saying it was a Bellamy salute... Which was pretty much the same thing here in America and was stopped specifically because we didn't want to be associated with an obvious Nazi symbol.
And you know the one person who matters who has not denied it was a Nazi salute? Elon.
Ban it. Ban apologists. Take a stand, and make sure it's more than just on reddit. Either we stop this shit now, or we repeat history.
23
24
u/B_Huij Truthwatcher Jan 23 '25
I’ve never used Twitter or X. I think the world would be a better place without it. I think that was true before Musk took over and has only gotten more true since then.
If this is the catalyst that makes the internet finally abandon X once and for all, great. I never click Twitter links anyway. They’re not worth the hassle.
26
u/ShingetsuMoon Jan 23 '25
Ban links and allow screenshots of news only. People who don’t have an account cant see anything from the X/Twitter link anyway.
So for that matter, I’m all for banning anything that requires a paywall or account in order to view it.
25
u/wrathsun Jan 23 '25 edited Jan 23 '25
Ban links, allow screenshots, encourage the use of other platforms. Just because it might fall under the heading of "free speech" doesn't mean I have to lower my standards of acceptable behavior from anyone.
18
u/SomeLameName7173 Skybreaker Jan 23 '25
Even if he wasn't, which he is. The fact that you now need an account to view anything on the site should be enough.
22
u/alex_munroe Larkin Jan 23 '25
I love this sub as it's a great place for discussions, memes and news about Stormlight Archive for people all over the world. To me, politics (especially American politics), external events unrelated to Brandon and his writings, and hate has no place here.
In my experience, there are exceedingly few links to X/twitter circulated on this sub, so many would argue that it makes little difference if it's removed entirely. I would disagree.
Like it or not, this is clearly a politically charged discussion and decision. To me, banning entire platforms because of political reasons or the potential for harmful cross-contamination would be making a political statement, something I believe this sub as an entity should not be engaging in. There are also authoritarian owned platforms, should they also be banned? There are also platforms rife with certain of it community members circulating hatred and racism (4chan, 9Gag, and most social media platforms to one degree or another), should they also be banned?
Of course, any post linking or containing content that breaks this subs rules (Especially Rule # 1 - Show respect to others) should be removed, user should be warned and if repeated banned.
I have not used twitter/X in over 10 years and have no desire to ever do so again, especially given it's more recent developments. I do however respect others peoples freedom to use it in a responsible manner. Additionally, I understand from other comments that Brandon still posts on the platform (I have not verified this myself), so I could understand people wanting to follow him on this platform.
The Nazis were some of the most disgusting and vile groups of people in human history, responsible for some of the most despicable acts humans are capable of. I would not lightly throw this term around, doing so reduces the horror and impact of their actions.
This community is known for being understanding, kind and patient with each other. I IMPLORE you, please, continue this by showing respect to each, and not devolving to name calling or other dehumanizing behaviour.
→ More replies (1)
13
u/Red-Lightniing Jan 23 '25
I was waiting for someone to post this here, it was only a matter of time
→ More replies (2)
17
u/possiblycrazy79 Jan 23 '25
Sure, why not? Twitter has been a cesspool for a long time anyway. Let it die. Society was perfectly fine without it & life will go on and the next platform will pop up etc etc
17
25
u/DarkSoulslsLife Truthwatcher Jan 23 '25
I dont really like the ban in principle. I also am not really going to put up much of a fight for X because I dont really use it.
→ More replies (6)
18
u/StriKyleder Jan 23 '25
I'm not sure what it would actually accomplish beyond making people feel virtuous. Plus, I don't recall people actually sharing X links here
→ More replies (2)
28
21
12
Jan 23 '25 edited Jan 23 '25
I really don't care. Frankly I think Bezos and Musk Zuckerberg are just as bad as the elongated muskrat even if they aren't as stupidly performative. I still shop at Amazon, I still use messenger. If everyone wants to ban it though, I'd rather do it to just keep discussion of these twats out of my niche fantasy subreddit.
I read fantasy to escape the world where these people control a bunch of things.
Edit: Getting confused between rich billionaires in human suits.
5
u/TheGreatPervSage_94 Jan 23 '25
We are all also using smartphones that have components made of cobalt that's mined by child slaves in Congo.
4
u/SturgeonBladder Jan 23 '25
Who is downvoting this lmao you're absolutely right. Unironically, we should ban smart phones too.
→ More replies (2)4
16
u/unica3022 Windrunner Jan 23 '25
I agree with a ban. It’s basically the only meaningful action to take at this point to disagree with Musk’s actions and subsequent reaction (or lack thereof) to the public outcry. But I understand not undermining content creators, so maybe there’s another way to make sure voices don’t get silenced at the same time.
14
u/Apollo506 Jan 23 '25
Allow screenshots. Ban links. This preserves freedom of speech while denying clicks/money to the fascist clown.
8
10
16
u/GrilledStuffedDragon Windrunner Jan 23 '25
I stopped using Twitter a long time ago.
I'm totally fine with not seeing it here.
14
Jan 23 '25
Oh come on guys, watch the video, don’t look at the screenshot. Is it awkward, yes, but calling that a Roman salute is over the top and in bad faith
8
u/tango421 Jan 23 '25
Like other subs we see, just ban links and maybe allow screenshots.
I honestly don’t remember the last time I saw a link there from this sub. Pretty rare in other subs I tend to follow as well.
10
u/Btaylor2214 Jan 23 '25
I don't think you can be a fantasy reader and not see how him and the people he represents are the literal bad guys in every series we read. Subtle changes based on the series of course but it's textbook villainous behavior. We should rail against it in any way possible.
13
u/AngelofShadows95 Jan 23 '25
I'm against it. This isn't a political sub, so why make a political statement?
→ More replies (1)
18
u/isekai15 Jan 23 '25 edited Jan 23 '25
I dont use twitter. Cant even see anything on it either since i have no account there; however, im not in favor of people telling me what i can and cant post because of who owns what. That sounds too much like forcing things on people based on your own beliefs, be it right or wrong. Whether he is a nazi or not i dont want to be subject to a rule you decided on because you dont like him.
to be clear, i am not supporting him or his behavior, i like having the freedom to do as i please. Stuff like this becomes a slippery slope slope fast, and then suddenly people are making demands for rules for anything they dont agree with
edit: someone has already misconstrued what i am saying here so i will be more specific. People do not need rules created by others grandstanding their own viruosity. Freedom of choice (in this case to post from twitter or not) is only a meaningful right if people are allowed to choose, and i believe in freedom of choice and freedom of expression, regardless of elon and what he does or doesnt stand for. We dont need rules to govern this kind of stuff. Make your own statement and do whatever you feel you need to without detracting from other peoples freedom of choice.
1
u/SomeLameName7173 Skybreaker Jan 23 '25 edited Jan 23 '25
Doing what you can to say no to Nazis is a slippery slope? You have committed so many logical fallacies. Jasnah would be disappointed in you.
Edit: punctuation changed a "." To a "?"
→ More replies (8)
9
u/stoneymcstone420 Jan 23 '25
Ban it, let’s prove Honor isn’t dead. The more subs and other platforms that participate, the more impact it will have.
8
u/magungaa Jan 23 '25
Ban twitter or X. I work in advertising at the largest agency in the world and we stopped allowing our clients to advertise on it 3 years ago
6
u/Qwayz7 Willshaper Jan 23 '25
Even just the requirement to log in should be enough reason to ban it
10
u/Kazyole Jan 23 '25
Fully support the ban. And I'd say anyone who is on this subreddit who doesn't should probably re-read these books, and pay extra attention to the themes this time.
14
u/Cynicivity Windrunner Jan 23 '25
Fuck Elon and his Nazi sympathizers. Definitely ban Twitter links
7
7
9
u/mlwspace2005 Jan 23 '25
We literally don't need to have a discussion, Twitter links are essentially non existent and so we're politics threads until this got posted. Can't we just enjoy crab people in space without bringing Nazis into it
22
u/PsychologicalHat1480 Elsecaller Jan 23 '25
If there's any bans to be done it should be a total ban on all real-world politics.
7
u/benbernards Jan 23 '25
Shut down the nazis. Starve them. Give them no quarter, no space, and no mercy.
6
u/TalnsRocks Jan 23 '25
It feels good to be able to do even this little something to remind these billionaires that actions DO have consequences. Please ban X like hundreds of other subs have.
6
u/WingUnderling Jan 23 '25
I have no issues with a decision to ban links to websites owned by or associated with known fascists.
If something very interesting or pertinent happens on one of those sites and someone would like to share it, perhaps a screenshot of the content instead of a link?
7
6
8
6
6
8
9
u/Deathranger009 Stoneward Jan 23 '25
I really don't think this is necessary. I don't think banning X is going to do anything meaningful (as it's not like this sub constantly links to X or creates traffic) but on the off chance something relevant to Stormlight is posted on X it would prevent a link to that from being referenced.
What if an actor or artist implies they might be doing something with a Stormlight show on Twitter? That would be very important to link. There could be any number of things.
In addition banning it just feels like lip service. Kinda hollow.
14
8
u/BalkanFerros Edgedancer Jan 23 '25 edited Jan 23 '25
Ban Twitter. Never used it and never will. To allow the support of his website, traffic to it and the monetization that comes with such traffic would be against the light that we radiants seek to be in the world around us.
Bigotry and hatred have no place here, the man threw 2 clear nazi salutes and he must be excised from our society, starting with the small places we will chase this out.
12
u/SomeLameName7173 Skybreaker Jan 23 '25
Call it Twitter he dead names his daughter. Dead name his website
→ More replies (2)
6
u/Steve_Macc Jan 23 '25
X has become a horrible place over there last few years, and after the display from the owner I'm no longer comfortable with it. I am fully on board with a ban.
6
u/TrueNawledge97 Truthwatcher Jan 23 '25
That hellsite has long ceased to add anything worthwhile to the world, ban it.
6
7
u/Cadamar Spearish Chap Jan 23 '25
The values of Musk are not compatible with any of Sanderson's works, and especially Stormlight. Hell, I'd argue you could find a Musk-equivalent in Mistborn. (VERY Minor spoilers up to Oathbringer) Radiants remember those who have been forgotten. We protect those who cannot protect themselves. We unite, not divide.
I would support this ban wholeheartedly.
→ More replies (1)
6
6
Jan 23 '25
I don't like X and don't have an X account so it does not really impact me either way. I personally would prefer if it were not banned solely because if there was one interesting post on X and linking it would be relevant, that would not be possible if it were banned. I think more channels for communication is always better. That being said, I understand the sentiment and support the decision to ban if that is how the community as a whole feels.
6
u/The_cman13 Jan 23 '25
I would be in full support. Even ignoring his terrible beliefs, the site is crem if you don't have an account.
5
5
5
5
5
5
u/PickUseful8048 Jan 23 '25
Agreed. Ban Twitter. We don’t need to send traffic to that dumpster fire of a website
5
5
u/Adventurous-Common63 Willshaper Jan 23 '25
Please let’s ban X! We can always get links from other platforms that aren’t owned by Nazis
5
u/bookmonster015 Jan 23 '25
I would heartily support a ban of Twitter links. I think it's incredibly important for fantasy readers to support the kind of empathy and curiosity in the world that reading sci-fi/fantasy gives us. I hope Brandon will move his account over to BlueSky soon, and that the rest of the celebrity & culture world follow. It's helpful to cut off the income stream of fascists and reduce their cultural impact on our communities.
→ More replies (2)
5
u/FallenAngel7334 Jan 23 '25
Definitely ban it. Its value has greatly diminished ever since you need an account.
5
u/bakedredweed Lightweaver Jan 23 '25
I think it’s fine to ban twitter links since we don’t really use those as a community anyway. Fascism is not very life before death, strength before weakness or journey before destination. Plus we stand tall and proud with the LGBTQ+ community.
5
u/fyoomzz Jan 23 '25
The only way to ensure the values of acceptance that abound the SA persist is by rejecting bigotry. Ban X.
-3
u/BenInEden Jan 23 '25
I vote no.
Brandon is on twitter and posts regularly. This sub is for fans of his.
Furthermore this sub is not about Elon or politics. If you’d like to discuss Elon or politics please do so in subs where that’s relevant.
15
u/Graspswasps Skybreaker Jan 23 '25
Maybe he will see this post and make a stand when he sees our solidarity.
Someone has to start, someone has to do what is right, because it is right.
47
u/CalebAsimov Ghostcrips Jan 23 '25
Nazis are a little more serious than casual policy discussion. Sometimes you've gotta take a stand dude, this is literally the bare minimum. Fascism burns everyone eventually.
→ More replies (22)30
u/AvivaStrom Jan 23 '25
Brandon will move with the audience. If he knows that fan communities across the web are no longer allowing X links, I think he’ll change how he posts.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (2)12
u/FallenAngel7334 Jan 23 '25
Anything Brandon posts about will make its way here sooner or later. Also, Twitter is dying, very likely, and he will move to a more reliable platform. Banning Twitter from this sub will only speed it up.
4
u/wirywonder82 Elsecaller Jan 23 '25
While I have seen a rare post here linking to Twitter (and I do mean Twitter, because I don’t recall any that linked to X), it is very rare and if my memory is correct, strictly in the past anyway. I’m not opposed to creating such a rule, and any content creators solely accessible through Elon’s site need to diversify at the very least.
4
4
u/-Ninety- Willshaper Jan 23 '25 edited Jan 23 '25
Ban X. (Only nazi’s downvote this)
→ More replies (1)
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
u/GayestElf Jan 23 '25
Ban that shit. Nazis have no place in this community and we shouldn't be sending people their way.
4
4
u/Venli-Sage-of-Stones Jan 23 '25
I think that banning Twitter/X links is a good policy and this community should do it. Since 2015 I have found the rising tide of fascism in the United States specifically, and reactionary movements globally, to be horrifying. If this community can do something, even simply joining with communities in boycott we should.
There is some discussion in this thread that the community should avoid taking a political stance because this is not a place for politics. I don't believe that is possible. I have never understood the position that something is "not political" or should "not be political." To my understanding everything involving two or more people is intrinsically political. I view attempts to avoid that reality as efforts to abdicate our civic responsibility to our community and each other.
We have an obligation to care for others, and that should be reflected in the interactions we have as groups. Taking the stance that we shouldn't do something because it is political is implicitly taking the stance that we support those in power over what we believe is right. I want to be part of a community that tries to do what is right, not just what is convenient. In simple terms fascism is wrong, opposing fascism is right.
At this moment this community has a choice to sit in collaborative silence, doing nothing, or to take the smallest of steps to bend the arc of history towards justice. Banning Twitter links is not some silver bullet which will end fascism for a generation. But, it is the next step and what's more important than that?
0
u/DarthBane713 Jan 23 '25
I rarely comment, love the books/cosmere, and don't even have an X account. That being said, I'd like for us all to take a moment and take some things into account.
This feels reactionary and performative. I'm of the opinion this is being sensationalized, he didn't do a full nazi salute, and he isn't a nazi.
You can't accuse him of being a nazi when he is one of the largest advocates for a program, H1B, that brings in primarily Indians and Chinese people to work in this country. I feel he is just a very VERY weird narcissist that wants to spread his name, like someone else we know.
I've never seen a link to that platform, so to ban it seems unnecessary. Not to mention, someone new coming in years from now will have no context for such a rule.
This is all observation and opinion so take it as you will but hopefully you reflect on this just a bit.
16
u/Dynegrey Jan 23 '25
He's a fan of H1B visa because he can work them longer hours for lower pay... not exactly a great argument.
14
u/Upper-Big-466 Jan 23 '25
The only reason he supports H1B is because it’s making him money. If it wasn’t a Nazi salute, why do the actual Nazis think it was? If he isn’t a Nazi, why does he support the AfD in Germany?
1
u/NoOnesKing Windrunner Jan 23 '25
Yeah I’ve also totally accidentally done the exact heart pound and motion of a Nazi salute multiple times in less than 30 seconds for no particular reason.
The reason to ban it is to not give X traffic and him money. The only way to hurt fascist freaks like him is to hit their wallets.
→ More replies (8)
3
3
u/Inlacou Journey before destination. Jan 23 '25
First Twitter degenerated a lot, then we got some good alternatives, now Elon does the nazi salute.
It is time. Ban Twitter from here.
3
3
3
3
2
3
u/socialjustice_cactus Jan 23 '25
I vote to ban X. Assuming that's what this is. Separate ourselves as much as possible from destructive political maneuvers
3
u/DennisPragersPornAlt Jan 23 '25
fully endorse the banning of twitter posts on here. Fuck elon and his fashy aspirations.
Not sure if Brando has a bluesky account but I'd strongly encourage him to switch over. and set an example for people. I know making a political move like that can be tricky when you're a public figure, but being on "X, the everything app" is becoming an increasingly political stance in and of itself.
3
3
u/INTO_NIGHT Jan 23 '25
Does Sanderson use twitter at all for book announcements or anything book related? If so im not sure if not there would be another source for those updates ?
16
10
u/SomeLameName7173 Skybreaker Jan 23 '25
Anything he might post to Twitter also gets posted on all other social media. Nothing exclusively to Twitter.
7
u/BenInEden Jan 23 '25
He does. Often. His last tweet was 5 days ago. Dragon steel and Cosmere Network are also active on twitter.
→ More replies (2)6
3
2
u/Pristine-Function-49 Jan 23 '25
Ban X.
We need to collectively move back to having absolutely zero tolerance to this shit.
1
2
u/niftium Truthwatcher Jan 23 '25
All but one Radiant order would support a ban. Let democracy carry the day. Ban X.
5
u/cloux_less Skybreaker Jan 23 '25
Curious what radiant order you think would oppose the ban? Willshapers? Dustbringers?
2
1
u/FartherAwayLights Willshaper Jan 23 '25
Yes please. Even if he wasn’t a nazi the sight is nigh unusable and blocked unless you have an account.
1
1
u/DCoyC Jan 23 '25
I agree. Ban it as this does go against literally everything the stormlight archive is about.
Journey Before Destination.
1
2
2
2
2
u/kennethgibson Jan 23 '25
Life before death, strength before weakness, the incarcerated firefighters are literally bridge 4 and storming fuck Kal we gonna block Twitter on there.
1
1
-1
-7
u/coala12369 Jan 23 '25
I think it is very pointless, blocking one way of information is just a way to create a bigger echo chamber, I don't like musk, actually I don't like most people and that's not gonna change soon.
And also I think a good chunk of this community is not from the US so it really is irrelevant to my point of view, it's just the big thing of the moment, people want to take action, 6 months in the future people will be babbling about the next politic or stupid gesture someone made, it reminds me of the time where people cancelled the Ok sing for being fascist or whatever.
-13
u/Far_Appointment9458 Jan 23 '25
I think this is an inappropriate response. Elon annoys me and sometimes infuriates me but his track record shows he is not an antisemite.
If you think he MEANT to mimic a Nazi salute, sit back and actually think about how that makes sense, even though thats obviously exactly what it looked like.
Also, blocking links to one of the largest social media platforms, the main one that functions as a global “town hall,” because you don’t like the owner’s politics (the dumb salute is not the reason, it’s the excuse) is a bit ridiculous.
22
u/ShouldersofGiants100 Truthwatcher Jan 23 '25
I think this is an inappropriate response. Elon annoys me and sometimes infuriates me but his track record shows he is not an antisemite.
Twitter user: "Jewish communities have been pushing the exact kind of dialectical hatred against whites that they claim to want people to stop using against them. I’m deeply disinterested in giving the tiniest shit now about western Jewish populations coming to the disturbing realization that those hordes of minorities that support flooding their country don’t exactly like them too much."
Elon Musk's response: "You have said the actual truth."
That shit is literally straight out of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion. It's antisemitism on a level no honest person could deny.
→ More replies (14)3
1
u/PteroFractal27 Truthwatcher Jan 23 '25
It makes sense because he’s a fucking Nazi. His generational wealth comes from South Africa’s apartheid, this shouldn’t exactly be surprising.
If you think he somehow did not mean to do the exact Nazi salute, sit back and actually think about how that makes sense.
1
u/whiskeywishes Jan 23 '25
Please ban those links. And we should encourage Sanderson to leave x. I looked for him on Bluesky and was disappointed and embarrassed when I didn’t see him there/ switching over. Hoping I typed his name in wrong or something.
1
1
u/kjexclamation Willshaper Jan 23 '25
Ban Twatter that said never seen it here I agree with people lol but still get banned
-2
-10
u/settingtrends247 Jan 23 '25
No way. Elon's an odd guy who made an awkward gesture in a moment of excitement. Can we stop with the performative grandstanding? Let this be a place where people discuss the books, stop dragging politics into everything
→ More replies (1)
-6
u/cosmernautfourtwenty Edgedancer Jan 23 '25
What perspective is there to understand? Elon is a Nazi punk and Nazi punks fuck off.
I would've led the charge in blocking his traffic through this sub if anyone genuinely posted xitter links all that often. My bigger concern is Brandon still using it as a means of disseminating information about his work. I've been banned for a while so I don't know how active any of the Dragonsteel folks actually are on twitter, but there are better alternatives than a Nazi propaganda forum.
-20
u/KatanaCutlets
Edgedancer
Jan 23 '25
•
This is a ridiculous question. Why would we ban anything of the sort in a fantasy book series sub? Keep real world politics in the real world.
24
-1
u/Virtual-Hour-9540 Jan 23 '25
Honestly. Im perfectly fine with distancing this subreddit away from Musk as much as possible, although allowing screenshots is maybe a good way to maintain freedom of speech. As much as i want to give him the benefit of the doubt, Nazi anything needs to be taken incredibly seriously
5
u/SomeLameName7173 Skybreaker Jan 23 '25
What is worthwhile that has been posted on Twitter that he hasn't posted elsewhere that is worth posting on here
→ More replies (1)
1
u/defnotmysmutaccount Jan 23 '25
Do yourselves a solid and sort by controversial.
With that being said; if it goes against this subs rules or Reddit’s ToS - delete/ban it. It’s that simple.
-18
u/Asparagus-Urethra Jan 23 '25
I have never even used Twitter in my life but go away with these nonsense posts. How often do these links even get posted here?
Discuss Stormlight here, not politics.
4
u/Morriganx3 Jan 23 '25
It’s not about how often they happen. It’s about publicly withdrawing support from entities that promote or support hate.
Even setting the nazi salute aside - and I think it was far too clear to have been accidental - Xitter’s owner uses it to try to manipulate a warped version of free speech that includes a lot of misinformation, bigotry, and violence. He also actively contributes his fair share of all of those.
In the 50s and 60s, my mom wouldn’t patronize any establishment that didn’t allow Balck people. 20 years ago, I wouldn’t sign my son up for Boy Scouts back when they were anti-gay. This is more or less the same thing.
-1
u/SomeDisplayName Jan 23 '25
Please ban billionaires
3
u/Ferret_Gaming Windrunner Jan 23 '25
Careful, our one and only Brando Sando might make it there one day...
-31
u/grand_soul Jan 23 '25
Whelp performative politics has infested another sub. I’m out. Thanks for ruining my escapism.
→ More replies (5)6
-6
-7
u/Sulla_Invictus Jan 23 '25
If you people think that was a Nazi salute you are delusional. You do not live in reality.
Signed, not somebody who has anything nice to say about Elon Musk
-7
u/cpb70 Jan 23 '25
Start banning due to politics and we'd have to consider religion as well. Which will inevitably lead to the author of this sub and that won't be pretty.
11
•
u/spunlines Willshaper Jan 23 '25 edited Jan 23 '25
Update: We tried. Thanks to everyone who gave their input. We'll let you all know once we've decided on next steps.
------
We're going to attempt to have a civil discussion about this. We will likely lock it tonight, and may lock it sooner if things get out of hand.
Let's try to understand each other's perspectives on whether or not there's merit in members of our community using certain website links. This is not a place to discuss the merits of literal nazis.