r/starwarscanon • • Oct 04 '25 Take My Energy Popcorn

Discussion The Return of Palpatine DOES ruin Anakin's arc (and I'm sick of people denying it)

Post image
6.1k Upvotes

The role of Anakin Skywalker in the destruction of the Empire and his master to save his son loses all meaning with Palpatine’s survival. This implies that the Chosen One prophecy not only failed to maintain balance in the Force but literally was never fulfilled. Consequently, the entire narrative arc developed over the six original episodes becomes meaningless.

And to top it off, not only did Palpatine not die, but he managed to reaffirm his control over the galaxy from the shadows, manipulating events through Snoke. The New Jedi Order founded by Luke Skywalker was destroyed, and in its place arose a kind of “Empire 2.0” under another name, once again led by the same villain. So, what was Anakin’s real purpose in the story? None.

Some fans argue that it’s absurd to think there couldn’t be conflicts after the Battle of Endor, since the prophecy only spoke of destroying the Sith. Some even claim that this prophecy might have contradicted George Lucas’s plans to continue the story. However, there’s a serious problem of interpretation here. No one ever said there had to be “eternal peace” in the galaxy. It’s perfectly possible for new threats to emerge, but the Sith cannot return, because the prophecy would have already been fulfilled.

The problem is that Disney, instead of building a story coherent with what came before, chose to copy the structure of the Original Trilogy to guarantee commercial success, even if that meant sacrificing the internal logic of the universe. The Empire “revives” out of nowhere, with apparently unlimited resources, despite having been defeated and dismantled. And to make matters worse, now Palpatine possesses a fleet of Star Destroyers capable of destroying planets—rendering the Death Stars and Starkiller Base irrelevant. Everything achieved in the Original Trilogy is reduced to child’s play.

There are also those who consider the existence of the Chosen One prophecy unnecessary, arguing that it diminishes the Original Trilogy because Anakin would have been destined from the start to kill Palpatine. But that’s not true. In the context of Return of the Jedi, Vader destroys the Emperor to save his son, not because a prophecy dictates it. Both interpretations can coexist: the prophecy and Luke’s actions complement each other. If Luke had not intervened, Anakin would never have escaped his master’s yoke.

As George Lucas explained, it was the love for his son that allowed Anakin to regain his humanity. Luke’s actions, therefore, are not irrelevant, and the prequels do not diminish the Original Trilogy. On the contrary, they reinforce it.

Bringing Palpatine back completely undermines the fulfillment of the prophecy and is, in essence, a desperate act by Disney to draw fans’ attention. Stories must maintain narrative coherence based on what has already been established. If what came before is ignored or invalidated, the question becomes inevitable: why tell it in the first place? Rian Johnson and J.J. Abrams did not respect Lucas’s vision, and altering another creator’s message without honoring his original intent is, at the very least, an act of creative arrogance.

A common argument is that “Palpatine’s clone didn’t unbalance the Force, and Rey simply maintained the balance.” Really? One of Luke’s students fell to the Dark Side, destroyed the New Jedi Order, and drove his master into exile. The Empire rose again under another name, and the galaxy once more fell under the rule of fear. The Jedi were annihilated again, the New Republic was destroyed, and only a small resistance remained. How is that not unbalancing the Force?

We’ve gone back to the exact same point where A New Hope began. What more does it take to consider that the Force is out of balance?

And before anyone says that “the prophecy didn’t speak of destroying the Sith but of maintaining a balance between light and dark,” let’s be clear, that’s a myth. George Lucas has explained on multiple occasions that the Light Side represents the natural state of the Force, while the Dark Side is a corruption of that harmony. That’s an objective fact provided by the creator of Star Wars himself.


r/starwarscanon • • Feb 23 '26

Discussion Why do we never see Force users use hyperspeed again?

Post image
5.6k Upvotes

Lucas only used it once in The Phantom Menace, and even then at a less significant moment in the film.

Now I understand what Anakin saw, more or less, in the Revenge of the Sith novelization when he entered the Chancellor's chamber and saw Windu and Palpatine fighting.

Back to the topic, is it a matter of special effects costs or what?


r/starwarscanon • • Jul 27 '25

Discussion Hold up Jabba the Hut was a Human in 1977? My mind is blown.

Post image
3.7k Upvotes

r/starwarscanon • • Jun 17 '26

TV Show Honestly, while I dislike the Kenobi show, this was a great moment outside of the context. Owen and Beru are unsung heroes of the saga.

Post image
3.7k Upvotes

r/starwarscanon • • May 23 '26

Comic "Who knew anyone of note was ever born on Tattooine?" Jabba shares his knowledge of Kenobi and Luke to Lord Vader

Post image
3.1k Upvotes

from Star Wars #4


r/starwarscanon • • Dec 22 '25

Discussion In your opinion, what are some of the best and worst examples of “fan service” in canon

Thumbnail
gallery
2.6k Upvotes

Fan service is in quotes because it seems like no one can agree on what it means. For the sake of this post, I’m defining it as “something for the put in just for the fans, and doesn’t disrupt the work if you don’t catch the reference.”

Rogue One was heavily criticized for having too much fan service at the time, but I honestly think the many appearances of the Ghost, Chopper’s brief appearance, and the mention of “General Syndulla” were a great way to tie the canon together and weren’t distracting at all. As a Rebels watcher at the time, it really felt like it was worthwhile to keep up with it.

However in the same film, I feel like the C-3PO and R2 cameo is kinda lame and distracting for the simple reason that they could have just been placed in the background on the Tantivie IV and not been as in your face.

Andor is another example of having multiple great references and fan service without being at the expense of the story. My favorite one is the Rakatan Crystal given to him as insurance by Luthen

Okay now for what I consider to be the most pointless and absolute worst instance of fan service in canon; Scorch in Bad Batch

In his initial appearance, it’s fine. It was nice to see him again, and he didn’t say anything so it’s hard to have a problem with it. Then he appears again, as Hemlock’s right hand, having none of the personality or charm of the original character. This can be head cannoned into the chip changing him, but it still begs the question; why even have this be Scorch at all? This could be any other clone. The only reason he’s him is because fans of the classic game will recognize him. And then they kill him… thanks


r/starwarscanon • • Apr 19 '26

Discussion My guess for how old Rotta is in every appearance

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

Wookiepedia states that he was born between 24-22 BBY due to events of Hyperspace Stories 6 (where the 3rd image is from).

His appearance in the comic is an error (being much older than he should) but it is still a canon representation of what he looks like at a certain age.

Im guessing live action baby Rotta is slightly older due to him looking slightly bigger.


r/starwarscanon • • Jan 27 '24

Comic A small interaction but it's very thought-provoking.

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

What does Vader mean? How does he know them by name? Was there another group known as "Knights of Ren" even before Ren and his crew from the comics? I'd love to get a book or comic focused on the Knights to further flesh out their origins.


r/starwarscanon • • Mar 08 '26

Question Why does Grievous wear a cape?

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

It's practically the only clothing he has. (Although Maul didn't initially do this; later he pulled some pants over his prosthetics, while he didn't.) If I remember correctly, in Vader's case, the cape also doubled as a shield protecting the rear, more vulnerable parts of his armor. However, Grievous easily took it off into battle. So what was it like? Was it just a storage area for his trophies? Because I think he also had holders for them on his hips.


r/starwarscanon • • Jan 03 '24

Comic One of my favorite moments in the whole canon.

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

What Disney+ won't show you lol


r/starwarscanon • • Dec 07 '25

Question How many seasons and years will Maul: Shadow Lord run for?

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

The next animated original Star Wars series “Maul: Shadow Lord” premieres next year in 2026 on Disney+, with a release date yet to be revealed. My question is how many seasons should we expect the show to have, as well as how many years could we expect it to run for?

I’m guessing maybe it could be around 3-4 or something. Who knows?


r/starwarscanon • • Jul 01 '25

Question When does this scene at the end of ROTS actually take place in the timeline?

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

r/starwarscanon • • May 07 '26

Question Why did Vader have strips of fabric stretched over his shoulder armor in the initial design, but not later?

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

His armor has generally undergone modifications since A New Hope. A different arrangement of diodes in his life support devices, smooth gloves instead of corrugated ones, and a change in the surface of the armor plates from matte to glossy. What do you think of these changes?


r/starwarscanon • • Jun 18 '25

General Canon An Upscaled Map of The Galaxy from 'Star Wars Complete Locations New Edition'

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

Noticed there was no high quality map of the Star Wars Galaxy on the internet from this book so I upscaled, re-edited and included the major trade routes key to fit within one rectangular frame.

I was intending to print this on a tapestry but it ended up being way too big to put on a wall so I figured I'd upload it incase someone else might have a use for it. Note that a few planets in the Unknown Regions i.e Exegol and Ahck-To have been cropped out in an attempt to make the scale rectangular. I've got one that's in much better quality but had to compress this one down to less than 20mbs due to reddits image size policy, so feel free to reach out if you need it.


r/starwarscanon • • Dec 01 '25

Question Photo of the Death Star laser dish in the wrong spot

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

I was flipping through the 1978 Star Wars Storybook and came across this unusual photo of the Death Star with its laser dish in the “wrong” location, across the equator instead of being off center. Interestingly it matches up with the black and white schematic shown in the film. Do you know of other photographs that have the dish in this location intersecting with the equator? There must have been a model made with this configuration.


r/starwarscanon • • Jun 07 '25 Gold Blast

Timeline Star Wars Canon Timeline, June 2025 Edition

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

Had some people asking for an update, so here it is! Updated with Andor Season 2, Tales of the Underworld, more books and comics (as always), and some refinement courtesy of the great reference book Star Wars Timelines.

Link to the raw Excel sheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1HX8vy3GX1TJxUExYAZKL2qiFVJxZ808P/edit?usp=drive_link&ouid=114915124622515148517&rtpof=true&sd=true


r/starwarscanon • • Feb 12 '21

Meta My Star Wars Galaxy Map V2.1 is done. I keep adding canon planets as they come out. When they don't have official locations, I add them to where they could be and change it later. I added Mando Season 2, Thrawn: Chaos Rising and Squadrons.

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

r/starwarscanon • • Jan 13 '24

Rumor Star Wars What If series possibly in development. If I were to give this a title, it would be "STAR WARS INFINITIES"

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

r/starwarscanon • • May 01 '24

TV Show Star Wars: The Bad Batch Final Poster

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

r/starwarscanon • • Mar 17 '24

Comic Yoda discovers what happened to Yaddle

Post image
979 Upvotes

It's really sad that even all those decades later he still hasn't completely gotten over what happened with Dooku.


r/starwarscanon • • Dec 24 '23

Discussion Which book character do you most want to see pop up in a show or movie?

Post image
963 Upvotes

My pick is Eli Vanto. He's such a compelling character in the Thrawn novels and I'd love to see him pop up in the Mandoverse shows. Maybe even have him take the place of Rukh where he's the one who betrays and kills Thrawn. To me that'd be such a fitting and tragic end to Thrawn, with Vanto being one of the only people that the Grand Admiral had ever referred to as a friend. I think Vanto would realize that in his decade of absence Thrawn has become too corrupted by the dogma of the Empire and is therefore an enemy of the Chiss now, hence why he would do it.

Anywho who are your picks and why?


r/starwarscanon • • Apr 23 '26

Discussion Do you think a real-world Empire would have just collapsed after Endor?

Post image
961 Upvotes

I want to get a few things out of the way first:

  • This isn't in any way, shape, or form an attack on ROTJ's narrative. I know it's a movie; I know that the story needed to wrap up.

  • Obviously, what happened did happen. I'm merely asking if you think it's realistic.

I know that the Empire was wildly unpopular in some corners. I also get that Palpatine had an oversized influence; that his centralized presence wasn't just that of a charismatic man keeping the Empire cohesive, but that there was also a definite "magical" component at play through his manipulation of the dark side of the force.

But even considering those two things, there is at least a case to be made that the Galactic Empire shouldn't have just imploded after Endor.

  1. There were trillions of people around the galaxy who were completely dependent on the system. Not just Imperial leadership or military personnel, but just regular civilians whose entire livelihoods were attached to providing support for the state: manufacturers, traders, miners, etc. All of these people had a vested interest in not seeing the whole government suddenly go ass over teakettle.

  2. The Empire was still wealthy beyond almost all comprehension. It was in no way financially crippled; it had not exhausted some precious, irreplaceable resource. Nor was it out of manpower. Outside the deaths of a few 10s of millions of people (it can be assumed) at Endor, it was still a relatively healthy entity.

  3. The Empire controlled thousands of worlds that could be regarded as completely stable. If the Rebellion was everywhere, all the time, the Empire never would have been able to embark on massive building projects (such as the second Death Star), or prepare intricate traps. Palpatine's confidence of victory at Endor wasn't because he was a desperate man playing his final card - he literally felt like he controlled the entire deck.

  4. While a large portion of the most senior Imperial hierarchy died on the Death Star, it's difficult to believe that this constituted everyone who might have stepped easily into the role of Emperor. Sure, Palpatine had no true heir, but there were people who were positioned to capitalize on his death. And, certainly, there must have been hundreds of such figures not only still alive after Endor, but who had given some thought to what would happen when their very elderly leader one day died.

  5. Finally, I have to point out that there really aren't any real world examples of Empires just self-destructing in the manner we saw in ROTJ. A few potential examples are the Roman Empire (took centuries to whither, and only died [in the west] after sustained invasions from multiple flanks and repeat sackings of Rome), the Russian Empire in 1917 (literally had some of the worst domestic conditions imaginable, a massive war it was losing, unpopular/ineffective leadership, and a broken economy), and the Soviet Union in 1989 (controlled enormous swaths of territory that had been forcibly herded into the Warsaw Pact and no longer wanted to be ruled by Moscow, was collapsing under the economic race with NATO and a number of enormous financial hits induced by events like Chernobyl, was wildly culturally repressive). Other Empires have collapsed, of course (Germany after WWI, Austria Hungary after WWI), but these were nations that were completely exhausted after years of fighting, surrounded, and, in the case of Austria-Hungary, essentially a country living on borrowed time due to its inherent mixture of populations who were innately hostile to one another. Britain after WWII also isn't comparable because it was financially ruined - it simply no longer could afford to maintain its control.

Again, I'm not saying this to try to out-think ROTJ. I'm more just curious whether you - as a person who knows a lot about Star Wars - fully buy off on the idea that the Second Death Star blows up, the Emperor dies, a handful of Star Destroyers and one SSD are destroyed... and that's just it for the Empire.


r/starwarscanon • • Nov 13 '25

Timeline Star Wars Timeline Watch Order

Post image
954 Upvotes

____________________________________________________
Last Update: 05-06-26
________________ Quick Links to:
________________ UPDATES File CLICK HERE
________________ Google Drive CLICK HERE

Most Recent: 
UPDATE 05-21-26:
-Google Drive Link now includes my MARVEL Cinematic Multiverse Timeline for all your Doomsday needs! Along with some Anime, TV Series, Movies, and Video Game Timelines. Please enjoy! Feedback is HIGHLY appreciated!

UPDATE 05-04-26:
-Added "Darth Maul - Shadow Lord" series and "The Mandalorian and Grogu" movie.

-Added a Google Drive Link for Everyone to View and Download their preferred version of the timeline.
More info about GD below.
____________________________________________________

Star Wars: A Cinematic Timeline
Watch Order
(Includes some Legends Continuity mixed with the Canon Universe, and some Canon Games)
Movies/Series/Games in a Chronological Watch Order.

Second Post (Updated Picture) CLICK HERE
____________________________________________________

Google Drive Link! CLICK HERE
☆Bookmark Me, I may never change☆
This link takes you to my Google Drive folder for Timelines.

Recommended: SWT Samsung Notes-C
The Samsung Notes App is downloaded from your phone's App Store. The SWT Samsung Notes-C.sdocx (Samgung Notes Files) can be downloaded on your phone, then tap the file and it opens in the Samsung Notes App. It's the Color Coded Timeline Checklist Version, there's also a non-checklist version. You can edit them and check the boxes to mark off what you've watched!
Example Pictures of Samsung Notes: CLICK HERE

-Click into the Star Wars Cinematic Timeline folder to View and Download your preferred version of my most recent updated Timeline.

This Folder includes:
-Picture Versions (with Lightsaber Backgrounds! Updated and WAY BETTER than the picture in this post)

-Checklist Picture Versions (same as above but with check boxes)

-File Versions: .txt [Notepad], PDF, and .sdocx [for the "Samsung Notes" App]

-There's a "SWT README info.txt" file that has info on what the folders contain. Double-Click or Tap the file to view and read it.
-Do the same to Preview any Picture, .txt, and PDF files.
____________________________________________________
ALL UPDATES will be posted to the "SWT Updates.txt" file inside the "4. UPDATES" folder viewable in the Google Drive folder. This is to prevent an even larger wall of text making these posts less user friendly. I will also post here the last time it was updated.
Quick Link to View the UPDATES File CLICK HERE
____________________________________________________

Alternative A- NOT Support Google: If you do NOT want to visit the Google Drive, I will happily Reddit Chat or Email you whatever picture timeline or file version that you want!

Alternative B: Use the Text Timeline at the bottom of this post.
____________________________________________________

PLEASE COMMENT any questions, suggestions, anything that may be wrong with my Google Drive, NEW Star Wars movies/series/games coming out that I need to add (I usually add them within 24hrs of someone commenting), and comment your favorite color Lightsaber Picture or your favorite File Version!

THANK YOU to every commentor who's contributed to this post. Your comments, good or bad, have given me the motivation to continue updating and making it easier for everyone to enjoy!!
May The Force Be With You All.

*This timeline is for entertainment purposes. This is not an official Lucasfilm or Disney timeline. User/Viewer discretion is advised.

PHONE USERS, or if things look outta place, adjust ZOOM - or + in your browser settings.

____________________________________________________
Timeline SECTION
____________________________________________________

STAR WARS CINEMATIC TIMELINE
Italicized = Series 
BOLD = Movies
☆Canon Video Games
*Optional Star Wars Legends Continuity, Non-Canon

Star Wars: Young Jedi Adventures (2023-25)

The Acolyte (2024)-season 1

Star Wars: Tales of the Underworld (2025)-episodes 4-6

Star Wars: Tales of the Jedi (2022)-episodes 2, 3, 1

Star Wars: Ep.I - The Phantom Menace (1999)

Star Wars: Tales of the Jedi -episode 4

Star Wars: Ep.II - Attack of the Clones (2002)

*Star Wars (Vintage): Clone Wars (2D Micro Series) (2003)

Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008-20)~Episode Reorder:
### = #=Season, ##=Episode
216, 116,
Star Wars: The Clone Wars (movie, 2008),
301, 303,
101-115,
117-121,
201-203,
217-219,
204-214,
220-222,
305-307,
302, 304, 308,
122,
309-311,
215,
312-322,
401-419

Star Wars: Tales of the Empire -episode 1

Star Wars: The Clone Wars ~Episode Reorder:
420-422
502-513,
501,
514-520,
601-613,
705-708,
701-704

Star Wars: Episode III.5
- Revenge of the Sith - The Siege of Mandalore SuperCut
☆☆☆☆☆☆ Or Watch ☆☆☆☆☆☆
Star Wars: Ep.III - Revenge of the Sith (2005)

(Siege of Mandalore Arc)
Star Wars: The Clone Wars -season 7 episodes 09-12

Star Wars: Tales of the Jedi -episode 5

Star Wars: Tales of the Empire -episode 4

Star Wars: The Bad Batch (2021-24)-season 1

Star Wars: Tales of the Jedi -episode 6

Star Wars: Tales of the Underworld -episodes 1-3

Star Wars: The Bad Batch -season 2

Star Wars: The Bad Batch -season 3

☆Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order (2019)

Star Wars: Maul - Shadow Lord (2026)-season 1

Star Wars: Tales of the Empire -episode 5

Solo: A Star Wars Story (2018)

Obi-Wan Kenobi (2022)-season 1

☆Star Wars Jedi: Survivor (2023)

*Star Wars: Droids (1985-86)
*Star Wars: Ewoks (1986-87)

Star Wars: Tales of the Empire -episode 6

Star Wars Rebels (2014-18)-season 1, episodes 1-5

Andor (2022-25)-season 1, episodes 1-7

Star Wars Rebels -season 1, episode 6

Andor -season 1, episodes 8-10

Star Wars Rebels -season 1, episode 7

Andor -season 1, episodes 11-12

Star Wars Rebels -season 1, episode 8-15

Star Wars: Tales of the Empire -episode 2

Star Wars Rebels -season 2, episodes 1-8

Andor -season 2, episodes 1-3

Star Wars Rebels -season 2, episodes 9-22

Andor -season 2, episodes 4-6

Star Wars Rebels -season 3, episodes 1-16

Andor -season 2, episodes 7-8

Star Wars Rebels -season 3, episode 17

Andor -season 2, episode 9

Star Wars Rebels -season 3, episode 18-22

Star Wars Rebels -season 4, episodes 1-15

Andor -season 2, episodes 10-12

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (2016)

Star Wars: Ep.IV - A New Hope (1977)

*Star Wars Holiday Special (Life Day) (1978)

Star Wars: Ep.V - The Empire Strikes Back (1980)

☆Star Wars Outlaws (2024)

*Caravan of Courage: An Ewok Adventure (1984)
*Ewoks: The Battle for Endor (1985)

Star Wars: Ep. VI - Return of the Jedi (1983)

☆Star Wars Battlefront II (2017)
☆Star Wars: Squadrons (2020)

The Mandalorian (2019-23)-season 1

The Mandalorian -season 2, chapters 9-12

Star Wars: Tales of the Empire -episode 3

The Mandalorian -season 2, chapters 13-16

The Book of Boba Fett (2021)-season 1

The Mandalorian -season 3

Ahsoka (2023)-season 1

Skeleton Crew (2024)-season 1

Star Wars: The Mandalorian and Grogu (2026)

Star Wars Resistance (2018-20)-season 1, episodes 1-19

Star Wars: Ep.VII - The Force Awakens (2015)

Star Wars Resistance -season 1, episodes 20-21

Star Wars Resistance -season 2, episode 1

Star Wars: Ep.VIII - The Last Jedi (2017)

Star Wars Resistance -season 2, episodes 2-19

Star Wars: Ep.IX - The Rise of Skywalker (2019)

Whichever order you choose…is the right one.
May the Force be with you.

____________________________________________________
FOR SUPER DUPER FANS!
____________________________________________________

STAR WARS: Ep.III.5 - Revenge Of The Sith - Clone Wars, The Siege Of Mandalore
SuperCut Watch Order

Star Wars: The Clone Wars s7e09: Old Friends Not Forgotten
0:00 to 16:25

Star Wars: Ep.III - Revenge of the Sith (2005)
0:00 to 27:34

CW s7e09
16:26 to 26:15

CW s7e10: The Phantom Apprentice
0:00 to 2:59

RotS
27:35 to 51:40

CW s7e10
3:00 to 24:16

RotS
51:41 to 1:00:54

CW s7e11: Shattered
0:00 to 2:19

RotS
1:00:55 to 1:01:54

CW s7e11
2:20 to 9:41

RotS
1:01:55 to 1:15:20

CW s7e11
9:42 to 10:18

RotS
1:15:21 to 1:23:32

CW s7e11
10:19 to 23:32

RotS
1:23:33 to 1:29:55

CW s7e12: Victory and Death
0:00 to 17:08

Finish SW: Ep.III - Revenge of the Sith Movie

Finish CW s7e12: Victory and Death Episode

____________________________________________________


r/starwarscanon • • Jul 30 '24

Question [Darth Vader 2017] New Star Wars fan here. Did Master Nu mean that Sidious wanted to replace Vader? If so, why would he do that?

Thumbnail
gallery
920 Upvotes