r/ratemysong • • Oct 05 '19

Discussion Whats wrong with this sub?

54 Upvotes

I am really dissapointed.

I get it. You want to get your music heard. Thats fine, we all do.

Wouldn't it be even better though, if you actually got some feedback? Well guess what? Nobody cares about your shit if they don't know or like you as a person!

How can you expect others to engage with you if all you do is come here to post your music without taking the the time and effort to listen to others an give them honest, valuable feedback?

I just went though pages and pages of songs dropping a comment here and there, whether I liked it or not, but noticed that almost every post has 0 comments.

My questions is: What the actual fuck? Is literally every one of you 10000 members only here for self promo?

Edit: Damn, even just give an upvote (or downvotes for that matter).. It takes like 0.1 seconds of your precious time.


r/ratemysong • • Aug 09 '25

Discussion Idk what genre this is but im really proud of it, would love some feedback.

44 Upvotes

r/ratemysong • • Mar 23 '26

Discussion Send me your songs and I'll listen to them

28 Upvotes

I listen to music everywhere and want some new songs on my playlists so please leave a song in the comments and I'll give it a try and if I like it I will add it to my playlist!


r/ratemysong • • Oct 16 '25

Acoustic Not sure if this vocal style works or not

27 Upvotes

r/ratemysong • • Jun 11 '25

Alternative is anybody feeling whatever this even is?

27 Upvotes

(song: slow nova by shrimpnose)


r/ratemysong • • Dec 27 '18

Announcement READ THE RULES. ALL OFFENDING POSTS WILL BE REMOVED

25 Upvotes

It's simple, guys.

-Critique a song before or after you post. No one's going to give a rating if they have never received one themselves.

-Title your post properly (SEE RULE 6).

There is an AutoMod bot that will message you with a reminder EVERY TIME YOU POST.

Please just follow the rules. It takes less than a minute to read, and the community will improve greatly.

Thank you,

Alpha Nova | u/SeymourJames

Edit:Removed non-constructive/ passive-aggressive lines, spelling.


r/ratemysong • • May 09 '20

Alternative [Alt-Pop] Neon Dreams - Sick of Feeling Useless

Thumbnail
youtube.com
21 Upvotes

r/ratemysong • • Jun 19 '19

Discussion I enjoy listening to all of your songs and want to hear more

21 Upvotes

I just discovered this Sub and will be going through and listening to a lot of your songs! Even older ones. I am a Semi Professional musician who loves new music and I think it's wonderful people are looking for critiques and thoughts on their music. I hope you all continue to keep trying to learn and improve your art. I can see this Sub is not super active, and was wondering if there is another Subreddit that is similar. If I'm breaking any rules by posting this I understand if it's gotta be taken down. Keep writing, keep posting, and keep learning!!!


r/ratemysong • • Dec 09 '25

Discussion drop your track too

20 Upvotes

r/ratemysong • • Jun 22 '24

Alternative I made this on the roof top at 5am in Malta watching the sun rise over the Mediterranean Sea. Let me know your thoughts

Thumbnail
youtu.be
20 Upvotes

r/ratemysong • • Jun 15 '25

Discussion My first song release, what do you think?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
19 Upvotes

It's mostly freestyled with the exception of the bridge. I would love to hear some feedback. Thanks in advance ๐Ÿค™๐Ÿพ


r/ratemysong • • Feb 20 '22

Discussion Do you want feedback for your song?

19 Upvotes

I've been coming to r/ratemysong off and on for some time now. I hate to say it, but I don't think any one has ever rated any of my songs. Or upvoted. Or even listened. I'm sure that's true for many of you as well.

If we want our songs rated, we should do more listening and rating.

I'm going to commit to rating as many songs as I can every night, for the next month. I challenge everyone else that pops in here to join me. It's the only way to foster a community that is willing to post AND listen.

It feels good to finish a work and have it heard. Let's make this subreddit more enjoyable by inspiring each other to make more content and grow as musicians.

Here's some of the vocabulary I use to discuss music

How does it sound?

  • Clear

  • Muddy

  • Crisp

  • Quiet

  • Loud

How does it feel?

  • Jarring

  • Fun

  • Exciting

  • Disorganized

  • Happy / Somber / Sad

How are the vocals?

  • Dissonant

  • Pitchy

  • Not emoting

  • Breathy

  • Powerful

  • Timid

How is the rhythm?

  • Makes you want to move

  • Boring

  • Predictable

  • Complex

  • Fun

Other commentary you can make

  • Is the genre correct?

  • What does it remind you of?

  • Will you listen to it again?

  • Does it move you?

  • What makes this song special?

Here is an example template for giving feedback

I listened to your song ___ times through.

My favorite thing was ___.

I feel like the song could be more interesting if ___.

I'd like to hear more of ___.

I would love it if you could give feedback to ___. (link to a r/ratemysong post)

Keep making music.


r/ratemysong • • 27d ago

Rock [Rock] me- The Gravel Line

17 Upvotes

Could I please get some honest feedback, I feel like the finished product isn't what I envisioned when starting but this could be because I've heard it so much.

It would be good to get a breakdown of what works and what doesn't.

Thanks in advance!


r/ratemysong • • Nov 05 '22

House [Tech House] tom - freaks (we're just happier)

15 Upvotes

been working on this for a few days - lmk what you think!

https://soundcloud.com/tom12345678910/freaks-were-just-happier

probably going to redo some of the vocals but otherwise pretty close to finished ๐Ÿ˜Ž


r/ratemysong • • Feb 04 '26

Alternative [8-bit Thrash Metal] Benikurage - Release of the Id

14 Upvotes

Any feedback, even if nitpicky is welcome. I feel I've reached a ceiling, but there should be room to improve.


r/ratemysong • • Oct 13 '25

Acoustic Rate my song.

14 Upvotes

Obviously still a work in progress and I am going to add vocals but is this melody unique?


r/ratemysong • • Jul 23 '25

Acoustic Thanks for listening

14 Upvotes

Any feedback is greatly appreciated.


r/ratemysong • • Mar 15 '20

Lo-Fi I'm new at making music. I made this piano and guitar song.. What do you think ?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
14 Upvotes

r/ratemysong • • May 04 '26

Electronic [Electronic] LORE1A1 - MEETING HER

13 Upvotes

Itโ€™s my first time posting my demo, iโ€™d be happy to get some feedback ๐Ÿ˜‹
Also Iโ€™d like to ask what genre it is because i donโ€™t know lol.
And if thereโ€™s any lyricists who would like to collab Iโ€™d be happy as peaches ๐Ÿ‘


r/ratemysong • • Dec 21 '25

Indie rate my song i rate yours

12 Upvotes

r/ratemysong • • Aug 30 '25

Electro House I made electrohouse for the first time.

12 Upvotes

Im a year into music prod. how am i doing so far? i tried to mix it to sound professional


r/ratemysong • • Jan 11 '20

Progressive Metal What do you guys think? Any feedback would be great ๐Ÿ‘

Thumbnail
youtu.be
12 Upvotes

r/ratemysong • • Apr 23 '17

Hometown Losers - Space Girl [Alternative/Indie/Punk Rock] (2017)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
12 Upvotes

r/ratemysong • • Dec 13 '13

[Alt/Indie/Electronic] Flight of Ryan - "Technicolor Souls"

Thumbnail
soundcloud.com
12 Upvotes

r/ratemysong • • Oct 11 '26

Soft Rock How i made "Watched you fly"

11 Upvotes