r/Python • • Aug 05 '19

Python's response to MATLAB

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

372 comments sorted by

View all comments

426

u/Stereoisomer Aug 05 '19 edited Aug 05 '19

In my experience, a programmer saying they actually like MATLAB immediately attracts every python dev in a five mile radius

Edit: someone edit this meme and post here for a karma double-dip I’m too lazy

297

u/cue_the_strings Aug 05 '19

In my experience, a programmer saying they actually like MATLAB means they either know very little about general programming, are not primarily a programmer but an engineer or have been pidgeonholed into doing just one thing that MATLAB does okay for quite a while.

The language is ugly and some relatively normal features are horribly clunky to use (object-oriented stuff, GUI primitives, ...), antiquated syntax that reminds me of BASIC. If you used any moderately modern language, (C++, Java, JavaScript, Python, Rust, Nim, ...) or even old ones like C, Lisp, Haskell - you just cannot like it.

54

u/mexiKobe Aug 05 '19 edited Aug 05 '19

The language is ugly

Not at all for numerical calculations / matrix math etc. It’s very good for that, better than Python with numpy. Look at these comparisons https://docs.scipy.org/doc/numpy-1.15.0/user/numpy-for-matlab-users.html

I mean saying it is uglier than C++ is kind of silly. Try doing simple vectorized calculations from MATLAB but in C++ and get back to me on that. And JavaScript? Come on man lol.

But yeah the problem is when engineers and scientists only use it and try to write applications with it. I’ve seen some FUCKED UP code written in MATLAB being used at huge research hospitals and in national security, and “subversioned” with duplicates on Dropbox. It’s actually extremely common, which should be shocking

1

u/I_Feel_It_Too Aug 06 '19

Not at all for numerical calculations / matrix math etc.

No, the language is grotesque for numerical calculations. It might be good at doing matrix computations, but that doesn't mean the language isn't hideous. And it isn't that good at matrix computations, either, because it's so shit at memory management, reading fucking plaintext from a file, anything having to do with the most elementary data structures, handling errors, ....

There are free alternatives to Matlab for literally anything that Matlab is good at that perform at least as good as Matlab does.

0

u/mexiKobe Aug 06 '19

You’re simply wrong

0

u/I_Feel_It_Too Aug 06 '19

Oh for Christ's sake. Here's math.js, copied and pasted from docs:

// create an array and a matrix
const array = [[2, 0], [-1, 3]]               // Array
const matrix = math.matrix([[7, 1], [-2, 3]]) // Matrix

// perform a calculation on an array and matrix
math.square(array)                            // Array,  [[4, 0], [1, 9]]
math.square(matrix)                           // Matrix, [[49, 1], [4, 9]]

// perform calculations with mixed array and matrix input
math.add(array, matrix)                       // Matrix, [[9, 1], [-3, 6]]
math.multiply(array, matrix)                  // Matrix, [[14, 2], [-13, 8]]

It's even easier with C++:

#include <iostream>
#include <Eigen/Dense>
// Create a 2x2 matrix called a.
Matrix2d a;
a << 1, 2,
     3, 4;
// Create a 2x2 matrix called b using an alternative but just as easy syntax.
MatrixXd b(2,2);
b << 2, 3,
     1, 4;
//Their sum
a + b;
//Their difference.
a - b;
// Increment a by amount b.
a += b;

// Make some 3d vectors.
Vector3d v(1,2,3);
Vector3d w(1,0,0);
// Mother fucking scalar product.
w - 2*v;
// Vector product. BAM!
w*v;

It's almost like you've never even fucking seen vectorized calculations done in C++.

And I'm not even sure if you are using that word right. MathWorks sure as hell doesn't. You see, in the world of numerical computing, vectorization means using processor instructions (sometimes called SIMD instructions) that are designed to work on multiple data elements at the same time, whereas in the land of Matlab it means not using a for loop. Which, to be fair, is good advice in most languages, but especially in Matlab where interpreted code is apparently transcribed by a hamster before execution on an abacus.

The Eigen C++ code above automatically uses SIMD instructions. In fact, it automatically uses the most powerful SIMD instructions on the many different hardware platforms it supports.

Meanwhile, Matlab... might use SIMD instructions maybe? depending on the computation you're doing. And despite being a CAS specifically focused on linear algebra, Matlab only gained this ability in, like, 2011. I kid you not. And it only got it then because it adopted MKL. Which means, for those keeping track at home, that only those operations for which Matlab uses MKL (plus FFT, apparently) use SIMD. How... cutting edge.

1

u/mexiKobe Aug 06 '19 edited Aug 06 '19

You said MATLAB was an ugly language for matrix calculations and then responded with some extremely basic operations in C++ using an external library. I don’t know what point that’s supposed to be proving. No one in research uses C++ as an alternative for MATLAB for a ton of reasons, one being that you have to compile it. This should be obvious to you.

I mean you claimed MATLAB was worse at managing memory than C++ which is nonsensical. C++ is slowly dying specifically because it doesn’t manage memory

and yes ‘vectorized’ in MATLAB means using vector operations instead of for loops so it is optimized better. If you really need to use SIMD you can always write a MEX function

0

u/I_Feel_It_Too Aug 07 '19

You said MATLAB was an ugly language for matrix calculations and then responded with some extremely basic operations in C++

... Yes I did? Because you literally said, and I'm going to quote you here, "Try doing simple vectorized calculations from MATLAB but in C++ and get back to me on that. And JavaScript? Come on man lol." And so I did simple vectorized calculations from Matlab but in C++ and then got back to you, you know, like you said. Except they the operations were actually vectorized in C++, whereas Matlab uses serial operations for matrix addition and subtraction. So where is the confusion here? Maybe here:

in C++ using an external library.

Oh, so it really just sounds like you're confused because you don't know how software works. Eigen is a C++ library. To do matrix/vector math in C++, you use a C++ library like Eigen, which, if I may reiterate, is written in C++. I wonder, do you know how Matlab does it's matrix arithmetic? For some of its operations, it uses Intel's Math Kernel Library (MKS), and MKS is in turn written in C/C++ and Fortran (and probably a little assembly language). Now I'm wondering what you think "external library" means.

The only part of Matlab that is actually optimized for modern processors is the part that uses MKS, because MKS is optimized for modern processors using SIMD.

This is basically where I realize you don't know how computers work. Not that there's anything wrong with that. It's just an unusual feature of someone who is arguing the superiority of one computer programming language over another.

I mean you claimed MATLAB was worse at managing memory than C++ which is nonsensical. C++ is slowly dying specifically because it doesn’t manage memory

At this point I am starting to doubt that you have ever used Matlab, much less C++. Even the hardcore Matlab apologists on this thread acknowledge how shitty Matlab is at memory management. Again, not that there's anything wrong with that, either. It's just, well, an unusual feature of someone who is arguing Matlab's superiority.

and yes ‘vectorized’ in MATLAB means using vector operations instead of for loops so it is optimized better. If you really need to use SIMD you can always write a MEX function

Aaaaand here's where I realize that it's not going to help much to explain things to you, so I might as well go back through my response and point out all the places I realize how little you know about what you are talking about, because it's a little more fun to be an asshole than to talk to a brick wall. Normally I have a twinge of guilt about indulging in assholerly solely for the entertainment value, but based on your comment history I can tell you are truly a horrible bigoted asshole, so I'm actually ok with this one.

→ More replies (3)