Our instructor warned us of the j, k that when giving us an intro to loops and stuff. This design decision further shows that MATLAB was meant for the engineering / physics crowd. As you already know, using i and j as unnamed counters is pretty much a convention in computer programming (C-derived languages especially), the designers certainly knew that it would be a problem, yet they decided they'd just make it more convenient for the non-programmer crowd.
I see MATLAB as a mutation of an ancient attempt to make a tool + language for engineers and scientists, which would be 'simple to learn' and have everything they need for numerical computation, visualization, ... But decidedly not for programmers. The dumb BASIC-like syntax is a consequence of that decision - at the time, BASIC was considered the 'easy' language for non-programmers that everybody could learn. It was even taught in schools.
Anyway, as it usually goes, once something is made one way, it's really hard to change it. There are and were large swaths of people to whom MATLAB is the only language they use. They don't know or care about any subtleties of programming as long as MATLAB helps them do their job. And those people learned it one way and are very resistant to change, they would be pissed off if the syntax was changed (say, for the better, not that they would know). So the language was just added onto and never revised, there are often multiple ways to do one thing because removing syntax is a taboo. The result is, of course, a hot mess.
You haven't met the people that "program" programmable logic controllers with "ladder logic". If you want to talk about lock in... Now that's an entirely different level.
Yeah, they're going to use i or j as the imaginary unit, and any numerical methods recipes they look up are going to have them using i and j and k as loop variables. It will obviously not end well.
And you're right that they're probably stuck with the design decision at this point, which is why I suggested printing a warning to the console, it would give people a heads-up without breaking backward compatibility.
30
u/cue_the_strings Aug 05 '19
Our instructor warned us of the j, k that when giving us an intro to loops and stuff. This design decision further shows that MATLAB was meant for the engineering / physics crowd. As you already know, using
iandjas unnamed counters is pretty much a convention in computer programming (C-derived languages especially), the designers certainly knew that it would be a problem, yet they decided they'd just make it more convenient for the non-programmer crowd.I see MATLAB as a mutation of an ancient attempt to make a tool + language for engineers and scientists, which would be 'simple to learn' and have everything they need for numerical computation, visualization, ... But decidedly not for programmers. The dumb BASIC-like syntax is a consequence of that decision - at the time, BASIC was considered the 'easy' language for non-programmers that everybody could learn. It was even taught in schools.
Anyway, as it usually goes, once something is made one way, it's really hard to change it. There are and were large swaths of people to whom MATLAB is the only language they use. They don't know or care about any subtleties of programming as long as MATLAB helps them do their job. And those people learned it one way and are very resistant to change, they would be pissed off if the syntax was changed (say, for the better, not that they would know). So the language was just added onto and never revised, there are often multiple ways to do one thing because removing syntax is a taboo. The result is, of course, a hot mess.