r/Python • • Sep 15 '15

Ask microsoft to include Python in Windows by default

https://windows.uservoice.com/forums/265757-windows-feature-suggestions/suggestions/6693586-ship-python-3-and-python-2-with-windows-10
1.2k Upvotes

329 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/the_hoser Sep 15 '15

NO! NO NO NO NO NO! I do NOT want this!

It would literally be the worst thing to happen to Python in Windows. It would co-opt the definition of "Python" to be "the version on Windows" all of Python software would be written to conform to their version, with whatever modifications they decide to make.

The best thing that Microsoft could do for Python is to provide a standards-compliant C compiler and build environment. Beyond that, their contributions to make Python work better in Windows are enough.

-2

u/desmoulinmichel Sep 15 '15

Right now you know what's is the best version of Python ? None. Nobody knows what to target. Nobody knows how to do cross-plateform scripting. Nobody can share a quick python script with a non dev on windwos.

So you assume it will be a problem (which stays to be proven, since 3.x is forward compatible and can be upgraded through windows update) and provide a solution that does not solve the cross plateform scripting problem at all.

3

u/the_hoser Sep 15 '15

Right now you know what's is the best version of Python ? None.

My opinion says 3.4 is pretty awesome. I'm still chewing on 3.5. That's an opinion, though. You can't have an objective "best version".

Nobody knows what to target.

That's not true at all. You target your audience. If you're a library vendor, you target the versions you want to support.

Nobody knows how to do cross-plateform scripting. Nobody can share a quick python script with a non dev on windwos.

But why does it have to be Python? Why do we need to sully application development in Python to make scripting 'easier' in Windows?

So you assume it will be a problem (which stays to be proven, since 3.x is forward compatible and can be upgraded through windows update) and provide a solution that does not solve the cross plateform scripting problem at all.

I have, though. Bash would be a superior solution. Development of bash is slow-moving. There are no plugin requirements for bash. Nobody writes applications in Bash, so holding people to an older version would have minimal impact. Bash would be vastly superior!