r/Python • • 10d ago

Discussion PYTHON πŸ†š ALL ...

"If you want to learn programming, don’t start with Python; you should start with another language."

This advice seems ridiculous to me, even though I hear it everywhere. Can someone explain this advice to me... and are they right?

0 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

View all comments

-6

u/fab_dot_io 10d ago

Microcode -> assembly -> C -> python. Prove me wrong

7

u/johnklotter 10d ago

It’s the other way around. From high to low concept.

Learn programming, then learn how to do it good and why that’s so.

-4

u/fab_dot_io 10d ago

Why you say so?

You want to master machines without knowing how do they work?

I mean I'm a huge fan to start teaching quaternions to kids and then move down to natural numbers but really is the other way around.

Unless you want to be an amateur. In that case anything is just fine.

2

u/kcunning 10d ago

You don't master any subject by starting at the hardest level and then moving to the easier topics. When you're learning, you're building a framework, and the easiest way to do that is to start with concepts that are easy to understand (a variable stores a value that can change over time!), then digging deeper (data is stored in physical locations on the machine that you can reference via their address) and deeper (data is stored as a series of ones and zeros because binary is the base for all computing).

-1

u/fab_dot_io 10d ago edited 10d ago

Why you are assuming that low level means harder? And why are you assuming that you need to master it?

I mean I'm serious go to exuarch.com and build yourself a 16 bit microcontroller. There's a tutorial it won't take more than an evening.

You can't do AI in microcode. But assembly would seem pretty obvious. Because that's what happened back then.

You can't do AI in assembly, but you will feel that all that conditional jumps are just so inconvenient and that C flow control stuff are so great that it will look like cheating.

Now you can do AI in C but this is not the point 😁. Then python becomes just a way to be free and dynamic.

2

u/kcunning 10d ago

I know low level tends to be harder for new coders to grasp because I've actually taught them. Sure, I can quickly allude to the fact that binary and assembly exist, but that's not the same as teaching it. It's a fun fact that can be explored more in depth later.

As for 'mastery', I don't mean being an unquestionable expert. In the field of learning and education, it has to do with competence in a subject that's required before moving on to the next unit.

And as for tutorials, I've personally found that tutorials, without base knowledge, aren't effective. It's why the lab comes after the lecture, and it's why the Godot forums are filled with people stuck in 'tutorial hell.'

0

u/fab_dot_io 10d ago

My learning and teaching experience was quite the opposite. I mean I have also learnt informatics that way at High school, it wasn't exactly rocket science.

I mentioned to have a tutorial for exuarch.com because that's just what you really need to know about microcode and how CPUs work.

Really give it a try. My point is still that anybody really need to start from the beginning and make sure to get the fundamentals.

Everything tend to make way more sense from a didactic standpoint because that's how the things developed over time and how we solved the same problems and limitations you are feeling while following that part.