r/Python • • Jan 28 '26 • This 2 Bravo 1

Meta (Rant) AI is killing programming and the Python community

I'm sorry but it has to come out.

We are experiencing an endless sleep paralysis and it is getting worse and worse.

Before, when we wanted to code in Python, it was simple: either we read the documentation and available resources, or we asked the community for help, roughly that was it.

The advantage was that stupidly copying/pasting code often led to errors, so you had to take the time to understand, review, modify and test your program.

Since the arrival of ChatGPT-type AI, programming has taken a completely different turn.

We see new coders appear with a few months of experience in programming with Python who give us projects of 2000 lines of code with an absent version manager (no rigor in the development and maintenance of the code), comments always boats that smell the AI from miles around, a .md boat also where we always find this logic specific to the AI and especially a program that is not understood by its own developer.

I have been coding in Python for 8 years, I am 100% self-taught and yet I am stunned by the deplorable quality of some AI-doped projects.

In fact, we are witnessing a massive arrival of new projects that are basically super cool and that are in the end absolutely null because we realize that the developer does not even master the subject he deals with in his program, he understands that 30% of his code, the code is not optimized at all and there are more "import" lines than algorithms thought and thought out for this project.

I see it and I see it personally in the science given in Python where the devs will design a project that by default is interesting, but by analyzing the repository we discover that the project is strongly inspired by another project which, by the way, was itself inspired by another project. I mean, being inspired is ok, but here we are more in cloning than in the creation of a project with real added value.

So in 2026 we find ourselves with posts from people with a super innovative and technical project that even a senior dev would have trouble developing alone and looking more closely it sounds hollow, the performance is chaotic, security on some projects has become optional. the program has a null optimization that uses multithreads without knowing what it is or why. At this point, reverse engineering will no longer even need specialized software as the errors will be aberrant. I'm not even talking about the optimization of SQL queries that makes you dizzy.

Finally, you will have understood, I am disgusted by this minority (I hope) of dev who are boosted with AI.

AI is good, but you have to know how to use it intelligently and with hindsight and a critical mind, but some take it for a senior Python dev.

Subreddits like this are essential, and I hope that devs will continue to take the time to inquire by exploring community posts instead of systematically choosing ease and giving blind trust to an AI chat.

1.8k Upvotes

478 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Fragrant_Ad3054 Jan 29 '26

What you're saying makes a lot of sense, and I agree with you on many points. I use AI in a very localized way to search for a specific term. I sometimes ask the AI ​​to code 20 lines to see if its output provides better reasoning on the specific topic at that moment. But it's more the overall form of its output that interests me; I very rarely just pick and choose lines of code.

And indeed, as you say, my problem is people who misuse AI, treating it like an office colleague who will do everything for them without trying to understand anything and without worrying about the quality of the output code.

Finally, to be honest, AI is also a bit of a problem for me because when I ask fairly specific questions, I notice absurdities in the responses.

For example, in my projects, I know that half of them aren't compatible with AI because they're too technical and complex, and have too high an error rate. I even calculated it for fun. And in some projects, the AI ​​gave me up to a 30% error rate in its answers, even though the questions were about a very localized part of the project.

0

u/Joppsta Jan 29 '26 edited Jan 29 '26

The problem with me for your anecdotal evidence about error rates is that you are a biased source of information just going from your original post. Without understanding the context, which model you were using, seeing the prompts myself and whatnot I can't say whether I agree or disagree with your methodology.

I dunno what professional context you're working in that you view it like that, but I don't think it's like that at all in any decent reputable company.

"For example, in my projects, I know that half of them aren't compatible with AI because they're too technical and complex"

This just sounds like pure egotistical self-stroking. You complain about people misuing AI and then provide evidence that you yourself do not understand how to use it effectively. The point of using AI when coding isn't to replace coding, it's to enhance it. My error rate, if we'll call it that, is probably higher than 30%, I'd say 90% of the code I get from AI I don't copy paste 1:1, but even though the AI doesn't give me code I can copy paste, what it gives me is a second perspective to consider or adapt the bits that look applicable into my code. AI is a rubber duck without a salary.

1

u/Fragrant_Ad3054 Jan 29 '26

No, no, there's no problem with equality or self-satisfaction, but here's the thing: AI can't bring me anything in intelligence software because I know what I'm doing, what I'm coding, and the few times I've wanted to check something, it's given me an answer that's completely out of context.

And the 30% error rate? Yes, it's true, but I don't see why I should bother sending you a PDF showing you, with proof, that it can get 30% wrong answers for what I ask it. I'm capable of doing it, no problem, but I don't owe you anything, so you don't believe me, and that's just how it is.

I also thank you for your concern about my ability to use AI. I want to reassure you that everything is fine. Finally, I think we've strayed quite a bit from the original post, which is primarily about developers abusing AI.

-1

u/Joppsta Jan 29 '26

"Because I know what I'm doing"

You might know what you're doing - but you don't know everything. Nobody can and it's humility that allows you to continue growing.

1

u/Fragrant_Ad3054 Jan 29 '26

That's true, you're right. Humility, it's true, sounds like something I've never heard of, but I am humble because I only master a tiny fraction of the possibilities that Python offers.

0

u/AgentDutch Jan 29 '26

You are extremely smug for having as little experience and understanding as you do. Bonus points for chastising others about being biased when you led with “if I didn’t have AI I would’ve been screwed!”

We know you need AI to do your job, and I like to use it for mine, but some of us don’t need for the vast majority of cases, maybe troubleshooting arbitrary task here, or save some time on boilerplate here.