The concern is that if the soviet union didn't have strong centralised leadership from day one they would have been been destroyed immediately and they would be back to square 1.
Well for one thing Socialism in one country was a failed concept, especially compared to the permanent revolution. Forming a united front with the enemies of German fascism pre-WW2 rather than purporting the myth of Social Fascism as well. The purges were also the height of paranoia, and actively contributed to his death.
All in all, I believe that Stalinism actively led to most of the (largely incorrect) fears that people have of Communism these days
All in all though, this is a historic debate, and shouldn’t stand between two Irish Socialists Comrádaí
Yeah, but I'm sure every country that elected a socialist leader getting couped by the CIA and/or sanctioned to fuck by the US State Dept was also a huge deterrent. "Look at what happens to countries that embrace socialism!!"
The Soviet Union under Stalin did try and form a united front with the UK and France before molitov-ribbetrop pact was ever signed, but they were turned down.
-16
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '20
As a socialist in what way would you have ruled differently than Stalin?