r/politicalopinion • u/newyork0120 • Feb 21 '22
We Must Openly Call Out “Lia” Thomas And The Whole Trans Charade
The Ivy League Women’s Swimming Championships were held last week. This is not the sort of event that would normally attract much attention, especially from me, except that it was the culmination of a year’s worth of controversy surrounding “transgender” swimmer Lia Thomas, a male who says that he’s a woman. Lia Thomas, as you’re probably familiar with by now, was a man his whole life and for the first three years of his college swimming career (and still is one, actually), but during that time as a college male swimmer named William, he ranked somewhere in the mid-400s. So, as an athlete, he could be most generously described as mediocre.
But then, through some miracle of science, wonder of wonders, William realized that he is actually a woman. What does that mean? In what way is he a woman? How could he be a woman? What is a woman? None of these questions, especially the last one famously, have been answered - all we know—or all that we are supposed to believe and accept anyway—is that the spiritual woman who had been mystically trapped inside William’s male exterior, his male shell, finally broke to the surface, which entitled him to swim against the women, where he instantly went from 400th place to first, which brings us to last week and the swimming championships.
Now, there were in fact two transgender swimmers on the docket, the other is Yale swimmer Iszac Henig, who is a female who identifies as a male. Now, Iszac won the championship in the 500 yard freestyle Thursday night. You might ask, “Hold on a second - if we’re supposed to take a person’s self-identity at face value and put them in a league that’s in accordance with that self-identity, then why would a ‘trans man’ still be allowed to compete against women? If Lia Thomas is a girl because he says he’s a girl, then isn’t Iszac a boy because she says she’s a boy? Meaning that by the very logic of the trans side, she should be barred from competing against women.” I mean, if we’re adopting their logic, by their logic, sure, Lia Thomas is allowed in because he says he’s a woman, but Iszac says she’s a boy, so then she shouldn’t be allowed by their logic. Well, the answer is “no” because there is no logic on the trans side; the only logic, if we can call it logic, is that the people in that protected class should be allowed to do literally anything they want all the time, no questions asked.
And that brings us back to Lia Thomas who dominated the 500 yard freestyle on Thursday night, easily beating all the REAL women in the field and setting a pool record at the same time. If you’re wondering what that looked and sounded like, well here you go:
”Thomas heads in for the final turn. It’s gonna be a race for second place, it might be… Penn going 1-2 with Buroker, making the turn currently in 2nd place. And over the last half of the pool, nobody will touch Lia Thomas, who’ll finish at 437-32, Lia Thomas, Ivy League Champion in the 500 free. Second place to Catherine Buroker…”
By the way, he beat second place by seven or eight seconds. The argument from the Left on social media and the trans activists, they’re pointing out, “Uh, yeah, but he (or “she” as they would call him) didn’t set a world record, so CLEARLY it’s still fair. Yeah, he set a pool record, so he was the fastest ‘woman’ to ever compete in that pool, and dominate the competition and beat second place by seven or eight seconds, but it’s not a world record, and so therefore, it was still fair.” But as far as it goes, Thomas finishes first, Catherine Buroker finishes second, so congratulations to Catherine Buroker for finishing first, she was the fastest woman in the pool, despite what the silver medal may imply - though ALL of the medals awarded to everybody involved in this farce are essentially worthless, especially Thomas’s. A very young child can make themselves an Olympic medal out of aluminum foil, and it has more value and meaning than any medal or trophy that Thomas wins. And unfortunately there’s a trickle down effect. His participation renders the entire event pointless and absurd, delegitimizing everybody involved, and undoing everything that everybody achieves.
The whole thing is a blatant, totally unjustifiable charade. Women’s sports have been turned into some kind of strange burlesque performance, a parody of itself. And the Left has tried its best to legitimize it, but the task is impossible. On Friday, the New York Times ran an article titled, “Trans Swimmer Revives an Old Debate in Elite Sports: What Defines a Woman?” Well, Matt Walsh kept asking that same question on that Dr. Phil episode where those trans professors kept refusing to answer him, as was I throughout this whole trans charade, though it’s not a question that was ever asked in sports up until now. This is not and age old debate in sports, “WhAt Is A wOmAn, AnYwAy?” No, it’s a debate that we’ve had for the last five seconds of human history because the whole attraction of sports—its value, its purpose, its meaning—is derived from the fact that it’s a raw physical competition between individuals and groups, where nothing matters but your skill and strength and strategy. The Left seeks to make this realm of refreshing clarity ambiguous, because that’s what they do everywhere and with every thing, they make it all ambiguous. Now, the article makes the case that the debate over William Thomas is no different from debates that have raged in the past.
These thorny questions over the nature of athleticism are not new in women’s sports. They have come up many times over the past century, typically when an athlete deemed too masculine started to win. Sports authorities have leaned on medical tests — whether anatomical, chromosomal or hormonal — to determine eligibility in women’s categories, while requiring no analogous tests for men.
But in the realm of elite physical performance, where extraordinary biology is the rule, science has never provided neat answers.
“In the end, it’s about how we think about who is a woman, right?” said Katrina Karkazis, an anthropologist at Amherst College and co-author of “Testosterone: An Unauthorized Biography.”
“And, of course, sport has for a very long period not been at the forefront of gender equality, inclusion,” she said. “So it’s no wonder that we’re having this kind of debate.”
Now, the article goes on for a while, twisting and torturing itself to try to find some way to justify biological males competing against women. Ultimately, it cannot BE directly justified, even by a New York Times writer, so instead they fall back on ambiguity as always, and it finishes with this:
Still, because of development during puberty, transgender athletes may have some lasting physical advantages in a sport like swimming, such as a taller height and larger hands and feet. Coming up with a policy for sex-segregated sports therefore requires making a choice: Either exclude these athletes, or allow them to compete with potential advantages, said Jakob Vingren, an exercise physiologist at the University of North Texas.
“There’s no good answer,” Vingren said. “Someone is disadvantaged one way or the other.”
But there IS a good answer, and a simple one: males compete against males, and females compete against females. If a few of the males would really prefer to compete against females for whatever reason, and if that preference when frustrated causes them emotional discomfort, that’s too bad for them, I’m sorry for them, but it doesn’t really create complications because the point of sports is not to make everyone feel happy and included. That’s actually close to the opposite of its purpose, in fact. The point of any sport once the competitors or teams take the field or the court or the pool is to find out who is the best on that day, which means that ultimately, you’re excluding everybody who is NOT the best, not everyone can be the best. But in order for that process itself to have any meaning, everyone has to begin on an essentially level playing field. All that means is that we don’t have high school seniors competing against middle schoolers. We don’t have pro athletes competing against college athletes (well, you know, actually high school athletes have competed against pro athletes when it was the men competing against female soccer players, and they beat them, but the other way, we don’t do it). And we don’t have men competing against women usually. If those basic walls of segregation are not put in place, then the result is a game, but not really a sport. A man can go outside to a driveway and play basketball against his kids, but he can’t derive any real meaning out of the fact that he wins. No one’s gonna give him a trophy for being undefeated against eight-year-olds in one-on-one basketball. If I were that man, I’d take that trophy if someone gave it to me because it’d be hilarious, but no one is offering it. And at best, that’s all that this is. With males competing against females, it’s at best a hilarious spectacle. That’s the silver lining.
Now, it’s also sickening and infuriating, but I lack the energy to be too upset about it because I have come to see it as a victimless crime - or at least a crime where the victims have volunteered, willingly submitted themselves to be victimized. We live in a culture absolutely infected with cowardice, it’s what most defines our age I think, and only IN an age of terminal cowardice could something like that happen - something that we ALL recognize as wrong and ridiculous, but which few have the courage to call as such. And so men entered into women’s sports, and few of the women fight back. A FEW of them! There’s a FEW women who fight back, and then there are some others who complain anonymously, as William Thomas’s teammates have been, they’ve been going to outlets and complaining about it, not putting their name on the complaint. But then most just go along with it, grumbling to themselves perhaps, but choosing to participate in the travesty, thereby validating it, and allowing it to continue. If you listen to that clip again, you listen to the audience, the audience even applauds Thomas as he wins! None of them are actually happy to see a man beat a bunch of women - ALL of them know that it’s stupid and wrong and bad what’s going on, but they lack even the courage to refrain from clapping their hands like gutless seals! Even that they can’t do, just sit on their hands and not clap, they can’t do that!
So female sports will collapse because the females in these sports lack the courage to defend it, and to defend themselves. It’s the same story replayed over and over again: bad people do bad things, while the good people prove they’re NOT so good by allowing the bad people to do as they wish. So there are very few victims in this story, but there is a primary villain, and now he’s taking home the gold.