r/Planetside • u/MajorMalafunkshun Emerald [SG] • Jul 04 '14
Air-to-Air Missiles: Time to chime in your thoughts.
I didn't have much experience flying against A2AM on Mattherson but after the merge Emerald now has many pilots using this weapon. With engagement radar I have noticed pilots launching missiles apparently from beyond 600m range. Even with racer + afterburner pods these missiles still catch up to a Reaver, although I have had mixed success outrunning A2AM in a Mosquito.
I haven't purchased Tomcats on my Reaver but I've tried experimenting with them in VR Training. The max range upgrade appears to not be working there as with max range 5 the lock on distance is still 400m.
What are your thoughts on the effectiveness and range of A2AM when compared to the skill required to use them? How would you like to modify them?
UPDATE: Performed some testing on the test server and found out some interesting information.
Lock range is 400m, regardless of the extra range mod being used or not used. Once lock is established, however, it is maintained until ~700m (well past the 600m range that Engagement Radar will show).
After firing, if the enemy ESF is hit before the next missile is loaded, the lock is broken and needs to be re-acquired. If the missile is still in flight when the reload occurs, lock is not broken when the missile hits. This is noticeable at ranges greater than 400m and multiple missiles can continue to be launched all the way out to ~700m with the original lock maintained for the duration.
10
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jul 04 '14
Honestly I'd like to see all A2A lock ons removed. They're to high reward for little skill and if your trait away the reward, they don't do enough damage for time sitting relatively still. Coyotes are the same way. Very little skill, but a pretty big reward.
If I couldn't get them removed id say make it take 3 seconds for them to lock on and then have them only do 25% of an ESF's health with a 2.5 second reload. Forcing people to use the nosegun, which should be the primary way of killing a target.
Either way being able to kill someone just by looking at them for a long enough time seems pretty cheap to me.
3
u/MajorMalafunkshun Emerald [SG] Jul 04 '14
Personally I'd like to have the maximum lock on range significantly reduced and/or the missile speed reduced. Being able to hit an evading target from > 400m takes extreme skill. Getting an air lock from the same range is exceptionally easy and the missiles are so fast that racer+ab can't out-range them (like you can with ground lock-ons). As they are currently, they are way too powerful.
Even the "defense" against them (decoy flares) are under-powered when encountering A2AM. You could pop flares and the enemy will still have time to launch all 3 missiles needed to take you out before the 25 second cooldown is over.
G2AM have a max lock range of 300m. Make A2AM base lock range 250m with up to 300m max lock range with level 5 skill. Reduce max level flares to 15 second timer.
3
1
u/Coolping Woodman(ORBS) Jul 04 '14
Screw your flares G2A missiles are the only reliable form of AA, 15 seconds is the time an ESF turns around for another pass.
-1
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jul 04 '14
Yeah that's pretty nice, but lock on users will cry for days about their nerf.
2
u/MajorMalafunkshun Emerald [SG] Jul 04 '14
5
u/Ninbyo (Emerald) Jul 04 '14
Funny, that's how I feel when I see pilots complaining about lock-ons.
2
u/MajorMalafunkshun Emerald [SG] Jul 04 '14
Right, because inescapable homing missiles that can be spammed out to 700m totally synergize well with the rest of air combat, right?
0
Jul 04 '14
[deleted]
2
u/ArcFault Poke4HossinPvP [QRY] Jul 04 '14 edited Jul 04 '14
You do realize even with the nose gun, it's pretty much just looking at the right spot for long enough right?
That's about as meaningless of a statement as:
The team that scores the most amount of points, by the end of the game, usually wins.
LOL. WTF?
Aiming a nose gun requires you to aim at an area a couple dozen pixels wide.
Aiming a lock on requires you aim it in their cardinal direction at most.
One is more difficult than the other and should be rewarded. Not the other way around.
I hope I misread your statement because you didn't actually complete your thought in the second sentence.
5
u/rguitar87 [PREY] Waterson Jul 04 '14
And you have to heuristically calculate ballistics and trajectory. Totally easy.
0
Jul 04 '14
[deleted]
7
u/Kazahael OPTR Jul 04 '14
It's clear that you haven't ACTUALLY used the nosegun much if you think it's just 'looking at the right spot for long enough'. Do you even know how to fly? You disgust me. SOE thinks you're disgusting as well. How do you even live with yourself? P.S. - I had to end my post early to vomit.
-3
u/Quickjager Emerald-Hunter Jul 04 '14
Kazahael your conduct is unbecoming for yourself and everyone else. Particulary the latest reply, ignore and move on.
5
1
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jul 06 '14
The fact that you took the time to make that post confirms that you're a lock on user.
0
Jul 04 '14
[deleted]
1
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jul 06 '14
Why do all the ground plebs think that? Pilots don't want to crush everyone, its part of the reason air squads get boring. You can generally crush anyone in the game with enough ESF's. It's dull. We like to have fights. Fights that are fair and that we can win if we play our best. Lock ons are like a big fuck you to that type of gameplay. They make the fight unfair, and even if you play your best and one clip the guy, you'll still probably end up losing your ESF because this guy can stare at you and click two times, way better than you can calculate and fire.
TL;DR: Stop thinking all we want to do is own noobs because it's not the truth. We want a fair fight and lock ons take that away from us.
3
1
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jul 04 '14
Not even. There's so much more calculation required. You have to make sure the bullets actually connect, there's no fire and forget. The damage each bullet does is no where near one A2A. This issue is basically impossible to debate against.
11
u/PorticusVaer Test Server [FLYT] Take flight - PTS Flight Practice Outfit Jul 04 '14
I was flying on Hossin yesterday, and I kept running into the same guy over and over again. He would just hide somewhere, wait until a lone ESF came by, wait until they are in ideal range (at maximum lock-on range), lock on and just keep pulling the trigger. The second missle was already in flight before the first one hit. Now I get hit by missles in intervals similar to the striker, but each missle takes away 2/5 of my health. He never even once fired his nosegun. How am I supposed to defend myself against that? I'm a decent pilot. I generally win more dogfights than I lose. I know how to shake ground lock-ons. But Tomcats? No chance. Dodging behind terrain is not very effective, as he can just stay above me. Afterburning outside of lock-on range doesn't work. I don't have flares, and even if I did, they would protect me from maybe 2 missles. Only thing left is to turn around and fight. So I turn around, by the time I'm finished the first missle hits. I use my fire suppression. The second missle is already en route. It hits by the time I'm out of hover mode and have my sights on target. Now I have to take down an enemy at 400m range in the time it takes to reload and fire one missle if I want to survive. Sorry, but I'm not that good. I can see how tomcats could be helpful to newer pilots. They can help them learn how to keep their sights on target. But that guy was BR 100. Pretty sure he had maxed out stealth. I checked his killboard, it was filled with tomcat kills. This guy knows what he is doing. Honestly, I think A2A missles should just be removed. They can never be balanced. If they are weak, then they can't help newer pilots, if they are strong they become insanely lethal in the hands of experienced pilots. But that's not gonna happen. So I would suggest to make them dodgeable, add another 2 seconds to the reload time and remove the ammo capacity cert line. You get five missles, if you run out, well, that's your problem.
6
u/CTMWood [TRID]CTMWood84 Jul 04 '14
The hard counter to AA missiles is Flares, Stealth and AB pods.
If you have such a big problem against lock-ons, then equip flares.
"But this makes me weaker against x"
Yes, it does.. But that's the point of different loadouts.
AA missiles ARE trivially counterable, you just don't want to lose out on other opportunities by equipping the right counter. But that's your choice; It's simply not true that they are uncounterable.
2
u/Kootal Jul 04 '14
Use flares and I will eat you with my nosugun + fire suppression. Use fire suppression and I will spam lock ons at you. And guess what, I don't have to choose different loadouts to do both.
1
u/iRhuel Jul 05 '14
Good luck trying to do either when I'm ab'ing circles around you.
2
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jul 06 '14
You mean dancing around waiting for him to kill you?
1
u/PorticusVaer Test Server [FLYT] Take flight - PTS Flight Practice Outfit Jul 04 '14
Thing is: 95% of the time nosegun + tanks + NAR is the better choice. I can't spare the certs for flares and stealth for a loadout that I only use in rare and specific situations. And if that guy is good with the nosegun as well as running skillcats, I'm still at a disadvantage as I don't have fire suppression...
1
u/Thomas_Vercetti Jul 04 '14
use teamwork to overcome this obstacle
1
u/PorticusVaer Test Server [FLYT] Take flight - PTS Flight Practice Outfit Jul 04 '14
I was playing on an alt, no outfit, no friends there. We actually had a huge amount of scythes in the air, but they were just hovering over a single base, waiting for an occasional lib to show up. Not exactly my idea of fun. When I fly I usually try to track down enemy air with the heat map, so I generally move across the whole map all the time. Sometimes another ESF will follow me around for a bit, but they usually turn around if we get too far away from the main battles...
1
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jul 06 '14
I fly in air squads of 2-3 reavers basically every time I play. If we fight any group with lock ons the chances of survival are grim. Not because we're bad, but because they out dps us.
6
u/Qqboxing MmMmYesss/NewAtFlyingmyTR Jul 04 '14
Make them Dodgeable like before none of this fucking splash damage shit
1
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jul 06 '14
And non of this 360 turn around no scope headshot bs. This isn't the Matrix.
2
u/fludblud Jul 04 '14
The current system is fine, having to maintain lock for the duration of the missile's flight is difficult in low altitudes and will get you killed if you are in a fight with multiple aircraft. Lockons are darn near useless in close range or if you get into a reverse thrust 1 on 1 dogfight.
I find my lockons to only be useful when combined with Racer 3 and embarking on high altitude high speed intercepts on lone enemies behind enemy lines or for picking out damaged ESFs or libs in an air battle while hoping friendly aircraft are covering me.
The only real thing that needs to be changed is that there should be a way to actually dodge the missile itself when in flight, but other than that A2AMs are a far cry from when they were fire and forget and pilots STILL complaining should really man up and get better.
1
u/MajorMalafunkshun Emerald [SG] Jul 04 '14
I get why you must maintain a lock at range; they're not fire and forget so you need to ensure they hit the target. The problem is that you can continue to fire missiles while you maintain that lock up to 700m away.
They made the game mechanics like this so that a lock isn't broken and missile misses if the enemy moves outside 400m. That's fine, but don't allow missiles to be launched from up to 700m. That's just absurd.
4
4
u/DeityFC [FCRW] - Connery Jul 04 '14
SOE should nerf the damage. Free damage should mean low damage. As compensation ammo capacity should be doubled (will the current max ammo capacity on them even kill a gal?), missiles should be dumfireable, and freelook lock should return.
2
u/Sucoon [DRA] Jul 04 '14
A2A is ok, there are no probems with outrun them with a scythe with hover and no extendet fuel. can cove them out behind trees, rocks or whatever and also dodge. nothing in compare with the A2G.
TTk is also lower than with the nosegun.
if A2A and coyotes are used, the one doen't have extendet fuel and a handicap in maneufer. its only a other kinde of gameplay.
its also the same if you get lamed in groups with or without A2A
1
u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jul 06 '14
Hypothetically you're one hundred percent correct. They technically have a higher ttk (lower implies better/faster ttk). But the trick is accuracy. No pilot, and I mean NO pilot, will be able to turn around on a ESF using locks and be able to out dps them at max range. Everyone misses a little. The tiny amount of missing makes the TTK on the noseguns significantly higher than the TTK on the A2A locks because they're designed differently.
The whole no afterburners so less maneuverable thing is bs to me. You don't need ab pods to be maneuverable. Sure they help in extended fights, but we're talking 2 missiles to fire, and a little bit of nosegun to kill. That's a short fight. Even an average pilots reverse maneuver should only take about 6 to 7 ticks off the Afterburner bar, so there really isn't much lost.
2
u/MorphingShadows WSNeo Jul 04 '14 edited Jul 04 '14
One big problem (for me at least) is that the air-to-air lock-ons (Tomcats) are inconsistent to the point where I'd just rather farm ground infantry instead (making me part of the problem), sometimes you aren't able to get a lock indicator to display. I've mentioned this before and another player confirmed that he noticed this as well, I don't know how to reproduce it however. Also, before it's mentioned I know how flares and stealth timers work, that's not the case here. Nothing happens.
Let's not forget the fact that after you've fired the missile, due to the the low range for the lock-on to occur it's extremely tedious to keep a lock on an enemy because the developers added a long range missile guidance concept that was designed for long ranged A2A missiles to a short range missile for god knows what reasoning.
A2A missiles should either be short range fire-and-forget (No maintained tracking required after launching the missile), or keep the tracking system that they have now, but increase the missile range that that particular missile guidance system was designed for. If you combined it any other way, you're going to have the two unfun concepts like the original concept that was unfun for the victims (long range fire and forget) or the current one that we have now that is unfun for the users (short range semi active homing).
This is honestly my biggest gripe. I love missiles in air combat. I've played a ton of Ace Combat growing up, while this is far from actual air combat (ESFs function more like high speed attack helicopters), I would appreciate if missiles worked to the point where they made sense from a combat perspective. Not shoehorning in a range reduction and calling it a viable weapon for the situation that it was supposed to fulfill previously.
In short, there should been either short range fire and forget missiles, or long range missiles with the current semi active homing mechanic that's in right now. Combining the two with a short range missile is not fun for either end.
1
u/Supraluminal [GOTR] PlotTwyst - Mattherson Jul 04 '14
In short, there should been either short range fire and forget missiles, or long range missiles with the current semi active homing mechanic that's in right now. Combining the two with a short range missile is not fun for either end.
So... Coyotes (Short range F&F) and Tomcats (Long range SAHR)?
2
u/_Equinox_ [QRY]>[BAX] Jul 04 '14
The issue with Tomcats and Coyotes is that they scale poorly. I would simply like to see more balancing around the abilities the ESF has rather than nerfing any more weapons beyond a few velocity/RPM tweaks I'd like to see.
Stealth should double all lock on timers and halve lock on 'hitbox'/halve lock on distance.
Flares should provide area protection from lockons.
Then you have some alternatives to FS and NAR.
2
Jul 04 '14
A2Am should have a minimum range, so when a player gets locked, they can rush the enemy to break the lock and start fighting. That way, missiles would be used to force enemies into combat because they can't run away.
2
u/Crazybrayden DeckButtes | Connery Jul 04 '14
Most un fun and frustrating things ever, when I see the lock warning I usually just bail as it's hardly ever a new pilot using these it's almost always a BR40+ who knows how to abuse these things very, and I know a lot of the times it's not for anything other than farming delicious tears. Coyotes are pretty nasty but at least they have a reliable way to counter them (AB tanks, stay at range), the only counter play to tomcats is to hope and pray he's not locking you from 300+ meters away (unless he's brain dead he will be at 300+ meters), and to try to get up close, or to pop flares and hope within your 5 extra seconds of immunity you can get to your warp gate or hide under something.
TL:DR they make my eyes roll into the back of my head 3 times due to how quickly seeing that "A" lock warning appear kills any sort of fun I'm having
2
u/truebuji Jul 05 '14
I can tell most of the older pilots quit, i remember the days when people would not defend cheese weapons, soon people will be asking for buffs for both coyotes and tomcats, its getting so bad that at this pace we will soon have lock ons on tank turrets, lock ons on maxes, everything that will make this game less dependent on skill seems to be the meta now.
Its sad and boring.
I like to play the underpop faction on connery, depending on the hour its usually TR, but sometimes its NC or VS, anyway there is always a squad of lock on users that no one can handle, most experience piltos quit and the ones that are left none of them want to fight boring fights against the massive squads of lock on users.
I still enjoy taunting them when i find one of those alone and destroy them, for some reason they think they are amazing pilots and get so mad when they lose 1 v 1s XD, but besides that i moved to tanking until SOE decides to ruin that Meta as well.
4
u/FishRoll Cobalt [RMIS] ✈ Jul 04 '14 edited Jul 05 '14
The problem with lockons is not their range, it is their ability to ruin good fights by just sitting there and dealing insane amounts of damage. They need to be removed, there is no other way to really fix them.
3
u/AngerMacFadden Jul 04 '14
Make them the a2a version of hornets (fast velocity "wire guided").
1
u/Sattorin Waterson [NUC] Jul 04 '14
Hornets are already pretty hilarious for A2A, if you line up the shot right.
God damn air torpedoes.
1
2
u/gimli217 [N] - Mattherson Jul 04 '14
You're not one to be talking about cheese.
2
u/Qqboxing MmMmYesss/NewAtFlyingmyTR Jul 04 '14
Can i talk about cheese?
2
u/Kazahael OPTR Jul 04 '14
Yes.
1
u/stroff Mpkstroff/MpkstroffNC/MpkstroffVS/MpkstroffNSO Jul 04 '14
1
1
u/FuzzBuket TFDN &cosmetics Jul 04 '14
Frustrating to use as trackings shitey.
Frustrating to counter as flares are slow
1
u/BlueberryFruitshake C4 Fairy Jul 04 '14
A2A missiles aren't the most fun, but there needs to be some form of A2A aside from noseguns.
Tomcats I'm 50/50 on. I find them to be a nice option to extend my maximum effective range but when I'm in a dogfight I'd rather have AB tanks. I only use the things once in a while and find that what they do best is prevent hover battles and take down running ESFs.
The problem is that while in a 1v1 most people can deal with toms there's nothing to stop an ESF from being insta-gibbed by a group of 3 ESFs with tomcats. Personally I like the way the tomcat mechanic works but I dislike how much they scale.
Lastly, fuck coyotes. Those things suck and so far have only prevented new pilots from flying, all the while netting more certs to the user.
1
u/-The_Blazer- Jul 04 '14
In addition to the current missiles, which are basically SARH missiles (semi-active radar homing), in that they require the shooter to keep "illuminating" (keeping in the crosshairs) the target for the missile to follow it, I'd like to have some low-accuracy fire-and-forget missiles.
Think of something from Ace Combat. Missiles in that game are insanely powerful (2 hits to kill with 2 missile clip) and highly spammable (fast reloads and 50+ missiles in reserve), but are also incredibly dumb. Unless you fire them exactly behind the enemy, they will miss more often than they hit. And even from behind, they can be shaken off with some fancy maneuvers.
Planetside 2 could also benefit from such a system. There could be G2A low-accuracy lockons that punish players for being too greedy and flying in a predictable pattern to farm infantry, but that do no harm to those who keep flying at 150+Km/h and never fly straight. Same for A2A, these low-accuracy missiles could be used to force the opponent into continuous high-speed evasive maneuvers, thus becoming an easier target for your nosegun.
1
u/dagonlives HSTL Sexualtyrannosaurs Jul 07 '14
I'd like it would be nice if they gave ESFs and liberators the 'harasser treatment' and make flares an automatic equip in addition to other stuff rather then forcing the player to equip them. If that happened, lock-ons would be fine.
1
u/UsedToLurkHard UPGRADE NOW! Jul 04 '14
Remove noseguns.
From loadouts with the current secondaries, other than maybe Hornets.
A little extreme, but I'm just theorycrafting. Say they get buffed in return. Pods get buffed but you have no nosegun to deal with air, if you have AA missiles you can't hurt the ground and can't fall back on a nosegun.
It would separate the roles (interceptor for nosegun ESFs, ground attack for rocket ESFs and air patrol for AA missile ESFs).
3
1
u/Corticotropin Jul 04 '14
I like this idea. :P Stronger pods or missiles in exchange for no other form of defense.
-2
1
u/moobybooby [0PTR] Tigobit - Waterson Jul 04 '14
I say just turn the ESF into a ram machine. Or give each ESF a faction specfic skill.
Reaver: Shield for 10 seconds (ramming would be fun)
Scythe: Makes you invisible for 10 seconds
Mosquito: A 50% life steal (hence the name of the aircraft)
This would be completely balanced.
8
u/weird_guy_ [TIW] shelNC Jul 04 '14
Reaver gets a shield, Scythe afterburner and the Mosquito should be able to lock down in one place and not move. Praise balance!
5
u/Qqboxing MmMmYesss/NewAtFlyingmyTR Jul 04 '14
i want a magnet or a Tractor beam on the bottom of my scythe so i can pick shit up and fling stuff of cliffs. or all you need to get like a group of scythes like 12 of those fuckers and together they Transform into a giant Robot like in power rangers you know you could have like ppa guns coming from your hand coyotes shoulder mounted missiles, Ab tanks on the back so you can move around the battle field at alarming speeds. and from its eyes YOU CAN SHOOT A FUCKING LASER BEAM AND JUST REKT SHIT.
This would be completely balanced.
3
u/DeityFC [FCRW] - Connery Jul 04 '14 edited Jul 04 '14
Would abduct poor little TR/NC nublets with tractor beam and feed them to vanutron.
0
-1
u/Ellieindahouse Jul 04 '14
A2A Lockons / Coyote Air Squads are the New Air Meta of planetside 2.
Especially with continent lock and fights funnelled into lesser continents now, its a more common occurrence than ever before.
Luvin it!
If you are new to air, find an outfit or some wingmen to fly with as you will get ganked quite soon after a short period of flying unless u are really lucky.
-1
u/Arquinas VS Jul 04 '14
Tomcats are boring but I use them because the amount of hilarious rage entertains me so much.
0
Jul 04 '14
[deleted]
1
u/MajorMalafunkshun Emerald [SG] Jul 04 '14
Good question, it's a close estimate I'm using. I took a friend to the test server, put on engagement radar, and started moving away from him until the lock broke. Engagement radar only works to 600m, but I was keeping a constant speed so judging the distance at which the lock broke after I lost him on engagement radar was fairly easy.
1
u/Herby20 [903] Jul 04 '14
They actually patched that in a few months ago. If you get the lock with A2A Missiles before they pass 400 meters, the lock will continue up to 700 as long as you maintain it. With the ability to continue firing missiles without needing to require a new lock, it lets you spam missiles at stupid ranges if the target has no cover to get behind for 2-3 seconds.
The striker has the same mechanic as well.
1
1
u/Morgsz Emerald [SG] Jul 04 '14
You go to the pts server have an outfit mate test these using way points for distance plus max ranked engagement radar.
4
u/Morgsz Emerald [SG] Jul 04 '14 edited Jul 04 '14
They scale really poorly (or well depending on what end your on)
1 AtA lock on is annoying and the range may be to high as running does not work consistently.
But get 3+ and it is messy.
I would say slower missiles so dodging is a bigger part of the air dynamic. This would make the game a bit more interesting and reward something besides hover fighting as fights may happen lower.