r/Planetside • u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) • Jun 06 '14
[Discussion] Provide AA capability for free
Note: No need to upvote/downvote. Its a discussion thread. Discuss away.
Perhaps this would solve quite a bit of the air problems.
Currently when you start out, anyone can pull air. It requires resources but as a BR 1 you can pull a Shredder Liberator that can kill most things.
If you are on the ground as a BR 1, you don't have options to fend off against air. All the options available must be bought. Skyguard, AA bursters, and AA lock-ons all require investments.
Perhaps a good solution to air would be to actually give new players the ability to fend off air.
Most new players cannot be asked to fly because flying is not an easy task and this game is already complicated as it is.
Could this be a solution to the AvG game? When they gave out shotguns, more new players had access to it and thus used it (regardless if you don't like shotguns).
tl;dr Give AA options for free to BR1s.
Edit: Cert cost argument is invalid because a BR1 has too many other things to spend on to save up 250 certs not to mention it is a snails pace.
1
u/Nmathmaster123 [ايرانستان] Emerald Jun 06 '14
Maxes have one free burster. And the 250 cert RLs aren't expensive .
1
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
1 burster is fairly useless against all types of air. I don't even think you can scare a ESF with that.
1
u/Cheesed3 Ceres [AMTE] Jun 06 '14
You can the first time. Then they figure its a single armed Burster and come back to completely destroy you.
0
u/AngerMacFadden Jun 06 '14
Combine it with your other gun for lucky shots. I did that v. esfs in my baby max.
-1
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
You mean the pounder?
1
u/AngerMacFadden Jun 06 '14
If they get too close you could hit them. I use shotguns all the time to hit esfs.
0
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
.....come on. A shotgun is easier to hit an ESF with than a pounder :D
1
u/AngerMacFadden Jun 06 '14
And strangely appropriate :P
Wonder how bad a scat max would mess up an esf.
0
u/VivaVizer Jun 06 '14
AA turrets are free as well.
Pretty large range and can scare off ESF's.
0
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
ESFs really aren't the problem. Heavy air is. And an AA turret will not last long. They are very easy to eliminate as an ESF.
3
u/Lobstrex13 [D1ZY] Emerald - I like tonkz Jun 06 '14
What? No they're not. If I'm flying alone, a single AA turret will keep me away from an area within 100m or so.
1
u/Cheesed3 Ceres [AMTE] Jun 06 '14
If you are alone. Even 2 coordinated ESFs can quite easily take out an AA tower (at least if you are using the AH).
Today me and one of my outfit mates were going against an AA tower at an amp station. He went in first and got the tower's attention. Then he flew around the other side of the tower to use it as cover. I went in putting a few shots into the tower and getting its attention. Then my friend came up again and destroyed him.
0
u/VivaVizer Jun 06 '14
If your problem is with Libs, then why would you want to give weapons that are good against ESFs but mediocre against Libs?
If the AA turret isn't going to scare a 2-manned Lib, then most other form of AA are no better.
Though I don't think I've ever lost my AA turret to a single ESF. It takes two to make it challenging.
0
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
I have destroyed countless active AA with my ESF. You just have to dodge in and out. 2 ESFs just guarantees the AA turret to be destroyed.
The idea is this. What can a new player do about Air? Not every place has an AA platform.
1
u/VivaVizer Jun 06 '14
And I've killed plenty of ESF dodging in and out of cover.
2 ESFs is trickier but playing distraction is like the most obvious thing they'll do.
Regardless, this is all moot since you yourself admitted that:
ESFs really aren't the problem.
My point is your solution doesn't solve the problem with Libs at all and is really only effective at the thing that you claim aren't really the problem.
So what's your idea about exactly?
1
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
BR1s/new players don't have a means to fight/repel air in any form. Fuzzbucket offered a good solution by giving both AA guns for free
1
u/VivaVizer Jun 06 '14
Except they don't do anything against what you call the real problem which is Liberators.
It is a nice stopgap at best and largely meaningless at most.
1
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
So how would you help new players fight off air?
1
u/VivaVizer Jun 06 '14
Not have Libs be more or less unkillable by new players.
Two default launcher hits should have it burning. Maybe burn short range flak damage and maybe have higher drop damage so air isn't just screwed.
1
Jun 06 '14
Basilisks?
And 250 certs is not a lot of certs.
2
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
Not a good argument since 250 certs is a lot for early BRs. Remember how much they have to spend on other things.
6
Jun 06 '14
Not for you or me, but remember that new players gain them at a snail's pace, so to them, it is
1
u/PolarbearGaming EDIM Jun 06 '14
There are already lots of options:
Basalisks, One burster, AA turrets and tanks if they can aim decently.
EVEN IF WE GAVE BR1s MORE AA OPTIONS FOR FREE THEY WOULDNT KNOW TO USE IT, UNLESS WE ADD STUFF IN THE TUTORIAL, WHCIH IS IFY.
3
u/FuzzBuket TFDN &cosmetics Jun 06 '14
1 burster does approximatly fuckall, AA turrets are dead most of the time, and magriders cant aim up.
basalisks are alright, but require resources to spawn.
0
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
A lock on rocket launcher is easy enough to use. Please.
1 Burster is fairly useless, AA turrets die incredibly fast, Tanks.....really?
Basilisk is a fair argument though but they don't really deter air that much.
0
u/Jaggedmallard26 Willerman[RPS]/[RTRS] ;TR-Cobalt Jun 06 '14
Please don't give AA to everyone, all this will do is make flying a nightmare. It doesn't scare off small scale fight farmers as they will either flare or Fire suppress any damage or if they're a Lib they'll just laugh. Instead you'll find it impossible to provide air support to a medium sized fight with everyone simply pulling air the moment the hear the slight roar or hum of an aircraft engine.
2
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
It is to BR 1s. If you have played long enough, you have bought AA weapons. Basically you don't want first timers to have something to defend themselves against air?
1
u/Jaggedmallard26 Willerman[RPS]/[RTRS] ;TR-Cobalt Jun 06 '14
My concern is more that it won't help the BR1s and just cause issues. It won't help them at all in smaller fights where the air can just laugh off their hits and they'll be sitting pointing a missile to the sky while the Lib gets a stationary target to shoot. In medium fights it will make flying a pain for everyone and force everyone back into farming with lower levels who don't know whether its worth pulling AA to deal with one Scythe just sitting constantly pointing at the sky waiting to shoot something down. Also AA isn't a fun job and it shouldn't be new players shouldering AA duties.
-1
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
Right but then new players cannot do anything. Remember that new players can do NOTHING against liberators. The only may be basilisks. A lock-on doesn't require that much aiming AND would be enough to make a lib think twice compared to a Basilisk. Is it fun when you can't fight against someone?
This wouldn't change medium fights because most longer term players at this point bought some form of AA.
1
u/Lobstrex13 [D1ZY] Emerald - I like tonkz Jun 06 '14 edited Jun 06 '14
I pilot a Lib a little. A lock-on does not deter me at all. Flak, on the other hand, gets me to GTFO as soon as I can.
1
u/Cheesed3 Ceres [AMTE] Jun 06 '14
^ I second this. If I have a competent gunner, going against lock ons is actually useful. Enemy heavy fires, we take negligible damage, we know where to shoot. A few shredder rounds and boom, 75 Exp for me.
0
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
Yes but as a new player you either have AA turrets which don't exist for most bases OR you have one-armed AA burster max. It will not get you to GTFO
1
u/Cheesed3 Ceres [AMTE] Jun 06 '14
Libs laugh, gals don't even notice. Just to be a douchebag, I've been solo-galaxying a bit lately and sometimes I genuinely don't notice a single lock on if my sound is off.
1
u/Jaggedmallard26 Willerman[RPS]/[RTRS] ;TR-Cobalt Jun 06 '14
Tell me about it, I quite like flying Battle Gals for direct squad spawning and they're ridiculously powerful if used properly. If I manage to go in from the right angle I can easily get 10 or 20 gunner kills and by the time the skyguards and AA notices me I'm already flying out and it takes so long for them to kill me.
Don't see as many Battle Gals though, kind of disappointing when you know how powerful they are. Lots of health+poweful guns+the ability to rain an endless supply of allies=fun times.
1
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
Problem is that they are slow. So while a Liberator can escape easily, a Galaxy has to play smarter to escape. And then once a Liberator is on your tail, if you don't have backup, you will probably die. However, I really do love Battle Gals. They are very very powerful when used correctly.
I make sure that AA is cleaned first by dropping troops on it. Then I swoop in low because really nothing is going to hurt me at that point.
1
u/Jaggedmallard26 Willerman[RPS]/[RTRS] ;TR-Cobalt Jun 06 '14
Of course but once you get the hang of it you can tank a lot of flak. You can't assault a Flak nest singlehandedly but if you scout out a fly by first you can often at the very least drop a full squad onto a target and survive. Flying low is the secret to Gals all the time, lots of people like flying high but I find that attracts attention, flying below the mountains and only going high when you need to prevents you from being spotted and means people can't see you as easy. Libs can be dealt with by a small "rear dip" and emptying both Walkers into them, with a bit of evasion you can avoid the Tank Buster and if you're smart you can do a quick turn and skywhale the Lib.
Gals are a bit harder to use effectively but when they are used properly they absolutely crush opposition. That and flying them makes me feel like an AC-130 when I do those pylon turns.
1
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
I actually prefer to fly high to clear AA nests because I can usually easily avoid the flak for long enough by dodging. Once the nest is gone, I will fly low. If I fly low initially, I often over commit and end up being less useful. Visibility wise, I think it is the opposite, I find that players including libs and ESFs never really look up. I am open for all to see yet few bother to really look up. Staying high gives me more opportunity to evade and escape. I miss the days that ESFs and Libs were less "smart" about galaxies because nowadays goomba stomping is very hard to do.
Connery Libs are smart enough to deal with my two walkers. The only time I really win is if the person on a bulldog hits the Lib. I can dodge the tank buster to a degree but the fact that I cannot hear a Lib + Lag means that I am very susceptible to ganks. Especially if they are using a Shredder and Hyenna build which many libs use now.
1
u/Jaggedmallard26 Willerman[RPS]/[RTRS] ;TR-Cobalt Jun 06 '14
I find flying low lets me dodge the AA better by being able to hide behind scenery. Its interesting how many tactics there are that work in this game. Its like with ESF's theres so many different styles of ground attack and so many work, keeps things interesting.
1
u/godhand1942 [MERC] Hans1942 (Connery) Jun 06 '14
Yup. I also like how meta-tactics have evolved. In the past a Battle Gal was an idea and not really a thing. Especially for our outfit, a Battle Gal was not really used in prime time because it was hard to load people into it. Ever since the squad deploy update, battle gal is a real threat and easier than ever to manage. However, the recent Sunderer update has made me logistically more useless. I hope they change it.
1
u/Cheesed3 Ceres [AMTE] Jun 06 '14
Yeah, someone has the idea a while back to allow battle gals to arm 4 walkers or bulldogs. My god that would have been devastating. Imagine 3 bulldogs raining down on you, or trying to take on 3 walkers.
1
u/Brandmon Cobalt Jun 06 '14
AA availability for new players has been an issue since the start. It was even argued at one point that "Giving everyone AA will ruin Air". Yet few months later the arguments shifted to "Bursters are breaking the game" because people did eventually get them. Then it became "Just shoot at the ESF with your rifle!". But then Liberators happened and all the complacent pilots left on the smallest sign of air-rebalance.
The best solution is to replace, or complement, the unguided RL available to the HA with a Coyote-like RL capable of homing towards both ground and air that possess very low damage but high reliability that would simply serve as a jack of all trades, master of none which is capable of exposing newbies to a wide array of engagement types (rather than "Oh I can;t do nothing, better run away!") and thus they could get a better idea of what to unlock next, depending on the need: be it anti-ground or anti-air, short-range or long-range, etc.
But the Coyote didn't work for ESFs, you say. But the reasons can be pinpointed and either isolated to the ESF or taken as an aspect that should not be emulated. The problem with the Coyote itself is that its use is not mutually exclusive to the nosegun; thus you can just switch back and forth, making it a viable option even to seasoned pilots that already are capable with a nosegun. Then there is the issue of guaranteed hits, which has been an issue with lock ons that SOE seems incapable of addressing. This wasn't the case, as more than a year ago Lock-ons had limited manoeuvrability and could be outmanoeuvred. Too easily. But instead of tweaking it just right, SOE just opted for the "Oh just give the missiles 100% accuracy". Thus lock-ons became an issue, not a feature. The solutions are there but the initiative lies on SOEs side. This shouldn't hinder possible lock-ons introduced in the game. It should, after all, be a boring mechanic that should serve as a versatile but ineffective crutch, NOT as a mainstay weapon. And the RL example I explained is a good examples of how lock-ons should function.
1
u/wolfiechica Connery - [WOLS] Sahnya Jun 07 '14
No.
You are given a burster arm already for your max suit.
You can pull a stock shredder at BR1, this is absolutely true. But you would not have any reasonable idea of how to USE that shredder. You would likely in fact crash into the first cliff face you find, if you're a BR1 pilot (I know I did!). In other words: you are not going to do much damage at that point.
Now, if you and half of your BR1 squadded buds pulled their maxes with single max burster arms and concentrate fire on that ugly pro-piloted lib? All from different angles, so he can't tell where to hit you from? Well, it seems like you might scare him off, if nothing else.
You are given tools to help take out air, if you choose to use them. You need spend only 250 certs to get a lock-on AA launcher if you're having trouble aiming or getting into a larger group. 250 certs is pitiful.
I mean, do you know it's going to take you at least 16-20 times that amount to deck out a lib to do what you're worried about them using against you? Really?
Just no.
1
1
u/Voggix Emerald | Havenwhite Jun 06 '14
So many tears...
1
u/FuzzBuket TFDN &cosmetics Jun 06 '14
ITT: pilots dont like being shot down. and dont want new players to be able to.
0
u/FuzzBuket TFDN &cosmetics Jun 06 '14
IMO twin bursters should be free, and annihlators should be 250c.
skyguards will always be a nieche weapon, and if everyone rolls 90 itll be horrendus for anyone flying. and the slow velocity means new players wont have a decent time with them
G2A launchers would be seen as a straight upgrade, and no new player would use anything else. so it could be a issue.
0
u/john55223 Jun 07 '14
"As a BR 1 blah blah blah..." You didn't think this argument through. Irately, a BR 1 will have an uncerted air vehicle, making it hardly effective. Secondly, it requires skills that new players don't have.
You can easily take down enemy air with 20 mins of practice with any AA weapon, whereas it takes 30-50 hours of flying to be decent.
3
u/AngerMacFadden Jun 06 '14
Best idea I've seen imho was shoulder mounted burster for heavies. Make it deplorable, new players would be happy to have it.