r/Planetside • [ايرانستان] Emerald • Jun 05 '14

Can we get airframes to synergize better with their respective ESF traits?

As it is there are three airframes : dog-fighting, Hover, and Racer. Now as we all know the three ESFs each have their own distinct strengths and weaknesses when it comes to flying. The mosquito is the fastest ESF, the Reaver has the best hover stability, and the scythe is the most maneuverable. Now aside from dog-fighting being mostly garbage, none of the airframes fully synergize with the ESF's trait that they emulate. The Hover airframe for the reaver needs to add more base stability than hover for the scythe and mosquito, the racer for mosquito needs to add more speed than racer for the Reaver and the Scythe. And dog-fighting airframe needs to be buffed so it isn't shit and it can somehow help out the scythe. what do you guys think?

9 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

6

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

Scythe has best hover stability. And it's most maneuverable, but only because it's much slower.

Reaver has fastest afterburner.

Mosquito is fastest in cruise

1

u/Nmathmaster123 [ايرانستان] Emerald Jun 06 '14

doesn't Reaver have the best hover stability? Or am I thinking about vertical thrust power and go-in-hover-mode speed?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '14

The scythe loses the least altitude per second. And the air brakes are the best, making a hover three scythe able to stay In VTOL while in a vertical dive

3

u/Okryt [GOTR] Jun 06 '14

Even my racer scythe has difficulty staying in forward flight while in a vertical dive.

I really wish it would stay in forward flight all the time. As soon as it goes to VTOL the stupid thing drops like a rock and refuses to start flying forward again. This kills the scythe.

Why can't we just have a toggle?

4

u/DeityFC [FCRW] - Connery Jun 06 '14 edited Jun 06 '14

+99 billion support points for a toggle. You can keep your scythe from derping like that if you keep your fingers off the decelerate/accelerate keys (When pointing down, decelerate = drop like rock. When pointing up, accelerate = drop like rock.), which is completely counterintuitive and a big part of why a manual toggle would do so much to fix the air skill curve.

1

u/Cheesed3 Ceres [AMTE] Jun 06 '14

Actually an upside down reaver has the best hover stability. Press descending thrust and you stay still indefinitely.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '14

ok challenge: Fly 100% upsidedown.

1

u/Cheesed3 Ceres [AMTE] Jun 08 '14

Challenge accepted. Now if only I could actually aim...

4

u/CandiedTripod Chaingun Enthusiast Jun 06 '14

Mosquito is fastest in cruise

I hate how this is our trait. Shouldn't we just have the fastest speed overall? I mean, NC gets their highly damaging noseguns and v-thrust.

2

u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 05 '14

Nah dude. I don't know how much your fly but I've tried all 3 frames in my reaver and I've used racer and hover on a mossie. There's a lot to go into these. These frames aren't designed to make the normal stats more OP.

3

u/Nmathmaster123 [ايرانستان] Emerald Jun 06 '14

What do you run on the mosquito? Also dogfighting airframe still needs a buff

1

u/rakrakrakrak [JAR] Rak Jun 06 '14

Dogfighting airframe is fine, it's probably the best airframe for attacking ground targets in fact.

I shouldn't be called Dogfighting, but it's still fine and doesn't need a buff.

1

u/Nmathmaster123 [ايرانستان] Emerald Jun 06 '14

Does it synergize best with the reaver?

1

u/rakrakrakrak [JAR] Rak Jun 06 '14

I'd say it synergizes best with the Mossie.

1

u/Nmathmaster123 [ايرانستان] Emerald Jun 06 '14

Dogfighting????? No way, racer would synergize the best with the mosquito. I should be more clear when I say "synergize" I mean it plays upon the strengths of the mosquito better.

1

u/VSWanter [DaPP] Wants leadering to be fun Jun 06 '14

I will agree that dog-fighting should have a buff however I'll pose a question. If maneuverability is inherently OP as per the ZOE, and Harasser nerf arguments in the past, then how is making my beloved scythe the most maneuverable of the ESF's with this increase going to be accepted?

2

u/Garlien Connery (DRED) Jun 06 '14

There's a such thing as too much.

1

u/VSWanter [DaPP] Wants leadering to be fun Jun 06 '14

Sure, but with something like improved maneuverability there is no middle ground. It is either useful or it isn't. Too much, or not enough.

1

u/Garlien Connery (DRED) Jun 06 '14

The key is to make it possible to outmaneuver the other ESFs, but not impossible.

1

u/mkgrider23 [OP4]The Opposition Force Jun 06 '14

I think hover is the best frame in the game. The ability to fly tilted forward at basically the same speed as racer is really nice. Plus you use the increased brake power to replicate maneuvers similar to the dogfighting frame.

2

u/DrSPAZZINATOR Connery: WTAC/BAID Jun 06 '14

I always thought if they wanted to buff dogfighting airframe, they should just look at what Rguitar's reaver rush looks like and base it off of that. Highly increased acceleration and brakes, as well as something else. Couldn't quite put my finger on the last aspect that should be added.

3

u/Emperorpenguin5 Reavers On Ice Jun 06 '14

SHHHH don't tell them the dogfighter frame is garbage, or they'll nerf all the other ones to compensate!

2

u/bracketl4d brackettr [CHI] Cobalt Jun 06 '14

Unless it synergizes with SOEs pockets it ain't happening

4

u/TGangsti may contain traces of irony or sarcasm Jun 06 '14

That's harsh - yet feels somewhat true.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '14

Let's just leave the hover, racer, and dog-fight frames alone please. Don't need any more crap happening to the esf air game.