r/Planetside • • Jun 05 '14

What if, instead of insta-gibbing pilots for crashing into each-other...

We just have them bounce off each-other like they do already but without the damage.

I know some of you will say "But it is not realistic!" remember that in planetside 2 we don't have an air tower commanding the massive number of pilots in the air.

So what do you all think? What would be the side effects/downsides to not having air insta-gib on contact?

1 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

3

u/VSWanter [DaPP] Wants leadering to be fun Jun 05 '14

I've been flying since beta and most of my deaths still come from collisions. Still eventually you learn to avoid them better, which is what should happen. Use your deaths as a learning experience.

My problem with this is that occasionally when I am being chased by multiple enemy ESFs rather than fight outright I will run and make them chase me for the kill. Doing this allows me to force them to crash into stuff, and more importantly into each other. It is rare when it happens, but on the occasions where you are being hunted by two pilots and they crash into each other, the feeling is incredible, and worth keeping.

2

u/Cookie-Man Jun 05 '14

More often than what you say, people usually collide into each-other when fighting the same target. Plus you cannot learn luck.

3

u/VSWanter [DaPP] Wants leadering to be fun Jun 05 '14

And they should collide into each other, think about it from the perspective of the evading target. You aren't just fleeing in a straight line, with a steady velocity. You are trying not to let them get a bead on you with their nose gun, nor a lock on, or the coyotes off. When multiple pursuers are chasing you, if they crash into each other, as much as it sucks for them, it is great for your survival.

I do think that collisions are broken in a real bad way. There are times where landing puts me on fire for no reason. Barely touching things will get you instantly destroyed, like explosion debris and tree limbs. I will totally concede that a glancing blow should not kill the pilots, but a real collision should set on fire, and/or kill.

3

u/Cookie-Man Jun 06 '14

Yeah, i agree that a full impact should kill you, although a slight bump from a teammate or a tap of a branch can instagib you and that is where my issues lie. I wish they could refine it but i am guessing they are too booked for the next 4 months.

4

u/avenger2142 HVAvenger Jun 05 '14

I don't fly anymore, but this was the #1 thing I wanted when I did.

2

u/Cookie-Man Jun 05 '14

I just don't see a point to the whole insta-gib thing. Especially with hossin coming out soon it is going to be a nightmare.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

Flying on Hossin isn't so bad. The trees there are lazy and complacent. Not like the trees on Indar which are sneaky and spiteful.

What you're really going to hate will be the way the canopy forces you under the maximum elevation of a Titan 150mm AP barrel.

3

u/Cookie-Man Jun 05 '14

It's not the trees i am worried about with hossin, it is the fact i can't see anything in front of me because of how dense the leaves are. I foresee a lot more friendly crashes happening.

12

u/sushi_cw Connery Jun 05 '14

I don't mind gibs from high-(relative) speed impacts.

It's barely brushing the guy you're dogfighting with or formation-flying with that's aggravating.

8

u/Mathiuz [BWC] Jun 05 '14

Get in mah belleh! -Space Whale

14

u/DeityFC [FCRW] - Connery Jun 05 '14

Space whales are a protected species and must be excluded from any collision nerfs in accordance with Auraxis environmental policy.

2

u/D16_Nichevo Jun 06 '14

There is one problem with this. It encourages ESFs to ram larger aircraft.

Why?

  • Ramming sometimes cases aircraft to spin out of control, which sometimes leads to crashing.

  • ESFs recover from this far faster than Liberators or Galaxies.

  • Therefore in a collision between an ESF and a larger aircraft, the larger aircraft suffers more.

If this change went live we'd see enemy ESFs (or trolling friendly ESFs) constantly ramming larger aircraft until they eventually crashed.

Now, maybe if we limited this to just collisions between ESFs (or maybe any collision with air vehicles of the same size) then I could see it working.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

They should drastically reduce the dmg dealt.

And remove debris dmg almost altogether.

It's enough that you go spinning out of control.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

Even if the debris of a Galaxy landed on a Tank, realistically speaking the Tank would still be operational.

1

u/doombro salty vet Jun 05 '14

I liked PS1's treatment of vehicle collisions. You would just bounce off whatever you hit, with a bit of damage, even if you were going at max afterburner speed in a light aircraft.

Trees and Debris are way too OP.

1

u/SpectreRaptor SOLx Jun 05 '14

While collision damage is a good concept, it never plays out well when you factor in the lag element on live. Im sick of blowing up a second or two after I clearly missed the other guy.

1

u/iamtenninja [XTE] Arkham341 Jun 06 '14

I was in a lib crew yesterday on amerish and we were getting chased by two reavers who were getting awfully close to our warpgate. One reaver decided to back off and fly away. He promptly crashed into the other reaver and both died on collision.

KEEPINSTAGIBBING

0

u/lowrads Jun 05 '14

This is the main offensive ability of the Galaxy.. so no thanks.