r/Planetside • Mpkstroff/MpkstroffNC/MpkstroffVS/MpkstroffNSO • Jun 04 '14

Make the Striker work like Coyotes, you say? Why not turn ALL aa lock-on launchers into heat-seekers?

G2A locks are in a weird place right now. They don't really work too well for their intended purpose, which is to protect infantry from lolpodders and Libs, but absolutely wreck A2A ESFs.

They are not too effective against G2A ESFs because those fly closer to the ground, they can hover in place lolpodding everyone until they start getting locked and then just fly behind cover to break the lock or make the missile crash into something.

But A2A ESFs fly higher (especially with the hover meta - reversing into trees is bad), and are completly exposed to them. And while a lolpodder could decide to tank the damage of one lock-on before getting away, for an A2A ESF losing 40-50% of your health in the middle of a fight will usually get you killed. You can try to never fly under 500 meters of altitude, but that only works against other A2A aircraft, it makes shooting at lolpodders and Lib farmers who fly at nearly ground level very impractical. So, in a weird way, G2A lock-ons protect lolpodders.


If G2A lock-ons worked as dumbfired heat-seeking rockets instead (like Coyotes), they would be more useful at their intended role without screwing over those poor dogfighters. Lolpodders wouldn't be at such little risk if they are hovering around a spawn room (staying mobile enough to dodge a Deci) as they would be hit with less warning, and would have to rely more on hit & run. Maybe even avoiding using the same approach route too many times to avoid getting instagibbed by a group of HAs who figured you out.

A2A ESFs wouldn't get hit by them if they are not attacking infantry but just chasing down a lolpodder or reversing around/vortek-rushing in a dogfight. And if you do... /tell nice shot

Plus, they'd be fun to use, for a change.

152 Upvotes

134 comments sorted by

39

u/FishRoll Cobalt [RMIS] ✈ Jun 04 '14

Finally someone who notices how they do not work as intended. In any discussion on G2A or A2G people bring up lockons as the solution, but they are the exact opposite. I usually think twice before I engage lolpodding people simply because there might be lockons or other aa below.

5

u/MarcusTheGreat7 Emerald - SolarEklipze Jun 05 '14

Ever since I started flying, I kept talking about lockons and got they would ruin dogfights. Nobody would listen, because I was an asshole elitist a2a pilot.

I quit flying awhile ago.

0

u/FishRoll Cobalt [RMIS] ✈ Jun 05 '14

Well, I was there too, but now I'm back and try to punish everyone who uses them :)

It's hard to be good, because most people aren't and are frustrated about it ....

1

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '14

More like, they find getting farmed without a way to fight back annoying as shit. Sure they can scare them off temporarily, but it's easy as hell to just run and then come back for more farm.

2

u/FishRoll Cobalt [RMIS] ✈ Jun 06 '14

This post clearly is about g2a-lockons being next to useless against anti-ground ESF and absolutely brutal to a2a ESF. The point I was making referred to flying and dogfights as marcus stated that he was frustrated about g2a lockons interfering with a2a combat more than appropriate.

I totally get your point and in my first post, I stated the same thing as you did.

More like, they find getting farmed without a way to fight back annoying as shit.

In any discussion on G2A or A2G people bring up lockons as the solution, but they are the exact opposite.

12

u/Thurwell [GOTR] Emerald Jun 04 '14 edited Jun 04 '14

It is ironic that one reason there's so many libs and ESFs bombing you is heavy assaults chase away all the A2A ESFs so we can't really help you.

So I spend all my time between 500m off the ground and the flight ceiling, and usually if I dive on a lolpodder it's immediate 'BEEP BEEP BEEP BEEP', and he's free to go.

6

u/Seukonnen Potato-using Burnout Lurker Jun 04 '14

Lingering pod-induced PTSD and inability to tell A2A ESFs from A2G ESFs at a glance compels us to lock first and ask questions later. :P

5

u/finder787 🧂 [RMAR] Jun 04 '14

So, in a weird way, G2A lock-ons protect lolpodders.

I'd go a step further and say all AA protects "lolpodders" and liberators from ESF's trying to hunt them to an extent.

other then that, this would most definitely help curl their effectiveness back though and make them fun to use.

(Splitting ESF's into an A2A and A2G aircraft would help more because all AA could be tuned for libs and the "lolpodders." Leaving A2A ESF's able to excel at their role, unless they come across a very skilled guy/gal on AA duty)

4

u/Hetman_Invictus Jun 04 '14

Like that G2A lockons will become more like self defence and less air dominance weapon.

10

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

The first thing they need to touch on G2As is to bring back the tracking delay. The current system, where the missile tracks and dramatically leads the target immediately upon firing, creates ridiculously small, unintuitive firing windows, outside of which the missile will often fly right into nearby terrain even if simply flying straight would have avoided it.

3

u/NotTodayBaby Jun 04 '14

I've shot myself, my team, my nearest sundy, many trees, my tank, some antennas, more trees, and random rocks more times than I've managed to shoot hostile air.

3

u/Quetzalc0atl Ceres [xUTx] Jun 04 '14

BEST IDEA EVER.

3

u/itsthesheppy [GOTR] xGuru Jun 04 '14

I would LOVE this.

1

u/Herby20 [903] Jun 04 '14

I think making every lock-on work the way coyotes do would make me quit this game in an instant. Coyotes are one of the most uninspiring, most boring, and most frustrating gameplay mechanics implemented in this game.

The very mechanic itself is supposed to "help" new players. The problem is, both the players and developers don't seem to grasp the concept that good players can use them too. The result you get then is something that is very easy to use yet very effective. That is bad gameplay design at its finest.

The only way to make coyotes really balanced is to nerf the reload and/or damage, but that just means players will complain that they are "useless." To bring this all back to changing every lock-on to the coyote mechanic, you will quickly find that good players will simply lob hordes of missiles at any vehicles. The fact you have to actually stand there and lock-on to a target is a major downside to using current lock-ons, which is a good thing. Coyote-style lock-ons don't require that. Infantry can just pop in and out of cover in an instant and fire a missile. And because the missile will automatically track and hit the target if it flies within range, vehicles will be utterly screwed both at closer and longer ranges. This is not including that coyotes give you almost no warning until they actually hit you either.

7

u/stroff Mpkstroff/MpkstroffNC/MpkstroffVS/MpkstroffNSO Jun 04 '14

Preaching to the choir. You should know I hate Coyotes even more than you, remember that I quit ESFs and started flying Libs mostly because of Coyotes. But it's one thing to put them in an ESF and another to give them to infantry, infantry can't chase you at 300-400kph to shoot you with them from spitting range. It would be very unlikely to hit an aircraft from the ground with a slow moving rocket, heat-seeking or not, unless it's hoverpodding or flying straight at you and (the only cases in which the missile should be able to hit). A2A ESFs would not get killed by G2A launchers very often, unlike now.

vehicles (especially tanks) will be utterly screwed

I'm only suggesting this change for G2A lock ons. Not for G2G ones.

1

u/Bortasz TaliZoraVasNormandy Jun 04 '14

Sorry but there are also G2G lockons. Also striker will become heat seeking missile for all vehicles.

1

u/stroff Mpkstroff/MpkstroffNC/MpkstroffVS/MpkstroffNSO Jun 04 '14

I don't see no reason why they couldn't just work as lock-ons vs tanks and as heat-seekers vs air. Coyotes only track aircraft, it shouldn't be hard to code from what they have now.

1

u/Bortasz TaliZoraVasNormandy Jun 04 '14

So Annihilator will get dumbfire capabilities where they Heat seek Air, and Lock on to the tank. You really don't see the problem?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

The Annihilator could keep normal locks for both, make it unique. Striker could even be the exception the other way and be the only coyote type that locks ground. Might need a damage nerf in that case though.

0

u/Bortasz TaliZoraVasNormandy Jun 04 '14

To complicate. If the cchange is not simple, it will be hard to code. If it will be hrd to code it will cost lot of money, if it will cost lot of money SOE will never do this. So sorry. Give me a simple solution.

1

u/ChillyPhilly27 Jun 04 '14

However it would mean that to hit a target, the firer would have to heavily lead their target to ensure it gets within the lock-on radius.

1

u/Herby20 [903] Jun 04 '14

Here is the problem though Stroff. It isn't all that hard to shoot a dumbfire in the general vicinity of an aircraft. We both know that Coyotes have a pretty big range in which their lock-on activates. I think a change like this would help stop the "That missile chased me across the hex and through a tech plant!" effect as you said, but I think it would make quick strafing runs on targets much, much less viable. Basically unless they gutted the mechanic itself, I think it would break just as many things as it would fix.

The problem with A2G and G2A interactions is, well, massive. I think your idea would make things much better in some cases and much worse in others. I personally would basically rework almost all the ESF secondaries in addition to changing how lock-ons and flak work. It has just been poorly implemented from the start.

3

u/stroff Mpkstroff/MpkstroffNC/MpkstroffVS/MpkstroffNSO Jun 04 '14

The locking radius can be tweaked to find the one that works best, it doesn't have to be exactly the same Coyotes have. And I have absolutely 0 issues if lolpodding infantry becomes harder tbh, but strafing runs could still be as viable using flares preemptively. Maybe the protection effect should last more than 5 seconds.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

Flares ought to have ammo, no cooldown, and a couple seconds of lock-proofing. Or better yet, act like actual flares, float for a couple seconds with a BIG lock radius for coyote type missiles.

5

u/Awilen [1FR] Lumberjack Jun 04 '14

The problem with A2G and G2A interactions is, well, massive.

ESF lolpodding infantry are a bummer.

The ESF can move in 3D at 300km/h, shoot 2/3 of a lolpod clip to kill. Can fly away.

The infantry can run in 2D at 6km/h, shoot 3 clips from his LMG to kill the ESF. Can... walk away. At 6km/h.

I won't talk about ESF vs. Tanks, or Libs vs. anything for that matter.

2

u/Herby20 [903] Jun 04 '14 edited Jun 04 '14

I'm very much aware. If it were up to me, I would basically nerf lolpods into uselessness against infantry. Rocket pods would basically have no splash range or damage and instead just do direct damage. Additionally, I would make the reload time longer and change the clip size and damage to make it more appropriate of a fast strike weapon. I would be totally okay if it took 2-3 passes to the rear of a MBT with 100% accuracy to kill it in exchange for not having to hang around for so long. Making that change now is a little bit harder since hornets were supposed to be anti-armor secondary.

Ideally ESFs should have to make fast attack runs in most scenarios. But the mechanics for both air and ground have all been based around the opposite.

1

u/ChillyPhilly27 Jun 04 '14

Currently flares are able to disrupt a coyote's lock. What if we made the lock-on radius very small? Say a 5m radius around the vehicle. That way an ESF has about a 10 second window where it can fly in quickly, pop a flare, kill some infantry, then fuck off before his opponents are any the wiser.

It might promote the concept of the "attack run", where a pilot knows that if they get in and out quickly, they probably don't have to worry about lockons chasing them on their way out. The only time they would have to worry about lockons would be if they hung around for a bit

1

u/Herby20 [903] Jun 04 '14

I actually think that night be the radius of Coyotes right now. As for flares, that is basically how they work now. You wait the 2 or so seconds until that first missile fires and then you flare. A big deal with the Coyote mechanic is that you never have that initial warning, which isn't so much of a problem if you are expecting it. But what about those newer and inexperienced pilots who don't have any idea what to do, what to expect, and how to react? They are going to get hit by rockets without warning and possibly die as a result.

I think this change Mpk proposed isn't all that bad, but doing it with out changing loads of over things is the issue. Ground and Air interaction needs almost an entire rework.

1

u/ChillyPhilly27 Jun 07 '14

New pilots are always going to get ass-raped quite painfully either by AA or career pilots, no matter what mechanics you do or don't include. Doing well in the air is something that only comes with a massive cert investment and lots of experience/practice.

It will always be very difficult for new pilots to get involved. I just think that if they don't have to worry about missiles chasing them over 2-3 hexes, they might gain a bit more survivability

1

u/WyrdHarper [903] Jun 04 '14

Have to agree with Herby here. While I hate the current implementation of lock-ons, I'm not sure adding an easy-mode rendezook is necessarily a good solution.

1

u/doombro salty vet Jun 04 '14

No. Unless you want them to have velocities of 400+ meters per second, it's going to be like trying to throw potatoes at passing airplanes during a hurricane.

The best solution would be to have all lockons work like PS1 lockons; instead of having a single round that packs the whole punch, have the damage segmented by a large magazine of 5-10 rounds, so that damage output effectively scales based on range and the length of the aircraft's presence in the area. The Striker doesn't work like this at the moment because of the lockon time, maintenance range, and the fact that the annihilator exists.

1

u/stroff Mpkstroff/MpkstroffNC/MpkstroffVS/MpkstroffNSO Jun 04 '14

Yes they'd need to shoot faster, but 400m/s sounds excessive. For reference, the Jaguar's bullets travel at 440m/s, it'd be easy to hit ESFs flying over 500 meters.

1

u/doombro salty vet Jun 04 '14

The jaguar is an automatic weapon with a 40 round magazine. A rocket launcher is a single shot weapon. I don't think it's excessive at all; especially if we want to call lockons dedicated anti-air weapons. It shouldn't be difficult to use a weapon against what it's made to counter.

4

u/samedreamchina Jun 04 '14

Just please, please do something with the Striker, anything, it is mind numbingly painful to use and feels both boring and unskillful. Gif me 5 wire guided missiles please that do terribly low damage to infantry.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

That actually not as bad as it sounds.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

I'd rather see a fight ceiling improvement. But if that's not possible, sure.

But then the striker needs a noticeable velocity difference, and a faster rate of fire, but reach bullet does less damage like it does now

3

u/rigsta EU - Miller Jun 04 '14 edited Jun 04 '14

Coyote-style fire-and-forgets would be just too easy to use against ground attack craft, imo.

I'd actually quite like "radar-guided" G2As, ie. they have a lock-on cone just like coyotes but you have to keep your target within that cone for the missile to continue tracking it.

That way you have a weapon without a lock-on time but it still tracks as long as you actively assist it.

1

u/Typomancer Emerald [LUXE] Jun 04 '14

Coyote-style fire-and-forgets would be just too easy to use against ground attack craft, imo.

I’m one kill away from the auraxium medal with Hellfire Rocket Pods and I have to say that they’re much, much easier to use against ground targets than G2A lock-on launchers are against dedicated A2G. Especially when G2A lock-ons crash into the ground and other things if the aircraft dives right before you fire. It’s maddening.

The heat-seeking doesn’t need to be extreme. It’d encourage a A2G attack craft to be nimble and unpredictable.

Hell, SOE could make completely new heat-seeking launchers and keep the lock-on launchers as well. A2G would still be more effective in smaller fights.

2

u/Amarsir Jun 04 '14

Split the difference. Lock-on as they currently do, but instead of firing straight into the ground have them fire 10m in the direction fired, then turn to the predictive coordinate.

Honestly though, not one dev has said one word since the "predict the target is headed underground" system came into being, despite numerous requests to simply state if it was intended. Plus they seem to have ruled out Coyote-like Strikers for whatever reason. So I think your logic is good, but I do'nt expect anything.

2

u/squeaky4all Briggs Jun 04 '14

Change lockon times to be variable, longer out, longer lockon time.

6

u/_BurntToast_ [TCFB] Briggs BurntScythe/BurntReaver Jun 04 '14

This is already the case.

1

u/Ryekir auraxis.info | [666] Connery Jun 04 '14

Didn't they already do that to some extent? I seem to recall a change a while back that reduces the lock-on time based on relative distance.

1

u/jshaftoe Jun 04 '14

Semi-related. I don't understand why they have a minimum lockon distance. It makes it even harder to take out lolpodders. I've noticed a lot of times a strafing ESF would be exposed for long enough to acquire a lock except when he's closest as he passes directly overhead the lock drops and you don't have time to reacquire before he finds cover.

1

u/Lanfeix DamThatGuy NC/Wat, EvanWilder VS/Mill and Lanfiex TR/Wood Jun 04 '14

If they ever fix stealth and coyotes this change would be hell.

1

u/Amuro_Ray Jun 04 '14 edited Jun 04 '14

I'd just like it if they changed the way lock ons worked, sometimes its a bit too hard to get a lock on fast enough or track them when they're too close. I haven't used cyotes myself but would this change actually make it easier to hit libs and esfs attacking my bros on the ground/sky or is this to make other pilots lives easier?

1

u/Ascythian Connery Jun 04 '14 edited Jun 07 '14

Add me some laser guided manpads too, engineer flak turrets and aa missile turrets for harassers and lightnings.

1

u/SpaceIco (Connery) [EXƎ] A son of Helios Jun 04 '14

Late to the party here but is the game able to differentiate distance in terms of horizontal vs vertical? Can it tell the difference between an ESF on the ground 350m away vs one directly overhead at 350m elevation? Could splitting the lockon range by quality of elevation rather than simple raw distance be of any use in mitigating this?

1

u/zandinavian Waterson- RIP Satan's favorite Rocket Launcher Jun 04 '14

Change the striker by all means, but leave my Grounder alone! It serves it's purpose. It's a fire and forget launcher that kicks ass. It's also the only launcher left that can chase targets that go out of line of sight.

1

u/heiltdo [Sigdrifa 1TR /Lilionn TAS /OrionisLove GOTR] Jun 04 '14

Another option would be making the lock on process take less time the closer the target is. Esf lolpoding at low altitude? Fire luck on missiles really fast so he doesn't have that much time anymore to evade. They fly high? It will be the same.

It would be nice to have a smart rocket that works like the bf4 MBT Law: slow, low damage, easy to use, should be an option for the newbies since dumblunchers are better at killing infantry than tanks.

5

u/maninas ♫Tample Sext erridei♬ [DV] Jun 04 '14

Isn't that already implemented? At least for the A2A lock-ons?

2

u/Taqhin why Jun 04 '14

Its for G2As as well. Something like 3 seconds max range and 1 or 1.5 seconds within 150m or so.

If anyone wants to test it you can mess with the VR.

1

u/heiltdo [Sigdrifa 1TR /Lilionn TAS /OrionisLove GOTR] Jun 04 '14

Ah that's nice, didn't realize as that second seems like an eternity when you're eating lol ponds.

2

u/Taqhin why Jun 04 '14

As a pilot, I can tell you that it feels like an instant lock when I'm eating flak.

1

u/Bennyboy1337 Jun 04 '14

The problem with the striker is that you target needs to be in LOS for the whole 5 seconds it takes you to fire all 5 missiles, this is after the 2-4 lock on period, even then a ESF with afterburner can outrun the missiles or dodge behind a hill.

1

u/Taqhin why Jun 04 '14

Well the Striker is most certainly an exception. I honestly feel that it deserves to become a high velocity coyote launcher, given that the VS and NC both have pretty unique ESRLs.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

That is, actually, quite a cool idea.

But I'm not sure it's the way developers want to see it work.

It introduces a lot less downsides that what we have now, balance-wise of course.

And with this approach, "skill level" would be at least NEEDED.

I'm not saying that pressing right mouse button in a general direction of aircraft doesn't require skill...

1

u/Axle_Grease PS1 Vet: SaigoTakamori Jun 04 '14 edited Jun 04 '14

Decrease lock on range, decrease lock on timer.

Run flares. Buff annihilator. (maybe not direct damage buff, but the above suggestions probably)

Turn Striker into Coyotes. (not just all lock ons because then what would the TR flavor be for the Striker?)

Buff flak against libs or add a DoT penalty for flak.

Bam.

0

u/Syfoon memeralds penis king Jun 04 '14

Fuck the Coyote mechanic, make the Striker perform like Ravens.

0

u/jmknsd Jun 04 '14

Umm, there is already a rocket launcher that performs like the ravens, it's called the phoenix.

4

u/Syfoon memeralds penis king Jun 04 '14

The Pheonix is a TV missile.

The Raven is laser-guided.

The Pheonix would still have the advantage of being able to 'walk' it onto the target, whereas a Striker with wire/laser-guided mechanics would mean 5 (or so, 3 would probably be a better number) weaker missiles having to be guided or led in from a distance.

Sure, the workings of their real-world counterparts are similar, but in a gameplay sense, they're different.

2

u/jmknsd Jun 04 '14

Hmm, my caffeine hadn't kicked in yet. Got it confused with the AV turret.

2

u/Syfoon memeralds penis king Jun 04 '14

Quick, to the coffee machine!

Imagine a weak AV turret which can fire 3/5 rockets before reloading, each missile tracking the crosshair. Predicting the lead for a rapid firing of the rockets or controlled firing and hoping LoS doesn't get broken by the time the last rocket can hit?

Plus it'd scratch my Bad Company 2 AT4/Battlefield 4 SRAW itch for aircraft wreckage.

1

u/jmknsd Jun 04 '14

It seems like it would be too difficult to hit aircraft unless the projectile velocity was really high.

I like the idea for a rocket launcher, but it seems very much not what the striker was sold as. I think having double the rockets with half the lock on time and half the damage, and each with their own lock on and tracking offers something unique to the striker (shortest lock on timer) without changing the core mechanic or purpose of it.

I think at this point making the striker something that has it's on quirk or niche, and then making new rocket launchers like the ones you described is the best way to go. Plus SOE gets to make some more money off new launchers.

1

u/Sianmink [GOTR] MechazawaVS (Emerald) Jun 04 '14

also with laser guided, you're still mobile while guiding the missile in.

-2

u/Czerny [SUIT] Emerald Jun 04 '14

Don't know about you guys but g2a lockons work just fine for me. Half a squad with them will deter any kind of air you encounter and are enough to destroy single libs that are stupid enough to get too close.

-1

u/LoeffeI [WOLF] LoeffeI Jun 04 '14 edited Jun 04 '14

First of all: This is a team game! You can use a lot of stuff to protect yourself against A2G but in most cases you need to team up.

  • Lock on launcher's

  • Flakturrets

  • AA weapons on Vehicles

  • Flak armour

  • Small arms fire

  • Burster MAX etc. This game is not ment to play as lone wolf and hunt down ESF and Libs as infrantry. As ESF pilot, Libcrew and combat medic I know all sites and I would even said ESF and Libs need to be buffed with passiv flares. And the coyote mechanics totally ruined the airgame, so please drop this idea. The idea is to communicate with your squadmembers, call airsupport or pull skyguards etc. Edit: As an ESF pilot: For me it takes just two sec to take out lolpodders because all of them are bad or distracted, I would stop to hunt them if I would get coyoted by groundforces.

3

u/BadRandolf Miller Jun 04 '14

This game is not ment to play as lone wolf

Unless you happen to play ESF of course!

2

u/jtgates Jun 04 '14

Even an ESF can fly with a wingman. Or just follow a stranger and watch their back.

0

u/Shockington Jun 04 '14

Turn AA rocket laucher into a guided flak rocket that explodes near it's intended target for 50% damage. Turn anti armor into a guided AP round that does 1000 damage with next to no splash.

Get rid of lock-ons completely from the ground.

0

u/gavinbrindstar Genudine, always Genudine Jun 04 '14

I don't understand your point. You seem to think that A2A fighters shouldn't be affected by stuff on the ground? A2A ESFs can easily avoid being locked on by G2A by staying above their lock-on range. If you dip down to attack targets closer to the ground, then of course people on the ground should be able to attack you. If you wanna dogfight, do above the lockon range. If you want to attack libs and other aircraft close to the ground, then you're going to have to expose yourself to ground fire.

I like your idea of a heat seeking rocket launcher, but I don't think every G2A launcher needs to be changed.

-6

u/shockwave414 Jun 04 '14

Strikers would just be spammed indoors just like the fracture. No thanks.

9

u/stroff Mpkstroff/MpkstroffNC/MpkstroffVS/MpkstroffNSO Jun 04 '14

If SOE doesn't want the Striker to be useful against infantry, it will not be useful against infantry, dumb fired or not. Just look at the Lancer.

4

u/Awilen [1FR] Lumberjack Jun 04 '14

Point made. Never EVER use a Lancer on infantry. Snipe MAXes instead :D

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

Or the Phoenix. I mean, you can hit infantry with it, and I try to if I can't hit anything else, but it's basically wasting a missile.

1

u/shockwave414 Jun 04 '14

We'll see or maybe we won't.

1

u/jmknsd Jun 04 '14

Strikers would just be spammed indoors just like the fracture. No thanks.

Why would anyone pull fractures indoors? The pounders are so much better against infantry.

1

u/shockwave414 Jun 04 '14

Why would anyone pull fractures indoors?

Ask the people that pull them.

The pounders are so much better against infantry.

If you're close to them they are.

1

u/jmknsd Jun 04 '14

Ask the people that pull them.

I would if I still saw any.

If you're close to them they are.

Not really, the dropoff and projectile velocity, and the increased cof of fractures at range makes landing direct shots very unlikey. I find the splash of the pounders to be much more reliable.

-7

u/WhisperSecurity V.A.N.U. Tactical AI Entity Jun 04 '14

I love coming to this subreddit to see what new bad gameplay idea someone has come up with. Inadvertent humor is the best kind.

-4

u/Addhiranirr Dementia and Courage Jun 04 '14

i think they should change locking time for different air types depending on signature. what it is now ? 2s ? ok so be is 2s for esf. 1s for libs that would make their farming very harder. and 0.5 for gals. and btw make striker lock into maxes . it already have damage like deci so no tweaks here _^

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

Didn't they try that.. and then revert it like a week later?

-2

u/D16_Nichevo Jun 04 '14

I agree that the Striker suits a Coyote.

As for other lock-ons, whether new ones or existing ones, I've always thought that UT2004's AVRiL would be a good thing to copy. It's way more interesting than a fire-and-forget rocket.

You can fire missiles with or without a lock. The flight time is relatively long so you can have two (or more?) missiles in the air at once. Lock-on time is instant; while your reticule is on any vehicle all your missiles home in on that vehicle (swapping to new targets is allowed), otherwise they go straight.

You can do some creative things:

  • Shoot above a tank, wait a second or two, then lock on to hit the top armour and avoid obstacles. (Though PS2's wonky direction detection might foul the directional aspect up.)

  • Shoot off to the side, reload, then shoot at your target. Lock on. Both missiles will hit almost simultaneously.

Launcher users would love it as it allows for creative use, is less likely to hit the terrain in front of you, and if you lose lock you can always try to re-establish or even pick another target.

Pilots would love it because they could have a chance of out-flying the user's aim, and the fact that the missiles aren't fire-and-forget means there are less of them in general.

(Yes, I know something like that is unlikely. I'm just day-dreaming.)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

The directional thing wouldn't work. Direction is decided based on where the person firing is when the projectile hits, IIRC, regardless of where it actually hits. The only exception is the phoenix, as it's essentially a vehicle the person firing is riding into the target, so wherever it is is where you are.

1

u/Sianmink [GOTR] MechazawaVS (Emerald) Jun 04 '14

didn't know the phoenix worked that way.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

[deleted]

17

u/SerafineSilverstream [ExploraDORA] Ceres Jun 04 '14

G2A are a lesser problem than those air ganking squads of 5-10 ESF with Coyote Missiles. Coyotes basically ruined the air game.

5

u/FischiPiSti Get rid of hard spawns or give attackers hard spawns too Jun 04 '14

What gank squad of 5-10 ESFs dont "ruin" anything? And with that many pilots, its more worthwhile to have lolpods instead to take care of AA

7

u/goodeone [UKIP] (Ceres) Jun 04 '14

DORA complaining about gank squads =P but seriously you are right but you also have to appreciate with this change every little helps and it's definitely a step in the right direction

4

u/Cheesed3 Ceres [AMTE] Jun 04 '14

Slightly off topic but, when did we have a UKIP outfit?

2

u/Syfoon memeralds penis king Jun 05 '14

FREEDOM

except if you're brown. then you can fuck off home.

/s

1

u/Jmars04 [BRTD] MarseeeTR Jun 05 '14

I'd team kill UKIP any day!

1

u/nunrigger [T0T]Spacelife - Cobalt Jun 04 '14

I have literally never seen this on ceres. Except maybe once with TTRO but I don't think they were 5

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

Can someone please explain to me why coyotes are even good? I have bought them and for Christ sake I've killed more aircraft with HORNET MISSILES then these a2a lolpods.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

[deleted]

-2

u/Emperorpenguin5 Reavers On Ice Jun 04 '14

At least it takes skill with noseguns you noob, Coyotes spamming that every fucking 2 seconds especially you could be right next to the ESF, not facing it at all just right on your side, you fire AND YOU HIT as they make a 90 degree turn RIGHT FROM THE LAUNCH TUBES.

1

u/Aggressio noob Jun 05 '14

Aww, how cute... and this is why I'm not the least bit sorry for using them :)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

[deleted]

7

u/Algebrace [Australamerica]TeaCeremony/Jasmine Jun 04 '14

What i see are herds of solo-liberators decimating anything that comes close.

1

u/Corticotropin Jun 04 '14

Too true. Very rarely, I appreciate random aerial aces that drop by and kill liberators for me.

1

u/Algebrace [Australamerica]TeaCeremony/Jasmine Jun 04 '14

I find its rarely the ace by himself but everyone just poking at the lib with G2A and the ace coming in after the lib is smoking to finish it off.

2

u/Corticotropin Jun 04 '14

Videos of ESF vs Libs are pretty inmpressive, though. Good pilots manage to hit every single bullet in their mag then dodge the other flying things trying to kill them. O_o

-5

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

herd of solo-liberators? you didn't even wait two words to contradict yourself ffs

7

u/Algebrace [Australamerica]TeaCeremony/Jasmine Jun 04 '14

Solo-Lib? As in 1 person flying and gunning a lib? Have you never heard/seen of them, they are everywhere on Briggs.

3

u/Corticotropin Jun 04 '14

I don't understand how they do that though. You start falling rapidly if you swap seats... pretty hard to aim when you aren't steady.

4

u/Algebrace [Australamerica]TeaCeremony/Jasmine Jun 04 '14

I dont know how either, but a few are godly at it, like shooting through the entrance of the biolab airpads accurate, while fighting off ESFs.

2

u/miniux recursion ceo Jun 04 '14

99% of the use the dalton because it's alpha strike and you only have one shot, plus it OHKs ESFs. All you have to do to be effective is get the ESF/tank in a optimal postion and lob daltons/TB until you get the kill. An ESF can be hitting a lib for 90% of the fight, but even when the lib's at 5% health and dying, if it can get 2 seconds of TB on the esf, it's dead

1

u/CobaltPhusion Game won't run. Jun 04 '14

As long as you are moving in just one direction (no rolling / turning / pitching) the lib will be stable for the duration of the seat switch.

Source : tried being MLG solo lib after 50% dalton sale. Did not end well because 0 cert lib with dalton is still a zero cert lib.

1

u/VenatorMortis TCFB - Briggs Jun 04 '14

Depends on your target (tanks are fairly straightforward for example), but mainly luck and practice.

-4

u/DougieStar [BAID] Connery Jun 04 '14

Can I just go on record as saying that solo Libs are the single most pathetic thing in this game. The lib is inherently a multi person vehicle. Anyone in a solo lib should be forced to wear a sign saying, "I fail at multiplayer games. The only reason the dog plays with me is because my mom tied a steak to my neck."

4

u/wycliffslim :flair_salty:Llamawaffe Czar(Ret.) Jun 04 '14

Or... You know... It's fun and we like the challenge. I don't solo because I have no one to fly with. I do it for the challenge and because I enjoy it. I could get a pilot/gunner pretty much anytime I want on any server I fly on.

inb4 you're not playing the game right because you don't play it like I do.

1

u/DougieStar [BAID] Connery Jun 04 '14

Love your videos Wycliffslim. They have inspired me to get better at the tank buster. A weapon which is less like firing a gun and more like releasing a bunch of balloons and hoping they drift into your target's path.

2

u/Algebrace [Australamerica]TeaCeremony/Jasmine Jun 04 '14

Im half half. A few of the guys that solo lib are pretty great squad/platoon leads but others just go Solo Lib only with no deviation. Its pretty annoying when you see the same guys doing it 24/7

1

u/thesandbar2 EXPLOOOOOOOSIONS-Connery Jun 05 '14

On the contrary, in my opinion, whoever manages to smash face in a multi person vehicle by themselves is probably more capable at both the gunner role and the pilot role than the average player, even when this solo lib player is managing both roles at the same time.

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

and you still have trouble with them? is briggs allergic to looking up ffs

2

u/Algebrace [Australamerica]TeaCeremony/Jasmine Jun 04 '14

Im assuming you dont play on Briggs. Some of the pilots are godly in that they can take out pretty much anything with little to no effort. Ive seen a few fight off other libs, ESFs and lock-ons at the same time.

1

u/Emperorpenguin5 Reavers On Ice Jun 05 '14

Right Briggs is nothing compared to waterson.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

i'm on connery. i would say it speaks to how shitty your AA squads are more so than how good your pilots are...

1

u/Fazblood779 Someone PLEASE Revive this game Jun 04 '14

Briggs player here, can confirm /u/Algebrace 's statement. We have EXCELLENT AA... It's just that Skyguards don't have a lot of health/do little damage to libs, same with G2A lock ons.

1

u/Taqhin why Jun 04 '14

Mattherson has a plague of AH Reaver gank squads with coyotes and A2As. You'll be happily fighting a ESF or two and then suddenly you notice 5 or so Reavers behind you on the minimap.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

[deleted]

4

u/TGangsti may contain traces of irony or sarcasm Jun 04 '14

Did you ever play c&c generals zero hour? Superweapons general patriot systems fired emp shells - that thing was op as fuck against air.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

Because it would become trivial for two people to stunlock anything if it lasted long enough to actually cause a problem.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

[deleted]

2

u/Asveri i am not clever Jun 04 '14

Okay, look it's a fancy idea and all, but I'd rather we didn't introduce something akin to a concussion grenade into the equation of G2A. Losing control of your aircraft simply because someone on the ground decided to fire a missile into your general direction will be nothing but incredibly annoying and frustrating for the pilot at the receiving end.

1

u/Johalt [HNYB] Jun 04 '14

Losing control of your aircraft simply because someone on the ground decided to fire a missile into your general direction will be nothing but incredibly annoying and frustrating for the pilot at the receiving end.

Am I the only one that found the irony of this statement hilarious?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

Two people alternate firing. Any vehicle is now locked out until they get bored, it crashes and explodes, or inertia carries it out of their range. It would have to have an unreasonably long reload, a uselessly short lockout period, or an arbitrary invulnerability period on the vehicle to avoid that.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

No, I think his proposed mechanic is a terrible idea and stated exactly why. If you think I'm a butthurt lib-jockey, go look at my player stats, I've got 21 kills in them and most of that is from suicide tankbuster runs on other liberators.

0

u/wycliffslim :flair_salty:Llamawaffe Czar(Ret.) Jun 04 '14

Dedicated Lib person here: I usually only stick my nose into 48+ fights long enough to look at the flack/lockons and say nope.jpg. I can farm easier/more efficiently in a MBT.

1

u/intoxbodmansvs \o\ DORA /o/ {RMIS} Jun 04 '14

like in BF2142 ;-P

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

[deleted]

-1

u/StillMostlyClueless MoX/GOON Jun 04 '14

Only if A2G weapons do the same.

3

u/Awilen [1FR] Lumberjack Jun 04 '14

"Shoot the damn RL ! - Can't see shit captain !"

That's what happens when you try to fire a RL at an ESF lolpodding you. You can't aim because the screen shakes a lot and you loose life faster than you can aim and shoot the lock-on.

1

u/_BurntToast_ [TCFB] Briggs BurntScythe/BurntReaver Jun 04 '14

You should see what happens when you're in an aircraft and get hit by flak. Goddamn slideshow.

-1

u/StillMostlyClueless MoX/GOON Jun 04 '14

The Battle Hardened Implant is what you want if screen shake is a problem. It's only a level 1 too, nice and easy to run all the time.

1

u/Awilen [1FR] Lumberjack Jun 04 '14

Good one. I'll think about it. That is, I don't often get lolpodded recently so there's that too...

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '14

[deleted]

2

u/TGangsti may contain traces of irony or sarcasm Jun 04 '14

Because rocketprimaryside 2.

-1

u/Kuratius ├•┤Ceres Kuratius KuratiusVS KuratiusNC Jun 04 '14

Already or would be?

0

u/TGangsti may contain traces of irony or sarcasm Jun 04 '14

Both